Zencastr
00:00:00
00:00:01
Speed1x
Format▸
Share
Embed
Report

Andy Dehnart Talks Reality, Masks, and Unscripted Truth | Candid Conversation. Underdog Wisdom. | Goodpain Podcast S03E10

Goodpain Podcast
Goodpain Podcast

2 plays · Oct 29, 2026

Transcript

Speaker: I'm Jeremy. And I'm Tyler. Welcome GoodPing. And maybe also to fantasize about and just enjoy the entertainment of like, wouldn't it be nice to actually kick someone off the island, out of my family, out of my workplace? Wouldn't it be nice just to be like, goodbye, i don't have to deal with you anymore, you're out, we voted you out, goodbye. Reality TV gives us that little bit of catharsis along with the reality, right?

Speaker: To defend the honor of this genre, it is like every other art form and medium, which is that there are complexities and I encourage people to never just write it off

Speaker: Welcome back to Good Pain. Today, as Halloween weekend arrives, we're leaning into spooky season with a conversation about the costumes we wear, the masks we put on, and the unscripted truth hiding right underneath.

Speaker: Joining us is Andy Dainhart. Andy is a writer, critic, and creator journalist who founded Reality Blurred to explore how unscripted media is made and what it reveals about us.

Speaker: He serves as president of the Television Critics Association, hosts the podcast Made From Humans, and spent 20 years teaching journalism and creative writing. In this conversation, we use the spirit of Halloween to unpack the roles, code switching, and defensive masks we perform every day.

Speaker: From childhood memories of Mr. Rogers and Double Dare to the high-pressure human experiments of survivor and couples therapy, Andy demonstrates how reality television functions as a modern mirror for human behavior. We explore why we edit our lives for an audience, how we find safety in the sandbox of storytelling, and why we crave the raw, unpredictable messiness of unscripted human connection over sterile algorithms.

Speaker: Andy reminds us that beneath every costume, editing choice, and public role, we are all trying on personalities, taking off our masks, and learning to live authentically.

Speaker: What is that story for you around this version and genre of expression in the world? Yeah, I think it goes back to all kinds of pop culture and television in my childhood and thinking about just, you know, like watching Sesame Street or Mr. Rogers and feeling like I'm among friends. And even when Obviously, i know that the puppets on Sesame Street weren't real, but there's real people interacting with them. And so there is some reality occurring here. Obviously, as a four or five-year-old, I wasn't thinking about scripting and acting and, you know, all the stuff that goes around on in the background there, but... So I think there's been like on ultimately in my life fascination with what's real, what's not. And also just, you know, loving television and pop culture in general. So I watched game shows like Double Dare when I was a kid. And that was in the late 80s, early ninety s And so I think it was also primed to, know, and the cool thing about Double Dare as a game show was these were kids just like me, my age. Literally, they filmed it in Orlando. i grew up in Florida. So I think it's like, oh, like this is happening really close by. It wasn't even like in the far off land of Hollywood or anything. And so there was the idea that you could go to a theme park and suddenly you're on TV going on this wild obstacle course. And it wasn't about fame so much as it was just about this experience.

Speaker: And obviously, i think to just leap ahead shows like Survivor or The Amazing Race, there's something really cool about the experience for the people to do something that they couldn't do in their real life, facilitated by the context of the show, right? So Amazing Race sends you on a race around the world and... at no cost to you then again you don't really get to linger in any places or explore that much either so it's a kind of a trade-off there but just who when else are gonna get a chance to to do that kind of thing um or on survivor like essentially playing a game of human chess while living on a beach somewhere or in a in another location for the earlier seasons so there's a lot of this kind of

Speaker: It's wild to step from your actual experience into something so completely artificial and yet playing off of what's actually happening to people in them, right? It's like the reason we watch these shows to get to my thesis, I guess, is people love seeing what happens and also it's unexpected and it is just like...

Speaker: You don't know how someone's going to react in the situation. And I think in many ways, we don't know how we would react in the situation. So we think we would go into Survivor or Amazing Race or anything else and behave a certain way or respond to it a situation in a certain way and stress and pressure and... Tiredness and all this kind of stuff that comes up for people creates a lot of complication. And sometimes that ah reveals the worst of people. And that's, I think, something that causes people to turn away from reality TV. And sometimes that brings out the best in people, too. And you just see joy and excitement and happiness and also... ingenuity and creativity and connection emerging in all these spots. So it's such a cool way of experiencing the human condition, I think, through all these, like, again, artificial, sometimes completely wacky, sometimes indefensible formats, completely, like, But reality TV is this massive, massive umbrella as far as I'm concerned. And it's grown that way since 2000 and Survivor, but it got its start in the 1990s with The Real World as the first modern reality show. And that, if you don't know the origin story, came from a producer who was in documentary news filmmaking and another who was in soap operas. And their combined sensibilities took...

