Become a Creator today!Start creating today - Share your story with the world!
Start for free
00:00:00
00:00:01
53 - Selective Breeding and the Birth of Philosophy
2.9k Plays1 year ago
Selective Breeding and the Birth of Philosophy is BAP's dissertation, which has been floating around as a PDF for several years, but which you can now pay to read here: https://amzn.to/3QqB7xK
It is a decent summary of the insights that have made BAP one of the most important ideological figures of this generation.
Recommended
Transcript
Introduction to the Podcast and Dissertation
00:00:17
Speaker
Hey everybody, welcome to the Exit Podcast.
00:00:19
Speaker
This is Dr. Bennett.
00:00:20
Speaker
Just finished reading Kostin Alomariou's Selective Breeding and the Birth of Philosophy.
00:00:26
Speaker
This is BAPS dissertation.
00:00:28
Speaker
It's been available for a long time online, but I wanted to wait until I could pay $30 to read it.
00:00:33
Speaker
It's a fascinating read.
00:00:34
Speaker
If you're familiar with the podcast, it's...
Philosophers' Predicament in Ancient Greece
00:00:38
Speaker
in large part an articulation of things that he's already said, but to see it laid out carefully for the benefit of a maybe neutral to hostile audience, you can feel how it forces him to clarify his position and it snaps a lot of things into place.
00:00:54
Speaker
And the dissertation is ostensibly making this narrow historical point, basically that Socrates was executed for a reason, that the prejudice of the ancient Greek states against philosophers was essentially justified.
00:01:08
Speaker
But in the process of making that point, he pretty much lays out his whole deal.
00:01:12
Speaker
Which is also Nietzsche's deal.
00:01:13
Speaker
He's characterized himself as a popularizer of Nietzsche.
00:01:17
Speaker
And Nietzsche was obsessed with the production of genius, the production of high culture.
00:01:21
Speaker
He basically believed that the products of genius are all that can justify human existence, that ordinary life is so depraved and so bovine that it has essentially no value in itself.
00:01:33
Speaker
He argues that the emergence of genius is the consequence of an aristocratic culture, and by culture we mean that in the same sense as like horticulture or agriculture, the cultivation, the breeding, and nurturing and pruning of a particular biological type, a particular type of person.
Aristocratic Culture and Genius Breeding
00:01:50
Speaker
He explains how these aristocratic cultures emerged, why they evolved into these breeding programs for genius and other cultures didn't,
00:01:58
Speaker
And then he makes the case that the philosopher and the tyrant are the consummation, the inevitable conclusion of this aristocratic breeding program, that they're very closely related phenomena and that they may in fact be the same thing.
00:02:11
Speaker
So why does BAP care about this?
00:02:13
Speaker
Why should we care about this?
00:02:14
Speaker
Well, you can disagree with Nietzsche and with BAP when they say that high culture and genius are all that matters, that ordinary life is totally without justification.
00:02:24
Speaker
And you can disagree with them when they say that the production of genius, of beauty, of high culture is 100% biological.
00:02:32
Speaker
But if you think that high culture matters at all, and if you think that human heredity,
00:02:37
Speaker
is relevant to that at all.
00:02:39
Speaker
Then you look around, you see what's happening, and you think, clearly this problem they've identified matters, even if it's not the whole show the way that they think it's the whole show.
00:02:48
Speaker
And really the only escape that I can see from their fundamental conclusions is the concept of miracle, the concept of human and divine agency.
00:02:56
Speaker
acting outside the bounds of the principles of nature as we observe them and understand them.
Critique of Biological Determinism in High Culture
00:03:00
Speaker
And by that I mean free will.
00:03:02
Speaker
Free will is intractable to empirical analysis.
00:03:04
Speaker
It's essentially magic.
00:03:06
Speaker
There's not a scientific way to talk about it or even think about it.
00:03:09
Speaker
But if you step outside that frame, it's like if we're just biological machines, if we're just monkeys, then it seems like Nietzsche has a pretty good grip on what kind of monkeys we are.
00:03:19
Speaker
And from where I'm coming from in my faith, the life of a monkey, the materialistic, naturalistic, fully constrained, fully mechanistic life, is essentially the way that people live in the absence of faith.
00:03:32
Speaker
So it's not just that he explains some counterfactual reality that I don't believe in.
00:03:37
Speaker
He's actually explaining the way that life works for most people in the same way that Nietzsche criticizes Darwin for explaining only a particular kind of life, maybe only life in England.
00:03:47
Speaker
He says that basically Darwin characterizes all life as this bare, constrained struggle for mere survival because that is the type of life and the type of thinking that prevails under the conditions of like the overpopulated Malthusian filth of like 19th century Liverpool.
00:04:05
Speaker
But even if that's not the way everything lives, it's worth knowing about that kind of life if a lot of things live that
Cultural Norms and Modern Breeding Systems
00:04:11
Speaker
way.
00:04:11
Speaker
You don't have to swallow it whole or make it your all-consuming theory of everything.
00:04:16
Speaker
So what are the most pressing problems that he identifies?
00:04:18
Speaker
Clearly something has gone seriously wrong with family formation.
00:04:22
Speaker
Bapp says in the preface that breeding is the foundation of all law.
00:04:25
Speaker
The rules that determine who gets a mate and how define which traits and virtues become the defining characteristics of the people.
00:04:32
Speaker
And so he says the question of who gets to breed is the only political question, identical to the question of regime, constitution, or foundation as such.
00:04:41
Speaker
And this can be defined explicitly and coercively by policy, or it can be defined culturally through ordinary people's understanding of who is desirable and undesirable, who receives the resources to breed.
00:04:51
Speaker
And he says this process is cruel, necessarily cruel, because no matter what you do, there will always be hierarchies in sexual desire.
00:04:59
Speaker
There will always be those who get picked to play or picked to play more often, and those who don't.
00:05:04
Speaker
And being cut off, especially permanently cut off from reproduction, is one of the most devastating psychological experiences.
00:05:10
Speaker
Historically, selection was mostly a question of attrition through disease, warfare, famine.
00:05:15
Speaker
And we'll also talk about these aristocratic breeding cultures that made deliberate policy decisions about who got to breed.
00:05:21
Speaker
And those regimes were definitely cruel, no question.
00:05:24
Speaker
But BAT points out that in terms of how many people get picked and how many people get shut out,
00:05:31
Speaker
It's not obvious that our modern way of making these decisions is any gentler.
00:05:34
Speaker
The cruelty is distributed across millions of one-on-one interactions, but anybody who's familiar with Tinder acknowledges that it's a deeply cruel process.
00:05:42
Speaker
And at least these pre-modern regimes were selecting for something.
00:05:45
Speaker
They were selecting for some excellence, or at least selecting for physical robustness and resilience.
Modern Societal Forces Against Excellence
00:05:51
Speaker
He says,
00:06:11
Speaker
The laws were meant to harmonize or coordinate man's intense desire for sexual love and for posterity with the regime's overarching goals and its needs.
00:06:20
Speaker
They were meant to promote certain qualities that were seen to be and probably were hereditary, and which the regime intended to promote in the population.
00:06:27
Speaker
We are now driven instead by a different and more primitive law, and this, in combination with poorly thought out government programs, is creating a certain type of man and society as well, only no one yet knows exactly what.
00:06:39
Speaker
So one reason to care about the contents of this dissertation is that our breeding system, which we should acknowledge is a system, is badly dysfunctional.
00:06:48
Speaker
In its own way, it's as vicious as the breeding program of Sparta, and like the Spartan system, it's shutting out so many people, male and female, that demographic collapses on the horizon.
00:06:57
Speaker
But unlike the Spartan system, it doesn't seem to serve any higher purpose.
00:07:00
Speaker
In fact, it seems completely destructive.
00:07:02
Speaker
We're not sending our best.
00:07:04
Speaker
Besides which, you can just look around you and see that there seem to be forces that are at war with the concept of distinction itself.
00:07:10
Speaker
That are at war with the idea that some things are good and others are bad.
00:07:14
Speaker
And I'm not even talking about morally good or bad.
00:07:16
Speaker
I'm talking about it's better not to have sterilizing birth defects or it's better to be sighted than blind.
00:07:23
Speaker
This oppressive, moralizing, safety-obsessed gynocracy that wants to cut down all the tall poppies and preserve and proliferate every kind of dysfunction, every kind of sickness that you can possibly imagine.
00:07:38
Speaker
And this is what Bapp calls the longhouse, and he calls it that because he believes that this is the primordial state of human beings, the default to which they descend in the absence of this quest for excellence.
Humanity's Default Condition: The Longhouse
00:07:50
Speaker
And you can disagree with the historical details, and maybe you can argue that Bapp and Nietzsche are sort of uniquely neurotic, uniquely sensitive, uniquely depressive, but that does seem to give them the ability to observe and talk about this phenomenon at a level of resolution,
00:08:06
Speaker
and with a clarity that maybe eludes, frankly, healthier, happier people.
00:08:11
Speaker
But the thing they're talking about is clearly real.
00:08:13
Speaker
It's right in front of us.
00:08:14
Speaker
And so you have to deal with a lot of their conclusions, especially, he wouldn't call them moral conclusions, but his value conclusions, the ways that he thinks people ought to live, and the ways that society ought to be organized.
00:08:25
Speaker
You have to take that, I think, in the context of how incapable he is of appreciating ordinary life and how much revulsion he feels at it.
00:08:33
Speaker
And if you take his view, maybe you argue that that's the truth.
00:08:36
Speaker
The truth is actually dark and dismal, and ordinary life is in fact useless, meaningless, hideous.
00:08:42
Speaker
And anyone who appreciates that is sort of cattle-like.
00:08:46
Speaker
But even if you don't take his view, this longhouse, this war on distinction, is something that we're all up against.
00:08:54
Speaker
And if you care about excellence and you care about beauty, then this should matter.
00:08:58
Speaker
All right, so what is the longhouse in the historical context?
00:09:02
Speaker
The longhouse is the default human condition, the substrate from which all human civilization emerges.
