Zencastr
00:00:00
00:00:01
Speed1x
Format▸
Share
Embed
Report

Episode 9: Use forests wisely

Branching out
Branching out

0 plays · Nov 16, 2026

Transcript

Speaker: Maybe I should start by saying that forests influence climate and therefore also climate change very, very much and in many ways. Unfortunately, these mechanisms are quite complex and therefore difficult to understand as well.

Speaker: Hello everyone, I'm your host Gerda Wolfram from the International Union of Forest Research Organizations, IUFRO, the global network for forest science collaboration. You're listening to the ninth episode of season three of Branching Out, the forest podcast.

Speaker: It's great to have you with us as we explore more forest science. In this season, we will find out how scientists in Iufro work across disciplines to tackle emerging topics.

Speaker: This work takes place in our 13 task forces. In our previous episode, we heard about post-conflict forest landscape restoration, and in this episode, we will discuss about the role of forest and climate change mitigation, and specifically about the interaction and synergy of carbon-3s, sink, storage and substitution, in forest value chains.

Speaker: Let me welcome my co-host Minseol Lim from the International Forestry Students Association and currently an intern at IUFRO headquarters. Thanks for being a co-host for this episode, Minseol.

Speaker: Could you briefly introduce yourself? Hello, my name is Minseol Lim. I've just completed my bachelor's degree in forestry environmental system with a double major in climate big data at Kungmin University in South Korea.

Speaker: And now, as an IFSA member, i am doing an internship at EUFRO headquarters in Vienna. I am passionate about learning forest and bridging it with science, so I am really looking forward to today's conversation on forest carbon.

Speaker: Thank you and a warm welcome to Branching Out, Minseo, and welcome to our guests, Shulrong Wu and Marko Lariyavara. Shulrong and Marko are co-leads of the IUPRA Task Force and they investigate how the three forest carbon functions, sink, storage and substitution, can be combined most effectively to maximize climate benefits.

Speaker: We're happy to have you with us for this podcast episode.

Speaker: May I first ask you, Xuerong, to briefly introduce yourself? What is your affiliation, your academic background, your main research focus, and your role in IUFRO? Thank you, Gerder.

Speaker: I'm Xuerong Wu, a professor at the Research Institute of Forest Policy and Information, Chinese Academy of Forestry located in Beijing.

Speaker: My research focuses on carbon markets, valuation of and payment for forest ecosystem services, multipurpose forest management and forest policy and governance.

Speaker: In UFU, I serve as a board member and coordinator of this task of force. I'm also coordinator of UFU working group,

Speaker: ah line point 4.2 on valuation of existing services and the carbon markets, and deputy coordinator of research group on forest resources economics.

Speaker: In this task of force, we coordinate an in interdisciplinary team of around 40 members from 16 countries across several youthful divisions, as well as partners from non- youthful institutions.

Speaker: Thank you, Shiron. What an impressive career. Now it's my turn to ask Margu. What is your career path? Where does your main research interest lie? And how are you involved in your flow?

Speaker: Thank you very much for the invitation, Gerda and Ninshio. The Finnish pronunciation of my full name is Markku Larjavaa. I'm currently an associate Associate Professor at the Department of Forest Sciences of the University of Helsinki in Finland.

Speaker: And I have studied all my degrees in this same place. That in between, I have been working in many other places in other countries as well. Panama, Burkina Faso, China, Singapore and also Malaysia.

Speaker: During some of these periods, I have worked in development aid, both in a company and in an intergovernmental organization. But I have spent most of my career doing research on how trees grow and develop, on silviculture,

Speaker: and on climate change mitigation related to forests and other land use. Actually, I don't have much experience with EUFRO yet. I have attended a few thematic conferences under the EUFRO umbrella over the years.

Speaker: And also two years ago, i was in the World Congress in in Sweden. And I haven't held any responsibilities with EUFRO before.

Speaker: So I was very pleased and grateful when Shui-Rong invited me to serve as deputy coordinator of our task force. Thank you, Sih-Rung and Marku. It's great to have you with us.

Speaker: In your task force, you focus on the critical role that forests and forest products play in mitigating climate change through the removal of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere.

