Zencastr
00:00:00
00:00:01
Speed1x
Format▸
Share
Embed
Report

Is Calvinism Biblical (Part 2)

Answering Pilate
Answering Pilate

17 plays · Nov 9, 2026

Transcript

Speaker: All right, Dustin, good to see you again. i'm Good to be back again. Good to see you as well. Yeah, thank you. Always glad to be here. And this is kind of like a part two. Yeah. We were talking about Calvinism, of all things, and I think we...

Speaker: You know, we were using the tulip. It's just sort of an easy way to summarize it. I mean, it's it's really more than that. but Anyway, we could talk. for hours and hours about this and be great to have. yeah Yeah. Be great to have somebody on here who.

Speaker: uh disagrees with us and then we could dialogue back and forth that'd be fun because i do believe in iron sharpening i certainly wouldn't get upset just have a great conversation but nevertheless I don't know if we can make that happen sometime. We'll see.

Speaker: But, be that as it may, ah Last time we were together, we talked about total depravity. You know, the sinfulness of human beings are born dead in sin. Total depravity doesn't mean that we're as sinful as we can be.

Speaker: but it means we're sinful in every aspect of our being. um Everything we think, do, motives. thoughts. It's all sin until... God works grace in us.

Speaker: And then we moved into unconditional election. And that's one of those big ones that everybody, you know, talks about. and Since you were saying that before the foundation of the world.

Speaker: God chose a people for Himself? That was the plan. He sent his son into the world to... atone for their sin. That's particular redemption, which we're coming to yeah next.

Speaker: And then the Holy Spirit applies that redemptive work of Christ to the elect. So, God. the Father, Son, and Spirit work in harmony with one another. And that may come up when we're talking about.

Speaker: particular redemption or limited atonement to keep in. Concert with the letters, TULIP. So, anyway. Thought we would... um Talk a little bit about free will. okay Before we move into limited atonement, because...

Speaker: I mean, we could talk about it anywhere, but a lot of time you know when folk are talking about election, you know one of the objections that our Arminian... brothers and sisters would make is, well, what about free will? And, you know, you hear things like God doesn't force himself on anyone. God's a gentleman. Right. He's not going to.

Speaker: force you to love him. And I heard someone say this morning in a completely different podcast. Talking about a completely different subject, but he was making the point that. God just...

Speaker: yeah He wanted people to love him. And um and and by the way, this guy's a ah wonderful, wonderful historian. But... i don't know that i would say i mean i know i wouldn't say the reason that god created us is not because he wanted us to love him he does he does all things for his own glory he didn't create us because he was lonely And I don't know that that's what this gentleman was implying, but nevertheless, he he went on to say that.

Speaker: you know, God one you know rocks can't love him creation can't love him and so he created people and You know, animals and angels, you know, can't love him, but we can love him and he wanted somebody to love him. and um You can't love.

Speaker: It's not real love unless it's completely free. and He said something else that was really interesting. It's escaping me now, but I may come back to that. but Oh, that's what he said. He said...

Speaker: He said, God is in in control of all things, but the one thing he chose not to control is your will. That's what brings me. Because we want to talk about. Free will, the one thing he chose not to control.

Speaker: is your will. He could have, but he chose not to. And, again, I would not make fun of his position, but I i would say. I think that needs a little bit more careful thought.

Speaker: And that's why we're here talking about it, even though it's a casual conversation. But that's what a lot of folk... yeah you know That's one of the objections. Well, what about free will? And one of the first things that I think we'd want to say.

Speaker: is that there is a distinction between free will. and free agency, right you know, when theologians talk about these things. and I don't know that a lot of folk are about that. Certainly, I think a lot of Arminian theologians are.

Speaker: Maybe modern theologians, not so much, but nevertheless. you know, the distinction between free will and free moral agency. Well, one of the things that we always say is we're not robots. We're not puppets.

Speaker: And so... um One of the things that that we should say, I don't know if you want to talk about free will or free moral agency first. Does it matter to you? No. Okay. I'll follow you. Okay. Let's talk about free will. Your will is not free from your nature. That's what we mean.

Speaker: It's not just out here. you're you You've got your nature. whether you're dead in sin or... Whether you're saved. Or whether you're God. I'll come back to that if I don't forget. yeah Your will is not distinct from your nature. it's not free from it and so the idea of free will we usually hear people use it They're talking about free choice or free moral agency, but they don't realize that there is a distinction. Yeah, a lot of people would say that in order for it to truly be free will.

Speaker: You have to have. the ability to choose the opposite Yes. of Of what you chose. regardless of what that choice may be. And the argument that we're going to attempt to make is that A person can't choose or will something outside of their nature. That's right.

Speaker: That's right. So if you're born dead in sin. I mean, you you asked that question last time. What can a dead man do? Yeah. like He can't do anything and do anything. Yeah, he's dead. He's spiritually dead.

Speaker: And, um you know, so. That that's the whole issue there. that if you're dead in trespasses and sin, You don't. want the things of God. right You don't will to want them. You don't...

Speaker: You don't understand them. you What does Paul say in 1 Corinthians 2 .14? He says the natural man, and natural is is who we are born you know by nature. So the natural man...

Speaker: does not receive the things of God. because they are foolishness to him. All right. So now think about that. By nature, when... When a person who's just born.

Speaker: Without having been born again, by nature he'd He literally doesn't receive the things of God. He doesn't want them. Why? Well, because they're foolishness to him. You ever taught talk to somebody in evangelism and they're just like, yeah, I don't believe all that stuff.

Speaker: I mean, that's what we're talking about. And then Paul goes on to say, Neither can he understand them. So not only does he not want them, he... Hey. in their foolishness, but he literally doesn't have the ability to understand the things of God. Because they are spiritually discerned. That's right. And what does that mean?

Speaker: Yeah, well, that's hearkening back to... We kind of already went through this discussion with our first two points, but... the need to be born again. Yeah. um Because...

