Zencastr
00:00:00
00:00:01
Speed1x
Format▸
Share
Embed
Report

US Midterm Election Debrief

The Democracy Volunteers Podcast
The Democracy Volunteers Podcast

13 plays · Nov 10, 2026

Transcript

Speaker: hello and welcome back to the democracy volunteers. podcast. Late last week, I had the opportunity to speak. Professor Quinton Kidd. to preview the US midterm elections. Now that the votes are in and they're beginning to be counted, I know Alaska is taking ages to to get us a result, but I'm delighted to welcome That's a Quentin kid back onto the podcast to discuss. the results.

Speaker: Quentin... As we speak the Democrats have won both the House and the Senate. the senate with 54 seats democrats and 240 seats for the democrats in the house Right. For our listeners who may not have been tuned in or wanted to stay up all night on Tuesday evening.

Speaker: How did we get to this point? So I think... um it's it's It's definitely... um historic in the sense that you know we haven't seen this kind of of of of one party taking seats.

Speaker: in the Senate, for example, from another party. We haven't seen this kind of turnover. you You can go back to the 1970s and Watergate or the early 1980s and the Ronald Reagan era to look for this kind of change.

Speaker: um I think it reflects a couple of things. I think it reflects Number one, the idea that the coalition that Donald Trump uh built in 2016 and then um And then also, ah ran on again in 2024.

Speaker: um was a little bit more fluid than maybe people um thought it was. And in the coalition, the the part of the coalition that was more fluid. is um a part of the coalition that was actually part of Barack Obama's coalition when he won.

Speaker: um in 2008. It was sort of a working class voter that would that would that a that was drawn to the populist. messages, um economic populist messages.

Speaker: Um, They believed Barack Obama in 2008 when he said he was going to sort of solve some of their economic challenges. um They abandon him.

Speaker: um when he didn't and went to Donald Trump. who who they believed was would solve some of their economic challenges. and and Trump the Trump administration and the president in particular made many decisions in their first two years.

Speaker: that convinced this coalition Dead. he really wasn't going to solve their economic challenges and he really wasn't. even focused on them, and they walked away from him in big numbers.

Speaker: um And... it Some of them just stayed home. um, but ah many of them actually shifted to voting for a Democratic candidate because they wanted to send a message. of frustration to Donald Trump.

Speaker: I don't think they were voting for Democrats. I think they were voting against Donald Trump. And that should be a a message of of warning to Democrats. you know you you have an opportunity it's a two -year opportunity what are you going to do with that Um, But I think they were largely voting against the president.

Speaker: ah more than voting for any given Democratic candidate. Hmm. Because the president has come out over the past few days and... almost kind of What? What he said is that he wasn't on the ballot.

Speaker: And that's the reason why the Republicans lost. Kansas... hasn't been democrats it's not a senate democrats since 1932. yeah And James Tallarico winning in Texas for the Senate.

Speaker: Texas hasn't been blue since 1988. Quentin, does that show... which policy issues were most important in this election. Yeah. Yes, I think it does. um ah for Texas um the the the Trump administration's Um...

Speaker: uh, ah inhumane approach. to finding immigrants on the streets and arresting them and deporting them, etc. That Really, really rankled. Hispanic voters, Latino voters.

Speaker: and And so you saw massive shifts in Latino votes away from Republican candidates toward Democratic candidates. Um, if you If you believe opinion polls and you believe, so I've watched leading up to these elections, I've watch i've watched about a dozen focus groups.

Speaker: And if and you listen to the focus groups and when the topic of immigration comes up. What you hear people say is, Well, we thought they were just going to get violent. criminals who were here illegally. off the streets.

Speaker: We didn't think that they were going to. um arrest you know the 65 year old lady who has been here for 45 years and raised a family and works and has never been in trouble.

Speaker: And so... That. That is. I think what explains a lot about Texas. um For Kansas, I think it's a slightly different story. It's the economic pain.

Speaker: of Kansas is largely a ah ah ah rural ah rural agricultural state. There's some industrial... um um aircraft manufacturing in Kansas, but it's largely a rural industrial rural agricultural state.