Speaker: Carbon dioxide is and a greenhouse gas that is released into the atmosphere in a large context through human activities and is a major driver of global warming.

Speaker: Marko, let us start with the forest. How do forests influence climate change? Maybe I should start by saying that forests influence climate and therefore also climate change very, very much and in many ways. Unfortunately, these mechanisms are quite complex and therefore difficult to understand as well.

Speaker: If we just focus on carbon in forest ecosystems, the two basic approaches are either to think of the pools of carbon in the forest or fluxes of carbon between these pools.

Speaker: Actually, both of these two approaches should lead to the same conclusions if assumptions are the same, but often They are not the same, and then those people focusing on pools may not understand how the flux people think and the other way around.

Speaker: I would say that when the attention is on forest ecosystems only, it's easier to figure out the mechanisms by focusing on pools and not on fluxes.

Speaker: The basic logic is then ah that as about half of the biomass of trees is element carbon, and this carbon could alternatively be in the atmosphere in the form of carbon dioxide.

Speaker: So the more there is biomass in the forest, the better it is as carbon dioxide is the most significant greenhouse gas warming our planet, like you said, Misha.

Speaker: Thinking of the fluxes of carbon from one pool to another is slightly more complicated. If there is a net flux of carbon to a forest, or in other words, the forest carbon pool is becoming larger, the forest is then called a carbon on sink.

Speaker: A steady state natural forest is not a sink, even though it can be very important for climate change mitigation, as its deforestation could be very harmful.

Speaker: So actually saying that the forest being a sink is a good thing and a source of carbon is a bad thing is a simplification in which the point of comparison is not clearly defined. A steady state natural forest is good for climate change mitigation if the alternative is deforestation and an extreme source of carbon.

Speaker: In a similar way, a modest sink can actually be bad for climate if the alternative is a faster sink, which is then better for climate.

Speaker: Normally, it's important to be clear about the alternative scenario to which the comparison is done. Natural forests are often quite far from being steady state forests.

Speaker: If natural forests are recovering from a recent natural disturbance such as forest fire, they can be important things. Similarly, planted forests are typically strong sinks as the biomass in the living trees is increasing rapidly.

Speaker: Typically, especially after a fire, there is simultaneous carbon accumulation in the soil as well, strengthening the sink of the whole forest ecosystem.

Speaker: These things can be very important. Global mean carbon dioxide emissions per person are about 5 tons per year, and that corresponds to some 1.3 tons of element carbon, as in carbon dioxide there is also oxygen.

Speaker: This number can be compared to a hectare of forest with relatively large trees having perhaps some 100 tons of carbon per hectare. If a person managing for example 100 hectares would take some action to increase the carbon pool by 10%, she could offset with this action annual emissions of nearly 800 people.

Speaker: A direct comparison of these numbers can be misleading as an intentional increase of forest carbon pool increases, it influences only the coming decades while avoiding emissions from fossil fuels has impacts for millions of years.

Speaker: Therefore, for precise comparisons, decisions on the importance of near future relative to distant future must be made, and those will influence the results very much.

Speaker: Thank you, Markku. Thank you for explaining, first of all, the basic terminology of what is a pool, what is a sink, what do we do when we think about fluxes and who understands what and how. And also ah for explaining or highlighting that we need to be careful when comparing emissions with the potential of forests to offset them, as we are often talking of different timeframes.

Speaker: Now, Shurong, we have just heard from Markku about the forest carbon pools and sinks. The task force, however, talks about three s So in addition to the S for carbon sink, there are two more S's, one for storage and one for substitution.

Speaker: Can you tell us more about how forest products and substitution effects influence climate change? Thank you, Goddard. Mark Kuhn has explained they forced the first carbon pool.

Speaker: The 3S framework follows carbon along the value chain. The first S is the sink. Forests remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and store it in biomass and soils.

Speaker: The second S is storage. When wood or bamboo is harvested, part of dead carbon remains locked in long-lived products such as construction timber, furniture, and engineered wood products.

Speaker: The third S is substitution. These renewable materials can replace steel, cement, and fossil-based plastics, and thereby avoid emissions in other sectors.

