Transcript
Speaker: If you heard someone singing, it was probably Alex. If a friend or family member found themselves laughing at a funny TikTok video, Alex was probably the one who created it. If you overheard someone making small talk with a stranger or calling the delivery person by name, it was likely Alex. And if you needed someone to help out when all else failed, you could count on Alex.
Speaker: He was the constant in most people's lives who was always there with a smile and an even quicker laugh. It's what makes the world seem all the more empty without him. The world lost that light in February 2021.
Speaker: While his death has officially been ruled a suicide, many details concerning the evidence, as you'll hear in our coverage, will have you questioning that ruling and instead shouting for justice. This is the case of Alex Van Dahlsen.
Speaker: Oh.
Speaker: Welcome to Coffee and Cases, where we like our coffee hot and our cases cold. My name is Allison Williams. And my name is Maggie Dameron. We will be telling stories each week in the hopes that someone out there with any information concerning the cases will take those tips to law enforcement.
Speaker: so justice and closure can be brought to these families. With each case, we encourage you to continue in the conversation on our Facebook page, Coffee and Cases podcast, because, as we all know, conversation helps to keep the missing person in the public consciousness, helping keep their memories alive. So sit back, sip your coffee, and listen to what's brewing this week.
Speaker: Before I begin our coverage of Alex's case, I want to sincerely thank Alex's mother, Jen, for allowing me to interview her for our coverage of this case. I could tell that every conversation about Alex rubs her grief raw again, which is why I'm so incredibly grateful that she was willing to put herself through that pain so that you, Sleuth Hounds, can understand the intricacies of this case,
Speaker: pain Alex's family feels and that anger they feel at being dismissed and at having no answers. So thank you Jen not only for your time but also for being the advocate you are for Alex.
Speaker: You probably know this by now if you've listened to our show, but I always begin an interview with family by asking about a favorite memory. I want our listeners to see and feel connected with the person at the center of our case because these cases are in all honesty, a fight for justice for the person and not simply about the details of a crime. It's about empathy.
Speaker: It's about advocacy and it's about action.
Speaker: All of the families deserve those three things from us at the bare minimum. So let me tell you a little bit about Alex. Alex VanDolsen was a lovable goofball from what I understand. He was always laughing, singing, making TikTok videos for people to laugh, or it could be found, as I mentioned in the introduction, chatting with anybody and everybody who would listen. He just loved people.
Speaker: And that didn't mean that he didn't also keep his mom on her toes, though. Here's Jen sharing some of her favorite memories. And he was just always happy and no matter what was going on, he was singing and dancing and trying to make everybody laugh.
Speaker: and watch the squirrels play. I'd get videos every now and then, like, look at what they're doing. I don't know if I can pick one. I got a four wheeler at one point for them to ride. And it was a manual.
Speaker: And James and I tried. Alex was, he was intent on riding it. And we rode with him. We ran next to him and it was, he had a hard time remembering the clutch. So it was pretty funny.
Speaker: like chasing the four -wheeler down the road. I also asked Jen if she could describe Alex for anyone who didn't have the pleasure to know him. Happy loving never had anything bad to say about somebody
Speaker: way too trusting though. He walked up to a perfect stranger and started a conversation. How all of our delivery people knew him. So he's talking to them and neighbors. Anywhere we would go, he would make a new friend. And he just
Speaker: But that fun -loving side of Alex also had a counterpart, and Alex was often very hard on himself. Like a lot of young people, he struggled to figure out what he wanted from life. After high school, Alex was unsure of what he wanted to do, so he worked quite a few different jobs to try to figure that out. Some of the jobs he would quit because he soon realized this was not the path for him. Still others he would lose for
Speaker: a different reason, though his reason for losing the job says a lot about his love for people. You see, Alex lost several jobs because he would be scheduled to work, but not show up because a friend had called to say they needed help and couldn't find anyone else. So Alex would prioritize helping people over his job. Sadly, those same quote unquote friends would rarely return the favor.
Speaker: In the summer of 2020, Alex's mom, Jen, took Alex's car away after he was involved in a minor car accident. Carless, Alex now needed a ride to wherever he needed to go. However, calls to those same quote unquote friends often ended with a hard no on helping out Alex.
Speaker: leaving Jen to transport Alex to town, to work, etc. There were really only two friends who entered Alex's life who could be depended on to help, who valued Alex. Those were Cassie and then Alex's girlfriend, Genesis. Even though Genesis lived some distance away, she worked near where Alex lived and would often swing by to pick him up.
Speaker: But Alex was over the moon when he got his vehicle back because one of his favorite things in the world was driving. Jen told me that he drove everywhere. In fact, she said every vehicle Alex ever had, he quote, put the miles on, end quote. It was relaxing, even therapeutic for Alex, just like riding was to him as well.
Speaker: Driving and writing were forms of release for the depression and anxiety Alex would sometimes feel. He had tried therapy and things had improved drastically, including his grades at school while he attended. But when a therapist left to move out of state, Alex wasn't able to find another therapist with whom he could open up as he could with the last one. That's why he tried to find his own healthy outlets for those feelings.
Speaker: The year Alex had begun therapy was a hard one for him. You see, when Alex was younger, his parents hadn't had the best relationship. It was a pretty volatile marriage that Jen had originally believed she had hidden from the kids. When she realized that they knew more than she thought, she had filed for divorce. Jen told me, quote, unfortunately by then
Speaker: they knew way more than they ever should have." Alex was 13 at that time, a tough age for kids anyway, let alone when dealing with family separation. It's a time when most every child tries to buck the system, question rules, and experiment to see what you can get away with.
