Hollywood's Literary Adaptation Trend
00:00:01
Sarah-Daye McDougall
The page-to-screen world is stronger than ever as Homer's The Odyssey is having a major Hollywood moment, but it's not the only book making waves as Emmy season celebrates some of television's biggest adaptations.
00:00:12
Sarah-Daye McDougall
A Darker Scrooge, A Magical Cat, and new fantasy epics are coming to screens as beloved literary worlds move one step closer to our screens. Plus, we've got casting news, first looks, and more from The Nightingale and the women in me,
00:00:27
Sarah-Daye McDougall
to love and other words and peculiar stars all that and more but first i'm sarah
00:00:36
Sarah-Daye McDougall
and this is the adaptation report
Book Discussions and The Odyssey's Relevance
00:01:13
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Okay, welcome back. So we're going to start with our spotlight, our bookshelf spotlight. um What are we all reading and watching this month?
00:01:25
Jordyn
I'm still working through rereading ACOTAR for my book club. We just finished Aqua War and Frost and Starlight. so we're starting Silver Flames next week, my favorite. So i'm very excited for that.
00:01:37
Jordyn
And I'm also reading Babel by ah RF Kuang. And that actually inspired my first long form essay that's going to go on our brand new sub stack. It's about the Odyssey and the nature of translation.
00:01:50
Jordyn
um so I'm really excited for that to come out when it does um it it the whole book is just really really fascinating I specifically took a class in college on um the English empire and this is set like right in the middle of the peak British empire and all of the terrible colonialism that's happening and it's taken through the lens of
00:02:06
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Mm-hmm.
00:02:12
Jordyn
these kids at this like semi-magical university and using translation to do magic. And so like there's these great long monologues from their professors about like the spirit of a translation and con conveying like the emotion and the intent behind a text versus like a literal word for word translation.
00:02:32
Jordyn
So it's actually really timely that I was, I'm reading that book while the Odyssey is coming out and there's all this discourse about like um the quality of, of Emily Wilson's translation, the quality of Nolan's translation and version of it. So really timely read, but it's very, very good so far. It's very dense, very like heavy on the soul talking about like colonialism and empire and and racism is very heavy. um So it's a heavy read, but I think it's really important and it's really, really well written. So highly recommend, I'm not even done with it yet, but highly recommend everybody.
00:03:08
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Sounds interesting.
00:03:10
Chris
Well, I am currently kind of in a reading slump. I have like nothing on my list right now. As my cohorts can see on my on our sheet here, it's definitely um not been easy to find something new to read. And at the end of like I finished some series, I um ran out of things that I was reading. so um I think I might have to pick up that Babel one though. I've heard really great things about RF Quan's writing overall and my book club that we were attending before I got super busy with all the jobs and baby stuff was reading the other book by them, Katabasis or however they pronounce it, which is about a descent into hell basically kind of journey. And I really want to read that
Media Consumption: Audiobooks and Films
00:03:53
Chris
one. So I might start with that Babel one and check that out first and then
00:03:58
Chris
move over to that one. um I have one more book coming, from the library on the ah hoopla right now. I'm waiting on it's the third book in the spell shop, uh, series.
00:04:11
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Oh. Hmm.
00:04:12
Chris
I think it's, uh, something about what's it called? Uh, I think it's about water. It's some sort of about the sea, dust sea of charms. That's it. So I'm ah waiting for that one. I should be getting it soon. It just came out, but I'm excited about that. Yeah.
Platform Transition: Patreon to Substack
00:04:29
Chris
yeah And we just finished watching the live action avatar remake. the And we watched the movie recently, the Aang series or Aang movie.
00:04:42
Chris
And that was really good.
00:04:42
Sarah-Daye McDougall
The animated one, right?
00:04:43
Chris
So Yeah, the animated one for that, the movie one that they put on Paramount+. plus
00:04:50
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Just wanted to make sure we weren't talking about the original live action adaptation.
00:04:58
Chris
Facetious, not really. But yeah, that's kind of me right now.
00:05:03
Sarah-Daye McDougall
I've been working my way through the full cast audios of the Harry Potter books. I just finished up the Goblet Fire.
00:05:10
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Well, I havn't yet I'm about to finish up the Goblet Fire. I'm also making my way through one Dark Window, which last month I was telling you guys how much I loved the Knight and the Moth.
00:05:21
Sarah-Daye McDougall
um And so i've I've started her other her
The Odyssey's Box Office Triumph
00:05:24
Sarah-Daye McDougall
books now. And then my book club is doing Strangers by Belle Burden, but I have yet to start that. But I'll be finishing up that month because book club is at the end of the month.
00:05:36
Sarah-Daye McDougall
I'm also watching Silo, which of course is based on a book. And I'm also working on a comparison for the sub stack that Jordan mentioned, um comparing Audible and Everand, which is another audio book.
00:05:52
Sarah-Daye McDougall
platform and I might throw some other ones in there that I've used. um I was gonna put that on my personal Substack but I think I'll share that with the Bookwatch one as well so stay tuned. The Substack is still kind of in the works but we are transitioning from a website and Patreon over to Substack so be on the lookout for that news on when we go live and you can follow us and all of that good stuff.
00:06:19
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Alright, should we get into
Cultural Impact of Book Adaptations
00:06:21
Sarah-Daye McDougall
some news?
00:06:24
Sarah-Daye McDougall
So first off, Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey is continuing its record-breaking box office run, surpassing the domestic lifetime earnings of its previous literary adaptation Oppenheimer, of his previous literary adaptation Oppenheimer, in just 13 days.
00:06:41
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Based on Homer's ancient epic poem, The Odyssey joins Oppenheimer as another example of how powerful source material from page can translate into major cinematic events, proving that book adaptations remain a driving force at the box office. And listeners, this episode should be coming out in between our two Odyssey episodes, so make sure you're listening to those.
