Transcript
Speaker: Hello and welcome back. to Democracy Volunteers podcast. It seems Professor Quentin Kidd is permanently on our YouTube channel. and I'm glad to welcome him back this time to talk about the Mississippi Senate race.
Speaker: These midterms have been historic on so many levels. Over 11 billion was spent on political advertising. the most ever spent on campaigning in an election.
Speaker: Kansas turned blue for the first time since 1934. Michigan voted in the country's first Muslim senator. and turnout was the second highest. in any midterm election since 1914.
Speaker: with only 2018 higher. to add to that list mississippi on thursday the twelfth of november voted in the state's first black senator scott columb since blanche bruce served from eighteen seventy five to 1881.
Speaker: Only with a vote margin. of 0 .5 percent or roughly 8 000 votes Quentin, it's great to have you on to the podcast. How did... Can you explain?
Speaker: what Scott Collum winning Mississippi means for that area of... America. um I mean, it's. historic as you mentioned historic in significant ways in terms of how long ago it's been since a black senator was.
Speaker: put into office but but in Mississippi. um So if you go back to 1875. um Senators at that point weren't popularly elected. They were elected. They were essentially put in the Senate by the state legislature.
Speaker: So this is the first time in history that Mississippi has had the opportunity to vote in. a black senator. And so it's historic in that. context Um, in 1875.
Speaker: the legislature in missip Mississippi. was essentially... constructed by the union um you know the union ah army in some ways because anyone who had fought.
Speaker: on the Confederacy side was barred from public office. And so. it was ah It was a legislature that was that was made up by the, you know, the victors of the war. and so when When those rules were relaxed in in the early 1880s,
Speaker: Um, the the two black senators that had been put in office by by the Mississippi legislature, we're quickly. removed from office. And so this is historic.
Speaker: i think it's historic for and a couple of other reasons or i think it's Historic and telling for a couple of other reasons. Number one. it It shows you, I think, and this is, I think, important for for some of the work that you that you do.
Speaker: Um, When you threaten to take the vote away and or make it harder for somebody to vote who has heretofore been able to vote. you might in fact get the opposite of what you expect.
Speaker: So. Mississippi, like many other southern states and many other states, had toyed with the idea of redistricting to try to make it harder for black voters to elect a candidate of their choice.
Speaker: Um, the Trump administration had been. trying to suppress um Turnout suppress. uh voting The Supreme Court. had been undoing some some of the civil rights legislation that made voting easier. especially for for um black voters across the South.
Speaker: And all of that resulted in an historic black turnout in Mississippi. such that in counties that were majority black or close to majority black counties, there was record turnout and the result was an 8 ,000 vote victory for Um, now Senator -elect Cullum.
Speaker: And and so I think it's a lesson in. you know, so to attempting to suppress voting may in fact spur voting on the part of the people that you're trying to suppress or or might be might be a worried about having their votes suppressed. i think You saw that across.
Speaker: many states on election day. I also think it says to Democrats. The South is worth Contesting. because Democrats, except for some states,
Speaker: Um, have kind of given up on the South. obviously they've not given up on Georgia and they've not given up on, you know, Virginia really is. electorally not really a southern state anymore. Virginia's been electing Democrats now for 25 years.
Speaker: but many southern states democrats had given up on And I think this says to to the Democratic Party. You know, there's something worth fighting for here. And if you encourage voters to turn out and you help them turn out.
Speaker: they will turn out. And so do you was expect in 2028 a kind of... a different approach to even where the democrats put their funding for the presidential elections.
Speaker: If they're smart, yes. you know obviously you know the factors or the conditions of 2028 are going to shape the decisions that that any party makes about where to put their resources. but um I think increasingly in American elections. whether for good or bad.
Speaker: Resources are not the problem. there there There will be... billions of billions of dollars spent in 2028. So it may not be a question of the resources, it may be a question of the... and the ability to figure out where to deploy those resources and in the best way possible to deploy them.