Speaker: I'm sure most of you listening remember times as a teenager when you thought you knew better than your parents and did things they expressly told you not to do. Alex was just like all of us in that respect. For a short period of time when Alex reached his late teens, he expressed that he didn't like rules and instead wanted to hang out with people in their mid 20s and smoke weed. Things his mom Jen forbade him to do.
Speaker: Jen told me in our interview that during this time in Alex's life, Alex was prompted by his other parent to write a letter to a judge that Jen was emotionally abusive because she didn't allow Alex to make his own choices. It was around this time that Alex's biological father filed for custody, Jen stated.
Speaker: Interestingly, Jen and her ex had other children together who were living with Jen who were not part of these claims, nor of the custody fight. Soon afterward, and being outside the purview of Jen's rules, Alex continued to hang with this crowd. That is, until a guidance counselor pulled Alex into an office to ask about his behavior and contacted CPS because the counselor too didn't think Alex should be doing the things he was doing.
Speaker: Luckily, with help again from his mom's rules and with the therapy he soon attended, things improved both at school as well as at home. Alex did continue to struggle with his mental health, but he became an advocate for himself in that battle.
Speaker: to illustrate in October 2020, Alex checked himself into a mental health treatment center called Sycamore Springs. However, they wouldn't keep him because they didn't feel his struggles were significant enough. Alex attempted to check himself into the facility, according to Jen, three or four times before they finally kept him for just under a week.
Speaker: Now, when Alex knew something was wrong, he was strong enough to acknowledge the need for help and would tell his mom Jen, talk to his friend Cassie about it, or go somewhere for help. But Alex would have to deal with a few more significant events in the year or two leading up to February 3rd, 2021, when our case takes place that either give insight into some detail that will be important later,
Speaker: or that may have some bearing on the case. So I'll share those with you now. One incident was that Alex had previously been robbed at gunpoint. The incident happened about a year or two before February, 2021. Alex had been asked by a so -called friend to loan some money. Alex knew the money was going to be used for drugs either to buy them or to pay off a debt. So Alex had refused.
Speaker: It turned out that the person had indeed owed money to the dealer. The friend, and I'm using air quotes here, asked for another favor from Alex. This time instead of money, the friend asked for a ride. A ride that ended with Alex being robbed at gunpoint. It is Jen's belief that the friend had arranged the robbery. In order to get the money, Alex didn't freely give. So that friend could pay back the weed dealer.
Speaker: Since that incident was significantly removed in terms of time from February 2021, I asked Jen if there were any other incidents closer to the time of the case that had her or Alex worried. She recalled to me that at the time there was something, something she wasn't particularly worried about, but that Alex was.
Speaker: She told me that maybe six to eight weeks prior, there was, again, a group of, air quote, friends causing issues with the common theme of, if you don't do things our way, then we'll harass you. At one point, Jen detailed, Alex told her that he was worried one or more of the group would show up at the house because they told him that they were going to, in Jen's words, quote,
Speaker: come out and shoot up everyone in the house." Jen wasn't worried because she would protect her family at all costs, but Alex was concerned that this time the threats were real. A final event with significance to small details in the case was a bad breakup that Alex had around summer to fall of 2020. After the breakup, Jen told me that Alex eventually took to leaving his cell phone at home
Speaker: because his ex had frequently tracked his location from it. In fact, Alex had left his phone behind for about six to eight months prior to February 2021. Often, Alex was only away from home for a short time anyway, so he wouldn't need a phone. When he knew he would be away for a longer period, he would instead take a spare phone
Speaker: that Jen had previously put on her plan for one of her nephews. Since the nephew wasn't using it any longer but the line was still on her plan, Jen suggested that Alex just take that spare phone when he would be away for several hours. It was because of that bad relationship that Alex was unsure when he first met girlfriend Genesis whether or not to jump right into another relationship.
Speaker: if he were in a good enough spot to do so, and whether Genesis would be ready either. Alex spoke to his mom about those concerns, and Jen advised him that if he were worried about Genesis being ready to be in a relationship with him, then Alex should allow that to be a decision made by Genesis. Alex shouldn't make that decision for her. But if Alex himself didn't feel ready, then that was something he would have to figure out himself, and that Genesis deserved to know that.
Speaker: Alex and Genesis talked and they both decided that their relationship was worth a chance. It didn't take long before Genesis proved to be a good partner for Alex.
Speaker: like friend Cassie, Genesis was always there for Alex when he needed something. And she grew to be a part of Alex's family as well, calling Jen or Alex's grandmother if Alex had left his phone at home and needed to let them know where he was. She had stayed at Alex's house, had brought her dogs over, had been introduced to friends like Cassie, and loved spending all her spare time with Alex. Things were finally calm and going well.
Speaker: Then, on February 3rd, 2021, everyone who loved and cared for Alex had their world completely ripped pieces. And with each new piece of information that has come to light in the time since, their pain has only continued to grow, their questions to become more extensive, and their fight for justice become more urgent.
Speaker: February 3rd, 2021 in Lafayette, Indiana, home to Purdue University in West Lafayette, and situated about an hour northwest of Indianapolis and about two hours southeast of Chicago, Illinois, was a typical cold one.