Speaker: people who were living their actual lives in that first season, all of them wanted to be in the entertainment industry somehow, and put them together in a loft and let them live together to see, as the tagline says, what would happen when people start getting real. And for me, as a kid who grew up in suburban Florida, an extremely white, ah town and neighborhood and school and also being a closeted gay kid who didn't even know he was closeted at some points. Looking at people who are some sometimes like me, sometimes completely unlike anyone I've ever met in my real life. And knowing that they're real people, not actors, not reading scripts, not being directed, changes the equation in terms of how I relate to them I think how we relate to people. So I was able to see

Speaker: you know And it wasn't really for me like mentors or role models or anything. it was just like ah kind of anthropology, essentially, like as a teenager, like i'm I'm going to see what this experience is like or what these people are doing and and how they respond to what comes up for them, which, as we know, can be conflict, but also can be connection. your first mention of Double Dare. And and the cheeky question, first of all, is would you take the question or the physical challenge? I mean, the physical challenge is always the most fun, right? And so that's ah going to be my answer usually.

Speaker: But at the same time, like, I loved the way that some kids would play Double Dare and just, like, they would ah essentially play the risk of that and then answer the question that they knew and then get the points without having to risk it. So the physical challenges, I think, you know if you're there given the opportunity, i would probably say that, especially if I wasn't so sure. But... I also like to think that I would be smart enough or clever enough to be like, those dummies don't know the answer, so I'm going to dare them. They'll double dummy back, and then I'll just take those 40 points for myself well and my teammates.

Speaker: What just outlined is the calculation of competition against other teams. You played that out, but then the physical challenge is this representation of... you against yourself or you at the very least against the clock. um Your skill set, whether you can you can perform that. And that's a really interesting dichotomy that I heard you start to paint out also within the emergence of some of these other competition shows that largely are physical, that do mix in some trivia as well. But there's this dance between the interaction with self and the interaction with others. And and something about that that is fun to watch, some fun to be a part of. It's probably, i don't know if this is like a universal human thing, but it's clearly something that humans are interested in, in terms of like sports too, right? Like that's obviously a big part of our culture and and just seeing these, like seeing people who are

Speaker: good at a thing or want to be good at a thing, you know, depending upon the sport and the type of competition that's going on. But I think in some ways, it's like ways to challenge ourselves and then other ways to be entertained. And reality TV mixes those in the the same way that probably sports do, but I would say also on ah on ah another level because...

Speaker: You know, football isn't stopping in the middle to like have people talk shit to each other on the sidelines. But maybe maybe they will eventually maybe that'll that'll be happening sooner than later. So, yeah, I think it's it's just there's something in there that that is.

Speaker: were clearly drawn to it. I don't know if it's like too much of a stretch to go back to like the, you know, like Coliseum type of like sport. And i don't know the psyche of people who are watching others, you know, die for their own ah entertainment, but clearly there's some draw there that feels pretty core to the human experience.

Speaker: I did not grow up with professional wrestling, but there's this concept within that space of the need for a villain, the heel, and the need for the hero. There's an entire concept of kayfabe within that, where we know that there is some aspect of scripting here, but we don't acknowledge it. There's something about the play acting that goes on. This gives rise to a pageantry within here that oftentimes within reality TV, we start to say like, well, we have villains. we you You talked about the worst is brought out and into people, but the rise of that villainy also gives rise to the opportunity to root for our heroes.

Speaker: What's going on there in terms of that theatrics? Yeah, and it's it's that's so interesting because there are so many things happening, especially in reality TV, that do the exact thing that you're talking about, the sort of the rise of the villain or the rise of the hero against the villain, the fall of the villain, or maybe sometimes it's the rise of the villain, like Survivor Season 1's shocking outcome of this sort of Machiavellian person who showed up to play the game to win a million dollars and then did and sort of surprised us somehow that that's, you know, that was the way... he played it's um to to back out a second i always really don't like when people say reality tv is fake and then they write off the entire genre because that's ridiculous and so ah like it's just impossible to say that it's kind of like writing off an entire genre of material like i don't like books because they're fake and it's like well of course

Speaker: you know, well, fictional books are fake, but what about nonfiction? and But then memoir is often very, there's like all kinds of complexity and layers there. So looking at the complexity and layers of reality TV, there are certainly shows that have more artificiality than others. But there are so many layers even within those. So if you think about someone who applies to a competition show so like we're talking about, the fact that they even want to go on it in the first place is a kind of self-selection of a person who's going to want to be on TV and whatever their motivations are. Then the people the casting producers pick in their their initial pool and send on to the producers are going to be those who kind of pop for them on screen. So we're we're narrowing our group already into people who are good at expressing themselves. Because if you don't have people who can talk about their experience, you don't have a show. and And now you then put them into this world. So they're affected by the kind of production around them, whatever that might be.