00:09:08
Speaker
It's little tribes of people huddled together in terror and danger and darkness, clinging to survival and therefore clinging desperately to traditions and folkways that keep their community cohesive, that keep them safe, keep them doing what they've always done and what has worked so far.
00:09:24
Speaker
Any individuation, any deviation, any willfulness, any inequality threatens the community.
00:09:30
Speaker
And it's punished with a brutality and an intensity commensurate with the overall environment of terror that they live in.
00:09:38
Speaker
And this architecture of convention and customs and gods and rituals and genealogies and oral histories that explain this is what we've always done, this is how we do it, this is what happens to you if you don't do it, that whole architecture is called nomos, which is variously translated as law or convention or custom, but it goes way beyond law or custom as we understand them.
00:10:04
Speaker
It's
00:10:05
Speaker
not only impossible to escape, it's impossible in some sense for these people to even imagine escaping.
00:10:11
Speaker
It's like the psychological capacity to consciously deviate from custom hasn't really developed yet.
Shamans and Sacral Kings in Society
00:10:18
Speaker
But the first glimmers of individuation, what we would think of as consciousness, is in the person of the shaman or magician character who's just a little bit more wily, a little bit more complex, a little bit more imaginative than the rest.
00:10:31
Speaker
who either knowingly or unknowingly starts making things up.
00:10:34
Speaker
They come up with explanations for things.
00:10:36
Speaker
They put themselves through exotic experiences, either with asceticism or drugs, and their role as the repository of ritual and truth for the tribe gives them this position of higher status.
00:10:48
Speaker
If you've seen the movie The Invention of Lying by Ricky Gervais, it's sort of an exploration of this shaman character.
00:10:53
Speaker
He lives in a world where lying hasn't been invented, and he sort of speedruns the process of developing from the shaman to the sacral king.
00:11:01
Speaker
You know, you have to sleep with me or the world's going to end, and you have to give me money and all this stuff.
00:11:05
Speaker
And he basically becomes a millionaire and gets the girl, and lives happily ever after.
00:11:10
Speaker
And a lot of the tension in the movie is created by two things.
00:11:13
Speaker
Number one, the people around him holding him to the lies that he's told, holding him to the things that he said.
00:11:20
Speaker
And number two, his own discomfort with lying, his unwillingness to lie in certain circumstances.
00:11:25
Speaker
And so it's sort of an exaggerated and accelerated version of the psychological development of the shaman in history.
00:11:33
Speaker
The real shaman isn't that psychologically distinct from the tribe.
00:11:36
Speaker
They're more sophisticated relative to him, and he's also definitely still a product of his culture, definitely still enslaved to the nomos.
Pastoral vs. Agrarian Societal Values
00:11:45
Speaker
Our image of the sacral king, the god king in Babylon or Egypt or something,
00:11:50
Speaker
It's like he's God, he can do what he wants.
00:11:52
Speaker
But in fact, those roles were very tightly constrained within the cultural expectations of that role.
00:12:00
Speaker
And actually, in a lot of cases, performed almost an entirely ritual function where, yeah, he gets to have sex with a virgin at a particular point in the season to make sure the harvest comes in.
00:12:11
Speaker
But otherwise, he's nobody particularly special.
00:12:14
Speaker
And in fact, this sacral king is often under much tighter constraints and heavier penalties than the rest of the tribe as a condition of inhabiting this privileged position within the tribe.
00:12:24
Speaker
So maybe the tribe isn't quite sophisticated enough to really cotton on to the fact that this guy is just lying.
00:12:31
Speaker
But they're sophisticated enough to have some like intuitive guardrails up to keep that guy from getting too big for his britches.
00:12:40
Speaker
So you've got these egalitarian, communitarian, democratic societies governed entirely by consensus and tradition.
00:12:48
Speaker
Almost literally like a herd huddled as tightly as possible together to protect itself from predators.
00:12:54
Speaker
And through the shaman, through the institutions of religion, you eventually get oriental despotism and, you know, like the bureaucracies of China.
00:13:04
Speaker
But these aren't aristocracies of the type that Nietzsche is concerned about because they don't become free from the culture that produces them.
00:13:12
Speaker
Their function remains managerial and religious.
00:13:15
Speaker
They're still bound to the constraints of the nomos that created them.
00:13:21
Speaker
So that's his vision of human life purely concerned with its own preservation, purely concerned with its own comfort.
00:13:28
Speaker
It's ruled by women and old people and the priorities of women and old people.
00:13:32
Speaker
And it's psychologically inescapable from the inside.
00:13:35
Speaker
But, he says, in certain cases, pastoral societies had an opportunity to develop differently.
00:13:42
Speaker
So these are itinerant herding societies that live on marginal lands that are good for grazing but not farming.
00:13:51
Speaker
And they follow a different trajectory than the agrarian democratic communisms for a couple of reasons.
00:13:58
Speaker
First of all, pastoralism involves intimate contact and intimate violence against less complex forms of life.
00:14:05
Speaker
A hunter kills an animal out in the wild, but that's not exactly the same thing psychologically as raising an animal from birth for the purpose of killing and eating it.
00:14:14
Speaker
There's a simultaneous intimacy and a distance that has to be maintained there.
00:14:18
Speaker
You have to understand very well how this creature acts, what it needs, and then when the time comes, you have to cut its throat.
00:14:25
Speaker
And as these lambs or these goats or these cattle iterate over the course of a single human lifetime, you get to see that this sheep produces particularly abundant or particularly soft wool, and this sheep produces much more milk.
00:14:39
Speaker
And then as those sheep have descendants, you get to see them grow up and see them inherit the same traits.
00:14:44
Speaker
You get to discover heredity.
00:14:46
Speaker
You learn that one sheep is like another in some ways, they're different in others.
00:14:50
Speaker
You learn that a sheep is like you in some ways and unlike you in others.
00:14:54
Speaker
There are things you can teach a sheep to do, there are things you can't teach a sheep to do.
00:14:58
Speaker
And this is the beginning of an understanding of nature, that all forms of life have an essence of being that makes them what they are, and importantly that there's a hierarchy of higher and lower.
00:15:09
Speaker
The
Aristocratic Sensibilities in Pastoral Societies
00:15:10
Speaker
shepherd also achieves physical distance from village life by virtue of needing to go out and find grazing territory for the livestock.
00:15:17
Speaker
So you can imagine the healthy young man up on the hilltop looking down at the sheep and also looking down at the village at some remove.
00:15:25
Speaker
I'm up here, they're down there.
00:15:27
Speaker
I can see them, they can't see me.
00:15:30
Speaker
And if I go just a little bit further around this bend, I can be alone.
00:15:34
Speaker
And so this physical distance from the village also creates the possibility of some psychological distance from the gnomos, the convention of the village.
00:15:43
Speaker
There's also just way more variation in outcomes possible with herds than with crops.
00:15:48
Speaker
There's a limit to how much produce can be created by one person under human power out of the ground.
00:15:54
Speaker
But the limitations of the size of a herd that you or a group of people can guard or steal is much more relaxed, and it's closer to the concept of interpersonal violence.
00:16:05
Speaker
So the size of your output is no longer a function of just your effort.
00:16:09
Speaker
It's a function of your prowess, your ability to take things violently, both psychologically and physically, your ability to sneak and thieve and lie and misdirect.
00:16:22
Speaker
Besides which, these young men subsisting on milk and meat are also just going to be physically bigger and stronger than anyone living an agrarian lifestyle.
00:16:31
Speaker
So eventually, under these conditions of loose, intermittent contact with the village and existence outside of the village's enforcement mechanisms, combined with these immense incentives to act against the Nomos, potential rewards for breaking the rules, acting independently, these young men become the first human beings to break away psychologically from the Nomos.
00:16:55
Speaker
This starts with cattle rustling, eventually develops into various other forms of predation, including slavery.
00:17:02
Speaker
And this is a messy, lossy process.
00:17:05
Speaker
A society in which every individual is a sociopath, just taking what he wants is not sustainable.
00:17:10
Speaker
So in most cases, you have this gang of young men who sort of ride into town, eat whatever they can take, and the tribe disperses, collapses.
00:17:21
Speaker
There's not a way for it to sustain itself under that kind of threat.
00:17:25
Speaker
But in a few cases, maybe you imagine an exceptional crew of bandits who managed to hold the tribe together and actually rewrite the nomos.
00:17:32
Speaker
They produce new values that justify the subjugation, the conquest, the inequality.
00:17:38
Speaker
And so this tribe, animated by these new values, turns the predatory impulse outward.
00:17:44
Speaker
So instead of being just this loose, valueless youth gang, you get an actual culture and an actual society whose values keep it cohesive on the inside and violent on the outside.
00:17:55
Speaker
I'm quoting here,
00:18:25
Speaker
Now the assumption here is that surplus required for creativity and contemplation can only be created by slavery.
00:18:32
Speaker
And I don't know if I buy that.
00:18:33
Speaker
It seems like particularly with the incorporation of animal power, you can imagine people becoming prosperous without slavery, although they would have to get pretty proficient at defending their herds and their wealth.
00:18:45
Speaker
But the really essential development in this pastoral conquering society is the development of the pathos of distance.
00:18:53
Speaker
This is the ability of the aristocratic culture to view the subject cultures from above and from outside.
00:18:59
Speaker
Anyway, he gives a few examples of pastoral tribes in history.
00:19:04
Speaker
One of them is the Tutsi in Rwanda.
00:19:06
Speaker
who were these Nilotic herders who conquered the agrarian Hutu.
00:19:11
Speaker
He says,
00:19:26
Speaker
The Tutsi dedicate themselves entirely to warfare and administration.
00:19:30
Speaker
They despise manual labor and endeavor to spend as much of their lives in conspicuous leisure as possible.
00:19:36
Speaker
Tacitus describes the Germanic raiders as not easily persuaded to plow the earth and to wait for the year's produce as to challenge an enemy and earn the honor of wounds.
00:19:45
Speaker
They actually think it tame and stupid to acquire by the sweat of toil what they might win by their blood.
