Transcript
Speaker: Darkcast Network, indie pods with a dark side.
Speaker: Welcome to Castles and Cryptids, where the castles are haunted and the cryptids are cryptic as fuck. And I'm Alanna. And I'm Kelsey. And I don't know if anyone can hear Pat droning on in the background, but if you like can, I can hear my partner downstairs. Okay, I really thought it sounded loud for a minute.
Speaker: Okay. he a They were watching The Simpsons. So, welcome to episode 201 to a one That is a number that we made to. Back to our regular scheduled programming. oh Back to basics.
Speaker: No. yeah Never. We're never basic. Celebration episode? I don't know. I enjoyed it. Even editing it back, it was really fun. and I was laughing at myself, being so stupid and going, it's a Kelsey!
Speaker: It's a Kelsey cryptid! you Oh, yeah. okay well oh it was great it was great and we hope you all did the cryptid quiz with us and had fun doing that even though sometimes they're like the most obscure cryptids and you're like well ah you know yeah but yeah it was good i liked it And we'll keep doing more if you guys keep coming back.
Speaker: It's spooky season. This one comes out on the 17th. We're well into it. And that means that after that, the 31st is Halloween!
Speaker: Save me!
Speaker: save me Take me away. so happy because I, at work this year, ah last two years, I think I ended up closing at work on Halloween night.
Speaker: And before that, I had gotten sick. ah Yeah. ah About this time of year. So i had bought candy, but ended up being way too sick. And...
Speaker: Like put a note on the door being like, I'm so sorry. I'm super sick. I don't want to hand out candy. Like, so sorry. um And then I, so I haven't had. Like take your own candy?
Speaker: I didn't even want to do that because I was so, so sick. And like nobody could tell me what I had. Like. That makes sense. Not everybody does. i have It was like the sickest I have ever been in my life.
Speaker: awesome that's great i forgot yeah it was when i lost yeah when i lost my hearing and my eye was giving me problems and your voice was gone yeah my voice was gone i had muscle aches that was a great time for everyone i was like oh no the podcast and poor kelsey's time it took like I don't know, probably at least three months after for my hearing to finally go back to normal.
Speaker: And ever since then, anytime I get even slightly plugged up in my nose, my ears crackle now.
Speaker: And they never did before in my life. But they're constantly filled up with fluid and then it like affects my hearing and then I... Oh no. kind I don't really get vertigo at least from it, but I've heard like that can happen too.
Speaker: but Yeah, it's been like three years and I'm still fucked up over it. Anytime I get a little bit sick, it seems to hit my ears and my hearing really bad. Like long COVID or something.
Speaker: just That's what I feel like. yeah But I tested i tested for COVID because I had at-home kids. And then i at first thought I had strep throat and they tested me for strep throat and told me it wasn't that either.
Speaker: But they don't know what it was. But the doctor I did see told me it was some sort of, like, very serious virus. But they couldn't do enough tests to, like, figure out what it was.
Speaker: You're like, great. Thanks. Thanks a lot. Yeah, I guess I'll never know. um never know. One day Maybe if you haven't known. I remember...
Speaker: I remember I was off work for three weeks, which is crazy to me. I've never been off work for three weeks unless or even two weeks unless I'm on a vacation.
Speaker: Exactly. Who could afford to? Yeah. Oh, my God. Yeah. It's pretty brutal. Yeah. yeah Yeah, what's ah what but what's been going on with you lately?
Speaker: At least that's only rearing its head every time you get sick.
Speaker: know.
Speaker: Not much lately. a ah worked on a list of spooky movies I'm going to try and watch this year. ah Some older like Vincent Price ones that just got added to... Was it Prime? and Prime or Disney Plus?
Speaker: I think it was Prime. Just added a bunch of them and I was like, ooh, this looks so fun. That would track for this time of year. i kind of did that, but with some books, like horror books that came out in 2025.
Speaker: was like, ooh, okay. Got some from the library. yeah that'll be good Stephen King one yeah yeah forgot all about like his so I read his Mr. Mercedes series and then they like there was a spin-off one about the Holly character and I was like oh shit I forgot all about those books I love Holly Gibney and I was like oh gotta to get that from the library yeah um cool cool cool yeah there's been like a lot of good movies this year
Speaker: So that's nice. It's been a good year for horror. Yeah, it has. um We should be grateful. um I was at my hairdressers today and.
Speaker: She was like telling me because we haven't seen her together like months. was like, I think it was like December last time I was there. Oh, geez. That is a long time. ah Yeah. Yeah. It's I don't love to go that long. My hair is like twice as long as it was when I last saw I look, I'm like, oh, my God, you guys all have new hair colors. like And then she was telling me that I was like, oh, yeah. Like, you know, she's like, how are things? You know, are things like better? I know, like, you know, it wasn't.
Speaker: maybe you were in the greatest spirits last time or whatever. I'm like, oh yeah, it's like, it's been a bit of a rough year, but it's starting to even out and getting like, and she's like, oh yeah, because it's the year of the snake. And it's like, I was born in the year of the snake. She's like, so it was tough for me, but it's tough for everybody. It's like it's one of those like,
Speaker: you know, that transitional, like kind of like going through it kind of things. Um, and she's like, but you'll, you'll start to do better now. And it's like, yeah it's starting to come your way. And I'm like, you're right.
Speaker: It That feels really good. And i was just like, it's having fun. I love talking about like woo woo stuff with her, with her and, and, uh, and stuff like that. And then I was like, we're like talking about different, um,
Speaker: zodiac signs because there's like you know that's the chinese one there's also like their mayan has an astrological zodiac as well they do yeah and and anyway whatever you can like look up a whole bunch of things that that'll be like you're a snake you're wind you're your symbol is storm and just think they're fun um But yeah, hopefully everybody's like on the upswing as this year starts to wind down. Yeah. i hope that for everyone.
Speaker: feel like this has been a pretty shitty year for like just most people. so yeah Like, obviously we don't get into much stuff about current events and stuff because it's nice to be a reprieve from some of those things. But like, yeah, obviously there's really shitty stuff going on that like,
Speaker: does need to be talked about and people are always happy like sometimes when people have a bit of a platform and they say stuff so it's like yeah fuck haters that's what I'll say what did oh there was some girl and she like ended her um like Emmy speech this like actress I can't remember it was on Reddit so i was just like scrolling past in it but she was just like fuck ice free Palestine I'm out or something like that. I'm just like, Oh, that was an epic closer. yeah So I thought that was great.
Speaker: Um, but yeah, yeah. Hopefully everybody's doing better. I'm fine. Don't worry. I'm fine. I'm just like
Speaker: pent up, um, energy from different stresses, but the full moon is over. I'm on vacation now. Woo. Yeah. And, uh,
Speaker: yeah Heather says everything's going to my way so I'm just going to go with that. That sounds good. Yeah. And then she was like casually like oh I got married it' this year. was like oh my god.
Speaker: It has been a fucking year. I'm not seeing you so that's always nice. Anyway.
Speaker: But now we're going to talk about some crime. and Yeah. On a not lighter note. Oh, it's still super light out here because we're recording at like four in the afternoon.
Speaker: That's probably why it's... Yeah. It just perked up a little. I was really having that like, so tired this afternoon. Like, what am I doing? am I going to fall asleep? I think it after my London fog wore off and you have that like sugar crash.
Speaker: But... i'm I'm drinking a dirty chai right now. chai with espresso. So... That would keep me somewhat awake. Dirty girl. Yeah. They sell it at Superstore. It's like mixed in the tea bag. I don't know how much espresso it has.
Speaker: I don't really ah normally feel different, but.
Speaker: I just don't enjoy a chai from time to time. I used to hit that so hard every time I went to the Starbucks that I kind of like chied myself out. But I've got some crystals downstairs that I use sometimes.
Speaker: Crystals. The powder. My mom sent me some that's in powder form, I mean. jesus Oh, like an instant? Those are nice. It's not bad. it came with a cute little wooden spoon. um But I'm just drinking Gatorade.
Speaker: That's so weird. I don't think you've ever drank Gatorade before. not that i Not that you ever mentioned to me. Well, Pat was teasing me in the car that I can't record without drinking and I like I know shut up
Speaker: he's excuse used to go pick up drinks I'm like whatever just like I'm a pro athlete now drinking gatorade was like I don't plan to get drunk I do have to fly all day tomorrow basically so yeah gotta be tip top man
Speaker: And they feed you free drinks on port-of-lights anyway. If you want to get little tipsy. Anyway, so what are you telling me about today?
Speaker: have the case, or it's a murder. ah
Speaker: Straight up, yeah, not bearing the lead. Yeah. No, I actually didn't even start with background this time. I'm like, I'm going to get straight into what happened and then we'll we'll go back to the background right after.
Speaker: I'll mix it up a little bit. It's almost like a Mr. Ballen type approach. Yeah, I like that. I like a little different storytelling style. or It's really hard to do.
Speaker: but i was like, oh my gosh. Yeah. It hurts my brain sometimes. I want to do my notes in chronological order because I just it easier. I always hear But yeah, then, ah yeah.
Speaker: I'll go to but one source and then you go to the other source and then then then when I'm typing it all up, then you're trying to splice it all together. Well, where did that go? Oh no! Very confusing. on so hopefully this makes sense. I didn't really like reread through it all. ah Nice.
Speaker: Yeah.
Speaker: yeah That's okay. I'll ask questions. We'll get through it together. We're here for each other. This is murder of Marlene Warren. Marlene, okay.
