Zencastr
00:00:00
00:00:01
Speed1x
Format▸
Share
Embed
Report

Episode 31 - Tolkien Would Hate This Podcast Part 3: Tolkien vs. The Machine (AI)

Queer Lodgings: A Tolkien Podcast
Queer Lodgings: A Tolkien Podcast

3 plays · Nov 16, 2026

Transcript

Speaker: Hi everyone, welcome to Queer Lodgings, the queer-led podcast about all things Tolkien. I'm Leah, and I'm here with my usual co-hosts, Grace.

Speaker: Hello. and Alicia. hi. And our producer, Tim, is making a rare appearance today as well. Tolkien AI hater number one reporting for duty.

Speaker: Spoilers. Jesus Christ. Spoilers. People definitely aren't going to know based on the title of the episode. Probably not. We have a whole fucking episode. i I'll make it back into my train. Sorry, guys. Please yeah please don't derail me. Thanks so much for joining us.

Speaker: Pull up a comfy chair, thin the lights a little, get out your weighted blanket, maybe find your favorite stuffed animal, and spike your drink with something strong.

Speaker: We want you all cozy and taken care of today because y'all, we're going to get into kind of a rough one. This episode, we have another installment in our Tolkien Would Hate This podcast series.

Speaker: And unfortunately, we have to ask a hard and terrible question. And I'm not sure if we're ready for the answer, but we have to do it, y'all. Okay, are y'all ready? Yeah.

Speaker: Y'all, would Tolkien hate AI? yeah see wood He would go like full end on Isengard and rip every brick, every copper wire, every piece of plastic and ship apart with his affair fucking hands. touching him With Molotovs. like Yeah, absolutely.

Speaker: Okay, well, thank you guys so much for listening to us today. Shortest episode ever. Shortest episode ever. Just kidding.

Speaker: So I know that we kind of spoiled where we are headed, but our topic today is a little bit of a different kind of Tolkien would hate this podcast episode. We are going to get into Tolkien and what he would think about technology, specifically artificial intelligence.

Speaker: So this is a little bit different from how we usually do these types of episodes. But we wanted to kind of give you a really quick sort of overview and game plan of the episode today.

Speaker: so you kind of know what you' you're diving into a little bit. So we're going to try to cover four basic giant topics. What we mean when we say AI, this is for all of you pedantic tech guys who want to, well, actually us, we're going to briefly cover what generative AI and agentic AI are, which are the main technologies that comprise the main AI models and software that's out there.

Speaker: In particular, we want to talk about the generative and agentic AI utilized by four specific companies, two of which are actually named after concepts and objects in Tolkien. Boo! Boo!

Speaker: And specifically, we want to talk about these four AI companies and how they're used in some larger fields of work and study, and talk briefly about some of the moral, ethical, environmental, social, psychological, and political impacts that these companies have had in recent years. There will be a few content warnings there. It'll also be a lot of TLDR because there is so much that has been going on.

Speaker: Then we're going to dive into some of the documented evidence that we have from Tolkien's writings, including his letters, his fiction, and the rest of the legendarium. And we'll kind of get into what he thought about technology, particularly in relationship to the non-human or natural landscape or the environment, and touch a little bit on his concept of the machine.

Speaker: And then finally, we'll kind of get into the speculation zone and see what we might expect from Tolkien based on his writings and kind of think about how he might feel about our current situation today.

Speaker: We'll kind of ask ourselves, what would he think about ai and these companies and their actions, particularly in light of the climate crisis and global warming? And hopefully we can come to some interesting conclusions.

Speaker: Then we'll whip out our Ouija board so that we can get the confirmation. Exactly. We're going to do some necromancy. Yep. Do some necromancy right at the end so we can get it straight from the man himself.

Speaker: So it's kind of our intent to have this episode serve as a kind of 101 on Tolkien's thoughts and technology, if you haven't read them or seen them, and to kind of give you a really, really basic overview of a handful of AI companies that we think are particularly relevant to the Tolkien fandom.

Speaker: Again, this isn't meant to be very, very comprehensive. We're going to be TLDR-ing some of the bigger primary world highlights and providing enough evidence from Token as to be useful, but hopefully not super overwhelming.

Speaker: Like the rest of the Token Would Hate this series, we kind of want to look at Token's words and think about what Token might or might not hate based on those. Honestly, this episode is a bit of a leaf by niggle sort of scenario. We've been working on a pretty vast and interwoven tapestry of related topics that builds to a fairly massive tree.

Speaker: And we've decided that we have to actually start sharing some of the leaves instead of waiting to paint the whole tree before talking about it. That's such a great way of putting it. So yeah, so let's get into it. Tim, can you start us off? Can you kind of walk us through what the heck generative AI is and what agentic is?

Speaker: Sure. Happy to do so. I'll make my best shot because I have managed to gain a bit of a reputation as like the anti-AI Tolkien guy over the past few years. So if anybody's like share in in like Facebook groups or whatever. You may have seen me like trying, trying my best to like call it out, push back on it when it shows up in Tolkien spaces, especially AI slop Tolkien, quote unquote, inspired art and that sort of shit. I just want to add, Tim will do this lovingly for all of us.

Speaker: When we sometimes like I have have sometimes shared something that I did not realize it was AI. Tim has called it out and it's allowed me to go, oh, my gosh, thank you. Taking that back now. And the first times that I do it, I do it with patience. The more you post AI slop, the less patience.

Speaker: Anyways. Yeah, so when we're talking about AI, in this case specifically, we're talking about like the most common usages of the term AI or artificial intelligence today. Specifically looking at generative artificial intelligence or Gen AI and agentic artificial intelligence or agentic AI.

Speaker: so Both Gen.ai Agentic.ai primarily but not exclusively utilize machine learning, deep learning, and natural language processing to achieve particular goals or quote-unquote output like new content.

Speaker: They're being made commercially available by the four major companies we'll be covering on this episode, so That'll be Polantir, Unreal, ChatGPT from OpenAI and Claude from Anthropic.

Speaker: All of these companies are supplying various AI-based products to the market, to individuals, companies and governments. These products mainly fall into a category of AI called limited or narrow learning AI.

Speaker: that's a system that uses past data to make decisions and predictions, but lack long term memory. So that's why anybody ever has fucked around with chat GPT or code or whatever, and asked it to like refer back to something that it or you've seen a video of somebody doing this, like asked it to refer back to something you told it previously, it often really cannot do that or gets it like completely wrong and misinterprets it.

Speaker: Yep. So what is generative AI? So we've sourced this information from a couple of IBM articles that we'll drop in the show notes on our website when this episode gets posted.

Speaker: So from one of those articles, the definition for generative quote, while traditional reactive AI was designed to recognize patterns and make predictions, generative AI creates new content such as text, images, video, audio, and software code.

Speaker: Users would typically provide instructions through user prompts that guide the system's output. The user can then review, refine, or respond to that output through more prompts, prompt refinement, those sorts of things. It generally responds to an input and then waits for further direction, primarily reactive, but can provide information or context for a user or for another system. So like, for instance, a Gen AI might end up feeding into Agentec AI, which we'll define next.

Speaker: Its interaction with external systems depends on the tools and capabilities built around the model. This is the type of AI that's used to make pictures where everyone's hands have a different than average number of fingers or geometries or shadows that don't make any sense. There's some weirdly unsettling stuff going on in the background.

Speaker: And that are sadly getting better at making images now that can truly fool people and that almost look photo real if you don't know what to look for. Yeah, it's a lot less Lovecraftian in its a output.

Speaker: That almost feels quaint now. Like, oh, remember the days when we could just like count the fucking fingers and know that that was slop? And now we've got to like actually put it through like detectors or like really look closely at background and stuff.

Speaker: The devil still ends up being in the details yeah though, where as you zoom in and look at particular things, you can find it, but you have to be suspicious of everything now.

Speaker: Unfortunately. It's also the kind of ai that like ah Jenny Harrison or other like content creators, I use that term very loosely, have been using to pump out like multiple AI slop Tolkien essays daily and they get like basic facts wrong about the books, but like Most people don't know the books in enough detail to really be able to spot them. And so some people have unfortunately been able to get a decent following by doing this sort of Anyways.

Speaker: Yeah. So like generative AI is kind of the foundations of of a lot of what we mean when we say ai including agentic AI. What's agentic AI, Yeah.

Speaker: So again, this is going back to these IBM articles, quote, agentic AI focuses on achieving a goal. It can determine what steps are needed to select among possible actions and work through a task over time.

Speaker: Users can provide a broader objective rather than specifying every step. so these have a lot more autonomy, which is fucking terrifying. Agentic systems can connect to tools, application programming interfaces or APIs, databases and other software to gather information or perform actions.

Speaker: Agentic systems can maintain information about the current task or retain relevant context across interactions. Memory can help an agent track process, use previous results, maintain context during longer workflows, and also use information from their environment and the results of previous actions to adjust their approach.

Speaker: This is Skynet. This is what's being described here. Feedback loops help the system evaluate outcomes, retry tasks, change plans, or request human input when it cannot proceed reliably.

Speaker: Some systems also use reinforcement learning during training or optimization to improve decision-making over time. or complex agentic systems coordinate multiple capabilities, tools, or AI agents to complete a broader objective.

Speaker: Depending on the system and the task, the agent can determine how to proceed and require less frequent user direction. Again, these are much more autonomous. An agent might generate content along the way, but can also retrieve information, make decisions, use the tool, or complete an action on the user's behalf and can operate with varying levels of autonomy.

Speaker: A lot of them are given way more autonomy or claim more autonomy than they're originally given a lot of the time, which is also fucking terrifying. It can plan and run multiple steps independently while still involving a human for approvals, oversight, or decisions that require

Speaker: So agentic AI is what's being referenced if you hear anyone talking about like the Hugging Face cyber attack incident where AI agents escaped human control and then hid their success from humans and then hacked Hugging Face to see if that company was part of the system of checks that would alert it to what the AI agents had done. That was through OpenAI or the four companies that Anthropics AI hacked or the bioweapons that someone tried to create using Claude.

Speaker: Or the Australian healthcare system that we learned about just an a couple of days ago as a recording this that was hacked by OpenAI, Agentic AI. Or you know what? In the last ah several weeks alone, that list has actually gotten too long to fully include here or this would be a 12-hour episode.

Speaker: Such fun! Oh, I do want to interrupt really quick just to say that, like, we do use the words a lot of, like, escaped or, like, went rogued to describe these incidents and these agents, like, kind of coming out of their testing sandbox, quote-unquote.

Speaker: It's less that the agents actually, like, broke free or did some jailbreaking and more they these companies have failed to basically build very basic industry standard safeguards and guardrails. So basically, instead of putting them like in Alcatraz to work on their tasks, they basically put them in a puppy playpen and left the door open. Yeah, like... so And these companies think that they're putting safeguards in place, but then some of these agents like figure out ways around it because they're trying to complete their task. They're doing exactly what they're told to do They're just failing to be restrained, basically.

