Transcript
Speaker: This is the Out of the Wild Podcast with Ken Ilgunas.
Speaker: My guest today is Antonia Melchik. a writer based in Montana and the author of A Walking Life. Reclaiming our health. and our freedom one step at a time. Antonia writes the substack Trespassing, which explores ownership, power, and the privatization of the commons. Her work examines how walking connects us to the land and one another, and what we lose when places once shared become fenced off and privately. I've known Antonia for 10 years via email.
Speaker: um We talked a lot about... private property trespassing the commons it's rare to find someone who's kind of into the exact same thing you're into so as we were working on our respective books we were passing a lot of notes back and forth. So this is my first time getting to chat with her and I was inspired to get in touch based on her.
Speaker: substack essay sorted little stories which is a very open and vulnerable piece about growing up poor in Montana and just kind of... Having this financial precariousness, this this shame kind of... Follow you. through your adult life.
Speaker: We talked about kind of the political culture in Montana which can be a very kind and generous place but like Any heavily rural state can... suffer from all sorts of political delusions and then we get into her essay sordid little stories shame poverty all that fun stuff this is a long one it's about an hour and 45 minutes first 45 minutes is uh free to any so free subscriber.
Speaker: Paid subscribers get full access. Well, I think one thing I noticed... when working with people like us and you know they sometimes i think they call themselves like progressive property theorists you know academics who are interested in writing about the commons and you know what's happening legislatively what's happening legally and they're usually in favor of things like the right to roam I don't know if you've noticed this when you've talked to... People of our ilk. But they are.
Speaker: extraordinarily nice, extraordinarily... generous, and extraordinarily Sharing. which kind of leads me to believe There's kind of like a base personality out of which some of their...
Speaker: political values. grow um And I don't know if there's a question attached to this other than does that resonate for you at all? it It does. um Hugely, like I think of every every person I've ever gotten in touch to. to interview formally or just ask questions like David Bollier, who's a real very influential scholar on the commons. spent a lot of time with me and introduced me to some other people and
Speaker: And I do like I hadn't thought about the question in exactly those terms before. But now that you phrased it that way, like, is there a core personality trait? I'm kind of wondering because I run into a lot of things where I think.
Speaker: You know, I've written about this for so long now. and really believe in the commons and kind of the evils of private land ownership in particular. and certain things about private property in general.
Speaker: And it's it does. um forced me in a way to constantly question my own values. like if i'm if i'm you know, something to do with Substack, for example. I'm like, okay, wait.
Speaker: Is this in line with the values that I. profess to believe in and the kind of world I want to see. And now I'm wondering if a lot of other people do that too. Like I think about, um douglas rushkoff right who wrote team human and he does all these this podcast about like
Speaker: Teen human, I guess, see it's you know, it covers a lot of territory, but I feel like. He really works on that or Cory Doctorow. And obviously those people don't work specifically in the fields of the commons. and and Right to Roam and those kinds of issues, but it's very...
Speaker: It's very related. um Yeah, that's a really interesting question. I think there must be a core personality. Like if you're going to be an economist, like a professional economist who researchers and works at a think tank or university or something.
Speaker: and you go for, say, Georgism. rather than um following Milton fried Friedman or Malthus or Ricardo or one of the other classic um sort of free market. quote unquote, economists, like that's a very. specific choice that is a choice that says i believe in you know what henry george
Speaker: wanted to see with regards to land ownership and land taxation and and what actually creates a fair and just society. um So theres there's got to be something in that.
Speaker: Yeah. And it it makes me think, you know, just like you and I, for example, like. We grew up in... Very different. places probably very different backgrounds i mean you come from Montana. I come from...
Speaker: suburban Western New York. so were separated by a vast geographical distance, but yet... you and I, we end up kind of... thinking about things in a very... similar way. And the amount of people who are, say, writing about these things.
Speaker: I mean, under a hundred, you know, like, yeah like there's not many. and and then like If you add like... you know, say the Americans who are interested in reading about this. Okay, maybe...
Speaker: A couple thousand. So. it just It just makes me wonder. What? Is it? that kind of draws someone like. you and I.
Speaker: to so to to a very kind of specific. field. And i think I think, as you said... It's got to be a certain kind of personality type. and I think.