Speaker: Again, if we're dead... as the natural man and we're dead in our sins. Our spirit is not. Alive, we've not been made alive By Christ, we haven't been born again.

Speaker: And so. If we don't have that ability. To understand those things. then then we're not going to. because we haven't had our spirits made alive in christ yeah that's right Gotta have the Holy Spirit. Got to have a new nature.

Speaker: ah That's what we're saying, and I'm reminded. My youngest daughter. yeah she's like 23 now i've actually got a 37 year old and a 33 year old which doesn't really matter but i'm just making the point But our my youngest daughter, she's 23, and I remember.

Speaker: She was writing a paper of some kind. back when she was in high school. And. um I honestly don't remember it, but I do remember. We were talking about certain things. She wrote she writes her own papers, but she would discuss certain ideas with me. sure And it had to do with these issues. It was a Christian class.

Speaker: Yeah. And... um I remember she said in there. I don't know if it's in a paragraph or the title of a section, but she said, even God doesn't have free will. and I was like, wow, I wonder what the teacher's going to say about that. And. um And she's homeschooled, but this is co -op. Yeah, I think a lot of folk that is. So anyway.

Speaker: And the teacher. ah She did. She got a good grade on her paper. And um I don't remember the exact wording, but the gist of what the teacher said, that's an interesting. thought I'm going to have to give that you know some more thought myself or something like that. Interesting point. I'm going to have to give that some more thought, and which which is great. You're trying to provoke anybody.

Speaker: But. Think about it. And this and i I'm only belaboring the point because we want folk to understand. You know, why we would say, well, you don't really have free will. Well, even God doesn't have free will. Yeah, and and again, a lot of a lot of people who would disagree.

Speaker: with us on this issue would definitely bristle at a statement like that, right? Because what does it sound like we're doing? It sounds like we're putting a limitation. on God and his power and his ability, correct? Right. But...

Speaker: the fact the make The fact of the matter is that God... is operating in the rules that he created. Right. So. By his nature, yes he cannot do things that are against his nature. That's right. God cannot sin. uh because he's perfectly righteous m he cannot do anything unrighteous and so In the sense of, like we talked about before.

Speaker: If you have to have the ability. To choose anything. regardless of your nature. then you would have to say, no, God does not have free will. Just like... We don't.

Speaker: Right. But God is free to do whatever he wants. Yes. What? What we would say is that. He can't want something that is outside of his nature. That's it. Well said. Just as we can't either. That's exactly right. and I think. um yeah You know, when you put it in those terms, it really helps people to understand you know where we're coming from. And that's why we can say, well, we're not robots any more than God is a robot.

Speaker: God makes choices, and as you said, A guy can do anything. You know, we were talking about this and another time. Would you ask me the whole question about the... Yeah, I remember people, you know I think kids used to ask this in Sunday school when they were young and things like that. Can God make a rock so big that even he couldn't lift it? Yeah.

Speaker: And. Obviously, that seems like. and Atheists might use a question like that to challenge our belief in God. And so it might seem like a gotcha question. But. It's fallacious.

Speaker: That's right. At its... at its founding Yeah, that's right. Why would he? Yeah, sure. um Because that. that goes against his nature. and Sure. And we're talking about a hypothetical.

Speaker: that. that just can't exist in reality. yeah right because god does operate in the rules that he created that's right that's right and he's the one that set the rules up the way that they are sure he's operating in that system that he established by his nature yeah and by his will. Yeah, yeah the the created universe. ah

Speaker: Follow certain... laws and rules, as you say, but it's by virtue of of who he is. There's nothing outside of God himself that compels God to do anything. There you go. His aseity is completely independent from his creation. That's exactly right.

Speaker: And as you said a moment ago, I just... Say it this way, there's an inherent contradiction in that. Can God make a rock so big that God can't lift it? Well, you're you're setting up the question. Right, yeah. So it's not really a gotcha question. Either you can't make it. Or he can't lift it. Yeah. yeah It's really a nonsense question, philosophically speaking. so But, um...

Speaker: Back to your your the critical point, though, that you made. the Bible. does literally say things like, God cannot sin. guy it's not that he simply chooses not to it's that he can't but because Because he's righteous. He's righteous, yeah.

Speaker: And it says that God... cannot lie it says that god cannot deny himself it says that god is not tempted by evil neither can he tempt anyone else to evil which brings up another question you know because uh you know when you get into these discussions about god's sovereignty and man's freedom.

Speaker: You know, and from the Calvinistic perspective, supposedly. ah God's the author of sin if you're a Calvinist because... God ordained everything. and How is God not responsible? Well,

Speaker: God you know so uses secondary causes, you know to decrease something. doesn't mean that God actually. perpetrated that something. It's not God who sins. It's sinful human beings who sin.

Speaker: And so... Why would a human being sin? But when you say God decreed it. Well, you said this last time. Forget who it was with reference to, but to just sinners in general.

Speaker: Pharaoh, I think it's Pharaoh. Yeah, you basically said... He did exactly what he wanted to do. You know, like on the one hand. He hardened his own heart. Only God hardened his heart. Exactly. Yeah. but Both things were true. yeah that's right God did harden his heart, but...

Speaker: the hardening of his heart that God... worked out was giving him over to do exactly what his hardened heart anded heart wanted to do he didn't give him grace to do otherwise he just let him do what he wanted as you said He didn't work evil in his heart. And God doesn't stop anybody from coming to him, as we said last time. Right. so You got to.

Speaker: You can't make. All of these are legitimate questions that people raise. But just be careful not to. You know, think, oh, well, this means that or that means, you know. Yeah, there's an underlying assumption, I believe.

Speaker: in in an opposition to this. That says. without maybe saying it out loud. that. If we truly believe.

Speaker: That we don't have, quote unquote, free will. then at some point... we're going to want to do something that we can't do. And what... We're saying is.

