Transcript
Speaker: Oh, a spicy question. love it. Because the writing is sort of everything, right? Like you can fix plot holes, but if the writer... So some readers love that and some readers are like, but I wanted more of this. So it's kind of, it's kind of a gamble.
Speaker: Hello and welcome back to the Right and Wrong podcast. on today's episode, I am joined by a Sunday Times bestselling author, dog lover, gin drinker, and tattoo enthusiast, CJ Tudor. Hello. Hello.
Speaker: Hello. Thanks so much for coming on. Don't like that description. No, thank you having me. That's your description. I found that on your Instagram. Yes, it is. ah It is on my Instagram. You know, it's, it's, a ah it sums me up fairly well. But the only thing I missed off there is disturbingly cheery, which I got called once and I thought was really good. Well, that's nice. That's a bit of a... Disturbingly cheery was the key word there. Disturbingly. Like eerily, like like ah like a character in a horror movie that's sort of uncanny.
Speaker: Well, I'm so excited to chat with you. Thank so much for coming on. Let's start, as we always do, with your latest publication, and that is your seventh novel, Serenity Falls, which came out in September.
Speaker: Tell us a little bit about the book. Okay, um well, Serenity Falls is basically the name of the town in the book. i So it's ah this sort of supposedly perfect um town in the US in Florida. It you know its it was founded by this this much loved entrepreneur, Harold Winsome, um who who runs theme parks and makes wonderful movies and is in no way, in no way based upon anybody ah real at all who might have done those things. um And he had this idea of founding these these sort of perfect towns and communities where people could live in safety and harmony and and bring their families up. um
Speaker: And in Serenity Falls, there's that there's never been a crime in 50 years. there's There's never been a murder. But despite that, despite all this perfection, it does have quite a high mortality rate. And there are are a lot of empty houses where people have just sort of left or or disappeared.
Speaker: um So into this perfect community um come Dan and his daughter Sadie, who are moving over from the UK. after a really mysterious and surprising inheritance from Dan's mum, who um he didn't know had this house in Serenity Falls all these years that she's never told him about. You know, she she you know lived a modest lifestyle. They lived in the north of England. But she had this secret, this this lovely house in this incredible community. um And as things aren't going too great for and Sadie in the UK,
Speaker: you know Dan thinks that, you know, let's up a move and start a new life in Florida. I mean, to be fair, the house itself comes with certain conditions that people who inherit a house in Serenity Falls, they have to move and live in it for five years. They can't sell it or rent it. They have to become part of the Serenity Falls community. um so Dan's quite up for this but his daughter Sadie who's 15 is a little less impressed by the by the whole thing suffice to say she she's a bit like you know I don't want to move to Florida it's awful it's hot it's it's full of Americans it's this perfect tent is awful and twee and I just hate everything about it um and to be fair you she sort of proved right because the first thing that happens when they arrive there is they find a dead body in their swimming pool so it doesn't get off to the best start
Speaker: Okay. And then obviously things unravel from there. And things get more weird and creepy and so on from there. Yeah. Is this, I'm picturing the town is one of those ones where it seems like everything, you're saying it's a perfect town. It seems like everything's fine. All the people are like happy and i'm so welcoming and okay. Okay. Disturbingly happy. perhaps Disturbingly cheery. yeah Okay, cool. And yeah, it's such a great jumping off point to have the like secret inheritance where it's like, oh, there's this whole other life or other secret that someone close to you might have had. And now you're going to investigate and sort of like a cold case for your family and things. I love that.