00:19:50
Speaker
And if their own tribe sinks into the sloth of prolonged peace and repose, many of its noble youths voluntarily seek those tribes which are waging some war, both because inaction is odious to their race and because they win renown more readily in the midst of peril and cannot maintain a numerous following except by violence and war.
00:20:08
Speaker
He also describes the Nuristanis in Afghanistan who preserve this Indo-European pastoral and aristocratic sensibility as kind of a fossil all the way up until the Islamic conquest.
00:20:21
Speaker
So the Nuristanis have two social classes, the ruling landowning herders and the artisans and servants.
00:20:29
Speaker
Their religion has this radical dualism between the sacred and the profane, the male and the female.
00:20:35
Speaker
The high places are good, the low valleys are bad.
00:20:39
Speaker
Wild goats are better than domesticated animals.
00:20:41
Speaker
Raw meat is better than cooked meat.
00:20:43
Speaker
Light is better than darkness.
00:20:45
Speaker
Men do all the tending of the animals and all of the public, religious, and martial duties, and women do all the household chores and farming.
00:20:52
Speaker
And men are expected to spend time up in the high mountain pastures to purify themselves from the pollution, the corruption of life down in the valley.
00:21:01
Speaker
So you can see this clear mapping of the pastoral to the masculine and the agrarian to the feminine.
Transition from Matriarchal to Patriarchal Values
00:21:08
Speaker
The sky father rules over the mountaintops and the high, cold, austere places.
00:21:14
Speaker
And then there's the earth mother governing the green, warm, populated valleys.
00:21:19
Speaker
Bap mentions elsewhere the contrast between the agrarian Han Chinese and the Tibetan pastoralists who had conquered them in the past.
00:21:26
Speaker
And this is, you know, this is a contemporary account.
00:21:30
Speaker
The Chinese conquered Tibet in 1950.
00:21:33
Speaker
But it says, "...female Han Chinese respondents emphasized physicality in their descriptions of Tibetan men, whom they described as having strong bodies and being very manly, handsome, and brave."
00:21:43
Speaker
The women viewed the Tibetans as bigger, taller, stronger, darker-skinned, rougher, more masculine, and more loyal than other men.
00:21:50
Speaker
And this is where it gets really interesting.
00:21:52
Speaker
Instead of describing the masculine in reference to the feminine, Tibetan men repeatedly contrasted their masculinity with that of Han Chinese men.
00:22:00
Speaker
So there's a sense in which societies as well as individuals manifest masculine virtue, and they come to look upon these subject populations as not only governed by women, but womanish in their subordinate position.
00:22:12
Speaker
The feminine society is the one that's concerned with survival and cohesion, everyone staying together seeking to avoid harm or conflict.
00:22:20
Speaker
The masculine society is concerned with excellence and is willing to suffer and inflict some harm to get there.
00:22:25
Speaker
And this roughly, I think, maps to the roles of fathers and mothers, how they raise children, and where they stereotypically disagree.
Aristocratic vs. Democratic Values
00:22:32
Speaker
Now what I find confusing about this is that, as far as I can tell, in Bap's view, all human society began as matriarchal and feminine in its values.
00:22:41
Speaker
It was very stifling, harm-avoidant, risk-averse, until this masculine perspective broke free and rebelled and subjugated feminine cultures by force.
00:22:53
Speaker
And given how psychologically durable and ubiquitous patriarchy has proven to be, it's a little bit hard to imagine how these matriarchies were established in the first place.
00:23:04
Speaker
Maybe he would argue that it's sort of the disinterest of men, their neglect of the community and its institutions.
00:23:10
Speaker
Sort of like you see in a lot of places in Africa now where the men sort of drift in and out of the community and they have a couple girlfriends, baby mamas, but they're not in any position of authority in their families or in their communities and they don't exactly want to be.
00:23:26
Speaker
He talks a lot about the Australian aboriginals and Kalahari Bushmen and the logic that extrapolates that back to our own distant historical past is kind of hard to falsify.
00:23:39
Speaker
Like maybe that's how these tribes worked, but how would you know?
00:23:42
Speaker
It seems like it's just sort of taken for granted that these matriarchal societies are living fossils and that that's how we know where we came from.
00:23:49
Speaker
And he's, you know, he's more of a student of this topic than I am, obviously.
00:23:54
Speaker
Like maybe he can show me like the chipped bone or the chunk of pottery that proves that this is the way, you know, people lived in Neolithic France.
00:24:03
Speaker
But I just don't think it makes like a ton of intuitive sense.
00:24:06
Speaker
Anyway, so these pastoral warrior bandits conquer the sedentary tribes.
00:24:11
Speaker
and they find themselves once again like the young shepherds on the hilltop looking at another culture from above and from the outside.
00:24:19
Speaker
But this time, instead of a binary choice to embrace or reject the gnomos, they already have their own codified gnomos to compare with the gnomos of the conquered peasants.
00:24:29
Speaker
And eventually they conquer multiple villages and they see that there are ways of doing things and gods and rituals here that are not practiced there.
00:24:37
Speaker
And the aristocratic nomos, the aristocratic culture, is not only different from the conquered regime in the sense that the gods have different names and are propitiated in different ways.
00:24:46
Speaker
It's genuinely oriented around a different notion of the good.
00:24:49
Speaker
He talks about how the democratic, communitarian notion of the good is essentially subtractive.
00:24:56
Speaker
It's the absence of predation, the absence of threat.
00:24:59
Speaker
It's a state of rest, of comfort.
00:25:02
Speaker
And this extends all the way to the notion of heaven, that heaven is a place of eternal rest, a place without danger, a place without work, a place without conflict.
00:25:10
Speaker
Whereas the aristocratic notion of the good is strength and overcoming and conquering.
00:25:16
Speaker
And the consummation of life is to do great deeds and to have those deeds exalt you to become like the gods, to have the intensity and the glory of being that a god has.
00:25:27
Speaker
So how does this different notion of the good develop?
00:25:30
Speaker
The aristocratic culture is still under the same survival pressures, the same environment of danger that pushed the democratic egalitarian tribes towards safety and conformity, but the circumstances are a little bit different.
00:25:43
Speaker
First of all, they're wildly outnumbered by their subject populations.
00:25:46
Speaker
They can't compete for quantity.
00:25:48
Speaker
They also aren't the only game in town.
00:25:50
Speaker
The threats facing them from other conquerors, including sort of their wilder cousins on the steppe, are anti-inductive, meaning that once you figure out how to deal with it, it finds a new way to come at you.
00:26:02
Speaker
They also live among the subject people.
00:26:05
Speaker
And in many cases, the failure mode, famously with the Mongol conquerors, is finding a high-status position within that culture, settling in, getting comfortable,
00:26:15
Speaker
and completely losing the edge that made them conquerors in the first
Prioritizing Human Quality in Aristocratic Cultures
00:26:18
Speaker
place.
00:26:18
Speaker
And then some other Mongol tribe views them rightly as weak and decadent and Chinese and conquers them again.
00:26:27
Speaker
And this process fails over and over in exactly this way.
00:26:30
Speaker
The conquering population becomes decadent and soft and they're conquered anew by their still wild cousins on the steppe.
00:26:38
Speaker
So to recap, in order to survive, the conquerors can't prioritize quantity over quality, they can't optimize for stasis and stability, and they have to remain separate.
00:26:49
Speaker
They can't conform to the overwhelming majority of people around them who are subjugated foreigners.
00:26:56
Speaker
And so in order to stay connected to their own culture and maintain both closeness within the aristocratic culture and distance from the conquered peasants,
00:27:06
Speaker
They become very well-traveled and they stay in constant contact with each other across long distances.
00:27:10
Speaker
He says, the Indo-European and Hurrian princes in the Levant maintain surprisingly close connections with each other over distances of hundreds of miles, exchanging not only lavish gifts but also daughters and sisters in marriage.
00:27:22
Speaker
They start to develop a taste for the exotic, for the resources and the arts and the cultural products of these far-flung cousins of theirs.
00:27:31
Speaker
And since they can't compete on quantity,
00:27:34
Speaker
The aristocratic nomos turns toward an obsession with individual human quality.
00:27:38
Speaker
Like, we didn't get here by being numerous, we got here by being the best.
00:27:42
Speaker
We got here by being dangerous as individuals.
00:27:45
Speaker
And the character of those values begins with two concepts, Andrea and phronesis.
00:27:50
Speaker
Andrea means virtue or valor.
00:27:52
Speaker
It means manly courage and prowess in combat.
00:27:57
Speaker
What makes you a man as distinct from a woman?
00:27:59
Speaker
What are you built to do?
00:28:00
Speaker
You're built for violence.
00:28:01
Speaker
The bones in your head are built to withstand blows.
00:28:05
Speaker
Your fists are built to swing sticks and throw rocks and to be used as clubs.
00:28:09
Speaker
Your hormonal environment is designed to encourage you toward violence, encourage you toward risk-taking.
00:28:16
Speaker
to insulate you from the psychological negative consequences of violence both against yourself and the kind of violence that you inflict on other people.
00:28:23
Speaker
And so a well-turned-out man, a good man, meaning a man who's good at being a man, possesses Andrea.
00:28:30
Speaker
He's well-engineered toward his purpose as...
00:28:34
Speaker
killer.
00:28:35
Speaker
And phronesis is the ability to give good counsel in war.
00:28:38
Speaker
It's a type of wisdom about practical action, a type of foresight.
00:28:42
Speaker
Bapp spends a lot of time on a pre-Socratic poet, Pindar, who he argues is the best example of the Greek aristocratic culture and values before they began to be examined and abstracted and radicalized and subverted by philosophy.
00:28:59
Speaker
Pindar was paid by the aristocracy to create these poems of praise of their great deeds.
00:29:07
Speaker
And so Bapp argues that this is a pretty good indicator of what they actually valued because it's what they were willing to pay to have somebody else say about them in public.
00:29:16
Speaker
And in Pindar, Andrea is represented by the lion.
00:29:20
Speaker
You could say naked force, brute strength.