Speaker: free moral agency. Means that we can do whatever we want to do. Yeah. We can't want to do something. That's outside of our nature. yeah That's why we call it a sin nature. We say you know we say that we're born.

Speaker: with a sin nature. Which again... All of these points are interconnected. That's right. So it goes back to total depravity. That's right. We are born. with sinful hearts that want to do sinful things. yeah And we can't.

Speaker: want to do righteous things. right unless we have been born again that's right and we've been given that new heart yeah and somebody might object and say well i know people who aren't christians who do righteous things but But as we talked about before.

Speaker: even those things that we would consider righteous. are still sin because they're not done with the heart. that is doing it to glorify God. That's right. It's doing it for whatever selfish motive it might be and to get recognition, to glorify myself.

Speaker: to make myself feel better just make myself feel like a good person yeah to achieve my own righteousness, whatever that may be. And so at the root of... What we do is still sin. There's still wickedness and evil. yeah And so...

Speaker: ah Sin isn't just about the outward action, but it's about the attitude of the heart as well. Yeah, that's right. Well, I think we can we can probably move on, but I do want to nail that down with a couple of Scripture verses just before we do. And I think you quoted one or two of them last time.

Speaker: But one of them, and again, you might have to look it up to to get the exact wording. Sorry about that. But John 1, 12. Okay. where he talks about, you know, we were born not of the will of man. To those who believe on him, he gave the right to become the children of God.

Speaker: who were born Not of the... will of the flesh or not of um Something about heritage or something like that. You got it? Yeah, I've got it. You can read it if you got it. yeah so um So yeah, so verse 12.

Speaker: Since that's where you said start. It says, but as many as received him. There you go. yeah To them. He gave the right. to become children of God. to those who believe in his name who were born not of blood There you go. none or of the will of the flesh nor of the will of man but of God. There you go.

Speaker: So, I mean, he he covers the basis there. yeah You know, again, you're not you're not saved because you're born to a certain group of parents, but. You know, not of blood, but you're you're saved not by the will of the flesh.

Speaker: not by the will of man. Is that what he said? Yeah. ah But the will of God. But the will of God. Yeah, but of God, and that's the new birth. And then um we covered Romans 9. I don't think we have to rehash that, but he basically says the same thing.

Speaker: In Romans 9 where... Again, forgive me. all All these verses used to be just right there at my fingertips. but You know, they, if you don't, what is it? to You don't use it, you lose it. and it's so I don't quote all these, we're we're talking about different issues most of the time now. So I got a whole other set of verses, but anyway.

Speaker: He talks about it's not of him who. runs It's not of him who wills. but of God. And I think it's in that whole discussion of Jacob and Esau and then the Pharaoh thing that you read last time. Yeah. So Romans 9. We'll start at verse 14. There you go. What shall we say then? Is there unrighteousness with God?

Speaker: Certainly not. For he says to Moses, I will have mercy on whomever I will have mercy. and i will have compassion on whomever i will have compassion there you go so then It is not of him who wills, nor of him who runs.

Speaker: but of God. Who shows mercy? There you go. of God who shows mercy. And that's that's all we're saying. If you think about what grace really means, and that's why we refer to the.

Speaker: Calvinism. I don't even like that label, you know, because it it has all these negative connotations. and we don't follow a calvin on everything as we said last time yeah and and we don't affirm it because calvin taught it that's right that's right so yeah i i don't necessarily want to call myself a calvinist because i'm not following calvin right i happen to agree with the way that he organized his thoughts on God's plan of redemption. That's right. But yeah. um

Speaker: We believe that. far beyond. this being a teaching of John Calvin, we believe that this is what the scripture teaches. Yeah, that's right. And um so we refer to them a lot of the time. a ah lot of Calvinist as the doctrines of grace.

Speaker: Because that's what we're saying. And I know Arminians believe that salvation is by grace, but we conceive of it a little bit differently. And um you know if you could earn your salvation, it wouldn't be grace. If you could work for your salvation, it wouldn't be grace. And the Armenians certainly believe that. Yep. But, you know.

Speaker: You realize, man, it's all of grace, as Spurgeon said. God chose me. God redeem me. God gave me the new birth. God. drew me to himself. And he's going to preserve me all the way to the end. so Anyway, yeah. that that could take us into the atonement unless you got something else no yeah i think yes all right Good place to roll into it. Yeah, there you go. Well, again, and and as you've said, and as we've said.

Speaker: all All of these these five points that we're talking about. Remember... And it was a fellow named Arminius. who came up with five points that were in disagreement with the larger church. ah in his day. And so, you know, the theologians and the pastors, they all met the 1600s, the Synod of Dort.

Speaker: And they came up with five responses to the the five. points that Arminius made, and they came to be known as the five points of Calvinism. That's where that came from. Right.

Speaker: And. um We've simplified it. to help us to remember it down in the tulips. So, total depravity, unconditional election, and then the L stands for the limited atonement. And so, yeah You know...

Speaker: It's often referred to as definite atonement or particular redemption. So we're going to talk about that. I'll just get into one of the objections that the Armenians raised.

Speaker: From the get go, before we even say what it is, they object. Well, you're limited in the atoning work of Christ. you dad That's not good. That's not right. You can't do that. And again, they're trying to defend.

Speaker: ah The honor of Christ and the work of Christ and all that. so I really appreciate that. Yeah, it's where the terminology actually. Again, if you just read the words at their face value can sound a bit problematic yeah to say limited.

Speaker: Atonement? yeah And if the atonement is something that Christ did. Which... We would agree and Armenians would agree that that was the work of Christ, the atonement. That's right. Then to call it limited.

Speaker: Does seem like. you're putting a limit on Christ. Right. You're saying. That he he made the rock so big he couldn't lift it, right? That's right. um Yeah. And so, again, that's why maybe we might refer to it as particular redemption. definite atonement or yeah or something like that.

Speaker: Because again, words can get in the way sometimes. But. We're not saying... that there's any limit on the power and ability of Christ's.

