Transcript
Speaker: Oh, AC and Evers right off the top here. Merely want to say thank you. This the season for being part of this podcast community. Thanks for listening. Thanks for making this little show a little part of your life.
Speaker: Oh, and also, has been dropping the ball lately with respect to the paperback of the Front Runner, which came out on November 3rd. It's out now. It's only $18.99, and it is pliable and weighs only 9.3 ounces, and it's 5 1⁄4 inches by 8 inches long. Too big for a back pocket, but it's still pretty small. It's still pretty cool.
Speaker: If that doesn't sell the book, I don't know what will, ah but maybe this will. Turns out your mom loved it. And a book can be more dynamic than an author, and an author can be more dynamic than their book.
Speaker: Oh, hey, CNFers. These mom jokes are probably costing me significant listenership because who wants such sophomoric humor in their podcast feed? This is a serious place for serious people, and writing is a serious art.
Speaker: It's creative nonfiction podcast, a show where I speak to tellers of true tales about the true tales they tell and the art and craft of true stories. I'm Brendan Amara, author of your mom's favorite book, The Front Runner. I'm sorry.
Speaker: I'm sorry. No more of that. I'm recording this nearly two weeks ahead of its pub date, which means i won't have any updates with respect to my trip east to see certain Trump-supporting family members and my mom transitioning to hospice care. Not gonna, like, not gonna die in three days, hospice care, but you know, the final chapter of a pretty sad book. had an uncle I quite like pass away the last week. So lots of death, man.
Speaker: How do we cope? How will we cope? How will we have coped by the time you listen to this? David Naaman is here.
Speaker: You know him as the host of the long-running Between the Covers podcast. In my original script, shit you not, I was like, the host of the Between the Sheets podcast. hi oh You could say that. Me, him, Brad Listie, maybe Joanne Penn.
Speaker: ah Joanna Penn? Maybe I should look that up. Hold on. Let's look let's look that up. Jo-an-pen? Joanna Penn. Okay. Good thing I looked that up.
Speaker: Are some of the longest tenured bozos in the literary podcast sphere. You don't even want to know what's happening in 2027, man. My life burns faster era is going to be fire.
Speaker: It's already happening. im mar I am ready. i am all ready to execute. Life burns faster. David's latest book here is Ursula K. Le Guin with David Naaman, Conversations on Writing. It's published by Zando, which owns Tin House.
Speaker: And everybody loves them some Tin House. It is dubbed the definitive collection of reflections on writing with Ursula K. Le Guin. I've never read Le Guin. I know. Show notes of this episode and more at brendanamara.com. Hey, hey. There you can search the vast archive of the podcast as well as peruse for hot blogs just as nature intended.
Speaker: You can also sign up for the wicked hot pitch club at welcome to pitch club at substack.com or the rage against the algorithm newsletter for tasty riffs, four book wrecks and seven juicy links. It literally goes up to 11.
Speaker: Make 10 louder and make 10 be the top number and make that a little louder.
Speaker: These go to 11. Now, David Neiman got me talking a bit in this episode, which means I deleted a whole lot. But it's no wonder he's a master at the long form conversation for getting someone a knucklehead like me so comfy to talk.
Speaker: Naturally, I deleted it. Many of his podcasts run about three hours long, which um is robust. It's a robust asking. When I book people for this podcast and I ask for an hour, some of them are like, can you do 45? They kind of roll their fucking eyes and I'm like, fuck, but but why why do we have to talk for an hour?
Speaker: I remember having the late Tracy Kidder on the show and we hit about 40 minutes and he was like, how much longer is this going to be? I think people's patience for me stops around 40 to 45 minutes. 45, maybe 60. Not so with David.
Speaker: That says something. If someone is willing to spend three hours with you, that tells you everything you need to know about the person. So, Between the Covers is a celebrated literary podcast hosted by, of course, David.
Speaker: Known worldwide for its generous and in-depth conversations with today's most vital thinkers. The podcast has garnered international praise in The Guardian, The Financial Times, and Electric Literature for its incredible and in-depth conversations. In partnership with Milkweed Editions, Between the Covers continues its mission to create space for immersive literary conversations that illuminate the complexities of contemporary writing. Oh, get a load of this. So if you email David thinking you're going to come on the show, this will check this out. Okay.
Speaker: Hold on. And you will get ah an auto reply. this is crazy. Watch this. All right. I am currently full through 2028. Okay.
Speaker: I'm nevertheless keeping a list of book and authors to consider for unanticipated gaps, which do happen, and I will definitely reach out if I'm interested and am able to move forward with an interview.
Speaker: Wild. At the moment, slots are full through 2028. i don't even know how that's possible. Isn't that crazy? don't even bother. don't even bother.
Speaker: just don't even bother ah His work has appeared in Orion, Agni, AGNI, I don't know, Fourth Genre, Boulevard, Tin House, and more. He has received a Pushcart Prize and has been reprinted in Best American Science in Nature Writing, Best Spiritual Literature, and the Best Small Fictions. I mentioned I haven't read Le Guin at all. Don't at me, man. But in this conversation, David talks about how he sees his podcast roster as an ecosystem, how he's changed as a host, why he only does two per month, The power of the Jory Graham episode of Between the Covers from 2021.
Speaker: Getting a PhD in Le Guin. Learning about Le Guin in cartography. What he still learns from her. Being a writer in progress. And a whole lot more. Fun stuff, really. And you might want to pair this episode with Brad Listie's appearance and any of Debbie Millman's appearances on the show. Parting shot on grit, or a lack thereof. But now, let's cue up that riffy montage.