Speaker: Yeah, I mean, it's sort of like Dan's like, you know, my mum basically, you know, used to recycle tea bags and and lived in this little little bungalow. And yet she has this kind of mansion in Florida, what on earth was going on. um So there's there's a lot of mystery involved there. And and obviously, the mystery of Serenity Falls itself, because, you know, quite quickly, Dan said, you start to discover that, you know, everything is not perfect here. And and there's there's a lot of strange, weird, uncanny things about Serenity Falls. You know, they have a curfew where everybody has to kind of, you know, be home by sort of 10.30. Yeah, and it's all presented in quite a reasonable way because, you know, it keeps teenagers off the street and it's good to not have, you know, have trouble and it's all about keeping things nice and, And everyone goes to sleep at a certain time and wakes at a certain time. And there's all these strange little rules that that on their own all seem quite sort of quite innocent, but start to kind of build up to be this kind of like quite claustrophobic, quite controlling sort of place. um And yeah, it kind of gets more uncanny and weird as it goes along.
Speaker: Okay, well, very cool. It's it's a great setup. ah And ah I don't i want to say any more because it sounds like the kind of thing where lots of spoilers and and and you want to kind of discover it for yourself.
Speaker: um Let's talk about the name. Look, I love a naming convention. So when I was looking through your list of novels, I couldn't help but notice that this is a break in tradition.
Speaker: I know it is, isn't it? It's because everything else has got a the in front of it. It says the Chalkman and the taking of Annie Thorne and the other people. And yeah, that that became, him that wasn't it it wasn't intentional really at the start. It was just how kind of the first sort of two to three novels panned out. Because I mean, ah not every author obviously chooses their own their own titles quite often. And i've I've always come up with the titles for my books. um the naming of the book is an important thing for me. I quite often have the name before I start writing the book. and I'm always happier when I have the name before I start writing the book because sometimes that the you know the title itself can actually just give me inspiration for a book. I'll come up with, that'd be a good title. I could write a story about that.
Speaker: So it just so happened really the first books all had a the, um and and that the names for the other books just seemed to work with a the. To be fair, um one of my other books, which became The Drift, was originally just called Drift to start with. And then kind of my agent editor went, we should put a the front of it. We should keep with the tradition and put a the in front of it.
Speaker: But yeah, Serenity Falls, it would just felt like it had it that was just had to be the title. mean, interestingly, the next book is gonna revert to a the again, But that again, it just that just happened to be the way the title that I came up with. um So Serenity Falls, yeah, it's it's it's kind of a standalone in an ocean of thes. There is no the.
Speaker: Okay. But so it's not really planned or anything like that. It just happens to be that that title made more sense. Yeah. Very few things that i do are actually sort of planned or or that cynical really. It's all quite organic. And it just seemed the title that fitted. And and yeah, my my editor and stuff like, oh, this discipline we're not going to do something sort of different. but I said make suppose it's slightly different because estimate it's not that different from all other books. There's perhaps a little bit more dark humor. It's maybe a little less dark overall. and Maybe it veers more into sort of mystery territory with a kind of an uncanny, weird, creepy edge. Whereas perhaps some of my other books have been a little darker with a little bit perhaps more more horror. but But overall, it's still a CJ Tudor book. we just We just happen to lose the the this time around.
Speaker: Yeah. Okay. um Interesting that, so you've never, you've always picked the titles. You've never like, it's never gone through process with the editor or whoever being like, oh, let's. The only book where we went through a bit of a brainstorm on titles was the second one, which was The Hiding Place. Hiding Place. Yeah, which was called The Hiding Place in the US. Hence why we ended up with two different titles actually. Because originally I think it was called something like The Residence,
Speaker: And then it was going to be called The Pit. I had a couple of different titles for it. And ah no one liked the first one. um And then The Pit, everyone thought, was a bit too horrorish. I really liked The Pit, but I was kind of downvoted on that. And we went through, oh, that that was the worst, actually We went through loads of titles. And then eventually my myself and my editor...
Speaker: Max came up with The Taking of Annie Thorne, which we both liked. But the US had already decided they wanted to go with something else. um So we ended with this stupid position of having two different titles, which still to this day, people go, I bought your book, The Hiding Place. i thought it was the only one of yours I hadn't read. And it's exactly the same as The Taking of Annie Thorne. I'm like, I yeah i't know, I know, I know. But yeah, that was the only one. All the others, pretty much the title of the book.