00:07:05
Jordyn
Really cool to see an adaptation like this big at the box office. Like I think books are easier to get out into the world than movies are. There's a lot less of a like upfront cost factor. So it's easier to get original ideas put out in book form. And so like, we're always wanting more original ideas and film. And I think like probably the easiest and my, our opinion, best way to do that is to take original idea books and translate them to film. So it was really awesome to see ah an adaptation and especially like
00:07:39
Jordyn
more thoughts in the actual episode. So I'm not going to rehash everything I think about the Odyssey here, but like just the fact that it's taking such an ancient, like cultural icon of a story like the Odyssey and bringing it to a modern audience.
00:07:51
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Mm-hmm.
00:07:54
Jordyn
I'm always going to appreciate that. So shout out Christopher Nolan, I guess.
00:08:03
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Well, that success isn't limited to the box office because we have just had our Emmy nominations revealed a couple weeks ago and several book to screen adaptations were recognized when they were announced.
00:08:18
Sarah-Daye McDougall
And I'm going to run through the overview of the nominations and then my co-host and I can talk about anything that we're interested in talking about. um So here we go.
00:08:30
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Best drama series. slow horses based on mick heron's slough house spy novel series this also got nominations for gary oldman for his portrayal of jackson lamb jack loudon for his role as river cartwright and jonathan pierce as a guest actor for his role as david cartwright this show received nine nominations total A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms, based on george R. R. Martin's Tales of Dunk and Egg novellas, received nine total nominations, including costumes.
00:09:05
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Best Limited or Anthology Series, The Beast and Me, based on the novel by Thomas H. Cook. This also got an acting nomination for Claire Danes as Agatha Wiggs and Matthew Rhys as Niall Jarvis. This received nine total nominations.
00:09:19
Sarah-Daye McDougall
All Her Fault, based on the novel by Andrea Mara, Sarah Snook and Dakota Fanning received acting nominations for their roles of Marissa Irvine and Jenny Kaminsky. This received seven nominations.
Anticipated Releases in Film and TV
00:09:32
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Best Comedy Series, we've got margo Margot's Got Money Troubles, which is coming up on our feed as well. This is based on the novel by Rufy Thorpe.
00:09:43
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Elle Fanning received a nomination for her portrayal of Margot, as well as Michelle Pfeiffer as her mother Cheyenne and Nick Offerman as her father Jinx. The show received eight total nominations.
00:09:56
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Outstanding Television Movie, People We Meet on Vacation, risk received a nomination. This is based on the novel by Emily Henry, which we have covered on the podcast. Remarkably Bright Creatures also received a nomination in this category based on the novel by shelley Shelby Van Pelt. Sally Field received a nomination for her role as Tova Sullivan. This received three total nominations.
00:10:18
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Again, another one we have covered on the podcast. Jack Ryan Ghost War, based on the character created by Tom Clancy, um also received a nomination for our Outstanding Television Movie. Other acting nominations include Chase Infinity, received for her role as Agnes in The Testaments, the sequel to The Handmaid's Tale by Margaret Atwood.
00:10:43
Chris
What a name, Chase Infinity. um
00:10:47
Jordyn
That's a name for TV.
00:10:47
Chris
Sally Fields definitely deserved for Marco with Bite Creatures. That was an amazing performance. People We Meet on Vacation was outstanding television, so I agree with that one.
00:10:58
Chris
um The Margo's Got Money Trouble ones were definitely earned. Those characters did a good job on the show, and especially Niffa Offerman, I really liked his portrayal.
00:11:07
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Yeah, i thought he was the best part.
00:11:09
Chris
The other ones I mostly don't know, but I really got to check out slow horses. I've been, it's one I keep hearing amazing things about and I still have not picked it up and started it.
00:11:15
Sarah-Daye McDougall
It is so good. i am i haven't read the books, but the show is, yes, Gary Oldman is the best part of that show.
00:11:18
Chris
Gary Oldman's supposed to be amazing.
00:11:25
Sarah-Daye McDougall
And that's saying a lot because there's so many good parts of that show. But we are um very loyal watchers of that show. And I do want to check out the books at some point.
00:11:37
Jordyn
Yeah, I've never heard of that. But spy novels and Gary Oldman,
Delays and Excitement in Adaptations
00:11:40
Jordyn
I'm in. Sign me up.
00:11:41
Jordyn
So I'm going to have to start that show for sure.
00:11:45
Sarah-Daye McDougall
You will not be disappointed.
00:11:46
Chris
It's on Apple TV, right?
00:11:49
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Yes.
00:11:50
Jordyn
Apparently all the best shows are. So I've got to start watching more shows on Apple TV.
00:11:52
Sarah-Daye McDougall
They are
00:11:54
Sarah-Daye McDougall
And there's, I think five seasons out right now and there's seven total like approved. So um yeah, definitely get your binge pants on because that is, that's, you won't want to stop watching.
00:12:08
Jordyn
Excellent, yeah. I'm also excited for Night of the Seven Kingdoms. I was very late on that train and did not watch it when it came out. um But when House of the Dragon season three started, we started watching those episodes, Night of the Seven Kingdoms after those episodes came out and we got through it in like two nights.
00:12:25
Jordyn
um And it was so, it was so good. I loved it so much. So I'm really happy that it's getting some some recognition. um
00:12:32
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Mm-hmm.
00:12:32
Jordyn
And then, yeah, everything that Chris said, I agree. Elle Fanning, Michelle Pfeiffer, Nick Offerman all deserve these, at least these nods. I haven't seen, like, all the other contenders, so I can't say, like, they deserve to win. um But, like, they are all phenomenal in Margo's Got Money Troubles. And then, yeah, Sally Field was just incredible and remarkably bright creatures, so...
00:12:53
Jordyn
I feel like a proud parent, like all my kids are doing so good at, you know, school award season, like, good job guys.
00:12:54
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Mm-hmm.
00:13:00
Jordyn
Like, and also like shout out to us for like picking, you know, really great adaptations to cover.