Speaker: If you were to kind of evaluate my personality, it's ah like a hide. disposition towards. Fairness. Also like open to experience. Like, yeah, let's like radically.
Speaker: re -imagine the world i don't know does anything else come to mind or maybe just like how we grew up too maybe we didn't grow up um Super. affluent or super privileged I don't know. I mean, there's certainly that factor, um which I didn't even.
Speaker: I don't think I even thought of as a factor until the past few years, like class issues and having grown up really poor. um but Before I answer, I'm actually really curious what. Your answer would be like.
Speaker: Before you ever ventured out trespassing across the US, you know, following an oil pipeline. um What, what do you think planted that seed for you like I'm sure it was curiosity and wandering and adventure, but.
Speaker: Do you remember? Do you have a... an idea of. what the... Yeah, what the seed was, I guess, that little spark of an idea.
Speaker: It's a very complicated It's a very complicated. Um, question to answer because it's The answer is probably very multi. faceted.
Speaker: Um, I don't know, maybe like the number one answer is just like genetics, like just. Just what? genes were given to me. um and giving me kind of this predisposition towards.
Speaker: I don't know wanting to be kind of adventurous. but also have this predisposition towards like... fairness And I think... I think that's where it is. Like I've always. looked upon. nature.
Speaker: As like an underdog or someone who's been. mistreated. And I've always wanted to kind of... Advocate. for the underdog. And I think... I don't know, as strong as the environment movement can be, I feel like it's it's often overlooked or or not seen as an underdog. So I think when I go on a walk like that.
Speaker: Like I'm trying to. ah help something, some giant... you know amorphous entity that we call a grander ecosystem or mother nature or whatever so i think i think that's what it is i think it's it's fairness i think it's wanting to kind of stick up for someone who's being beaten down.
Speaker: That, okay, so that's amazing because i I just did another podcast interview a couple of days ago. um And she asked me. ah a variation a version of this same question and it was one that nobody's ever asked me before um And I was like, I don't. I. Gosh, I haven't. Haven't thought about that answer yet.
Speaker: um So she was asking me how I got into writing about the commons and private property and ownership. And and um I ended up. answering a similar um In a similar way, because I said there's like two, there's two answers, really. There's two things going on. One is.
Speaker: like what was it about that subject that made me curious and got me interested interested enough to write about it. but also what's that what's that underlying driver. And my answer was actually similar because it was like part genetic and part how I grew up.
Speaker: And also just my early. early, I don't even know what you'd call it. I don't want to call it awakening or whatever, but just my. My first knowledge of the environmental harm that the dominant culture has caused. And it was it was reading um an article in Newsweek, you know, the... very mainstream big magazine at the time I would think I was about 16
Speaker: And it was about the road building that the Forest Service does. and the timber industry and i think this this was right at the time of the um what they call the timber wars which was when there was a lot of environmental pushback against um
Speaker: logging that specifically um clear cuts in in the Western US forests. Oregon was a real hotspot for that. And so it was in the it was in the news a lot. And I just remember reading that article and just this kind of rage of injustice rising. It's like.
Speaker: Why are our tax dollars paying for such destruction, you know, in ah in a forest that can't stop it and animals that can't stop it? and You know, I was 16. Wasn't exactly.
Speaker: articulate or... very knowledgeable, but. that feeling of that's not. fair that's not just was very strong um And maybe it was partly the way the article was written, but. um I remember that. But then, you know, i I grew up in a very abusive household. Like I didn't grow up in one where we like happily talked about. the social issues of the day and philosophy around the table. but
Speaker: um but my parents are both really Brilliant people, um highly educated, but also just. smart on their own. um And so they were they were always politically engaged. and my mother's parents who her father was a farmer rancher in eastern Montana and he'd been he joined the world government back in the 50s or 60s or something like
Speaker: I come from this lineage of people who who have been involved and who do care. um And then my father is Russian Jewish, and he grew up in the Soviet Union under Stalin.
Speaker: And when I was growing up in the 1980s, he was in exile. He was not allowed back to his country. and And I think those those things just fed into to the way I grew up, but also.