Speaker: Huh.
Speaker: Beginnings are the worst. Oh my God, I'm such a poser. Get this thing that's like a kick in the nuts. And I take orders from my friends and, hey, I'm going down to the Walmart. What do you need Run into a fucking wall. Excuse me. It's going to have to interest somebody somewhere other than me.
Speaker: bringing you back to the microphone to have these kind of conversations?
Speaker: Well, I think it's mainly learning. Learning new things is is a huge part of it. I didn't study English in school. I didn't study history in school. And so in a weird way, some of the interviews I get most excited about Of course, their literary interviews are ones where I'm learning about a topic I know nothing about. So if I have like a Kurdish poet on and I'm reading about the history of Kurdistan and Kurdish poetics, or it could be something entirely political, like about...
Speaker: what happened in Haiti and the indemnity in Haiti in relationship to a novel. I really love that. I think if I'd hit some sort of hard horizon around learning new things, that I probably still wouldn't be doing it. And then the other part is just getting feedback from listeners about how a certain conversation was really important or sort of served as a place of solace or ah or a place, a stepping stone towards something in their own writing or in coping with what's going on in their life.
Speaker: But there's also just the self part where I'm like, okay, I want to be, i want to feel like I'm not having 24 conversations a year that all feel really known before I have them. I want to, I want a sense of discovery. Yeah. So does that mean like you might do some cursory research, but you leave yourself open to surprise and like you said, discovery mid conversation?
Speaker: Yeah, I mean, there's a lot of discovery before conversation. i think there's always discovery inherent in the encounter, right? And like there's not a it not a direct parallel between the way you experience a book and the way you experience an author.
Speaker: And a book can be more dynamic than an author and an author can be more dynamic than their book. Yeah. and So there's always discovery in those gaps between the way somebody talks about or is able to talk about their work and accompany their work into the world versus the work itself. It's ah when you're deciding on how to yeah curate who you have on the show. Like what is some of the yeah know the the thinking behind who you who you select? Because you're you're booked out pretty far. So I imagine you're you're really thinking about the decisions you need to make.
Speaker: Well, I do try to think about it as an ecosystem in a given year. And I think at the beginning, pretty early on, maybe in the second or third year, i started also using, it doesn't exist anymore, but the Vita, do you know the Vita count?
Speaker: that used to exist. Oh, It was an organization that counted how many women were published in a given magazine. So um you could look at, say, like Harper's or the London Review of Books where they had really bad scores. like Let's say, I'm going to make this up so let's say they had but it's probably in the ballpark, 85% of the people they published in a given year were men.
Speaker: And then they also looked at... what works were reviewed regardless of whether they were reviewed by men or women. And so I sort of started that as ah as a first metric independent of like what books am I interested in talking to? Because in my experience, i havent there's an overabundance of potential people I would be interested in talking to. There isn't a scarcity. I wanted to start paying attention to gender on the show and making sure there was a good gender balance to sort of do the Vita count on my own show.
Speaker: And that led to more and more, like in terms of the ecosystem of a given year, I'm balancing the genres, poetry, fiction, nonfiction.
Speaker: Like you, i want to balance between poetry, high profile and debut and also small press and big press. More recently, since the show went remote, because ah before 2020, it was in person only, I've been trying to have between 30 and 50% of the authors be non-Americans.
Speaker: So there's just been a ton of different ones. It's always imperfect, insufficient, and and under correction. And years that are correcting from past years. like It's always a sense of just reevaluating.
Speaker: how to balance it. And then also, honestly, like part of it could be political too. Like I've been trying in the last three or four years, given the political climate to center more Muslim, Arab and trans writers yeah than I had before.
Speaker: And that's partially just a response to what's going on in the world. And of course, then there's the actual literary part, right? Like this is all demographic, ah curatorial, which I think has a political aspect to it. But of course, I want to pick writers where I'm hoping I'm going to love the book, but also writers that I could imagine having good conversations with if I didn't like the book. Yeah.
Speaker: Yeah, same with the sort of the gender disparity too. I noticed early on that a lot of... i remember you know Brian Compliments the moment comes to mind. I did it like a gender audit on his show just for my own edification through his first 100 or 120 shows. and It was like 85% men. i was like, oh, I need to do something different here. And so my mine is are a pretty 50-50 split. Maybe skews a little A little more women than men, but it's typically 50-50 over the course of ah of a year. But I noticed that early on. So many of those early podcasters who are popular, you look at their backlog and it's like, oh, wow, Tim Ferriss just interviews dudes. And ah yeah they all interview dudes that look like them.
Speaker: and it's like Yeah, and it's not just podcasters. i mean's That was so great about them doing the account was because when these magazines, very very acclaimed storied magazines would get really low scores, some of them didn't care, but some of them cared.
Speaker: And then you'd watch them over five years change, yeah which was great. like just to have And it changed me. I like metrics. I like um following numbers. So like that sort of thing that was motivating to me.
Speaker: but Rather than just entirely following my own, I don't want to just be interviewing people who are like me on the show. I mean, I think part of what's fun is meeting someone who isn't like me. Yeah.
Speaker: Yeah. And how how have you noticed your your evolution as a as a host in the, you know, the 15, 16 years you've been doing the show? Well, the beginning, it was on a radio.