Speaker: um You know, but if you look across the south There are states like Mississippi. Alabama, South Carolina that have significant black populations.
Speaker: 30 to 40 % of the entire population. If they turn out and vote in big numbers, that will drive the election. And so and I think Mississippi is just a case study in how that can happen.
Speaker: Hmm. And so... How would you respond to this idea that kind of seeing... the blue wave that happened in the midterm. So Kansas, Texas and Mississippi.
Speaker: You talked there about the importance of turnout. Looking at ideology. In your opinion, does this kind of blue wave indicate a permanent change in the political ideology of these traditionally Republican states?
Speaker: Oh. is it as likely that these can bounce back red? as quickly in 2028. yeah It is absolutely likely that these states can bounce back red.
Speaker: in a heartbeat. um so The states that you name, Mississippi, Texas, and Kansas. I think of those as pretty... pretty common sense.
Speaker: um uh populations common sense electorates Um, Salt of the Earth people, you know. ah ah Not. not the progressive that you might see, you know, the Mamdani. you know new york progressive um but but basically rural more rural voters And I think what they care about are.
Speaker: basic bread and butter issues, you know. jobs, health care, the ah access to health care. um They're probably... more socially conservative than not. They're probably more um you know more fiscally conservative than not, but they do want.
Speaker: you know if government is going to do something they want government to do it right um They don't want to be. um ah they I think they don't want to. be assumed to be. pawns to be used. i think Hispanic voters in particular in Texas.
Speaker: felt like that they that they voted for donald trump for one re for one um reasons you know and then he ended up doing things that hurt them.
Speaker: So. All of that to say, if Democrats in Congress don't do what they said they were going to do. Um, these voters could very easily either not turn out in 2028 or uh decide that they're gonna vote for you know a moderate republican who says um that that that that they will go do you know what those voters want them to do And going back to Mississippi.
Speaker: The vote share between Democrat .com and... Republican Cindy Hyde -Smith. was 0 .5 percent. yeah what Was this grounds for a recount? and I don't believe, and why was there not a recount?
Speaker: so um a lot of times campaigns have to pay for the recount and if the if the uh If the turnout in the modeling suggests that... um that that that nothing will change, then ah then a campaign may not want to pay for it.
Speaker: Um, It didn't look like, you know, 8 ,000 votes is a lot of votes. and so Um. even though it's a small percentage. you know, ah vote I think I think it says.
Speaker: a couple of things. Vote counting is is very accurate for the most part. Um, And it is also the case that vote counting is that that that it's very rare that there are a lot of mistakes, not in the counting process, but in sort of the ballot process. and so the idea that 8 ,000 votes can be overcome i think in ah in a situation where the vote counting is pretty accurate.
Speaker: There aren't really any questions about. um the integrity of vote ah ballots you know in terms of... how they were delivered or how they were processed or anything like that. so Absent...
Speaker: Um, anything that suggests there is a problem. It's a big mountain to climb. I think it also says something about Hyde Smith and her. sensibilities if you will.
Speaker: um you You didn't hear her talking about... stolen elections or you know so anything sort of untoward. like you might have heard in some other states.
Speaker: um And I think that speaks to the sensibilities of her as a candidate. And probably the sensibilities of her campaign as well. so if this had been in you know just go back Two years, Arizona.
Speaker: Carrie Lake. losing by A little bit more than 8 ,000 votes. but claiming that there was you know fraud and and and all sorts of issues.
Speaker: um yeah I just don't think hyde smith is that kind of a person she's not going to make those kind of claims absent any real evidence. And so I think that's a big part of it also. Hmm. And I think something that a lot of people have found surprising is actually...
Speaker: kind of The... the lack of discrediting the election after the results kind of across the board as well. Do you think that's because...
Speaker: I mean, the Republicans just lost so big that it was... it it was impossible to say that or or even attempt to discredit the election. Do you think it's just because it was just too big a margin or has there been ah a change in the Republican Party towards elections?