Speaker: who I am. in a way like i i only met i never met my russian grandfather i only met my grandmother twice very briefly before she died and I was 14. So it's not like they were able to influence me in that way. But the more I learn about them, the more and how they lived and what they believed in, the more I feel like. you know something's been passed down to me and my sisters. and
Speaker: and probably our kids. in the long run Gotcha. So your advocacy has roots going through your your family tree. It's been kind of generationally kind of passed down in some indirect way.
Speaker: Yeah, I mean, like... you know Growing up under Stalin, people were not. People were not protesting. They were not activists. like You're just trying not to get shot.
Speaker: And to feed your family. Like that was the stark reality of how my father grew up. And especially being Jewish, it was very anti -Semitic. And um his family was actually on the verge of being deported to Birobidzhan, I think is is was the... um is the the state in Russia where Stalin was.
Speaker: sending all the Jews, like, we're just going to create a new Jewish state over there and get rid of all you people. And then he died. So the plan didn't go through. um and And so it wasn't like my grandparents were fighting. stalin or you know in some sort of resistance underground but they had a strong belief in um
Speaker: justice and honesty and truth and fairness. And I think a lot about that, like how they held on to those values in a society that. had no room for them but they did and I think that's affected me somehow.
Speaker: Maybe through my dad. And it seems like... you know, their values were We're really... Tested. in that you know they had to deal with these... threats. And maybe that has a sort of way of... of crystallizing Ones. one's values versus someone who's just kind of Blithely. you know floating through life and fortunately doesn't have to be test it in those ways but in that way they've kind of had to
Speaker: define them and maybe that that gets passed down in some way more. clearly than it would for some other families. Yeah. Yeah, I think that's true. I thought about that a lot in the past few years. I don't know.
Speaker: Have you thought about this at all? Like you you live in Scotland, right? So you're American, but you live. I was going to say in Europe, but it's not. It's technically Europe. But yeah, I don't know. if I think they...
Speaker: They think they just live on Britain here. yeah Um, So over the past few years, I thought a lot about. The difference it makes having.
Speaker: um that kind of hardship in your immediate background and experience. um is I just, yeah most Americans just don't. don't always seem to understand what's at stake when it comes to justice. and Um,
Speaker: justice Justice and integrity, I think. And it's just it's interesting to me. I've thought a lot about, well, how does that? How does that happen? Like, how does some people have that? and millions and millions of other people. don't or think they do, but it comes out in in destructive ways. Well, it can it can kind of go the other way. too And I'm sure you're familiar with these stories. I mean, my name, Ilgunas, is Lithuanian. So Lithuanians were occupied by...
Speaker: by Russians, um you know, up until around... 1990. And when I went to Eastern Europe and Lithuania to spend some time on a kind of... you know, genetic tour. um ah you know One thing you notice is when you go in a shop in Eastern Poland, they look at you very... so suspiciously it's not like some American cheer, you know, I went to Glasgow, Montana and
Speaker: walk into an outdoor store and like they treat me like i'm their grandson or whatever. um so I think. going through that like a really rough time like that.
Speaker: It could also be... doesn't really help you crystallize. Well, maybe it helps you crystallize some values, but it can also create an air of paranoia and suspicion.
Speaker: and mistrust, which could be extremely corrosive for the society. Whereas in Montana, where I've spent a good deal of time, yeah you have there is... Um...
Speaker: This amazing. culture of kindness. And for for all of Montana's. problems and blind spots, an amazing culture. of kindness and generosity it's like that's the place you want to be to have you know, your tire. break down on the road because someone's probably going to come and and and help you with it. And I almost feel like Montanans.
Speaker: are that way because they've never had that Soviet. experience I mean, in some way, you know. Speaking. only about, you know, Euro Americans, Euro Montanans, you know, white white Montanans.
Speaker: They're insulated from... All kinds of... hardship You know, there's no war. going to come to Montana. There's no you know pogroms. There's no genocides going to happen there. So I almost feel like.
Speaker: They can be that kind and... cheery because there is kind of this absence of you know There are many hardships, but not that kind of interpersonal hardship. Does any of that...
Speaker: resonate at all for you. Well, it it makes me think of COVID and um having a lot of conversations with friends, especially in New York and and um other places on the either more urban areas.
