Zencastr
00:00:00
00:00:01
Speed1x
Format▸
Share
Embed
Report

Scarce and expensive housing is eroding BC’s liveability and economy

Redeye
Redeye

187 plays · Oct 7, 2024

Transcript

Speaker: Hello and welcome to today's episode of Red Eye. I'm Jane Williams.

Speaker: On the podcast today, Mark Lee of the BC Office of the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives on how expensive housing is eroding BC's economy and the need to build equity for the future.

Speaker: If you live in British Columbia and you care about equality and social justice, you probably have many conversations in a week about how unaffordable housing is becoming. Economists at the BC Office of the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives have examined this issue and have come forward with a multi -pronged approach to tackle the problem. From renter protections to rezoning to bolstering and funding non -profit housing, they say a full court press is needed.

Speaker: Mark Lee is a senior economist with the CCPA. He is co -author with Alex Hemingway of a new report, Building Equity Lessons for Affordable Housing in BC. Hello, Mark. Thanks for being here today. Hi. Thanks for having me on. Now, Mark, you just have to look around to see how ordinary people are suffering because of the cost of housing. But how are high housing costs eroding BC's economy?

Speaker: Well, I mean, obviously, when it costs a lot to put a roof over your head, you have a lot less money for everything else. And there's only so much money to go around. I think what we've seen in recent years in the rental market, for example, a lot of folks who have been in their apartments for a long time have been relatively insulated from the big jumps in in rents because of rent control. So though they're still vulnerable to annual increases. you know like This year it's ah about 3%. And then you know other people, if they are needing to move ah because their family has grown and they need more space, sometimes people need to move because their landlord can legally evict them so that their own family can move in or to do renovations.

Speaker: ah Then people facing market rents are really, really pinched because, you know, as everyone listening knows, you know, it's about $2 ,000 to rent a one bedroom in Vancouver. And, you know, it's leading to situations where people are having to live with a lot more people than they would like. In order to cut down on rental costs, it means that there are young people who are living still with their parents who would like to have their own place.

Speaker: ah but are not able to to move out. It makes stresses for people who are moving here, and it just makes stresses, I think, for a lot of folks who have lower incomes, who may be working full year, full time, but don't necessarily make the highest wage, and will find that most of their income is getting burned on just paying the rent.

Speaker: I found interesting in your report that ah you introduced housing as a system. Why do we need to adopt that framework? I think we're wanting to push back against the idea that housing is just a market, that you know all housing should be built by private for -profit developers, that if you rent, you should be renting from a for -profit landlord,

Speaker: that know all of the other dynamics you know are just driven by supply and demand. And you know really that's not how things work and that's not how things should work. That there are a whole bunch of ah laws and regulations at the federal level related to mortgages and you know regulations and other things that happen at the provincial level, all of which shape the housing market.

Speaker: You know, in a province as wealthy as British Columbia, it's a shame on our society that we are unable to house adequately so many of of our citizens and and, you know, including the people who are outright homeless. And, you know, if you lose your security of housing and our dire situation, it can be very hard to get that back.

Speaker: Now, Mark, you say that a broad consensus has emerged that much higher levels of housing construction are needed to rebalance the market. But will increasing supply help solve that affordability crisis?

Speaker: I think it's a key part of the answer, in particular because our population has been growing quite substantially in in recent years. and you know That's always been true in in British Columbia. We've always tended to have a net in migration, whether that's from other provinces or other countries.

Speaker: And, you know, as a result, you know, the housing supply needs to keep pace with that. And and clearly it's not. I mean, you see that in the ownership market with really high prices that make the most of the headlines in the newspapers. But the ultra low vacancy rates we're seeing for rental housing tell us that there's not enough rental housing or certainly not rent enough rental housing at a reasonable rents for the vast majority of people. and And as you know, we noted at the start at the outset that this kind of erodes the ah capacity of the economy to ah produce, particularly if people need to live very far away from where they work and then incur costs in other ways as well in terms of like,

Speaker: having to deal with very long commutes ah in order to get to it ah to where they work simply because of where they need and where they can afford to put a roof over their head. Now, currently less than 4 % of the housing market in Canada falls into the category of non -market and public housing, things like co -ops. How does this type of housing fit into the affordability picture?

Speaker: Well, to me, it's it's a core piece of affordability. In other countries, they have invested a lot more in public or non -market alternatives. So at 4 % of our total supply here in British Columbia, that's really on the low end of major industrialized countries around the world. But if you look at some of the countries in Europe, for example,

Speaker: The amount of non -market housing is 15%, 20%, 25 % of the overall housing stock. In some places like Vienna, Austria, it's ah about half of the housing stock is non -market housing. so To me, non -market housing is is a real key in terms of providing housing that is dedicated and affordable over the long term, that when you think about building a non -market housing project, you automatically reduce the cost of the housing ah once it's constructed because you've taken out developer profits.

Speaker: And you really only need to price that housing in terms of the rents that you charge people who live there to cover the costs of that upfront construction, buying land, and other fees. So you can rent on ah essentially a break -even basis. And if you do that and have you know help through governments by having 50 -year amortization on the mortgages that that that build these things,

Speaker: That allows you to to deliver rents at much lower than what a private sector developer will do as a landlord, which is to rent at whatever the market will bear. So ah there's a gap there that we can exploit through non -market housing. And furthermore, over time, those rents will stay low and stable and effectively will be more affordable over time as people's incomes rise.

Speaker: Whereas in a private rental situation, it's always going to be chasing the highest market rents, and there will always be an incentive for landlords to evict tenants who have been protected by rent controls, particularly if they've been there for a long time. I mean, it seems like such a ah no -brainer to bring in not -for -profit projects, but you're saying that that's not a total solution in itself. Why not?