Speaker: ah So there's like potential for producers to, you know, throw in twists or something to kind of like push out buttons and, you know, things they already know about. Because during the casting process of reality TV shows, people speak to psychologists and do different kinds of testing. And all of that is for the benefit of the producers, not the people on the shows, so they can understand who they're casting here. So then we have all this footage of everything that's happened, hundreds or thousands of hours that then has to be condensed down into manageable episodes. And so you have a team of story producers looking for narratives and finding them and then assembling those. And then you have people who are technically editing this and basically creating those narratives out of the footage that they have. which in some shows cases means hacking up sentences from other sentences and like creating brand new sentences. And like that can be totally, you know, that's there's layers of artificiality there too, right? So if you create a sentence from all the words I've just been babbling for the last few minutes, ah you could take, you could say something that like basically gets at my general idea, or you could totally fictionalize what I'm saying. And so those are possibilities. And then we've condensed that, turned that into a TV show. And now we're filtering out through the people who are watching it and what they're focused on, what they're noticing, what they're seeing. And so where things are real, quote unquote, or fake, like quote unquote, are there's so many places that those things can arise. And it's so interesting just to think about all of the people involved. And it's like, you know, Survivor has like five, six, 700 people behind the scenes, some of whom are doing things like the laundry for the crew or cooking for the people who are filming. Others are like, you know, driving people around. But then there's some people who are having a direct influence based on where they place the camera or the question they ask in an interview. So it's extremely complex. And so are people, i would argue, right? So this is ah like a version of assembling reality that allows us to see what it takes. But I think a lot of times people don't want to really do that work. And I get it. Like, you just want to watch Survivor and enjoy it. And just assume that what you've seen is like, this but this person is awful and evil in real life, just exactly like they are right now. But it's helpful to realize, I think, that we're seeing...

Speaker: a fraction of a moment in a very artificial context and then filtered through all these other things and know that that affects our experience of of seeing them. When we talk about reality TV, there are choices that are being made.

Speaker: To take the amount of footage that's being run for a single episode There's an inherent science to the nature of cliffhangers where in an ad break world, we still wanted people to be able to come back and keep watching. And there's this engine behind it. But in front of that is still the theatrics of real people living in front of a camera. The presence of the camera itself does something within an individual who knows, is aware that they're being watched. Yeah. And that as much as we want to start talking about, well, here's all the elements that make this for some individuals make this fate. You and I also both know and and all all of us know is is that that actually approximates a fair amount of what's happening to us.

Speaker: Whether that's through block cameras, whether that's through algorithms that are collecting that information, we casually might forget that for a moment and go about behaving as if we're not being watched. But increasingly, we and specific populations are very aware that that we must edit ourselves depending on the venues in which we are finding ourselves. And and That seems, even for me, if we're like, there's there's a rub there. There's some friction there that we also want the ability to to navigate a world where we don't have to edit ourselves as much. like what Yeah, I think it's interesting because... You're absolutely right in terms of the how much we're being filmed, surveilled, cetera. And some of that is self-surveillance, right? And I don't just mean like the ring doorbells that people then you know film something ridiculous that happens to themselves or their family members and put that online. But now, like obviously, Instagram, TikTok, short form video, people are... producing their own lives for this audience. And even the most casual looking video where someone's like, I'm in bed and I'm just going to start filming myself talking about a random idea. There's a level of production there. It's like, this would make a good TikTok video. So I will film myself right now. And maybe I stumble at the beginning and I'll just cut that out. um

Speaker: But even back up before all of this, like, I think there's a sense that the editing you're talking about happens just in our normal lives with people, audiences, groups that we're with. Like, we're probably different people than we are at work than we are with our people we live in in a house with, whether it's family, friends, pets. And then we're probably different. Like, if you go to ah visit, you know, family, friends for a holiday, there might be a little bit of different kind of way that you perform your life. And there's, ah you know, there's the term code and switching, where you're actually like literally switching the way that you talk, the vocabulary you use, the things that you're sharing based on the context and the people who are around you, so that you're kind of speaking in code, quote unquote, to

Speaker: the people that you're with. And I don't want to reduce, you know, the very like sort of survival based code switching that can happen for people in marginalized communities with what, you know, going home for Thanksgiving for like a suburban white kid. But it's also like you're going differently around your family than you are your friends. And so we edit ourselves constantly. And so a reality TV show editing its contestants can be a version of that. Although, granted, there's someone else involved, not necessarily just the self-editing of what I'm doing in front of the cameras, but now someone else is selecting what people see of that.