00:13:07
Sarah-Daye McDougall
That was just like my thought too was it's just so nice to see that like we've covered so much of this and like you said like it is really fun to see that you know things that we've talked about on the podcast getting nominated and like hopefully they get some awards and you're right like it is like a proud parent moment it's like oh like I read that I watched that I'm so excited.
00:13:26
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Moving on to headlines. um So this month's releases and reviews. We've got Reacher season four coming out on August 12th on Prime Video. Adapting Lee Child's Gone Tomorrow.
00:14:02
Sarah-Daye McDougall
The Dog Stars will come to theaters August 28th. Ridley Scott directs this adaptation of Peter Heller's post-apocalyptic novel starring Jacob Elordi and Margaret Wally.
00:14:13
Sarah-Daye McDougall
The Whisper Man is preparing on Netflix on August 28th. This is Alec North's best-selling psychological thriller with Adam Scott and Robert De Niro leading the cast.
00:14:25
Sarah-Daye McDougall
And as I mentioned in our intro, Silos season three is continuing on Apple TV+. plus This is the adaptation of Hugh Howey's Wool series. And it's just about a mystery and involving underground silos. And it's it's a lot of fun.
00:14:43
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Post-apocalyptic world.
00:14:46
Chris
Kind of love those post-apocalyptic worlds. um I am super psyched for more Reacher. That show has been phenomenal. And honestly, I'd love to cover it on the series here, but are on the show here, because it really, i mean there's four seasons now and every one of them has been a super, super loyal adaptation.
00:15:05
Chris
And we have a lot of fun with it, I think. And Alan Richardson does such a good job with that character portrayal. I mean, there's he knocks out of the park and has an amazing performance every time.
00:15:18
Chris
So I'm definitely excited to start watching that again on August 12th. I've been rewatching the other seasons. They actually just in my free time when I'm doing other other stuff right now. It's it's so good. So rewatchable.
00:15:32
Jordyn
Alan Richardson is a Hunger Games alum. forget his character's name, but he was in Catching Fire. So if you'll see anything.
00:15:37
Sarah-Daye McDougall
One of the careers, right?
00:15:39
Jordyn
Yeah. Yeah. It's like glimmer and gloss or yeah.
00:15:40
Chris
He was so tiny back then.
00:15:43
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Yeah. The brother. yeah
00:15:46
Jordyn
So shout out him. um So The Whisper Man, skipping ahead a little bit to The Whisper Man, I have actually read that book, which, shit, crazy, proud of myself.
00:15:48
Chris
Just a little baby.
New Adaptations and Genre Expansions
00:15:56
Jordyn
um It is a little spooky, little scary psychological thriller. i am I had no idea that it was being made into an adaptation, so that's really cool. I will probably watch it since I haven't read it um The details are like a little bit fuzzy in my brain, so I'm not 100% like,
00:16:15
Jordyn
like sure like how scary it is so I will be watching it in the middle of the day with the lights on and the sun shining into my home um but I remember the book being good but you know as usual with me I'm like uh not really my jam like it was a good book glad I read it but like probably won't read anything else of this genre or by this author just because it's not not my jam um but good for them that they're making it to a movie that's cool
00:16:45
Chris
think covering the dog star, right? Dog stars, right? So that should be something we have coming down unless we switch things around, but I'm excited to read and watch that soon.
00:16:56
Sarah-Daye McDougall
All right, so um updates after years of delays, Kristen Hannah's The Nightingale has been slightly pushed back once again, moving from February 12th to March 19th, 2027 to hit that Easter weekend and spring break crowds. The long awaited World War Two adaptation stars real life sisters Dakota and Elle Fanning in their first film together with Michael Morris directing the TriStar production.
00:17:24
Chris
I'm sad it's been delayed, but that's not too bad. Just a month delay. But it has had kind of a rocky um production schedule as far as it keeps getting delayed and kept having stuff come up.
00:17:39
Chris
But I read this book. It's it's a really... It's a bit of a tough read because the mean most Kristen Hanna books are She puts a lot of heart into them.
00:17:46
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Mm-hmm.
00:17:49
Chris
She really researches her topics. She does a great job of portraying characters that really go through things. So I'm excited to see how Dakota and Elle perform this.
00:17:59
Chris
I'm excited to see how they portray the world. This is a yeah World War II in France ah ah story that... ah has a lot of heart and a lot of grief and I'm excited to see, i want honestly want to read it again and I'm excited to watch the film.
00:18:18
Jordyn
I haven't read any Kristen Hanna books, but the way you just described it, I'm like, why haven't i This sounds exactly like the type of thing that I'd be into. I love a little historical fiction.
00:18:26
Chris
Historical fiction.
00:18:27
Jordyn
i love a little sister Bond moment.
00:18:31
Jordyn
um I'm excited to see Dakota and Elle fanning in a movie together. i feel like they each have such... different pads through Hollywood to become the big name, like household name stars that they are now.
00:18:41
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
00:18:45
Jordyn
So to like have their joint sleigh in one film, I think is going to be really, really cool. And it sounds like this is going to be a great place for each of them to show, you know, the absolute peak of their acting abilities.
00:18:59
Jordyn
And, you know, it's a sister story. So casting sisters, I think is going to make all everything like hit that much deeper because you're like, like you as somebody with sisters, like I can be in that situation be like, oh my God, what if that was me and my sister?
00:19:14
Jordyn
And then like for them, it actually is me and my sister, like filming it and going through that, even the journey of filming together. I think that I can just only imagine how like,
00:19:25
Jordyn
much of a magical experience that's going to be for the two of them so I'm really excited like on the personal level for them as if they're my own sisters um but I think the movie is going to be great so if it has to keep delaying to make it really really great then by all means take your time like I have no dog in the fight
00:19:40
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Well, and this this delay makes perfect sense when you know you're going to have all that spring break. People are going to be wanting to go, especially like the college girls are going to be wanting to go see this movie. I have not read The Nightingale, but I have read The Women by Kristen Hanna.
