Transcript
Speaker: Welcome back to the World of Education. I'm your host Colleen Sellers While schools absolutely should be held accountable for educating students, The way we are using standardized testing in the United States is fundamentally broken.
Speaker: We have built a multi -billion dollar assessment system around our kids. It consumes instructional time, disrupts the school year, increases student stress and anxiety, and attaches increasingly high stakes consequences to scores that were never designed to carry all the weight we now place on them.
Speaker: At some point, Measuring education began interfering with education itself. So what is all of this testing actually buying us? Before entering education, I spent nearly 20 years in management.
Speaker: I know operations, logistics, accountability and what happens when policies written at the top collide with reality on the ground. I entered public education in 2013 and was elected to my district's decision -making committee during my first year teaching in Texas.
Speaker: Since then, I've taught in Texas, Louisiana, Hawaii, and Indiana, working with elementary, middle, and high school students across general education, inclusion, resource, self -contained, virtual, and homebound settings.
Speaker: I've seen testing from the policy level and from the classroom floor. And I've watched standardized testing become something the entire school year increasingly revolves around.
Speaker: The Council of the Great City Schools examined 66 large urban districts and found that students in those systems were required to take an average of 112.3 standardized assessments between pre -K and graduation.
Speaker: Another study The Student and the Stopwatch compared testing across districts. By eighth grade, a student in Denver would have accumulated approximately 159 hours of math and English testing, compared with about 54 hours in Chicago.
Speaker: That's a difference of approximately 105 hours. or 19 instructional days. Nearly four weeks of school. and that's just the difference between two districts, not the entire amount of time devoted to testing.
Speaker: But anyone who has worked in a school knows the official testing calendar doesn't tell the entire story. Testing season reminds me of a major sporting event. There's the pregame, the game itself, and the postgame.
Speaker: First comes the pregame show. The practice assessments, benchmark testing, adaptive diagnostics, test preparation exercises, schedule adjustments, and all the work surrounding preparation for the big event.
Speaker: Some assessments provide useful diagnostic information. But when schools continually add another checkpoint, another benchmark, and another digital assessment,
Speaker: We need to ask when collecting information begins competing with instruction. And technology has accelerated this process.
Speaker: I'm not anti technology, but I am strongly opposed to excessive gamification that distracts students from learning.
Speaker: When children are clicking through animated challenges, chasing rewards and completing one computerized diagnostic after another, Are we developing understanding? or simply generating more data.
Speaker: Then comes the game. Testing begins. Schedules change, intervention groups are interrupted, Rooms are reassigned. Teachers become proctors, students rotate through testing spaces, and makeup sessions extend the disruption.
Speaker: Finally, the post -game show. More makeups, disrupted routines, and the process of returning classrooms to normal. A test scheduled for two hours does not necessarily cost a school only two hours.
Speaker: and every hour devoted to unnecessary assessment is an hour unavailable for instruction. But instructional time is only one part of the price our children may be paying.
Speaker: What happens to the child sitting in that chair? What happens when the pressure surrounding the test begins affecting the child's ability to demonstrate what that child actually knows?
Speaker: Because at that point, We don't just have a mental health concern. We have a measurement problem. Researchers studying children in New Orleans measured cortisol, a hormone associated with the body's stress response during high -stakes standardized testing.
Speaker: They found that cortisol levels immediately before testing averaged 18 % higher than during ordinary school weeks. Among boys, the increase averaged 35%.
Speaker: But the most troubling finding involved performance. Students whose cortisol levels changed substantially whether increasing or decreasing performed approximately four -tenths of a standard deviation below what researchers predicted from their ordinary academic performance To illustrate the magnitude, researchers compared that difference to approximately 80 points on the 1600 -point SAT scale.
Speaker: Think about that. We're administering an assessment to determine what students know yet the conditions surrounding that assessment may influence their physiological responses and their resulting scores.
Speaker: And this is not the only research pointing toward that problem. Another study examined children in third through fifth grade. Researchers compared anxiety associated with high -stakes standardized testing against anxiety associated with ordinary classroom testing.
Speaker: The children reported significantly greater overall anxiety during high stakes testing, including more cognitive and physical symptoms. We're talking about elementary school children.
Speaker: Children who may understand far more than their performance under pressure suggests. And the larger research picture is even more concerning. In 2023, researchers published a systematic review and meta -analysis covering 76 studies, 85 independent samples, and more than 53 ,000 children.
Speaker: They found that test anxiety was associated with lower achievement in mathematics and literacy, lower academic self concept, and lower self efficacy. It was also associated with higher levels of general anxiety, social anxiety, and depression.
Speaker: Now consider what those findings mean beyond a single examination. Academic self -concept is how children perceive their own academic abilities. Self -efficacy concerns whether they believe they can succeed.
