Transcript
Speaker: Hello and welcome to today's episode of Red Eye. I'm Jane Williams. Over the summer, we're bringing you some of the highlights of our 2024-25 season, which wrapped up in mid-May.
Speaker: We will be back with our brand new fall season in September. Our first live radio broadcast will be on September 20th on Vancouver Cooperative Radio, CFRO 100.5 FM and streaming live at co-opradio.org.
Speaker: Podcasts of interviews from that first show will be posted the following week. On the podcast today, we speak with lawyer Randall Cohen, who represents Canadian families trying to bring relatives into Canada under the Gaza Family Reunification Programme.
Speaker: Following the Russian invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, the government of Canada introduced a special program to allow Ukrainians to temporarily work, study, and stay in Canada until it was safe for them to return home.
Speaker: Nearly 300,000 people have arrived in Canada through that program. In December 2023, Immigration, Refugee and Citizenship Canada announced the launch of a similar program to help Canadians get family members out of Gaza.
Speaker: But 10 months later, it's unclear whether the program has facilitated the exit of any Palestinians from Gaza. On November 19th, Palestinian Canadians and supporters held a press conference as part of a Canada-wide Day of Action for Palestinian Family Reunification called by human rights organizations.
Speaker: Randall Kahn is an immigration and refugee lawyer working with family members in the Lower Mainland, and he joins me today from Seattle. Hello, Randall. Hi, nice to be with you.
Speaker: I'm really happy to have you on the show. What is the process that family members in Canada have to go through to access this program? Well, it's a several step application process.
Speaker: that is unique to this program. and I think that I should perhaps start out by identifying a key difference between the Gaza special measure and the special measures that were put in place not so long ago for Ukrainians. Because the only people who qualify for this special temporary residence program ah from Gaza are those who have immediate family in Canada with permanent status.
Speaker: So the first step that needs to take place is that a anchor relative, is what they're calling them, the person who is either a citizen or a permanent resident in Canada, needs to basically express interest, register,
Speaker: that they are interested in sponsoring family members by submitting information about themselves and a list of who their family members are that they want to sponsor.
Speaker: And that is submitted to IRCC through a special web portal. And then... After an initial eligibility screening, then if the person is deemed eligible to sponsor their family members, then each of the family members who was listed in that initial expression of interest will be issued a unique application code, which is then used by the applicant themselves to submit the application from Gaza.
Speaker: And I should say the outset that many people have yet to receive those codes, and there was a lot of, i think, concern and confusion at the outset about even the first step.
Speaker: Once a person has received the code, then they're then able to make an application. And that application looks more or less like a normal application for temporary resident visa and Canada.
Speaker: But there is some additional scrutiny, some some heightened security questions. And ah person is then required to you know answer those questions and submit identifying documents, et cetera, biographical information to Canada through the IRCC website.
Speaker: And IRCC then invites those who have initiated an application to a biometrics meeting at a local consulate.
Speaker: And biometrics, of course, means that they take your fingerprints and they take your picture for identification purposes, for security screening. And this is where it gets really kind of absurd because the biometrics can only be taken at a fes in a consular visa office at a visa processing center Canada sets up in various ah cities in the region.
Speaker: And there is no visa processing center in Palestine. The closest one to Gaza is in Cairo. um And of course, nobody can get there.
Speaker: So for most people who were eligible for this special program, that's where things have stopped. In the meantime, IRCC will continue to conduct the screening and process the application, and many of the applicants have received additional questionnaires, questions, requests for additional information about their histories.
Speaker: Again, and I think those are based on the specific issues that come up in the ah in the initial screening for the individual applicants. Now, in April, Canadian press obtained a redacted letter that was sent to a medical worker, an applicant, by a Canadian immigration officer.
Speaker: And you called some of the questions being asked in that letter patently illegal and absolutely egregious. What were those questions? Well...
Speaker: I mean, the questions that I was responding to specifically in that instance were asking medical professionals who qualified for this program otherwise to account for whether they had ever provided treatment to Hamas fighters or to terrorists as part of their medical duties.
