Transcript
Speaker: Welcome to ROI University. a higher ed marketing show for people turning big ideas into real results. Join Rustem Arani and Chris Shepard as they explore the strategies, stories, and technology shaping how institutions connect with students.
Speaker: From marketing and enrollment to data and AI. Every conversation brings a fresh perspective. is something you can put to work. This is ah ROI University. Alright, Chris.
Speaker: What a week it's been already. um I'll tell you, we've got a lot. going on on our end, but a lot of. amazing conversations happening as well, right? with our clients, with just people in the industry, um and then even internally.
Speaker: I know our teams, we have that we've got a Slack channel for industry news where we're just talking about stuff that's happening. uh in google and meta all over the place, right? And.
Speaker: Man, I'll tell you. The one of the reasons why, Chris. I switched from engineering to marketing. It was because... I mean, this marketing world, when I got into it back in 2008, when I got pretty heavy into it, like Google was just taking off and like.
Speaker: Email marketing and like all of this stuff that, you know, it amazed me the most was. You could track stuff back to performance and. Because before that, like i I took my my MBA, I got in a concentration of marketing, but that was all about the four Ps. That was about ah the SWOT analysis. That was about all of these kind of core fundamental marketing principles. which are still amazing, still relevant.
Speaker: But when I got into this world of measurement and Google and all of that. Man, it was just an eye -opening for me being like... a math person. I love the fact that I knew every one hundred, $200 we spent generated 400, 500, $800. That's right.
Speaker: Whole new world, right? It was almost like ah that song. But, ah you know, whole new world. um But anyways, ah it was just it was just awesome. And so I think that's a relevant and an awesome place to start because you and I were talking a little bit earlier.
Speaker: One of the interesting things that came out. I think that was this week that Google. Actually, or alphabet. um This is earnings, right? Yeah. um By, I think, 11 % overall. 11%, yeah. Uh huh. And one of the components is AdWords.
Speaker: um And they're there. Paid revenue, right, from their advertising. That's right. Although the interesting thing is it was down, it missed forecast, but it was still up 12 % year over year. Year over year, yeah. I think 63%. 0 .3 billion dollars. That's right.
Speaker: So it's a miss. that's wrong What does that tell you, Chris? like is is ad work What's going on here? Are we in trouble here? Should we be having different conversations? yeah We're big AdWords guys. yeah you know interesting in I've been kind of following along, you know, and the the earnings calls just came out and it was kind of interesting to see.
Speaker: How um the media played on this as well and kind of like, you know, missing earnings and forecasts and whatnot. Um, you know, everyone's a little concerned. and um I think one of the... the concerns is around.
Speaker: Wear alphabets. Google is actually heading. um how ai is actually impacting so other businesses other companies and then Like.
Speaker: as Google actually cannibalizing themselves with AI overview and Gemini, where folks are searching in those and not seeing ads as much. um So I think there's a lot of concern there and just understanding kind of where all that's going.
Speaker: ah Yeah. And I think, yeah, I don't think it's. ah I think we talked about this earlier. but I know. There's obviously still a huge need and a huge opportunity for Google ads for sure. And doing them right is obviously the biggest piece of it. Making sure that you have a partner that does them right.
Speaker: I think you nailed it, Chris. I think this is the big thing, right? And look, we talked internally. we've We talked about this a little bit more. Um, Oh, I mean, some people are like, well, AdWords is now fall. Like, do you, should you be advertising on Google anymore? Is there even value there? Let's put all our money in A -E -O -G -E -O -L -M -E -O -E -O. all these other like areas, right?
Speaker: which I've got my own opinions on some of that stuff. We don't go into that today. we've We've done that a little bit recently, but I think. you know with with AdWords, um with search in general.
Speaker: there's There's no doubt in my mind that like. some of the ecosystem is is changing a little bit, right? Yeah. but AdWords, when done well and done properly and set up properly.