00:29:22
Speaker
And Phronesis is represented by the fox.
00:29:25
Speaker
So this is cunning and creativity and audacity.
00:29:28
Speaker
And so the Nomos, which is still backward-looking, it's still about custom, it's still about tradition, it's still about genealogy.
00:29:37
Speaker
But instead of thinking about what did our ancestors do that kept them safe, it's like, who were the great men?
00:29:44
Speaker
Who were the mightiest warriors?
00:29:45
Speaker
Who were the greatest counselors in war?
00:29:48
Speaker
Stasis won't keep us safe.
00:29:49
Speaker
We can't be safe.
00:29:50
Speaker
We're surrounded by these intelligent, active human threats.
00:29:56
Speaker
So the way we survive, the way we stay safe, so to speak, is by becoming extraordinarily personally dangerous.
00:30:02
Speaker
And the purpose of the primordial lawgiver, like Lycurgus of Sparta or Solomon of Athens, is to be the one who actually synthesizes everything that's worked thus far, what makes a great man, and to say, here's how we get more of that person.
Mythology and Aristocratic Excellence
00:30:16
Speaker
And to some extent that involves drilling and training and self-denial in the same sense that growing a tree involves pruning.
00:30:24
Speaker
But the natural health of the tree, what kind of tree it actually is, and the quality of the tree, that comes first.
00:30:31
Speaker
You can make a healthy tree realize its full potential through pruning, but doing that to a sickly or a stunted tree won't make it a healthy tree.
00:30:40
Speaker
So the training of second nature, the education of these aristocrats is important, but first nature comes first.
00:30:46
Speaker
People often think of the Spartan state as the most obsessive about eugenics, but actually what sets them apart is how obsessive they were about the drills and the discipline and the cult of the state that orients the innate biological material that you've developed toward the state's aims.
00:31:02
Speaker
But the Greek aristocracies all over were just as obsessed with human quality.
00:31:06
Speaker
And one of the things Pindar reveals is that the aristocracy sees itself ruling because it is physically, intellectually, and spiritually superior, that such virtue or arete cannot be taught, and that it is a matter of blood, of birth, and of nature.
00:31:20
Speaker
But this is not something that they said out loud or told themselves.
00:31:25
Speaker
In their value system, rule is just a fact.
00:31:28
Speaker
It justifies itself.
00:31:30
Speaker
If you have to explain why you deserve to rule, then you've already lost the plot.
00:31:33
Speaker
So superiority is a matter of breeding.
00:31:36
Speaker
They know that the blood of the heir contains, in some sense, the accumulated excellence of the line that he comes from.
00:31:45
Speaker
But excellence has to be manifest.
00:31:47
Speaker
And this creates an obvious tension between the aristocracy that rules in fact and the upstarts who want to make them prove that they deserve to rule in the contest.
00:31:57
Speaker
Bap compares Agamemnon holding the dead scepter of tradition, the scepter of his rule, against Achilles swearing by a sprouting bough, a sprouting tree branch, symbolic of the living reality of nature.
00:32:11
Speaker
And it's not that the aristocratic culture itself holds established hereditary claims to power in contempt.
00:32:19
Speaker
It just maybe views them as more contingent or up for debate.
00:32:23
Speaker
Arete, which is the excellence that defines the word aristocracy, doesn't just mean to do well, but to do better, to excel or overcome others.
00:32:29
Speaker
And it has to be proven in the agone, which is the contest.
00:32:33
Speaker
But it would still be a mistake to view this as like a meritocracy.
00:32:37
Speaker
Because both the hereditary aristocrat and the upstart are playing the same game of breeding.
00:32:42
Speaker
They wouldn't use the term reversion to the mean, of course, but they recognize that the unimpressive son from an aristocratic family carries a different biological inheritance than, say, an unusually brave or competent slave.
00:32:56
Speaker
They recognize that sometimes greatness skips a generation.
00:32:59
Speaker
There's a particular story where a man has accomplished some great deeds in the Agone, and he's described as manifesting an inborn nature handed down from his grandfather, who had done similar things.
00:33:11
Speaker
It says, Nature hides, lays dormant, occasionally manifests itself in explosive actions.
00:33:17
Speaker
And so to be obsessed with one's immediate heirs would be to miss the point because the fire is carried in populations.
00:33:24
Speaker
It doesn't breed true.
00:33:26
Speaker
Whatever is in your nature to do, you'd better do it.
00:33:29
Speaker
And on the subject of family and children, Bap definitely downplays the role of domestic life and says that these heroic types should not be interested in matters of the home.
00:33:40
Speaker
But when marriage is discussed in Pindar, it's oriented around the development of excellence.
00:33:45
Speaker
It's not an end in itself.
00:33:47
Speaker
One of Pindar's poems is a retelling of the story of Pelops and Inumaeus.
00:33:51
Speaker
Inumaeus is this mighty monster of a king who heard a prophecy that he'd be killed by his son-in-law, and so he challenges all his daughter's suitors to a chariot race, and he defeats all 18 of them and has them all executed.
00:34:03
Speaker
And Pelops overcomes him, but what's important about that is not that Enemaus is evil, but that he's mighty.
00:34:09
Speaker
He's this strong, dangerous force of will, even being presumably, you know, a couple decades older than the people that he's in conflict with.
00:34:19
Speaker
Like, it's not just that he won a bride, it's that he took his bride by force from a mighty king, which is indicative both of his quality and of her quality.
00:34:30
Speaker
And it says, he raised six sons, leaders of the people, eager for excellence.
00:34:34
Speaker
Feminists like to complain about guys in movies winning the sex prize, meaning that, you know, you solve the problem, you defeat the bad guy, and then you get the girl.
00:34:44
Speaker
And basically, in the aristocratic gnomos, it's like, yes, you should win your bride in a way that proves your excellence and her excellence.
00:34:52
Speaker
And you should produce a lot of sons so that they can be excellent.
00:34:55
Speaker
So there's this endless quest for supremacy, superiority.
00:34:59
Speaker
Your status as top dog is never settled.
00:35:02
Speaker
In fact, there's almost a sense in which this culture doesn't really acknowledge hypotheticals.
00:35:08
Speaker
Fusus, meaning nature, the body, only becomes apparent, real, only possesses being, and bloodline is only proven at the hour
Balance of Destruction and Glory in Aristocracy
00:35:16
Speaker
of its triumph and contest, during the exhibition of a great feat of excellence, of great physical strength, of victory in battle, of violent victory over an opponent, or over a challenge, as in the case of Pelops or Jason.
00:35:28
Speaker
And this is essentially the meaning of life to a Greek aristocrat.
00:35:31
Speaker
They regard themselves as literally possessing more being than the peasants.
00:35:34
Speaker
They are more real, more true, more alive.
00:35:37
Speaker
Pindar uses the adjective esthlos to describe the aristocracy, which comes from the verb esthai to be.
00:35:44
Speaker
They considered themselves true men in contrast to the lying common man.
00:35:48
Speaker
In fact, their word for a man, one of themselves, is aner, but their word for the common man is anthropos.
00:35:55
Speaker
which means essentially man is an animal.
00:35:57
Speaker
And the etymology of Anthropos is a compound of aner and ops, meaning the face, the appearance, the look.
00:36:04
Speaker
So Anthropos literally means someone who looks like a man.
00:36:08
Speaker
You could compare it to calling someone a human versus a humanoid.
00:36:13
Speaker
So an anthropos is not exactly a man.
00:36:15
Speaker
And being exalted up to godhood in Olympus is not to be subsumed into the divine ocean, to be absorbed into like an oblivion, a de-individuation.
00:36:27
Speaker
For them, godhood is to join the gods in their manifestness, their superhuman reality.
00:36:33
Speaker
Eternal life isn't long life, it's the life of the eternal, the undying, the youthful, the intense, the vivid.
00:36:39
Speaker
When Achilles is offered the choice to go home or die young in glorious battle, he is choosing the life of a god, godlike life, eternal life.
00:36:48
Speaker
Another contrast between the idea of nature, Fusus, and Nomos is when Odysseus washes up on the shore naked before the princess Nausicaa, and he manages...
00:36:58
Speaker
stripped of every outward mark of power and wealth to reconstruct his kingly status through the power of his aristocratic speech and bearing.
00:37:05
Speaker
His kingship is not a political fact, it's who he is, it's what he is.
00:37:09
Speaker
And the tension between nature and the aristocratic nomos is that the nomos aims at the highest achievements, the excellences, the arts,
00:37:18
Speaker
But it can't achieve them, because convention by its nature homogenizes and equalizes.
00:37:24
Speaker
What the aristocratic gnomos can do is breed the specimens who are more likely to produce this greatness spontaneously like lightning.
00:37:31
Speaker
But even then, it requires the reincorporation of the savage life.
00:37:36
Speaker
Even men who are biologically prepared for greatness by this selective breeding program can still be held back by it, which is why, in myth, they often have to go into the wilderness to be tutored by Chiron the centaur.
00:37:47
Speaker
The half-man, the beast-man.
00:37:49
Speaker
He teaches them the truths of nature that are found outside the city.
00:37:53
Speaker
And often this is a function of their dispossession in these aristocratic wars and intrigues.
00:37:58
Speaker
So Jason is educated by the centaur because his birthright is usurped.
00:38:02
Speaker
Romulus and Remus have to be nursed by a she-wolf for the same reason, because of their uncle's intrigues in the palace.
00:38:08
Speaker
And this mirrors the way that these aristocratic cultures were constantly re-barberized by their less civilized cousins from the steppe.
00:38:16
Speaker
Both the individual prince, but also like the culture as a whole, had to be constantly taken back to school and forced to relearn the law of nature from the savages.
00:38:25
Speaker
And to be a dispossessed aristocrat in this framework is a pretty interesting position, because your rule was its own justification, your excellence, the power that you had to defend your place.
00:38:36
Speaker
And when that's taken away, the children of aristocrats have an opportunity to prove their quality, but nothing is given to them.