Speaker: But I would like to stress one point. Renewable does not automatically mean low carbon. The late substitution benefit depends on the whole life cycle, where the raw materials come from, how much energy is used in processing, transport, product lifetime, recycling, and end-of-life treatment.

Speaker: and on a clear baseline for the product being replaced. So the 3S are not three isolated numbers, they are a continuous chain of climate benefits from forest to product to society.

Speaker: So it's not just about the material, but the whole life cycle behind it. Now, we have learned more about the 3S, the sink, the storage, and the substitution, and their potential to mitigate climate change.

Speaker: How can we best use and boost the potential? Marco, let's get back to the forest. What can be done in forests to increase the capacity of climate change mitigation?

Speaker: Thanks for the question, a difficult one. To know what should be done to mitigate climate change is not easy. I have been going with first-year forest science students at at my university, University of Helsinki, to a border of an old trout forest with very large pine and spruces, maybe 400 years old or so, the oldest ones.

Speaker: and a mid-aged, maybe 40-year-old pine plantation. I have been then asking the students to point which of these forests is better for wood production.

Speaker: Typically, they all point correctly to the planted stand as the protected area does not produce any wood. then I have asked which is better for biodiversity.

Speaker: And they all point to the old growth forest as it may hide quite many endangered species. When I have asked which is better for climate change mitigation, some have pointed to the planted forest and others to the natural one.

Speaker: And again, they have been in a way right. As the correct answer depends on the timescale and many other assumptions, which I did not openly state.

Speaker: So with some certain assumptions, both answers are correct. If only the first S in our task force is considered, it's clear that the more there is carbon in the forest ecosystem, the better it is.

Speaker: However, with storage in the wood products and substitution, things get complicated. Typically still, the old growth is better in the timescales that are normally used in these calculations.

Speaker: That it's unclear. But what is very clear, however, is that more wood produced without decreasing forest carbon pool or greater forest carbon pool without decreasing the amount of wood produced both mitigate climate change. Thank you, Marco. This is indeed an excellent and easy to understand way of raising awareness on the complex interconnectedness of the three S's and of needing to understand the assumptions and the time scales.

Speaker: So, Marco, if boosting wood production or carbon storage in the forest without influencing the other is beneficial, what are the ways to do this? yeah well Much of our silviculture or forest management has been designed mainly on or almost purely for wood production. However, often a large range of solutions are roughly equally good for production, but they could be very different for climate.

Speaker: For example, lengthening or shortening the rotation period probably influences only little wood production, but lengthening could significantly boost carbon pools.

Speaker: There could also be more innovative approaches, because individual trees consume less energy per unit carbon stored, the larger they are. A few dozen huge individuals per hectare could store plenty of carbon but shade smaller trees only little.

Speaker: Then, in a way, some trees in this planted forest could serve more ah for the wood production while others would be mainly there for carbon.

Speaker: In the global scale, things get very exciting. Trees grow very fast in the hot equatorial tropics. But the very largest biomass, these antolestries, are not found in these climates, but in temperate maritime climates, just just like in northwestern California and the Pacific Northwest in North America.

Speaker: Therefore, if globally wood production and carbon storage to mitigate climate change are optimized, storage in the forests I mean, not in the wood products, the distribution of plantations and natural forests would be very different than what it is currently.

Speaker: that really highlights the potential of more diversified forest management. Then finally, Marco, can you briefly highlight the differences between planted forests and natural forests in this context?

Speaker: Can you perhaps give examples from different parts of the world? Well, planted and natural forests are totally different when thinking of wood production or biodiversity.

Speaker: Like our first year students already knew when they were pointing in the right direction, that they are much more similar for climate change mitigation. In planted forests, maximal biomasses may be quite close to the biomasses of old-growth natural forests,

Speaker: and The big difference is that the planted trees are normally logged way before they reach their maximum size. But in some parts of the world, there are forgotten plantations.

Speaker: Actually, in most countries forested countries of the world. And these forgotten plantations, if they have not been logged for a long time, they might have huge trees and similar biomasses as old-growth natural forests.

Speaker: Well, thinking of natural forests, by definition, human impact has been small and it will remain small if the forest will remain natural also in the future.