Speaker: The weather had been in the high 20s, low 30s, and snow had just blanketed the area with more on the way. 21 -year -old Alex was set to start a new job at 930 that evening at 350 Liquors in Lafayette. Jen was a little bit worried because of the job itself, but Alex had all of his paperwork ready to go and was excited to start. Jen had gone into work at the local Subaru plant, and Alex had shortly followed suit.
Speaker: However, even though he had all his paperwork completed to start the new job, in the rush to get there on time, he had forgotten the folder in his bedroom. Jen knows he must have been mad at himself for doing that, since he wasn't able to start his job without that paperwork. He returned home.
Speaker: Because Alex was only gone from home for about an hour, Jen believes that he drove to the liquor store, spent 10 to 20 minutes there, and then drove home. According to the Purdue Exponent in an article by Joe DeHownick, when Alex got home, he told his sister what had happened with the paperwork, and then he told her goodnight. Around 11 .44 p .m., according to camera footage later viewed,
Speaker: Alex left his home again, this time without his sister's knowledge. He left on foot, leaving his car behind. When Mom Jen got out of work the next morning, she turned her cell phone off and back on again to see if Alex had texted to let her know how his first night went. She told me that inside the plant, the cell service is so bad that she can rarely use her cell phone in the building at all and had learned that
Speaker: She would need to restart her phone in order for text messages sent to her during her shift to come through. But she didn't have any new messages from Alex. When she got home, she saw that his bedroom door was closed, so she assumed he was asleep after working the late shift. When Alex hadn't come out after several hours, Jen checked his room, only to find his bed empty.
Speaker: When she saw that, her first thought was that, well, Genesis likely swung by to pick Alex up for them to spend some time together. He had left his wallet, minus his ID, and his phone behind in his room, an indication to Jen that Alex hadn't planned to be gone for long. And remember, leaving his phone at home was something he frequently did.
Speaker: As for leaving his wallet but taking his ID, that was something Jen told me Alex also did frequently. Later that evening, still fighting that feeling in her gut that it wasn't like Alex to not contact her to at least let her know how his first shift went.
Speaker: Jen had to return to work. After receiving a call from Genesis that she also hadn't seen Alex since February 3rd and was wondering where he was, Jen knew something had happened. She came home, checked again to find an empty room and everything in the same place it had been the last time she checked, and placed a call to the police. Alex VanDolsen was missing.
Speaker: Now, before I tell you the next detail, I want you to put yourself in Jen's shoes and the panic that she was feeling in that moment. It had already been nearly 24 hours since anyone has seen Alex. Time was of the essence. It took law enforcement almost two hours to respond to the call at a time when every second likely felt like an eternity.
Speaker: When they did arrive, Jen didn't feel comforted. According to that same article by Joe de Hownick in the Purdue Exponent and his discussion with Jen, quote, because county police had come to their house for well -being checks on Alex in the past, she said, they assumed his disappearance wasn't a big deal and would soon resolve, end quote.
Speaker: In other words, Jen didn't feel that law enforcement understood the urgency that she herself felt. They searched Alex's room and found a note stuck somewhere on his desk. It read as follows, quote, please give back to Genesis, her journal, boxers, house key, bracelet, anything else she has here, end quote.
Speaker: Along with the list, Jenice's phone number was written three times on the document. When police found the note, they didn't think anything of it, telling Jen specifically that they didn't think it was a suicide note or anything of the sort, just a spur of the moment list instead. They also found the video footage that showed Alex leaving his car behind to walk off screen, away from town. Because he left his car behind, didn't take his phone,
Speaker: and wasn't dressed for the weather. The temperature was below freezing. There were several inches of snow on the ground, and Alex was wearing just a black sweatshirt with a Chevrolet emblem on the front, brown leather boots, and gray sweatpants layered over blue jeans, but no coat. Jen believed that he likely took a ride with someone. After all, Alex had severe asthma.
Speaker: And Jen said that he could barely walk several yards, especially in the cold air, without needing his inhaler. If he had planned on going any significant distance for that reason, he would have taken his car. Still, Jen didn't get the feeling that the Tippecanoe County Police Department was taking her missing person report as seriously as she knew it deserved.
Speaker: While waiting for law enforcement to begin investigating and hopefully find Alex, Jen began doing what she could on her own.
Speaker: As a parent, there is no part of you that's good at waiting when your child hasn't come home. As part of our own search, Jen accepted help from friends and family as well as community members to look in any place they knew Alex frequented. One member of the community even showed up with a search dog to try to help pick up Alex's scent.
Speaker: However, additional inches of ice and snow between February 3rd and February 5th when the dog was brought proved detrimental to the attempt. When the dog did trail Alex's scent down the road to an intersection before the scent was lost again, it made Jen sure that it was likely someone had picked Alex up. But who? And where had they gone?
Speaker: As the days passed, those questions loomed larger. When law enforcement pulled into Jen's home on February 9th, around 4pm, she knew right away why they were there. And when they showed Jen a picture of the rose tattoo that Alex had on his hand, which she confirmed to be his, that was positive confirmation that the body they had found just three hours earlier
Speaker: was Alex van Dalsen. According to Jen, that was when law enforcement officers gave her the following details. Alex had been found near the softball fields at Crosser Sports Complex, that there was no obvious signs of trauma, and that they would have to wait until they got the autopsy results to be able to tell her the cause of death. In the meantime, she would need to contact the funeral home to begin making arrangements to lay Alex to rest.