Speaker: the tariffs um and the war in Iran. That drove up fuel prices in particular diesel caused a lot of farmers to essentially say this is not going to work for us we can't Make a living.

Speaker: selling our you know wheat um or whatever you know whatever other product they were trying to sell when we're having to deal with tariffs constantly and we're having to pay. 60 % more for diesel than we were just a few months ago. And so I think there are different factors in different states.

Speaker: I think those are the two that explain Kansas and Texas. I think it's definitely worth for our UK listeners. Something that shocked me. Kind of. when you come to the US s and you see how big of a country it is you realize how all these states kind of have such different different features and ah as a result very different policy issues which are more important.

Speaker: than the others In our last conversation we talked about what the result might mean for campaigns going forward. and whether The campaign with Vivek Rameshwani kind of chose to operate whether that would show that you can be a bit more abrasive in your campaigns Um,

Speaker: What can we learn from campaigning because we As part of Democracy Volunteers, we attended Trump's speech at the Lincoln Memorial. um where he spent 20 minutes talking about algae.

Speaker: Looking to the presidential election in two years, what are kind of the fundamental answers that we've heard of how to campaign. Now. I think there's a mood in the country.

Speaker: that says um Let's back off a little bit. on the meanness um and the um and the mean spiritedness. and the dirtiness of campaigns um and and perhaps perhaps we've gotten our fill of a president who's crass and and and oftentimes seems to relish.

Speaker: The idea of being mean -spirited to somebody I do think there's a mood. Away from that right now um However, having said that, campaigns take on a life of their own and Candidates will get desperate.

Speaker: um And they will do desperate things because they're desperate. And I think that's what we saw in Ohio. with the Ramaswami campaign. I think that's what we saw. um in michigan a bit um there was a there was there was some xenophobic rhetoric um that was directed at the al -saeed campaign um and And you saw...

Speaker: bits and pieces of that in some of the other campaigns. But none of those candidates won. um I think the overriding reason had to do with them. a distaste for Trump and ah and an and ah an intention to send a message to Trump.

Speaker: but The message also gets sent to those campaigns that that kind of rhetoric isn't going to help you. And as much as you might. think or hope that it would. Hmm. And come January when...

Speaker: All these new Democratic senators and Congress people. are sworn in. What do the next two years... of politics look like for Trump and what can the Democrats actually do?

Speaker: So the Democrats are going kind of going to control both houses of Congress. They're not going to have veto -proof majorities. um And so... I think the best thing Democrats could do is pass legislation that does speak to the to the economic needs of voters.

Speaker: recognizing that A lot of that legislation perhaps will never become law because the president will veto it. But but Democrats at least have the ability to say this is what we did. This is what we tried I think the Democrats would make a mistake if they just focused on attempting to fight the president.

Speaker: um You know, if they they they may or may not try to impeach the president again, but if they just focused on fighting and investigating, I don't think that's going to do Democrats any good. as we approach the presidential election um in two years.

Speaker: I think Democrats are going to need to present some substance to voters. um and and and demonstrate that they at least tried to address some of the issues. and i And I will say this, I also think that if they did do that,

Speaker: some of that substance would actually become law. The President ah could very well sign some of that substance into law. um But um but. He'll never do that. if it isn't presented to him and so That's what I hope Democrats do. Um, They're, you know...

Speaker: um Holding investigations and and looking for the gotcha moment so that you're so that you're on TV. um is is like sugar and and candidates like that stuff. um Sometimes the... the hard work of you know producing a substantive piece of legislation doesn't get you on TV as much as you might want. So there's going to be a poll to do.

Speaker: you know, the the the the the the cute stuff that gets you on TV. But I hope... that there's some real work that goes on as well. Yeah, I think everyone's I think that is a very important question at the minute. What Democratic Party do we see? Do we see a witch hunt?

Speaker: to Trump or do we see a democratic party that is aiming to win the presidential election on the basis of policies of what they're able to do in the next two years. Yeah. Is there any inclination of the policies which... they will try to pass through kind of a lot looking at the president not looking at culture wars at the real kind of nitty -gritty aspects of politics is there any any kind of inclination Yeah, i've I've read. I've read.