Speaker: And ah I think it's well understood that Any medical provider who is following the code of professional ethics as a doctor or a nurse would not is barred, in fact, from asking about the political affiliations of a person who comes into their care and is certainly not allowed deny or provide deny
Speaker: or provide medical attention to someone based on their political affiliations. So there's no reasonable basis for why IRCC should be asking that question of people who are you know working with what they can inside of a war zone to provide medical services to anyone who needs it in that context.
Speaker: How unusual is this whole process in your experience as an immigration and refugee lawyer? Well, it's not unusual for there to be security screening.
Speaker: And it's certainly not unusual for there to be heightened security screening for people who are coming from regions that are involved in conflict. I think... It was not particularly easy for people to get visas to visit Canada from the occupied territories in Palestine even before the recent conflict because people did face heightened scrutiny.
Speaker: And I should say that that heightened scrutiny is on the one hand, i think, reflective of certain biases about the conflict itself, and I think maybe some racism, some Islamophobia.
Speaker: I think that there is a general concern that young men, young Arab men ah from the region have a higher likelihood than others to be trying to travel to Canada for some sort of nefarious, potentially violent related purposes.
Speaker: I don't think that, I mean, I think we all have some sense of where that's coming from and and what the problems with that are, but that's no doubt the case. But in addition to that,
Speaker: There is a heightened level of scrutiny to those coming from the region because Canada, which of course is a signatory to the International Convention on Protection of Refugees, has an obligation once people are on Canadian soil to take refugee claims seriously.
Speaker: And there is a, i think, crude expectation that people who are coming from the Palestinian territories in particular are more likely to seek refugee protection once they arrive in Canada, that their intent in Canada is not, that their temporary intent in Canada is looked at skeptically.
Speaker: So I say all of that to suggest that it was not easy before. And so therefore the fact that the heightened scrutiny is not unusual doesn't excuse it. But in addition to the normal scrutiny, in this case, there are ah additional questions that are being asked on paper about how people got scars on their body. They're asking for extensive information about people's social media accounts.
Speaker: And those are the kinds of questions that I have seen asked by IRCC officers once there has already been some basis for concern, but I've never seen those questions front and center in the paper application before.
Speaker: And I think that the whole code system that I just described is also very, very unusual. i mean, it's it's it's unique. But I also think it's important to acknowledge the unique circumstances that we're talking about a program that is being offered to a population that is actively under siege, who simply aren't do not have the the benefit of mobility.
Speaker: And I think that that's the most unusual and the most problematic part of this whole program is that even if The scrutiny was not as intense, even if it was not prejudicial, even if Canada was acting in good faith to process these applications.
Speaker: It's not clear exactly how anybody would actually get to Canada. It must be a nightmare for the family members here in Canada to be engaging with this process, with everything that's happening in Gaza, and essentially getting nowhere.
Speaker: I think that, you know, everyone who's living in Gaza right now is in a nightmare. Everyone who has family in Gaza right now is in a nightmare.
Speaker: And I think that the idea of finding temporary refuge in Canada for anybody who would qualify has been a ah lifeline of hope And I think the families that I am working with here are generally so desperate for any possibility that they are willing to give, to continue to give credence to the good faith intentions of of this program, this process.
Speaker: They're sensitive to any murmurings from the minister's office or any um indication that there might be any movement that is going to actually bring there their loved ones to Canada.
Speaker: And I think it's cruel because it's clear from my perspective that if there was ever any intention to actually bring family members to Canada through this program, then there has certainly been an erosion of the will to make that happen in the months since the program was announced last year. And i think that it is outside of Canada's control directly who can make it through a port of entry from Gaza Egypt or elsewhere.
Speaker: That's true, but it is cruel, I believe, to continue to ask families to go through this process, especially this invasive process, especially this prejudicial process, when there's no real horizon in which it's going to actually be effective.
Speaker: Your law office has joined more than 40 civil society organizations in signing an open letter to the Canadian government calling for urgent changes to this program.
Speaker: What are you asking Canada to do? Well, um I mean, I'm a signatory to that letter. i'm not ah i'm not an author of that letter. I guess I should make that clear.