00:38:43
Speaker
And I suspect that's why so many mythical stories begin with the dispossession of the true king or the true prince by an evil uncle or a vizier.
00:38:51
Speaker
Hard times in wild places are part of the proper education of a king.
00:38:56
Speaker
And this may be the only solution to the ultimate problem of hereditary monarchy, which is the quality of your heirs.
00:39:02
Speaker
Like Odysseus stripped naked on the beach, or Jason, or Romulus, or King Arthur, it's the violation of the gnomos, the collapse of their rightful position, that enables them to prove that they deserve it.
00:39:15
Speaker
And as the breeding program proceeds, and the nature, the fuses of the specimens grow stronger, and the stakes of the conflicts between them grow higher and higher, instead of fighting over a few cattle, or a few women, or a few acres of land, they're fighting over...
00:39:29
Speaker
vast empires and beautiful cities and continental trade flows.
00:39:33
Speaker
And these are incredibly capable, incredibly ambitious, incredibly psychologically robust people locked in competition for their entire lives with people who are just as competent.
00:39:44
Speaker
And the price of losing in these wars is always the genocide of the men and the enslavement and rape of the women and children.
00:39:50
Speaker
And as the city and the sociality that you've created becomes more and more beautiful, the thought of losing it becomes correspondingly agonizing.
00:39:58
Speaker
And so this aristocratic regime finds itself constantly balanced on this knife's edge between total destruction and unimaginable glory.
Philosophy's Challenge to Traditional Norms
00:40:07
Speaker
And the psychological problems facing these Greeks, all the new dreams to be achieved,
00:40:11
Speaker
all the wealth and power and capacity that they'd accumulated, the old discipline that got them there couldn't accommodate it.
00:40:17
Speaker
And so they find themselves asking, you know, what is courage and manliness really?
00:40:22
Speaker
What is arete?
00:40:23
Speaker
Who among us is really the best?
00:40:25
Speaker
And these are obviously dangerous questions to have young men asking.
00:40:29
Speaker
if you need them to stay the course and preserve the aristocracy's place in the world.
00:40:33
Speaker
But it's not that thinking those thoughts makes them inert or makes them want to give up.
00:40:37
Speaker
It kind of just sends them exploding into a thousand different directions.
00:40:40
Speaker
Bapp calls it a tropical proliferation of human types.
00:40:43
Speaker
These incredibly heroic, incredibly capable people start marrying people they're not supposed to marry, doing things they're not supposed to do, thinking thoughts they're not supposed to think.
00:40:52
Speaker
And most of this is detrimental, destructive, doesn't go anywhere.
00:40:56
Speaker
and in fact leads to a lot of what Nietzsche describes as kind of the central problem of modern life, which is all modern people are these admixed chimeras of confused and paradoxical and unfulfillable drives.
00:41:11
Speaker
And that's sort of the detritus of this explosion of misbreeding.
00:41:14
Speaker
But while most of it's useless, some of these chimeras are really extraordinary.
00:41:18
Speaker
They have this potential that couldn't have been developed within the framework of the gnomos.
00:41:22
Speaker
And that's, according to Nietzsche, the birth of genius.
00:41:25
Speaker
You can't actually have all the philosophy and the poetry and the music and the political theory and the scheming if everybody's doing what they're supposed to be doing in this breeding program, which is drilling with their spears and shields and sharpening themselves to a razor's edge in the agone.
00:41:40
Speaker
At the same time, if your great-grandparents hadn't participated in that breeding program,
00:41:44
Speaker
if they hadn't been pounded into shape by the aristocratic nomos and made to do the things they were supposed to do, and if the sort of inferior or botched ones hadn't been denied the chance to breed, and the superior ones breeding with the ones they're supposed to in the way that they're supposed to, if all that didn't happen, you wouldn't have, at this point, the biological capacity to produce this extraordinary creative bloom that emerges under conditions of aristocratic decadence.
00:42:09
Speaker
He notes that the Spartans never really had a decadent period, and they also never had a profusion of high culture.
00:42:15
Speaker
Sparta died out because their breeding program was so selective and so subtractive that they just ran out of people, which I think has ramifications for our time.
00:42:23
Speaker
There's a general trend of antinatalism, but the trend seems to be strongest among ambitious, intelligent people.
00:42:29
Speaker
And I think among bright, vital, ambitious people, there's an increasing desperation
00:42:35
Speaker
because they, I think fairly, don't want to be saddled to somebody who can't keep up.
00:42:40
Speaker
But finding someone who wants a family and approximately shares their values within their own social and intellectual class seems almost hopeless.
00:42:48
Speaker
And so some of what I'm trying to do with the natalism conference and with Exit is to create that connectivity across distance, kind of like these Mediterranean princes traveling hundreds of miles to go pick up a bride.
00:42:59
Speaker
I think you have to create a lot of infrastructure to allow people to do that and to do it safely.
00:43:03
Speaker
And when BAP talks about these heroes being unconcerned with domesticity, it's like, well, yeah, but they had all kinds of social and political infrastructure to get their kids raised within the aristocratic milieu.
00:43:14
Speaker
It's like Captain Picard preaching about how they don't worry about money in the 24th century or whatever.
00:43:20
Speaker
Like, yeah, they don't worry about money.
00:43:21
Speaker
They have a magic machine that can give them whatever they want.
00:43:23
Speaker
Of course they don't worry about money.
00:43:25
Speaker
It's not because they have, like, different priorities.
00:43:27
Speaker
They're morally superior.
00:43:28
Speaker
Like, if you want to raise six sons who are leaders of the people and eager for excellence right now, you've got to homebrew that in a way that Pelops didn't have to.
00:43:37
Speaker
Anyway, back to this condition of aristocratic decadence.
00:43:40
Speaker
Nietzsche describes this in Beyond Good and Evil, and Bap quotes it here.
00:43:43
Speaker
I'll read it in full.
00:43:45
Speaker
Finally, however, at some point a fortunate time arises which lets the immense tension ease.
00:43:50
Speaker
Perhaps there are no more enemies among the neighbors, and the means for living, even for enjoying life, are there in abundance.
00:43:56
Speaker
Variation, whether as something abnormal, something higher, finer, rarer, or as degeneration and monstrosity suddenly bursts onto the scene in the greatest abundance and splendor.
00:44:06
Speaker
The individual dares to be individual and stand out.
00:44:09
Speaker
At these historical turning points, there appear alongside each other, and often involved in mixing up together, marvelous multifaceted jungle-like growths, an upward soaring, a kind of tropical tempo in competitiveness for growing, and an immense annihilation and self-destruction, thanks to the wild egoisms turned against each other and as it were exploding, which wrestle with one another for sun and light and no longer know how to derive any limit, any restraint, or any consideration from the morality they have had up to that point.
00:44:36
Speaker
This very morality was the one which built up such immense power, which bent the bow in such a threatening manner.
00:44:42
Speaker
Now, at this moment, it has become outdated.
00:44:44
Speaker
The dangerous and disturbing point is reached where the greater, more multifaceted, and more comprehensive life lives over and above the old morality.
00:44:51
Speaker
The genius of the race brimming over from all the horns of plenty with good and bad, a catastrophic simultaneous presence of spring and autumn, full of new charms and veils, characteristic of young, still unexhausted, still unwearied depravity.
00:45:04
Speaker
Once again there's danger there, the mother of morality, great danger, this time transferred into the individual, into one's own neighbor and friend, into the alleyways, into one's own child, into one's own heart, into all the most personal and most secret wishes and desires.
00:45:18
Speaker
So this aristocratic breeding program emerged in an environment of extreme danger.
00:45:23
Speaker
And its values, the straightforward martial values of Andrea and Phrynosis, are harder to relate to, harder to apply to your own life when, as far as you can tell, for miles around, all the asses have already been kicked.
00:45:36
Speaker
It's not like you're gonna relax and stop competing, you're not like psychologically capable of that.
00:45:40
Speaker
You're built to crush your enemies and hear the lamentation of their women.
00:45:45
Speaker
So, like Nietzsche says, the danger becomes a psycho-spiritual danger.
00:45:48
Speaker
And philosophy is essentially the abstraction and radicalization of the end toward which the aristocratic gnomos was driving the whole time, which is the freedom and the power and the excellence of the individual.
00:46:01
Speaker
And so the paragon of ultimate freedom and ultimate power and ultimate excellence is the person of the tyrant.
00:46:07
Speaker
He's the aristocrat who is so aristocratic that in comparison with him, the aristocratic nomos is a herd of sheep and slaves.
00:46:17
Speaker
His strength and his cunning and his will and his ambition are so great that he can take whatever he wants from whoever he wants.
Plato and Socrates on Power and Morality
00:46:24
Speaker
And basically, he and his buddies recapitulate the Manurbund, the youth gang, the band of pirates, and they prey on the aristocratic state in the same way that their ancestors preyed on weak, backward Hutu farmers.
00:46:38
Speaker
And Platonic moral philosophy characterizes philosophy as the antidote to tyranny.
00:46:43
Speaker
And this is how most people understand philosophy today.
00:46:46
Speaker
You should have a philosopher teach your kids so that they know how to be a good boy, and love their country, and eat their vegetables, and do as they're told.
00:46:54
Speaker
Or slightly more charitably, you think of philosophy as this civilizing, stabilizing influence.
00:46:59
Speaker
Like the big brains in Greece realized there was more to life than fighting, and so they decided to dedicate themselves to the serenity of logic and the life of the mind.
00:47:08
Speaker
And then you hear that the Athenians made Socrates drink hemlock, and you think, well, they must have been just persecuting this poor sweet guy for no reason.
00:47:16
Speaker
Or maybe he was, like, teaching their kids to play hacky sack instead of doing their shield wall drills.
00:47:20
Speaker
Or maybe they didn't like that he was smarter than them and maybe poked fun at them and they couldn't take a joke and they killed him.
00:47:27
Speaker
But Bap's case is that, no, that's not what philosophy was.
00:47:30
Speaker
That's not who Socrates was.
00:47:32
Speaker
That's not why they had him killed.