Speaker: It's still such a huge driver for us, for our clients. Uh. And again, they're some of the highest intent. ah you know, prospects you can get. Right. And I think what you are saying, and that's the key. is
Speaker: There's probably a lot of some of that. bottom performance type stuff that's moving away, that's being cannibalized, right? We talked about it in the last few episodes about no click, where that's going. yeah um And I think.
Speaker: That's a part of it. right I think that's absolutely a part of it. And um you know I think it's going to be interesting to see. How much Google... ah you know, takes that to heart and what they do about it.
Speaker: Because... Are they going to advertise in their own search results on the on their own, on Gemini? that's the question It's interesting and it kind of differs across industries. I mean, for some industries, there's local service ads, you know, if you're in the service businesses. And of course, we have normal Google ads and then we have the map pack and then we have organic listings. and Like there's just so much Google's doing and it.
Speaker: in Now AI overview, of course, and Gemini. And so. it It can get confusing and kind of where to be and what to do. But I would say that Google ads obviously is like by far.
Speaker: The. The second. uh, highest producer. Um, and um, leads. in the higher ed. um realm. So like SEO and and Google ads, they definitely go hand in hand. I mean, you get some of the um
Speaker: highest, best quality leads from Google ads and from SEO, particularly because. Somebody is actually searching for. you or you know, what you have to offer and they're finding you. So they're already seeing you there. um and you know they're going through that funnel. um so So we have that. But.
Speaker: I don't know what is going to happen with. you know the whole ecosystem as you you know as it as it stands you know ai overview and Gemini and how that's going to look. And if they're going to start having ads, I heard a little bit. ah that there could be ads in some of these other, you know, instances like. Gemini or AI overviews and different things like that where you might have to pay to play. Um,
Speaker: But I don't think it's going to go away. I do think. um There's still. you know, they're trying to figure it out as Now ChatGPT and some of these other big LLMs are jumping in, not only to steal the search, but now they're offering up. ads like ChatGPT ads. So now they have their own platforms. Right.
Speaker: Yeah. And. And I think. Like for. us and for some of our clients and just in higher ed, I would say in general. um I think it's not necessarily. that.
Speaker: Google ads, again, like we've been just talking about is going to go anywhere. It's going to stop working. or you're going but I mean, three. Reality on that side is.
Speaker: you are going to have a little bit of a different experience potentially between the search, the results, the clicks. where they're coming through, what they're getting there, where they're getting their information from. And then ultimately, um you know, how that experience.
Speaker: Uh, Turns into them actually figuring out that they want to enroll, right. Or they want to do whatever that next step is kind of in that process. And I think some of that is changing. It's evolving. You know, we've talked a little bit about this, the loop versus like the funnel. right that yeah I mean, it's all part of the student journey, right? And you know we believe in the student journey. We believe that there's different aspects of it. And I think some of that is is starting to kind of.
Speaker: Change around a little bit and just how the touch points are where the people are getting their information from is There's no... ah if If there's a school out there.
Speaker: that Hasn't seen. a decrease in their website traffic and an increase in their lead quality conversion. We'd love to hear from you. yeah Um...
Speaker: Because either you're a newer school and you're just growing or. um Something else is going on there because like I can tell you. um Quality is absolutely, intent is absolutely up. on. school sites,
Speaker: But traffic is down and it's a lot down because of old blog articles, a lot. That's right. I mean, how many schools have we seen, Chris? where I can tell you there's still articles from like 2020, 2018 talking about marketing in 2018 or programs in 2018 that didn't even factor.
Speaker: AI into it or other things. Yeah, that's right. I'll tell you one of the One of the biggest tips, just real quick, because I'm on this rant, Chris. One of the biggest tips I'll have for anybody listening right now is.
Speaker: If you've got some really good articles that did well in the past on your site. or some great content that's aged, that has, it's outdated. Update the date. Update the article or the content to be a little more relevant to today.