Speaker: Well, I mean, what we are arguing for in our paper is 250 ,000 new non -market rental units over 10 years. So a quarter of a million units. And that's a measure that would build on the scale commensurate with the problem.

Speaker: Back in the 1960s and 70s and into the 1980s, we had federal and provincial governments partnered with nonprofits and churches and other organizations like that, that built out the co -op and non -market housing that we still see ah today, that is the bastion of affordable housing ah in in British Columbia. And then you know starting around the mid 1990s, we essentially sat on our hands for a couple of decades.

Speaker: What we've seen in recent years is a bit of a re -emergence of the federal government and provincial governments into the space of non -market housing. But mostly we've seen really big multi -pronged agendas that do everything but really build out non -market housing at the scale that we need. So we we definitely need a lot more of that. That has to be at the core of what we're doing.

Speaker: And then on top of that, we we look at other things that have been discussed in in the housing discourse, like measures to ah protect ah renters that are facing displacement, measures to invest in existing rental housing that may be affordable, bring it into the non -market sector so that it can be safeguarded and kept affordable over ah the much longer time. And then we do need to also talk about density. you know As the population grows, people need to live somewhere And you know up until now, we've been concentrating new density on main arterial streets or at transit hubs, ah which may be convenient in some regards, but also tend to be noisy and polluted. And they're not allowing people to have the same level of access to the quiet, leafy residential streets that are tend to be reserved for detached housing, particularly in Vancouver.

Speaker: Well, I hear a lot of pushback against density here in Vancouver, but it seems so important to develop that in cities where housing is needed. I mean, I think you have to if if if you're going to have a population that is growing, then you need a housing supply that is going to grow with that as well. If you just rely on the private market to deliver that housing, those private developers are only going to be building for the high end of households, people with you know middle and upper middle incomes and higher who can afford those new developments. So if we really want to have housing that is genuinely affordable for people in the middle and people with low incomes, then I think we really need to look at these kind of measures that protect existing rental housing and build new rental housing that's genuinely affordable. What does the province need to do to push forward progress on affordability?

Speaker: Well, so in our report, and I should mention that this report is based on four years of research that we did as part of a grant we got from the Vancouver Foundation. That grant was primarily looking at Metro Vancouver as a case study around affordable housing. But for our final paper, ah we tried to take all of those lessons and apply them province -wide and then broke down recommendations for each level of government. So we have a number of key directions for local governments and similarly for the BC government and the federal government. Specifically for the BC government, we look at the issue of housing supply and how in in certain areas like in historically detached housing neighborhoods, we can allow more

Speaker: density so there's more opportunities for people to live on those quiet ah residential streets as I mentioned. We talk about ah the 250 ,000 new non -market rental units. ah We talk about expanding the rental protection fund that allows non -profits to purchase existing affordable rental housing and keep it affordable over over the longer term.

Speaker: And we talk about a number of other measures that you know look at reforms in the tax system and creating a new housing benefit, which would essentially amalgamate the homeowner grant, which currently goes to almost all homeowners just by virtue of ownership.

Speaker: and the newer rental tax credit that the government just brought in. But basically pooling that money together and creating a benefit that flows to low to middle income households rather than a situation like the homeowner grant where someone living in a $2 million dollars home is getting the same amount as ah someone who's living in a $500 ,000 home and getting absolutely more than someone who's a renter.

Speaker: Mark, what questions around housing should voters be asking in this upcoming provincial election? Well, I think that that key piece is around non -market housing. you know What are governments willing to do to build new non -market housing? And i don't it shouldn't be a hard question, too, because you know unlike, say, investing new money in health care, you'd be like, OK, well, where's the money going to come from to pay for that? It's a legitimate public policy question.

Speaker: When you're building non -market housing, you're also building the revenues that will pay for it because you're generating a stream of rental income once it's built for every year, you know, for 50, 70, maybe 100 years if that building lasts that long.

Speaker: So usually when you do the math on these things, the, the rental income pays for the original upfront investment in 25 to 30 years. So there's no reason why governments can't be doing this. And if, if anything, they should be doing it because they have the financial resources to make that upfront capital investment. And then, you know, essentially have that be repaid over a longer period of time.

Speaker: and they can work that out on their books. It's a much more comprehensive approach to building the housing we need, in our opinion. There are a lot of unhelpful memes and myths circulating around housing issues. If you were to offer a few simple ideas to people who aren't economists to reimagine how housing can become affordable, what would you suggest?

Speaker: I mean, again, I always love pushing on non -market housing and you know just making the case that you can whittle down the costs of construction in various ways. If we had more standardized design templates or if we had a dedicated construction ah workforce,

Speaker: or other types of of new innovations like modularized housing where components are being built further away and then assembled on site rather than just you know and knocking together two by fours to start from scratch ah on each site. Publicly contributed land is another big one. And we're starting to see the provincial and federal governments move ah in this direction. But obviously the cost of land is a huge factor in places like Metro Vancouver. So there's a lot of land that's owned by municipal governments and local governments and and federal and provincial governments. If we could put that on the table towards nonprofit affordable housing, you know, that can lower the upfront cost. So all of those things like that. Another one is is is eliminating municipal development charges for nonprofit projects.

Speaker: So all of those can lower the the front end, the cost of getting a new building built. And that then translates into lower breakeven rents on the resulting project. Well, it's been great talking with you today, and I really appreciate your joining me. All right, thanks very much.

Speaker: I've been speaking with Mark Lee. Mark is a senior economist at the BC office of the Canadian Center for Policy Alternatives. He is co -author with Alex Hemingway of the new report, Building Equity Lessons for Affordable Housing in BC. And you can find that report at policyalternatives .ca.

Speaker: The Red Eye Collective is based in Vancouver. You can check us out at coopradio dot .org slash redeye.

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Recommended