Speaker: atoning work that's right on his blood you know yeah His blood is all sufficient. Yeah. His work of atonement was all sufficient. Yeah. What we are saying is that.

Speaker: There was a plan of redemption that... God, the father. God the Son, God the Spirit. Had before time began Yeah. to redeem a people. unto himself. And so what we're saying is that the the blood of Christ, the work of the Son.

Speaker: to atone for those people is completely sufficient. what But what we're also saying is that... By believing that... We do believe that those who...

Speaker: Reject Christ. he did not die for them right right Yeah. And I want to address, because that's good. I'm glad you brought, I'm glad you said it that way, using that language. We'll come back to that in just a minute, if that's okay. yeah But I want to also address something that you said, which is is absolutely right. I mean, everything you said is right.

Speaker: But. um Everyone limits. the atonement in some way. If you think about. And when we say limit, again, we're talking about how we conceive of of what. What is the intent of the atonement, the atoning work of Christ?

Speaker: What is the extent of the atonement? And. So we, as Calvinists, as we limit it by saying, even though we wouldn't we don't like that terminology, but we say,

Speaker: That. Christ. Death was for the elect. Who did Jesus die for? He died for the elect. Whose sins did Jesus pay for? He paid for the sins of the elect. That's what we would say. The Arminians would say. And so we limit it to the elect.

Speaker: The Armenians would say, No, Jesus died for everybody. He died for the sins of everybody. And we would then say, well, you limit. and not by way of criticism, but by way of theological argument, we would say, Well, you're limiting the power then.

Speaker: of Christ's atonement. and his atoning work because If Jesus died, for every single person. If Jesus died for all the sins, of all people Why are there many, many people who are not saved? And so there's a limitation, whether they would conceive it that way, but there's a limitation.

Speaker: On. The efficacy, if you don't like the word power, okay. the efficacy of the atonement. It didn't work for a lot of people right in in one sense.

Speaker: And so... You know, that's really the the heart of the matter. That's the question. particularly between um We Calvinist and Armenian brothers. yeah you know, what what was the intent of the atonement? Well, we would say Jesus Matthew 121, he came to save his people. Well, who are his people? They're going to say.

Speaker: Those who believe. Well, that's true, but we're going to say those whom he chose. He came to save. His people from their sins. right Matthew 121, I believe it is. so The intent of the atonement was not just to die.

Speaker: in a general sense again that's another term like general redemption versus particular redemption he came to die in a particular sense or a definite sense in in that he came to pay the price for the sins of his people.

Speaker: So... You know... And again, we want to get into some other objections. But this first one. again, um, I think John Owen put it best.

Speaker: He asked three questions. He said... All right, you you got three options here when you're thinking about the atoning work of Christ. He said, and we got to give some verses to back this up is what I meant to.

Speaker: But he said. all right did jesus die for all the sins of all men. Well, that doesn't work, as we said a moment ago. That's the first one. That doesn't work because not all men are saved.

Speaker: All right. Did Jesus die? for some of the sins of all men. Well, that doesn't work either because if he only died for some of the sins of all men, then nobody would be saved. Or did he die for all the sins? of some men and that's what we're saying he died for all the sins of some men but as you said That doesn't mean...

Speaker: that we limit the sufficiency or you know of his atoning work You know, a lot of people, and I want to come back to this, would say, well. Christ's death was...

Speaker: sufficient for all, efficient for the elect. I wouldn't say it that way because There's... The meaning that you gave, yes, I would say it that way. But when people, when theologians say that, they mean something else. And that's what I want to deal with, what I alluded to earlier.

Speaker: But what we're saying is. And I know I'm belaboring the point, sorry. But what we're saying is. that Jesus' death actually atoned for sin. It actually. accomplished what what he intended it to accomplish, but we we would also say it is sufficient.

Speaker: In this sense, that it it's sufficient for a thousand worlds if God created a thousand worlds. and Jesus doesn't have to do anything else.

Speaker: If there's... You know, more and more elect. he his His atoning work, he doesn't have to do anything else. It is sufficient in that sense. right But... When, um... I don't know if I should get into this now, but since we raised it, when... when Armenians say...

Speaker: Well, it's, it's... not our minions. Armenians wouldn't say it's... ah efficient for the elect and sufficient for all. they don't They don't deal in terms of its efficiency or its and efficacy.

Speaker: There are other Calvinist. who say, well, It's... Efficient for the elect but sufficient for all in what they mean. Gosh, you get into a lot of, I don't even want to get bogged down in this, but.

Speaker: Some of them. you know Those who would hold to hypothetical universalism, for example. We're going to have a whole broadcast on that, so we've got to be real brief or we're going to run out of time.

Speaker: These are Reformed people, Calvinistic people. Yes. But again, they would say sufficient for all, efficient for the elect. But what they're concerned with is. It is the ah the the the gospel offer.

Speaker: And whether or not we can truly say to someone, Jesus died for you. All you need to do is believe. and And because if you say that Jesus only died for the elect, then you can't truly say to someone,

Speaker: what I just said. Jesus died for you. And if you believe you'll be saved. And so they make a big deal out of that. Well, that's really an Armenian argument. Armenians say that all the time. Well, you can't.

Speaker: And truthfully say, if you're going to be honest. you can't truthfully say that Jesus died for you. The way I would respond, it would be multifold, but just in the brief time we had.

Speaker: I don't I don't. The apostles never said that. They never say in evangelism, Jesus died for you. They never say Jesus died for every single person. in In history, we're going to have to deal with some verses that Arminius said, wait a minute. Right. We'll get to that.

Speaker: The apostles just said, repent and believe. Right. And what we would say is. If you believe the gospel, you will be saved. That's a fact. Yes. So we are very happy.

Speaker: and very obligated to give the free offer. of the gospel. and the hypothetical universalist. Even though they're in that reform camp.