Speaker: Going back to the picture of the producer who's working on a reality show, they're making a selection on what they're going to put out there, um on what they're encouraging. And that even within ourselves, we putting everything out there is based on some version of us making a choice of even what we're going to put out there. That itself is still an editorial decision. And it being silent,

Speaker: is an editorial decision. a Choosing to withhold certain aspects, to get small, to to hide, to to put on a mask, speaks volumes about ourselves and our relationship to what makes us feel safe, how we take back control, potentially, how we maybe just decide or have... have the the memory of, yeah, last time I offered up advice to somebody else, I got burned this way. This time maybe I'll, and we will even say that that version of silence might be a form of wisdom. Like we have to make these choices. What's it like navigating a world where authenticity or being genuine is itself actually evolving? Like it's unfolding reality. what I said yesterday I considered to be genuine and in a week later I'm like that wasn't genuine that was still me trying to control the narrative. I mean part of what you're describing not to be overly reductive but it just sounds like growth right as people that we're we're better for our thinking about what we did yesterday and trying to adjust today and what we know today might be different than what we know yesterday like

Speaker: I have the privilege of having written on the internet for more than 25, close to 30 years now. And a lot of that stuff is just still there and would not be the way that I would write that exact same thing today. But that's because I'm a different person in many ways than I was. Like, I don't want to think of myself as like a completely transformed and, you know, uh,

Speaker: Somehow like idealized version, but it's like if I haven't grown or learned or changed or like found had different perspectives that help me understand what I'm watching on TV or what I'm reporting on, like that feels not great. So, yeah, that I think that process that you're describing can be one that is. right I guess just like, it sounds like it's something that is not that great to have to edit ourselves and to think about the way that we're approaching things, but also i wouldn't want to not be doing that.

Speaker: For some populations, that activity is not an exploration of expression, of wholeness. It's a, how do I segment myself in order to maintain my safety? That's that's one arm here. I think the other arm, having the space to try on costumes or personalities for a period of time and say that what fits with me?

Speaker: How do I experiment with what it is that i don't know yet what I'm in the process of becoming? I want the space, the breathing room to be able to do that. I think we see this oftentimes through adolescence where I'm going to try to be a part of this group and I'm going to do the code switching with this group for, you know, my sophomore year. And then the next year i i switch to a different group or, and that even itself has a degree of inborn privilege to be able to have multiple choices of what group I'm going to be a part of.

Speaker: And I think this gets back to even the first part is, is that what happens where being a part of the group or a group is a safety measure, is ah is a security measure versus one that's a part of the development and being able to to explore.

Speaker: And I think that's so individual too, like that that's the, and there's so many gradients and so many different things that affect individual experiences and the context that they grow up in.

Speaker: So this the same, even somebody who sort of like looks demographically similar to someone else might have very different experiences just from family or economics or whatever the case might be. And I think people tend to look for simplicity, categorization. i think reality TV plays into that a lot in terms of like we kind of lock someone into a role or back in the real world days, it was like, here's the jock, here's that this person, here's the... that and i think you know now we're seeing some and don't know if pushback is the right word or just like freak out from the kind of boomer generation of like what are all these terms the kids are using to describe themselves i don't understand them and it's like yeah you don't understand that that's okay like it's there there's maybe they just are looking at the gradients and thinking about themselves in more complex ways That isn't to say that like the boomers weren't similarly complex. It's just that they didn't have the language or the permission to analyze themselves. It's like when I was teaching gender and media class to undergraduates, i used to talk, I'd like show a picture of a light switch and be like, you know, my grandparents' generation, I think, kind of understood for sexual orientation that like,

Speaker: they got it that it's like there's a switch and it's like you're straight or gay like there's a a thing and then maybe maybe get one of those toggles where it's like straight bisexual and gay like maybe but actually like and then i would show like a picture of like a control board for a recording studio or something like these are actually all the dials and knobs that all of us have for every part of gender identity and so sexual orientation and just our understanding of our own bodies and whatever else. And so those are all different, and but we don't necessarily have the language to describe them and it gets confusing.

Speaker: So it's like the more and more complexity you add into that equation, the more difficult it is for us to even talk about it. Like right now, like it's like all these are kind of hypotheticals, right? Like how are we talking about other people or even even our own experiences?

Speaker: You started off with reality TV of having the the categorical stereotype of this person equals this. And then that picture of not having the language and we're trying to embrace some more plurality, a multiplicity of what it means to be human. And yet there's still this This gravity around being able to understand the dynamics of this person equals villain, this person equals the job. What is that from a storytelling perspective? Why is it so important for us to be able to either put ourselves into a box temporarily or when we're looking out at at characters to say, oh yeah, this person equals x I mean, I think the story part of it is interesting because it has to be like storytelling and is is a reduction of the complexity that we were just talking about too. So if you're writing a memoir, for example, you must figure out what parts fit into this this storyline and then like pick and choose scenes. Because like we can't just offer a transcript of our lives as a memoir or transcript of a famous person as a biography, because that's too much and also not at all interesting. So we pick the stuff that is kind of like peaks and valleys. And I think storytellers, whether they're reality TV editors or... great novelists or playwrights are going to do the same thing, where they find people at their best and worst or on the cusp of those things to give us something to look at and think about and talk about. and there's a great example ah

Speaker: on television every year in the United States called Big Brother. It's on CBS, airs in the summer. It is probably one of the worst reality TV shows in terms of the actual episodes that air week to week in terms of quality production. I would not highly recommend it for artistic and craft purposes, nor is the game particularly interesting because it's a lot of Calvin ball of just kind of making up new rules and seeing how people adapt.