Speaker: It was when Jen got a phone call from the funeral home that everything she thought she knew was turned on its head. Here's Jen. We met with the funeral director and he actually was a neighbor of my mom and stepdad for lots and lots of years. He did my dad's funerals. He knew the whole family. He watched my kids grow up.
Speaker: And he asked us what happened in trying to play on the funeral. We don't know. This is all they have told us so far. And he was like, OK. So we play on the funeral based on that. And then he calls me Saturday morning, which he had told us that day. If there were any delays or anything like that, we might
Speaker: I know if he wasn't released in time or anything. OK. So he calls me Saturday morning and. Hey kiddo, we need to talk. I can you know my thought is like he's not going to be released in time. We gotta. You know reschedule things and like OK like we can do this. He says what were you told again?
Speaker: So I repeated, you know, just what the detective told us, no obvious signs of trauma. So we're waiting on the autopsy results. I've called the coroner's office numerous times. They tell me that they'll call me when the autopsy is ready, that it could be weeks because they got to wait on toxicology. Okay. He says, well, I don't understand.
Speaker: what's going on. But I will be calling the coroner and the sheriff's department when we're done. Because I shouldn't be the one to be telling you this. But you can't get any more obvious than a gunshot wound to the head. What? What? What? What are you talking about? And he's like, I don't know why. You haven't been told. I don't know.
Speaker: what's going on, he said, but I can't wait to figure that out. I need to let you know that the plans that we've made may not work because of this. Right. Wait a minute. Wait a minute. What? I'm like, okay. All right. What? What do we need to do? He says, well,
Speaker: You may need like different casket, different liner. Can't be the one that you picked. Jen's voice broke as she said to me, quote, I didn't want to have to go through this once, let alone twice. End quote. She even asked the caller, are you sure you've got the right kid? But the director knew Jen.
Speaker: knew Alex, knew the whole family. This was, indeed, Alex that he was talking about. Jen was dumbfounded. Why had the police explicitly told her there was no sign of trauma when clearly there was? Jen called a detective on the case first thing the following Monday. She said that he repeatedly responded with comments like, I didn't mean to mislead you.
Speaker: Jen scoffed at that comment in our conversation, responding, quote, no, you blatantly lied. End quote. As a result of that misinformation, Jen and her husband had to show up to the funeral home 30 minutes early to look for themselves and decide whether they would have an open casket at the funeral or not.
Speaker: From that moment on, Jen has discovered a lot more misinformation and experienced a lot more heartbreak. When you lose a child, there is a desperate need to do anything and everything just to have a small piece of them back. For Jen, that meant wanting Alex's clothes. She recalled to me that the sweatshirt he'd been wearing was one of his favorites and one which she had bought multiple times over from getting worn out.
Speaker: However, the funeral home only had a couple of vape pens, his boots, eight $1 bills, and his piercings. They told Jen that was all that they had received from the coroner. Jen then expanded her questioning about the clothes to both city and county police since she was told that both had attended the autopsy. Both agencies denied having Alex's clothes. She then called the coroner who told her that
Speaker: if the police didn't collect them, that they were probably burned. But not a single person could give her a solid answer. She wanted that sweatshirt and now it was likely gone forever without her ever having gotten a say in the matter. Then about a week after the funeral, Jen heard the archived scanner calls from the afternoon Alex was discovered.
Speaker: Jen and her husband wanted to visit the area because they were told that Alex's ID, which we know was not in his wallet, was also not found on his person. They wanted to go look for it. On those scanner calls, she heard several cops who had gotten lost trying to find the location where Alex was. As such, one officer gave explicit instructions on how to get there. Jen followed those instructions.
Speaker: And that's when she learned that Alex was not found near the softball fields as she had also previously been told. Rather, he was in a much further and much more secluded spot. In fact, he had been found by a snowplow driver who had been in the area. He was covered with the newly fallen snow and had almost not been seen. But how did he get there?
Speaker: There was no way in Jen's mind with the way Alex was dressed and with his severe asthma that he could have walked nearly 10 miles to this location. Someone had driven him here. And if that were the case, she wondered, are they the ones who did this to Alex?
Speaker: My daughter and I love smoothies, but what we don't love are smoothie bar prices. With our Blendjet 2 portable blender, we can make smoothie bar quality drinks for a fraction of the price. Blendjet 2 is portable, so you can blend up a smoothie at work, a protein shake at the gym, or even a margarita on the beach. And it's small enough to fit into a cup holder, but powerful enough to blast through tough ingredients like ice and frozen fruit with ease.
Speaker: Even better blingit to his whisper quiet, so you can make your morning smoothie without waking up the whole House, plus it lasts for 15 plus blends and recharges quickly via usbc. You guys have heard me say it before and i'll say it again. Best of all the blingit to cleans itself just blend water with a drop of soap and you're good to go, plus they have so many trendy colors to choose from the hardest choice will be which design you want to rock.
Speaker: We also want to introduce you to the Orbiter Drinking Lid. The Orbiter Drinking Lid balances a leak proof design with one hand use convenience and a modern minimalist design. The Orbiter Drinking Lid is so easy to use you only need one hand. BlendJet's patent pending design allows you to open and drink by simply rotating the lid with your thumb. Just when we thought the BlendJet 2 couldn't get any better, it did.