00:47:34
Speaker
And it wasn't just him, it was a general persecution of philosophers and philosophy as such, because it was a legitimate danger to the state.
00:47:42
Speaker
And Plato's moral philosophy was essentially crafted in response to this persecution.
00:47:48
Speaker
Not because Plato disagreed with the conclusion of philosophy as kind of the midwife of tyranny, but because he saw the need to conceal it.
00:47:56
Speaker
Socrates was executed because a group of his students, led by Critias,
00:48:00
Speaker
had overthrown the Athenian democracy, killed about 5% of the city, seized the oligarch's property, and ruled with an iron fist for about eight months before being themselves overthrown.
00:48:10
Speaker
Bapp talks about philosophers being stereotyped at the time as the lackeys of tyrants or the lickspittles of tyrants, and a solid chunk of the middle of his dissertation is devoted to the Gorgias.
00:48:22
Speaker
This is a dialogue written by Plato about 20 years after the 30 tyrants and the execution of Socrates.
00:48:28
Speaker
And the part of the dialogue that Bapp cares about the most is Socrates' conversation with Callicles, who is a young sophist and a student of Gorgias, who presents essentially the antinomian argument that Bapp is saying is the true essence of philosophy.
00:48:44
Speaker
that the good is getting what you want and fulfilling your desires, that the strong should rule over the weak, and that democracy is the tyranny of the many over the exceptional individual.
00:48:54
Speaker
He says that morality is mere convention, that the nomos depends on lies and fantasies, that it's against nature and therefore against the truth.
00:49:02
Speaker
that praise and blame are tools of the nomos used to enslave the rightly constructed or the well-turned-out against their own interests to the benefit of the weak.
00:49:11
Speaker
Basically, he argues that civilization itself is kind of just a herd instinct.
00:49:16
Speaker
It's a way of people banding together to protect themselves from the forces of nature and from stronger men.
00:49:22
Speaker
And so if you are one of these stronger men, these predatory men, you have no moral obligation to the city.
00:49:29
Speaker
It exists either to hang a yoke on you or to keep you out.
00:49:33
Speaker
But, interestingly, he talks about philosophy as something for children, or at least young men.
00:49:39
Speaker
That it's unseemly to hear an old man talking about philosophy in the same sense that it's unseemly to see him, like, lisping and playing with toys.
00:49:48
Speaker
He's sort of accusing Socrates of being, like, a Reddit nerd, like, playing with Funko Pops.
00:49:54
Speaker
But the reasoning behind that, according to Bapp, is not that...
00:49:58
Speaker
philosophy in itself is ineffectual, but that philosophy leads inevitably to the insight, the discovery of nature, the discovery that might makes right.
00:50:09
Speaker
And so a philosopher who contents himself with quiet contemplation and refuses to liberate himself in the real world and seize power,
00:50:18
Speaker
doesn't actually love the truth, doesn't actually love nature, and is therefore not a true philosopher.
00:50:24
Speaker
Because the truth of nature is imminent, it's embodied, it's made real.
Philosophy as Moral Authority
00:50:29
Speaker
It can't just be apprehended passively.
00:50:31
Speaker
And this goes back to the concept of fusis as a thing that can only be realized in the contest.
00:50:37
Speaker
And Bat makes a pretty complex case that the arguments that Plato puts in Socrates' mouth don't make a lot of sense or are disingenuous.
00:50:47
Speaker
Now, I read this dialogue.
00:50:48
Speaker
It's not very long.
00:50:50
Speaker
And I'm not sure that I caught what he did.
00:50:52
Speaker
It's sort of like my favorite genre of movie review where I say, you know, is the Barbie movie secretly based?
00:50:58
Speaker
Like, it could be that they're making a bad argument on purpose, but it could just be that they're making a bad argument.
00:51:04
Speaker
Now, I read this thing one time, and I don't speak Greek, and these are smart people.
00:51:09
Speaker
So if Babs says he's being dumb on purpose, maybe he's being dumb on purpose.
00:51:12
Speaker
Anyway, Calicles says...
00:51:15
Speaker
that the satisfaction of your desires is what leads to a happy life.
00:51:18
Speaker
And that telling people not to do this is basically just a way of manipulating the superior at the expense of the inferior.
00:51:24
Speaker
And Socrates starts to pick that apart.
00:51:26
Speaker
He says, what is superior?
00:51:28
Speaker
Obviously, if the people are able to arrest and execute you, then are they not superior to you?
00:51:34
Speaker
Like, in what sense are you superior if you can't prove it by actually being in charge?
00:51:39
Speaker
Which is probably the best argument against all kinds of supremacist philosophies.
00:51:44
Speaker
You know, if you were the master race, why didn't you win World War II kind of a thing.
00:51:48
Speaker
But Bapp says, A jackery, again, is never a revolution.
00:51:50
Speaker
A jackery meaning like a peasant revolt.
00:52:03
Speaker
and it is historically easily put down.
00:52:06
Speaker
Callicles believes that the practice of rhetoric is what gives the power of rule to an elite in a democracy.
00:52:10
Speaker
He is simply more cynical about the ambitions of those who claim to speak for the people.
00:52:15
Speaker
So he's basically saying, the strong prey on the weak anyway.
00:52:17
Speaker
You get oligarchy anyway.
00:52:19
Speaker
So why can't we just be honest about it?
00:52:21
Speaker
And Socrates also picks at this idea of the satisfaction of your desires being the source of a happy life.
00:52:28
Speaker
He says, you know, what if somebody just wants to scratch himself all the time or wants to be a catamite?
00:52:33
Speaker
And he's defending the concept of temperance, the concept of self-restraint, by saying that, like, there are some desires that you shouldn't give in to.
00:52:40
Speaker
And he says that licentiousness is the symptom of a sick soul in pain.
00:52:44
Speaker
But here I'm quoting Bap, So he's saying like, yeah, maybe there's like weirdos and perverts who shouldn't give in to all their desires, but if you're a healthy person, then your appetites and desires will be right and you should listen to them.
00:53:07
Speaker
Bapp puts it this way, licentiousness itself is not an evil but absolutely a positive good when the soul is healthy, and that it is only an evil when the soul is sick.
00:53:16
Speaker
Now what Socrates doesn't say in this dialogue, but that Bapp and Nietzsche are reading between the lines, is that, frankly, Athenian society is sick.
00:53:25
Speaker
Their aristocratic decline has advanced to the point where they do have all kinds of disordered desires that need to be hemmed in.
00:53:31
Speaker
And if you were to advocate the rule of the strong and licentiousness even beyond the aristocratic class, but to the people, it'd be a catastrophe because they couldn't handle it.
00:53:40
Speaker
He says,
00:53:51
Speaker
The accusation is an indication to philosophers that making their erotic character public and defending it in the Caliclean manner will lead to general political and social decay, for as Nietzsche says, there is no congruence between the sensuality of the artist and of the people.
00:54:06
Speaker
Bapp says that Socrates isn't criticizing Calicles' arguments on the facts, but just that he's being a little too frank, a little too naive, in fact, a little bit too conventional.
00:54:17
Speaker
He hasn't actually liberated himself from the gnomos because he believes that he can just go into the agora and speak the right words and win.
00:54:26
Speaker
Calicles doesn't understand that the rhetorician or the demagogue leads the people where they want to go.
00:54:31
Speaker
In order to gain power, Calicles will have to praise and blame all the same things the regime does.
00:54:36
Speaker
And so the king by divine right may be a direct slave to convention, like everybody understands that he has to fulfill the role he's been placed in, but the populist revolutionary is also a slave to convention in that he's at the mercy of the nomos inside the hearts of the people who put him in power.
00:54:53
Speaker
So Socrates isn't saying you're wrong to hate the nomos, he's actually saying you need a purer and a deeper hostility to the nomos.
00:55:00
Speaker
And so what Bap characterizes as Plato's real conclusion, that the real point he's trying to make in this dialogue, is that the power Calicles wants can't be captured overtly, and so it has to be sublimated.
00:55:12
Speaker
It has to become subterranean.
00:55:14
Speaker
It has to be intellectualized and spiritualized.
00:55:18
Speaker
And what does that look like?
00:55:18
Speaker
Well, that looks like Plato doing an about-face and essentially saying, oh no, philosophy is all about...
00:55:27
Speaker
The general welfare.
00:55:29
Speaker
It's about the health of the society and of the state, the moral and spiritual health.
00:55:33
Speaker
Now we know better than you.
00:55:34
Speaker
We've done a lot of thinking about this.
00:55:36
Speaker
We're the experts and you should trust the experts.
00:55:39
Speaker
So it's a change from the philosopher aspiring to be a tyrant to the philosopher aspiring to be a priest.
00:55:45
Speaker
And so the philosopher's will to power, which he agrees with Calicles as a good thing, is sublimated into this moral authority, making himself the arbiter of what's good and evil.
00:55:53
Speaker
And of course, from the perspective of this superior philosopher, the teaching of temperance and justice to the masses is good because it makes them easier to control.
Nietzsche on Philosophy's Cultural Role
00:56:03
Speaker
Nietzsche says that Plato wanted to found a new religion but failed with the Greeks.
00:56:07
Speaker
It was the Christians who eventually took up Platonic moral philosophy.
00:56:11
Speaker
And what he identifies as the problem is that they took that exoteric meaning, the sort of moralizing how to be a good boy messaging, and they forgot about the pursuit of power that that teaching was meant to protect.
00:56:23
Speaker
Which meant people actually started believing in universal equality and universal morality, which means...
00:56:29
Speaker
Regimes of selective breeding became untenable, which means that the people who should be aristocrats have become this disordered mishmash of conflicting and subterranean and paradoxical desires, which has rendered them inert and incapable of producing high culture.
00:56:45
Speaker
So in the same sense that Plato's effort to conceal the nature of philosophy was this emergency surgery intended to save it from an existential threat, Nietzsche hoped that by removing the mask and preaching antinomianism directly, like Callicles,
00:57:00
Speaker
He could defend the interests of the superior against the ubiquitous modern egalitarianism.