Speaker: And so each episode was either 28 56 minutes, depending on the slot. and they were all in person. When it started becoming a podcast alongside the broadcast and there was no longer a forum, my maximalist tendencies took over um for better or worse. worse But as you probably noticed, the conversations are really long, often between two and three hours, which has does two things that are contradictory. On the one hand, I think it limits appeal.
Speaker: and There are people who even might be interested in the guest who aren't going to listen to a two and a half hour show. But it also increases the passion and depth of the people who do want to do that or who discover that they like it when they try it Um, the people who want to be in a different relationship to time around the conversation really like it. And then there's people who sort of feel on the outside of that at the same time. So it's a, it's a double-edged sword, but it also makes, makes it, that's why I only have two episodes a month partially too because if you're going to do five hours between two guests, instead of 10, 30 minute interviews with
Speaker: with 10 different writers. It's just a different, it limits the the number. So instead of breadth, it's hopefully being more depth. other Other than that, I think the writers themselves have have informed my own politics. They've informed my own understanding of writing.
Speaker: They've changed my notions around philosophy, a whole bunch of different things over time. Because you'll get, at least I'll get, a writer that I'll bring on because of a question that I don't have an answer to, I would say about writing or maybe about something in the world.
Speaker: Maybe I want to have like five or six writers all trying to answer this question in their own way differently from each other. And then you sort of come upon not only more questions, but maybe you come on upon a more sophisticated answer for yourself.
Speaker: Where do I sit among this ah this array of opinions? So I would say in a lot of ways, it's changed many, if not most things about me.
Speaker: me Yeah. Slowly. Yeah. Not in any sort of dramatic way, but looking across a decade 15 years. Yeah. It is really glacial in that regard. You never notice the change ah like week to week or in your case, like, you know, biweekly. um And maybe for you, David, just ah just went from your writing perspective, like how is the the show itself informed your writing and strengthened your writing?
Speaker: I don't really have a writing practice. I write when I get solicited to write something. So like maybe two or three years ago, i wrote three pieces, all of which I loved. And then last year I wasn't asked to write anything, so I didn't write anything. so it's very primitive.
Speaker: um Because i'm though the podcast is too all-consuming, and I don't have a lot of discipline around carving out a writing practice. But I would argue that the show has changed me profoundly around how I write, when I do write,
Speaker: Because at the beginning, I was only starting out. At the beginning, I was really only comfortable interviewing fiction writers only because I didn't really know anything else.
Speaker: and And in my mind, which I think is funny now, i i was most scared to talk to poets. And I don't think I started talking to poets regularly until, I don't know, maybe five, six, seven years into the show.
Speaker: Now they're the my not only the place that I most want to be in conversation, but also i'm not a poet, but I think my writing has a poetics and I think that indeterminate cross-genre writing that's very language forward is a result of having interviewed a lot of poets. Mm-hmm.
Speaker: And so I think it has moved me to find what i what forms most speak to me in terms of my own voice. yeah yeah Even though I'm not sitting down all the time and and making new writing. What poets come to mind that really kind of lit you up in conversation?
Speaker: Yeah, um a lot of poets. um Jory Graham, the first Jory Graham conversation about Runaway, both of them are amazing. That's probably the one that everybody, not everybody, but a lot of people have listened to many times.
Speaker: There are people who've written that they've listened to this episode five, six, seven times. Wow, that's awesome. it's It's really rich. It's engaging. It's not forbidding in the sense of like,
Speaker: It's difficult to listen to, but it's dense in a way where you can't get it all on a first or second listen. Like a good poem. um Yeah. and but she's um she's amazing. Dionne Brand, Lely Long Soldier, Natalie Diaz.
Speaker: A lot of great poets yeah that that stick with me in my brain. um yeah Have you talked to Jericho Brown? I would like to talk to Jared. Yeah, he's he's a special talent a special talent and a great conversationalist too.
Speaker: Have you talked him? Yeah, ah right around the time The Tradition came out, so before he won the Pulitzer ah for it. And yeah, he's just... ah He's amazing. He is amazing. Richard Blanco is really...
Speaker: It was really wonderful too. And um when I talked to Mary Carr back in the day, it was when she had Tropic of Squalor come out. So we talked to her in context of actually her poetry versus the memoirs she's she's written. So that was you know pretty pretty special. And yeah, at least for me, because I traffic in nonfiction, lot of poetry primarily at least the poetry I've been fed is a lot ah lot of nonfiction. It's great to have those conversations and it's just ah it's a different medium of nonfiction storytelling for the most part. and i love Yeah, it's really fun. It changes things up.
Speaker: I think the the um my sweet spot is poets writing prose. Whether it's poets writing fiction or nonfiction, that's sort of the that's sort of the amazing place, I think, when you see people writing narrative, but with a poetic sensibility. yeah I'm sure you've had plenty of those people on And i when um when I was reading your um your your book with on Ursula Le Guin, your conversations in fiction poetry and nonfiction, i was really struck by the depth of your knowledge of like her her work
Speaker: In the back and forth that you have, i just it was like you have this almost ah a PhD level concept or even understanding of her work that I was really i was really struck by. And is it was that something that you've just kind of absorbed over the years or you always went in with great study when you went to speak with her?
Speaker: That's a good question because I think what you're witnessing is just how much I do in terms of preparation for any interview because I would argue actually I didn't know very much about Ursula Le Guin when we had those conversations except for the preparation that I did for each of the individual books.
