Become a Creator today!Start creating today - Share your story with the world!
Start for free
00:00:00
00:00:01
What does Proposition 12 mean for the pork industry?
11 Plays2 years ago
Amaru Sanchez, an associate at law firm Wiley Rein LLP, discusses California's Proposition 12, which went into full effect in January.
Recommended
Transcript
Introduction to Prop 12 and FDA Regulations
00:00:06
Speaker
Hello and welcome to the Feed Strategy podcast.
00:00:08
Speaker
I'm your host, Feed Strategy senior reporter, Ann Roos.
00:00:11
Speaker
Amaro Sanchez is an associate at law firm Wiley Ryan LLP, where he counsels domestic and global companies in matters involving products regulated by the US Food and Drug Administration, the US Department of Agriculture, and relevant state agencies.
00:00:24
Speaker
I recently spoke to Sanchez about California's Proposition 12, which went into full effect in January.
Prop 12: Space Requirements and Sales Ban
00:00:30
Speaker
Prop 12 establishes minimum space requirements based on square feet for breeding pigs, field calves, and egg-laying hens, and bans the sale of meat and eggs from those animals when they are raised in a way that does not comply with the minimum requirements.
00:00:42
Speaker
Prop 12 withstood legal challenges when the Supreme Court ruled in May 2023 to uphold the law.
00:00:47
Speaker
Sanchez and I talked about how Prop 12 affects the US pork industry and how producers can deal with changes brought about by the law.
00:00:54
Speaker
Here's our conversation.
00:00:56
Speaker
Hi, Amaru.
00:00:57
Speaker
Thanks for joining me.
00:00:59
Speaker
Thanks for having me on your podcast.
00:01:02
Speaker
Can you explain how Proposition 12 affects regulations within the pork industry?
00:01:07
Speaker
Sure.
00:01:08
Speaker
Well, Proposition 12, also known as Prop 12, which was endorsed back in 2018 in California, really reshapes the landscape for animal housing standards, especially for breeding pigs.
00:01:21
Speaker
You know, what it does is introduces this mandate that each breeding pig must be allotted a minimum of 24 square feet of usable floor space.
00:01:31
Speaker
I mean, this is quite a leap from the usual 16 to 18 square feet that's been the norm.
00:01:38
Speaker
Now, the interesting part is that this regulation extends to all uncooked pork sold within California.
00:01:44
Speaker
So it's not just impacting producers within the state, but also those outside the state who want to enter the California market.
00:01:52
Speaker
It really is a significant shift that's influencing both local and national pork producers that sell pork in California.
Economic Impact on Pork Producers
00:02:00
Speaker
What are the specific challenges or concerns pork producers may face as a result of Prop 12 and how can they address them?
00:02:07
Speaker
Great question.
00:02:08
Speaker
The biggest hurdle that we've heard with Prop 12 is the economic impact, particularly the cost of modifying existing facilities or constructing new ones to comply with these new space requirements.
00:02:21
Speaker
A university study I came across estimates the total expense for this conversion to be in the range of $1.9 to $3.2 billion.
00:02:29
Speaker
Now, to put that into perspective for individual producers, it's about an investment of $3,500 per breeding pig.
00:02:37
Speaker
Now, for larger operations, you can imagine this goes up to millions of dollars.
00:02:42
Speaker
Now, to navigate these financial challenges, producers are looking at various strategies.
00:02:47
Speaker
You know, these include seeking financial aid, leveraging new technologies to optimize costs, and even rethinking their business models, such as avoiding doing business in California altogether.
00:02:57
Speaker
So it's a complex scenario that really demands both innovation and adaptability from the pork industry.
00:03:05
Speaker
What operational changes do pork producers now need to implement?
00:03:09
Speaker
Good question.
00:03:10
Speaker
So when we talk about the actual changes that pork producers need to implement to comply with Prop 12, it is quite a substantial shift.
00:03:18
Speaker
Essentially, and this was recognized at a recent webinar and in documents provided by the California Department of Food and Agriculture, or CDFA,
00:03:28
Speaker
pork producers are likely going to transform their existing breeding pig farms into group pens to meet the confinement standards.
00:03:36
Speaker
You know, this 24 square feet of usable workspace and the turning around freely requirement.
00:03:43
Speaker
Now, this isn't a simple tweak.
00:03:45
Speaker
It is a significant overhaul of their current housing systems.
00:03:49
Speaker
And one of the implications of this change, especially with a new requirement, is that it can lead to a reduction in the number of breeding pigs that a producer can feasibly maintain.
00:04:00
Speaker
It is a major adjustment in how they operate, with a clear focus on animal welfare, but also with notable operational implications.
Animal Welfare and Farm Transformation
00:04:09
Speaker
What legal obligations does Proposition 12 impose on pork producers in terms of animal welfare, and how might these obligations differ from previous regulations?
00:04:18
Speaker
Prop 12 really marks a significant legal shift for pork producers wanting to sell their products in California.
00:04:25
Speaker
It mandated they provide a substantial more space for each breeding pig than what was previously standard.
00:04:31
Speaker
This change really underscores a greater emphasis on animal welfare, steering away from the traditional individual pen approach to a group housing approach, essentially.
00:04:41
Speaker
You know, what we're seeing here is a broader movement within agriculture, a move toward prioritizing the well-being of animals.