Speaker: a few places where The Democrats. have this hundred hour agenda for when for when they... um Take control in January. And among that is...

Speaker: um to to bring back health care subsidies that the Trump administration and Republicans in Congress got rid of. and to roll back on some of the tax cuts that cause budget reductions.

Speaker: in some of the social safety net programs um Again, these things may not become law, um but at but at least Democrats will be able to say. We tried to do that. um But let me tell you, I think some of that stuff could become law. I think the president also recognizes, and I and i think some of the president's supporters recognize that.

Speaker: um rollbacks on health care subsidies actually hurt many of Republican voters. that were frustrated and then voted for Democrats to express their frustration. And so we may see some of that.

Speaker: um ah that some of that work become law. if Democrats present it to the president. Hmm. And... The queens are now turning to the presidency because even in watching the campaign for the midterms you do see that politicians are starting to position themselves ahead of the presidential primaries, which would be starting around early 2028.

Speaker: looking at Let's focus on the Republican Party for a minute. As you say, in your opinion, that the election was an anti -trapped vote. What does this mean for?

Speaker: The assumed front runners for the Republican primary... J .D. Vance and Ted Cruz. who are generally joined at the hip with Trump. what What does this mean for them?

Speaker: it's it's going to be really hard for them. And I would put Marco Rubio, the Secretary of State, in that group of like the three names that you often hear. um, um It's gonna be hard to distance themselves from Trump.

Speaker: for a couple of reasons. they have such a long record such a track record of um, you know, of of aligning themselves with. with ah the president um on some of his most radical.

Speaker: policy ideas. And so to to start to separate themselves might mean that they incur the wrath of Donald Trump in doing that, right? um but i but ah But I also think that It might...

Speaker: Look disingenuous by half. to voters. on the Republican side. I do believe that there is an appetite on the Republican side also to Um,

Speaker: to move beyond Donald Trump. and and And I, it would, it... They're... they're I don't know who that candidate would be, but I think it needs to be a candidate that has some credibility in their ability to move beyond Donald Trump. and so is JD Vance. credible enough, I think it would be hard to make that case.

Speaker: um Ted Cruz, it would be hard to make that case. um And so, you know There may be a name that emerges that we're not talking about yet. um and And here's what I'm getting at. Part of the reason that... um that uh that uh Ken Paxton lost in Texas.

Speaker: is that the Texas Republicans are really two camps. One camp is kind of the Trump cruise camp. And the other camp is more of the John Cornyn, the outgoing senator. um the george w bush the rick perry the former governor of texas camp they're more moderate what I would call classic economic Republicans, economic conservatives. and not so much culture warrior conservatives. And so...

Speaker: I think the Republican Party... base voter would be more interested in a classic economic conservative. um to move beyond the Trump era.

Speaker: than to have a culture warrior. who probably was really aligned with Trump on many things. to say, I'm now the one to move us beyond Donald Trump. And so I think you know just from - the large landscape i think it's going to be more of a classic economic conservative who's going to come out of probably we're not talking about that person right now come out of the woodworks to say you know here's Here's what I think we should do as ah as a Republican Party. And if that person has the right charisma, if they have the right resources.

Speaker: Um, then they could rise to the top. um You know, I always say campaigns are about luck, timing and resources. And so if the right person comes out, they have the right resources, and and I think the timing is probably right.

Speaker: They could be the candidate that that emerges to move beyond the Trump era. And they can also take the criticism of Trump. because they weren't part of Trump's camp anyway. and And now looking to the Democratic Party and the possible...

Speaker: presidential elections because it's so exciting we're having two new candidates for the presidency with obviously no incumbent. Yeah. has people such as James Tallarico kind of Winning Texas has has that thrown a cat amongst the pigeons as as we would say in the uk what What's the situation? and There are just so many front runners now in the democratic situation. Yeah, so the Democrats are in a different situation in the sense that they've been out. you know,

Speaker: out out for um for for It'll be four years. The former president, a Democratic president, is probably not going to play a big role.