Speaker: prior to them. So it makes me happy that it comes across as me knowing a lot. I feel like I knew i learned a lot more because she, as as you discover in the in memoriam in that book, she died suddenly while we were doing the copy edits to the book. So this was the first book that came out after she died and one of the last books that she was involved in in any way while she was alive.
Speaker: And so it sort of carried me on a several-year journey where people were reaching out to me to write about her after the book came out about things I didn't know that much about, but then like I did for those conversations, would then sort of study to try to be able to to write those essays.
Speaker: But i do i do an and so I do an insane amount of prep work, I guess, for each of the conversations that I do. which is also why I'm only doing two. It's partly because of ah the length of each of those conversations, but it's also partly because I want to sort of feel like I can justify being in the conversation with the person on their own terms, which is harder or easier depending upon who that writer is. And with her, i mean, she was writing for a half century in all three genres, right? So she was in her eighty s
Speaker: There's no way, or I wasn't going to try to do some sort of survey of what her importance was in in the world over the course of the time she was on earth. So you're sort of saved in my scenario that we're really narrowing it to the book that's between the two of us.
Speaker: But the book that was between the two of us, the first book, was a craft book. And that craft book is engaging with everything. It's engaging with everything. you know Even though it's looking at the sentence and looking at grammar, it's engaging with class and capitalism and feminism and gender.
Speaker: So really, you're you're starting to discover all the things that are making her science fiction and fantasy worlds, but you're discovering it in a book about how to write a story instead of about her own stories. Yeah.
Speaker: So really those i those encounters, I think, set me on a journey to learn more. I still feel like I'm learning more now. you know it's It's eight years later.
Speaker: i was asked last year to write for an anthology in England that was an anthology of her relationship to maps and cartography. ah knew absolutely nothing about that.
Speaker: And so they gave they gave us this document where we could look at every map she'd drawn in her life, both within the books and just in her like sketchbooks, and choose one to write about.
Speaker: And I was blown away by all the things that I learned. I thought I knew a lot. And it feels like i never have wretched reached the edge. But at the time we were talking, I've never reached the edge of my interest, but at the time we were talking, i had no idea she would continue to be somebody that I would be that mesmerized by. well It's wild. Yeah. and she has ah she comes across as someone who has such ah firepower, yeah intellectual firepower and It can be hard as an interviewer to just keep pace with that. And and he can be insecure about going into a conversation like that. You know, research helps for sure. So, you know, you can go in whatever direction you need. But, you when you're stepping up to the the plate and, you know, you're going to be speaking with her for a long time and you've got to figure out a way to just to keep pace with her. Yeah. How do you approach that?
Speaker: I'd be curious to hear your answer about this too, because there have been certain writers that I've known in advance that there are certain things that are going to shut them down or that are pet peeves. Like there are certain writers that I don't, I don't necessarily include Ursula in this, but there are certain writers where I knew that interviews had gone off the rail and some of them are great to witness like print interviews where,
Speaker: they become antagonistic to the interviewer and it's, it starts to go off the rails and, but it's kind of exciting, but you would never want to be that interviewer. yeah that That isn't this case, but like, for instance, an example, I knew that when I interviewed Percival Everett, that he'd hated to talk about what a book he wrote was about.
Speaker: He insisted, and I don't even disagree with this. He insisted that the meaning of any book that he writes or that any writer writes is constructed by the reader. You shouldn't be asking the author what it means.
Speaker: And so I knew it going in, like, if I was going to start there, well, tell me what your book's about, or why did you do this? it's not It wasn't going to be good, and he was going to close up. yeah So I had to come up with an oblique strategy and try to have a conversation. i i really love the conversation we had that never goes directly at the book the way that he hates things going directly at the book.
Speaker: With Ursula, there was just this sense, even not even if you didn't know, how important she was to the history of science fiction and fantasy. You just got the sense from being in the same room with her that she would take no bullshit and that you better not ask a stupid question i she might tell you it was one.
Speaker: um But she was warm and she was funny too. So it's like she's there was an intimidating factor, but also a sense of interpersonal connection. So in that sense, I feel like you feel like you want to step up your game to to be there. You don't want to be that interviewer. I think where she's asked to predict the future and she hates that. like I knew she hated...
Speaker: Being asked to be an oracle. Yeah. Which a lot of science fiction writers are treated as if they can see beyond the veil and tell us what's going to happen. As you're constructing the the book and curating what you were talking about with ah errsaa and what you're putting in the book, you know, how were you thinking about how you wanted to structure it and what to include and not include?
Speaker: Well, it it all arose from me saying to her during the last interview in her house, um the nonfiction interview, I can't imagine having done a conversation like this, looking over a half century of writing in one genre, let alone three genres. And that's when she suggested we make it into a book.
Speaker: So, I mean, the the basic... ah skeleton of the book is we're going to travel through the three genres and what they mean to Ursula. So on fiction, on poetry, on nonfiction.
Speaker: So then there's the part of how to make those interviews, not just be transcripts, but to be readable on the page.
Speaker: And then also one of the things a lot of writers really love about it is the we There are these black pages throughout with white print where we give ah examples. So for instance, if she's talking about syntax and the rhythm of J.R.R. Tolkien or Virginia Woolf, you'll have an excerpt or there'll be poems by Ursula or translations that she did of Gabriella Mistral.