Speaker: um came right at the inception. ah And it was very much part of the kind of the creative process. I do prefer and I like to have a ah ah title in place. and And I know sometimes they can be working titles, but but aside from the taking of Annie Thorne, um none of them have ever changed. i Yeah, it's a thing I like to do personally. I don't really like someone else picking my title. I think picking the title is part of the author process.
Speaker: but But that yeah is maybe just me. I know sometimes titles have to change and it's one of those things. um You know, that the new book that's coming out, I was looking for titles for it. And I realized when I was sort of searching, so I always do a check to make sure there's sort of not books with the same title that might be coming out at the same time. You know, if it's been a while ago or something, then it's kind of okay. Um, cause it's very hard to find a title that's never been used before really. yeah Um, and I, I kind of had to tweak it slightly cause there was a book, um, that was pretty much coming out, came out this year or last year with the same title. Um,
Speaker: Yeah. ah but But a little bit of creative manoeuvring. And now it's a similar title, but not the same. Sure. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So you can be distinctly different. um So you mentioned, I've not heard that before. You mentioned that you often come up with a title and then you kind of build the idea around the title.
Speaker: Sometimes, sometimes the title is really important on that front for me. I mean, I normally have an idea for the book and, and the title sort of comes at the same time. Right. um But yeah, occasionally, I mean, with things like the other people, um I did have a kicking off point for a story I wanted to write, but then I also had this, I had this phrase, the other people in my head that I thought would be a good title for a book. um And kind of the two things sort of then came together.
Speaker: So, yeah, it's as soon as I'll just have a phrase or a word and then that forms part of the title and it becomes part of the idea. So it's, yeah, it's all quite an ah sort of an organic process, really. I mean, sometimes a title might be a short story title. i mean, I want to do another short story collection. I mean, maybe maybe even next year, hopefully.
Speaker: yeah And I've had the title for that in my head for ages, which was, um it's later than you think. And I was always like, yeah i'm going to use that title for my my next short story collection. It's just, it's just going sat there on the shelf waiting for me to now put the stories together. Yeah. Cause your first short story collection was a sliver of darkness. Yes. Yeah.
Speaker: Okay. Yeah. You said that not much is planned ah when it comes to your kind of the unfolding of your books. When you you, you come up with the concept and often the title comes kind of comes with that.
Speaker: Do you, is the whole process organic from that point? Are you just writing and seeing where it goes or do you plan it out before you start writing the prose? No, I never plan it. out i'm not I'm not a planner. I'm a pantser. And it's if you are someone who plans, the idea of just writing it and seeing where you go sounds absolutely horrifying to them. And to somebody who just makes it up as they they go along, like me, the idea of sitting there and tediously planning every chapter and planning the whole book from beginning to end just sounds like nightmarish to me. sounds horrific.
Speaker: I'm like, where's the joy in that? Where's the fun in that? I just, I'd hate it. So yeah, just i really I have a vague idea generally. Some books are more fully formed than others. Some books change a lot partway through.
Speaker: and The endings very often change because I'll just have an idea partway through that completely throws things and then I have to kind of rework it from the beginning. But yeah, it it is a very organic process. I start writing. I see where it goes. I normally get to a certain point. Often it's around 30,000 words. as I have what I call my vomit draft. So I'll quite often write 30,000 words or more without stopping to do any editing whatsoever. I might edit the first chapter and then that's it. because that's normally only the first or the first three chapters, because that's normally what send my agent or editor to check that they're on board with the idea.