Speaker: Now you can blend anywhere without spilling everywhere. So what are you waiting for? Go to blendjet .com and grab yours today. And be sure to use the promo code coffeeandcasesblendjet to get 12 % off your order and free two -day shipping. No other portable blender on the market comes close to the quality, power, and innovation of the BlendJet 2. They guarantee you'll love it or your money back.
Speaker: Blend anytime, anywhere with a BlendJet 2 portable blender. Go to blendjet .com and use the code COFFEEINCASESBLENDJET to get 12 % off your order and free two -day shipping. Shop today and get the best deal ever. Another week passed with still no indication of where Alex's clothes may have gone and still no answers to any of Jen's questions.
Speaker: Detective Tislow assured Jen that he was looking at various things and investigating Alex's death. And Jen received copies of various documents and reports that she hoped would provide more details. One would think that the call she received from the funeral home that the death certificate was ready, if she wanted to come and get a copy, would have given her more answers. The death certificate being completed meant that the autopsy was complete after all.
Speaker: Jen went to get a copy, but as she began reading it, she was in disbelief. And a couple of days later, she called the sheriff's office to ask about what she felt was the most implausible part of the report. The cause of death was the fracture at the base of Alex's skull and a gunshot wound to the head. But the manner of death read suicide.
Speaker: When she spoke with a detective, according to Jen, they told her to calm down and that the autopsy wasn't completed yet, even though Jen says as she spoke with them, she was holding a copy of it in her hands. She kept repeatedly asking if he would like for her to bring him a copy because she was holding one. How could the autopsy say suicide when she knew he didn't get there alone?
Speaker: After feeling like she was getting nowhere talking to law enforcement, Jen told me that she said something like, go ahead and file the autopsy and close the case so I can hire someone who will investigate. And that's exactly what happened a few weeks later. The case was officially closed.
Speaker: citing the letter with the list of items to Genesis as evidence of suicidal ideation, despite having earlier said otherwise. It was that earlier comment that Jen believes, because Genesis's number was written all over the document, and had it been recent, no friend or family member would have needed Genesis's number.
Speaker: Genesis called them all regularly. It made a lot more sense if the list had been written after Alex and Genesis began seeing each other around the time when Alex began questioning if they were ready to be in a relationship. After the case was closed, Jen immediately submitted a request for all the reports related to Alex's case. When she received them, Jen says she was shocked yet again.
Speaker: When Jen had received the autopsy, she knew it was short. Now she knew why. Citing the fact that Alex's body was frozen as justification, the autopsy had only been completed on Alex's head. Jen understandably was infuriated. The purpose of an autopsy is to provide as much information as possible, but a full autopsy wasn't completed.
Speaker: Had there been other injuries to his body? We don't know. Was there gunpowder residue on his hand? We don't know. Jen specifically asked law enforcement about gunpowder residue, though, since Alex's death was ruled a suicide. The response she got was that they no longer test for gunpowder residue because it's no longer admissible in court and because the powder can carry such a distance.
Speaker: Jen said to me, quote, I still think 30 seconds of their time could have answered some questions, end quote. The autopsy also listed the time of death as the date and time when Alex was found. There wasn't any indication that an attempt had been made to determine a more accurate time of death between February 3 and February 9, as again, any detail could provide more information that could prove
Speaker: invaluable. The likelihood that Alex did not go to this location by himself because of his asthma and because of the weather, and the fact that his hands were not tested for gunpowder residue to see if he did indeed fire a gun, were some of the issues that Jen had questions about, among others. Why was a complete autopsy not completed?
Speaker: She read in the reports that a gun was found under Alex's body, partially under his back hip and his elbow. Whose gun was it? Was it tested to know if it had recently been fired? No such test nor answers were in the reports. If the intent had been for Alex to commit suicide, why hadn't a gun been taken from his home? Jen had plenty there and Alex would have had easy access to them.
Speaker: Also in the reports were that police searched for two hours with metal detectors all around the area and weren't able to find a single shell casing. If this were a suicide, as they claimed, wouldn't the casing be right there near Alex? While parts of the images taken from the scene were blackened out, Jen also saw a description of the way Alex's body was found lying on the ground, ankles crossed,
Speaker: with what appeared to be his hands and his pockets. How was that position possible if this had been a suicide? How had the gun, after having been shot, somehow made it under his elbow? The photos also showed no signs of blood spatter that even with newly fallen snow, one would assume would continue to show discoloration in the snow. What was an explanation for this detail, Jen wondered?
Speaker: Additionally, she saw in the paperwork that a deputy coroner who first arrived at the scene had given varying details from the official report from the coroner that wasn't completed until just shy of 45 hours after Alex was found. One very important discrepancy was with the entrance and exit wounds on Alex.
Speaker: The deputy coroner, Evan Litman, had said the entrance wound, 1 .5 by one centimeter, had been on the left temple, since entrance wounds are typically smaller, and that the exit wound, six and a half by six centimeters, was on the right temple. This account would be consistent with what we typically know of the difference in size between entrance and exit wounds.
Speaker: However, the official autopsy report by forensic pathologist Dr. Darren Wolf listed the opposite, that the larger wound on the right temple had been the entrance wound and the smaller wound on the left temple had been the exit wound. Jen wondered why the discrepancy until she clarified for me in our conversation that since the gun had been found on Alex's right side,
Speaker: They must argue that the entrance wound, even though it was larger, had to be on the right side in order to support the suicide theory. Jen sent email upon email asking questions like these of law enforcement.