00:04:47
Speaker
Clear reflection of the evolving perspectives and practices in the industry where animal welfare is becoming a very central concern.
00:04:57
Speaker
Are there potential effects on pricing, competition, or other market dynamics?
Market Implications and National Influence
00:05:02
Speaker
Fantastic questions.
00:05:03
Speaker
Now, I do want to preface this by saying that I am not an economist, I'm a lawyer, so my insights here are purely speculative, but with Prop 12, I mean, there is clearly an anticipated economic ripple effect, especially in terms of consumer prices.
00:05:18
Speaker
You know, considering the increased costs that producers are facing to meet these new compliance standards,
00:05:24
Speaker
it's hypothesized that these costs might be passed down to consumers.
00:05:29
Speaker
Therefore, we might see an uptick in pork prices.
00:05:32
Speaker
We don't know.
00:05:33
Speaker
While, again, I'm not an expert in economic forecasting, such a price increase could really significantly alter market dynamics.
00:05:41
Speaker
Furthermore, this situation really creates a unique competitive landscape.
00:05:46
Speaker
For instance, producers adhering to these rigorous California standards could potentially be at a competitive disadvantage compared to their counterparts in states with more lenient regulations.
00:05:58
Speaker
Again, this is just my speculation based on the current situation, but overall we're looking at a complex scenario where
00:06:04
Speaker
regulatory compliance and market forces intersect.
00:06:08
Speaker
And while I don't claim to be an economist, these potential outcomes are quite intriguing to consider.
Legal Challenges and Statewide Adoption
00:06:15
Speaker
Are there potential legal challenges or litigation risks associated with Prop 12?
00:06:20
Speaker
Here's where things get really interesting.
00:06:22
Speaker
So when we consider the legal landscape surrounding Prop 12, it's interesting to note that there's a theoretical room for further challenges, particularly on the grounds of the dormant commerce clause.
00:06:34
Speaker
Justice Kavanaugh and the Supreme Court legal opinion upholding the constitutionality of Prop 12, have concerns about the constitutionality of statutes like Prop 12, not just under the commerce clause, but under other legal theories,
00:06:49
Speaker
such as the import-export clause, the privileges and immunities clause, and the full faith and credit clause.
00:06:55
Speaker
This broadens the potential for legal challenges.
00:07:00
Speaker
In this regard, there's a relevant development here.
00:07:02
Speaker
A Missouri-based pork producer, which operates in various markets, including Massachusetts, was clearly paying attention to Justice Kavanaugh's writing.
00:07:11
Speaker
You know, right now, I'm sure you and your listeners know that Massachusetts is curling rolling out its own animal welfare law, the act to prevent cruelty to farm animals, also known as question three, which is similar to Prop 12.
00:07:26
Speaker
In a recent lawsuit filed by his Missouri-based producer, they closely mirrored Kavanaugh's argument.
00:07:34
Speaker
It's intriguing to see how closely their legal strategy aligns with the points raised by the justice.
00:07:40
Speaker
Now, moreover, in a separate but related case in Massachusetts, the Massachusetts Restaurant Association v. Healy, there's been a delay in the implementation of Question 3 with U.S. District Attorney's
00:07:52
Speaker
Judge Margaret Guzman approving a stay postponing the enactment of this law for at least six months.
00:07:58
Speaker
All these developments suggest that the constitutionality of Prop 12 and similar laws may well be up for debate again.
00:08:05
Speaker
As for the future, it remains to be seen how these legal battles will unfold and what implications they might have for Prop 12 and similar statutes.
Enforcement and Exemptions
00:08:15
Speaker
That's an interesting point.
00:08:16
Speaker
How will Prop 12 be enforced and what are the penalties for noncompliance?
00:08:21
Speaker
So the enforcement of Prop 12 falls squarely under the purview of the California Department of Food and Agriculture or CDFA.
00:08:29
Speaker
If a producer knowingly sells products that don't comply with Prop 12's animal confinement standard, they're committing a misdemeanor.
00:08:37
Speaker
This could lead up to a fine of $1,000 or imprisonment in the county jail for up to 180 days or potentially both.
00:08:45
Speaker
However, there is an exemption here to be aware of.
00:08:47
Speaker
Prop 12 doesn't apply to a combination of food products like soups, sandwiches, pizza, hot dogs, or other similar processed or prepared foods.
00:08:56
Speaker
So the decision to enforce specific legal remedies under the law is at the discretion of the state attorney general or local authorities such as the district or city attorneys.
00:09:08
Speaker
In what can be seen as an effort to help stakeholders affected by Prop 12, the CDFA created a webpage with resources and materials that guide stakeholders through Prop 12.
00:09:19
Speaker
And here you can find printed material as well as videos that I found very helpful.
00:09:24
Speaker
You know, it's a comprehensive approach ensuring that the laws reach extend beyond just the farming impacting the entire supply chain.
00:09:33
Speaker
Interesting points there too.
00:09:34
Speaker
Well, thank you so much, Amaru, for talking this all through with me.
00:09:37
Speaker
It's my pleasure.
00:09:38
Speaker
Thank you again for having me and a great topic.
00:09:41
Speaker
And thank you to the audience for listening.
00:09:43
Speaker
I'm Ann Roos for Feed Strategy.