Speaker: um And then I'll just go. And when I say a vomit draft, it really is a vomit draft. I literally don't stop for punctuation. I don't stop to worry about, you know, any typos. I often just rewrite the same sentence a few different ways. um it It just is a vomit draft that I know I will go back and make sense of, but it would, yeah, would it would horrify ah lots of people. There's a lot of red. There's a lot of red on the screen. And then I'll go back and I'll kind of knock all that into shape. And that that often involves massively rewriting it all and moving chapters around and taking huge chunks from one bit and putting them in another bit just for for the for the pacing of it. It's what I'm doing at the moment, with my current book. And then I'll sort of hit
Speaker: whatever point it is, 30, 40,000 words. um And then I'll do the same thing again for the next 30,000 words and then okay knock all into shape. The second half of the book tends to be often written in a little bit more of a structured way than the first first half because I've already got a lot of plot points in in place then. So sometimes I have to do that smaller chunks. um But yeah, that's that's kind of how I do it I like to get in the writing flow and just get all the ideas down of as much as possible. Um, and then yeah, go back and edit and knock them into place. So the first part of the process is generally pretty quick. And then the editing is, is, is the slow, painful part. Yeah.
Speaker: Yeah. Okay. Interesting. So, and I mean, seven, seven novels in a short story collection in, is that, is that process, the process that you've used since the beginning, or is that evolved over the course of your writing?
Speaker: it's pretty much the same process. Every book is slightly different. um The Drift, I wrote in a slightly different way because because because of the nature of the, you know, how the Drift is constructed. There's three separate scenarios that kind of tie up.
Speaker: um And because they were all very separate, but, but you know, did have to sort of join. I wrote them all as individual kind of stories, essentially. So I said, there was like, i was like, you know this will be 30,000 words. This 30,000 words. This will be 30,000 And then I very sort of carefully knit them all together and ah and kind of tied up all the little things within them as I knitted them together. So that was a slightly different process. And it had to be slightly more structured than than I would normally write because it was quite a complex plot.
Speaker: um And I actually wrote the ending first on that, which is very unusual because I don't normally, sometimes I don't know the ending until like, completely and definitely until halfway through. But I had a very specific ending in mind for that, that I almost came off came up with his at the same time as I came up with the idea for the book.
Speaker: And so I wrote that first. And so that was always absolutely set in stone, um which I don't always do. So they're all slightly different, but i've yeah I've never sat down there and gone, I will do this in chapter one and then this in chapter two and this in chapter three. Um, cause I just find it mind numbingly dull.
Speaker: Okay. Okay. Yeah. There's no adventure. There's no sense of risk. You gotta live on the edge. Yeah. And, and it sounds like you fully commit to the idea of like, I just need to get something on the page.
Speaker: And it doesn't matter how messy it is. And then I can, and then I can fix this. Yeah. And I know some authors who are like, they have to have every single word perfect before they can move on. Right. I am very much not because I, because I will, when I'm in the editing process, I will sometimes sit there and take two days, just knocking one chapter, one paragraph rather into place. and So if I did that from the start, I just would never get the book written. yeah So I know I have to just get a load of words there that I can play around with.
Speaker: Yeah. So much of it is about momentum. And if you just, if you can keep the momentum going, then that help. why i don't like the idea of taking too long to write books really, because I think you do lose that momentum. You've got to kind of keep in that mind space.
Speaker: Yeah, absolutely. um So we're approaching, it's almost the 10 year anniversary of your debut, The Chalkman. Oh God, craziness.
Speaker: Um, so over that kind of period of time you've published, uh, you're just, this will be your so your seventh novel that we're talking about. Yeah. 34s is the seventh. Yeah. Has the, the kind of experience and process of publishing a novel and like releasing a book out into the world, does it feel different to you now from when you first put the chalk man out?
Speaker: inevitably yes yeah it it it changes because you you start to know a little bit more about how how everything works i always say to any debut author you know really enjoy that lovely bubble between that amazing feeling of signing a deal for your book which you know quite often as a debut author but you know it sounds like you've just written a book and got a deal with most debut authors you know and like myself, have taken a long, long time to get to that point. They've got lots of failed projects and rejections and perhaps you know years of work behind them. So that amazing feeling of getting a publishing deal finally. And then all the exciting stuff that you get with a debut, like you know meeting with editors and and and publishers and talking you about covers. And it's it's so exciting and and brilliant and yeah you know all the things you've ever dreamed of. getting that book out there.