Speaker: But still, there could be ways to keep them natural and make them suck more carbon. We could, for example, fertilize them or cut woody climbers in the tropical forests to boost the growth and size of the largest trees.

Speaker: However, I do not think that this is wanted by the people in these forested areas or globally, as many would even say that these fertilized forests would not be natural anymore.

Speaker: Maybe a more acceptable way would be to fight natural disturbances such as forest fires, which lower ah carbon pools of these forests.

Speaker: And this is already done, orex even in the remote parts of our circum boreal forests in Russia, Canada, Alaska, forest fighting is is is conducted.

Speaker: I would say that the best way to use natural forests to fight climate change is simply to let them remain forests, so to battle deforestation.

Speaker: Forest areas area is quite bad metric in climate change mitigation. If we are in a hurry, if forests are shifting from one place to another, another there will be young forests in this new forested area and it will contain much less harbour.

Speaker: Well, my main takeaway here is that there is a need to hold deforestation in the first place, and that forests' cover alone doesn't give any accurate picture of the climate change mitigation potential of a forest.

Speaker: Marco explained about what we can do in the forest and why this is important. But besides forests, however, the task force has a broader scope, as it aims to connect the 3S, the sink, storage and substitution effects across forest value chains.

Speaker: So Zhurong, we have not yet talked a lot about the value chain and substitution effects. Can you tell us what can be done in these fields to mitigate climate change? Can you perhaps underpin this with examples?

Speaker: So far, several actions can be taken along the value chain. First, maintain the forest sink through sustainable forest management, restoration and quality improvement.

Speaker: Second, prioritize long-leaved wood and bamboo products and cascading use. Use wood first for materials, then reuse and recycle, and recover energy only after material use.

Speaker: Third, design products for durability and circularity. Fourth, use lifecycle assessment, carbon footprint, green procurement, green finance, and certification to make climate performance visible.

Speaker: Fifth, collect carbon markets and downstream value back to upstream forest protection and sustainable management. Let me give examples from different continents.

Speaker: In China, forest coverage has reached 25.09% and a forest stock about 21 billion cubic meters.

Speaker: So the focus now is shifting from area expansion to quality improvement and sustainable use. Bamboo and wood construction are important bio-based value chains.

Speaker: A national study using about more than 400,000 permanent forest inventory plots suggests that existing forests could contribute around 70% of the simulated biomass carbon sink to the year 2100, and optimized management could add further carbon storage in forests and wood products.

Speaker: In Europe, engineered wood and cross-laminated timber buildings provide well-documented examples of long-lived storage and substitution, but the lead benefit still depends on sustainable sourcing and lifecycle performance.

Speaker: In Africa, especially in Kenya, restoration and the community-based tree growing can supply sustainable wood while supporting livelihoods, but we must avoid unsustainable wood-filled use and leakage.

Speaker: So the lesson is, there is no one-size-fits-all solution. We need continent-specific value chains and safeguards. That's a great overview, especially how the approaches differ across regions.

Speaker: Shiroong, the task force is advocating for a holistic approach and highlighting the synergies of the three S. What are the main challenges of connecting these three S?

Speaker: Well, the main challenge is that the 3S are often studied and governed in silos. Forest ecologists and civiculturists focus on the forest sink.

Speaker: Forest broadcast researchers focus on store storage and a substitution. Economists and policy researchers focus on incentives, markets, and governments, but the climate benefits cross these boundaries.

Speaker: Second, the accounting logic is different. Sink, storage, and substitution operate at different timescales and with different boundaries.

Speaker: We can't simply add them together. When carbon markets are involved, we must deal carefully with the baseline, the additionality, leakage, and double counting.

Speaker: Third, data along the value chain are still fragmented. It is not easy to track carbon from the forest to the product through use, reuse, recycling, and final disposal.

Speaker: Fourth, there are trade-offs. Maximizing 1S may affect biodiversity, soil, water, or long-term forest stability.

Speaker: Fifth, policies and incentives are fragmented across forestry, industry, energy, construction, and finance. So the real challenge is to build a common language, consistent system boundaries, and cross-sector cooperation.

Speaker: That sounds like quite a range of challenges, and they somehow all seem connected. Then, Xirong, how does the task force address these challenges? What do you do specifically contribute to building the synergy of forest-based carbon 3S?