Speaker: However, the fascinating part about this show is that they stream what's happening in the... So the... In case you haven't seen Big Brother, basically 18 or 15 contestants live in a house, which is actually a soundstage house, and do that for three months. And the show airs concurrently to this actually happening. Kind of like other shows like Love Island, but Big Brother allows us to watch the footage from inside the house, you know, on all day, every day. So you can turn on Pluto TV or go to the website and just see surveillance camera footage of people sitting around talking. and most of this is completely boring. Most of this is absolutely uninteresting.

Speaker: occasionally there's something kind of weird and funny and human that happens. Like there was a great clip earlier this summer that I highlighted where someone was, know, washing dishes and another person was like juggling or pretending to juggle like silverware and like a knife flew out of her hand and like over the other person's head. and it was obviously totally accidental, even though they're playing a game against each other. it was just like, this year was so apologetic and they hugged each other. And like, but was just like a great little human moment that we got to see occasionally those things will make it on a show, but generally it's like, we need to see the big you know game of strategy. Like where the big decisions being made? What's happening? What are the turning points? And so all the softer stuff gets erased and edge, you know, removed. So my point in sharing Big Brother as a model here is that there, I think there's a reason why when we're telling stories, we get rid of those middles. Like,

Speaker: And for sure, a good story is going to have ah some of those pieces, some of those little human moments, but an entire TV show or book that's nothing but the kind of like small human but inconsequential moments for whatever the larger plot or story or game is just isn't going to work for us as readers, viewers, whatever the case might be.

Speaker: We want to see those because they give context. And yet the more that we believe that those equal the story, we forget that there's nuance um that might happen in the in-between. That the in-between itself, what would happen if the in-between is actually the context?

Speaker: um And and the the highlights is the noise. And sometimes it seems that we forget that. But what I hear you describing is is maybe the aspect of entertainment. There's something about we're more entertained by the peaks and valleys. Yeah. And it's because, it of course, like seeing, you know, how someone deals with an obstacle or how someone recovers from ah a challenge that didn't go well. And I mean that, like, literally in terms of like a double dare challenge or a challenge of just in life.

Speaker: Absolutely. and I think those are also more instructive because then we can so look at them and say, like oh, would I do the same thing? Would I react in the same way? And you're right. Like all the stuff that leads up to it is just as important. And I think some stories, including reality TV, do try to give us that kind of arc and give us like, here we're seeing something that's happening and then it's going to inform something that happens later. But it also is impossible to like trace all those things back, right? Even before, whether it's outside the context of the game or just like how someone thought while they were falling asleep about what happened that day and how it affects what they do to the next day.

Speaker: Some of those things can't even be captured. So you're right that it's... absolutely entertaining and gives us that kind of like pleasure and joy and of watching something.

Speaker: i just, it's interesting because hearing you say that too, makes me think about how I actually think there's a kind of fatigue in American filmmaking right now or not filmmaking, but like in corporate media's version of like films of like, especially the superhero movies where it's just like, it doesn't feel human anymore. It doesn't feel like we are, know, in getting characters that we can relate to. It's just like everything devolves into this like fight where everyone's just like shooting, you know, ah CGI lasers at each other. And there's, that's that's boring. And there's been some interesting reporting about this new Avengers movie where like actors didn't know who they were acting against. or where they were in scenes in the story. And so then they're just performing. And so it's like, I think you can feel that as a viewer, like the filmmakers don't know what's informing this. The actor doesn't know. It's just all like computer driven stuff. And so i think we actually do want the smaller moments. We do want to just see two actual actors playing off of each other in a scene and seeing what they can discover. Just like we want to see the moments in Big Brother when, you know, they're just washing dishes and having that little moment. And and it's like, just when you get to know people too, like you might get to know if a person at work and you see them in one context and then it's like, you hang out a little more and then maybe you discover, oh no, we are not meant to be friends. Like they are very different in this other way. And like, the in-between time is not of interest to me. I'm glad to glad to have them with me in meetings, but not here. Or it might be the opposite where you're like, this person is super annoying at work. but actually love hanging out with them and doing whatever activity we love together. So yeah, it's interesting to kind of see the way this manifests in culture and in our lives around things.