Speaker: That's right. Get back to me if if your're if your traffic does not see an impact from that in a positive direction. That's right. One of the lowest hanging fruits that's out there right now for core SEO opportunity. Yeah, I think.
Speaker: I think. A lot of people know it, they just don't do it because it's like, it's just it's a lot, well, it isn't a lot to do, but it's something to go back and try to dig it all up and figure it out and find it and then rewrite them and do all the things. You mean it takes work, Chris?
Speaker: Yeah, that's right. um And like making it relevant to today, you know, and even if like you're, you have um blog posts around your programs are different. you know, opportunities or whatever it might be, some of that stuff may have changed. So you got to kind of go rebuild it all. but The. The fact is you keep the same yeah URL, URL structure. So you're maintaining all those backlinks and all that those relevance through the years. And so you can kind of just. Like you said.
Speaker: Revamp it. and republish it. um to get it back out there in front of the search engines but I'd say like. Just to talk a little bit more about. Google ads. Are you think institutions are like overly dependent on Google? paid right now or Um,
Speaker: You know, I know in my experience it was. obviously one of the highest. um like outputs of. of of revenue for us, you know, as a spend.
Speaker: Um, And it was. almost one of the largest lead generators, right? And so... and It was. That way on purpose, because you could just get a lot of leads. You had to be able to pay for them. And to our point, they had to be done right. And you had to make sure that cost per click and that cost per lead and everything really lined up and the quality was there for them to work right. But do you think. institutions are leaning on him too heavy or is it still kind of that age where
Speaker: We still need to be leaning on them. And oh my gosh, what about the cost per clicks going up every single year? I mean, that's probably just part of. Yeah. economy in general. um But like, what are your thoughts on that?
Speaker: Yeah, and I think... We talked a little bit about this last week with Charlie on ah the episode. Yeah. Charlie Parker. um He's an OG in this space. Bright, you know, such a bright guy. It was a great conversation. Really awesome having him on. but I think I mentioned like.
Speaker: And I had heard. gary v talk about this right like is google adwords kind of going to be the yellow pages um And and what what that means to me when you think about it like that is like.
Speaker: It's going to continue to become a place where, you know, if you're not ah evolving and understanding that there is a larger ecosystem or a kind of a different way to expand the experience into, you know, how important. It is that your brand, regardless of platform.
Speaker: is out there, is in the community, is doing the things it needs to do to showcase what you're really good at. And how you're good at it. um I think that's. The shift that.
Speaker: I see happening is social. um You know, obviously organic, even connected TV like. All of these different touch points. I heard on a podcast, I think it was this week, maybe Monday or Tuesday. It's like.
Speaker: You hear these numbers all over the place, but the bottom line is like. I think in the past it was like 12 to 14 times. If you're a high ticket product. It takes 12 to 14 touch points. some sort of touch point with your brand before somebody really gets to remember it.
Speaker: And maybe even engage with it. And so if you're at 12 to 14, I heard like again this week that it's like now up to like 17 to 22. Right. It used to be six and seven, six, seven. I had to do that for my kids. yeah But i no, I mean, it might. be 30. I honestly don't know the bottom the the true point there is like it's increasing. So
Speaker: AdWords will continue to be. apart. I still believe that I still think the early so ah early part of, you know, kind of like the the yellow pages. um But it is becoming where, you know, the book is really thick now and you've got to have.
Speaker: Full -page ads. Targeting the right people. ah Doing it right, right? Doing it right. You don't need 10 full page ads. You just need one in front of that right audience. Right. And I think that's the big change. The other thing is.
Speaker: Not only do you have to be in there, but you have to be on TV. You have to be here. You have to have kind of that brand presence. Awareness. Yeah. Awareness. outside of you know even the the normal places we've talked about reddit we've talked about quora we've talked about right You know and people it's it's it's funny, um you know Now everybody's talking about PR and the impact of PR. It's like making a comeback. Yep, it is. yo out there a is like It is, yes. I mean.