Speaker: it's It's a lovely, lovely bubble. um and And I think you just really, really got to enjoy that bit, because you kind of never get that again. um Anything seems possible in that bubble, you know, you can you can you can imagine that, you know, you all these wonderful things for your book, and it's it's quite easy to get carried away. And often, you know, the reality can be a little bit coming down to earth. But I would say just enjoy that wonderful debut bubble because you'll never get that much attention again because debuts just do. They just do get all the attention. You're given to such a lot of lovely things as a debut author. You get lots of attention. You tend to get more publicity, more promotion. um And it's it's just a really nice bubble to be in um for that first book. And then that's where the hard work starts because suddenly, you know, you've had, you know, all this time to write that first book, you get all that lovely attention and hopefully the book goes out there and hopefully it does well.
Speaker: But even so you have to be knuckling down and writing the next book. um And that is really where the hard work starts because you will never get all that attention again. It's almost like, and I'm not, i don't want to sound like I'm criticizing publishers because I have amazing publishers. They're so good. um But everything does get thrown at the debut. And then it's very much like it's up to you because you're never going to get that marketing, that promotion, et cetera, again. So you really have to knuckle down and put in the hard work. And, and you know, you really have to be working on your book while you're in that lovely bubble. You need to be working on the next book. You can't rest on your laurels. You need to have that read next book ready to go. And I think that can be intimidating for a lot of authors. You've had all the time in the world to write that debut and make it as good as you want it to be. And suddenly you've got a year and you need to turn around the next book. um and there's a lot of expectation and you don't get all the promotion in the marketing and so on for your second book it's it's a lot more on you you know because you know as well as writing the book you need to be marketing that book you need to be getting people excited about the next book um and and second novels are a bit of a a poison chalice for a lot of people um you know if if your first book doesn't do great um then you know you you you won't get as much attention and and sort of
Speaker: push behind the second one. If your first book does well, there's a lot of expectation on what the second one is going to be. You're damned if you do, damned if you don't. Because if you do the same thing, people criticize you for doing something the same. if you do something different, people moan because different to the book that they liked. So I think the second book's really tricky.
Speaker: um And if you get through that unscathed, then you you should be working on the third book if you're lucky enough to get your next publishing deal because you tend to get two book deals. So there's always that little voice in the back of your head. Oh, my God, I want to, you know, God, I hope I get a second, you know, my next deal. um I was fortunate. I got signed quite quickly for the next, you know, for books three and four. um But it's it's kind of scary. It's uncertain. And there's a lot of pressure. um which you you don't know or realize or understand before you you get into it. And it's you know it's amazing because you're doing what you love. And I was particularly fortunate that you know The Chalkman enabled me to write full-time and become a full-time author. That's not true for all authors because you know depending on sort of advances and many other things, um it's not always possible. A lot of authors have to have another job. um
Speaker: So yeah, you learn them a lot more about it as you get into it. um And there is pressure. And there are lots of things you didn't know about the industry that you do know once you've you've published a few books, like how much is out of your control. You know, you can write the best book in the world. And if it publishes on the wrong week or you don't get the promotion or the marketing, um yeah you know, it it it won't sell. um So there's lots of things you learn. um I absolutely love the fact that, i you know, I love what I do. I love writing. I love making up stuff for a living.
Speaker: But it's been a huge learning curve because I had no prior knowledge of the publishing industry at all. um So it's it's been a massive learning curve. And I'm still learning, you know, certainly I'm still learning with writing. learning with With writing, there's never a point you get to and go, yeah, that's it. I'm done now. Brilliant. Yeah.
Speaker: sorted out don't get you better than this ah because you know you're ah you're always so self-critical but yeah it's it's an interesting and fascinating journey and it's it's been yeah it's been really good I've been very very lucky and fortunate to sort of be here seven books eight years on really yeah and have a good audience and you know sell a decent amount of books Yeah.