Speaker: The following are portions of the email response from Lieutenant Payne from the Lafayette Police Department that Jen has shared. I will read direct portions from that email now. Quote, on the day of the call, LPD responded to the area north of Crosser sports field for a subject that appeared to be deceased. The person plowing the trails is the person that called us. End quote.
Speaker: He went on to say, quote, we treat every death scene as a homicide until it is determined to be something else. I was able to make contact with a detective that sent me pictures of the scene in a FaceTime video where we were able to get a better idea of what was going on, along with speaking to officers on scene. The coroner's office was contacted and they sent a deputy coroner to the location to conduct
Speaker: his investigation as well. Over the course of the next few hours, the CSIs and detectives spoke to the person that located the body along with two individuals that got their vehicle stuck at a different portion of the trail." As for questions about the gun, Payne wrote, quote, I do not know where the gun came from at this point. End quote.
Speaker: He writes that he was given a description of the gun, but was under the impression that someone told him family had verified that it had come from Alex's home. He then says, quote, I have since clarified with Detective Tislow and have asked for ownership tracing to be conducted on the gun. I should find that information out today or tomorrow, end quote.
Speaker: In the email, Lieutenant Payne also addresses Jen's questions about asthma and what she felt was the easy way out for them to just say that Alex went there alone. He says, quote, As far as asthma goes, I guess it would be up to the extent of how bad it is.
Speaker: I coach local kids in sports and several have asthma and do fine with long runs and sprints. Sometimes they use their inhaler, sometimes they don't. My sergeant has asthma and is able to complete our physical assessment test which includes a wide variety of exercises including running. We also have to do long walks for a health benefit on our insurance
Speaker: and he's able to complete them. I don't have asthma, so I cannot give an opinion. If someone gave Alex the gun, drove him to that location, and allowed him to commit suicide, there would be nothing criminal for us to investigate that person for. If the person assisted by other means, then certainly we could investigate that. As of this time, we do not have any reason to believe this is the case."
Speaker: Lieutenant Payne ends by responding to what he, based on the tone of his email, must have felt was an attack on the integrity of his department, that because of Alex's experience with mental health issues,
Speaker: because there had been health checks in the past and because Alex was a transgender male, that they had not taken the case as seriously as they should have and merely rushed to get it done. Payne writes, quote, our division and department take death cases very seriously. And if there's a homicide, we have the entire division working on it for as long as needed. We are still a relatively small community and we have the time to work those cases to the bitter end.
Speaker: We do experience quite a bit of larger city crime these days, so we are very busy, but those aren't the types of cases we would just, quote, get done, end quote. That was the last correspondence Jen says she received from the Lafayette Police Department, despite many follow up contacts.
Speaker: Meanwhile, in June of 2022 was when Jen first saw the body cam footage from the responding officers in Alex's case, who were heard on camera indicating their belief that the details of the scene pointed to homicide.
Speaker: The following is a transcription of the audio, as published on July 20th, 2022, in the Purdue Exponent. Quote, several Lafayette police officers huddle around a snow -covered body. They've placed him here. Officer Jacob Dobbenmeyer says to the other officers, he was killed somewhere else. That's my guess.
Speaker: It looks like his hands are in his pockets, Officer Brian Landis says, moving his own hands to simulate shoving them into a pullover hoodie pocket. Mm -hmm, a third officer concurs. That's weird, Landis continues. Dobbin Meyer trudges back to his squad car through the heavily packed snow. It looks like they've dumped him here, he says. His legs are crossed and his arms are in his pockets, end quote.
Speaker: With this newfound information that responding officers believed it to be homicide leads us to question, why were law enforcement now claiming it was suicide? And what reason did they give about the change in entrance and exit wounds? While those answers were not provided to Jen, they were given to the media. Here's what they've said.
Speaker: While Lieutenant Payne would not respond specifically about Alex's case, he did answer questions for the Purdue exponent that were more generalized. He said, quote, if the weapon used is still present, it's a lot more likely the death was suicide, end quote. It seems as though he's taken that comment to heart in Alex's case. A present weapon equals suicide.
Speaker: The Purdue exponent reported on a conversation they had with Tippecanoe County coroner, Kari Costello, quote, Costello said the responding officers and deputy coroner aren't experts to my knowledge and any conclusions they came to were simply preliminary observations, end quote. Of the entrance and exit wounds, she went on to say the following, quote, there are so many factors that go into that, she said, including the type
Speaker: and caliber of the bullet and the direction it travels through the body. A recent study published in the National Library of Medicine, however, says entry wounds are typically smaller and more regular than exit wounds. Exit wounds are typically larger and show outward beveling of tissue.
Speaker: But Captain Clyde said that when a gun is in close proximity to the victim, it's easy to mistake the entry and exit wounds, even by an ER doctor." Are these true explanations or are they justifications? As for why Alex's body was positioned in a way that didn't seem to support suicide, Costello noted, quote, sometimes death doesn't happen simultaneously.