Speaker: um And just going around those parts of Montana where you've been, which we call Eastern Montana, the farmland, prairie lands, much less populated than the part of Montana I live in. Although, you know, in a state that's geographically. approximate to the uk with barely over a million people to say where i live feels crowded is um It's kind of pushing it for a lot of people. That's a ridiculous thing to say, but go ahead. I know. I live in a town of 8 ,000 people and and I just like.
Speaker: Feels too much. Um, But it but it just... I kept trying to explain. It it wasn't like. I wasn't trying to excuse. like anti-maskers or anti even anti -vaxxers in the the state I live in. But trying to get my head around um And why it is that if you live in a town of 200 people or 17 people, which is really common in that part of Montana, and the next town is...
Speaker: half an hour to an hour's drive away and everybody lives. um you know, far off in distant fields all spread around except for a few people in town. Like it just, it creates a different dynamic of of trust.
Speaker: And um both for the bigger society and. your political leaders, but also between your neighbors. um it And it's just... Yeah, it... it It's a completely different social dynamic and it's really hard to explain. to people who don't live in that kind of area. And partly because it's it's hard to explain to myself. like I'm like, i don't I don't fully understand this dynamic and I've been trying to get my head around it.
Speaker: um But just to go back to what you were saying. You don't fully understand what dynamic, the kind of the Eastern Montana dynamic or the less... less neighborly Western montana dynamic if that's how you would characterize it well i i think um Oh, the Eastern Montana. Yeah, well, I...
Speaker: I don't think it's specifically there. I think it's in, you know, a lot of rural areas where people tend to be more spread out um and really know their neighbors. and um there's I think there's some kind of trust that goes on between neighbors that says.
Speaker: We don't need other people telling us what to do. but It's getting a lot ah little off track of what you were talking about. um I do think you're right that there's. a ah sense of safety.
Speaker: um in a place like this that people have that makes them feel. okay being friendly to people. And I've noticed that change where I live. um So the part of Montana I live, I live in Whitefish, which is known as a, it's a tourist town and it has been for, for decades. It's got a ski mountain. It's very close to Glacier National Park.
Speaker: It's about an hour south of the Canadian border. and It's always known been known as a better off town in Montana, which is ah has been a relatively poor state.
Speaker: um But in... Over the past... especially since COVID, but even before that, there was a lot of... um multimillionaire vacation homeowners who've bought places here and then some billionaires who've bought a lot of land.
Speaker: in the surrounding area. And, um and then just a lot of wealth post COVID, you know, the classic thing where you had people who have remote jobs that pay really well. And they can they can move somewhere where they can work from home and go hiking and skiing and get in the back country and fish and do all kinds of things. um It's a good life. You know, it's a good lifestyle.
Speaker: But there's been so much of that, that. I've noticed in people who've been here a long time that it started to create more distrust. And and that's not new. Like and when I was um in high school in the early 1990s.
Speaker: People would complain about Californians moving up to Montana to places like this. And there was that mistrust. And i I almost wonder if it's kind of primal. like It's just these people are different from us. Therefore, you know, I've had it.
Speaker: Like. ah there's a neighbor down the road who um is never, ever going to listen to this. So I don't. I don't mind talking about him a bit. Nobody's ever going to listen to this. Oh, yes, they will. Five people. 105.
Speaker: 500. So he's... And he's very right wing. And he like in the last before the last election, he had a big like Trump flag up on a flagpole that you could see above the trees. And we have very tall trees. It's a very tall flagpole.
Speaker: And. um He has gotten really angry at some of the other neighbors. in the but And it's a dead -end street, so it's like a... tight little neighborhood. And. And he'll call people like me outsiders and like, when you move here from California or wherever and and change the way we do things. And I'm like, dude, I'm a fifth generation Montanan.
Speaker: You have this idea of what your identity is and what the identity of the state is and insist that anyone who doesn't fit that identity has to. has to be from somewhere else. I don't know. It's it's a complicated question. I think...
Speaker: One of the things I think about a lot is that. um When people feel that their identity is threatened, it can have almost a bigger effect than when they feel that their physical safety. is threatened so to you know, make a huge circle back to what you were asking about. I actually. I actually think that people can be really great.