Speaker: Yeah. I mean, yeah that's all, that's all true. And it's it's nice to hear it sort of candidly laid out. Um, we're going to get into your kind of publishing origins and how you got a foot in the door in a minute, but right now we are at the point in the episode where I ask you, CJ, if you were snowed in at a cozy woodland cabin in the middle of nowhere, which book would you hope to have with you?
Speaker: Well, you asked me, Stan, I hadn't pre-prepared this because I'd not realised this bit. And the first book that sprung into mind, which I always say is one of my favourite winter reads, was The Shining.
Speaker: like okay yeah I know it's not particularly cozy, but I just just think there's not a better book if you love if you love horror, if you love Stephen King, even if you don't, to read in a real in a snowy setting in winter. I think it's just it's just the perfect book because it's you know it is obviously set in this weird, creepy old hotel, The Overlook, um and you know snowed in in wintertime. And it's one of my favorite winter books. I like i do like to reread it around wintertime. I'm not always fortunate enough to get snow here. So a snowy cabin with no one around and a big old chunky creepy book sent it set in a deserted haunted hotel with no one around. Seems perfect to me. And then you can kind of slowly go insane, you know, with Jack in the book. Oh, perfect. As you start stalking around your cabin going, all work and no play. yeah ah Yeah. That seems like a perfect wintry snowy cabin read to me.
Speaker: that's Yeah, it's a good one. And it's funny because you said that it it doesn't seem cozy, but I think there is this sort of growing movement of um horror as a cozy thing. Like when it yeah gets cold outside and wet outside and you kind of a all warm inside and you you like watch a horror movie or read a horror book. Yes, absolutely. And as you know, mean, it's longstanding tradition, isn't it? Because, yeah you know, ghost stories were always traditionally told sort of around Christmas time and in winter, you know? so I think there is this tradition of of reading scary stories and and cuddling up under a blanket with the fire and being a bit scared that works really well. Watching horror movies on a summer's evening isn't quite the same, is it? No. Same thing for a scary book, maybe.
Speaker: Yeah. Yeah. There is something about... Yeah, being cozy and weirdly being tired. Maybe it's because you're cozy. You're like, well, I have more bandwidth now to to be scared. Yeah, yeah.
Speaker: ah You don't want to be like hot and sweaty and like slightly uncomfortable. and then No, it doesnt it doesn't work. No. yeah it ah Doesn't mesh. um Okay, cool. With The Shining, that's a great a great book to take along there. um Next up, we are going to talk a little bit about the TV adaptation, and then we're going to get into what we were just talking about. We'll talk about how CJ first started writing, um getting into the industry, literary agents, all of that stuff that led up to publishing her first novel and then publishing six more after that.
Speaker: That will all be in the extended episode, available at patreon.com forward slash right and wrong. So the publishers now are looking for something different from that, most probably. You will always be behind the curve. And also, you know, you're not writing what you love.
Speaker: Create a new genre, create a new, you know, must this this is the new thing. Don't don't try and copy what other other bestsellers have done. Write something you love. and and create a trend rather than try and follow the trend.
Speaker: Yes, that's great advice. I like the the idea of thinking, yeah, an idea of creating a trend instead of following one. That's ah great advice and and a lovely sentiment to end the episode on. Thank you so much, CJ, for coming on and chatting with me, telling us all about your writing and publishing ah adventures. It's been so fun chatting with you.
Speaker: Yeah, thank you. Thank you for listening to me ramble on. No, it's been great. I love all. For everyone listening, Serenity Falls, which is CJ's seventh novel, is is out right now in all the usual places. You can go and find it. And if you want to keep up with what CJ is doing, you can find her on Twitter at CJTudor, on Instagram at CJTudorAuthor, or on Facebook at CJTudorOfficial.
Speaker: To support this podcast, like, follow, and subscribe. Join the Patreon for ad-free extended episodes and check out my other podcasts, The Chosen Ones and Other Tropes. Thanks again to CJ and thanks to everyone listening. We will catch you on the next episode.