Speaker: There are some people that survived this." Law enforcement also responded to the media concerning Jen's claims that she wasn't given the information about the gun's owner. Police told media that they don't know why Jen hadn't known the owner of the gun until about a year later because they argue that the owner of the gun was listed, they said, in all the paperwork that Jen had received from them in March. Perhaps they had indicated
Speaker: Jen just didn't know how to find it. Jen responded to that claim in our conversation by arguing that she didn't understand why police said the name of the gun owner was in the paperwork in March when she had gotten a response from Lieutenant Payne a month later in April that said he didn't know the owner of the gun either, but would learn that information in a day or two.
Speaker: With that said, law enforcement were able to determine the owner of the gun found at the scene. Well, at least narrow it down to one of two people. You see, Jen isn't exactly clear to this day on whether the gun belonged to Alex's best friend, Cassie, or Cassie's ex -wife. The two had together purchased two guns, one for each of them.
Speaker: The couple had been on again and off again for some time by February of 2021 with Cassie's ex moving out and moving back in several times. The only thing that is clear is that uncertainty surrounds every detail of Alex's case. Nobody is certain of how the gun ended up at the scene, nor of how Alex could have been in possession of the firearm.
Speaker: According to an article in the Purdue Exponent from July 20th, 2022, Cassie wasn't even aware herself that the gun found at the scene was registered to her. She told reporter Joe DeHaunik that she didn't learn that detail until 17 months after Alex's death in July, 2022, when the Lafayette Police Department captain called to give her that information.
Speaker: Jen isn't even convinced that the weapon found at the scene is even the murder weapon because it was never, to her knowledge, tested. Jen has become a pro at research since Alex's death. She told me that in the research she has completed, she didn't see any findings indicating that a nine millimeter as the black and pink camouflage gun found under Alex was correlates with the size of Alex's wounds.
Speaker: Since Jen isn't convinced the gun at the scene was the murder weapon, the very reason law enforcement give as to why they believed Alex's death to be a suicide, I asked her how she believed it got there. Here's what she said. I think it was either planted or by by the way that he was laying when they placed him there, that maybe he
Speaker: knew like, okay, I don't fully trust this person. And I had it in his back waistband or something. Her feeling is that Alex had likely had the gun for protection. In Jen's mind, that would explain why the type of gun doesn't match the wound and if it fell out of his waistband, how it ended up in the position that it was in, in a way that the suicide ruling can't fully explain.
Speaker: She wonders, is that why Alex walked off camera to catch a ride? Because he knew Jen wouldn't like or trust who was picking him up. Why else would the person have not pulled up right in front of the home? Getting answers has proven even harder now that law enforcement have stopped responding to Jen.
Speaker: When asked about the case, law enforcement have told several media outlets that they stopped communicating with Jen and with the media because she had hired an attorney, filed a tort claim against them, and had started a social media group about the case. I asked Jen about that claim to which she laughingly replied, quote, I can prove a timeline to show that the communication stopped long before those things happened, end quote.
Speaker: She said the last communication with law enforcement was on April 5th, 2021, in the email from which I shared portions. She told me she didn't contact an attorney until July of that year. The attorney told her that the only course of action she could really do would be to file a tort claim, which she did, in August, claiming that TCPD and the LPD failed to issue a silver alert
Speaker: conduct a missing person search and appropriately conduct a murder investigation because Alex was transgender. By that point, several months had already passed with no correspondence. Jen told me about her fight to get answers. And no one wants to do this with their life every day. I want to remember my child.
Speaker: and his friends and family be able to remember him, not have to continuously relive the time that he was missing all the failures of law enforcement during that, the failures when he was found. But what options did they leave me with when they decided that
Speaker: They were just going to quit speaking to me because they knew they couldn't answer those questions. While we don't have answers, we do have theories, other places to explore, to push, to find evidence, or at the very least, to close some doors. The first of the theories is suicide. Those like law enforcement who argue suicide point to the note in Alex's room with a list of items to return to Genesis.
Speaker: They point to the gun being found at the scene. They point to Alex's struggle with depression and anxiety. They argue that no parent wants to admit it when their child has taken their own life.
Speaker: In the article, Was Sun's Death Really a Suicide?, new video adds to mother's concern about 2021's shooting by Joe DeHaunik, published in the Indianapolis Star, quote, Police and the coroner told Indy Star they stand by their findings. They said the new concerns raised by Van Dalsen are not enough to reopen the investigation.
Speaker: What a grieving mother sees as critical discrepancies, they said, are the results of different roles and levels of expertise between patrol officers who initially respond to crime reports and the investigators who follow up to determine what happened."
Speaker: But just because someone is struggling with their mental health doesn't mean this is an open and shut case. After all, as Jen pointed out, why was Genesis's number written all over that note when they all knew her number, unless it was from early in their relationship? And Jen says, Alex loved to write. She is convinced that if Alex had been planning to commit suicide, he would have left a note.
Speaker: Also, if suicide were the intent, why not take a gun from the home? Why not drive there? How do we explain the placement of the gun, of crossed ankles and hands and pockets, of the lack of blood spatter? Where's the shell casing? Here's what Jen said. I think a lot of people look at it and, oh, you know,
Speaker: grieving mom can't accept the fact that her son did this. Like, you know, if this is what happened, I would accept it. But you can't prove to me that this is what happened because everything that you're showing me shows me something different. I tried in the beginning, like explain this to me.
Speaker: These are my questions. These are my concerns. Explain how you got this from this because nobody else can put two and two together and get four in the manner that you have. So help me make sense of it. And they could not.
Speaker: And even if we can explain away some of these questions, can we really explain away all of them? I'm not convinced that we can. The second theory is that his death was caused by a so -called friend.