Speaker: I would push back on them just a little bit because their arguments are very, very similar. to the armenians i just leave it there because we could talk a whole right yeah because i yeah i think it is faulty to if you are trying to share the gospel with someone to try to lead with.

Speaker: Jesus died for you. Amen. Or maybe another phrase that we've heard a lot in evangelism. Especially. From a more Armenian persuasion, it would be God loves you and has a wonderful plan for your life. Yeah. Right. yeah Um, and.

Speaker: Those things sound great and they sound inviting. Yes. You know, to the person that we're talking to. And and that's why. It's tempting to want to use that. Yeah. um But that's coming and that is starting at a faulty position.

Speaker: As you said. at any time during the new testament when the apostles were proclaiming the gospel to the world, they never used such language. They simply said, repent.

Speaker: And believe in the Lord Jesus Christ and you will be saved. That's right. that's um And so we do extend that call. We also don't believe that some. is a small number Right. And i I feel like a lot of times.

Speaker: There's the perception. of that. right That if we say... He only died for the elect. Well, then you're talking about such a small number. You're limiting, you know. Yeah, yeah, yeah. and The fact of the matter is, in one sense, we have no idea.

Speaker: We know from... reading in Revelation. that it's a number that no one can number. That's right. Well, even in Genesis. Genesis to Revelation. Yeah, Genesis to Revelation. um yeah The Lord tells Abraham that his descendants...

Speaker: will be as numerous as the stars in the sky. That's right. And we still haven't counted all of those, I believe. Not yet. And so we're not limiting the number of people that can be saved. yeah We believe that as many as the Lord brings.

Speaker: we'll be saved. And we don't know what that number is, and we don't know when we're going to reach that number. And so we continue to proclaim the gospel because we continue to want to see more and more people saved. And every time we see a person saved, we say, praise the Lord. Yeah.

Speaker: They're part of the elect. That's right. That's right. Yeah, I don't know if you want to maybe... kind of pivot into some of the verses that you mentioned that yeah in opposition, since we're kind of, let me say one more thing and then go to that because you brought up.

Speaker: You know, God loves you and has a wonderful plan for your life. well you know That's what they would say. Well, God loves everybody. He loves everybody in that general sense. He causes the sun to shine on the saved, the righteous verse and the unrighteous alike. Yeah, the fact that he has chosen not to destroy us already.

Speaker: All. Yeah. Because we all deserved it. Yeah. Means that in that sense, yes, God is a loving God. But. saving There's a saving love, which is different. He treats certain people different than others in in that sense. He does.

Speaker: And. Even if you're an Arminian, you'd have to admit that. I mean, some are saved and some are not. But you quoted it last time, Romans 9, Jacob have I loved. Esau I hated. And he says, before the children were born, before they had done anything good or evil,

Speaker: It was said, Jacob of Elod, it was said to the older, you shall sow the younger. Jacob of Elod, he saw the hated. That the purpose of God, according to election, might stand. Yeah. I mean, it literally says that. so that's where we're coming from we're just trying to yeah And listen, I know the Armenians.

Speaker: They're going to raise these verses that you that you're ready to go into, and I am too. They're saying, okay, what about these verses? Great. Because now... That's what we're seeing. We're looking at certain verses that say this. You're looking at certain verses that say that that's where we ought to be. John Owen's argument notwithstanding.

Speaker: It's a good argument, but he's not our authority. The Bible's our authority. all right so hit yeah and us with some of those verses um so uh the first one um that not necessarily the first one first one on our list yeah uh we just did a little short list yeah that they would often use uh would be first john 2 2.

Speaker: And I'm going to pull it up and... Yeah. Actually read it word for word here. um So 1 John 2, 2, he says, and he himself. I'm talking about Jesus, is the propitiation for our sins.

Speaker: and not for ours only but also for the whole world So... yeah How do we answer that? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. No, that's a good question. And there's a whole slew of verses like that. and um And...

Speaker: God so loved the world. Talking about love and the word world there. But... propitiation for our sins and and only that the whole world. As you said, on the one hand, Jesus' death is sufficient for...

Speaker: yeah you know not only the whole world but whole universes even though Even though there's only one one universe, one world, one earth, that's where God's people are. you know We put it in that context of the old versus the new.

Speaker: and how under the Old Testament, we talked about this a little bit last time. You know, you had national Israel. And now the gospel. is going to the nations, to the world. yeah to the people groups, the Pantata ethnos, all the people groups of the world.

Speaker: you use a Hebrew word, to the goyim. And so you have Old Testament verses even alluding to that. Listen, you Gentiles, listen, you coastlands, all that. And so when you come to the New Testament,

Speaker: Remember, Old Testament is types and shadows preliminary Prophecy And then the new testament is fulfillment. Paul, just as another issue, we didn't talk about this last time, but he uses the term multiple times in the New Testament. I show you a mystery. or This is a mystery.

Speaker: And mystery doesn't mean... Something was mysterious. That's hard to understand. It's not how the word is used in Greek in the New Testament. And he tells you how it's used, Ephesians 3, for example, and there are many places, but he says,

Speaker: No, a mystery is something that's given in seminal form. in the Old Testament. But it's now through us, the apostles, being been fully revealed. And so, again, the types and the shadows are revealed.

Speaker: in the New Testament. And Paul says, it came to me by way of revelation. This is how I understand these things. It's not that I'm smarter than you guys. It's that God's revealed it. So I think that's a massive dynamic. So when you get to the New Testament.

Speaker: The whole. The fact that the Gentiles, he says in Ephesians 2, are going to be included in the people of God. That was a mystery. that It was in seed form in the Old Testament, fully revealed in the New.

Speaker: And because it was only in seed, well, I don't know if it was because, but because it was only available in seed forms for one reason. There are many. But most of the Jews didn't get that. And that's part of the reason the New Testament is explaining these things. That's part of the reason this language is used.