00:19:56
Sarah-Daye McDougall
And yeah, Jordan is really good.
00:19:58
Sarah-Daye McDougall
She's she's a good author. like she Her writing is really good. Her stories are really good and original. And yes, historical fiction.
00:20:06
Sarah-Daye McDougall
The women is about the nurses in the war. I believe it was Vietnam and kind of the PTSD and their treatment after the war and how they weren't really looked at as veterans.
00:20:23
Sarah-Daye McDougall
um And that one also is getting an
Creative Debates and Author Involvement
00:20:26
Sarah-Daye McDougall
adaptation, I believe. So we've got a lot of Chris and Hannah on you, Jordan, have a lot of Chris and Hannah on your TBR.
00:20:35
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Universal's film adaptation of Britney Spears' best-selling memoir, The Woman and Me, has taken a major step forward, with Emmy-nominated writer Liz Merriweather tapped to write the screenplay.
00:20:47
Sarah-Daye McDougall
John M. Chu remains attached to direct the highly anticipated biopic, which is being produced by Mark Platt, as the project continues to develop following Universal's acquisition of the memoir rights in 2024.
00:21:01
Jordyn
I think this is going to be really interesting for them to do a biopic and a memoir on somebody who's like still alive. Like most of the biopics that we've seen come out, you know, other than Rocketman with Elton John, I think just off the top of my head, like,
00:21:18
Jordyn
Weird Al. Like most most of the other ones are music are musicians who are like have passed or are like well, well, well past like their prime versus like Britney steer Spears is like still in the public eye.
00:21:20
Sarah-Daye McDougall
if that's a biopic.
00:21:33
Jordyn
Like she's still like she's on Instagram right now, like personally posting Instagram.
00:21:33
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Mm-hmm.
00:21:37
Jordyn
stuff for better or worse um and she like like she's still and she was very very famous only you know 20 years ago like she's a very recent phenomenon um and like cultural icon so to have this be coming out like
00:21:48
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Mm-hmm.
00:21:53
Jordyn
right now i think is going to be interesting but John M. Chu he did the Wicked film so like Broke and Direct we know that so I think it's going to be if he brings you know the same kind of energy that he had in Wicked to this because it is i mean it's a musical movie at the end of the day like she's a musician so there's going to be music and performance um so i think it it's going to be a really great film and i hope that it does her justice like she like britney spears like we all know is very famously
00:22:00
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
00:22:27
Jordyn
gone through a lot of like mental health struggles and like the conservatorship and free Brittany and all that. um So I hope that whatever we get out of this film is something that she can stand behind and say, this is my story brought to life and like it's true to her and her journey. and That's my ultimate hope for her because girl has been through so much. And so I just, I don't want this to be another thing that she has to look at and say like, all these people took advantage of me and like mistreated me and misinterpreted me. And I i feel like I trust John Chu now after Wicked and how how highly he was spoken of by Ariana and Cynthia after that movie. Like, I feel like this is ah the right match for for them to get that the story across.
00:23:15
Chris
Now, have either of you read the book, the memoir?
00:23:17
Sarah-Daye McDougall
I haven't, but it is on my TBR. do you love a good memoir.
00:23:20
Chris
I read it. it was It was pretty good. It was an interesting read. I like a good biopic. So when it came out and it was popular, I picked it up. And yeah, she's been through a lot. It really was interesting to to see the story from that angle and really get to dig into some of those moments that you only saw on the news or you know things like that that were ah deeper than ah than we ever saw.
00:23:41
Chris
And so I'm definitely, i'm I'm interested to see the story get made because it ah has a lot to say for others that might be going through similar things or might be, you know, helpful to people.
00:23:52
Chris
But also, yeah, she deserves to have her story told from her perspective.
00:23:55
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Absolutely.
00:23:56
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Yeah. And I, i'm just going to echo what Jordan said that I do think it's in good hands with John M.
00:24:01
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Chu because he did seem to really care about the Wicked story and preserving, you know, what makes Wicked on Broadway so loved. And I think he's going to preserve what makes Brittany like so beloved.
00:24:15
Sarah-Daye McDougall
So yeah, I'm very excited to A, read the book, read her memoir. I've read a lot of excerpts from it, and then B, see this movie and I'm really looking forward to it. And I, like you said, just really hope it does her and her story justice.
00:24:30
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Morgan Spector has been cast as the new Robert Langdon in Netflix's upcoming adaptation of Dan Brown's The Secret of Secrets. The series will bring Brown's iconic
Romance and Mystery Adaptations
00:24:41
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Harvard symbologist back to the screen in a new mystery involving a missing scientist, a groundbreaking manuscript, and a race to uncover secrets at the intersection of science and ancient lore.
00:24:55
Jordyn
I have never read a Dan Brown book, but my mom read them growing up and we watched like those movies, went that the Tom Hanks movies when they came out were on a lot in the house. um So I really want to get into my Dan Brown era and read these.
00:25:12
Jordyn
This is, again, like so up my alley, a little historical fiction. It's giving and Indiana Jones national treasure.
00:25:18
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
00:25:19
Jordyn
Like it's all the things that I love in like a fun adventure story. So I'm excited that now there's going to be a show so we can just have more and more and more. i don't know Morgan Spector from Adam, but like good for you that you're Robert Langdon.
00:25:34
Jordyn
um And I think recasting like for obviously is going to be the right move. Tom Hanks is not the same age he was. whatever 20 years ago when those movies came out um that's voice acting chris
00:25:43
Chris
he did toy He's still doing Toy Story. Why not? you know
00:25:48
Chris
It's a series. It'll be fine.
00:25:50
Jordyn
it's whatever um so i i do intend to watch this i intend to read the dan brown books go back and watch the movies uh the da vinci code and angels and demons right um and watch the show when it comes out so yay
00:26:02
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
00:26:07
Chris
I'm with you on that. I never, I actually never watched them growing up or anything. They were one of the things that was not on my house, but I do want to read them, read them, watch them. They look like they're right up my alley. I like that sort of thing as well.