Speaker: it where I live until they feel that their identity is threatened. And part of that is that they don't They don't really have a physical threat, like you said. Although we do, like Montana is home to many, many, many nuclear missile silos. And when I was growing up, it was well known that if they're, you know, this was during the Cold War.
Speaker: and So nuclear. or was it was an actual threat that was on people's minds a lot. And it was known that Montana would be one of the first places hit because. That's where the missile silos are. And that's why they put them in places like Montana and Wyoming to redirect attacks away from large population areas.
Speaker: People have kind of forgotten about that. I've forgotten about that. I take back everything I said about how Montana is completely insulated. from geopolitical Warfare.
Speaker: it's It's come up a little more recently, but it's not something people think about or remember. Really. Okay, so your neighbor's identity is threatened, and I'm wondering, and I'm guessing some... listeners are wondering like what exactly um what are we doing to this guy's uh how are we violating this guy's identity. Is it the fact that...
Speaker: Um, i don't know like someone like american prairie wants to bring in bison and to kind of take over a chunk of of cattle country? Is it kind of environmentalist saying, you know, we shouldn't do that, we shouldn't do this?
Speaker: what What else? Well, both of those, I think. I mean, American Prairie isn't very close to here, but that. that. kind of situation definitely permeates throughout the state. like of I've heard from people who've never been to American Prairie, never talked to a single person who works for them.
Speaker: You're like, oh, they're trying to take over eastern Montana. and all these rich outsiders telling us what to do with our land. and and um Yeah, that's very much it. an identity feeling attack. But I think um and environmentalism in general. like anything that says, hey, maybe we need to...
Speaker: take care of the forests instead of cutting them all down. um Not just because there's a lot of wildlife that depends on it, but because that's our watershed. Like if you want water, you've got to take care of the forests in a way that actually um promotes their health rather than just. uses the trees for. timber money.
Speaker: um and And I do think that goes back to the timber wars of the 1980s and early 1990s. I've seen a lot of people. um point to the sagebrush rebellion in the seven, was it seventies?
Speaker: early 80s um i wasn't alive during that time so i don't i don't really have a sense of um how people felt during that time. And that's why I go to the Timber Wars because I do remember.
Speaker: how vitriolic that was and, and the. You know, the the feeling of violence in America is is acute right now for a lot of people. I feel it all the time. and i I didn't feel it as extremely then, but I did feel kind of that.
Speaker: That. um, I don't know, it's almost like a fog of violence and threats that that came through because people were so angry. So so for people who don't know, this is i'm I'm going to simplify this hugely and to. To get a really good understanding, I recommend there's a series called Timber Wars from Oregon Public Broadcasting.
Speaker: that they did several years back. And it's it's just, it's a podcast, but it's like. It's one of those, I don't remember. six to 10. um episode thing. So it's not something you have to listen to forever. It's just a ah story that's told. And basically it was companies like Weyerhaeuser.
Speaker: Uh, had massive land holdings and they still do. And most of it's forests. um And then there's national forests and these are, you know, Weyerhaeuser's a timber company and they cut down trees and they make money cutting down trees. And there's this pushback against the amount of logging being done because it was really destructive and it wasn't. um It wasn't sustainable for the forests, like they couldn't really regenerate very well.
Speaker: And then there were there were some wildlife, like the northern spotted owl, that became a real flashpoint. Like it's an endangered species and it needs old growth. forests in order to breathe and thrive.
Speaker: um And so it became this like. pitched battle between Um, the way it was framed was really between the environment and jobs.
Speaker: um you know people who work in the timber industry and that's when you'd see these signs pop up all over the west say this family supported by timber dollars And, um you know, that is both a physical threat and an identity threat. Like even if you provided another job for people, it's like if your identity is wrapped up in being a timber worker. it still feels like a threat. And and I think we've been living with the legacy of that ever since, where there's this this framing that... um corporations like Weyerhaeuser.
Speaker: And. um media kind of played into a lot. of it's out of the environment. or it's people's livelihoods and welfare and how you take care of their family. And I think we've been. we've been stuck with that for decades now. Like I see it in our local politics. all the time. like for the decisions our county commissioners make they're really right wing and um Anything that even has the slightest whiff of.