Speaker: He is the propitiation for our sins, the Jews who believe, but not only ours, for the whole world, not every single person. yeah But the Gentiles as well. That's what he means. you know that explanation of mystery it's similar to Jesus teaching in parables. Yep. right So Jesus would would give a parable.

Speaker: ah the sower or the shepherd or or whatever it may be. And he would explain the story. And... a lot of people in the crowd would just not get it yeah and then but then we see in scripture where the the the disciples would come to Jesus afterwards and say, Can you please explain what you just said? yeah um And then Jesus would explain it right in in further detail. So that message was given, but not understood by all until it was revealed.

Speaker: to them. that's Um, you know, with the parables, it was literally revealed by the word in flesh by Jesus himself as he explained it to them. yeah Um, and then they understood.

Speaker: that That answer um that you just gave would be similar to another verse. that they would use, which would be 1 Timothy. oh okay chapter two yeah um verses five and six says there is one god one mediator between god and men the man Jesus Christ.

Speaker: who gave himself a ransom for all. to be testified in due time. Yeah. um But if you keep reading into the next verse. Again, we can use that same application here.

Speaker: He says, for which I was appointed a preacher and apostle. We're talking about Paul here. Yeah. I am speaking the truth in Christ and not lying, a teacher of the Gentiles. in faith and truth. So Paul points out the fact that he was the apostle sent to the Gentiles, yeah to the world. To the world, to Paul. As he said, yeah. And so even right there, he's explaining.

Speaker: You know what he means. Because, again... This is a very transitional time. in the people of God, in the church. In its infancy. Mm -hmm. And.

Speaker: So... even the early believers. are having to come to the understanding of What? is truly happening here that God's plan is now moving beyond jerusalem yeah And it is moving to...

Speaker: The ends of the earth or the world, yeah as we would say. Yeah, that's right. Can you just read that verse again yeah from the beginning? starting with verse five well w yeah whatever you read yeah for there is one god and one mediator between God and men.

Speaker: the man Christ Jesus. who gave himself a ransom for all to be testified in due time for which i was appointed a preacher and an apostle. yeah I'm speaking the truth in Christ and not lying. A teacher of the Gentiles.

Speaker: in faith. and truth yeah Yeah. Just a pile of reverse. I just wanted to hear it one more time. Sorry. let let Let me deal with... ah Two quick issues there.

Speaker: I want to... two Two... ways that I would. to argue our case again, in addition to what you've already said and I've already said. I was actually, this morning, I just... I was in my Bible reading. i'm a we We have this little group of folk. They're reading through the Bible in a year together.

Speaker: And I'm... um About three weeks behind, I hate to admit it. Here we are in November, and I'm trying to catch up. But anyway. I was in Colossians 1 this morning as part of that Bible reading.

Speaker: And. Colossians 1, verse 6. Are you able to pull that up real quick? And I was just reading along, it's like, oh. Boom. yeah that's That's something that... relates to you know what we're going to be talking about today.

Speaker: um Not one of our verses, but just just read that if you don't mind. And I'm going to ask you a question. Okay. Colossians 1 verse 6. Yeah. which has come to you as it also has the gospel by the way yeah Oh, yes. Start over. um You want to back up and... give a couple yeah maybe a verse or two ahead of time but all right I'm going to start at verse 3, because that's where the sentence kind of sure starts off. Again, we got Paul writing those sentences. Yeah. yeah yeahs yeah um So Colossians 1 verse 3.

Speaker: We give thanks to the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ praying always for you since we heard of your faith. In Christ Jesus. and of your love for all the saints. Because of the hope... which is laid up for you in heaven.

Speaker: of which you heard before in the word. of the truth of the gospel which has come to you as it has also in all the world. and is bringing forth fruit.

Speaker: as it is also among you since the day you heard and knew the grace of God in truth. Okay. So Paul's saying that the gospel came to you at a particular time, and it's bearing fruit.

Speaker: and it's all as it also has in all the world. Now, if you're going to be consistent with your hermeneutic from an Armenian perspective, you're going to have to say the world there means every single person.

Speaker: So are we to believe that at that point that the gospel had been heard by every single person? Absolutely not. Yeah, of course not. Yeah. So again, when Paul says it's going into all the world,

Speaker: I think he means Gentile nations now. But even if he doesn't mean Gentile nations, he just means it's spreading pretty rapidly. But I do think it means Gentile nations because where did it start?

Speaker: Jerusalem. Where's it going? Judea. Samaria. uttermost parts of the earth. Here we've got a church in Colossae now. Paul's the one.

Speaker: He's over there in the Middle East, and he hears the mac ah sees the man man from Macedonia come over here. takes the gospel to Europe, right? grease greece and all all that. Anyway.

Speaker: So... Again, just arguing that that we understand these things. in context because nobody would say that every single person in the world had heard the gospel. In fact,

Speaker: I think most of us say we don't think every single person in the world's heard the gospel today. um It's pretty widespread, but but there's still some unreached people groups. So again, it just means it's going to all the nations.

Speaker: which is what the Great Commission is all about, make disciples of all the nations. You know, there's a verse, and I don't even know where this is, but it talks about... I'm just supporting my argument here, just in terms of how language is used.

Speaker: It says that Jesus came preaching and all Judea went out to hear him. What? I don't think they mean every single person in Judea went out to hear Jesus. They closed all the shops for the day. Right. Yeah. You know, we might say yeah Hey man, who was at that?

Speaker: party the other night you and i don't know everyone was there everyone everybody was there yeah yeah Okay. Not everybody, but it was there. Yeah. yeah a lot of folk were there yeah yeah anyway well i i'm part of the cool crowd but i wasn't there Anyway, no, I'm just kidding.

Speaker: But. Yeah, there was another argument I wanted to make, but it's gone now, so we'll just well keep moving. That's right. um There are some verses, though. Oh, well, this is the other argument. Okay.