00:26:22
Chris
um I definitely read on our sheet, Morgan Spector as Mark Spector at first. And I was like, wait, the guy, the character from Daredevil is going to be in this. Or not terrible. keep saying that the from Moon Knight is going to be in this.
00:26:32
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Moon Knight.
00:26:35
Chris
That's Morgan Spector, not Mark Spector. Maybe another personality. But yeah, I'm interested. This sounds cool. Secrets, the secret of secrets. I think that was one of his newer ones and should be a should be an interesting series to bring to TV.
00:26:51
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Yeah, I haven't read them, but I did see the Da Vinci Code. It's been quite a while, but yeah, like you said, Indiana Jones national treasure right up my alley. Very excited to read these books and and and see the show when it comes out.
00:27:09
Sarah-Daye McDougall
And Netflix can be hit or miss, but um with this kind of like IP, hopefully it gets ah a decent budget.
00:27:18
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Netflix adaptation of Carly Fortune's This Summer Will Be Different has found its cast with Sophie, Nalissi, Robi Adle, and Francesca Real joining the 10-episode romance series. The best-selling novel adaptation will follow Lucy and Felix's complicated summer romance on Prince Edward Island, bringing another bringing another of Fortune's viral romance hits from page to screen.
00:27:45
Chris
I don't know any of those names, but I just looked up Sophie and it seems like she's been in The Book Thief and Yellow Jackets, some bigger things recently.
00:27:56
Chris
I don't know the other ones, but um this one we've been talking about a few times and it's come up in the news with different just announcements and stuff. So it seems like it's getting staying in the light, guys.
00:28:07
Chris
So I'm excited to see what they they do with that.
00:28:11
Chris
So sure, let's do it.
00:28:14
Jordyn
We love a little summer romance story, so go for it.
00:28:16
Sarah-Daye McDougall
We do.
00:28:20
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Peacock's live action adaptation of Matt Deniman's Dungeon Crawler Crawler has announced its first major casting news with fan favorite audio book narrator, Jeff Hayes set to voice the iconic Princess Donut.
00:28:32
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Hayes will bring his acclaimed audio book performance to the role of the talking magically enhanced cat companion at the center of the alien apocalypse adventure. The series is being developed by Seth MacFarlane's Fuzzy Door Productions with Chris Yost writing and executive producing.
00:28:49
Chris
They really need to tell me if this is going to be animated or live action soon, but I'm so excited.
00:28:53
Sarah-Daye McDougall
I believe it's been it's confirmed live action.
00:28:56
Chris
Okay. I keep meaning to look and a little deeper because at first it did not show that. So, um, I'm super excited for Jeff Hayes to get that role. He is the, um, narrator of the audio books. And so he and he performs a different voice for every character. Honestly, they could just put him in as the, only one man show of this whole thing and probably still have an amazing performance uh but he is iconically uh princess donut's voice to the point where he deserves this role to be his uh since that part will be voice acting and so to ncgi probably to give us a you know live action cat but um super psyched to see what he does with that probably a little different than the book uh the audiobook i would hope so that he can differentiate a little bit but he's so good at coming up with these characters that I have total faith and if he's a part of the production at all it's going to be amazing
Conclusion and Listener Engagement
00:29:46
Sarah-Daye McDougall
I have not gotten far enough into the book where the cat has spoken, but I'm literally going on Everand right now to download the audiobook so that I can hurry up and finish the book and hear this acclaimed voice acting.
00:30:03
Sarah-Daye McDougall
um you know
00:30:04
Chris
Definitely the way to read those.
00:30:06
Sarah-Daye McDougall
The like voice acting is getting a lot of recognition lately. Like it's always been for like animated films, but um you know, the puppeteer for Project Hail Mary got a lot of recognition. He also voiced the voice of Rocky and now we're getting this cast. So I'm just, it's just fun to kind of see those people in a live action behind the scenes, um you know, get that recognition.
00:30:32
Sarah-Daye McDougall
The first trailer for Ty West's Ebenezer debuted at San Diego Comic-Con showcasing Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge alongside an all-star cast including Ian McKellen, Daisy Ridley, Rupert Grint, and Andrea Risborough ahead of the e film's November 13th theatrical release.
00:30:50
Sarah-Daye McDougall
the first poster The first poster featuring the tagline, before he was Scrooge, he was Ebenezer, has sparked online debate with many viewers interpreting it as a prequel to the Diskins classic tale, though the film is yet to
00:31:04
Sarah-Daye McDougall
though the film is yet another reimagining of A Christmas Carol and the origins of its iconic character.
00:31:11
Jordyn
Yeah, we talked about it here. Chris did not like that tagline for the exact reason that you said, thought it was a prequel. I mean, i guess it could be more of a prequel-ish and like focus more on like the like ghost of Christmas past and like how Ebenezer Scrooge became the Scrooge of the story.
00:31:32
Jordyn
And so like that could be interesting because it like each of the three ghosts kind of have like the same amount of time spent with them. So if you like extended the visit with that ghost, you know, to tell more of that story, i guess it makes sense.
00:31:48
Jordyn
um I'm really curious, like these actors like Ian McKellen, Daisy Ridley, Rupert Grant, who are y'all going to be? Like, I guess Rupert Grant could be his nephew, probably.
00:31:59
Chris
I'm guessing he's either the, he's, he's, um, uh, um, Kermit's role.
00:32:07
Jordyn
Oh, okay. Yeah, that could he could do that too. I don't know. I haven't i don't think I've seen Rupert Grant since the last time he was in an Ed Sheeran music video. And before that was literally Harry Potter. So...