Speaker: Yeah, Marlene Warren. We watched The New Conjuring, too, by the way. Okay, I'm done. That's all have to say. have seen it. That's pretty good. So this ah was started on Saturday, May 26, 1990 in Wellington, Florida, when 40-year-old Marlene is at home with her adult son, either went by like... ship so Yeah, they're just like having a nice breakfast Saturday morning together. his His name either goes by Joe or Joey.
Speaker: depending on like the source I was reading. Okay. You're enjoying their nice, nice. Yeah. So this morning breakfast, when the doorbell rings, she gets up and goes to the door because ah Joey had actually broken his leg.
Speaker: So he had like a cast. um So he wasn't getting around very well. so when the doorbell rings, she's like, oh, I'm going to go grab that and opens it. And there's an unusual sight.
Speaker: and that There's a clown that's standing on her doorstep. And they're holding flowers and balloons. Okay.
Speaker: Gotta love a clown on your doorstep.
Speaker: Uh, Marlene, I guess, remarked how pretty and how nice, um, like, the flowers and balloon looked before she was shot, uh, point blank in the face by the clown.
Speaker: Okay. Damn. That was quick. Right? Like, just out of nowhere. Hopefully quick and...
Speaker: possibly painless. You know what I mean? as I hope so. Yeah. yeah
Speaker: The clown, I guess, was wearing an upright orange wig, this big fake red nose, and had a painted on like happy face. And ah Joey, a Marlene's son, he like heard what happened.
Speaker: He's 21 years old, and he rushed as fast as he could to his mom's side. um She had collapsed in the doorway of the house and you the clown, I guess, was still standing there when he like came to her side.
Speaker: So he like looked at the clown and was like, look, made eye contact with it and was like kind of staring them down and noted that their eyes were like brown and stuff. But with like the costume on and the makeup, he couldn't really make out facial features or recognize the person or anything like that. Yeah. I'm not sure how elaborate the makeup was, um but... So not like i couldn't really full mask? Like not like a face mask?
Speaker: No, it was with face paint. Okay. um Yeah, so he... He's there at his mom's side now and the clown, I guess, just turned and just like walked slowly away, got into a white Chrysler LeBaron that had been parked.
Speaker: It might have even been in their driveway or something, nothing really said, but it didn't have any license plate on it. And the clown got into that vehicle and drove away. the hell?
Speaker: Right? That'd be so fucking creepy though. like Right? Like i think back a few years ago when they were talking about like the killer clowns or whatever that kept popping up and that ended up kind of just being like was it like a viral hoax or something?
Speaker: but Something like that. portion Clowns have been getting consistently creepier over time. Yeah. Like ugh. I remember yeah they've like even asked children and if they should you know, cause they want to know, Oh, should we keep painting them in like children's hospitals? All the kids are like no, we don't like them.
Speaker: It's like, who is it for? Just do like cute. Just stick to cute animals and stuff. You never go wrong with cute little animals, little forest free animals, cats and dogs.
Speaker: like Exactly.
Speaker: Uh, yeah. So Marlene was put on life support, um, like rushed to the hospital, put on life support.
Speaker: and I guess died like two days later in hospital. um I'm sure she was probably unconscious for like that whole time because being shot in the face. Yeah. Probably pretty traumatic, but I don't have the exact details on that.
Speaker: Either way, it's completely horrific. Right? Yeah. ah so getting of like... into background of like What was going Yeah, who, what, where, why? Yeah.
Speaker: <unk> We'll try and answer those. so Marlene, in one of the sources, was described as a Midwestern girl ah who had grown up on her grandfather's farm.
Speaker: And at the by the age of 20, she was a single mother. She had two sons, Joe jo Joey and John. And when she...
Speaker: when they were born and everything and she was 20, she had met 18 year old Michael Warren and they had pretty quickly fallen in love, ah getting married just a few years later.
Speaker: and for everything that anybody could see, Michael reportedly cared for Joey and John as if they were his own sons. And they were pretty young when this was all happening. Joey was only like three at the time.
Speaker: I guess, that they got married. So, like, what really was the, um, his father figure and everything growing up. And... Okay.
Speaker: Uh, life went good for the next few years until 1988 when their son, John, suddenly died in a car accident. Uh, I don't know exactly how old he would have been,
Speaker: but Obviously, it would never prepare you. Yeah, nothing would ever prepare you for, like, losing one of your kids or anything like that. Yeah, any family member, any close family member. Yeah.
Speaker: Suddenly. oh yeah Wow. um And this obviously caused um Michael and Marlene to drift apart. Yeah.
Speaker: It says every movie ever. Like, yeah. Well, it's just, and it's cause it's based in truth. I mean, it's, and obviously the people can stay together, but even like, even miscarriages, sorry if that's yeah triggering for anybody, but like, it's, it's triggering for anybody. i would say. i think it's hard because you can, you can like grieve in so many different ways. And if, you know,
Speaker: you can't understand how like the other person's grieving or it's not following how you're grieving. It can, I'm sure that would be really hard to work through.
Speaker: Yeah. Creates a divide. Like, yeah. Chinks away at you. I'm sure.
Speaker: Okay. okay So this is rough already. Yeah. Um, Michael, ah so I guess the couple managed or had a car lot that they owned called Bargain Motors.
Speaker: And i guess Michael was kind of in charge of managing that. While Marlene was more looking after the couple's rental properties. think something said they had three, two or three rental properties.
Speaker: um And altogether they would have been worth about a million dollars at the time. like in the 1990s, like they were pretty well off. They were like really good.
Speaker: um Yeah. Nothing like having some mostly passive income that you just get to collect. and Yeah. Yeah. Pretty cool. um It was reported that after John's death, Michael had kind of put more of himself or threw himself into the car lot.
Speaker: to help keep his mind occupied. So that probably caused them to do part more.
Speaker: Yeah. And at this point they had been, yeah, at this point they had been married for 20 years and they were described as well off. um They were living in a very nice community. It was actually an exclusive community called Arrow Club, which this sounds wild to me um this aero club community had an airstrip nearby that the people living there used to land their personal aircraft and that like I guess they're implying most of the houses had like air hangers in people's backyards oh yes I've heard of that kind of community it's it does seem
Speaker: Very eccentric from the outside looking in They were living in one of those, like, very well off, doing great for themselves. but obviously, like, with the loss of the son John and everything, it would be really hard, I think, for anybody. Mm-hmm.
Speaker: So that's... couldn't do remote. Yeah. i guess they're not really remote. But i was like, it's, like, weird. It's like living on a houseboat or something or somewhere where there's no roads. Like... different yeah i don't really know exactly why they had an aircraft or if they themselves even had one or if it was just their neighbors that kind of did but uh yeah it seems like it's like places where people gather where yeah they're we're all plane enthusiasts so we'll have a yeah you know airstrip here and everybody's got their own little plane parked at home i'm like
Speaker: Okay. but Back in the 90s, though, is what threw me off. I was like, that's something I had expect nowadays. But like in the 90s, were we really doing this? ah Wow. Yeah. Crazy.
Speaker: a So that's kind of all the background I could really find about like their family situation going on. um So getting back into after the Marlene shooting, ah police kind of cordoned off.
Speaker: the scene and they were trying to gather all the evidence they could one of the things they figure out is that one of the balloons obviously they investigate like the balloons that she was given by the clown because those were right i kept seeing pictures of them at like kind of like an eating nook or like kind of like bar top area in the kitchen from the crime scene photos. But I, so I don't know if they had taken them and put them there. And then she went back to the front door before she was shot or what.
Speaker: Don't really know how they ended up so far in the house, but one of the balloons was heart shaped. Okay. Sorry. One of the balloons was heart shaped and said, you're the greatest, which I think is mean.
Speaker: Yeah. Nothing more sinister than clowns and balloons. Right? Clown coming to kill you, giving you a balloon that says you're the greatest. Was it red?
Speaker: Was it a red balloon? think so. I think it was. It was heart-shaped, so... so I'll only take 99 red balloons. That's the only way i will accept red balloons.
Speaker: ah Weirdly, I also have no explanation for this. The other balloon she had been given was one that had Snow White and the Seven Dwarves on it. Oh. So, like, those are the balloons you picked, I guess.
Speaker: Just weird, weird balloons. Odd choice for a murder. ah The flowers, which were left outside the front door after the shooting, were red and white carnations, and they had been arranged in a nice little basket.
Speaker: i wanted to look up what red carnations and white carnations meant. So red can mean love and affection, and white carnations can mean innocence, purity, pure love, and good luck.
Speaker: So they're also another weird... combination ones oh okay i was like are those those ones they use a lot of funerals and stuff too though because that's macabre yeah i don't know i'm not really up on my flower association neither am i i was like i was like maybe the flowers have a meaning uh
Speaker: I don't think there was really much other evidence at the scene. ah Four days after the shooting, the LeBaron vehicle um that the clown had gotten into was found in a Winn-Dixie parking lot.
Speaker: Oh, okay. And I've heard Winn-Dixie before. Is like a burger joint or something? think so. It's making me hungry. of drive-in thing.
Speaker: that's Right? Right. uh there's some suspects that are interviewed some questions get asked uh but with no real like concrete evidence they're never really able to make any arrests charges against anybody it's just so crazy they could just come in and get away with that and just leave saturday morning You're never safe. In a wealthy, well-off neighborhood.
Speaker: yeah. Like, totally. With all the white privilege or whatever. I don't know. Was she white? Yeah. in ah With the weird, like, obviously no other evidence was really found and neither the clown costume nor the gun that was used it was ever actually recovered. Yeah.