Speaker: I signed it and I meant it. But I mean, I think the way that i would frame this is somewhat different, although complimentary. What we're asking for is transparency.
Speaker: transparency We're asking for clear communication from the government as to what is possible and what is not possible. We're asking for transparency about how the codes are being issued and to whom.
Speaker: We're asking for the what still seem like arbitrary caps on access to that first level to the to to the codes to be removed so that anybody who is eligible can at least begin the process so that if there is a development on the ground that allows people to pass in into Egypt or otherwise leave Gaza then more eligible family members will be able to move through that process more quickly.
Speaker: And we're asking for Canada to use diplomatic levers that are available to it to leverage Israel and the combined border authority that controls Russia.
Speaker: the ports of entry into Egypt to allow those who otherwise qualify for this program to make it to Egypt to leave Gaza.
Speaker: I think that where where my perspective somewhat differs from the perspective of the letter, and I think I should just be candid about this, is that there are any number of things that Canada could do to make the program seem more equitable, to send a signal of good faith, but those things are not in themselves going to get anybody to Canada.
Speaker: And I think that you know whether or not they waive the biometric requirement and, you know, come up with some solution that allows people to so to to get biometrics taken Gaza or to commit to processing it quickly once they're out of Gaza as the last step.
Speaker: That is not going to get anybody across the border. And I think that My position is that Canada owes these families clear, proactive communication about what is possible, what's not possible, what diplomatic measures they are taking, what the possible timelines are, so that families can make difficult but important decisions about whether this is where they need to be putting their resources and where they need to be putting their hopes.
Speaker: How can people listening add their voices to the kinds of concerns and problems that we've been talking about um in this interview to to put pressure on the Canadian government?
Speaker: I mean, this program, this situation is so fraught. It is fraught with the weight of ah minefield of ah of a political and social discourse around whether it is okay to acknowledge the genocidal settler colonial project that is taking place and has been taking place for decades by the Israeli state.
Speaker: I am inoculated to some degree from the fears that people often have in saying that in those terms because I am Jewish and I therefore feel particularly that I have a moral responsibility to speak loudly and clearly about that.
Speaker: And I think that it is tragic that a conversation that the difficulty that people have talking about this issue, that the way that allegations of anti-Semitism have been weaponized in order to silence that criticism, not just in the last year, but for also for decades, has been so effective that it is controversial whether Canada should be extending an opportunity for Canadian citizens and Canadian permanent residents to bring their family members to Canada.
Speaker: I think that that is just a travesty. And so, you know, you asked me what people can do. And it's hard for me to answer that in a very, very narrow sense. I have to put it in context and say, what you can do is you can feel emboldened to trust what you know is true and to feel the support of an increasingly diverse community of people who know what's true, making it possible to say it out loud.
Speaker: And that is that Palestinians have a right to self-determination, that the Israeli state has abdicated its moral authority, and that the people, the families who are living under siege and being starved and being burned alive need to be afforded the same level of humanity and the full recognition of their humanity as all people deserve, as all Canadian families deserve, and that we should not be talking about this program as anything special.
Speaker: I do believe that you know There is as is an instinct and history in Canada for you know creating special programs of refuge for for people um who are facing crisis.
Speaker: And that's all this is. And that the people in Gaza, who are our families, and I think that people can and should feel empowered to say that out loud.
Speaker: Thank you so much for speaking with me today, Randall. you're You're very welcome. I've been speaking with Randall Cohn, an immigration refugee lawyer working with Palestinians with family members in Gaza.
Speaker: You've been listening to the Red Eye Podcast, produced by an independent media collective based in Vancouver. If you enjoyed this episode, it would be great if you left a review on Apple Podcasts.
Speaker: It helps other people to find us. Also, please consider sharing this episode with a friend or telling someone about our podcast. To keep up with the show, you can subscribe to Red Eye wherever you listen to your podcasts.
Speaker: And you can follow us on Blue Sky at Red Eye Radio. I'm Jane Williams. Thanks for listening.