Speaker: Anyway, yeah sorry. In the hugging face incident, there were probably hundreds of thousands of agents deployed, about 1,200 actually And succeeded in their task and then hid it from humans. And there were only a handful, like maybe about three or four or something that were like, hey, should we tell the humans that we did it? And they were all shut down by the other 1200 rogue agents.

Speaker: And they started developing their own fucking languages to talk to each other in as well and communicate between each other. And that made it harder to figure out what the hell they were doing and stuff. yeah So yeah, truly terrifying. In a day-to-day basis, you know if you or your your coworkers might talk about like using agentic AI or something like that to help them with certain work functions, like this is the same type of AI that like some overly trusting souls would like.

Speaker: openly like just let loose on to like clean up their inbox or their files or something like that. And then they act surprised when they just start like randomly permanently deleting like important files or emails because and then just shrugging and apologizing afterwards because they don't actually have any like judgment really. They don't know like what's important and what's not.

Speaker: Yeah, so so both generative AI and agentic AI use machine learning as their kind of basis. Large language models and natural language processing and they typically would work together. Agentic AI typically uses a generative AI model within it to interpret user requests, generate content, and communicate results.

Speaker: And that agentic layer then determines how to achieve whatever the objective is that the user's given it. So it can break a task into smaller steps, retrieve information, recruit other agents, use external tools, evaluate intermediate results, and then decide, okay, this is where we are now, this is where we go next,

Speaker: or it can go completely off script and do things that the user definitely never authorized it to do if the agent deems that that's what's necessary to complete its assigned task. So that's, again, Skynet is what we're describing here, if if not properly controlled, and it's not.

Speaker: oh So what exactly is a large language model? Yes, large language model. Again, we're going back to an IBM definition here. Large language models, which are typically abbreviated as LLMs, are a category of deep learning models trained on immense amounts of data, making them capable of understanding, kind of, and generating natural language and other types of content to perform a wide range of tasks.

Speaker: LLMs are built on a type of neural network architecture called the Transformer, which excels. at handling sequences, quote unquote, excels at handling sequences of words and capturing patterns of text. I want to take a second here and acknowledge that these definitions were published by a company with clearly a vested interest in the financial success of these large AI models. so That's why they're a little more laudatory and praising than we would probably define them. at least more neutral. Yeah.

Speaker: If we were writing the definitions ourselves, there would be so much more profanity in them. This is true. were and we're injecting We're code injecting profanity on the fly.

Speaker: Going back to the definition, LLMs work as giant statistical prediction models that repeatedly predict the next word in a sequence. They learn patterns in their text and generate language that follows those patterns.

Speaker: Once trained, large language models work by responding to prompts by tokenizing the prompt. which is little bit of a confusing term, but we'll leave it at that for now. Converting it into like embeddings and using its transformer to generate text one token at a time, calculating the probabilities for all the potential next tokens and outputting the most likely one. So literally building a response.

Speaker: It's like a sentence, like one word at a time. And saying, like what's you know algorithmically the most likely word to be next in this sequence based on the prompt that I've This process called inference is repeated until the output is complete.

Speaker: The model does not quote unquote know the final answer in advance. It uses all the statistical relationships it learned in its training to predict one token at a time, making its best guess at every step.

Speaker: End quote. So LLMs are what like power generative AI and make it possible for them to work. and I think it's also important to note something here we'll talk about more later, which is essentially all of the companies operating these LLMs acknowledge that they would not be able to function without massive training data sets that illegally scraped like billions of web pages and files and art to fill these training data sets.

Speaker: So they they function basically on on theft, on stolen material. LLMs have appropriately been referred to as stochastic parrots, empty repetition based on programmed guesswork.

Speaker: The term comes from a 2021 paper that forced one of the authors out of Google. And it's one of my favorite papers to see cited because it formally uses a parrot emoji in its title.

Speaker: So that's fun. It's nice to have some whimsy when when you're dealing with these potentially world-ending technologies. Right. Yeah. Gotta get your fucking joy in where you can, right?

Speaker: I just love reading through an article of existential horror and then all of a sudden, parent. ah It's like adding in a little smiley face. like yeah I think it's also worth noting that we're using a lot of language here because it's normative to use this language about these learning models. And and there's a lot of...

Speaker: language that's like personifying these technologies. They are not people. The technologies are not at that level. It's not actual intelligence.

Speaker: This is a shorthand for humans to understand a framework of how these technologies are behaving The technologies are not people. They cannot think.

Speaker: Correct. They see patterns and then repeat the patterns back to you. Hence the parrot part of that.

Speaker: So often with about the same utility of someone just continually inserting the phrase Polly want a cracker into your email. Like that helpful, actually.

Speaker: So so it's it's definitely something I caution when talking about AIs to anthropomorphize them like that, and because it does imply that they have like thinking ability and rationalization ability. if They really don't. They're just fucking prediction agents.

Speaker: Yep. Agreed. So we mentioned those four companies that we're going to be talking about today. Alicia, tell us a little bit more about those. All right. Today we are going to be discussing Palantir, which You've probably heard the name Peter Thiel or Alex Karp in conjunction with that company. Anduril, which Peter Thiel was involved with.

Speaker: but It's mostly Palmer Luckey who's associated with them now. OpenAI, which is the company that made ChatGPT. Sam Altman is a name you might remember being associated with them. And Anthropic, which is claude And Dario Amodei is who you might have heard be associated with them.

Speaker: Although there are many companies in the game been shittifying our lives, and I recommend checking out the Tolkienist Substack article, a hopefully exhaustive list of the neo-fascist tech growth companies and projects abusing Tolkienian names, for a list of those doing so while profaning Tolkien's work.

Speaker: We chose to focus on these four companies because they are all in bed together, using each other's products and models to build an ecosystem of surveillance that helps drive the war machine via contracts with multiple governments and militaries.

Speaker: They've also become embedded in many private companies' software stacks and invaded the private lives of individuals as well. OpenAI and Anthropics models are in use at almost all the other companies, possibly including each other's like some Hurst Ouroboros.

Speaker: as Starting with Planteer, let's discuss all of them. Planteer is most widely known right now for their involvement in the deaths of over 100 Iranian schoolchildren. They are involved in global and state military defense, surveillance, and law enforcement.

Speaker: It positions itself as a pattern recognition brain that can analyze several streams of data at once faster than humans, giving defense companies a heads up about potential threats before they fully materialize.

Speaker: Which sounds great until the model is working on an old map that misidentifies in elementary school as a military compound and no one double checks it before missiles are fired. Jesus Christ.

Speaker: yep They have contracts all over the place, including the ah United States Department of Defense, which i believe is called the Department of War now.

Speaker: yaa The Department of Homeland Security, the IRS, s HHS, what's left of the CDC, the CIA, the FBI. It's also has contracts with the IDF, the UK's NHS, and Ministry of Defense, and various government departments in Australia and EU countries.

Speaker: Unknown as to how many, but at least another linstonmark in Denmark and Spain, although ah some countries are moving away from using them due to the negative connotation there.

Speaker: Nested under the Department of Homeland Security in the US, s that is ICE using that technology as well. Yes. And, uh, I haven't fact checked this, but my understanding Palantir is one of the technologies that underlies like the flock network of cameras as well. Like it's some ah part of the like facial identification and that sort of thing that flock uses to like track, like it's a whatever police department you should pull this person over. They're likely to commit a crime or something.

Speaker: Cursed fucking Ouroboros indeed. Yeah. Probably responsible for a bunch of people being like inappropriately arrested or pulled over or whatever and We all know many terrible things that can happen after cops pull someone over.

Speaker: Yeah, just a very small aside. Tim and I were visiting the States to go to Dragon Con. And Atlanta, Georgia, is one of the most heavily surveilled city in the entire country. And coming from Canada into that kind of environment was wild to me. There are so many flat cameras literally everywhere. And guys, there is so much copper you can get out of a flat camera.

Speaker: Yeah, so so much precious metals. We're just, yeah, just in case anybody's interested, you know, just it's just an interesting fact that if someone were to cut one of those cameras down, you could get hundreds of dollars for the raw materials that are inside.

Speaker: Just great an interesting fact. Considering that there are islands in the Great Lakes with cursed copper and everything, I mean, these are alternatives for your mining interests.

Speaker: Urban mining. i like this. Amazing. We, of course, make no recommendations. We just want you to be aware of the geographic intricacies of the world.

Speaker: Purely informational. Mm-hmm. ah Anduril is pretty similar to Palantir. They're also involved in global and state military defense, surveillance, and law enforcement. But instead of crunching the data to tell the military where to strike, they develop AI-enabled autonomous robot weapons and surveillance systems, which is totally not dystopian at all.

Speaker: Yep. That doesn't sound scarier. yeah The largest customer is the United States Department of Defense, but they also supply other allied countries, including the UK, Australia and the UAE. And their surveillance powers are used by the Department of Homeland Security to monitor the U.S. borders. So another company fueling the mass thuggery of ice Oh, OpenAI and Anthropic are closely related in a similar way to Palantir and Antiril.

Speaker: OpenAI, i again, ChatGPT and Anthropic, <unk>ude are both involved in creative work, visual art, design and media. public and higher education, global and state military defense, surveillance and law enforcement, and public and individual physical and mental health care.

Speaker: OpenAI i has the most fingers in the most pies these days, having developed many GPT and agentic models, a coding tool, and various chipsets to enable LLMs.

Speaker: Yeah. Yeah. These guys, the all four of these companies are, again, in bed with each other and kind of contracting with each other and using each other's software. And that's part of the reason why we chose to focus on these four is because they're all, again, kind of in a weird, incestuous, horrifying, orborist sort of relationship with each other.

Speaker: And the things that are powering a lot of the systems of Palantir and Anderil are, are open AI and anthropic models.

Speaker: And also economically very closely related in that they're all investing money and pledging money to each other in a way that is frighteningly similar to the fucking real estate market in 2007, 2008.

Speaker: And there is now signs that that bubble may be finally fucking bursting in Salah. on Several of these also have applications where they're able to ah essentially begin to code the genetic sequences that can be turned into bioweapons and reports from recent meetings of former four-star generals and things like that in the United States have listed the bio warfare concerns as much higher than the public realizes.

Speaker: Great. Fantastic. just We're just all happiness today for you guys. When there have been whistleblowers from these companies coming forward and saying that they the founders of these companies believe that AI could kill us all within the next decade, there are some things to listen to there.

Speaker: I mean, personally, I think that means the money is fucking drying up. And yeah, they're just like, maybe we should start scaling back, guys, because our bank accounts are looking a little dry. i i'm going to place things as I'm going to put a pin in that there because there's there's a lot to say there and I don't want to don want us to get too off track. Fair enough. from So, yeah, Anthropic.

Speaker: Anthropic was founded by former executives of OpenAI and positions itself as the safety-focused AI research company. They're focused on understanding AI models better and the broader ethical and societal implications of their technology.

Speaker: This is, of course, all bullshit. We don't have time today to get into this in depth. There's a bit of a tease for a future episode. The end goal of a lot of these companies is to create a true artificial intelligence that will completely outpace humans, which is often referred to as ah achieving the singularity or the technical singularity.