Speaker: don't like that. They don't know what happened to it. Exactly.
Speaker: ah so it kind of goes into this period of it being classified as a cold case. um During this time, Michael and um I don't know how much Joey was around. Again, he was like 21 when this happened. So like he wasn't necessarily i don't know if he was necessarily living at home or what but he probably started having his own life going on and michael ended up kind of having his own thing going on too ah he settled down again i a little while later marrying this woman sheila keen who he met at the bargain motors car lot uh
Speaker: And after a little bit, they got married in 2002 and ended up moving and relocating to Southwest Virginia. and in two thousand And 2004, they sold a restaurant that they had been running.
Speaker: um think they sold it for like a pretty good profit or something. And they bought a house worth $600,000. Also in 2004, they did that.
Speaker: also in two thousand and four they did that um So they were kind of like off doing their own thing. Yeah, still making good money.
Speaker: yeah so it's staying kind of cool case this whole time when in 2013 investigators kind of start looking back on some of their old cases and decide to rerun some DNA evidence that might have been collected. Oh, that's good.
Speaker: Yeah, it's always nice when you hear about these kind of cases. Yeah. I don't really know why, maybe because it wasn't a priority or something, but um unfortunately when they ran the DNA evidence, it said that it would take about three years to get the results back.
Speaker: Holy. Yeah, I don't really know why Like, it would take three years to get one DNA test back, but... Expedite that shit.
Speaker: Right? Right. But after that long wait, they did get an identical match, which we'll get into where that DNA test like came from. um But the culprit, who I never saw coming, was Sheila, Michael's second wife,
Speaker: who was just 27. it was your second wife. Did you ever see that SNL skit? It's time to meet your second wife. It's so funny.
Speaker: Who's in Each of their... um
Speaker: Michael Keaton guy, I think. And then... Oh, it's so funny. It has ah bunch of people. It's, like, older. i know... um Amy Poehler and Tina Fey are in it.
Speaker: So they, I don't know if they were like cast members or they were helping like host it or whatever, but they're the ones that are like running this game show thing where they're like, it's time to meet your second wife. And like each of the male contestants is currently married to their first wife.
Speaker: So they're like, what is this game show? Like what's happening right now? And they're like, this is your second wife. And each, each guy that they introduced, the second wife gets progressively younger. uh of course i this is nine-year-old Susie she's currently interested in horses and coloring it's just like this your second wife and then and then the last one ends with this like uh a girl that comes up on stage and the guy's like oh phew like she's not as young as the last one or whatever
Speaker: And they, like, introduce her and she's like, she's carrying your second wife that hasn't been born yet. Yeah,
Speaker: yeah it was so funny. Yeah, it's a fantastic sketch. It is on YouTube. I'm watching it every once in a while. It's so funny. Sounds like something they could have written. Yep. Tina Fey. All their first wives are, like, in the audience just, like, fuming. Because they're like, what the fuck?
Speaker: Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker: No, I gotta watch more, like, SNL skits and stuff. Like, I'm sure they're all over. Yeah. Shorts all over I don't regularly watch SNL because I just don't find it all that funny, but I like the compilations of, like, the best of whatever season.
Speaker: Yeah. Or stuff. Just give me the stuff that worked. I don't want to sit down and watch an hour group. Oh, it's terrible. We're also, like, yeah short attention span now.
Speaker: Yeah. um so guys have plus to listen us just kidding who's michael's second wife she at the time of marlene's murder was just 27 working with him and yeah so she was already working at the place um i don't know if she really knew marlene all that well marlene was like 40 so michael would be 38 so she's like so she's like
Speaker: 11 years younger than Michael. um But she was the one responsible for pulling the trigger. um The pair were reportedly already having an affair at the time of the murder and had met when Sheila and her then husband, can't remember his name, ah they were running a car repo business.
Speaker: um And they must have, because Michael was running that car a lot, they must have somehow gotten contact or whatever. And Michael ended up hiring both Sheila and her current husband.
Speaker: And then they ended up, like, having an affair. And then all that was about five months before Marlene was shot. So it all happened pretty quickly. Damn.
Speaker: It all went down the drain so fast. Yeah. Like, what the hell? yeah Why are people so insane? like Right? Yeah. Usually it's a man that's like, I can't just get a divorce. I have to shoot one of these, one of our spouses.
Speaker: Ugh. And now, Sheila. we'll see. We'll Maybe there's still more. no. I think I've heard this one before. That's the worst part, is that I'm like, oh, this all sounds horribly familiar.
Speaker: That's how I felt when I was looking it up and I was like, am I just confusing it with the hairdressing one whatever? That was the other Halloween episode. Is that the one where the what the one having the affair is the wife and another woman? The wife.
Speaker: Yeah. And then they kill the husband that's a hairdresser on Halloween night. Yeah. Trick or treating or whatever. At the door, too, though, was At the door. Yeah. Yeah. Oh, yeah. What the fuck?
Speaker: This is becoming a thing, people. Don't make that happen. Oh, my God. So I do have quite... Two of my best sources were All That Is Interesting and another site that... Yeah, fantastic. Fucking... I put my phone on fucking silent. I'm sorry. I don't know why it keeps notifications beeping on me.
Speaker: The other source was like the Palm Beach Post because again, this all happened in Florida. So... um But this next lord bunch of things I had are all from All That Is Interesting Um, this is kind of like what investigators ended up releasing after that DNA evidence came back, because this wasn't like released to the public before that, um about like little bits and pieces of information they may have gathered in their initial investigation.
Speaker: Like they didn't release that to the public as far as I could tell. ah But I guess investigators had previously learned about the couple's affair. ah Coworkers at the auto shop were quick to tell investigators that Michael, the husband, had been having an affair saying it was no secret that he was a player. They'd leave the doors right open. There was no hiding it.
Speaker: And according to several of their fellow employees, um Sheila became possessive of Mike, though most but of the employees believed that Mike was interested in only having a casual sexual affair with her. And then she casually killed his wife and casually married him most yeah this is low-key uh usurp your fucking spouse okay um michael had been the first initial suspect when investigating marlene's death as he would benefit financially from her uh death
Speaker: Everything they owned or owned together was actually in her name. And when she passed away, he acquired 100% of all of those assets. So like the company, the car lot they were doing, and then the three properties, and then I don't know, probably their house too, that stuff was all in her name. Okay, wow. He got it all.
Speaker: Yep. um However, at the time, Mike actually, or Michael, had an alibi. At the time of her murder, Mike was in a car with some friends on their way to a horse race.
Speaker: So he was conveniently absent from the Saturday morning breakfast.
Speaker: At a horse race. Sorry. On a Saturday morning horse race. Sure, sure, sure. Don't know if that's something he regularly went to or maybe just that Saturday morning.
Speaker: Sounds a lot like an alibi. Yeah, how many people can we put into a car and go somewhere public? Yeah, exactly. And then I went home and asked for a receipt as I went through the drive-thru Wendy's. Yeah.
Speaker: And then I, what? Got pulled over by a cop or something. Just like anything. I waved at a traffic camera. Something rock solid.
Speaker: I sat in the park and fed the birds for nine hours. I was on TV at a baseball game. That was then part of Curb Your Enthusiasm. Oh, we gotta cover that one.
Speaker: That's crazy. Okay. ah basic That's basically it. So both investigators... or sorry, butt investigators soon learned about his relationship with Sheila.
Speaker: um Everybody was kind of reporting that they should actually first look at Sheila and not the husband Michael. um and that was this assistant state attorney who worked on the case, recalls.
Speaker: And within the next day or so, tips were being called in that you should really investigate Sheila Keene and Michael Warren, like together for planning it. Sheila claimed that she had been...
Speaker: There you go. Sheila claimed that she had been looking for repossession vehicles at the time of Marlene Warren's murder, but she was unable to name any specific locations or times, and she and Mike also denied having an affair, and Sheila said that she did not own a clown costume.
Speaker: Well, that's the best defense so far. Yeah. Continuing, it says, that said, police found a store owner who remembered a woman fitting Sheila's description buying a clown costume a few days before Marlene was killed.
Speaker: And workers at a local supermarket also remembered a woman with long, dark hair buying flowers and balloons like the clown had been carrying. And their descriptions of birth. And they receipts.
Speaker: And joe or Joey's description of the killer's vehicle also led investigators to find the clown's getaway car. ah Inside, they found brown hair, which seemed to match Sheila's and orange fibers that looked like they were from a clown's wig.
Speaker: So that was the DNA that they ended up retesting um in 2013 was like a hair that was found in the wig. And then they matched that DNA.
Speaker: to Sheila and it was inside the orange wig and then they matched the fiber like the fake hair from the orange wig into the fake hair the orange hair that was like found at this shooting scene so like they linked her to the wig and then they linked the wig to the scene and that was how they did it and it was obviously cut in the car yeah pretty and open and shut or whatever you want to call it yeah um fuck so just Throw the book at her. alene Just four months after Marlene Warren's murder, Mike Warren was arrested, though not in connection with her death.
Speaker: Police instead raided his car lot, where they found evidence of racketeering and odometer fraud, which was enough to put him behind bars for the next eight years. Upon his release in 1997, he decided to start a new life.
Speaker: And that's when him and Sheila... like started dating again after he got released in prison and then he got married in 2002 and the murder happened in 1980 1990 1990 still wow yeah so he was in prison eight years unrelated people just don't know
Speaker: still wow yeah so he was in prison for eight years unrelated people just sigh i don't know Yeah. ah Michael, yeah, he got they got married and they ended up moving to Tennessee.