Speaker: We actually want some degree of the messiness that comes from trying to bounce off of each other in real time. and And that this feels like it goes a little bit back to even where we started with the unscripted nature of things, where where we want the surprise. we want We want the co-creation that happens when there's not something um ah predetermined.

Speaker: about the outcome. And while I couldn't help but hear as you were describing the Avengers story, is it's it's almost, i mean, there's this classic clip of Bill O'Reilly, um you know, saying, well, you know, we'll fix it in post or or um something along the lines of this idea that that we'll just make it work. We don't have a shared goal here. We're going to feed something into this And then whatever we get out of it, we're going to, we'll make it work afterwards in almost a sycophantic way, which is whatever is good enough. And then we'll just point it in whatever direction we think the audience wants it to go. I couldn't help but hear some degree of, without us just triggering our own soapboxes, but AI and this inherent belief that, well, just just put whatever you have out there to this machine and it will tell you what the predetermined formula is supposed to be We're sick of that.

Speaker: We want to do the play acting. We want to jump into the sandbox and make mud pies and and make a mess of things. And we look for that somewhat in whatever reflection of the art of the day is. And and right now we're not seeing it There's a part of me and I think a lot of other people that creates a kind of certainty, understanding, especially when things are uncertain. And as we know, the AI chatbots are good at one thing and one thing only. And does that is making you feel convinced and good about what they're saying.

Speaker: Even when they're making stuff up completely and citing things that don't exist and never mind stealing from artists and writers who've created all these things in the first place, they say something in such a confident way that it's like, ah. So you know before I'd searched Google and I couldn't find the thing I was looking for, now I search Google and I don't to look at any websites. It's just going to tell me, here's ah here's the answer.

Speaker: And if I drill down, I might find out that all the things that it's citing don't exist, don't actually say what the summary says, but I have a really confident answer. And so you'll see people screenshotting those AI summaries on social media and stuff as like proof. And it's like, well, I understand that we want that kind of confidence.

Speaker: In especially where there's uncertainty, but to speak out of the other side of my mouth now, like, yes, I think people also love play and discovery, especially when it's safe. And reality TV, I think, provides that safety for us as viewers, but also for people who are experiencing it.

Speaker: You know, people will say like, Survivor is fake because of course they're not really surviving. Like they're not going to let them die. And it's like, yes, of course, this is a is a TV show made by a giant corporation. They have medical staff on hand. Like anything can go wrong anywhere, but they're not out there and they're just not going to wither away and die of starvation because they can't find a coconut. However, it is creating this entire context and then seeing what happens. And so you have a kind of safe...

Speaker: quote unquote bubble, even one that's like, you know, has a bunch of variables in it. And now you get to see what happens in that messiness and see how you as a game player play that or someone you know or are interested in following will actually do that. So I think there is that attraction to you to just like, yeah,

Speaker: trying things, playing. And our society and especially capitalism doesn't like that. We you need to be efficient. We need to have everything like done and figured out and answered. And that is not how humans work ultimately.

Speaker: That That stereotype is that same form of shortcutting, which is, you know, I'm going to tell you exactly what to believe, what to feel. There's something about the rug pull almost for us is it that some rich storytelling emerges when we remember that we like to almost be found to the fools. Like,

Speaker: There's a reason we like sleight of hand magic, where we we know we're going to be fooled, that we know that we're going to be looking in a certain direction. But then we do that because we we like to be found to, how did they do that? What... what and And there's something here about being told this is the villain. But then in to to have something happen that makes us start to question maybe not even what our appraisal of villainy is, but whether this person even qualifies for that. And and by showing some of that nuance, showing some of the more full picture.

Speaker: to play with that dynamic to some degree um that says your first inclination, you should be at least suspicious of what that is and and here's how we're going to show you where we should have more nuance and more play.

Speaker: Is there a reality series or show or approach that you feel has, does that more justice than others? Yeah, I think there's quite a few examples. And the best one that I can think of that's a current show that has a few seasons behind it is called Couples Therapy on Showtime or Paramount+. plus And probably no surprise that this is actually about the therapy process. And so you get to see couples who are obviously seeking help to, so they have some conflict, they have something that they're trying to figure out together,

Speaker: meeting regularly over more than half a year with a therapist weekly and kind of learning and changing and going through that. So the people who start off at the very beginning, sometimes like grating or annoying to me and like suddenly you, used as the therapist, Orna Guralnick,

Speaker: kind of digs into things you you learned about them, why they might be doing this. Sometimes it's really fascinating to see their blind spots. Like we can see it, but they can't still. And you, so you're on kind of out of the side of their partner or Orna and you're seeing it and they're missing it. And it's like, oh, how am I?