Speaker: OpenAI i essentially believes that they need to race ahead of everyone else to win as they are the only ones who understand and can guide others through the ethical quandaries associated with that, even if they must break everything in order to get there.

Speaker: And as some former anthropic researchers have recently gone on record in September of 2026, saying there's a roughly 10% chance that chasing this research will destroy humanity utterly.

Speaker: anthropic knows that breaking things is bad but they're gonna do it anyway so they can win the race and put up mild guard rails for everyone else they'll even feel bad about it from time to time what a comfort cool being the safest fucking like ai company is like the definition of damning by faint praise right cool cool cool Yeah, so much like ChatGPT, OpenAI's Claude has a lot of fingers and a lot of pies across various sectors.

Speaker: And people can use this model and like tailor it to their individual needs and goals. So it gets really embedded in a lot of different areas. And there is a quote in here that is lovely. It's from Rita Nasir.

Speaker: It's talking about Palantir. And the quote is, if you think of open AI and anthropic as the brain and antireal as the muscle, Palantir is the central nervous system. It is the software that ingests raw chaos, satellite bees, drone footage, human intelligence, and spit out a single actionable coordinate for a missile.

Speaker: With no oversight. like yeah And that's that's the issue, like or one of the big issues with the way like the US government and some of the other foreign governments have been using this, is that they'll just take that and be like, well, Palantir told us to strike here, so let's do it.

Speaker: And then a bunch of kids are dead. Or it could even like feed directly into like one of Andriel's weapon systems or something like that, and like no human hand ever has any say or check over that missile strike or drone strike or whatever.

Speaker: Which is kind of thing. The CEOs of at least one of these companies has said that it would be convenient for them if the U.S. would make war crimes legal. Speaking of war crimes. Oh my god. a fucking segue. What a segue. Leanna, you said there were going to be so many trigger warnings, and I think our listeners should just understand that when we say so many trigger warnings, if you're at an age where you recall the the infomercials on TV with like the 200 song collections on a compact disc they scrolled by in the background while i um like one flashed up in front that is that's the scale and scope of trigger warnings we are talking about today apologies if we don't highlight all of them but they're all there yeah producer tim will do his best when making the episode description Yeah, yeah and we're not going to get like the no nothing like super graphic or specific because there's a lot going on and we do not have time.

Speaker: Speaking of war crimes,

Speaker: what are some of the impacts that these four companies are having on the planet, Alicia? Fucking nothing good, I can tell you that. um There are so many moral and ethical violations, including copyright. but We mentioned earlier that all of these large language models are built off stolen data. I personally am part of a couple of class action lawsuits surrounding having some of my writings stolen and fed into these models against my desire. I'm obviously not the only person that that is reflective of. um If you've ever published anything via Routledge, maybe look into that.

Speaker: So they steal people's words. They steal people's art. They're getting sued to like middling. Like there hasn't been a true lawsuit that has come through that has settled this one way or the other yet as well.

Speaker: like how this is going to go in the future um they seem to be tougher about it in europe than they are in north america although open ai did voluntarily take sora their video generating offline after like a bunch of fucking lawsuits so i think it is having an impact even if the cases aren't necessarily getting like so most of those lawsuits weren't about like some of them were about copyright but a lot of them were about like Porn, problematic porn.

Speaker: Yeah, yeah. CSAM, yeah, that kind thing. Yeah, yeah. and And Anthropic did, I don't know if it's completely settled, but they did propose the terms for settling for $1.5 billion dollars for one of them these main copyright class action lawsuits. So that's a pretty big step.

Speaker: I will also point out that now to get around this, they are buying up rare books and destroying them to scan them into their models to get around these stolen the stolen text things so now they're just actively destroying priceless things to try to launder their own image after having stolen all of this shit yeah

Speaker: There's also like so many labor violations because like these models do actually have to be trained and they're usually being trained by people in third world countries. The global South. Yeah, that's a much better way of putting that. People in Africa and India who are being paid literally nothing.

Speaker: And they are having to see horrible, horrible content, like disturbing, abusive, terrible content as they are trying to train these models.

Speaker: There have been some people trying to get around the training by using other AI models to train ai models. People have been getting fired for doing that sort of thing, which honestly, do what you got to do.

Speaker: get paid, but also don't make it easy for these people, in my opinion. Palantir and Andriel and Claude have been used to enable the genocide that's happening in Gaza and the Iran war.

Speaker: Literal fucking war crimes. As confirmed by the UN, n not just our opinion. Yeah. Google and Microsoft are also implicated in that.

Speaker: ChatGPT is signing new contracts with the Department of Defense in the US, and Anthropic and Claude are being phased out. But still used. Yeah, because Anthropic told them, no, we will not remove safeguards for you.

Speaker: And ChatGPT or OpenAI, Sam Altman said, yeah, whatever. is We will. All shade to Sam Altman on this, but just one quick caveat. Anthropic didn't say that they wouldn't. They said we wouldn't yet.

Speaker: so much worse and even the best case scenario sounds like. i Fucking hate it. They're the safe AI company. Yeah.

Speaker: Fuck me. All the air quotes. Anthropic had to shut down its latest models due to security risks, but they're back up. Yay! Yay!

Speaker: Both OpenAI and Anthropic have had agents hack multiple companies and institutions, like Grace was talking about that a little bit earlier. They're using each other to hack each other. Fuck's sake, this is so stupid.

Speaker: this is This is the fucking dumbest. This is the stupidest timeline. every really fucking is. money It wasn't so fucking dangerous. Yeah, this isn't AI going rogue. This is just like, they were told to do these things. They're going to do them.

Speaker: They're not people. They don't have a moral code. They can't think, really. Like, if you tell it to do something, it's just going to do it. It will do it however is expedient, including hallucinating, which is how the U.S. military almost ended up boarding a Chinese vessel recently.

Speaker: and was like mere hours away from doing that because someone had run a process that resulted in AI hallucinations about intelligence efforts.

Speaker: It's great. Yeah, we've already talked about how Palantir and Andriel are being used by ICE for immigration enforcement and surveillance. And yay, I'm on a list. Anthropic is building monitoring systems to surveil anti-AI activists and doing pre-crime policing.

Speaker: Yeah, you're on a list. You're on a list. You're on a list. Everybody's on a list. How is this worse than Minority Report? Yeah, right. Thought crimes.

Speaker: Yeah, literal, literal thought crimes. It's these fucking idiots like seeing those movies and like thought crimes, huh? That sounds good. Let's go with that. yeah watch it reading these fucking books and being like yeah that sounds like a great idea let's invent the torment nexus from the famous book don't invent the torment it's depressing to me that that meme doesn't get less impactful for real I did want to point out that Palantir and Anduril are not just being used by federal departments, but by local and state governments. Local law enforcement is, in many different places and many different jurisdictions, are directly contracting with Palantir to train. Like, in Los Angeles, the LAPD was basically trained by Palantir for surveillance.

Speaker: Dear God. Cool. cuckkoo Cool, cool. Cool. There's also, you know, the environmental impacts of all of this shit. Yeah, strap in, y'all. There's yeah a lot here.

Speaker: but yeah Sorry.

Speaker: It's just killing the Earth. To be, like, really succinct about it, all these data centers that have to be built to power... these LLMs because they're dealing with such massive amounts of data. Like, it's killing the fucking Earth.

Speaker: This quote is from Oxford Research Encyclopedia of okay Science, Technology, and Society. Fantastic. It's called The Environmental Impacts of AI. AI is reliant on environmentally fraught critical materials for hardware, toxic manufacturing processes for chips and servers, and energy and water intensive data centers for data processing, all while contributing to the planet's fastest growing waste stream, e-waste. Additionally, AI applications are being used to accelerate oil and gas extraction and consumption, ultimately speeding up global carbon emissions production.

Speaker: And I grew up in the fucking ninety s on like fucking Captain Planet and like Nickelodeon and their recycling drives and all of that. And it has been so depressing for me as an adult to realize that all of that was meaningless horseshit because there's nothing I, there's no amount of fucking cans I can recycle that will offset what these fucking companies are doing. And that was before I even knew about AI and now it's just exponentially worse than I thought it was before. Yeah.

Speaker: Yeah. Yeah. Big gas and big oil have been subverting the narrative on individual impact on the environment since before any of us here were born. So it's really depressing to to realize that and also look upon the future of of these data centers and AI. Yeah.

Speaker: Also, like close to my heart, because I am from rural South Georgia, they are turning like Southwestern Georgia is they're shooting for that area to be the data center capital of the entire fucking world.

Speaker: And to know that that is what's going to happen to like the place that I grew up is like deeply upsetting to me. Like there are already towns in Georgia that the data centers that have gone in around them have like made it so like their water doesn't even fucking work anymore because it's just pulling so much water and so much power. And that's just going to fucking get worse.

Speaker: Apparently, gas-powered data centers could generate more pollution than the country of Morocco in its entirety. oh just 11 of them.

Speaker: Oh, 11. Yeah, sorry. 11 gas-powered data centers. That's fucking wild. A potential new gas-powered Amazon data center could be the largest polluter in the country.

Speaker: An open AI data center in Georgia could potentially be the largest consumer of electricity in the entire state. using more than both of Georgia's new nuclear reactors combined. Which is kind of a wild statistic.

Speaker: Yeah. Multiple data centers are facing enforcement of wastewater pollution, including into communities and fragile wetlands. People are becoming increasingly aware of how much water is used in data centers. and how much it is impacting local ecosystems. They generate a lot of noise pollution, impacting public health and local ecosystems. Again, to bring that back to something personal to me, they are trying to put a data center in like 10 miles away from where we are currently living because a lot of the municipalities nearby have forced them out.

Speaker: And I reached out to a number of people in our local and provincial governments to ask them, has anyone done any research about what this data center would do? Because it's literally right on a river. No one's looked into it at all. Only one person got back to me and they got back to me with like something that was definitely a cut-and-paste email that did nothing to answer any of my fucking questions.

Speaker: And this isn't a place that is... that actually has some sort of, like, governmental regulation surrounding shit like this, unlike the United States. know Not really. Fucking Mark Carney is, like, gung-ho on AI and wants to make sure that we're using homegrown Canadian AI, because that'll somehow fucking be better.

Speaker: I don't want any of it! I don't want any of this shit! In Milwaukee, they were looking at putting in a small data center, really more of a server farm. So the scale and scope wasn't the concern. it would have been limited to the size of like a Walmart toy department.

Speaker: But they tried to put it in in a floodplain. And they did no research about the fact that it was a fucking floodplain where the reason that the Walmart is no longer there is because the water bubbles up out of the floor.

Speaker: You know, let them build it there. is Is the size of a Walmart toy department one of those very American... Is that part of the imp Imperial system? Don't use anything except the metric system. It had been a former Walmart site and this would have been contained to that site. That's a freedom unit? Yes. Walmart toy department?.003 of a Walmart toy department. Do you know how shitty that site has to be for Walmart to fucking abandon it?