Speaker: um you know that would be Joe Biden. And so the field is going to be wide open for Democrats. And I and i think you're going to have lots of people who are are willing to have their name bandied around, even if they're not going to seriously consider running. I think James Tallarico might be one of those.

Speaker: Abdul El -Sayed might be one of those, etc. You're going to have names like that in the mix, and and at the end of the day, they're not going to they're not going to run. um and and But people are going to take them seriously in some ways because That's what Barack Obama did. he he He won a seat to the U .S. Senate.

Speaker: And then within two years, he was running for president. and And so it's not impossible that that could happen. I just... I have a hard time seeing that right now. um Instead, I think you're going to get People like Gavin Newsom, the governor of California. You're going to get some of these names that you've already heard. Kamala Harris has talked about running again.

Speaker: You're going to have... At the end of the day, 12, maybe 14, maybe 16 people. who put their dip their toes in the water even if they don't end up running you know all the way through the primaries it's going to be an exciting time And it's going to be a debate between the progressive side of the of the party, which is Philly and Bolden right now.

Speaker: And the more moderate side of the party, which is which which says, look. you know, Progressivism is a little bit too far for us. We need to be more down the middle. um and so that's going to be the the sort of ideological debate within the democratic party how progressive Do we go? Do we have a democratic socialist?

Speaker: who runs for president or Do we nominate a more mainstream kind of moderate? Democrat. um That'll be the debate in the Democratic Party, I think. Hmm. And coming to the end of our kind of debrief of the midterms, which feels like we're covering all bases here.

Speaker: The last thing, which obviously as an as an electoral observation organisation there was a lot of talk around the election integrity. and the presence of DOJ observers and monitors across the nation.

Speaker: Are you surprised at the kind of... acceptance of the vote and the belief in the election integrity. um despite all the conversation about election integrity before.

Speaker: So, as an observer of elections in the United States. I'm not surprised. because The elections in this country have run really well for a long time.

Speaker: um And I think that is partly because We have a pretty decentralized. process for running elections. And I think that's that decentralization is part of what...

Speaker: um what caused um the the election system to hold in the in the face of of the Trump administration's pressure. um States run elections in the United States, not the federal government.

Speaker: Um, And in fact, most localities run their own elections. in states. um not the state centrally. And so we have a very decentralized process of running elections.

Speaker: um The states have very well organized rules and very well organized. ways of managing voter rolls. Um, and and so It was hard.

Speaker: for the federal government, the Trump administration, to inject themselves into that process. They tried. And. um part of the federal system, the federal nature of the of the political system in the United States. The court said no.

Speaker: On many occasions, including just a day before the election, the US Supreme Court. said no to the Trump administration about injecting themselves in the California election. And so.

Speaker: I think Part of what... held is The system itself, because it's decentralized, And the federal. the federal nature of the system held, the courts held.

Speaker: The states ran their elections. The elections have always been. pretty safe and and secure. Um, despite the rhetoric that you hear from the trump administration there's very very very few cases of actual voter fraud.

Speaker: um And there are very few cases of actual voter registration fraud. um in the grand scheme of things. you can You can find a few cases here and there. But in the grand scheme of 100 million votes being cast.

Speaker: it's It's really rare. And so I'm not surprised. um at at at at how well things worked and how. quickly Elections um are processed and the results are known.

Speaker: And in cases where the results are slower coming in, it's because of the nature of the way the state runs their elections, right? California, most people in California vote by mail. It takes time to process the mail.

Speaker: Alaska has a ranked choice voting system. And so um once all the votes are counted if if one of the candidates isn't above 50 percent Then they go to the second round and count the votes. dropping off the lowest um the candidate with the smallest number of votes so that takes time right so you can explain the delays by the nature of how a state runs their elections.

Speaker: All of it transparently. People can see how it's done. um and And it's all done pretty well. Yeah. Well, that's all we have time for, Quinton. Thank you very much for sparing 20 minutes or so to chat about the results of the election.

Speaker: Yep. Thank you. Thank you for listening to the Democracy Volunteers podcast. You can listen to the podcast across all your major streaming apps. I've been your host, Joshua Paisley. And thank you very much.

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Recommended