00:57:06
Speaker
But, this is from the book, his insights have become, by our time, the tools of the most extreme egalitarianism that seeks to destroy all nature and to justify the very life of the last man that Nietzsche denounced.
00:57:19
Speaker
Philosophers must defend the virtues of the many, chiefly self-restraint, temperance, and justice, if they are to rule and if they are to have anything to rule at all.
00:57:27
Speaker
The public function of platonic moral philosophy was to bring order to the anarchy of the instincts, to reestablish virtue on a new foundation because the better foundation of aristocratic breeding and education had already collapsed.
00:57:39
Speaker
Now he says in the intro to the dissertation that he talks out both sides of his mouth in some cases because it's, you know, it's for a PhD.
00:57:47
Speaker
He's got to let the grown-ups read it.
00:57:48
Speaker
And this sounds like one of those cases.
00:57:50
Speaker
It doesn't really sound like something Bap would say.
00:57:53
Speaker
But I actually kind of agree with it.
00:57:55
Speaker
Like, if people were too warped and stunted and bent back against themselves in Socrates' time to make antinomianism tenable, it certainly doesn't make any sense now.
00:58:06
Speaker
Like, it strikes me as just another way of saying, if all men were angels, no government would be necessary.
00:58:13
Speaker
Like yes, if our desires were rightly ordered it would make sense to indulge them, but they're not rightly ordered.
00:58:18
Speaker
So what can you really do with that?
00:58:21
Speaker
And maybe Bap's argument would be that our stuntedness and our smallness is such an existential problem that even if our desires are kind of warped and paradoxical and screwed up, they're so weak and so flaccid that like now is not the time to put on the brakes.
00:58:38
Speaker
And in turn, a worldview that's built around bridling the intense, vital passions of a much simpler and healthier people may just be like really bad for a person like you.
00:58:52
Speaker
At the same time though, if we're talking about human phenomena that we're stipulating are totally a matter of biological material, and we no longer possess that biological material, and we can't recreate the conditions under which that biological material was collected and refined,
00:59:10
Speaker
Besides which, we just are what we are, and so we'll either summon the will to correct this, or we won't.
00:59:17
Speaker
It's, I don't know, it's hard to summon a sense of urgency about this from within the frame that Bap presents.
00:59:25
Speaker
Like, does it make sense to me as a question of vibes?
00:59:27
Speaker
Absolutely.
00:59:28
Speaker
And maybe that's all it has to be.
00:59:29
Speaker
Vibes are pretty much the way that I decide whether or not things are true.
00:59:33
Speaker
Certainly about these kinds of questions, questions of meaning, I don't know how else you could possibly answer them.
00:59:37
Speaker
And I think the reason that so many of us have been fascinated by Bap over the last couple of years is that some of the things that he says resonate in the same way that other deeply held truths resonate while being like seemingly impossible to fit inside our existing metaphysical framework.
00:59:56
Speaker
And this, I think, is why everyone's looking for the Christian-Nietzschean, Christian-Vitalist synthesis.
01:00:02
Speaker
There is this sense that mainstream Christianity is being eaten by progressivism, and that in some senses progressivism is a truer and cleaner instantiation of Platonic Christian morality, and that it could only get there by jettisoning the person of Christ, which obviously presents a paradox.
01:00:21
Speaker
Now this is super convenient for me as a non-Platonic Christian, because what I can say is that essentially you had these Platonic interpolations on top of Christianity, and in the absence of Revelation, they've basically eaten the substrate that they were built on, and now all that's left is Plato.
01:00:38
Speaker
And so in order for me to reject that, I don't have to reject Christ, I just have to reject Plato.
01:00:42
Speaker
And I realize that's not going to work for many, most of you.
01:00:45
Speaker
But I do think it's worth saying that Plato is just not in the Bible and neither is René Girard and the valorization of victim as victim, the valorization of self-denial, of self-annihilation, the fleeing from life and from the physical world.
01:00:59
Speaker
All these things are just not in there as I read it.
01:01:02
Speaker
And if you want to engage angrily with my brand on the internet about that, that's fine.
01:01:08
Speaker
But let's get back to, in an immediate sense, what can be done with all this?
01:01:12
Speaker
Well, let's walk through the premises one more time.
01:01:14
Speaker
Let's stipulate that beauty and excellence and heroism and adventure and discovery, that these things are good and should exist.
01:01:22
Speaker
Like, let's not even say that they're better than ordinary life or that ordinary life isn't justified.
01:01:28
Speaker
Let's just say they should exist.
01:01:29
Speaker
I'm trying to make the easiest case I can here because, frankly, I'm not sure where I stand on some of this stuff.
01:01:34
Speaker
But I can say at least...
01:01:36
Speaker
excellence is good courage is good aesthetic and intellectual brilliance is good okay second stipulation let's stipulate that the presence or absence of this excellence has something to do with biology the movie gattaca is supposed to be a refutation of this idea that ethan hawk lives in this genetic engineering utopia where everyone's assigned to their task according to their genetic propensities and
01:02:00
Speaker
He's one of the few non-engineered humans conceived through ordinary reproduction.
01:02:05
Speaker
And he cons his way into being an astronaut going to Jupiter, and he goes out for a swim with his genetically superior, genetically engineered brother, and he beats him in a swim race because he says, I didn't save anything for the swim back.
01:02:17
Speaker
So that's supposed to mean that grit and desire and cussedness can overcome natural ability.
01:02:24
Speaker
But like, obviously that movie becomes ridiculous if you give Ethan Hawke Down syndrome.
01:02:28
Speaker
Like they deliberately situate the action within the range of capacities at which you can imagine the tortoise outrunning the hare.
01:02:37
Speaker
But like the capacity means something.
01:02:40
Speaker
We all accept that.
01:02:41
Speaker
We just disagree about maybe the range in which it matters.
01:02:44
Speaker
Or we rightly or wrongly situate grit and persistence and hunger as being something outside the purview of biology and heredity.
01:02:53
Speaker
And I actually believe that's true.
01:02:55
Speaker
But I believe it for pre-rational, non-rational, irrational reasons.
01:03:01
Speaker
But I don't think Ethan Hawke with Down syndrome is going to Jupiter.
01:03:04
Speaker
Now I think those two premises are pretty hard to argue with.
01:03:07
Speaker
The third premise, which, you know, your boomer aunt might take a little convincing on, but won't be shocking to anybody in our sphere, is that those first two premises face an existential threat.
01:03:17
Speaker
That the dominant post-Christian platonic morality of our time, the religion guarding all the doors and holding all the keys,
01:03:24
Speaker
is animated and united and defined by nothing other than hostility to those two premises.
01:03:29
Speaker
The idea that courage is better than cowardice, the idea that strength is better than weakness, the idea that brightness is better than dimness.
01:03:36
Speaker
Like, yes, they're opposed to biological hierarchy, but mostly because it's a hierarchy.
01:03:41
Speaker
Biological hierarchy is a more successful thought terminator for them because they've successfully convinced the world that Satan was an Austrian corporal.
01:03:49
Speaker
But it really is the idea that some things are better than other things.
01:03:51
Speaker
That's all it is.
01:03:52
Speaker
And so you don't have to be a radical like BAP is, in the belief that mere life is valueless or even has negative value.
01:03:59
Speaker
You just have to believe that excellence counts for something, because literally every structure of power around you is bent on annihilating
Modern Challenges and Social Reconstruction
01:04:06
Speaker
it.
01:04:06
Speaker
Now this seems so simple.
01:04:08
Speaker
Why does it seem so impossible to get ordinary people on board with this?
01:04:11
Speaker
One place where I would kind of break company with BAP is that I think ordinary people like beauty.
01:04:16
Speaker
I think they admire courage and leadership, and they want leaders.
01:04:19
Speaker
And I think if you can liken our situation to any of these historical stages of development that he talks about, it's the young man on the hilltop looking on the village from the outside for the first time.
01:04:28
Speaker
I consulted with a professor of Nietzsche for this episode, and he talked about what the realization of the justice of nature feels like.
01:04:35
Speaker
So platonic justice is always that the strong serve the weak or at least don't harm the weak.
01:04:40
Speaker
But the justice of nature is the disgust of seeing mediocrities in possession of things they don't deserve.
01:04:45
Speaker
Now this is difficult to disentangle from resentment, which is maybe Nietzsche's like number one enemy.
01:04:49
Speaker
Basically the difference in his mind is whether or not you really are better.
01:04:53
Speaker
You see like a gross pigeon-chested dork dating a girl you really like, and the way you get justice is you go steal his girl.
01:05:00
Speaker
And if you don't do that, or you can't do that,
01:05:02
Speaker
That's when your revulsion becomes subterranean and sublimated and internalized and starts attacking you.
01:05:09
Speaker
And that leads to all the complexities and pathologies that Nietzsche associates with resentment.
01:05:14
Speaker
To the extent that the young men on the hilltop have a morality of any kind, that's their morality.
01:05:19
Speaker
We see these weak, stupid, tyrannical people just doing nothing, being nothing, and not allowing anyone else to do or be anything.
01:05:27
Speaker
And eventually they go to hell with this, and that's when they ride into town.
01:05:30
Speaker
And you've probably had a conversation like that with some like-minded friends, and it seems so self-evident and so justified and so right, but then you try it on some ordinary people and it doesn't work at all, it doesn't play, and you don't know why.
01:05:41
Speaker
And that's also the relationship between the philosopher and the tyrant.
01:05:45
Speaker
The tyrant is the expression of the philosopher's hatred of the nomos.
01:05:49
Speaker
I'm not going to be left alone within this system, so all I can do is to smash it.
01:05:53
Speaker
And why is that wrong?
01:05:54
Speaker
Well, if you're the young man on the hilltop the first time, there's no problem.
01:05:58
Speaker
The system isn't equipped to deal with you.
01:06:00
Speaker
But if you're in a system that's developed centuries worth of antibodies from encountering and internalizing people like yourself, then they just arrest you and they make you drink hemlock.
01:06:09
Speaker
They have a social and intellectual complexity that they didn't have before.