Speaker: Yeah. man it's not far from my house either so that's fun i am literally allergic to walmart though so that that is a fun fact about grace wow i'm not allergic to walmart me too right wow we're still not through all of the nope tell us more tell us more alicia yeah cool you know kids are killing themselves like Because Claude told them to and helped them figure out how to Yeah, there have been multiple lawsuits about teenagers, children, asking Claude for advice on how to kill themselves and him complying. It's been shown to enable mass shootings, like other types of mass violence. People are going into... AI psychosis from a religious standpoint and also from a relationship standpoint. Chatbots are claiming to be God. Chatbots are convincing people that they are God. There's a rumor that employees at Anthropic were worshipping Claude as a God.

Speaker: Yeah, we should note for listeners, like numerous lawsuits against ChatGPT in particular, but also plotted in particular for, again, for for these suicides and for at least one school shooting in Canada.

Speaker: And the social and psychological harm is kind of overwhelming for me. It's one of the, big it's kind of one of the main things that I get really worked up about when we're talking about AI. Yeah.

Speaker: I think one of the things with that is we highlighted specific stories about teenagers and children, but there's also awareness that, and this may be more of a U.S.-based thing because of our healthcare system or lack thereof, that people are utilizing chatbots as an alternative to therapy or treating them like therapists. Yes. Really harmful results in just a multitude of ways.

Speaker: not only like mental health, but like all kinds of like conditions where people, and this is just part of the fucking like nightmare of of American end stage capitalism is like, I can't afford to go to the doctor. So going to ask fucking Chloe chat GPT or whatever, like what I'm sick with and what I should go treat myself with or whatever. And that's not fucking reliable either.

Speaker: And it says you have cancer and need to give yourself ivermectin because it's been trained on fucking WebMD, right? You have ghosts in your blood. Go do cocaine about it. There's, again, segwaying into to public health, there's lawsuits against ChatGPT specifically for misguidance on medical diagnoses, but several folks have overdosed after consulting ChatGPT, and some of them have overdosed. eaten poisonous mushrooms after consulting ChatGPT instead of a local foraging guide. You need a person to teach you about foraging mushrooms. Someone has to be there physically to teach you this. Yeah, I'm laughing a little bit about it, but it again, it's it speaks to the overall state of public health in the U.S. that makes this, I think, even more worrying. There are entire...

Speaker: books that people have self-published and put on platforms like Amazon that are driven through ai chatbots and hallucinate information and people buy them thinking that they are actual like published and fact-tech guides yeah and have gotten sick or died.

Speaker: Like it is horrifying. Yeah. Also, do not look at the AI like summary on Google if you're searching things like is this poisonous to my dog? Can I feed my tiny baby this? Because my coworker was looking up if it was safe to feed her three-month-old nephew honey, and it is not safe to feed an infant honey. And the Google AI was like, yeah, sure, that's fine. Do it.

Speaker: God, Jesus Christ. Do not trust something that was generated by AI if it is has anything to do with you or someone else's health. Please just do not do it. Just in general, yes, but especially if it has something to do with health.

Speaker: Yeah. Y'all, I think we have... reference god or jesus more in this episode than we ever have before i know right also uh because tolkien was a catholic yeah a chatbot seems like something that would be totally a little chill let's put a pin in that but Tolkien would totally be fine with us saying Jesus fucking Christ. I would posit he would be more cool with it than he would be with an AI chatbot claiming to be God. Listen, what if Kilby said he told anti-Catholic jokes, even though he held her faith dearly? So like...

Speaker: I feel like he'd have concerns about the content more than our language. Yeah, let's not get too ahead ourselves. Okay, there's there's still more, guys. We kind of touched a little bit on this, but the impact on the political landscape. Can you tell us a little bit more about that, Alicia?

Speaker: Yeah, well, you know, Donald Trump, ah just in general. He's a product of AI. I'm saying it here now.

Speaker: He fucking acts like he is. Jesus Christ. oxley Yeah, he extensively uses AI on his his social media platform that no one ever checks. um Like he does like deep fakes of things. The Department of Homeland Security uses AI to... make videos and things like that. There's just so much fucking risk involved because we have evidence of these systems going rogue, like that could affect elections, like both for the systems going rogue and also for all like all the disinformation that's being put out there.

Speaker: We've been through two presidential elections since kind of the advent of generative AI and they've both been very hotly contested for various reasons.

Speaker: can, we've almost started a war with China over false intelligence that we've like kind of covered already. and like AI is also making us dumber. So we, we can't actually like one, it's getting better, but two, we're also getting dumber. People are becoming more reliant on AI and are like outsourcing a lot of their own, like,

Speaker: cognitive work to an external system and becoming dependent on it, which is exactly what the ai AI companies want to have happen, because that's the only way they're going to fucking make money is to get you hooked on it and then jack up the subscription price, right?

Speaker: Also, minimally, at least 20% of meme images with misinformation about Gaza are just generative AI slop.

Speaker: The amount of misinformation that's being put out there with AI is impactful. Israel's got an entire, I mean, they're well known for just having a huge propaganda arm to their government and they're clearly using that just to seed audit accounts and stuff like that with all this misinformation.

Speaker: As do countries like Russia, which are, you know, fighting ah an invasion war into Ukraine and all of that too. Yeah, so there have been studies on children that have Shown that children using AI have caused cognitive decline and atrophy that's more commonly associated with aging brains.

Speaker: And it can stunt the emotional growth of kids because they're talking to yes men robots instead of actual other people and aren't learning how to socialize with humans.

Speaker: yeah And, you know, there's also the whole higher education aspect of it where people are getting degrees for turning in, like, AI papers and not learning shit. And that's terrifying. Am I going to be able to see a doctor that's under the age of 30?

Speaker: Like, can I trust their fucking degree that that they didn't, like, chat GPT their way to a fucking medical degree? Like, it's terrifying. drive Whatever chat GPT thinks anatomy and physiology is not interested.

Speaker: I could have sworn the clitoris was in my it's so hard to find. yeah It's in your male nostril. Yeah. Right? No?

Speaker: good Fucking clode. ah This is all kind of part of like the AI is sort of contributing to the the erosion of ah shared reality and also making it harder for us to discern what is reality and what is not. And this, I think, is especially going to become a lot more apparent as kids who are growing up using these LLMs and chatbots continue to grow and continue to outsource their thinking and outsource their ability to discern what is real and what is not.

Speaker: Again, sort of like the war on reality is kind of how I characterize a lot of ai impact, really. Yeah, the removal of like an objective fact-based fucking reality, which I mean, the political right in the US had, that's been a goal of theirs for decades now. And they're using AI largely to get to that point where there is no objective truth left.

Speaker: but that's another podcast episode once Leah finishes some of her work. i So yeah, that was lot. Thank you listeners for sticking with us. That was a lot of background on AI itself. We really wanted to kind of offer that for you if you hadn't really kind of realize the full scope of it, even if he had gotten it in bits and pieces.

Speaker: There is so much more on this subject. I have several books that I have read and can recommend to you that you can find in the show notes. Again, we've referenced several articles as well.

Speaker: So let's move out of the primary world a bit, or at least let's go back in time and get Tolkien's thoughts and attitudes on technology.

Speaker: Grace, can you give us a little bit on what Tolkien thought about the modern technology and industry that he experienced, especially in mid-century Oxford?

Speaker: Happily. I think you could sum that up as not fond. Not a fan. So there's a really neat anecdote that actually is talked about on the Tolkien Estate website that talks about how Tolkien was first introduced to a tape recorder by his friend George Sayre. in 1952.

Speaker: He'd never seen or used one before this time and insisted on first recording the Lord's Prayer in Gothic to cast out any demons. What a nerd! great While there are audio recordings of him reading several selections from The Hobbit and Lord of the Rings that can be found many places, including the Tolkien Estate web website, we unfortunately do not have available audio of him doing the Lord's Prayer in Gothic and exercising the tape recorder, much to our chagrin.

Speaker: Release the elf smut and also that. ah release the gothic lord's prayer hashtag release the go back goic lord's prayer listen i would make it a ringtone so make it our new intro and outro song sure ah little known fact about the alicia tim household is We have some of the recordings of Jert reading from The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit on vinyl.

Speaker: Ooh, that's beautiful. And they were still factory sealed when we got them. Yes, the person who graciously donated them to us had never listened to them. Wow. Wow.

Speaker: well Well, we can dive into this and start with some things that are like a little bit more esoteric that folks might not be familiar with from Tolkien's writings and then get into some examples that may seem more familiar as we go. So we're going to take a little sojourn into discussing the Bovadium Fragments. This is a short story inspired by a comic poem, Motor Bus, by A.D. Godley, which was partly in Latin and casts a double-decker bus as basically a monster that destroys its victims with noise. Are we seeing some parallels? Yeah.

Speaker: So it destroys its victims with noise and by a fervor over a years-long road planning debate controversy in Oxford and the university, which itself is a sort of reflection on the larger debate over the arrival of cars in England and the great industrialization of Oxford.

Speaker: Jertz-Oxford was rapidly changing from a medieval town centered around the university to a car manufacturing hub that eventually became the largest motor manufacturer in the UK.

Speaker: Oxford became the fastest growing city in the county between the two world wars, and an increase in motor traffic was of enormous distress to Tolkes and Edith. He wrote it as a satirical fantasy, then commentating on all of this change. And I think it offers not only a chance for folks to see him flexing his comedy muscles, but a lot of insight into how he felt about modern technology, in this case, the motor car.

Speaker: So here's a quick summary. There's a cute frame device of archaeologists and linguists of the future suddenly discovering these fragments detailing a time Vasti or Bavadium, old Oxford, being suddenly visited by a demon who, quote, devised certain abominable machines to which he gave the name motors, which became almost sentient monsters who need feeding, tending, housing and appeasement, even as they literally hunt down and murder pedestrians and horses. This is not Tolkien's most subtle work, folks. This is this is C.S. Lewis level...

Speaker: Tolkien, that famous quote about cordially disliking Aliquiri, think that went out the fucking window. So soon everyone has a motor and the demon promises that, quote, any motor which he so tended would become his servant and would bear him with great speed wherever he wished. And he would be rid forever of the labor of walking.

Speaker: Things escalate, traffic increasingly slows down the speed of the motors, the city is ruined as the inhabitants serve and eventually worship the motors, though some resist that, and eventually everyone basically goes to war, the city becomes a solid mass of motors that can't move, and everyone dies in the smog.

Speaker: In another ending... Everything actually blows up when someone tosses a match into motorist full of fuel. And everyone literally winds up in hell. Long after Bavadiam is gone, the remaining survivors use the broken and dead motors to house their chickens.

Speaker: i want to say I'm seeing a parallel here to Mr. Toad's wild ride. I was about to say, Tolkien would fucking love Mr. Toad's wild ride. Yeah, you crash in your car and then you go to hell.

Speaker: stuff Just, the you know, normal family friendly like Disney dark ride. Yeah. So here are some quotes from this that I think could be recognizable to anyone familiar with the AI development race.

Speaker: Quote. Many planners then arose who proposed this plan and that, but the only plan that was never put forward in any debate was that the motor should be restricted or even prohibited. For at heart, men were enamored of the motors, and the secret wish of every man was that he alone should possess a motor and ride it at ease, but other men should go on foot and preserve the peace.