Speaker: and other things. So throughout, you're getting the conversation sort of interleaved with various examples from outside the conversations. And then other than that, she wrote a really hilarious introduction called Fear and Loathing in the Interview.
Speaker: And I wrote these introductory texts that sort of try to situate me and her in time in relation to when those interviews happened, but also to contemplate what it is about that genre and Ursula's relationship to it. What does it tell us about both? Like, so what does poetry, the poetry chapter tell us about Ursula, her relationship to poetry?
Speaker: um But also what does Ursula have to say about poetry versus storytelling? And it's it's quite different. And her emotional relationship to the three genres is really different.
Speaker: So, i mean, that's but I think that pretty much summarizes it as ah as a way to, i think it's a good book because all three of the conversations are marginal to her most well-known works. They're they're about things that were really important and central to her, but not central to her reputation.
Speaker: You just sort learn a lot about potential places you might want to explore afterwards, yeah whether that be her translation of the Tao Te Ching whether that be Her essays, she has amazing, i think very pedagogical book reviews where um if she admires the writer, but she's critiquing them, you usually learn something about craft in her book review of that writer.
Speaker: There's just a million ways you could go where this book could sort of be a portal towards figuring out where you might want to go. Yeah, for sure. It is incredibly readable because I imagine in your conversations, they're a bit not as, for lack a better term, rat-a-tat ah that you're reading. It's going to be a bit more you know drawn out, but you you do make it like, oh, this is a different experience. So you're you're reflecting the experience that people are having in hand. And ah as a result of that, yeah, it is ah very approachable. I do love the interludes of, yeah, the black pages with the white text in it. It's like ah it's this little little break. You know, we're going to take a this little like B-roll detour. And then then we circle right back to the conversation and and move forward so that in ah of itself, it feels as static as the book is. It feels kind of kinetic and interactive.
Speaker: I'm glad to hear that. Is there... um yeah What do you... you know now that Now that she's gone and and exists, you know in be it in audio and audio archives and the work she's you know left for us, you know what do you miss most about her?
Speaker: Well, I mean, one thing people... mistakenly presumed is that we were close friends, especially in the Spanish edition. They called me, uh, Sue amigo, but we weren't close friends.
Speaker: So in a strange way, i feel like she's been very present in my life. since 2015, and in some ways more present in my life since the book came out and since she passed away. Because in 2022, I ended up doing ah a limited series on the show called Crafting with Ursula. So an extra episode a month, we invited 12 different writers to talk about their own work, but in relationship to a really narrow aspect of Ursula's. So it could be Kim Stanley Robinson talking about ambiguous utopias, or it could be someone talking about feminist classical retellings or someone talking about science and women.
Speaker: And so we have all these different episodes. So, i mean, that entire year was probably but my most immersive year, but here it is. The book's coming out, reissued now. I'm on a little like mini tour.
Speaker: People are discovering her for the first time still. People are discovering this book for the first time. She really stepped into ah a role in the last 10 years of her life as a public intellectual in a way where she was critiquing Google and Amazon and writing these really fiery letters to the editor in the Oregonian about the Bundys taking over the Malheur bird refuge and any number of things. Like she was prescient about a lot of things and a lot of her concerns are, are kind turning out unfortunately to be true in a worse form now
Speaker: She was writing about Trump and how to oppose Trump in her blog in her final years of her life. I feel like she's ah missing would be the wrong word. I mean, I think the missing part for me would is that i so i just kind of hoped that when the book came out, we would get to celebrate it together, that maybe we'd have an event at Powell's and we would, you know, talk about talking together with each other.
Speaker: i wish that we'd had more conversations than we'd had before. Other than that, since then, i feel like she's been become a bigger and bigger part of my life, and I couldn't have predicted that. I couldn't have predicted that before the book came out, even a hint of that being possible, or that I continue to find her really inspiring and interesting.
Speaker: Yeah, I love ah yeah a moment ago you brought up you know how even if she admired a writer, but she's going to review their work um yeah in the book here. You to kind of reference the Bone Clocks of David Mitchell. um I haven't read the book, but she reviewed it critically. ah And I imagine she had respect for for Mitchell. Yeah. But yeah, it's, but it's one of those deals where i think a lot of writers are maybe don't want to cut another writer down because there's enough factors out there cutting everyone down to kind of want to lift everybody up. And I wonder if just maybe you can pull on that thread a little longer of just like, maybe, maybe it is good for a writer of stature, not to cut someone down, but to maybe imbue their criticism and maybe treat it, like you said, like a ah craft lesson. If they admire the writer at their core. Yeah.
Speaker: Well, I mean, maybe this is particularly relevant to your show since your show is more nonfiction centric. that was That's the genre she felt maybe most she had the most, she had the most unease about writing nonfiction, I think because it's generally more declarative.
Speaker: And um I mean, not necessarily. If you're writing memoir and personal essay, can be very not that, but yeah. And her essays are some of the best things that she's written. But she had an unease about the world of realism and taking stances, even though she took tons of stances and wrote tons of nonfiction. But that said, her book reviews, I think, went the whole gamut. She has some bone-chilling takedown reviews. Yeah.
Speaker: that are thrilling to read, but if I had received one of them, I don't know if I'd ever written again. And I remember one of these writers who got one when the the day she died, this writer retweeted the the horrible takedown of their work in a way that just felt really generous. And kind of I was kind of amazed that they would put it back into circulation.