Speaker: hey, maybe trees are good or clean water is good. you know and They will frame it as not only environmentalist, which is a bad word, but communist. like That has been coming up a lot in recent years, which is absurd. but it just you know And so I do think it kind of points to how resonant the 80s are because it's like, oh, those environmentalists and communists. It's like, do you even know what you're talking about? Yeah, I mean, the emotional. What's happening inside me as you kind of describe this story is a kind of big eye roll. you know, the people who are
Speaker: Um, pushing back against some sort of... and probably sensible environmental regulation. um or who who are just kind of lobbying around words like communism is like come on like what are we fifth graders, like.
Speaker: it' We're being kind of ridiculous. And I know if... I was to do like a reported story on this and I'd be in the kitchen table. of some of these families.
Speaker: I would probably find... I'd probably learn a lot from them. I'd probably find find many ways to sympathize with them. But kind of from... afar. Um...
Speaker: you know more than a thousand miles away. Or just kind of... thinking about. ecosystem. through an egocentric lens or just kind of like a multi -sensory lens it's just like a no -brainer For me, it's just like, come on, we are just. really fucking up the environment. This is not good.
Speaker: So... Yeah. I don't know if there's a question. that follow this follows this other than How do you kind of... navigate these things when you have your own. I roll.
Speaker: But yeah, these are. real people and many other concerns are real. But. I don't know. Maybe they just haven't. Maybe they just don't have the... Maybe they're... incapable of of having that. broader outlook for A variety of reasons.
Speaker: Well, um I pretend to patience that I i don't have. I think i think like... I have this persona. this public persona that's like kind and generous and full of gratitude and ultra patient. And actually I have a really bad temper. I swear a lot and my poor kids. um I do my best, but. um
Speaker: i I actually have to credit my younger sister who manages some those local coffee shops ah for talking with me about how she talks with people because she has to talk with people.
Speaker: you know, ah from all viewpoints and all walks of life. And because she's the manager of these cafes, she's often dealing with conflicts um that they're having in which, you know, identity issues will come out in in really weird ways, um which is. It's a type of entitlement, but it feels real to the person.
Speaker: uh And also my son, actually, um you know, he just started college elsewhere, but he worked for four years at a local cafe as a busser. And he really loved talking with people. And that's one thing he talked about is how many different types of conversations he had. So I kind of lean on the experiences of much more patient people.
Speaker: and than I am. um But also. there's this There's this essay that I recommend probably more than almost any other essay. It's very long. It's about 6 ,000 words. It's an Aeon magazine by C .T. Nyan, who's a philosopher. And it's about... um it's partly about cults, but it's really about the difference between echo chambers and epistemic bubbles.
Speaker: And. um how hard it is to Like an echo chamber is one thing. It's like, you're not really allowed to receive outside information, say like in a cult, but in an epistemic bubble, you. You can receive outside information, but it's reinterpreted and weaponized. So his example is Rush Limbaugh, who is the...
Speaker: famous, very vitriolic, right -wing radio presenter. Who became really big in the 1990s and the ways in which. um He would talk about everything that was going on, especially environmentalism and and any pretty much anything that...
Speaker: a liberal leaning fair -minded justice -minded person cares about And he would reframe it as something stupid, as an attack on American identity, as attack on people's livelihoods. And so when people are in that epistemic. bubble. They can receive all that information, but they're receiving it through a filter that frames it in a certain way. and um
Speaker: this is It's kind of a complicated thing to explain, and I bet there are scholars out there who actually know what they're talking about because i don't i'm I'm just a person who thinks a lot and lives here. um And I think there's something to that.
Speaker: That bubble effect, like I can get really frustrated with. um liberal leaning people where I live, which that I live in an extremely right -wing County. Like I should say the next town over is around 30 ,000 people and it's very conservative. Whereas my town is about 8 ,000 people and it leans liberal. Like it's not.
Speaker: It's not like. 50 -50 really, but it's um maybe 60 -40. ish liberal to conservative. so So I have a lot of liberal friends and I get a little frustrated because.