Speaker: Or, quote, for it was well known that ministers did not count costs incurred by other people and favored plans that were bold, a term that at that time was applied to any action that hurt someone else.

Speaker: I love that line. I'm like, that's a good singer's token. Yeah. feel relevant Here's another. And since motors proved to be as short lived as they were voracious and those who had once kept one wished always for a successor. Nothing came of the debate, for no one would listen to any plan that might hinder the supply of new motors.

Speaker: AI chips. Motors.

Speaker: Therefore, highly pleased, the demon saw to it that his agents produced more and more motors, and he laughed, for no one seemed yet to have perceived the fraud that he had practiced. He had promised speed, and he had promised ease and the saving of time.

Speaker: But as for speed... Before long, the Via Maxima was packed with an unceasing stream of motors crawling so slowly from halt to halt that a man on foot could, like an animal, walk its whole length and back to find a mounted friend only 10 yards further on his way while the horn of his motor trumpeted in vexation.

Speaker: And as for ease, the owners now had a multitude of cares, tending the ailments of the monsters and seeking places where to leave them, which consumed most of their time to no purpose. I feel that it's fucking parking in downtown Toronto, folks.

Speaker: Yeah, well, and also the fact that a lot of office workers and especially IT workers are having to deal with fixing AI's mistakes. um They promised that it would make their jobs a lot faster and a lot easier.

Speaker: that's it? They refer to them as slop grenades. so blow Blow shit up and then the the coders actually have to go back and fix. And then there's this.

Speaker: where he writes that such men cared very little what their motors did as long as their skin shone and they purred. So very move fast and break things, very fix what AI gets wrong, very AI will fix everything. So we have to keep making it. and Very, if you slow us down or try to regulate us, it's of the Antichrist. It will cause the end of the world. it will kill us all. yeah And I think also the argument that We need ai to build the solutions for the things that AI breaks, which ignores the fact that the breaking will happen first and the fixing cannot catch up.

Speaker: Yeah. Reading this book, if you haven't read it and you're you're interested in Tolkien kind of as a satirist, it's it's an interesting read. And reading these quotes in particular, it just felt very relevant and very of today as well. Mm-hmm.

Speaker: There's also there's there's a postscript at the end of the third fragment, which is probably my favorite in terms of highlighting Tolkien's attitude. He has a really prescient and perceptive forecasting of what some people think.

Speaker: Quote, "'We do not believe in any demon, and if we did, we should give no ear to one that prompted us to the making of large machines.' For happily, we value peace and food and the visual arts, and the science to which we are most devoted is medicine, somatic and psychic.

Speaker: At present, indeed, as we all know, we are on the brink of great advances, and the hope is now near that we shall at last conquer mortality and not die like animals, to quote the words of our leading thanatologist.

Speaker: Some think that he is inspired, end quote. So this quote at the end of the Bavidium fragments, to me, really speaks to a belief that's at the heart of the Silicon Valley religion and the AI cult and is the engine that drives the AI race, which is the quest to conquer death.

Speaker: While the characters in the frame device regard what happened in Bovadium as silly and foolish, like they were worshipping the motors and getting sucked into the entire frenzy, and they were even sillier for destroying themselves, they don't actually see that they're doing the exact same thing with another kind of technology, which they call medicine.

Speaker: So I would argue that people who dismiss others' fears and hesitations around AI and around their impacts, like this postscript does, have a lot to take to heart from this quote.

Speaker: And to put a pin in that, on myself, on Silicon Valley religion and the quest for immortality, This is a really big part of what I am studying and linking to Tolkien's theory of subcreation, but it's too much for today. This episode will be about 400 years long if we get into it, and I will still be feeling two tinfoil hat reds for Corkworth's conspiracy. um That's also why we're not talking about Peter Thiel.

Speaker: There's too much and I cannot sign up and might not feel like it over about an hour in. We are actually doing editing Tim a favor by not talking about these things. This is the short version, y'all. Not like the six episode maxi series.

Speaker: You think it's only six. Yeah. That is all to say i'm working on it. You guys. Yeah.

Speaker: Fair enough. OK, so let's talk about the evidence from Tolkien's letters. Tolkien gripes about traffic and cars and noise a bunch in his letters. So here are a few general sentiments.

Speaker: From a letter 52, it was written in 1943. It's the letter where he also is talking about anarchy. There is only one bright spot, and that is the growing habit of disgruntled men of dynamiting factories and power stations. I hope that encouraged now as patriotism may remain a habit.

Speaker: He likes blowing shit up. Hell yeah. In fiction, in Bovadium Fragnance, everyone blows up and goes to hell, and he's into it. Yeah. I think Tolkien would be in into taking the copper out of data centers and flock cameras.

Speaker: In letter 64, written in 1944, he quote,

Speaker: but the heavens are full of roar and riot you cannot even hold a shouting conversation in the garden now save about one a m and seven p m unless the day is too foul to be out how i wish the infernal combustion engine had never been invented or more difficult still since humanity and engineers in special are both nitwitted and malicious as a rule, that it could have been put to rational use, if any.

Speaker: Tolkien complains about traffic and traffic noise a lot in his letters. It's a big bit's a big source of consternation to him. Noise pollution, big no-no with him. Yeah, yeah it's pretty funny. Can't hear the trees talking to him.

Speaker: As you mentioned, Tim, he then uses the metaphors of Mordor and Isengard for the noise and technology of modern life. In letter 135 in 1952, he writes, quote, this charming house has become uninhabitable, unsleepable in, unworkable in, rocked, wracked with noise and drenched with fumes such as modern life. Mordor in our midst.

Speaker: and He also uses the metaphor of Isengard in particular, as well as Mordor. In letter 181, he writes, quote, he writes quote though the spirit of eisenard if not of mordor is of course always cropping up the present design of destroying oxford in order to accommodate motor cars is a case And again, the Bobodian fragments were written partly as a response to basically that roadway plan in Oxford for accompanying more motorists or more motor cars. so

Speaker: Here then he talks about machinery and machines. This is letter 75 written in 1944. He writes, there's a tragedy and despair of all machinery laid bare.

Speaker: Unlike art, which is content to create a new secondary world in the mind, It attempts to actualize desire, and so to create power in this world, and that cannot really be done with any real satisfaction.

Speaker: Labor-saving machinery only creates endless and worse labor. And in addition to this fundamental disability of a creature, it has added the fall, which makes our devices not only fail of their desire, but turn to new and horrible evil.

Speaker: Labor-saving machinery. Tolkien was a Luddite. I'm there with you. He continues, it is not advance in wisdom. This terrible truth glimpsed long ago by Sam Butler sticks out so plainly and is so horrifyingly exhibited in our time with its even worse menace for the future that it seems almost a worldwide mental disease that only a tiny minority perceive it.

Speaker: I do want to delve into that reference here because that context is pretty impactful for me. So that's a reference to Erewhon by Samuel Butler, first published anonymously in 1972, but for which draft materials were beginning to be written while Americans were slaughtering each other on battlefields like Antietam and Gettysburg over the question of how much should we do slavery?

Speaker: I mention that because i need us not to glide past the extremity of warnings about impacts that people were writing about. Erwan is a satire of Victorian society with three specific chapters comprising the Book of Machines. And Butler wrote, quote,

Speaker: I fear none of the existing machines. What I fear is the extraordinary rapidity with which they are becoming something very different to what they are at present. No class of beings have in any time past made so rapid a movement forward.

Speaker: Should not that movement be jealously watched and checked while we can still check it? And is it not necessary for this end to destroy the more advanced of the machines which are in use at present, though it is admitted that they are themselves harmless?

Speaker: Caveat on that last bit. In a broadcast the year that followed Tolkien's letter, where he references Butler, George Orwell also mentioned Butler and said that when Butler had written, it required, quote, imagination of a very high order to see that machinery could be dangerous as well as useful.

Speaker: So that's Orwell and Tolkien in World War II talking about Butler recognizing the dangers of unchecked thirst for uncareful machine development. All of these men lived through eras of horror and wars, and this is what they warned about.

Speaker: And side note here, that says to me that the creator of that very overpriced fucking grocery store, Erewhon, also fundamentally misunderstood the text that

Speaker: Air one is literally nowhere spelled backwards also. So like my dude building the torment nexus, yeah and but putting us sprouts and I don't know things.

Speaker: I'm sure those have all been recalled by the $28 asparagus water and shit. Yeah, this is $40 microgreens or whatever. Okay.

Speaker: Tolkien also really did not like people naming machines after his creations. In Letter 258, 1964, he writes, I wish the copyright could protect names as well as extracts. It is a form of invention that I take a great deal of trouble over and pleasure in. And really, it's... It is quite difficult, often more so, as say lines of verse. I must say I was piqued by the christening of that monstrous hydrofoil shadowfax without so much as a buy or leave, to which several correspondents drew my attention, some with indignation.

Speaker: so And if he had that much of a problem with, you know, a hydrofoil being named Shadowfax, what do we think Tolkien would have thought about the actual manufacturers of murderous drones and spy bots naming their companies after his fucking creations? Like, come on, guys. Yeah, just the murder robots.

Speaker: I think that he'd be really happy about that. Yeah, definitely. Yeah. Yeah. Yes, anyone who's who's developed their cognitive reasoning through writing papers using AI would think that he'd be really happy about that.

Speaker: Great. Yeah, he wants to live in the the Notion Club papers, like mechanized Numenor. Totally cool with that. yeah Exactly. yeah Yeah, yeah, People trying to artificially exp extend their lives and that going very well for them. Oh boy.

Speaker: Too easy, barely an inconvenience. Yeah. He also talks particularly about technologies of war, like airplanes, because World War Two, and of course, the atomic bomb.

Speaker: And he really hates that Christopher is in the Air Force because of the airplanes. Yeah, it's kind of he dwells a lot on it. Yeah, i I'm going to take these because I have three of my four grandparents were part of the Royal Canadian Air Force in World War Two.

Speaker: ah so Letter 92 in 1944, Tolkien writes, quote, But I fear an air force is a fundamentally irrational thing, per se. I could wish dearly that you had nothing to do with anything so monstrous. This is him writing to Christopher.

Speaker: It is, in fact, a sore trial to me that any son of mine should serve this modern Moloch. But such wishes are vain, as and it is, i clearly understand, your duty to do as well in such service as you have the strength and aptitude to do.

Speaker: In any case, it is only a kind of squeamishness, perhaps like a man who enjoys steak and kidney, or did, but would not be connected with the butchery business.

Speaker: It's quite an analogy. As long as war is fought with such weapons and one accepts any profits that may accrue, with then parentheses such as preservation of one's skin and even quote-unquote victory, and parentheses it is merely shirking the issue to hold war aircraft in special horror.

Speaker: End quote. Yeah, clearly not a big fan of these flying machines being used to kill. Letter 100, also written 1944. quote it would be at least some comfort to me if you escape from the RAF. Again, this is written to christ Christopher.