Speaker: Jen feels in her gut that one or more of those quote unquote friends know more than they've let on. Her gut tells her that they must or why would Alex have walked off screen to get into a vehicle as she's convinced he did. Recall the asthma, the weather, and the search dog stopping at the intersection.
Speaker: As I stated before, that would explain the position of the gun if Alex had taken it from Cassie's for protection. It would explain why in Jen's estimation, the wounds don't match a nine millimeter, because perhaps they didn't come from a nine millimeter. It would also explain why there's no shell casing. It could explain the posing of Alex's body and
Speaker: In Jen's mind, she now goes back to those worries Alex had about the threats made by those friends to, quote, come out and shoot up everyone in the house, end quote, of him telling Jen that they would harass if they didn't get their way. She wonders if Alex had finally told one of them no, and this was the result.
Speaker: After all, one had set Alex up previously to be robbed at gunpoint over saying no to loaning money. Could something like that have happened again? But this time it cost Alex his life. The third theory is that something else happened to Alex after leaving home that snowy, cold February night. Perhaps something that someone out there holds the answer to.
Speaker: Jen points out that there were two individuals police said they spoke to whose vehicles had been stuck in the snow not far from where Alex's body was found. According to Jen, the stories told by the vehicle owners and when they were stuck has changed several times. I wasn't able to find concrete information about those vehicles nor the owners to verify, but at the very least, she wonders if they heard or saw anything that could provide more information.
Speaker: Jen went on to say that also near the scene was a tent that a homeless man lived in. Although, again, I wasn't able to verify with law enforcement. It's Jen's understanding that the police made no attempt to contact nor question that man. What other information could be out there? What other questions haven't been asked? What really happened to Alex van Dalsen?
Speaker: Unfortunately, so many of these questions can't be answered now since a test was never completed for gunpowder residue. The gun wasn't processed to verify if it had been fired recently. No shell casing was found. A full body autopsy was never completed. And Alex's clothing has mysteriously disappeared. But all of those roadblocks haven't stopped Jen from trying to find out what happened to Alex.
Speaker: Most recently, unsuccessfully, she tried to get the case reopened through the Indiana State Police. I asked Jen what reason they gave, but she didn't feel she ever got a clear answer to that question, other than having the personal impression that she had, in her words, quote, hit a blue wall, end quote, and that she, quote, didn't feel they had any intention to reopen the case, end quote.
Speaker: Jen has faced some criticism online for her questioning of the police in Alex's investigation that she is, quote, blaming police because she didn't get the outcome she wanted. End quote. She responded to those accusations on Facebook, and I want to read you her response because it is powerfully worded. She wrote, quote, no.
Speaker: A dead child is never an outcome a real parent wants, but I'm not blaming the police for that. Do I think they could have done more to help find Alex? Yes. If they had, could we have found him alive? I'll never know. I'm definitely blaming them for willfully failing to do their jobs when he was found.
Speaker: So to message me and say, I did not get the outcome I wanted. You're right. I didn't. I want Alex safe at home with his loving family. But since that can't happen, I want answers as to how and why this happened and who participated in it. I will continue to fight to find those answers until my very last breath." End quote.
Speaker: But Sleuthhounds, we can fight for answers alongside her. First, join the Facebook group called Justice for Alex Blake -Vandalson to show your support. A link is in our show notes. Second, sign genschange .org petition. The link is in the show notes as well. And the 30 seconds it will take you to sign it will mean the world for Jen. Third, if you are able,
Speaker: Contribute to Jen's GoFundMe, also linked in the show notes, that will go toward paying for a private investigator. And finally, share. Share Alex's story. Share a link to this episode. Keeping his name out there is more significant than you think. And Jen, as you listen to this, know that you are not alone. There is power in numbers.
Speaker: and you now have many more people to push for answers alongside of you. Anyone with information in the case of Alex Vandalsen is asked to call the Tippecanoe County Sheriff's Department as 765 -423 -9388.
Speaker: Again, please like and join our Facebook page, Coffee and Cases podcast to continue the conversation and see images related to this episode. As always, follow us on Twitter, at casescoffee, on Instagram, at coffee cases podcast, or you can always email us suggestions to coffeeandcasespodcastatgmail .com. Please tell your friends about our podcast so more people can be reached to possibly help bring some closure to these families. Don't forget to rate our show and leave us a comment as well. We hope to hear from you soon.
Speaker: Stay together. Stay safe. We'll see you next week.
Speaker: If you've been listening to our show for more than one episode, then you probably know about my love for animals. What I don't often talk about is the difficulty of meeting all their nutritional needs. Trust me, not all dog food is created equal, but we're about to solve that problem for you. It's called Nom Nom.
Speaker: In Nom Nom, you can actually see proteins and vegetables like beef, chicken, pork, peas, carrots, kale, and more. And ordering it is the easiest way to take the guesswork out of feeding your dog the best. Nom Nom meals are pre -portioned for your dog's exact caloric needs.
Speaker: Isn't it time to feel good about the food you're feeding your dog? Order Nom Nom today. Go to trynom .com slash coffee and cases and get 50 % off your first order plus free shipping. And Nom Nom comes with a money back guarantee. That means if your dog doesn't love fresh, delicious meals, Nom Nom will refund your first order. No fillers, no nonsense, just Nom Nom.