00:32:17
Jordyn
Good for him getting some work in um Love that. Yeah, i I'm still excited for it I'm excited for, like, Johnny Depp's comeback. um I'm excited for another Christmas Carol adaptation. um But, yeah, there's a lot of there's a lot of, like, weirdness around, like, with Johnny Depp, of course, and then with, like, this tagline and this poster, like, what is this movie even, like, trying to do?
00:32:41
Jordyn
Like, there's a lot of weirdness about it. So, like, I'm still going watch it We're still going to see it and cover it probably. with our annual Christmas Carol coverage. But there's some weirdness, so we'll see how it goes.
00:32:54
Chris
Now that you said that, I really want like a three season show where they spend like a whole season with each of the ghosts and spend time in the world with that ghost having to experience things from the past, present, future.
00:33:07
Chris
That just sounds like so much fun.
00:33:07
Jordyn
Yeah. like really traumatize him.
00:33:10
Chris
Right. Yeah, really, really, really show us that pain um and then have it all still be one night or whatever. um
00:33:18
Chris
ah But yeah, this one, i watched the trailer. It was good. ah I don't know if it really portrays the um more gritty version of of Christmas Carol that the I think they were originally saying it was.
00:33:31
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Mm-hmm.
00:33:31
Chris
i think Johnny Jep's just got that. that weirdness to him that, uh, that doesn't let things be that serious. I mean, I know he can play different roles, but he just, he like he likes to get weird with things and it, uh, makes it more of a, um, a funny, um, performance I feel like. And, uh, so I think it looks good. I think he looks good as the role. And, um, I think the tagline was mostly just to explain why they're calling it Ebenezer.
00:33:58
Chris
because he wasn't always, i mean, that's his name. And so they were just trying to say he is, this is who he is. So don't get this confused. This is still a Christmas Carol, but I think it's weird, to um a weird way to bring about that, that title and just a weird tagline. I wish they just said something like, you know, about the actual story instead about him.
00:34:19
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Brandon Sanderson revealed that he has completed the first draft of the screenplay for the long-awaited film adaptation just in time for the book's 20th anniversary. This is Mistborn. On his Instagram, he states, do please remember that this is just an early step in the very long process, but I'm terribly excited by how it turned out.
00:34:39
Chris
man, that guy can write. He's already done with a, he probably already released another book too in the timeframe it took him to do that. So, you know.
00:34:47
Jordyn
Every time we talk about Brandon Stinson, I just hear Hamilton my mind. Like, why do you write?
00:34:50
Chris
Why do you write like you're running out of time?
00:34:51
Jordyn
Like, you're always running out of time. Literally. i'm like, this dude is just cranking it out. I love seeing authors, like, in the writer's room, though, and, like, doing...
00:35:00
Sarah-Daye McDougall
okay
00:35:00
Jordyn
the screenplays like that makes me really excited. haven't read any Brandon Sanderson yet. It's on the list. I'm getting there. But the fact that he's like so heavily involved in the writing makes and and it's going to be on Apple TV.
00:35:16
Jordyn
I can't see how the show isn't like incredible.
00:35:22
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Agreed. I'm very happy that Apple TV is the one that picked up his rights because Honestly, I don't think they can do any wrong. Everything that I've seen in Apple has been phenomenal. So I'm, and like you said, he's in the writing room with them. So this is going to be a really faithful adaptation and he's looks like he's along for the ride from start to finish.
00:35:44
Sarah-Daye McDougall
So it's going to be his vision and this is going to be a really fun time.
00:35:51
Chris
I could see this ending up with some of the like some of the changes that you know authors make in books like Percy Jackson, where you know there's things that the author's okay with changing because it works better in film.
00:35:51
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Okay. Okay.
00:36:01
Chris
And I i could see this having a lot of people ah torn on it at first because he is having to adapt his whole world to a film world.
00:36:13
Chris
And so i could kind of see that in the direction this goes and polarizing the audience for a little bit. But I think people will come around to it.
00:36:21
Jordyn
Yeah, i always, you know, mentioning Percy Jackson, I'm always more inclined to give benefit of the doubt to an adaptation that makes changes if I know that the author is in on it and behind it. So like Rick Riordan recently like answered a post on threads or something or on Goodreads where somebody was asking like, what do you think about the changes? And to me, it was a very like wishy-washy, like non-answer. But he like can reaffirmed that like, I'm in the room. I'm approving these changes. I am like, it's okay by me that they're doing these things, you know, for the sake of getting it put out on on in a new medium on TV in this case. um And so it's like, you know, all right, fine.
00:37:06
Jordyn
You know, like even though I, you know, if i I want it to be, line for line, scene by scene, exact replica. And you know i just have had to accept that it's just not gonna happen.
00:37:18
Jordyn
And so I think you're probably right. There's probably gonna be a some of that with miss with the Mistborn series where you know you simply can't do things in live action.
00:37:27
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Mm-hmm.
00:37:28
Jordyn
And so changes are gonna have to be made. But again, knowing that Brandon Sanderson is writing the screenplay, he's behind it, he's approving it. Who am I to argue with the guy? You know, like, all right, fine. I trust you Let's let's get it done.
00:37:45
Sarah-Daye McDougall
One of the year's most anticipated fantasy adaptations has also come has also become one of its most talked about behind the scenes. Children of Blood and Bone author Tomi Adeyeme has publicly distanced herself from the film, saying the adaptation process was the worst thing she's ever experienced and that she won't watch or promote the finished movie.
00:38:07
Sarah-Daye McDougall
While the exact reasons remain private, the comments have sparked widespread discussion just as the film's first trailer debuted ahead of its January, January, 2027 release.
00:38:19
Jordyn
This is major tea. I've been trying to research like what happened or what was going on.
00:38:24
Jordyn
But she like to her credit, I think she has actually been very cagey about what exactly happened and been very like private and like not.