Speaker: But she also had book she also had reviews that were like, glowingly positive, ah like ah China Mieville's Embassy Town. That review is incredible, where she's trying to argue that, in which she was arguing her whole life, that science fiction is literature, and it's as respectable as a form as so-called literary fiction, and that his book should be considered as good as the greatest literary fiction.
Speaker: But I do think the most interesting ones are the ones like with s Salman Rushdie and with David Mitchell, where she really respects their career and as a peer with an enormous amount of stature, wants to lean into the way she feels like a given book is both good and falls short.
Speaker: I think those are really interesting reviews and also generous because, um, their point, they're pointing at ways for writers, not just the writer being critiqued, but for any writer, because the David Mitchell one's really about her reservations about,
Speaker: how in vogue present tense is. And she's not against present tense, but she argues for all the things that are given up in in bone clocks by choosing that tense over, say, a close-in third person.
Speaker: And she relates that to questions of memory, and how our memory works. um She gives examples of how something how reading that book, if I remember correctly, it's sort of like all you can see is the little place where the spotlight of your car is illuminating right in front of the car in utter darkness. Mm-hmm.
Speaker: So you're just seeing this thing right in front, right in front, right in front. And of course, there's a power and immediacy to that. And books are going to do more or less with that. But because she had...
Speaker: this long view and this long writing life, surely she saw so many different writing fads writing styles come and go. So I think she sensed that this passion around the present tense shouldn't blind us to all the options that are available. Like maybe your book could be better told with this point of view that's Not really popular right now, but would have been a better one for your book. Yeah.
Speaker: I like the idea of maybe reading her criticism or criticism done well is that it teaches you how to be a better reader and it allows you to interrogate choices that are happening on the page because they're all choices. and In fact, there's a lot of agency in that. There's rarely a very passive moment of what it actually ends up in the in the book. it's It's there for a reason. that Someone put it there and it and lobbied for it to be there. And then if someone takes ah maybe a little bit of an issue with it, there's an opportunity to be like, oh, this is a a new way to be studying the game tape. there' There's my sport metaphors. studying Studying the game tape so that we can be like, it rewind it and play it again, rewind it, play it again, and learn. And then we get better as a result of that.
Speaker: Yeah, that's exactly why I think it's generous, because it'd be one thing to say, this didn't work for me. Or I hate the reviews. There's sometimes reviews where they give the book to a reviewer who doesn't actually like the genre that they're reviewing it.
Speaker: And they'll say something like, well, I really don't like mysteries. And then they diss a mystery book. And I'm like, well, why are you reviewing it at all? If you're going in you don't like the the genre to begin with, and then you critique it entirely on the terms of the genre, it's completely wasted space, essentially, in my mind. Yeah. like You're not showing us anything new. All we're learning about is your personal taste. And it's it feels like a waste of time for everybody, ultimately. yeah Well, you know you brought up ah how how Ursula was you know lobbying for science fiction to be like on on the level with more literary fiction. And I think that's where ah she ah if she had a literary beef with Margaret Atwood, it it was that. Because Atwood was kind of eschewing the title because she didn't it was like dirty in a way. and ah But Ursula was like, no, it can't this genre can be elevated, and she's proved it. So is Margaret Atwood, or even she doesn't want to own that label. I mean, she's made it.
Speaker: Yeah, she has elevated the elevated the the genre. So i just what what did you notice with ah any like literary rivalry or beefs that ah that that ursula had?
Speaker: I mean, I think that they were, I think Atwood and Le Guin were close. I don't know that for sure, but I know they've been on stage together at Literary Arts in Portland. I think they had mutual admiration. So I don't know that that was a beef, but but I did think Le Guin had a complicated relationship in the sense that she didn't see herself as only a science fiction and fantasy writer. She wanted to be seen in enough in the full breadth of everything that she did.
Speaker: which included novels that weren't those things. But she very proudly considered herself a science fiction and fantasy writer. And so both were true.
Speaker: She didn't disown the genre. she's She came from the genre. She defended the genre. She would argue that just as much pulpy, bad literary fiction or realist fiction exists as pulpy, bad science fiction.
Speaker: um That most great literature historically was fantastical literature across culture. you know whether Hamlet or Don Quixote or The Odyssey or Kafka, much of it's fantastical until pretty recently, that there's something about the way our minds work and the way we told stories going back to Around the Fire that...
Speaker: In a weird way, I think she would argue that fantasy gets to something most real about the human more than so-called realism, which in her mind isn't very real, both because there's not a lot of um imagination technically, but also because it's so human-centric, because the world isn't human-centric in her mind.
Speaker: yeah That having works where you've centered humans at the exclusion of everything else is na iser is both reiterating a problem with a certain view of the world, but isn't really reflecting the world as it is. So in a strange way, I would think that she would say that fantastical writing is more real in the larger sense of real.
Speaker: which I know is a strange, it's a strange and different argument, but um she really fiercely defended the the importance it. Yeah. I think I might've read that if Kurt Vonnegut had a certain measure of maybe insecurity around his work being labeled science fiction. yeah I think he wanted to be seen as something a bit more serious in literary. and ah But yeah, is it because it seems like the, yeah as a genre, it's at the kids' table. of of fiction. And even though fantasy, I mean, science fiction too, but fantasy gets connected and denigrated as if it's all children's literature.
Speaker: And then she did this really complicated move there too, where she didn't try to, so a lot of fantasy writers would try to distance themselves from children's literature. Yeah.
