Today's clip is from episode 160 [https://learnbayesstats.com/episode/bayesian-statistics-vs-epistemology-critical-rationalism-popper-vaden-masrani], featuring Vaden Masrani. In this conversation, Vaden lays out a sharp critique of Bayesian epistemology - the roughly hundred-year-old philosophical tradition, popular in some Oxford-adjacent circles, that treats subjective probability estimates as legitimate even when there's no data behind them.

Vaden's core objection: doing Bayes' theorem on numbers you made up in your head is like fitting a regression line to an empty scatter plot - the math looks rigorous, but there's nothing underneath it. He argues this "math-washing" can trick people into thinking a decision is well-informed simply because it's dressed up in probability language, when frequentists and data-driven Bayesians alike would say the same thing: no data, no model.

Get the full discussion here [https://learnbayesstats.com/episode/bayesian-statistics-vs-epistemology-critical-rationalism-popper-vaden-masrani]

Support & Resources
→ Support the show on Patreon [https://www.patreon.com/c/learnbayesstats]
→ Bayesian Modeling Course [https://topmate.io/alex_andorra/1011122] (first 2 lessons free):
Our theme music is « Good Bayesian », by Baba Brinkman (feat MC Lars and Mega Ran). Check out his awesome work! [https://bababrinkman.com/]

Bayesian Epistemology Is "Bayes' Theorem Without the Data"

Today's clip is from episode 160 [https://learnbayesstats.com/episode/bayesian-statistics-vs-epistemology-critical-rationalism-popper-vaden-masrani], featuring Vaden Masrani. In this conversation, Vad

Are you a researcher or data scientist / analyst / ninja? Do you want to learn
Bayesian inference, stay up to date or simply want to understand what Bayesian
inference is? Then this podcast is for you! You'll hear from researchers and
practitioners of all fields about how they use Bayesian statistics, and how in
turn YOU can apply these methods in your modeling workflow. When I started
learning Bayesian methods, I really wished there were a podcast out there that
could introduce me to the methods, the projects and the people who make all that
possible. So I created "Learning Bayesian Statistics", where you'll get to hear
how Bayesian statistics are used to detect black matter in outer space, forecast
elections or understand how diseases spread and can ultimately be stopped. But
this show is not only about successes -- it's also about failures, because
that's how we learn best. So you'll often hear the guests talking about what
*didn't* work in their projects, why, and how they overcame these challenges.
Because, in the end, we're all lifelong learners! My name is Alex Andorra by the
way, and I live in Paris. By day, I'm a data scientist and modeler at the
https://www.pymc-labs.io/ (PyMC Labs) consultancy. By night, I don't (yet) fight
crime, but I'm an open-source enthusiast and core contributor to the python
packages https://docs.pymc.io/ (PyMC) and https://arviz-devs.github.io/arviz/
(ArviZ). I also love https://www.pollsposition.com/ (election forecasting) and,
most importantly, Nutella. But I don't like talking about it – I prefer eating
it. So, whether you want to learn Bayesian statistics or hear about the latest
libraries, books and applications, this podcast is for you -- just subscribe!
You can also support the show and https://www.patreon.com/learnbayesstats
(unlock exclusive Bayesian swag on Patreon)! This podcast uses the following
third-party services for analysis: Podcorn - https://podcorn.com/privacy

Bayesian Epistemology Is "Bayes' Theorem Without the Data"

Recommended