Speaker: Yeah. Digital PR. Yep. Yeah. writing Writing blog, writing content with actual experts. That's digital PR. Yeah. At a position I had, we did quite a bit of that, and it actually worked out. Great. We have a great PR team. and you know Not only did we get amazing backlinks from all the...
Speaker: Yeah. news channels and publications, but we got out there um in front of. our audience. um We're always sharing, you know, the latest and the greatest and all the news and all the different things that were happening. And they made all that happen. And it was amazing because to your point, it was just another touch point. It was just another awareness play that actually happened to have backlinks built into it, which was. kind of helping us with SEO. So it was great. Yeah. yeah um But.
Speaker: if if If we were to say like, okay, so. You know. Alphabet didn't necessarily hit the projected numbers this quarter. There could be some cannibalization in all the things that they're doing.
Speaker: I think they're trying to figure that out or at the very least. They're doing it. We just don't know yet. um I know they're doing some testing on a couple of other things, but like. What if folks are...
Speaker: Doing. Running ads or are not running ads yet. but want to run as or running as and just not sure if they're really optimized. Like what are some of the next steps that they should do? um to kind of make sure to to the... what we're talking about, like they're done right. And they're getting in front of the right audience and those types of things.
Speaker: So look, and this is where, again, I believe AdWords. is so... Awesome. with being able to directly attribute. your campaigns to the success and the and the ah roi or the roas or whatever right yeah so If you are not tracking your campaigns. at the campaign level, at the ad group level, at the ad level.
Speaker: All of that down to a T, to into your CRM to see. how that's impacting your cost per enrollments or whatever it is down funnel by campus, by program, like all the things we have built into Pennant.
Speaker: A little plug there, Chris. Pen and dash dot com. ah um But if you're not tracking. All of that backed out. You're not going to get.
Speaker: everything you can out of a successful. adwords campaign That is where the biggest opportunities are for people who are doing that, who are tracking all of that.
Speaker: They've probably maximized and gotten to an equilibrium point where like incremental. ROAS comes at a lot higher cost. You might have to expand broad. You might have to do other things, right? outside of where you're typically fishing. um So I think that's where the biggest.
Speaker: opportunity is Chris like For folks who are doing it. There's probably opportunities to expand and doing it well, expand out and making sure that they can attribute.
Speaker: other channels and the impact other channels have on their overall marketing efforts and return on those efforts. But for AdWords. If you're not doing that.
Speaker: You've got to figure that out. because otherwise you're just not creating the efficiency and it's not getting any easier. Yeah, I agree. i I think they keep selling it that it's getting easier, like with Performance Max or some of these other platforms.
Speaker: Like... you know, Still at the end of the day or AI max and all these things at the end of the day, you still have to know what you're doing. You still have to like know your audience. You still have to be able to build all these things and really target and focus on all the things. um It's just not as easy as clicking a button, which some people actually think it might be. And that's, that's too bad, but there's still a lot going on there. Well, here's the thing. chris like Again,
Speaker: Right now with. with AI and everything, it it is a little bit of kind of like. The Wild West, right? Yeah. And I think. The biggest risk there that I see.
Speaker: is And I'll just. say it like this because the way it is for a lot of people, there's like a lot of snake oil. Salesman. Yeah. It's been like that. Yeah. um But like you always get that in these like. kind of technological pushes and stuff like that, right? I remember when mobile marketing was making a big push. push and like it Chris, I kid you not.
Speaker: At every conference I went to, probably from 2008. Maybe 2006 or seven. Yeah. 2014. Chris.
Speaker: Seven to eight years, every single year was the year of mobile. Yeah, that was like that was a headline. But every single conference, every talk was the year of mobile. But it sounds pretty familiar with the year of AI, right? See, that's exactly it, right? And we're in that same kind of.