00:38:34
Jordyn
Like saying that like it's, you know, ah the worst thing she's ever experienced. I'm not promoting it. Distancing herself, like you said, like I want no part of it. Don't associate me with it. Like that's very, very harsh. But also like she's not actively like calling out or talking crap on specific people involved with the movie. um So i there was some drama with like the lead star, Amanda Lessenberg, who played Rue in The Hunger Games. And she's had more roles besides that. That's just the most famous one that I can think of. And they had like some tiff over Instagram, like commenting or like unfollowing each, something like that. Very pretty petty, but still. um
00:39:13
Jordyn
So this, I can't decide if this makes me want to see it more or see it less because like they're talking about it so much and the trailer looks cool.
00:39:17
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Yeah.
00:39:20
Jordyn
So I'm like, okay, I want to see what what all the fuss is about. But also like if an author has said like, this is not true to my work, like we just talked about, like, I don't support this.
00:39:30
Jordyn
This is not, a faithful adaptation, then it's like, I'm going to tend to side with the author and say like, you know, yeah, that, you know, we, I don't want to support something that is not true to what the author intended.
00:39:43
Jordyn
So I think ah most people are going to be having the same kind of thought process. So I'm curious to see, you know, when the movie does come out next January, what is going to win out people's loyalty to the author or people's desire to see what is going on with this movie.
00:39:58
Jordyn
And so we'll see when we get there.
00:40:01
Chris
This is such a hard balance because when a the when a studio buys the rights to your your book, they don't have to keep it the way you had it.
00:40:10
Chris
They have the rights to change it up and do it the way they see fit. um we've know We know from our coverage of things and the all the past movies that they work better when they're kept close to the author's vision, but it's not in the contrary. They need to do it that way. It can be a whole different story that can be good still.
00:40:30
Chris
not being exactly what they envision i tend to agree with you that i'd rather see that be um adapted better but i think we'll definitely have to add this one to our list because it is going to be an interesting watch and read to compare so i think we've got a lot to look forward to as far as our podcast goes with this one because there'll be a lot to talk about if they're uh um that different or that much going on with this.
00:40:56
Chris
So I'm, I'm, wasn't, I haven't read it.
00:40:59
Chris
I don't know much about it yet, but I'm now excited to check it out one way or the other.
00:41:04
Sarah-Daye McDougall
ah I feel like since we do this podcast, like, yes, we do have to cover it. We have to read the book and we have to see the movie to see, you know, is it a change that she was so upset about or, you know, what actually happened? Is it just drama where the two girls didn't get along? And so she was like, you know, like, did she want that actress to not portray that character or what, you know? um So, yeah, I do think as much as we want to side with authors, think,
00:41:34
Sarah-Daye McDougall
That's our job is to compare the adaptation. So let's see, you know, what this movie tells, what story it tells and what her book tells and if those messages align or not.
00:41:45
Sarah-Daye McDougall
On the other hand, i don't think the mass general public basis if they go see movies on the books um like yes and with the rise of book talk it might be different like if this drama is getting a lot of buzz and people are following her and she's saying don't go see the movie i don't think it's going to have that big of an impact on the film's success i think what's going to have a impact on the film's success is are people going to want to see this movie nothing to do with the book in this drama of the adaptation.
00:42:18
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Now people like us that want to see movies because they're book adaptations, yeah, like we're in the know about that, but the mass public is not.
00:42:26
Sarah-Daye McDougall
So we'll see how the film does um when it releases next year and we'll just go from there.
00:42:36
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Moving on to Pixby... Moving on to books being picked up for adaptations, Christina Lauren's beloved romance, Love and Other Words, is officially headed to the big screen with newly launched production company, Magic Hour Entertainment, developing the feature adaptation. The novel, a book talk favorite that follows childhood best friends turned first love, Macy and Elliot, as they reconnect years later, joins the growing wave of best-selling romance novels, making the jump to page to screen, though no casting or release date has been announced yet.
00:43:11
Sarah-Daye McDougall
I'm very excited for this. This was one of the first books from that 12-12-12 challenge I did a few years ago that got me back into reading along with Throne of Glass. This was one of the romances, you know, we're Throne of Glass to the fantasy. This was my romance pick. And the twist at the end really was an emotional punch. It's a dual timeline, if I'm remembering correctly. And i love that. And I'm just very excited to see this get picked up because it's kind of like a full circle moment for me. Like this is the book that got me back into reading after college. and Now I have this podcast and now it's going to be one of the adaptations that we talk about.
00:43:52
Sarah-Daye McDougall
So very, very excited.
00:43:55
Jordyn
I've seen a lot of discourse online, like people, mean, this is just my algorithm and secretly what I want, but like people talking about, they bring back like good rom-coms and bring back, you know, like good, like,
00:43:55
Chris
Never heard of it, so cool.
00:44:12
Jordyn
chick flick type movies like we haven't had a lot recently that have like actually been good and so i think you know with emily henry christina lauren like other authors like this like putting out these romance novels and like you said book talk being a heavily like woman dominated space um and pushing romance to the masses and like getting these stories out i think is awesome and so i'm excited that you know, something that has had a big impact on my friend, Sarah is like getting brought to life and like other people who have also been impacted by it will get to see it brought to life.
00:44:13
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Mm-hmm. lehe
00:44:48
Jordyn
I just think it's broadly like it's really awesome to have like parts of your soul like that you put into a book and that a book puts into you be brought to life like on screen.
00:45:00
Jordyn
So um the more adaptations, the better. Keep them coming. Too much content, not enough time, but keep them coming anyways.
00:45:05
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Thank you.
00:45:09
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Apple TV Plus has officially ordered Guilty Creatures, a thriller based on Mikita Brotman's true crime book, Guilty Creatures, Sex, God, and Murder in Tallahassee, Florida.
00:45:20
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Julia Garner will star and executive produce the series with Craig Alepsey directing and newly an announced Louis Pullman joining the cast as the other lead in the story of two adulterous lovers whose lives unravel after a murder they hide for nearly two decades.