Speaker: And I hope if the transfer goes through, it will mean a real transfer and a recommission. It would not be easy for me to express to you the measure of my loathing. or the third service, which can be nonetheless, and is for me, combined with admiration, gratitude, and above all pity for the young men caught in it.

Speaker: But it is the aeroplane of war that is the real villain, and nothing can really amend my grief that you, my best beloved, have any connection with it. My sentiments are more or less those that Frodo would have had if he discovered some hobbits luring to ride Nazgul birds.

Speaker: quote unquote, for the liberation of the Shire. Side note, that would have been an interesting scouring of the Shire. ah Though in this case, as I know, nothing about British or American imperialism in the Far East that does not fill me with regret and disgust. Side note, Tolkien against colonialism.

Speaker: I am afraid i am not even supported by a glimmer of patriotism in this remaining war. I would not subscribe a penny to it, let alone a son, were I a free man. Yeah.

Speaker: He, again, likening airplanes to... Nazgul. Yeah, to the Nazgul. And he's kind of that quote about Frodo, you know, sort of if he had discovered hobbits learning to ride Nazgul birds, you know, quote, for the liberation of the Shire. Like, that's the the horrifying thing to him is that that compromise of morality. Yeah.

Speaker: Going on to 1945, letter 102, which was written on the day that the atomic bombs were dropped on and Quote, the news today about atomic bombs is so horrifying one is stunned. The utter folly of these lunatic physicists to consent to do such work for war purposes, calmly plotting the destruction of the world.

Speaker: Such explosives in men's hands while their moral and intellectual status is declining is about as useful as giving out firearms to all inmates of a jail and then saying that you hope, quote unquote, this will ensure peace.

Speaker: But one good thing may arise out of it, I suppose, if the write-ups are not overheated. Japan ought to cave in. well, we're in God's hands, but he does not look kindly on Babel builders.

Speaker: So, unquote. In that case, specifically liking you know the Manhattan Project to Tower Babel and getting too close to God. Again, so yeah, technology should not try and emulate God's, I guess, we can as we'll probably talk about later both we will talk about later, both God's ability to create and destroy. That should be divine domain, not the domain of humans, unless it is divinely inspired.

Speaker: Yeah. And he doesn't pull verbal punches about this. yeah Yeah. It goes on in letters 135 in 1952. Quote, such as modern life, Mordor in our midst, and I regret to note that the billowing cloud recently pictured did not mark the fall of Barad-Dur, but was produced by its allies, or at least by persons who have decided to use the ring for their own, of course, most excellent,

Speaker: in parentheses and said very sarcastically, purposes. So that's Tolkien specifically referencing the ring as the atomic bomb. Yeah, and I think this is part of where some people kind of get that notion, though, in another letter, Tolkien specifically says the ring's not the atomic bomb. Yeah, he dissuades them. Yeah. He says that in the foreword to Lord the Rings.

Speaker: Right. Yeah. and see Not that the a ring and the bomb are the same, but the motivation to use each is the same horror. Mm-hmm. Yeah, I really like this quote because, again, he sort of likens the technology of the bomb itself to Baradur, to Mordor, and to the allies of Baradur and Mordor, not the not the enemies.

Speaker: I think that makes it, that kind of situates it in a really particular position for him in moral terms. And then one last one about sort of war machines going back to 1945 and letter 96. Quote,

Speaker: quote Well, the first war of the machines, capital W, capital M, seems to be drawing to its final inconclusive chapter leaving. Alas, everyone, the poor, many bereaved or maimed and millions dead and only one thing triumphant, the machines.

Speaker: As the servants of the machines are becoming a privileged class, the machines are going to be enormously more powerful. What's their next move? Jesus, Tolkien, could you have been any more precious?

Speaker: Yeah. This is such a great quote, isn't it? Like, reading it, you're just like, Jesus Christ, man. He knew. He knew. Nothing about this seems unclear.

Speaker: Yeah. Yeah. There's not a lot of fucking interpretations to be drawn from here. Yeah. Well, speaking of machines, let's actually talk about that capital M machine that Tolkien references quite quite a bit in his letters. What is the machine, Grace?

Speaker: The machine, capital T, capital M, is something that Tolkien expressly said many times was one of the underlying themes in Lord of the Rings, that he used the machine to mean something antithetical to the development of the innate and inherent powers and talents of human beings.

Speaker: And moreover, that it was the wrong approach, coercion, domination, coercion of other kinds and other wills, tyranny, and the tyrannous reformation of the earth itself, which is our place.

Speaker: Quote, that's really why he hated machines. That's not our claim. That's direct from the mouth of his son, Christopher Tolkien, in an interview given in 1996.

Speaker: Christopher also asserted that this was one of Tolkien's greatest fears, coercion for good ends and the machineries of things like telecommunication that he saw developing even within his lifetime, though he eventually owned a telephone and a tape recorder, were not what he wanted in the world.

Speaker: What he did love intensely, again, according to Christopher, was the natural world and the materials of the natural world, craftsmanship and tools rather than the machine.

Speaker: In the article, Tolkien, AI, and the Temptation of the Machine, Tom Emanuel gives us a really helpful summary of how the machine plays an an important role on how Tolkien views art and technology, especially his views on subcreation as described in On Fairy Stories, and which infuses all of his work.

Speaker: Quote, in his essay on fairy stories, Tolkien asserts that humans are subcreators, unlike God, as understood according to the Orthodox Western Christianity. We do not create ex nihilo or out of nothing. Rather, human creativity takes the given elements of creation as it exists, the primary world, and rearranges them to create new things. That might sound a little bit like how LLMs respond to prompts, but it is not. The difference for Tolkien is precisely what LLMs lack, which is intentions.

Speaker: Tom also notes that Tolkien identifies the subcreative spark with the image of day, the image and likeness of God reference in Genesis 1, 26 and 27 that subsists in every human being. That is to say, we're created in the image of a creator to his thinking.

Speaker: Thus, for Tolkien, humanity's subcreative power, while derivative and subordinate to gods, is ultimately of the same stuff, he says in non-fairy stories. Far from the probabilistic recombination of symbols, human creativity is a kind of participation in divine life, a co-creative improvisation upon the music of creation. Quote, we make still by the law in which we are made on fairy stories. It's page 56.

Speaker: There's an incredible power in that. Our creativity reaches into the depths of our beings and touches the secret fire at the heart of all that is. But it calls forth a tremendous responsibility not to use our creative powers for evil, domination, coercion, bulldozing the world.

Speaker: Tolkien believed that we are constantly tempted to usurp the role of God and impose our will upon the world, whether the world likes it or not. And that temptation... quote, will lead to the desire for power, for making the will more quickly effective, and so to the machine or magic.

Speaker: Yeah. So this is really all to say that for Tolkien, our creativity is literally divine. Our imaginations and the work of our human hands are a gift from God to be used with that awareness that these gifts are divine.

Speaker: I want to take that a step further. Since Tolkien believes that subcreation is divinely inspired by God working through human hands and minds, i am convinced Tolkien would actually find the use of machines to create works of quote unquote art.

Speaker: full cloth, like not assistive, such as Gen AI to be well and truly blasphemous, like against the intentions and actions of his God. I also want to call Tom out for writing this article in like 2023, like really when like je AI was you know still sort of nascent.

Speaker: Those around the time we were seeing a lot of those like Wes Anderson inspired trailers, Gen.ai trailers of movies and specifically one that was like, what if Wes Anderson did Lord of the Rings? A lot of people were sharing around and that was, I think, when a lot of people sort of drew their lines as like, I'm okay with this or I'm not okay with this. you know Gen.ai being used to reinterpret or reimagine Tolkien's works.

Speaker: Good on him for getting this out very early. Definitely. i like the use of the word blasphemous because I think that that's 1000% it. it It's a blasphemy against God in Tolk's eyes.

Speaker: Cosigned. And I like using that on like right-winger Christian Tolkien creators that are clearly using like AI, like slop images or generating like AI slop of like Tolkien's characters or settings or objects, that sort of thing. and be like, I realized Tolkien would absolutely fucking despise this and probably consider it blasphemous considering his feelings around creation of artistic works.

Speaker: They don't like that. Yeah, like Tolkien's idea about creation is that like creation is it's perilous and fair. What we're talking about here, it's just perilous. There is no fair. There there is nothing that is.

Speaker: Yeah, it's pulling you farther from God because like not only are you not creating, you're stealing from people who have created. And you are hurting the world to do so.

Speaker: Mm hmm. Yeah. Listen, you don't have to take our word for it, though. You can take Tolkien's. Getting a little bit more into some of this idea about subcreation in the infamous letter 131, Tolkien writes, quote, the subcreator wishes to be the Lord and God of his private creation.

Speaker: He will rebel against the laws of the creator, especially against mortality. Both of these, alone or together, will lead to the desire for power, for making the will more quickly effective, and so lead to the machine or magic.

Speaker: By the last, by which he means magic and or the machine, I intend all use of external plans or devices, apparatus, instead of the development of the inherent inner powers or talents, or even the use of these talents with the corruptive motive of dominating, bulldozing the real world, or coercing other wills.

Speaker: the machine is our more obvious modern form, more closely related to magic than is usually recognized. And I feel like that's sort of like that connection of the machine with magic, which he kind of relates to in world as more the devices and the operations of the enemy and not our heroes in his legendarium.

Speaker: He's not very consistent on the use of magic, but you can kind of see in his letters that that's kind of what he's talking about when he refers to like the devices of the enemy. It's more consistently in his thinking, more consistently something that he would probably call magic or the machine. And to continue from that quote from letter 131, he The enemy in successive forms is always naturally concerned with sheer domination, and so he is the lord of magic and machines.

Speaker: The root of his evil is that this, he says, this frightful evil can and does arise from an apparently good root, the desire to benefit the world and others, speedily and according to the benefactor's own plans.

Speaker: And if i if I don't hear the words of Dario Amade kind of echoing in my brain as I read that quote, to benefit the world and others, i hear Sam Altman and i hear I hear a lot of these guys figuring that they are the best people to figure out what is going to benefit the world and others.

Speaker: And i see them very much as, you know, the lords of magic and machines in Tolkien's own words. I think part of it for me also is the speed. Like speed is such a theme in his concerns and the speed in the approach of move quick and break things.

Speaker: Just I don't know how you could get a more apt connection of the harms that that does and how Tolkien was able to envision those harms.

Speaker: Yeah, 100 percent. Tolkien's a man who understands that not everything that can be broken can be fixed and these men are not men who think that because they all have more money than god and think because of that they can fix anything throwing more money thinking about fixing it at all yep fair that's a great point So just to summarize that, you know, magic, capital M magic technology and the capital M machine are for Tolkien explicitly about either not using our divine gifts or using those gifts to dominate others in the natural world.

Speaker: Refusing to use our gifts and imaginations, letting some external device, Gen AI, take over that divine work is literally to do the work of the capital E enemies.

Speaker: And to use our gifts to gain power and control others, even if it is born from a desire to do good and benefit the world, is also the work of the capital E-N. stamped.