Speaker: And instead, Ursula deepened the connection but elevated the mind of the child. She doesn't say all fantasy writing is children's literature. That's ah obviously not true. But she does say that there's something incredibly unique and complex and singular about childhood consciousness that should be understood on its own terms um and has a sort of inherent fantastical element to it.
Speaker: And so she would somehow found a way to, probably to the chagrin of some fantasy writers, deepen the connection between the two in impulse, even though they're not the same, and to defend the child in ah so in a strange way. Instead of like having fantasy literature be stained by a child and its imagination, have it be elevated by the child and its imagination. Yeah. That's really well put. And I imagine, too, as you're curating the material for a book of this nature and going back through the tapes of, you know, all those conversations, it's probably, you know, it's just really, really kind of really cool to re-experience that. And I imagine, too, that there are there are elements of those conversations where you're like, oh, I'm still learning from her. So I wonder if, like, what... ah yeah What are you still learning from her, even though she's you know passed away a few years ago at this point? But you know there is ah a containment of here, kind of like a vessel, a time time capsule, if you will. like we yeah So what are you still learning from her?
Speaker: Yeah. Well, the thing that i bring up most often is she had this really... unusual relationship to being imperfect and limited in the sense that she could often be really ahead around something and behind at the same time.
Speaker: ah For instance, in the seventies with feminism, she was critiqued a lot by other big sci-fi feminist writers for being um not up to speed on feminism And at the same time in in those critiques, which she agreed with 20 years later, looking back, she's like, I agree with what they said. And she goes through this 20-year journey around it. But she was also had her heels dug in at that point around motherhood and being and being a writer, where I think feminism was behind at the time around motherhood and denigrating motherhood.
Speaker: and she was in in defending motherhood. So she was ahead and behind, but in the process of figuring out how to deal with that for herself, she spent like 15 years trying to figure out how to write adult female protagonist.
Speaker: where she wasn't just going to slot them into the hero structure that a man would normally be in. And in figuring that out, she writes all these really iconic essays.
Speaker: She goes back into worlds that she's created with new books and changes the rules. um She gives speeches where she asks for feedback on the speeches and keeps working on them from her audiences.
Speaker: But she does it all facing her readership. where she's sort of like self-revising, but she's leaving the evidence of who she was all along the way. There's no like disowning who she was. there's like It's almost like when you can look at the various copies of a document,
Speaker: She's preserving all the documents yeah and also revising them. And so, i mean, really, the things that she's most known for being really far ahead around, whether it's race or class or gender, she could also have been canceled around.
Speaker: And still are. And, you know, like so many people, I'm sure there's people canceling her around them. But what's so fascinating, I guess the thing to learn for me is, She was about being a writer in process.
Speaker: Like she was about a process happening through time. And so, yes, you could pick any moment in that time and it's it's not perfect, but her relationship to to being a limited human being, like we all were we all are, think it's kind of inspiring ultimately.
Speaker: Oh, yeah. Well, it's great. I love that the this book, and I'm i'm someone who had i I'm familiar with a lot of her titles, but I haven't i haven't engaged with them. my I haven't really read much much of her at all. And i maybe there are similar people out there, and I love that this book kind of is a portal or a like introductory. be Like, oh, cool. Like, I'm going to like dip a toe into this pool or maybe just dive full. dive headfirst in and and and try to and in absorb even a little ah a little slice of each of the things that she was so proficient in. So I think ah that's the great gift of what you've packaged here and are giving to the world. So I just got to really you know thank you for this because I think it'll turn people on to her work and maybe get more people reading her.
Speaker: Yeah. Thank you for having me on the show. Absolutely. And there's one more thing I'd love to, uh, I love bringing these conversations down for a landing, David, by just asking the guests for a recommendation of some kind. That's just like anything you're finding fun and cool. It doesn't have to be a book. A lot of people recommend books, but it could be a fanny pack or a brand of coffee. It's totally, totally up to you John Moran Jersey. I don't know.
Speaker: Maybe I could, I could suggest a couple of things by Ursula. yeah Like to me The greatest novel of hers is The Dispossessed, which came out in the early 70s and I think is as timely as ever. It hasn't really aged. In fact, I would say maybe it's more relevant than ever, The Dispossessed.
Speaker: Super engaging. Super interesting setup. And so as a novel, but if you want to get a taste of her writing that's shorter, there's a thought experiment that's probably her one of her most taught pieces of writing.
Speaker: It's called The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas. And it's an utopian thought experiment that disturbs a lot of young minds when they read it in high school and college. But it's worth reading also. And it has some of the same questions, I think, ultimately as the dispossessed. The dispossessed is a much more like fleshed out world where basically some anarchists on on this planet are dealt with by given by being given a satellite moon to to go live on instead of the home where they're originally from.
Speaker: And they set up this ah anarchist society on this moon. And then, I mean, that's the setup. That's the background of the drama, which I won't speak to the drama, but the drama is you have these two extremely different social arrangements happening, both people from the same place, different people having different challenges and different worldviews, and then something that requires an interaction around the two cultures.
Speaker: Fantastic. Awesome. Well, David, thanks so much for hopping on the show and talking a little shop about podcasting and certainly about you know this wonderful book you brought to light with your conversations with Ursula. So just thanks so much for the time and thanks for coming on the show.
Speaker: Yeah, thank you, Brendan.