Speaker: um But people knew Sheila as a blonde woman going by the name of Debbie. But Debbie obviously wasn't her real name. And she wasn't a natural blonde. And Michael's new wife was none other than Sheila Keen.
Speaker: oh can't imagine just going by a different name all of a sudden. just yeah and like i don't know where the son joe or joey was when all this was going on because like he saw the clown's face then you see and he saw that guy as his worst yeah and you must see pictures of like your dad getting your quote-unquote dad getting remarried and stuff and like i don't know it's really weird um yeah yeah it's possible it's like
Speaker: you don't live in the same city, you know, then you don't see your parents as often. Yeah. um Yeah. Yeah. and When this comes out, I will be hanging with my mom.
Speaker: Woo! Shout out! We love you, Ginny. ah She'll listen to this in six months.
Speaker: Sorry. Continuing on, they said, there's here's someone whose wife had been murdered and he just married the chief suspect. ah When you combine the fact that the two of them were having an affair and then later they got married, it did seem like mission accomplished.
Speaker: Could you be any more suspicious? Yeah. Yeah. um While in Tennessee, Mike and Sheila opened up a burger restaurant they called the Purple Cow, where rumors about their past swirled.
Speaker: ah Former employees described Sheila as awful, aggressive, and mean, and they claimed that they had even heard rumors that Debbie had killed Mike's ex-wife.
Speaker: Oh my god. And Debbie... this is where i got mad. It said Debbie for her part wasn't subtle. She even dressed as a clown in the restaurant one year for Halloween.
Speaker: And there's pictures of that. And Debbie is Sheila. Okay. yeah Yeah. So there's pictures of her with her face all painted up like a clown. And they believe she would have done something similar that the day of the murder.
Speaker: It's not a great picture, but... Pictures exist, people. Pictures for proof. Right? ah just Just don't do it. Don't do the blackface. I just recently heard that Joan Mitchell did.
Speaker: What's her name? Joan Mitchell. That's an old blackface character. They talked about it on a podcast and then I saw it on the Reddit page for that and went, oh my god, it is really bad. Yeah.
Speaker: What's wrong with people? Anyway. Yeah. the The internet can find your embarrassing photos. Yeah. Oh, no.
Speaker: Oh, this is where it was. In 2014, police received a grant for cold case investigations. That's why they started testing the DNA. And they were able to re-examine the brown hair that they had found in the getaway car, and they also found a second strand of hair attached to a balloon from the crime scene.
Speaker: And after being sent off for comparison, the hair um with the hair Sheila had provided, it ca batches ah he came back as a match, and Sheila Keane Warren was finally arrested for first-degree murder on September 26, 2017, full years after marlene Warren was killed.
Speaker: free 27 years. Because the evidence the whole time. Just like in It. Like It. 27 years. No! ah It's too many clown connections. It all comes back to clowns.
Speaker: Right? Hi, baby. Oh my god. It was also determined that yeah so that the balloons that ah Sheila had bought brought to Marlene were actually sold by the store Publix and I guess they narrowed it down because only one specific location sold that brand of Mylar balloons. Should have gone to Party City.
Speaker: Right? And that one singular location in all of the city or whatever was only half a mile from Sheila's apartment. So, like... Jeez.
Speaker: At least expand your range. Like, jeez. Walking down the corner street. Um... But so Sheila gets arrested. Michael is standing by her side, insisting that they had nothing to do with Marlene's murder and blames investigators for letting Marlene's real murderer get away.
Speaker: okay Prosecutors initially sought the death penalty for Sheila, but that was eventually lowered to just life in prison.
Speaker: I mean, not just, but lowered to life in prison. Yeah. Oh, well, I don't love her, but I don't love the death penalty either. and Yeah. um She entered a plea deal, which ended up carrying 12 year prison sentence.
Speaker: um And she did that and she pleaded guilty to second degree murder in 2023. So like that was pretty recent.
Speaker: um okay and that's when she got 12 years or no she was what ended up happening is because of sentencing laws i don't really know how this works because of sensitive sentencing laws in 1990 and then having to spend five and a half years in jail um after her arrest because of like covid delays um because she was arrested in like 2017 her trial must have supposed to have been like 2020 or something it got delayed and it didn't happen um for a long time so yeah she had served five and a half years um already at the point of her trial so she ended up just serving a bit more and getting released in november of 2024 after serving 18 months like additional on top of that five and a half years so she got off pretty good
Speaker: ae I'm like, that doesn't, I'm like 18 months plus five and a half years does not equal 12 years. just want to point that out. Pretty short film exactly life sentence. Yeah.
Speaker: For murder.
Speaker: Damn. And then getting to live free for 27
Speaker: Yeah. ah Probably people have gotten more for drug charges in the States. I don't know. Yeah, for sure. What I have coming up, this is kind of stuff that I wanted to mention because I don't necessarily believe that Michael wasn't involved.
Speaker: I think he played a much bigger part in this all than um some of the sources will even lead you to believe. And that she just didn't snitch.
Speaker: Yeah. um So this was all from like a Palm Beach post saying Marlene Warren reportedly told her mother and her son that if anything happened to her, it was her husband who did it.
Speaker: And she said multiple times. be Just something you normally say. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I always well like to hear that. Yeah.
Speaker: Michael was on his way to Calder Racetrack in Miami Gardens when the clown came to Marlene's door. um
Speaker: Yeah, so he had, like, created an alibi a year before. um was this oh a year before the killing michael was in the palm beach county courthouse walking out of a courtroom with attorney christopher de santis when he asked the lawyer a question as one casually does such as if a husband were to murder his wife what would happen to her estate like fuck you giant eye roll
Speaker: Okay. yeah hit the warrior jail Yeah. The lawyer says, my first impression was, is this guy nuts? Because why would you ask that question with your wife there? ah DeSantis told police in 1991.
Speaker: um he continued saying, and then I looked around and his wife wasn't there. DeSantis had been representing Marlene's son on a 1986 assault case. And Marlene talked to DeSantis frequently.
Speaker: DeSantis said he always thought that there was no problems with like the Warrens' marriage. So he thought the comments were a little weird. Get out of left field. Right?
Speaker: Just what are you doing Friday? what would happen if somebody murdered their wife? Just wondering. LOL. That's good for a friend. Yeah. The attorney say figured the question was a curiosity, like a law school question.
Speaker: And in this case, I didn't think this was... It says, in this case, Florida law was peculiar. And DeSantis told Michael Warren, son... What? Son of a clown murder victim doesn't think Oh no, that's like the title of a... Sorry, I think.
Speaker: don't know why that's in here. Sounds like well-worded headline. Son of a clown murderer. Yeah, i hated that headline. I mean, isn't it? No, this is what he says.
Speaker: um it really is an issue of whether a man kills his wife. The question is whether the man is convicted of murdering his wife. Because there's if he's convicted of murdering his wife, he wouldn't inherit.
Speaker: But if he were... ah But if he were convicted of a lower charge, he would. And not only that, DeSantis went on, but if he had a friend who did it and they couldn't tie him as an accessory to that friend, he would get away scot-free. Hmm.
Speaker: So like, if somebody murdered the wife on his behalf and it couldn't be tied back to him because maybe he had an alibi, then, huh, gee, he would inherit everything.
Speaker: which is basically what happened. hate it. That's such yeah stupid loophole. um Attorney DeSantis talked again to police around the time Sheila was arrested back 2017, saying he remembered telling Michael something else.
Speaker: I don't know if I necessarily believe this or not. but saying a killer dressed as a clown would likely get off because the witness would have a hard time telling whether it was a man or a woman.
Speaker: So, like, how do you prove? That's a very specific statement. Yeah, I don't really understand what the point of that was, because, I mean, she'd already been killed at that time, so, like, I think he's just trying to point out that, like,
Speaker: maybe it was a good costume to pick because if you did it properly like people couldn't tell if it was a guy or a girl but I figure I think there's plenty of other costumes that would be a lot better being able tell somebody's gender makeup isn't much of a yeah it's not a it's not a full mask exactly yeah it changes the shape of your face and so yeah so I was a little confused by that one Yeah, they're just trying to throw some doubt in there. All you need is some reasonable doubt.
Speaker: Yeah, we have a little bit more. um back to that All That Is Interesting article saying Sheila insisted that she only accepted that plea deal because she knew she would be released quickly and Michael still standing beside like behind her.
Speaker: um echoed that statement saying my wife did not commit this crime and it was difficult to see her plea to a crime that she did not commit but it wasn't worth the gamble that she would be offered a deal sorry when she would be offered a deal that'll have her home in 16 to 18 months.
Speaker: They're saying like even though she took the plea deal she didn't do it. ah Michael himself has never been charged in connection to his wife's death. find that interesting because So he still could be.
Speaker: No, I don't know. He probably won't be. feel like he is. um Yeah. And then for Joe, i think his last name's Aaron's.
Speaker: um He, yeah i guess, struggled with alcoholism and drug addiction after his mother's death. ah And Sheila's, but he says that like Sheila's guilty plea was a relief.
Speaker: saying it was very emotional because that was the end of something so huge that grew for 33 years of its life. And finally it was over and he was relieved.
Speaker: But he also, i think that was what that little thing was, was saying that was like son of a clown killer's victim or something. I think he also believes like Michael was somehow involved and that Sheila didn't act alone.