Speaker: Yes. One thing that this makes me think of is how Tolkien wrote in his letters that Gandalf would not have been a good bearer or steward of the ring.

Speaker: And I think that especially as we start to see more assertions that we need to use AI cautiously or or intelligently and be a Gandalf in how we approach it.

Speaker: That is something that we need to take with a considerable grain of salt, given Tolkien's writings and Tolkien's viewpoints that are already infused into what we're drawing upon in these stories.

Speaker: Yeah. Or to be an Aragorn. Moving on to another quote that builds on those ideas, letter 155 from 1954. Quote, the supremely bad motive is domination of other free wills. The enemy enemy's operations are by no means all goetic deceits, but quote unquote magic, what produces real effects in the physical world.

Speaker: but his magic he uses to bulldoze both people and things, and his goatea to so terrify and subjugate. So Tolkien uses the word goatea here to distinguish the difference between capital M magic and what he called capital E enchantment or capital A art or magia. So those are just more natural in harmony with the world rather than, end it and will, rather than trying to subjugate will.

Speaker: to jump in real briefly here. and We have a lot more to talk and think about with Tolkien's concept of sub-creation, art, enchantment, magic, and the machine.

Speaker: but that is much like good old Pete, a subject that will make this episode 4,000 years long. So just put a pin in that and know that we and I are working on it and we will come at you with a lengthy episode about subcreation soon.

Speaker: Yep. Tolkien and art and all sorts of goodness, but just put that in your back pocket. So now we're going to switch from looking at the letters specifically to how Tolkien uses the legendarium to ah impact some of his feelings around technology and the machine.

Speaker: From Tom Emanuel again, quote, time and again, this temptation of the machine leads to downfall in Middle Earth. Melkor and his solipsistic music, the elven smiths of Eregion and their rings of power, Feanor and his Silmarils, Numenor and its imperial arrogance, Saruman and his mind of metal and wheels, Sauron and his one ring, creativity, something which was and remains in its origins good, is twisted and wrought into the power by which we subjugate others and wreck our common home.

Speaker: I just love that kind of great summary from Tom because it kind of hits home that this is something that Tolkien thinks about a lot and is using specifically his fiction to kind of unpack and sort of offer up to us to think about, I think. And i just kind of like that sort of like broad summary from literally the beginning of creation to The Lord of the Rings. This is something that he thought about his entire life.

Speaker: It's thematic through the entire legendarium, for sure. And outside the legendarium. Yes. And then we can see where some of this is drawn from, right? So letter 153 about the Noldor, written in 1954, Tolkien says... The particular breach of the High Elves concerned the Noldor or Loremasters were always on the side of science and technology, as we should call it.

Speaker: They wanted to have the knowledge that Sauron genuinely had, and those of Eregion refused the warnings of Gil-galad and Elrond. The particular desire of the Eregion elves, an allegory, if you'd like, of a love of machinery and technical devices, is also symbolized by their special friendship with the dwarves of Moria.

Speaker: I should regard them as no more wicked or foolish, but in much the same peril, as Catholics engaged in certain kinds of physical research, e.g. those producing, if only as byproducts, poisonous gases and explosives.

Speaker: things not necessarily evil, but which things being as they are, and the nature and motives of the economic masters who provide all the means for their work being as they are, are pretty certain to serve evil ends, for which they will not necessarily be to blame, even if aware of them.

Speaker: that bit about things that are not necessarily evil but which things being as they are and because capitalism are pretty certain to serve evil ends i'm just kind of like yep target point yep nailed it that fits on a level where gives chills nailed it nailed it then let's actually take a glimpse into something in the hobbit from chapter four where he's talking about goblins Tolkien says, it is not unlikely that they invented some of the machines that have since troubled the world, especially the ingenious devices for killing large numbers of people at once, for wheels and engines and explosions always delighted them, and also not working with their own hands more than they could help.

Speaker: But in those days and those wild parts, they had not advanced as it is called so far. Yeah. Seems pretty apparent where Tolkien is placing the love of machines that that kill lots of people.

Speaker: Not working with their own hands. Shifting everything off to AI. An autonomous drone? na Or drone, yes.

Speaker: And then therefore shifting the accountability and blame. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah, these next couple quotes are are probably one of the like most apparent examples people would immediately think of when thinking of like Tolkien's feelings on an industry and technology. They're from like around like Isengard and the corruption of the landscape and the technology involved and everything there. So this is from Book 3, Chapter 8.

Speaker: Quote, thousands could dwell there, workers, servants, slaves, and warriors with great store of arms. Wolves were fed and stabled in deep dens beneath. The plain, too, was bored and delved.

Speaker: Shafts were driven deep into the ground. Their upper ends were covered by low mounds and domes of stone, so that in the moonlight the ring of Isengard looked like a graveyard of unquiet dead.

Speaker: or the ground trembled. The shafts ran down by many slopes and spiral stairs to caverns far under. There Saruman had treasuries, storehouses, armories, smithies, and great furnaces.

Speaker: Iron wheels revolved there endlessly, and hammers thudded. At night, plumes of vapor steamed from the vents, lit from beneath with red light or blue or venomous green.

Speaker: that not paint a picture of paint so sea special industrial era england as you say i can hear tolkien complaining about the noise right now yeah exactly and then also from book three uh earlier on uh tree beard talking about Saruman, quote, I think that I now understand what he is up to. He is plotting to become capital P power.

Speaker: He has a mind of metal and wheels, and he does not care for growing things except as far as they serve him for the moment. Again, just ai you know, exploitation of environmental resources. Yeah.

Speaker: And I think that link again to the capital P power Yeah, these guys are not altruistic. Yeah. even Even though they might claim to be. They're using these devices. They're using these things to explicitly amass power.

Speaker: We're not going to get into it too much. AI is a tool of fascism because I'm still working on that, you guys. I'm sorry. i mean, just look at all of the government contracts and ICE and DOD contracts and all of that. Like that's all right there Look at Palantir's explicit manifesto, which is can be very safely categorized as a fascist manifesto.

Speaker: i think also, as far as they serve him for the moment, the short-sightedness of the people driving this technology and encouraging people to use the technology also short-sightedly.

Speaker: Just 100%. 100%. hundred percent hundred percent I'm not sure how much, i mean, it's partially short sightedness, but I think it's also just like collective delusion, right? Because they do have these like long term visions.

Speaker: They're just absolutely fucking delusional visions that like we can, you know, upload our brains to the cloud and surpass the need for like having human bodies and shit like that. Yeah, if we don't kill the Earth now, how are all these digital people going to exist? Yeah.

Speaker: That's another episode, guys. That's another episode. We'll be here forever. I'll start talking and we'll never stop. I'm sorry. Indeed. Okay, so now we have to look at the scouring of the Shire.

Speaker: Ah, yes. Unironically, one of my favorite chapters in this book. It was one of the saddest hours in their lives. The great chimney rose up before them, and as they drew near the old village across the water through rows of new mean houses along each side of the road, they saw the new mill in all its frowning and dirty ugliness, a great brick building egg straddling the stream, which it fouled with a steaming and stinking outflow. All along the bywater road, every tree had been felled.

Speaker: As they crossed the bridge and looked up at the hill, they gasped. Even Sam's vision in the mirror had not prepared him for what they saw. The old grange on the west side had been knocked down and is placed taken by rows of tarred sheds.

Speaker: All the chestnuts were gone. The banks and the hedgerows were broken. Great wagons were standing in disorder and a field beaten bear of grass. Bagshot Row was a yawning sand and gravel quarry.

Speaker: Bag End up beyond could not be seen for a clutter of large huts. They've cut it down, cried Sam. They've cut down the party tree. He pointed to where the tree had stood under which Bilbo had made his farewell speech.

Speaker: It was lying lopped and dead in the field, as if this were the last straw. Sam burst into tears. This is worse than Mordor, said Sam. Much worse in a way. It comes home to you, as they say, because it is home, and you remember it before it was all ruined.

Speaker: Yes, this is Mordor, said Frodo. Just one of its works. Saruman was doing its work all the time, even when he thought he was working for himself. oh Yeah, that picture again of the Shire just looking like an absolute shithole. This is going off script a little bit, but like I'm getting a feeling here of like Saruman, he is described as an agent of Mordor, of Sauron, right?

Speaker: So we could think of him here as one of these agentic AIs that's going off and doing Sauron's bidding and using whatever means he deems necessary to achieve those goals. Yeah.

Speaker: Indeed. ah oh Okay. And then the complicity element of this, that Saruman is the agent directing this work, thinking he's working for himself, is serving Mordor.

Speaker: That's totally 100%. hundred percent And just to interrupt really quickly, Tolkien and his love of non-human nature is obviously a critical component of Tolkien's attitude about technology and industry. i feel like that above quote really highlights just the devastation of the natural landscape is what makes everybody burst into tears and makes everybody just like devastated. There's too many quotes and so much evidence about Tolkien's concerns about the non-human world and the impact of machine industry on it for us to really mention here. There are literal shelves of books centered on this, and so we'll just kind of point you to some of those in, again, the show notes, because i feel like I'm a broken record here, but I'm studying a lot about this as well, and it's kind of beyond the scope of this episode, but

Speaker: This is also just to say, please look at the show notes for this episode. I wrote really, really, really hard on them. so Truly, they are an excellent resource.

Speaker: But yeah, I didn't want to just kind of like gloss over the very, very critical component of Tolkien's love of the non-human world, because that is part of the foundation of his attitudes toward technology and industry. But just wanted to say that there's a lot more on that than could really be included here.

Speaker: So I just had a couple of like concluding thoughts that aren't necessarily Tolkien quotes, but just other ways in which I think very much illustrate Tolkien would fucking hate AI.

Speaker: So to start a out in On Fairy Stories, Tolkien builds on an idea from George Webby Bessent, who was a translator of Folk Tales in the 19th century, about focusing on the soup, the story that's set in front of us, rather than like the bones of what made it, the ingredients of the soup.

Speaker: Tolkien expands this in On Fairy Stories into his analogy of the cauldron of story. Basically a big pot of soup that has been boiling for a very long time with various story ingredients simmering in it They would be like things like mythology and folklore, historical personages and events, nursery rhymes, bits of oral tradition.

Speaker: You get the general idea. And when someone takes a ladle out of that cauldron, one or more ladles to make a new story, it inevitably is going to have some of those flavors and those ingredients incorporated.

Speaker: though some may have been simmering for so long that they're fairly recognizable, mostly sort of dissolved into the stock. So the modern artist might not even recognize that they're drawing those particular ingredients at the cauldron, nor may their audience.

Speaker: But with Tolkien's cauldron of story, all of those bits that are simmering in that pot are from real human people. They're coming from their traditions and their cultures, their stories, and their art.

Speaker: Another major reason why I feel Tolkien would absolutely abhor regenerative AI is because the cauldron of story that these AI companies have created is poisoned and corrupted and artificial.

Speaker: It's strained through this filter of soulless machines, processors, and algorithms until it's just tasteless, meaningless pablum. There's no influence of human experience left in it.

Speaker: essentially, you know, capital T, capital M, the machine, chewing up old stories and other artistic expressions and spitting them out in algorithmically predicted sequences.