Speaker: missing this too like and of course the thing about this show is it's cast right and then like it's also edited we're not seeing we're seeing like ah several couples every half hour and then across like 12 episodes is is half a year so it's really being reduced as well The actual process that they went through is still real and still something that helped them as a couple. um And just as a tangent, something about the show that makes it particularly authentic is that the production does everything it can to hide the production from the people who are participating. So they show up to an office.

Speaker: that is just a door onto the street that then they go into a hallway where it looks like there's multiple offices. They go into the doctor's office. There's a waiting room. They never see a camera operator. They never see a producer. They're wearing mics. So there's that because like someone has put a mic on them before they've gone in But otherwise it's like kind of all invisible. Some of them have joked like you hear someone like sneeze on the other side of the wall and it's like, oh, there's actually like a whole production here. But by really just bringing it down and reducing it to is a couple and a therapist in a room talking to each other. And that is the entire show. You get to see a really great example of what you're just describing, even with the editing, even with the condensing that has to occur.

Speaker: Yeah. yeah For you, um what keeps you excited about reality TV? You said you've been you've been doing this for a long time. like what What keeps you engaged? I think it's the surprise. And it's the surprise of the human beings who have agreed to put themselves out there for us. And they can really do stuff that is wildly entertaining and funny and infuriating and frustrating. But then it can also be like really great examples of... like good behavior, bad behavior, things like how do I want to behave as a boss or as a partner? And so there's all kinds of stuff to learn, too, in addition to being engaged. And so even the shows that are the same, like couples therapy, you just swap out a couple and you have a whole new ah set of interesting things to look at and and wonder about. Obviously, same set, same therapist. Nothing else changes, but we're so invested suddenly in this new couple. So the same thing is true of shows like Survivor, or The Traders, or Amazing Race, or whatever, where new people bring new things, new locations, new challenges. And just seeing how people evolve and change, like there's far less ah people on The Amazing Race now who get into a cab in a non-English speaking country. and start shouting in Spanish at the cab driver because they don't know the language, but they think that increasing their volume and speaking the only language they know will help them. So there's maybe been a bit of learning along the way that how do we actually communicate with people, even in high pressure situations. So yeah, I just find it endlessly entertaining. And then I also, to be quite honest, like as a reporter, journalist, critic, I think there's a lot to analyze, discuss about the way

Speaker: These corporations are basically turning people into profit machines, the way they're treating them, the way, and that can be good in some situations and it can be really awful in others. And so for me, holding them accountable or pointing out the layers that we've talked about is a lot of material and it changes constantly, you know, We've just had ah this summer on Below Deck a person who's been on the series for multiple years. This is a show that follows a crew on luxury yachts. And this guy has been a leader, but he's a terrible leader in part because he's so aggressive and gets like kind of on the verge of feels like being violent. And now he was just convicted in absence of domestic violence in Australia and because he didn't show up in court and so now he's wanted in Australia. And it's like, wow, we've, you know, we've gotten to know his leadership style, obviously not his full life on the show, but it's like, to what degree did the show contribute to this? Like, I'm not blaming the show for his actions in his life, but also like, do you enable somebody by continuing to hire them and put them in positions of power when they're not qualified? And that is a reality TV question, but it's also a question for just ah regular jobs and bosses and our own lives.

Speaker: What does platforming mean? What does it reflect about our ethics, about what our responsibilities and obligations are in light of this corporate machine that says, you know, all eyeballs are created equal and the more you can get, you know, do that. And yet it reminds me of a conversation, i think six weeks ago when, when,

Speaker: Jimmy Fallon invited Conor McGregor on. um ah And there's an outstanding question here, which is, you know, should we be creating platforms or using our platforms that we have built that stand for something? Should we should we be co-opting those? Should we be allowing those to be the platforms for for people that we consider to be bad actors, like bad actors in the space that are doing nefarious things. and And that's a, what I hear you saying is, is that we may not have an answer for that right now. That's not the scope of our conversation, but the very least we should be having that conversation. We should be exploring what it means um for us to co-create something together um in this, in reality. Right. Yeah. And I ask, those are questions I ask myself all the time as I'm writing. And sometimes it's, do ignore the show to not give it more oxygen? Or do i be the only voice that's giving some critical context to it? Is that helpful? um You know, with Below Deck that I just mentioned, it's like, I was making jokes about this couple's relationship just earlier in the season because they, you know, had a child together, like, and...

Speaker: The child is now like eight weeks old and it was unplanned. And so it was like, I was just kind of treating it frivolously because that's how the show was. you know was just um And now I'm like, did i you know, I know I didn't like cause any of this, these events to happen because they're in the past, but it's like, do i hurt people with that? How do i change what I do right now? or um And so, yeah, it's like, I think the thing about platforming ultimately is like what happens once they're in the platform. So like Netflix just giving specials to people who make transphobic jokes doesn't do anything except give more audience to transphobia. And it's like, you know, this small, tiny group of people in the world and are getting this disproportionate amount of mocking, hate, et cetera. And like, why is Netflix doing that to them? That's different than me potentially like interviewing someone who was on a reality show and was transphobic and talking to them about what they did or why they did it or covering that, you know, I'm still platforming them. And maybe that's not as good as ignoring them entirely. But I think it matters when we add context, when we um present things as they are, instead of just like pretending that they're not what they are.