Speaker: Are there any task force activities that you would like to highlight? Our task force addresses these challenges by collecting research, policy, and practice across the whole region.

Speaker: As I mentioned, we have around 40 members from 16 countries with three working structures, an advisory board, working group one, enforced by economy and a carbon markets.

Speaker: Working Group 2 on Forest the Ecology and Management and an Early Career Scientist Chapter. I coordinate the task force and lead the need they are Working a Group 1.

Speaker: Our activities include regular weblas, annual all-hands meetings, A technical session of forest carbon and a natural-based climate solutions at an international event held in Beijing in September this year, with more than 150 participants in person, and a special issue 2026 in forests, the forests.

Speaker: We are planning a science policy meeting in 2027 and session at the UFO Regular Congress in Edmondon in 2027.

Speaker: We will also bring the results to the UFO World Congress in Kenya in the year 2029 and produce a final report and a policy brief.

Speaker: We are collecting material carbon flow data, promoting science-based tools, and supporting carbon trading schemes that enhance the 3S while considering co-benefits such as biodiversity.

Speaker: We also work with partners such as the geolot forest and carbon footprint and carbon balance and management. So the task of force is a platform to align measures, exchange evidence and communicate the 3S to a wider audience.

Speaker: Thank you, Xiu Rong. This is an impressive list of activities and we look forward to seeing outcomes at the upcoming major events that you just mentioned. Now, before we wrap up, can I ask all of you for a concise key message?

Speaker: And Marco, could I ask you first, what would you like our listeners to remember from this talk? Well, I would first repeat what I said in the very beginning, that forests are very important for climate change mitigation.

Speaker: My second key message would be that whether it's better to focus on increasing carbon in forest ecosystems or producing a lot of wood depends on the assumptions and time horizon.

Speaker: If we are in a hurry with a climate change mitigation, typically better is to focus on increasing carbon in our existing forests and of course protect most of the high biomass forests of the world.

Speaker: but This is not a key message, but I would want also want to advertise my book on these and other topics, which came out earlier this year entitled Trees and Forests of the World, Why They Matter to Us, published by Oxford University Press.

Speaker: That's all imp important key messages, and thanks for the book recommendation. Now it's Shui-Rong's turn. Can you give us your key takeaway, please? Well, my key takeaway in this is forests are more than a carbon sink.

Speaker: They are a renewable carbon system. We will not solve climate change by maximizing one single indicator. We need to cut emissions in all sectors first, and then use forest wisely, protect and restore the sink, store carbon in non-leaved products, substitute where it generally reduces emissions and account for the whole value chain with safe gas for biodiversity and sustainable forest management.

Speaker: In short, we need to move from carbon sink to carbon flow. from single target management to to system optimization, and from fragmented governance to the whole value chain corporation.

Speaker: That is how the 3S can deliver real and lasting climate benefits. Thank you, Shurong. So I understand there is never a one-size-fits-all solution to complex issues, and the interlinkage of the 3S, the sink, the storage and substitution, is such a very complex issue.

Speaker: And also, while we aim to maximize carbon benefits across the entire forest value chain within reasonable boundaries, we should also strive to minimize emissions in all sectors.

Speaker: And of course, we would like to hear from you, Minseo. What main learning or message would you like to share, perhaps also from the youth perspective? I think my main takeaway is that forests offer many opportunities to address climate change.

Speaker: But how we manage them really matters, and the right approach can look very different from one region to another. As young people, we often think about the future consequences of today's decisions.

Speaker: So it's important to look beyond short-term benefits and consider the long-term role of forests, both for climate mitigation and for future generations.

Speaker: Thank you, Minso. And thank you, Shurong and Marku, for these important and inspiring messages and the conversation on the role of forests and the forest value chain in climate change mitigation.

Speaker: through the 3S. And thank you to our listeners for joining us. Look out for our next Branching Out episode, where we'll explore the Precision Pest Management or PPM-enforced ecosystems, the topic of another EUFRO task force.

Speaker: And if you want to know more about our EUFRO, follow us on social media or click on the show notes. And until next time, goodbye.

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Recommended