Speaker: Yes, awesome. Thanks to David for coming on the show to talk about Between the Covers and his book with Ursula K. Le Guin. Don't you want to just go read The Dispossessed now? I know I do. I think that's going to be my first soiree.
Speaker: Soiree? Foray. Idiot. Fuck. Foray into the Le Guin expanded universe. Thanks to you for making it this far in the podcast. No small feat.
Speaker: The data tells me most people only listen halfway through. And actually, a very small percentage of people even make it halfway. Most don't even make it through the first 10 minutes.
Speaker: That is very depressing to say. Be sure you're subbed up to the show, whether you listen for 10 minutes or 60, and go to Pitch Club at welcometopitchclub.substack.com and consider maybe purchasing a paperback of the front runner for the runner in your life for the holiday season.
Speaker: You know, sometimes I wonder if I'm working hard at all. and May a long-time listeners of Parting Shots know I often struggle with this. Or if I'm working too hard on a thing that feels trivial. I think it comes down to grit, and I'm not the grittiest.
Speaker: I tend to flounder. I tend to have great Mondays that get progressively worse until Friday comes. I tend to waste time on my phone. getting better with that a bit and I owe a lot of that to August Lam's new book You Don't Need a Smartphone which I read twice and we'll have her on the show soon but her audio was so bad because we were recording it on my telephone telephone's recording app and she doesn't have a laptop or a smartphone ah so yeah the audio is garbage i I might have to maybe try to re-record with her try to get her into a studio somewhere I don't know.
Speaker: Or get someone to... I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. And when I look at the myriad ways of how I waste time, i I think I could have written another book proposal by now. I could have been a better freelancer.
Speaker: yeah What's got to do with all this internalized capitalism, man? But honestly, if it wasn't for this work I do, what would I even be doing? I don't really have any hobbies, and if I'm being honest, i don't really want any. think I admire people who play instruments or paint, but after knowing how long it has taken me to become a halfway competent writer and podcaster, I don't have it in me to spend 20 years getting just okay at something.
Speaker: This is what I'm decent at right here. Might as well just try to keep getting better at this. I like drawing like cartoons and one-panel comics and everything. yeah like I did this one thing where there's a guy talking to a rolled oat, right? Like a singular rolled oat with a headband on his head. And there's a couple other oats that are running off in the distance. And the guy tells the singular rolled oat, he says, no use in chasing them, them quick oats.
Speaker: By and large, how cool is this little gig? I get to read books and talk to people about them. I get to call them a colleague, a peer, and sometimes a friend. Right? i get to play some small part in getting and helping to get you where you want to go. That's really cool.
Speaker: I feel somewhere in my core that I could do more. And not just more, that I can do better. That I can do more. And better. That in and of itself is teasing my Life Burns Faster era, but more on that later this year. And all of this is coming down to grit.
Speaker: Do I have what it takes to be better? Can the show they maybe make a buck? i don't know. Can it eventually make me a buck with another book contract? That's what this really about.
Speaker: build that platform, make me attractive. Very, so very attractive to the publishing sphere. Can I get the show in more people's hands? I do need to carve out more space for famous authors. um I just do. They simply get more attention to the podcast. It is objective fact.
Speaker: On Spotify alone, like Chuck Kosterman's recent appearance, that live podcast, has been listened to significantly more than other ones and other recent ones. It's a...
Speaker: And I don't think he's sharing it at all, too. Most famous writers don't engage in the sharing. This is this I know to be true. But they bring attention to the entire enterprise, as I've said countless times, many, many times.
Speaker: I see the podcast as like a rock festival. And Chuck Klosterman is one of those headlining artists that you see at the top of the poster. They bring people in the gate so then you might attend some of the smaller, fonted acts who are every bit as talented. Maybe not. But but every they are competent. They are good people.
Speaker: But those big names bring you in so you experience maybe other people, other acts who might not otherwise check out were it not for the big headliner types.
Speaker: When I examine my grit, I don't feel like I have much grit. What's the maybe maybe fine grit? Sandpaper? know It's okay, but it's like yeah something you need like super grit.
Speaker: You want something that like rips the skin Okay. I feel like I'm always a little bit lazy. I'm easily distracted. A sign of the times, I guess. I still get weirdly competitive when I see certain things online and my hackles go up and it's it's a me problem and not a them problem. I know this.
Speaker: But I still have this nasty streak in me I don't like. And the only way I know how to snuff it out is by drowning it out by working harder and doing more. Just running my own race and plowing my own acre.
Speaker: yeah What's a candle for if not to burn both ends? I want to push my limits. I've sandbagged it for too long. It's embarrassing, really. It's insulting not to leverage the full power of my privilege. I also want to somehow maybe free my partner from her job.
Speaker: She'd find another one right away, but she's trapped in this one. for the health insurance of it all. have a sticky note on my monitor that says slow is fast.
Speaker: And it's true, so long as you don't get pulled into the riptide of other bullshit. If you stay on task and just plug away like the tortoise, you get there. You get there.
Speaker: I have a long ass way to go, man. And there are people who I feel have started, quote unquote, after me who have already surpassed me. But I'm also outlasting others because my why is very strong when it comes to this.
Speaker: Okay, by the time you hear this, I'll be on my way back to Oregon. I will have run a half marathon here in Eugene along the river path. I will have seen and hopefully survived a trip to see family on the East Coast.
Speaker: I may have seen my mother alive for the last time. So that's where I'm at. So stay wild, C&Fers. If you can't do interview, see ya.