Speaker: You got to ask yourself another question. So one question. world. All in other context, you know because everybody says all means all. Well, yes. But all is always in a context just like any other word, right? So all the kids were there. On what kids? Well, all the football players or all the...

Speaker: High school or whatever. yeah Yeah, similarly, just to pile another verse on. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But again, it's the same answer, really and truly. ah Hebrews 2 .9. yeah says but we see jesus who was made a little lower than the angels for the suffering of death crowned with glory and honor, that he, by the grace of God, might taste death for everyone. Well, again, they're going to say die for everyone. Does everyone mean?

Speaker: everyone in the world. Or... Does it mean... Everyone. for whom he died i think that yeah which is obviously the way we'd interpret that now Okay.

Speaker: So they're they're still not convinced. I can tell. So... And we can talk about some more of those verses if you like, but let's go to some verses that say. that jesus died For the elect. Or died for his people. I've already quoted Matthew 121. He came to save his people from their sins.

Speaker: you You got a couple there? Yeah. um John 10. Okay. Let me get there real quick. And then before I interpret the verse, once you read it. I'm going to ask this question that's in my okay my head. John 10, we're kind of in the middle of.

Speaker: the Jesus. describing himself as the Good Shepherd. Yeah. Okay. And so let's see. Verse 11. I am the good shepherd. Yep. The good shepherd gives his life for the sheep.

Speaker: And if you skip down, because we need to skip down. but Right. for That's good. for ah For brevity's sake. Which we have a lot of that. Verse 14, he then says, again, I am the good shepherd.

Speaker: And I know my sheep and am known by my own. As the Father knows me, even so I know the Father, and I lay down my life for the sheep. Yep. or other translations would say my She, yeah.

Speaker: And so... Again, here he's talking about... He's not laying his life down for the goats, right? No. He's laying his life down. for the sheep um and he also even further explains later on that same passage that again going back to this whole notion of Now the gospel is going beyond the Jews.

Speaker: that He says, I have sheep that are not of this fold, ah and they will hear my voice and come to me as well. Who's that? That's us. That's the Gentiles. That's the Gentiles. it's not yeah Okay, so you said it very specifically.

Speaker: He says I lay my life down for the sheep. And in that context. He didn't lay his life down for the goats. He didn't lay his life down for the wolves. He laid his life down for the sheep.

Speaker: And so there you got a verse that says, That's why Jesus died. Now again, the Armenian comes back and says, well... He just read a verse that says he died for everyone. Okay. Can there be a contradiction? This is my question. Can Scripture contradict Scripture? Right. And the answer is absolutely not. absolutely not And this is why we talk about the analogy of Scripture.

Speaker: that Scripture interprets Scripture, and you have to put it all together. You can't pick and choose. So you got to know how words are being used in their particular context. Okay. Did all Judea, every single person hear Jesus preach?

Speaker: Is the gospel going out into all the world? Has everybody heard the gospel? especially in the first century. or Are those words in those contexts meaning something a little different as we explain?

Speaker: Okay, well, the second question is... Again, can Scripture contradict Scripture? No, it cannot. So you have to... You can't make them contradict. And so when you've got this issue here that Jesus lays his life down for the sheep,

Speaker: Well, that's going to help you to understand. Along with the other things we've been talking about, the context of the New Testament, the gospel going to the world, the all the Gentiles. And you've read several verses that support that.

Speaker: when it says that he gave his life for the world or gave his life for all. Doesn't mean every single person. All the sheep. Means all the sheep. Oh, the elect. That's right. So that that that would be where where we're coming from. but You've got other verses that say he died. Yeah, well, and you mentioned Matthew 1 already. yeah And again, this is in the middle of what we call the Christmas story. Yeah. Right. ah the The angel Gabriel has appeared to Mary and.

Speaker: is telling her what's going to happen to her. She's going to... become pregnant and she's going to give birth to a son. And in verse 21. Actually... Let me make yeah sure I get this go ahead exactly correct.

Speaker: The angel is talking to Joseph at this point okay and telling Joseph. The she's pregnant with the son of god don't put her away this is part of god's plan And in it. He's explaining to Joseph. Okay. Why? And he says, she will bring forth a son. and you shall call his name jesus from what we did the Old Testament we would call Joshua, Yeshua, right? Which means...

Speaker: God saves, right? um And it says, for he will save. His people. from their sins. yeah Um, yeah and so again, it doesn't say he will save all people. Right. From their sins. It says he will save his people. And again, read in context with all the scripture.

Speaker: You know, we understand that to mean the the sheep that he calls and hears his voice and come to him. Yeah. My sheep. Hear my voice, my sheep. And in even in that verse. ah My sheep.

Speaker: Hear my voice. He's saying. Of all the... The... the And. sheep out there. And goats. My sheep, and they hear me beforehand, and they come to me. and In one place, he literally says this. My sheep hear my voice, and they come to me, and they.

Speaker: They will in no wise be cast out. Yeah, because and and cause he also talks about... hirelings. Yes. False shepherds that will come in. And, um... The sheep do not follow. yeah after them they will not follow another because my sheep know my voice and they follow after me's right um And again, we would say that those sheep know his voice because he's opened our ears to hear his voice. yeah

Speaker: Maybe just a couple more. I'm thinking you may have several written down there. I'm thinking Ephesians 5 .25. I don't know if that's on the list. Husbands, love your wives just as Christ also loved the church. and gave himself for her.

Speaker: that he might sanctify and cleanse her. With the washing of water by the word. Yeah. So Christ gave himself for the church. So again, you have verses. They're very particular. And then you have some verses that...

Speaker: seem to be universal. Well, they are universal in in it in what sense? Not that Jesus effectually died for every single person. Yeah. But that he came to save Jew and Gentile. Yeah. Again, I i come back to, like I said before.

Speaker: that that whole notion of some not being a small number. And so when we talk about the world or all. Yeah. um It's a large number. um that that no man can number.

Speaker: And so... That's why we can use... Words like all and words like the world, we can use. these words that mean a massive group.