Speaker: Um, yeah, i don't see how you could trust your dad the same after that. Yeah, exactly. um that ah attorney guy he reacted similarly, saying at the end of the day, a guilty plea is a guilty plea.
Speaker: And he said that Sheila Keen Warren will always be an admitted convicted murderer and will wear that stain every day for the rest of her life. um and there was i didn't have time to watch this i don't know if it's available anymore but there was a three-part documentary called killer killer clown murder on the on the doorstep um which was done by sundance and amc plus um beat around the bush with that title right
Speaker: right
Speaker: I kept singing like murder on the dance floor, but not give the group. I was like, nope Wonder what this one's going to about. Yeah. um Yeah. so I don't know if that's still available to watch. I didn't have time to end up watching it.
Speaker: No, but people could check it out probably. Yeah. be I think it'd be nice if it has more from like family members and everything. Like,
Speaker: Yeah, that makes it always hit harder for sure. Yeah, like Marlene's son and her her mother, who I think was still alive and everything when everything happened.
Speaker: So, yeah. That's crazy. And I hate it. Did you watch that one about, or called like the American nightmare or something about the guy and he has two kids and he goes and to, or he's from Ireland and he gets an au pair and she's American and they end up getting married and moving back to America.
Speaker: It's, it's a good one.
Speaker: and Sounds vaguely familiar. He gets murdered. Yeah. And then it's all about like, yeah. Well, that's kind of a spoiler.
Speaker: It's like, I don't know. It's like, like she's she says he's beating her, but then her dad says, I came downstairs to help her and, and you know, we were it was only self-defense, but then like, there's all this blood everywhere and it just doesn't...
Speaker: make a lot of sense. And so it's, it's really tragic. Like there's a lot with the, with the kids from the kids perspectives and you can just see how it really affected them.
Speaker: Yeah. Like they, they talk, um, as grown-ups and whatever so yeah it's it's pretty devastating but it's a good one like it's worth worth a watch it's yeah yeah can't remember my american nightmare or something like that yeah um okay well let's all go watch some horrible documentaries and then something to cleanse the palate yeah i and to think i was looking up listicles of nice funny crimes
Speaker: like I kind of started in that vein too because I was like duct tape bandit like that they covered it in wine and cry. He just like covered his face in duct tape and that was basically is his whole disguise.
Speaker: I watched a couple good ones that was like somebody dressed up in a full like rabbit costume and somebody dressed up like a bottle of Coca-Cola. And I was like, these are pretty fun. These surveillance videos are entertaining. then I was like, that's not a great podcast format, though.
Speaker: no but that could be a fun segment for a Patreon episode. Bonus episode. Yeah, I could probably find it again. Because it didn't matter it wouldn't matter than if it was a bit shorter. Yeah.
Speaker: Yeah, I mean the video itself of this was included in it. So it was like funny video about a duck, funny video about a bunny, somebody wearing a cardboard box on their heads. This case that took up like three out of eight minutes of the thing and then it went back to like funny ones and I like, what?
Speaker: I was like, one of these things is not like the other. Yeah, yeah. One of these sure did catch my attention and this funny little montage of people wearing stupid costumes.
Speaker: It's like, Jesus Christ. There's a Smartless spinoff um podcast. it's just It's called Clueless, and it's like little quizzes and stuff, and it's with Sean Hayes.
Speaker: And they do this game, Odd One Out, and then the intro music for is like, odd one out, get out! And every time Sean laughs, he's like, I love that one! It's so cute.
Speaker: It's just like an AI voice. And like music or whatever. Silly. from Okay, well, we're going to take a break. And we'll be right back. Here's a word from our ah independent podcaster friends. Yeah.
Speaker: Sometimes it's not the loudest stories that keep us up at night. It's the quiet ones. The ones that never quite made the headlines. The ones that left behind more questions than answers.
Speaker: The Final Trace is a true crime podcast about the strange, the unresolved, and the stories that slip through the cracks. From disappearances to mysterious deaths. To cases that were technically solved, but still don't sit right.
Speaker: We dig into the overlooked, the eerie, and the human side of every story. Because even when a case goes cold, there's always something left behind. A clue, a feeling, a final trace.
Speaker: Follow The Final Trace wherever you listen to podcasts and come find what still lingers in the silence. I'm your host, Hopper Daly, and this is The Final Trace.
Speaker: Music
Speaker: Well, they missed all that hand cream chat.
Speaker: I have one here that's, this is so old. I bought this from like Chapters when I still worked at the West office. Oh, okay. This one's wild jasmine and bluebell. And as you can see, it's still full. Hardly touched.
Speaker: Smells great, though. We were talking about, I got Hemp's brand lip balm and they have a lovely new hand cream scent too. That's bergamot and warm vanilla. And I said, it's basically a London frog.
Speaker: Oh, I love it. But they had um like this and but caramel apple. The caramel apple one actually kind of smelled like shit. I was like, I'm glad you guys let me smell that one because I wanted to try it.
Speaker: Yeah. try it yeah There testers. Always talk to me. Yeah. And they were like, here, we'll just open it. And then I was like, oh, and the girl's like, yeah, I usually like that one, but I didn't like it this year either. Oh, weird.
Speaker: I can't remember what one it was that me and some other people were like obsessed with. Okay. When I worked at. Sometimes they're really good. It was like the first one I got introduced to.
Speaker: um It was watermelon and something, um but it smelled so good. It didn't smell like watermelon because I hate like watermelon scented things. Oh, was it the watermelon coconut? I've had that one. Maybe like something like that.
Speaker: ah So good. This was forever ago. it was at my first job. So like, I don't know, 11, 12 years ago. I had that one at work and and yeah, people would remark upon it that were worked near me.
Speaker: It's like, oh yeah. Love to have a nice smelling scent. don't know. Tropical.
Speaker: Yeah. And when you're like, have to wash my hands at work and they get all dry. Well, at least I get to put on something, you know, lovely. Yeah. Excuse me.
Speaker: Yeah, especially going into winter, you want to keep your hands moisturized. and of like One of my old managers, her hands would get all cracked and they would start bleeding. It was so bad.
Speaker: Oh, wow. I mean, come on, you're not like a farmer, but it does get to like minus 40 here, so that actually doesn't surprise me. like it Yeah, that sucks. Yeah, I'd be like, ugh.
Speaker: Moisturize people! um Okay, that's a weird turn. No. It puts the lotion on its skin.
Speaker: Oh my god. Barkly. Yeah, all that to say, ah sell a bunch of shit at my ah salon that I didn't know about. and From shampoo to hand cream and I even saw some lube and like like like sort of cologne. I don't know. They just had like everything. And then there was like this oh something kind of mask and it said something cryo mask. And I was like, what is this? The future?
Speaker: Cryogenic. Freezing for my face. yeah i can I can see that kind of stuff and like cologne because men, one stop shop. Yeah. Beard oil. Anything to make them anything to make them even slightly more hygienic.
Speaker: Yeah. They smell better. They're going to, hey, would you like to buy this? But lube. Why? lube. That's weird. don't know. I thought it was funny. um Yeah. And like, yeah, it's like a nice one. It's chatters. They have like everything from that to like hair dryers and stuff too. So it's really, it's kind of a one-stop shop. Yeah. I rather like it.
Speaker: And I got, yeah, I got all the tea. Yeah. yeah From my favorite lady. So that was nice. Rain was like, I just woke up. I'm hungry. She was like monosyllabic.
Speaker: But Heather understands. She's got kids of her own. Yeah.
Speaker: um And then we fed Rain and she perked right up.
Speaker: You're not you when you're hungry. do Snickers or whatever. I know. I had a big London frog and then I didn't hardly eat anything, but those are full of calories, so that's probably why. You know how you like yeah drink a big coffee or something or a latte? like It really fills you up yeah quite a bit.
Speaker: i think it's all like the cream or dairy and stuff in it too. doesn't help. Right. People are like, don't eat a lot, and then they're like, Or, like, a lot of calories. And then you're, like, drinking, like, a frickin' milkshake, basically, made of coffee. Like, a Frappuccino. And they're like, what? That's what I said to somebody. Because they're, like, they were... can't remember what was talking them about. And I was like, I... Other than, like, iced coffee, which... I put some sugar and, like, milk and stuff in. I don't drink a lot of other types of drinks. So, was like, I'm trying not to, like, just drink my calories every single day. Like...
Speaker: Yeah. Save some of that for the alcohol, at least. If it's not iced coffee, I'm normally just drinking tea or water. like yeah Depending on how the temperature outside.
Speaker: yeah Sometimes i'll kind I'm conscious, like, yeah, you had a big luncheon. Maybe don't have anything to drink tonight or whatever. because it does add up. um And I'm trying to get rid of some of this fat in my face.
Speaker: Oh, anyway. Okay, so we get to talk about something um a little less murdery now. So that's fun. Okay. Yeah. Switching things up.
Speaker: Yeah, we're going to talk about a dude called William Slick Willie Sutton.
Speaker: Nickname. I'm calling him a master of disguise. Okay. ah Okay.
Speaker: Yeah. um Yeah, I was like looking up lists and stuff and it varied from like, you know, best disguises in history, even though I looked up like, i thought I looked up worst or weirdest or something. And then it's like, yeah, and horse.
Speaker: You're like, well, okay, but maybe not so much that. And like, I don't know, like people dressing up as like, men to be like soldiers in the Civil War, like, like women. Yeah.