Speaker: No, I do think it was it was too profound. a result and it was too widespread. across too many States. That.
Speaker: Otherwise, you wouldn't expect a to lose like they did. But I also think it was really critical. critical when the Trump administration, the the Justice Department, asked the Supreme Court to to force the issue on the on the on the Justice Department suing the state of California over those 20 ,000 voters that they thought might not be legal voters.
Speaker: And the Supreme Court. within I believe it was within two hours, essentially rejected the Justice Department's request emergency request. without comment.
Speaker: So what that did, I think, is it sent a very loud message. to the Trump administration and probably across the political the the political landscape generally. to say the court's not going to entertain.
Speaker: Any gaming. or any any any um any effort to mess around in the election or the election results. and so I think if there was an appetite to engage in any kind of.
Speaker: um You know. Gaming of the system if you will gaming of the of the election results on the part of the Trump administration They probably had that appetite. diminished by the Supreme Court's pretty quick.
Speaker: Um, decision. So normally in an emergency appeal like that. The Supreme Court would say to both sides, both parties. you know um Come. Come before the court within a day or two, three days. It's an emergency. We'll make this quick. Bring your Bring your arguments.
Speaker: the The Supreme Court didn't even ask for anything. They just said no. and i think that was a real loud message so i think the combination of a widespread. um set of results. across a lot of different jurisdictions where you wouldn't expect.
Speaker: Democrats to win. And the Supreme Court saying. We're not going to entertain any idea of messing around with the the election results. made for a very quiet night when it came to allegations of election fraud.
Speaker: on the part of the trump administration and you know you observe elections All the time. We were hearing a lot about this and there was a lot of concern that the that the Trump administration might try to do something.
Speaker: And so. you know looking ahead two years from now i'm i'm I'm thinking now. um The Supreme Court may be able to play a role, a similar role in the presidential election of 2028.
Speaker: if it needs to. because it it's pretty clear that the supreme court making the statement they made kind of settled things down in ways that were. If we had had that in 2020, that might have saved.
Speaker: some lives, actually. And you talk about an immediate response to the DOJ suing of the California government. Um, Within hours, the Supreme Court gets back to them.
Speaker: What wasn't an immediate response was the counting in Mississippi. It was on the 12th of November. that. Senator Colm was.
Speaker: Elected. Why does it take this long? The election was on the 3rd of November. The reason this one took so long is because the results were so close. so It is not.
Speaker: It is very common. In fact, there probably isn't a state That has certified its election results yet because Because...
Speaker: States typically leave a window of anywhere from, you know. 10 to 12 days. for overseas voters. to mail in their ballots and for their ballots to get to them and for them to be counted. and so Typically if one candidate wins an election by eight or ten points You don't really need to wait on those remaining four five ten fifteen twenty thousand votes to come from overseas
Speaker: and be counted because the results are so overwhelmingly i' clear. But in a case where you have an election that is won by 8 ,000 votes, the 10 or 12 ,000 votes from overseas voters may may may may be meaningful. and so that's the reason that the mississippi election didn't get called so ah for so many days because it was such a close election M -M - Again, I don't think any state has certified their election results yet because what happens is.
Speaker: After the deadline for all votes to be counted, then ballot machines are tested to make sure that they were counting properly. um you know there's there's an audit done of of ballots to ensure that that you know if a jurisdiction turned in 4 ,200 votes.
Speaker: then Then there's an audit to determine that there are 4 ,200 ballots. you know So there's a lot of back checking and auditing that goes on. Um, that that that that will take place for weeks after an election even though the election has been called And the the winner won by so many votes, nobody's even questioning it.
Speaker: Hmm. Well, that's all we have time for tonight. Thank you very much, Quinton, for joining us. i don't think you'll be joining us again actually unless there's some ah Some more US midterm news in the next couple of weeks.
Speaker: thank you for listening to the democracy volunteers podcast you can listen across all your major streaming apps i've been your host joshua paisley Thank you for listening.