Speaker: Because we do believe that the elect is a massive group um yeah that that the Lord has redeemed or is redeeming. Yeah. um But so again.

Speaker: To use that word limited, we're not limiting. God's grace to a small number. right um But again, we have to be able to read. these words, these terms.

Speaker: into the context of all of scripture. Yeah. To understand. that his sheep are his sheep. and And that's a particular group. Yeah. That group can be the world. Yeah. You know, it's it's a massive group. Yeah, sure. um he has He has sheep.

Speaker: all around the world you know like like you were talking about earlier in the first century or even now. could we say that the gospel has gone forth to the uttermost parts of the earth? No, maybe to their understanding.

Speaker: It. it had as far as they could understand. But again, we have to remember. in first century they didn't know They didn't know how big the globe was. um I mean, we are sitting.

Speaker: In the uttermost parts of the earth. Yeah. If you really and truly think about it. I mean, we talked about Paul taking the gospel to Europe. Sure. centuries later. Europeans brought the gospel.

Speaker: To a whole nother continent across a whole massive ocean. Sure That. Paul probably didn't even know about it. No, no, that's right. I don't think Paul ever saw the Atlantic Ocean. right He may not have. Probably didn't. yeah um And then the fact that there was a whole nother continent. All the way there.

Speaker: yeah um and so Again. We're not limiting at all the scope of the gospel. We believe it is a global enterprise right um that that God is sending forth into all the earth. Yeah. When we talk about these things. Yeah. And and I think also just from ah a historical point. to We even know that that from the scriptures, Colossae, the church at Colossae, those weren't the last group of folks saved, even in the New Testament.

Speaker: you can't say that you know the gospel had gone to every single person right Yeah. Yeah. Seemed like there's some other objections that we were gonna... mention and and and try to deal with, but... um I don't know. kind of yeah yeah just It just flew out again. I didn't have. Really?

Speaker: more written down. Yeah, that's okay. You know, we think that... um yeah You know, did did Jesus Actually. Atone for sin. Yes, that's the issue for us.

Speaker: The other thing I would say before we move on. is, um, If Jesus... Died four And theologians have pointed this out. If Jesus died...

Speaker: for all the sins of all people. then why is there anyone in hell? Okay, so John Owen. dynamic. But think about this. If somebody's in hell, why are they in hell? Well, because they're.

Speaker: paying for their own sin. Well, I thought Jesus paid for their sin. Well, now you got a double payment and that just. Yeah. It doesn't work. I was actually going to go back to the the same.

Speaker: question I was thinking about it earlier. When you brought up. John Owen's three questions because As you're saying. If you want to argue. that Christ died for the sins of all men.

Speaker: But you would agree? that not all men are saved then you have to say... that the atonement Didn't.

Speaker: Pay for all sins. And so if it. didn't work for some. but it did for others. Why? yeah Why is that? And that's ah that's a question that...

Speaker: I feel like has to be answered if you're going to take. that position yeah and then I think If you... want to say that Uh... to his second question.

Speaker: That he died for... some of the sins Of all people. I think that's born out of. ah You know, there there are some who... you know maybe not necessarily Would...

Speaker: or maybe, would be talking about an unforgivable sin. Um, which you know we know that there's there's some Christians who believe in... and that sort of concept.

Speaker: But. even some that would say that the the the only unforgivable sin is is unbelief. Yeah. So then that would be maybe. the answer that they would try to give for Well, Christ died for the sins of everyone.

Speaker: But if a person dies and they're in hell. because they rejected him, then they're... there. being punished because of their unbelief unbelief is still a sin that's right And so...

Speaker: If you have to say that Jesus died. for all sins then how is that sin? not covered yeah you got it yeah you have to you have to answer for that Yeah. and I don't.

Speaker: feel like you can. for yeah no Right. Yeah. Sin, yeah, unbelief is a sin, just to reiterate what you just said. and If Jesus paid for that sin. He made for it. Yeah.

Speaker: Yeah, that seems insurmountable to me. But that's because... I'm a Calvinist. Anyway. Um, You ever been at a restaurant though, and somebody catches your. your lunch and you don't know it and then you go it to pay and they're like oh so and so Paying for you.

Speaker: It would be evil of them to take payment twice. Oh, yeah. And God's not evil. he so Anyway, I just throw that out there. All right, now. Are we going to tackle the next two or are we going to have to come back? I think we're probably going to have to come back for part three. I think we're sitting at an hour right now. I cannot believe it. I thought we were just going to rush through this. Not rush, but I thought we'd just sail through this. and I am not in the least bit surprised. but Alright.

Speaker: Well, we still have two to go then. We do, yes. Irresistible Grace. A lot of objections to that, too. And then... And in similar fashion, a lot of those go back to the notion of free will.

Speaker: exactly Exactly. So that's good we laid that foundation. Yeah. So we we can talk about that. Next time, as we continue to talk about these things, Perseverance of the Saints will be the last one. that we'll talk about. But again, just just to bring it back.

Speaker: Um... to the gospel. which is what we always want to end on. is that in these discussions, again, as we talked about last time, We want... We want people to.

Speaker: to see the truth of the gospel. yep And to know that there is a call for all men. to repent and believe in the Lord Jesus Christ. and you will be saved. it's try home and It's not for us to worry about who is the elect and who is not the elect.

Speaker: Who did Christ die for? Who did he not die for? right If you believe. and turn to Christ, you will be saved. And guess what? You'll be part of the elect. That's right. so Yeah, I can't say any say any better than that. All right. so so We'll look forward to...

Speaker: Part three of this discussion, and we'll see you next time. on answering pilots. The Answering Pilot Podcast is a ministry of Randall House Church in Greer, South Carolina. You can learn more at RandallHouseBeer .com slash church.

Speaker: You can also find us on Facebook and Instagram. at Randall House Church. Don't forget to like and subscribe, and we'll see you next time.

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Recommended