Speaker: Yeah, i ran across stuff like that too so I kept being like we um Strange ah Costumes worn to commit crimes And stuff Okay, yeah, I think I put more like yeah Weird disguise And stuff um Yeah, there's some different ones We could probably revisit it, I know There's other ones I've heard On different podcasts Let us know if you like it As always Um Don't forget to rate us, too.
Speaker: God damn it. On our Spotify. Yes. Rate, review, subscribe. It was only a little bit triggering to be listening to We're Here to Help today. Why am I giving them more free shoutouts? They don't need it. Because theirs have something that says over 100,000 plays on a few of their early episodes. And I was like, if we get to that, then Spotify would tell people.
Speaker: Can you imagine? Oh. Or 25,000. I don't even know about her.
Speaker: We're so close. Oh, our... Our, uh... Yeah, our analytics is harder to find on Zencaster than it was on Spotify for podcasters or whatever, so... Yeah, I kind of miss having the, like... Yeah. Breakdowns like, the countries and... The Spotify rap. You to tell us some interesting stuff.
Speaker: You get for the podcasters, too. was nice. Ugh, whatever. Um... Yeah, we'll figure it out.
Speaker: Hopefully we'll have some more time to work on some of that behind the scenes marketing and crap that everyone else seems to be so good at. Here's all the reels of us recording the episodes and looking amazing. Shut up.
Speaker: I hate you, but good for you. Hey, I'm in my pajamas like night. I'm in my comfy clothes 90% the time. I know. I'm so hard relate when like... It just me wearing this sweater every second episode.
Speaker: It's kind of a big Lebowski sweater. I love it. um This one's Harry Potter. My sister-in-law bought it for me. It was of the first Christmas presents I actually ever got from her. It's the pattern. It's so cute. It's like gray and black. Yeah, so these are the hats.
Speaker: And then the golden... Oh, that's just like a star. Then it's got all these ages on it. oh it does. And then here... Down here down here is
Speaker: Oh, here's the golden. There's golden snitches across right here. And then done in gray there's wands. Oh, here's the l the elder wand right on the bone.
Speaker: Oh, okay. So it's a covert Harry Potter sweater. You would never know. That's kind of true. oh Oh, and if we are showing, no, we're not on video. I was going to say, yeah, I relate to um podcasters that usually do video, like Creeps and Crimes. They'll be like, this one's audio only.
Speaker: don't want to dress up. But um I am wearing i'm wearing a shirt I just got that says, Dinna Fash Sassanek. With the dragonfly. Oh, okay. I couldn't tell what the dragonfly was. I was like, is the top of her shirt censored?
Speaker: like just looked like it was like the top lines were censored and then I couldn't make out what the bottom said. I was like, why is she blurring the top of her shirt?
Speaker: Just self-censoring. Oh, no. with talk if we keep this in now, we have to add pictures of our shirts. Because people will be like, what? It's audio medium. Like, I hate it when people go, and then I just did this.
Speaker: And then they do something and you're like, I'm not watching this. This is a podcast. Because, like, everybody's on fucking YouTube at the same time. Anyway. So.
Speaker: Back to our... I am ready. Back to our boy here. so ah William Slick Willie was born on the 30th of June 1901 in Brooklyn New York.
Speaker: He's from Brooklyn. That's old? 1901? Okay. Turn of the century. I know we went to different decades as well.
Speaker: Yeah. Yeah. um he was actually born in um a place in brooklyn called irishtown so that's fun because he was of irish descent it's like right on the nose but maybe that's because they used to like really discriminate against irish people and like italians and stuff so probably that's because they got shoved into one area i'm guessing yeah it's like um
Speaker: Like, whenever there's, like, people are like, oh, yeah, this is, like, the Chinatown. And I'm like, but is this a good thing? Right. um like Hopefully now we're leaning into it, yeah. Because, like, oh, I loved living near little Chinatown. um Here we live near in Edmonton. Yeah.
Speaker: Yeah. I'm like, oh. and Yeah. Sometimes I'm reading the historical books and I come across something and they're, like, talking about, yeah, yeah at the time there was, like,
Speaker: um well, they called it racism because like the the British people or whoever would be like, no, the Irish are like a grosser race. And like they have yeah babies as fast as rats do. And and then we call it and that's where we got the term for like Irish twins because they were saying that like they'd, you know, be pregnant for nine months, be not for two months and then be pregnant for nine months again. and Because apparently that's how rats do it. But in weeks, yeah.
Speaker: And I'm just like, oh, I never realized like how racist the origin of that term was. Like I just say it without thinking like, oh yeah, Irish twins. And then you're like, oh, camp. Like those things we got to think about now looking back.
Speaker: Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker: Okay. Okay. So was that out of the way, he was the fourth of five kids. So yeah, I think he did have a few siblings possibly even in quick succession. i don't know.
Speaker: ah But it said his mom was Irish. Either she was born in Ireland and then they moved to the USA or her parents were the ones that moved and she was born in Maryland. So they were like first or second generation immigrants, I believe. oh cantor Yeah.
Speaker: So pretty damn Irish still. Yeah. He left school after 8th grade to get a job, which is probably not that uncommon at the time. No, not for Yeah.
Speaker: Yeah. Gotta go work in the mines or something. I'm a child, I yearn for the mines. From the Minecraft movie.
Speaker: So good, guys. Jack Black and... What's his face? Jason Momoa. They're just a treat. Yeah.
Speaker: I love how they got really close together but with during that filming. And i think one of them knitted the other a sweat, like matching sweaters. it It was like this bromance. I feel like Jason Momoa probably doesn't have a lot of people that want to like goof off with him.
Speaker: Like, you know, because he's done a lot of like serious movies and like. action movies and yeah it was kind of thing so it's nice to get to be like goofy cornball with somebody true I think he even talked about that a little bit on he was recently on like smart listen because he got called like called the Khal Drogo on Game of Thrones and so then I think he got those types of roles like very serious yeah to play around much or talk much even
Speaker: Yeah, that too. Just sat there looking good. I'm re, I'm, watching yeah, I'm watching one of the YouTube channels I'm watching. They're, they just started reacting to Game of Thrones.
Speaker: And was like, damn, it's been, i think I only ever rewatched the first season. And then other than that, I've only ever seen most of the episode was once. So was like, okay, I'm saying like, sit down and watch it.
Speaker: And that's one thing i noticed. I was like, oh, this is the sixth episode and he's had like no lines.
Speaker: Oh no, he just said his first line in the sixth episode. Damn. but True. Or at least that's how felt. I love the first seasons. The first few seasons are so good.
Speaker: um Okay. Anyway. Oh yeah, so he so he got many little jobs for short periods of time, including like a clerk, ah a driller, and a gardener. Okay.
Speaker: Miscellaneous, I suppose. Just whatever you... Yeah. Just odd jobs. and Yeah, who knows. But his longest job at the at the time was only 18 months long, so he couldn't really seem to hold down a job.
Speaker: Yeah. but still somehow managed to get married in 1929 to a Louise Ludeman. ah But ah even though they had a daughter together named Jeannie, she did leave him after he went to prison for the for the first time.
Speaker: Oh no. ah Okay. i mean yeah
Speaker: Going to prison is not great. He's a, he's a big fan of the, the Robin. Robin. Likes to rob. okay. Yeah. ah So... So that's... what You know, he's not a... Not a killer, though.
Speaker: Okay, yeah. i would be totally different, too. think he just wants a little money and a little fun. But we'll get into it. He's got so some quotes and stuff. um He did remarry eventually... Or I guess so that's about four years later to an Olga Kowalska...
Speaker: not sure how long that one lasted. Yeah. Honestly, not a lot of sources on guy, if I'm being honest. Oh, okay. Yeah, that happens. Yeah. Relied heavily on ah Wikipedia and one from, like, FBI.gov.
Speaker: so that one damn. Yeah. was interesting. It had a lot. I've used that as a source sometimes when somebody is on, like, an FBI wanted list or something. Exactly. You're damn, I'm getting... Information straight from the FBI.
Speaker: Straight from the gov's mouth. Yeah. So he was kind of of that era where he was like more known as the sort of the gentleman robber that's not prone to violence.
Speaker: Yeah. known Known to be quite polite by reputation. and Also very well dressed. I'll have to try and find some. I didn't see a ton of pictures of him all dressed up, but you know, it's the time where everybody's wearing them hats and looking good. Yeah.
Speaker: Even their their everyday clothes is better than our Sunday best.
Speaker: Yeah. um One witness at a bank robbery of Willie's said it was like going to the movies, only the usher had a gun in his hand. Okay.
Speaker: I mean, okay. Sounds like he wasn't scared. ah Yeah, i was just going to say it sounds like the threat of violence was not being felt by the general public yeah he wants them to fear how much they love him i love michael scott yeah um and then there was a description of him ah that started quote a little bright-eyed guy just five seven and always talking chain smoking cigarettes with bill durham tobacco
Speaker: and
Speaker: two That was from, oh, sorry, I should have prefaced this. This is a quote. It was a quote from a mafioso named Donald, Donald Frankos. ah So Frankos stated also that Sutton dispensed mounds of legal advice to any convict willing to listen.
Speaker: He's a lawyer too now. Okay. Way to go. Yeah. Was it good legal advice? Doesn't say. Yeah.
Speaker: Inmates considered Sutton a quote, wise old head in the prison population. When incarcerated at the tombs, ah which was a man how or nickname for the Manhattan house of detention, I guess he did not have to worry about assault because mafia friends protected him.