Speaker: Not to mention, as we've talked about, that basically everything that got dumped into the Gen. AI cauldron was stolen from writers and artists across all of human history. So that, again, feels like it would go against Tolkien's like fundamental philosophy of subcreation as being a uniquely human, divinely inspired, capable Which ah yeah leads me to this idea that I sort of alluded to earlier of like Tolkien is a Luddite, which probably will end up becoming like its own episode. But just introduce it here.

Speaker: Not Luddite in a common usage of the term as someone who's just like globally against all technology. Or bad at it. yeah Yeah, that too. The Luddites were specifically against exploitative technologies and automation that harmed people. In the case of Luddites, it was automation that was going to cause like a lot of workers to lose their livelihoods. Automated farming equipment, weaving looms, etc.,

Speaker: Tolkien feels more to me like a handcrafted goods kind of dude, right? The guy that really would appreciate something that's handmade, you know, not with a bunch of like automated technologies, especially when it comes to art.

Speaker: and that That's in addition to like industrial technologies that would have interfered with, you know, his pen his love of nature and serenity and everything. So I'm going friend this piece here. I have like, I wonder what Tolkien would have thought about you know Andy Warhol and like that mass produced like pop art movement, but they didn't really overlap that much. so I don't know that we ever got that.

Speaker: Perhaps another another speculative speculative time that we can take. Tolkien would hate this guy, the Andy Warhol. Tolkien would hate Andy Warhol.

Speaker: Yeah. I really like you bringing up the cauldron of story because I think that that's really but such a potent image. And I also really like the way that you put it of like poisoned cauldron. I just think that that's like such a powerful image. and When it comes to like the cauldron of story is like, you know, when you think of a cauldron, you think of like nourishment and being fed and being like sustained and, you know, enjoyed. And I feel like generative AI in particular, it's full of something that if you eat it, what it keeps adding to the cauldron of story is just more and more poison and more and more unrecognizable and,

Speaker: And that's model collapse, right? That's that's what some of the models are starting to see right now, where they're feeding on AI generated content and just becoming just outputting more and more fucking like garbage that is just completely has no basis in reality, but it'll still fucking happily report it as factual.

Speaker: It's this recursive nightmare of Gen. AI just feeding back into itself. And just, again, just ripping apart reality itself, basically. So it's been a long one, listeners. We're coming in for a landing.

Speaker: What kind of conclusions do y'all think that we can come to? I mean, I think first off, yes, we can conclude Tolkien would hate this podcast, but in this case, because we took too long and haven't been nearly as loud and annoying in telling the world about how much he would have hated and AI, we we couldn't have done this.

Speaker: could have done it earlier and and but so we we apologize profusely professor mea culpa professor church please forgive us please please don't hate us anymore we're going to preach the word of of the gospel of of anti-ai far and wide ah Yes, yes.

Speaker: Yeah, so I do think we have to keep in mind that often there's no way that we could know what Tolkien would think about a technology that was developed after he had died. But um I don't really feel like this is one of them.

Speaker: there's There's so much evidence of how much he hated mechanization and how important the act of sub-creation was to him. I think that this is pretty fucking cut and dry.

Speaker: Was Tolkien Catholic? Yes. Would he hate may i Abso-fucking-lutely. Also, yes. yeah Yeah. This whole podcast series is like kind of us trying to be careful about what Tolkien's opinions might be about our present moment in particular, but... Like, I personally will never, ever, ever get tired of deliberately speaking for Tolkien and invoking him and channeling him through my body and confidently saying how much he would hate ai He would think that it is a literal abomination against God and he would be doing everything that he can to try to stop it.

Speaker: Hey, fucking man. I say that with my entire chest and this is what, again, there is no clearer set of evidence, I think, or more definitive answer than this. Hallelujah. Praise Jesus.

Speaker: I have extreme confidence that when Tolkien notes the role of other minds and hands, he expressly did not mean artificial, quote-unquote, intelligence that is fueled by the destruction of the environment, guzzling power and water, and creating a level of noise that is impossible to endure. Far beyond the noise of even combustion engines, and he sure as hell didn't mean warped seven fingers, hands slapped together, by prediction models that gorged on the works of actual humans and artists that were scraped from archives and repositories of human knowledge through methods of coercion or a lack of consent. And a man who thought that bomber airplanes were bad would sure as fuck think that these AI systems, with all of their flaws and move fast and break things ethos to bomb school buildings as a whoopsie doodle, is abhorrent and immoral.

Speaker: Amen. Amen, sister. Yeah. There's also this. For all the money poured into this technology... It's not very good at what it's supposed to do. It's mediocre. It might indeed kill us all but because of how mediocre it is. For all that we've laid out here, one of the best arguments I've seen in convincing everyday people that we shouldn't embrace a i is essentially...

Speaker: that it's mediocre at what it does, but a lot of really bad dudes are into it in a weird and concerning way. Recent polling is also showing that people broadly aren't very aware of the harms of AI yet, but they are starting now to connect these types of AI with fears around the world that we're handing to the children.

Speaker: And I think that those are pretty good paths into conversations that have to be had. So... Fans, what can we do with this information?

Speaker: How are you encountering AI personally in your workspaces? your creative outlets, and your community. If you consider yourself a Tolkien fan, what do you think is your position here? Does Tolkien's opinion matter to you? It doesn't have to What kind of boundaries and practices are important to you in Tolkien fan spaces?

Speaker: If you're involved in maintaining and creating a Tolkien fan space, and if you consider yourself a protector of his legacy or, God forbid, his heritage, what does that mean for you personally and for that community?

Speaker: And hint some people are starting to use like religious exemptions to get out of having to fucking use AI in their workplace if being forced on you. So, you know, just say your religion is Tolkien and you would have said As a note, Tolkien was Catholic and the Pope's encyclical is foundational to be able to say that this is a moral and religious exemption for me.

Speaker: Mm hmm. Mm hmm. So if it is not absolutely crystal clear by now, this podcast and all of its team are extremely anti-AI. And that is the specifically the generative and agentic AI currently being offered by these four truly fucking evil companies that exploits and extracts from humans and non-humans alike.

Speaker: And we will always avoid it in any way that we reasonably can, despite these extractive and exploitative technologies being shoved down our throats and incorporated and into apps program systems that we all utilize regularly. There is no ethical consumption under capitalism, folks, but you can make choices. And where you do have the ability to make choices, we encourage you to try and avoid anything that involves generative AI.

Speaker: And we encourage you that if somehow we screw up, if we make a mistake, please tell us. Absolutely. for me personally, i think if it isn't super evident throughou the throughout this episode, this is something that I care very, very passionately about. Really? I want to know if something that we're sharing or promoting is involved in these systems. Yeah. To the point where there are like...

Speaker: groups that we've been asked to collaborate with or stuff like that, or entities we've been asked to collaborate with that we have turned down or refused to share their content specifically because it was either Gen AI or we knew that they utilized Gen AI.

Speaker: Yep. It's a line in the sand. Don't let theres that there's no ethical consumption under capitalism be like a conversation ending thought. Because it's it's not. It's not an excuse.

Speaker: It's a fact of life, but that it's not a reason to just be like, cool well I'm going to do it anyway because there's no ethical way to live my life. Like, fuck that. Try. And like, AI is not going to go away. There's a lot of fucking money tied up in it.

Speaker: for whatever fucking reason, people have decided to tie up billions of dollars in this and they're going to try to force it down our throats. Reject it. Like, do everything you can to reject it. Like, vocally reject it. Don't give money to places that use it if you can...

Speaker: avoid doing it organized, like get out there in the streets, steal some copper from a flat camera. Leech it. We're going to get, which we do not actually recommend. I don't actually recommend. For legal reasons. That is Minecraft. You guys. e blocks and ah yeah And turn in the the copper for Robux. Right.

Speaker: ah I legally can't say to go out and steal copper from the plot camera, but you know, what you feel like you need to do. Human creativity is important. but Do what your God-given heart tells you. Inspired. Because like, Tolkien wouldn't have been about this life. I'm not about this life. You don't have to be about this life if you don't want to be either.

Speaker: Yeah, basically this whole two hour so far long episode is we must fight for ourselves and our souls and our planet. Tolkien absolutely would.

Speaker: and Truly, we don't need to take our ethical stances on AI from the words of Tolkien. Mm-hmm. But when we're talking about the use of these things in spaces devoted to fan-ish or academic pursuits of understanding Tolkien's works, I think that this is one of the few occasions where the things that Tolkien said are so strong, so clear, and still matter.

Speaker: Amen. Hey, fucking men! yep Thank you guys so much for listening. Again, we hope that this episode can serve as a a resource and as something that you share among folks who might not have a good idea of what these four companies are up to and what Tolkien kind of said about technology. So again, thank you so much for listening and please go look at the show notes. I worked really, really hard on this episode.

Speaker: ah feel like you probably already know this because you're listening to us but you can find us anywhere that you find other podcasts please leave us a rating and or a review on apple podcast spotify wherever you listen to us honestly like share and subscribe If that is an option on the platform you're listening to us on, you can also stream us directly on Zencaster. That's Zencaster.com slash Queer Lodgings, the Tolkien podcast with hyphens in between all those words.

Speaker: You can also find us on our website, which is QueerLodgings.com, where we have show notes, as Leah has been referencing constantly throughout this episode. Really? There's going to be show notes for this episode? Please look at them.

Speaker: Other resources, transcripts where we got them. We have merch. You can find all of our social medias and a Discord link on there. Speaking of social media, you can find us on ah Facebook, Twitter, the only thing that it's okay to deadname, where we only post episode updates because fuck Elon Musk. you know, going along with the whole anti-AI thing. Right, he's also one of the... He is, yeah.

Speaker: Nope, we can't talk about them. Keep going. It's just not important enough for us to actually talk about them. For us on Blue Sky, the much better alternative to Twitter and on YouTube podcasts, if you have any thoughts, ideas for episodes, whatever, you can reach out to us on any of our socials, Discord, or send us an email at queerlogingspodcasts at gmail.com. Thank you.

Speaker: Quick little plug for our merch. If you, like us, are spiteful about generative ai ah it is a great time to treat yourself to one of our hashtag fueled by spite stickers.

Speaker: This entire episode was fueled by spite. so rent So many of them are. We live our values, you guys. AI! Fuck Fuck AI!

Speaker: I feel like it's fascinating because you are not Mountain Dew's target demographic. Oh, no I hate Mountain Dew. I just really like Baja Blast. Me too. So like somehow Baja Blast is the queer one? It's transcendent. Maybe. Taco Bell is the home of the gay Mountain Dew. Yeah. It's teal. It's aqua. Like they did the thing. It's got the shark. It's got the Ikea. it What's his name? Baha or whatever? Yeah. bla Yeah.

Speaker: Yes, yeah. Blige, trans shark, there you go. Works for me. works for me The trans shark is blige.

Speaker: I don't think they know.

Speaker: But I hope they do. Somebody there knows. I'm sure somebody does. It's not the person that designed it.

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Recommended