00:45:38
Chris
Anybody else seen a trend, remarkably bright creatures, guilty creatures. What's next? Uh, um, adventurous creatures. I don't know. Um, sounds like an interesting story.
00:45:50
Chris
Um, it's kind of feels a little bit like, uh, um,
00:45:54
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Bonnie and Clyde.
00:45:55
Chris
Yeah, I was going to say that other the one we watched, his and hers sort of feel to the story, very possibly.
00:46:03
Chris
Lewis Pullman is ah should be a really good ah star for that, along with having Julia julia Gardner in there. i'm I'm definitely interested to see what they do with this.
00:46:14
Chris
It's not my genre I read or watch much of, but sounds fun. Let's do it.
00:46:19
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
00:46:20
Jordyn
Yeah, I think the combo of Julia Garner, Lewis Pullman, and then I just double checked Craig Gillespie because I was like that I know that name. He directed this year Supergirl. He's also done Cruella and I, Tonya, which all well, I, Tonya especially was very critically acclaimed starring Margot Robbie and Sebastian Stan. Supergirl had mixed reviews. Cruella also had kind of mixed reviews. So we'll see. But like Julia Garner, I feel like tends to pick good properties to work with. She was in...
00:46:55
Jordyn
Oh, the horror movie.
00:46:56
Sarah-Daye McDougall
The Ozarks. Oh.
00:46:57
Jordyn
Yeah, Ozarks. Wasn't she also? Never mind. Moving on. um So, and then Lewis Pullman is on the rise, you know, in his own right. He's a Nepo baby. We know that. But he's, you know, doing a lot of stuff to make a name for himself where um he, yeah, he definitely is.
00:47:10
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Yep.
00:47:11
Chris
He's putting in the work for sure.
00:47:13
Jordyn
So these three people collectively make me interested. But God, what a title. Murder in Tallahassee, Florida.
00:47:21
Sarah-Daye McDougall
if this
00:47:22
Jordyn
That's that's a whole... I want to get into that just on its own. Like that is such a title. Like, yeah I'm going to judge that book by its cover and I'm probably going to read that because what is that even talking about?
00:47:34
Sarah-Daye McDougall
All right, and last but not least, certainly, we have Rebecca Yar's upcoming romance novel, Peculiar Stars, is already heading to Apple TV Plus as a television adaptation. Apple acquired the rights in a competitive deal with Yar's attached as executive producer through her production company, Full Measures Productions.
00:47:53
Sarah-Daye McDougall
As the streamer expands further into the romance genre, the series will follow a woman stranded on a desert island with her fiance's cousin, where survival leads to an unexpected connection and complicated secrets after they return home.
00:48:08
Jordyn
T crazy. um I hope that Rebecca Yaros' romance novels are better written than Fourth Wing respectfully.
00:48:19
Jordyn
And if not, like good for her anyways. I think she's another one of these, like how we've talked about before, like industry darlings where like anything she puts out is going to get adapted because she's such a big name now.
00:48:29
Jordyn
And she's also another one of those people like Brandon Sanderson who seems to be constantly putting something out.
00:48:30
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Mm-hmm.
00:48:35
Jordyn
Like she's this is an upcoming novel that hasn't released yet. That's already been announced for an adaptation. And then she just announced like the fourth wing, like prequel novella. And then fourth wing four is coming out.
00:48:46
Jordyn
Like she's, she is grinding. um And I love that for her. Like, people love fourth wing i'm not one of those people but people love fourth wing and so like that and again like we've talked to like it's interesting that like fourth wing is on amazon and this one is on apple tv so i'm curious to see they're fundamentally different being a fantasy dragon story and like a contemporary romance but i'm still curious to see what differences there might be in the ah quality of the production and like the smoothness of getting it made as well.
00:49:21
Jordyn
um So we'll see how that all goes.
00:49:21
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Right.
00:49:25
Chris
and this one's being done by her own production company conjunction with that instead of through like the other one has been picked up by a Michael B. Jordan's production company for the fantasy.
00:49:35
Chris
But most of Rebecca Yaros' books are this contemporary romance. The fourth wing was her one-off where she said, I want to do a fantasy, romantic style story.
00:49:45
Chris
And so I think that it's cool that she branched out that way.
00:49:49
Chris
I think that the the fourth wing was... decent I have my problems with it too, but I think the story can be good and I think the film will be a cool idea. But most of her stuff that is going to be coming is going to be in this contemporary romance area. So I don't know.
00:50:05
Chris
I've read a couple of them or maybe one other one other than Fourth Wing, but they're decent. And I don't know. I'm not a big romance reader overall, so I don't know how to compare it in my mind to other things.
00:50:17
Chris
But out of what I've read, the one at least the one I've read, one or two I've read, we're good and though they should make pretty good ah adaptations, but there's definitely more that hasn't been adapted from her than has. So um we'll see if she keeps this trend of, of continuing to bring things to the screen.
00:50:35
Chris
I know she's been spending a lot of time in Oregon lately because her son is going to the university of Oregon right now. So she's been over in Eugene and Portland quite a bit coming to her son's stuff. So um maybe I'll get to see her at a, Seattle book signing or something soon.
00:50:46
Jordyn
Maybe you'll run into her.
00:50:47
Sarah-Daye McDougall
I was going say, go find her.
00:50:50
Chris
She's been at like the Powell books here. One of the biggest bookstores in the world is in Portland here. And, uh, she's done some signings there and stuff. So maybe I'll go to a panel or something. One of these days, if she gets, if the timing lines up right or something.
00:51:04
Sarah-Daye McDougall
And that's all we have. um Keep in mind that there's a lot of page to screen adaptation news. So if there's something that we missed that you really want us to talk about or want to inform us of, please write in and let us know.
00:51:17
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Otherwise, we'll see you next week for more next month for more bookish news next week for the Odyssey part two. And Margo's got money problems coming up after that.
00:51:29
Sarah-Daye McDougall
Thanks for listening.
00:51:31
Chris
Thank you. Cue that outro.