Speaker: Because here's the thing. There's uncertainty. There's people don't know what's happening. and like That's right. When you're ignorant and you don't understand. and Honestly, like even a lot of us that are in it day to day, there's so many things changing on a day to day basis. We're still learning. We're still trying to figure it out. We're still trying to understand.
Speaker: the advantages and benefits of some of these tools and the drawbacks. You and I talk about that all the time. Yeah, yeah that's right. Yeah. Well. So to close it out, like. Are we doubling down on Google ads? Are we kind of like... shine away from it? I mean, what?
Speaker: We kind of talked about it a little bit, but never really made a yeah a good decision. we are we still maximizing We're maximizing that channel as much as possible. And if you're not tracking it. down all the way to.
Speaker: The whatever your. Goal is for a lot of our our schools, it's cost per start or cost per enrollment. If you're not doing that, you're not going to be able to maximize it. And so that's all that I still think.
Speaker: There's a lot of room. there. um But it does get to a point where there is a ceiling. um And if you're optimized and you're hitting that ceiling. Well, you better be thinking about kind of the entire ecosystem. You better be thinking about, you know, we're testing chat GPT ads. we're
Speaker: on TikTok. right We're looking at Snapchat and some of those opportunities, you know, there's advertising in Snapchat. So, and then not only that, but what are you doing ah with your current community? How are you engaging them? Like with your alumni, how are you engaging? It's like.
Speaker: it's It's all a part of the community. AdWords is just one little piece of it. so Bye. I don't think it's going anywhere. I think doubling down if is is only recommended.
Speaker: If you've got the right processes, tracking systems and everything in place, and you see that there's still opportunity. Otherwise... think You might be. I'm with you. and I think you know if anyone's out there and they just need someone to look at.
Speaker: you know, their ads or have questions, feel free to reach out to us at ah rgiconsulting .net. ah We'll leave a link in the description down there. But, you know, we're more than happy to talk with you. Or if you have some questions or need someone just to look over your ads. I mean, it it is changing. um It's been changing a lot over this year, too. Just the whole ecosystem.
Speaker: um And like I mentioned earlier, like the Performance Max, the AI Max, some of these different features that are built into. all the campaigns and how to run them. So yeah, rgiconsulting .net. Feel free to reach out to us if you guys need a hand.
Speaker: Yeah. and And I think with that, right. And a lot of times, like when we do do these audits, there's like the basic fundamentals of campaign setup of structure. of geo targeting of like all of these things, right?
Speaker: Um, There are definitely states if you're running national campaigns or online campaigns, there's absolutely states that will pull many, many inquiries for you. Right. California has one of the biggest populations. I guarantee if you're running national campaigns and you're in California.
Speaker: probably your top state. Even if you're in New York, um right? It's like right up there. So I think like, you know, there's a lot of those things that are that, that you can insights that you can kind of gather, but like.
Speaker: The basics still are key. And then kind of from there, understanding what's happening across the entire student journey. So, yeah. Appreciate that. uh Chris. and I think, look, a
Speaker: It's such an exciting time. know Like, I think about this stuff sometimes when I even wake up. um And I know you and I kind of. ping each other articles on Slack all the time with what's happening. Yeah. new technologies, new opportunities, and so on. but Um, At the heart of everything is that.
Speaker: ah You know, is that hero of your story, which is the student? Right. At least for us, for a lot of our clients. Um, you know And if you keep that in focus.
Speaker: and build everything around that. Should be in good shape. Yep. Yep. Yeah. I'm with you on that for sure. so The moral of the story is... Keep going with Google ads. um and or don't Or don't if you don't have it set up properly, because I can tell you, you can waste a ton of money if you don't. and so
Speaker: Please, please, please make sure you you take a look and and set everything up properly. Um, But yeah, that is the moral of the story, Chris. That's right. Alright, well, awesome conversation, Chris. ah Appreciate ah jumping on with you. and Until next time, that's all for this episode of ROI University. We're the biggest ah ROI. is personal.
Speaker: Bye.