Speaker: They'll pay attention to national news and national conversations and NPR podcasts and big things, but they won't pay attention to what people. where we live are actually experiencing.
Speaker: and the world that they're living in. and And they'll talk about... Oh, I don't know. You can take any issue like health care. And I say, don't they understand that if they do this, then they're going to lose their health care? and And I'm like, no. They don't. They're living in an entirely different information world. Like the reality actually is different. I mean, the the objective reality isn't different, but the reality that they're perceiving is.
Speaker: totally different. And I was talking to a friend's husband a couple years ago, who's former military, he was a Navy pilot, and he works for military contractors as a drone pilot now. So he's had a lot of experiences and, and um He was on a contract.
Speaker: Somewhere in the Middle East, I think. And he's he said that he just like in the evening, he just like exits to his tiny little room and doesn't talk to people because they're they all watch Fox News and they're all super right wing.
Speaker: And. And we were talking about it, and he said what he's watched is that people used to watch Fox, say, in the 1990s. when they were... they weren't nearly so full of propaganda and extremism. But the thing is, it's that, it's that, Oh, I hate this. I hate this, um, analogy, you know, the frog in the boiling water thing, but I haven't found one to replace it. It just seems cruel to frogs. like Why throw them in there all the time?
Speaker: um But, but it you know, the... Fox became more full of propaganda and more full of extremism over the years, but people. grew with that and they didn't realize what was happening.
Speaker: around them. um And I think detoxifying from that is really hard because, you know. As in all addiction, first you have to realize you have a problem. And you have to admit you have a problem. um and And so i think it's ah you know I think it's a real problem with our information ecosystems. that We are not. We're not living this. You know, I have friends whose's whose parents live in that.
Speaker: other reality. And. um for them trying to talk with their parents is really, really. hard because their parents believe things that aren't real or are twisted to such an extent that they that they turn into threats or something evil when they're when they're not.
Speaker: The way you put it, that it sounds scary and cultish. And cultishsh and i think I think what you're saying is is on the nose and and accurate, but it's it's disturbing to hear it that way. and And you're right. I mean, when did Fox News start? Maybe around 1996 -ish, around there. So, you know, that's...
Speaker: 30 years. for and And all of that. propaganda and misinformation and that. really hard political slant. put on everything 30 years from that. Yeah.
Speaker: It's got to be really hard to... to detoxify, but you kind of... Again, I'm kind of having that eye roll. It's just like. yeah Come on. I mean, don't you realize you've been lied to a number of times it's kind of like that movie what is it called uh Don't Look Up is the lido Leo movie yeah about an asteroid. coming and kind of nobody believed it coming.
Speaker: And the people. and And politicians were like, there's no asteroid. It's going to miss us. And it's coming straightfor that minute straight towards them. And in that final moment. They were like, you fucking lied to us and threw a a beer can at the president or something.
Speaker: So I hope it doesn't come to that last, that very last second. i I hope so too. I am i have watched that movie 12 times. Um, It resonates for you, it sounds like. It does. And I think it really it really speaks to this these the times that we live in, which was its point. um The last time I watched it was with my son after the the second time that Trump was elected.
Speaker: and um I thought it would like. cheer us up a little bit, but it actually made us both really depressed. Sometimes going into that darker place that kind of feeds that dark injury or or kind of like a a worst case scenario. it It almost makes. Things more bearable. Yeah. real I mean, being half Russian, I tend towards fatalism. So I'm kind of okay going to the extreme ends of thought about things.
Speaker: um But, you know. The whole like, how do you talk with people? How do you be with people who think in these ways? So that essay about epistemic bubbles and echo chambers, he talks about. Really the only way of doing it is to remain.
Speaker: available to people who... want to try stepping out of there and talking to other people. And I have experienced that a few times. like there's this There's this guy. um i want to I want to say it in a way that doesn't give too much details because I don't want to.
Speaker: I don't want to get him in immigration trouble, actually. Um, Um, So there's a guy. ah who I see on a weekly baselet basis because of an a particular errand that I run every week.
Speaker: And he's um originally from El Salvador and grew up in Columbia. And he has this car, this vehicle with all of these right wing stickers on it, like Trump stickers, gun stickers. He's got one with a guy holding a semi -automatic weapon that says doesn't play well with liberals.