Speaker: So that's nice. Nice. In conversation with Donald Franco, he would sadly reminisce about the 1920s and 30s when he was most active in, this is later on, obviously, active in robbing banks and would always tell fellow convicts that in his opinion during the days of Al Capone and Lucky Luciano, the criminals were the bloodiest.
Speaker: um
Speaker: Gangsters from the time period and many incarcerated organized crime inmates enjoyed having Sutton for companionship. he was witty and non-violent and francos declared that sutton made legendary bank thieves jesse james and john dillinger seem like amateurs that's the whole oh really oh going after john dillinger was like shots fired except not because he doesn't like to shoot sorry so getting into his first day's
Speaker: February 15, 1933, he and his first accomplice try and rob this bank called the Corn Exchange Bank and Trust Company in Philadelphia. Corn.
Speaker: ah Rain's friends were Philadelphia. Or Pennsylvania. I don't so second attempt was on... or sorry but but but back up sutton was dressed as a mailman and went in first thing in the morning ah but they chickened out after some scrutiny from an onlooker spooked them um okay second attempt was on january 15th 1934 so a year later willie and two accomplices get in through a skylight somehow oh damn that's a totally different approach
Speaker: I'm like a skylight. They walk in the front door one time one year or the next year. They're coming in through the roof. Mission Impossible style. Right. Yeah, so they like break in, i think, in the night. And then when the watchman arrived, they forced him to admit the employees as usual. And each employee was handcuffed and crowded into a small room.
Speaker: And yeah, that was how that one went. It was pretty successful, I guess. He robbed ah robbed a Broadway jewelry store by, quote, impersonating a postal telegraph messenger.
Speaker: um and he also used cost costumes or uniforms of dressing up like a cop, a messenger, and a maintenance man. So he did like to do that to get in. Classics.
Speaker: I mean, people don't question it, right? Yeah. You got it like a clipboard and stuff. And I mean, but you're wearing ah I don't know, they call it a boiler suit in Britain.
Speaker: Just like a jump suit. Whatever. Yeah. um He did love to carry around some guns. He had an affinity for Thompson machine guns and pistols.
Speaker: And he had this quote, it said, ah you can't rob a bank on charm and personality. He once observed um in an interview in the reader's digest published shortly before his death, Sutton was asked if the guns that he used in his robberies were loaded.
Speaker: He responded that he never carried a loaded gun because somebody might get hurt.
Speaker: Damn. And nobody ever called his bluff. I guess not. it's crazy. And kudos to Reader's Digest. What the fuck kind of articles are they doing?
Speaker: I know! Sometimes they're good. My mom liked Reader's Digest. I mean, inspired... Sometimes when used them as a source, I'm like, what the hell? Yes. Or you're like, oh, they inspired the Lagina boys to come dig up Oak Island. Like, they're affecting people.
Speaker: um But yeah, i thought that was kind of funny. ah It said that he stole from the rich and kept it, though public opinion later made him into a type of gentleman thief like Robin Hood.
Speaker: He allegedly never robbed a bank when a woman screamed or a baby cried.
Speaker: Oh.
Speaker: It sounds like he's taking on like legend status to me. Yeah, I don't think that's true. That no women were like, ah! Ever. Ever. He's like, well, I'm out. Sorry to... Pardon me, ma'am.
Speaker: Have a nice day. of Oh, that's the only the only... Strike one. Woman crying. I'm out. Yeah. But, like... It does remind me, too. if We did watch the adaptation about the the Stockholm Bank that got robbed.
Speaker: That was starring Skarsgård there. It himself. Pennywise himself. Yeah. Bill Skarsgård. And there was a lot of sex, but it was good.
Speaker: it was really funny as Clark. I don't know. just like banging some chick and then like her mom was there and then he was like banging the mom. was just like, okay. It was a lot of like, it was because there was some backstory about him growing up and stuff like that. and Okay. I was going to say, I don't remember that from your case.
Speaker: No, but he almost hooked up with one of the One of the bank tellers, I think. Like, there was, like, rumors of stuff going down. I can't remember. It's been it's been a hundred years.
Speaker: i know. Everybody go re-listen to the um episode that we covered that in. Whichever one that was.
Speaker: Yeah. Sweden crimes, maybe? oh Nope. I don't know. I need to look it up. I can't remember. i think we... Did we do specifically, like, robberies or something?
Speaker: Bank heists, yeah. Guys, tell us. Let us know in the comments. I think we did... um
Speaker: like hostages i think it was about like people being hostages because the one I did was um but the one where they kept the bus yeah they kept the yeah the bus and then the a cup they took a couple hostages with them in the car yeah and stuff that was the one I did so I think it was something about hostages that was horrifying yeah Like, you're scared to ride the goddamn bus!
Speaker: Ugh! Where the media and everything got so involved and it messed up everything. Oh, yeah. That was so Like, photographed. that was the crazy part.
Speaker: Yeah, like, hours. Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Speaker: Oh, Kelsey, that one was sad. i don't want to think about it anymore.
Speaker: Let's go back to this now. Where he's going to go to jail again. yay Oh, shoot. This kid... June 1931. I have the date, the year wrong here. Because we just saw him rob two banks. We got up to 1934. And then I have he was rearrested in June 1931. Oh, shoot.
Speaker: so Has Wikipedia failed me or did I put it down wrong? Because i i already had I did have to fix a different date where I went, that doesn't make any sense. 17 years later is not the next year or something like that.
Speaker: Oh, I'm so sorry. um So, yeah, I guess this is when he goes to jail at one point, probably still in the nineteen thirty s because he's in there for a while.
Speaker: it says
Speaker: Anyway, I don't know. a little unclear about the beginning clearly i have he was sentenced to 30 years at that point and then about a year and a half later have in december of 1932 he escapes so perhaps perhaps i was incorrect in that the february 1933 one is his first attempt but that's what it said i'm sorry timelines oh yeah me crazy
Speaker: Oh no, is nothing going to add up now? Okay. Year and a half in December 1932, he escapes. Okay, escaped in 32.
Speaker: Right, then robs a place 33. and and 34. Oh no, he's attempted. Okay, okay. No, I think we're good. I'm so sorry.
Speaker: It was also long ago. um He was caught, I'm pretty sure again, on February 5th, 1934. and this time they said he'd get 25 to 50 years at the Eastern State Penitentiary. Never heard of it.
Speaker: Nope, never. Isn't that the haunted one? I thought that was the haunted one. Yeah. Oh.
Speaker: In Philly. And this is for the machine gun robbery of the Corn Exchange Bank. Okay, yeah. He does a lot of getting in jail and escaping. He next escapes on April 3rd, 1945 with 12 others through a tunnel. Through the use of a tunnel.
Speaker: Oh, are they shopping at Gordo? Yeah. I'm trying to contain this furry, furry child. oh Pat was watching a... a podcast on YouTube earlier and their cat was weaving around and also, yeah nudging against its laptops. I'm like, oh, it's pulling the gordo.
Speaker: Yeah. They all do it. Okay. So this, you be sorry.
Speaker: check ah Okay. This time he was appretended the same day by the Philadelphia police and they were annoyed at this point.
Speaker: This was his fifth attempt at that prison, apparently, to escape. Damn. He was then sentenced to life as a fourth-time offender. so yeah, he's been in and out at this point.
Speaker: Goes off to Philly, country Philadelphia. and Didn't want to write that all out. ah County prison in Holmesburg. And then on February 10th of 1947, he and others stole some guard uniforms, classic, his favorite, and they head out to the yard.
Speaker: Jesus. If I can use it to get into places, surely I can use to get out of prison. Yeah. He's a career ah prison escapee.
Speaker: Escape artist. Yeah.
Speaker: Like, stop robbing banks. You just keep going back to jail. Yeah. Armed with ladders in hand, they went to the perimeter wall, and when searchlights spotted them... This is great. I love it. Sorry.
Speaker: Walking with ladders under cover of darkness. do do just Like a little cartoon. They got their guard uniforms on. They're ready for it. They see the searchlights, and they just yell out, It's okay!
Speaker: We're all good down here! Maintenance! It's just us! And the Garfs just waved them off again. just casually go on your merry-go-round. Oh my god
Speaker: And this is why on March 20th, 1950, he was added to the FBI's most wanted list. The newly made what Wow. I think he was one of the first ones.
Speaker: um And they also would, when they wanted, when he was on the lam... They would show his wanted photo to like tailors and dress shops and all these fine clothing places.
Speaker: Cause he was just such a spiffy dresser. Hey.
Speaker: um and it was ah ironically, finally on February 18th, a lot of February's, uh, 1952, he's spotted by a 24 year old man named Arnold Schuster, who was a Brooklyn clothes that clothing salesman and amateur detective.
Speaker: Um, amateur detective i don't know one source just said a taylor son but then the other source said that which was way better ah yeah i'm a taylor but i'm also batman night um so he saw sutton on the subway and he then followed willie to a gas station where he was buying a battery because apparently that was where you could buy a car battery at the time.
Speaker: And the police caught up with him there and he did not at risk resist arrest, but did deny any crimes committed since his 1947 escape. He was like, no, I've been ah swear You can't arrest me for escaping prison if I've been good. haven't tried to rob anyone.
Speaker: ah he They said he was owing one life sentence plus 105 years. Yeah, I was going to say he must have been sentenced to 100 years by now. And he's not going to get out after five in 18 months.
Speaker: No. ah Ugh. No, in fact, at this point, they have a trial in Queens County Court where they slap on 30 more years. we're like, that's not good enough.