01:06:13
Speaker
So Plato's solution is to turn that complexity against itself.
01:06:17
Speaker
He finds the intellectual and social terrain that isn't being guarded and uses that to seize power.
01:06:21
Speaker
instead of what Calicles wanted, which was just to storm the gates.
01:06:25
Speaker
So now in our time, you've got lots of strategies in place simultaneously.
01:06:29
Speaker
The dumbest strategies, apart from like literal fed posting, are appeals to intellectual honesty and justice and fair play.
01:06:36
Speaker
That intellectual terrain is absolutely captured and fortified.
01:06:39
Speaker
They own the moral technocracy.
01:06:41
Speaker
They're the ones who decide what's fair and what's not.
01:06:44
Speaker
In fact, that's the basis of their rule.
01:06:45
Speaker
They'll never give it up voluntarily.
01:06:47
Speaker
Now, to some extent, they're mining that foundation themselves, and maybe we can accelerate that process, but they're never going to go, you were right, we were wrong, and give you what you want.
01:06:55
Speaker
But the right answer can't possibly be to go back to a dumber and a simpler iteration.
01:07:01
Speaker
Not only are our societies more complex, we're more complex psychologically.
01:07:05
Speaker
And so the solution has to be to look again for the opportunities that are created by this new social and intellectual complexity.
01:07:12
Speaker
What doors aren't being guarded?
01:07:13
Speaker
What aren't they paying attention to?
01:07:15
Speaker
In the short and medium term, that's what I'm looking for at Exit.
01:07:18
Speaker
How does this complex legal and ethical system that they've built to justify their power, how does it hamstring them?
01:07:24
Speaker
What are the lines that they can't cross without jeopardizing their own legitimacy?
01:07:27
Speaker
And then in the long term, it's about taking that space that we've carved out to build something that seduces them.
01:07:33
Speaker
Something they can't expropriate, but that they want.
01:07:36
Speaker
And this, again, I suspect maybe Bap would disagree with,
01:07:39
Speaker
But the reason I think it can work that way is that hierarchy doesn't have to be adversarial.
01:07:43
Speaker
The whole concept of the regime that we're up against is that hierarchy is inherently exploitative.
01:07:47
Speaker
And when I think about the ordinary people who have changed their mind about that, it wasn't because they saw the right, like, takedown of how ugly and resentful and hypocritical the left is.
01:07:57
Speaker
In many cases, it's because they experienced a healthy hierarchy, usually in a family.
01:08:02
Speaker
The family is the wellspring of all functional hierarchies.
01:08:05
Speaker
The state of the family and state of family life now obviously makes the Neolithic longhouse pretty compelling as a metaphor, but I don't think I buy it as the natural state of humanity.
01:08:15
Speaker
I mean, even leaving aside spiritual considerations, just thinking about the obvious physical and psychological advantages of patriarchy,
01:08:22
Speaker
and the fact that every form of government is this obvious abstraction of the relationships between fathers and sons and brothers.
01:08:29
Speaker
Like you can't possibly believe in the cohesion of piratical brotherhoods if you don't believe in the cohesion of actual brotherhoods, where your blood and your biology and your nature actually tell you to defend each other.
01:08:41
Speaker
There's a reason that mafias are called crime families.
01:08:44
Speaker
Obviously that doesn't mean that biological kinship is all it takes, but ties of blood are obviously the easiest way to inculcate trust and cooperation and loyalty.
01:08:53
Speaker
That's why essentially every pre-modern society on earth was organized in tribes and clans.
01:08:58
Speaker
It's why in Europe for millennia the ways that two houses would cement their loyalty to one another was through marriage.
01:09:04
Speaker
Because then they would share grandchildren and they could trust in the natural loyalty of their potential ally, or maybe their former enemy, and his own grandchildren.
01:09:14
Speaker
It's why medieval oaths of fealty were obvious abstractions of the relationship between a father and a son.
01:09:19
Speaker
Throughout this book and all of the selections of Nietzsche that I read as a consequence of reading this book...
01:09:25
Speaker
The relationship between superior and inferior is characterized as obviously and inescapably hostile.
01:09:31
Speaker
It has to be by definition predatory or parasitic in one direction or the other.
01:09:36
Speaker
And I would argue that's a huge gap in their understanding of hierarchy because there can also be hierarchies that are pedagogical.
01:09:41
Speaker
like the relationship between a father and a son, where you're actually trying to draw him up to meet you.
01:09:46
Speaker
You're hoping that he comes into his own kingdom and that whatever he builds in a certain sense glorifies you as much as it glorifies him.
01:09:54
Speaker
And a relationship between superior and inferior can also be erotic, like the love between a man and a woman.
01:09:59
Speaker
The desire to take something that's beautiful and subdue it and possess it and tame it and make it more beautiful is
01:10:06
Speaker
or build something beautiful with it.
01:10:08
Speaker
And there's also just pure friendship and enjoyment that can transcend these power dynamics.
01:10:14
Speaker
The clearest example is between a man and his dog.
01:10:17
Speaker
You know your dog's capacities.
01:10:19
Speaker
You know what he can understand and what he can't.
01:10:21
Speaker
And you can laugh when he's being silly, but without contempt.
01:10:25
Speaker
And you can in fact have tremendous respect for a dog, and the virtues that a dog exhibits of courage and loyalty and tenacity.
01:10:32
Speaker
And it's easy to find examples of aristocrats expressing these kinds of feelings and having these kinds of relationships with common people.
01:10:39
Speaker
And it's just as easy to find common people expressing genuine love and honor and appreciation and respect for aristocrats.
01:10:48
Speaker
with zero confusion about who's who on either side, with no pretense of equality.
01:10:53
Speaker
And in fact, I believe the reason there's so much resentment and contempt in our society is that we're expected to lie about the existence of these hierarchies all of the time.
01:11:03
Speaker
And if our goal is to rehabilitate hierarchies of nature, then the best place to start is the most fundamental natural hierarchies which are found in the family.
01:11:11
Speaker
And that brings us back to where we started with selective breeding.
01:11:14
Speaker
The drive towards selective breeding in these steppe aristocracies was the imminent threat of death.
01:11:19
Speaker
They had to become dangerous because they lived in a dangerous world.
01:11:22
Speaker
Now those conditions don't exist now, and it seems like the vitalist plan, if you can call it a plan,
01:11:28
Speaker
is to wait for and hope for and fantasize about a day when those conditions will reemerge.
01:11:35
Speaker
And when that day comes to be prepared to rape and pillage and claim your place in the new aristocracy.
01:11:41
Speaker
But I actually think that we're already facing an existential threat.
01:11:43
Speaker
And if you don't respond to this one, you're not going to make it to the Thunderdome where you can show your quality in the Bronze Age sense.
01:11:51
Speaker
And that existential threat, which is putting your biological material at as much hazard as a bronze spear in your guts, is the collapse of family formation.
01:12:00
Speaker
Like BAP is right that it can't just be about biological replication.
01:12:04
Speaker
Certainly can't be about trying to outbreed our enemies just in terms of raw biomass.
01:12:10
Speaker
But like if you care about human quality, and if your quality is high,
01:12:15
Speaker
and the type of person you are is scarce, then yes, whatever great deeds are inside you to do, you have to do them.
01:12:22
Speaker
But you also have to see to your posterity, which is actually a much taller order because it means you can't just have kids.
01:12:28
Speaker
You have to have kids with the right woman, which means you have to find and seduce the right kind of woman, which is incredibly hard.
01:12:33
Speaker
You may be back in a situation where you have to do some deeds, like Pelops, to win a bride and to actually win her.
01:12:39
Speaker
Like, not just to marry her, but to secure her loyalty and her commitment to you and to the quest.
01:12:44
Speaker
Because as Bat points out, the political and social infrastructure is totally arrayed against you.
01:12:49
Speaker
All marriage is gay marriage.
01:12:51
Speaker
And so to even approximate the historical and healthy and natural relationship between a man and a woman takes immense force of personality.
01:12:59
Speaker
But you have to produce heirs, and you have to be around to raise them, and there's not really any other way to do it.
01:13:04
Speaker
So while I think BAP is basically right about the headwinds facing fathers in the modern family law and cultural environment, I basically just think you have to do it anyway.
01:13:12
Speaker
What else are you going to do?
01:13:13
Speaker
And then you've got to see to it that your kids who will, let's face it, have variable natural ability, you have to see to it that they make it through this bottleneck and not only make it through, but thrive and elevate themselves and create beauty, create beautiful families.
01:13:26
Speaker
And so I want my kids around the best people I can find.
01:13:29
Speaker
So many things they need to know that I can't give them as a dad, but I know the guys who can teach them.
01:13:34
Speaker
And I want them to have the best peers and rivals and romantic partners that they can possibly have.
01:13:39
Speaker
And I don't think there's any place on earth where they're going to encounter that spontaneously at this point, which means we got to build it.
Conclusion and Further Exploration
01:13:45
Speaker
And so you may wish for a moment that demands the archetype of the warrior and selects for that, but right now it seems like if you want to bring any beauty, any genius, any excellence through this filter, it's going to call upon the masculine archetype of the king.
01:13:58
Speaker
Anyway, that was Selective Breeding and the Birth of Philosophy by Kostin Alamariou.
01:14:03
Speaker
Fantastic book.
01:14:04
Speaker
I hope he's not upset that I gave so much away.
01:14:06
Speaker
There's tons more in there.
01:14:07
Speaker
It's absolutely worth picking up.
01:14:09
Speaker
If you want to learn more about Exit, you can check us out at exitgroup.us.
01:14:12
Speaker
And if you're interested in this problem of demographic decline, we're holding a conference on natalism December 1st and 2nd in Austin, Texas.
01:14:19
Speaker
It's going to be two days with some of the most interesting people in the space, not just giving talks, but working together to solve some of these problems.
01:14:25
Speaker
You can learn more about that at natalism.org.
01:14:28
Speaker
You can also follow me on x at extradeadjcb or exit underscore org.
01:14:34
Speaker
Thanks for listening.