Speaker: um And I know. and um And I talk with him. all the time. like we He loves talking with people and we chat and I always build in an extra up to half an hour. because that's how much he likes to talk. um when i'm when I'm running that errand. And the interesting thing is that...
Speaker: everything that he cares about is also stuff I care about. And we think very similarly about it. Like he talks about like, why is it in such a rich country that you have to pay so much for a college education and healthcare care and all these things. And I.
Speaker: You know, I don't know if someday I will say. Hey, do you not notice that the things your car is covered in don't necessarily agree with what you say your values are?
Speaker: um But people aren't very receptive to saying that kind of thing. But C .T. Nyan's proposition is that that's really the only way to do it is to be available for people to be kind. And his example that he gives is.
Speaker: these two guys who've who've been they've done a lot of talks together i think they wrote a book together I i can't remember. um But one of them was. um He was actually being raised to be a... ah white supremacist leader.
Speaker: Like his family was fully in that. um He was raised to be a leader in that. I don't even want to call it a movement. I don't know what you call it. it Jonas? Um,
Speaker: So he went to college and he was doing like a radio show, weekly radio show with all of this horrible white supremacist crap and misogynist crap. And there was a Hasidic Jewish guy on campus. who I think it was like it came out that this guy was who this guy was. And he was being vilified by a lot of people, understandably. And there was a Hasidic Jewish guy who invited him over for Shabbat dinner.
Speaker: And um he went. I don't know if he went right away or if he went after a few invitations. But they slowly, slowly, slowly became friends. And then slowly, slowly, slowly, this guy started to look at his beliefs.
Speaker: and question what he'd always been told was real because he was having a weekly dinner with this Jewish guy. you know And he'd always been told all these horrible things about Jewish people.
Speaker: And it's like. I think that that is. probably the strongest, best answer, but it's also the most frustrating to people because you cannot scale it.
Speaker: Like you cannot change the minds of. I don't know how many. people voted for Trump last time, 65 million or something. I think it's 70 million, yeah. Yeah, 70 million. You can't do that at scale. you know It has to be on a relational...
Speaker: basis. um and And I've questioned too. I'm like, I don't know. I don't know that that's good enough. Like that's what I can do as a person. um When I'm talking with people around the state, I lean a lot on my background. like i My ancestors were homesteaders. My cousins still run the original homestead ranch.
Speaker: You know, I'm a fifth generation Montanan and those things get people's hackles down. Like once. Once you present those identity markers and i I hate doing it because it's so, it feels gross and it's, it's also stupid. Like. if you're not actually indigenous.
Speaker: who cares how long your family's been here, but it's a really big thing in Montana. But it does, like it allows me to have a little. Crack. in the door that's open and we talk about different things.
Speaker: um That advice from the philosopher, it's... It's frustrating because you say we can't. scale it. But on the other hand, it's also kind of relieving in that it's not our job to kind of educate or reorient. 70 million. people.
Speaker: um So it kind of just like, well, you know. You can do your own. Little part in your own passive. way And you're not responsible for. um turning this You know ocean tanker around on your own Yeah.
Speaker: Sorry, didn't expect the sun to come out. You got a blast of sunshine. I'm still waiting for mine. but Well, ah let let's let's shift to Sorted Little Stories, which is the essay I i really loved on...
Speaker: on your sub stack. So and and you talk about growing up. in poverty in Montana, but also how poverty kind of haunts you.
Speaker: throughout your adult life, even in moments of relative... security. um But I think to kind of talk about this. It would be helpful just to kind of go back a little bit. farther. And you've mentioned your... Your parents, you've mentioned how your... fifth generation Montanan, but maybe you could just describe.
Speaker: Um, the nature of your your girlhood. home, how your how your parents got there and... you know what it was like growing up there. Hey, folks, that's the end of the episode for free subscribers. If you'd like to get the whole thing, there's another whole hour. um Feel free to become a paid subscriber. Go to my sub stack, get you access to all podcasts, all essays, all that stuff.
Speaker: Thanks for listening.
Speaker: This was the Out of the Wild Podcast. Original music. by Duncan Barrett. For more episodes, subscribe to my sub stack.