Speaker: That's meaningless at this point if he just escapes again. I know. Or as long as we can hold him. Yeah. But instead, this time he spends his time writing a book in jail, a book called I, William.
Speaker: um Published that. Will I Am? No. And just as ah an aside to mention that he his other nickname was The Actor for all his different roles he played. Oh, really?
Speaker: It's funny. Yeah. He's a chameleon. Yeah.
Speaker: a Okay, so 17 years after that, they overturn his two life sentences and the 105 years due to good behavior. And this, I guess, is because he's also ill with emphysema and he needed surgery on his leg arteries.
Speaker: Oh. I don't know. So December 1969, the Sutton is released from Attica State Prison.
Speaker: And when he heard that he was getting released, he responded, thank you, your honor, God bless you, and wept as he was let out of the court building. He's too old to escape prison now.
Speaker: Yeah. He's just like, yeah, just want to live. um But next year, does an ad for a new Britain-Connecticut bank and trust company's photo credit card program.
Speaker: I know he does like a commercial for this bank. Which, um, there's the only other details is in this quote that talks about his life after prison.
Speaker: After his release, Sutton delivered lectures on prison reform and consulted with banks on theft deterrent techniques. He made a television commercial for New Britain the Bank and Trust Company in Connecticut for their credit card with picture identification on it.
Speaker: um so it's a pretty new technology at the time maybe um his lines were they call it the face card now when i say i'm willie sutton people believe me
Speaker: love such good advertising that's so funny that's like um a level of that guy well now they're calling into question whether or not he actually did these crimes the guy that like um to catch me if you can that guy can't remember oh okay he was like that's based off yeah yeah now they're like a lot of people are saying he might have been exaggerating a lot of the crimes and stuff he's claiming um and stuff but i feel like that of like going to work with like the government or going to work with the people you were ripping off now it helps the bank yeah
Speaker: Yeah, but it does, it does happen. It's giving me ah vibes of, you know, that, like, CEO and whatever at the Coldplay concert that was caught cheating there. and Oh, yeah.
Speaker: And then, so Coldplay, so Chris Martin, and then that company that he worked for whatever, like turned around and hired Gwyneth Paltrow to do a PR ad for them or whatever. I thought that was funny. I was like, Oh, smart. Lean into it. You're getting the press anyway.
Speaker: Might as well make it Well, apparently good apparently, whoever was married or whatever, they were actually in midst of a separation or something. So, like, it might not have actually been an affair.
Speaker: But, like, still, you, as a CEO, should not be dating the head of your HR department. Yeah, I was gonna say, I didn't hear this um separation angle. Maybe that's someone trying to put out something for some damage control.
Speaker: I think so. But I'm, like, still not a great look to, like, be there with. and an employee like that and just don't be so fucking weird when the camera hits you guys that's all you had to do yeah the world is looking for something to be viral that's not horrible at all times yes absolutely not horrible for us yeah yeah
Speaker: yeah i need to look at um more seal compilation videos like somebody sent into sinister hood which was like seals flopping around and doing silly stuff it's just yeah fix your fix your algorithm make it funny animal videos instead of tragic world news or something yes or like and then well i heard a podcast and they called the seals um chub marines so made shock burning I know when there's like the term for when they come up out of the water to like bask in the sun. It's like bellying up or laying up or something.
Speaker: It just sounds like, yeah you know, curling up on the couch and being a couch potato. It's so great. That's awesome. you um Okay. So he did die November um in springhill florida We ended up in Florida.
Speaker: Oh, no. Connection. Florida man. He was 79. But his legacy lives on. So this is kind of fun fact. He has a law named after him that's used in medicine education.
Speaker: So Sutton's Law, ah it's called, ah so it refers... Yes. Okay. So it refers to when he was supposedly asked by a reporter why he robbed banks, he replied allegedly because that's where the money is.
Speaker: um Which he later refuted saying that, but he became like famous for it. So it said um the quote evolved into Sutton's law, which is often invoked to medical students as a metaphor for emphasizing the most likely diagnosis rather than wasting time and money investigating every conceivable full possibility. So kind of like Murphy's law.
Speaker: The simplest explanation the correct one, I guess.
Speaker: if It sounds like a Sutton. No.
Speaker: Interesting. But he said in his autobiography, so maybe that was the I, William one, um it said Sutton denied originating the pithy rejoinder.
Speaker: And he said, he wrote, the irony of using a bank robber's maxim as an instrument for teaching medicine is compounded I will now confess by the fact that I never said it. The credit belongs to some enterprising reporter who apparently felt a need to fill out his copy.
Speaker: I can't even remember where first read it It just seemed to appear one day and then it was everywhere. If anybody had asked me, I'd probably have said it. That's what almost anybody would say. it couldn't be more obvious.
Speaker: Yeah. Like, I'm a robber. I rob places that have money. You wouldn't see me robbing a place that has no money. Ask a stupid question. a stupid answer yeah get a stupid answer. say...
Speaker: um but he did also say Okay, I think this one's from the book too, and like they're saying he did say it. Why did I rob banks?
Speaker: Because I enjoyed it. I loved it. I was more alive when I was inside a bank, robbing it than at any other time in my life. I enjoyed everything about it so much that one or two weeks later, I'd be out looking for the next job.
Speaker: But to me, the money was the chips. That's all.
Speaker: And that's Willie Sutton. He just likes the adrenaline. Exactly. He is. He's an adrenaline junkie. That's why he had to keep plotting and escaping and icing.
Speaker: ah Yeah. Oh. Yeah, i thought he was fun.
Speaker: Yeah. Not too bad. Yeah, when you get two nicknames.
Speaker: Well, that's all I got. That was fun. Hopefully you guys enjoyed it. Yes. Not so much yours.
Speaker: But it was a good story. yeah I was like, I retract my statement. Yes, we didn't. We found it interesting.
Speaker: and know it is. It is an interesting case. Like, wow. um And then next time, we are moving on to perfectly paranormal for Valerian.
Speaker: Spooky stories. Yeah, I mean, spooky stories. Some creepy stories. Whatever we find, run across to share for Halloween. Keep it a little easier episode. If anyone wants to send castlesandcryptidsatgmail.com Send them all in.
Speaker: Creepy ghost story if you have story you really like. Anything. Yeah. um Yeah, I love listener stories. I'll hear them on other podcasts and sometimes it's just like someone thinks they, you know, maybe got a sign from ah a loved one that's passed and, you know, just stuff like that. It doesn't have to be anything like you think you heard a Bigfoot.
Speaker: because like But I bet we all wish we had a story like that. but Probably. No. Sleep paralysis. We did have that one listener story on our 100th? 150th? Yeah.
Speaker: Something like that. Love it. Love to see it. Love to see you guys listening. And um yeah, spooky stories. That should be fun.
Speaker: Yes. o not For Halloween. Yeah, I can't believe. Halloween and then it'll be Christmas before you know it. What the hell? Year the Snake will be done.
Speaker: My work already has Valentine's Day stuff. Like... Oh my god. Not just the Christmas priest, but the Valentine's Day. It's like, haven't even had Thanksgiving here, haven't had Halloween yet, haven't even had Christmas, and we have Valentine's Day.
Speaker: You're like five holidays ahead. Oh my god. Calm down. Right? Who do you think you are Party City? I'm just Just sell all the holidays all year round then, okay? Spirit to Halloween turns to The spirit of Christmas turns to Valentine's Day adventures.
Speaker: Hey, the way some people decorate their high houses now. Oh, man. I saw a really cool one on Reddit. It looked like Monster House. It looked like they gave it like almost like it where it looked like teeth coming down from the eaves with lights and stuff.
Speaker: Yeah. And then with the lights off, it was like all lit from the inside. But even for all the he like all the holidays now, people go all out. like I don't remember a few years ago there being such thing as Valentine's Day decorations.
Speaker: And like now it's crazy. Yeah, people love like a decorative hand towel. Decorative hand towels, decor, everything. like Kitchy housewares. Yeah. yeah Yeah.
Speaker: Um, and yeah, make sure to check back out on our Patreon. I know we were talking about trying to do another or do with like a Halloween, um taste test.
Speaker: We've got some spooky looking glasses and stuff. And today I picked up pumpkin spiced wine from a Canadian wine. Oh, that's interesting.
Speaker: yeah ah Say maybe when I get back. We plan a day where we can do a little taste test or something. A little cocktail party. Sounds fun.
Speaker: Yeah. Maybe some snacks or whatever. Watch a scary movie. That would be nice. Sounds good. Well, until next time.
Speaker: Keep it cryptic. Keep it cryptic. I was like, is she going say Keep spookily cryptic. Creep it cryptic. Oops. you Creep it. cryp That's really hard to say. is actually. Oh my Crypt it, keep it.
Speaker: Crypt keeper. Tales from the... Alright. Bye bye. but i
Speaker: Thank you for listening to Castles Encrypted. We love all our listeners and appreciate every subscriber, every new review, every listen, rate, and download. Our music is by Kobe off air and our cover art is by Antonio Garcia.
Speaker: We are also a proud member of dark cast network where you can find the best and spookiest of all indie podcasts. Follow us on social media where we are at castles and cryptids on mostly all of the things now, including Tik TOK check out our bonus content on PATREON.
Speaker: cryptid clashes, video mini-sodes of your hosts making asses of themselves, ask me anything, quizzes, other special episodes, and more. Starting at just $2 a month, you can get one to two extra episodes, depending on your level.
Speaker: We produce, edit, and research everything ourselves, and any support you can lend helps us to keep it cryptic.