Speaker: in my experience, even for myself, of finding times where I want to speak about my my rights of saying something without also ah the obligations that come along with the, what's the responsibility with what what comes along with that? And I think I hear within you advocating at the very least for let's let's have a more balanced conversation of, yes, I do have the right, I do have the privilege,

Speaker: and And that doesn't mean that ah it's consequence-free. And that also I have a choice in and how i steward this platform. I take the responsibility seriously, even though it's in this world of play and entertainment. And it's it has real consequences. And and i don't get to hide behind the, hey, i'm I'm a pop culture entertainment commentator here. Yeah, and I think a lot of people do that. It's like, this is just, it's just TV. Like, don't, you know, stop, stop. And and even when I've criticized other journalists in the past, like I had somebody once years ago write to me and basically be like, I write this in my pajamas at night. Like, don't make, why are you, why are saying, why are you questioning what I'm writing? And it's like, because you have a massive platform and you're writing for a big company that has credibility on top of that. And, Yeah, it's like as a journalist, I really ah have always thought you know about the freedom of press, freedom of speech as being critically important. I've also understood that those are things about the government censoring us, not not anything else. And so my ability to... ah

Speaker: talk shit or whatever I do on the internet is going to sometimes come with a consequence that I need to accept. And it's like, you know, a cancel culture is not a real thing as far as I'm concerned. It's just people being held accountable for what they're saying. And the people who've been quote unquote canceled and not in the legal system, but just like because they said something,

Speaker: Look at them and they they're still doing things. They're getting work. They're getting, they still have jobs. Like maybe they disappear for a year and now they're fine. So no one is truly being canceled because, and just so the fact that they had to like, you know, endure people questioning them or like endure the consequences of something is like just pathetic to whine about that really. Yeah. So anyway, i'm I'm going way far away. from No, no. But well, well well i'll I'll bring it back to to one piece, which is as you were talking about that and brought cancel culture, all I could think about was there is this form of cancel culture that's embedded within carrying your Tiki torch and having it extinguished as you get kicked to off of the island. we We do have some idea that says,

Speaker: This is the time when you don't get to play the game any longer and others get to go forward and and you've got to go find something else to do with your time. And we're okay with that until we start throwing a hissy fit. No, I want to keep playing and I'm going to stay here and and and you don't get to to send me anywhere. but i like that. e's So I do think there's there is a a playfulness here to I think where we started is, is that so much of this.

Speaker: reflects very much the reality of what we're contending as what it means to live together, ah to to do society together, and that we don't have clean answers, whether that's the clean answer of determining, well, this equals fake, therefore I'm not going to participate in it.

Speaker: Well, that's not that's that's not how the world operates. and And even though it is scripted, even though um it's unscripted, but edited or all these different pieces is is that it reflects some aspect of what it means to be human together, to walk through time and to ah to deal with the drama and the comedy and all of the things that are in between. Yeah, and maybe also to fantasize about like, and just enjoy the entertainment of like, it wouldn't it be nice to actually kick someone off the island, out of my family, out of my workplace? Wouldn't it be nice just to be like, goodbye, i don't have to deal with you anymore. You're out. We voted you out. Goodbye. And that's, you know, not really possible in most of our lives. But ah reality TV gives us that a little bit of catharsis along with the reality, right?

Speaker: To defend the honor of this genre, it is like every other art form and medium, which is that there are complexities. And I encourage people to never just write it off as, you know, you watched a clip of one Real Housewives show, and now you think all reality TV or all Real Housewives are worthless. That's probably something you want to interrogate within yourself. Like,

Speaker: and And I don't mean you have to be a fan of The Real Housewives, but I would love to just encourage people to explore the the range of entertainment that this genre has provided us with and the range of, you know, emotional connection and information and learning that we can get from shows as well.

Speaker: Thank you for sitting with us in this conversation, for bringing your own story, your own questions, and your own hard-won wisdom to what we're building together. If you want to keep this going, subscribe to Good Pain on Apple Podcasts or Spotify, where you can also leave us a review that helps others find their way to these conversations.

Speaker: And for weekly doses of conversations that go beyond quick fixes or surface-level advice, subscribe to our Kindling newsletter at goodpainco.com. Good Pain is recorded in Colorado on Arapaho, Ute, and Cheyenne ancestral lands.

Speaker: And let's remember, we are not alone in this. Our struggle is not our shame. Whatever we are carrying today, we don't have to carry it alone. We will see you next time.

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Recommended