Speaker: When children repeatedly experience assessment as a threat rather than an opportunity to demonstrate learning, we need to consider what that experience may be doing to their confidence and relationship with education itself. And children have been telling researchers about their experiences for years.
Speaker: In one study, 225 students in grades three through six were asked to draw pictures and write about their recent high -stakes testing experiences.
Speaker: Researchers identified themes involving emotions, the testing environment and children's perceptions of the experience. More than half of the drawings depicted a child alone.
Speaker: often as a small figure surrounded by empty space. That doesn't mean every drawing represents psychological harm. but it gives us another perspective that standardized scores cannot provide.
Speaker: how children themselves experience assessment. The international evidence adds another dimension. In OECD research examining student wellbeing,
Speaker: 59 % of students reported worrying that a test would be difficult. 66 % worried about poor grades, and 55 % reported feeling very anxious about tests even when they were well prepared.
Speaker: Students reporting greater schoolwork -related anxiety also reported lower satisfaction with life. The OECD also found something especially important.
Speaker: The frequency of testing alone did not explain student anxiety. How threatening students' perceived assessments to be mattered. And that's why we have to examine both the volume of testing and the consequences attached to it.
Speaker: The number of assessments affects instructional time. The pressure surrounding them can affect well -being and performance. These aren't two unrelated problems. They're two sides of the same assessment system.
Speaker: Now consider what we do with the resulting scores. Take the word proficient. We use it as though it has one universally agreed upon meaning. It doesn't.
Speaker: States set their own proficiency standards while the National Assessment of Educational Progress or NAEP uses a different framework. The National Center for Education Statistics conducts mapping studies because state proficiency results and NAEP achievement levels are not interchangeable.
Speaker: And NAEP proficient does not simply mean performing at grade level. So when someone one announces that 70 % of students are proficient, my next question is,
Speaker: proficient according to what measure? High school creates another problem. States use assessments such as the SAT or ACT for accountability. even though those examinations were developed primarily around college readiness.
Speaker: But not every student is following the same path. One may attend a university. Another may choose community college, an apprenticeship, technical training, military service or employment.
Speaker: Indiana requires its grade 11 cohort to participate in SAT school day for accountability. even when a student has already completed an official SAT independently.
Speaker: Pennsylvania offers an interesting contrast. Under Act 158, Students have five pathways for meeting statewide graduation requirements. including career and technical education and alternative ways of demonstrating readiness.
Speaker: But let's be clear. Pennsylvania is not a perfect testing model. Its students still take PSSAs, Keystone examinations, and locally selected assessments.
Speaker: Graduation flexibility does not eliminate the broader instructional time burden.
Speaker: If we acknowledge that students need different pathways after high school, Why are we reluctant to acknowledge that they may need different ways of demonstrating what they know before they get there?
Speaker: And the consequences don't stop with students. According to a 2022 National Council on Teacher Quality report, 23 states required or explicitly allowed statewide assessment results to be used in teacher evaluations.
Speaker: That creates a serious attribution problem. A fourth grade student does not begin learning when the fourth grade teacher meets that child in August. that child arrives carrying years of prior instruction family influences, attendance history, language development, school mobility, disability related needs and other experiences that have shaped learning.
Speaker: The current teacher matters. But that teacher is one part of a much longer educational history. Teachers should be accountable for the quality of their instruction and the growth occurring in their classrooms.
Speaker: But a standardized score cannot cleanly isolate one teacher's contribution from everything else influencing the child. Teacher quality should not hinge on how a student takes a test on a Tuesday.
Speaker: This is where our international comparisons become especially important.
Speaker: In our first episode, Beyond the Test Scores, we examined 10 educational jurisdictions, comparing academic outcomes and structural features of their education systems.
Speaker: Switzerland ranked highest in the comparative framework I used. while Northern Ireland ranked lowest. Singapore was another important part of that investigation because of its extraordinary academic performance and the changes it has made to assessment.
Speaker: It remains one of the world's highest performing education systems. Yet its Ministry of Education deliberately began reducing assessment pressure.
Speaker: Beginning in 2019, Singapore removed weighted assessments and examinations in Primary 1 and 2. It revised the primary school leaving examination scoring system in 2021, reducing excessively fine distinctions between students.
Speaker: By 2025, Mid -year examinations had been removed across primary, secondary, and junior college levels. singapore's ministry of education connected these changes to reducing excessive academic competition creating more time and space for learning and supporting students broader development and well -being This was not a struggling system abandoning academic expectations.
Speaker: This was an academically successful system recognizing that achievement and well -being both matter. And Singapore provides an especially timely piece of research.
Speaker: A 2026 longitudinal study examined 3 ,497 students across 13 government schools. Researchers measured cognitive test anxiety and five dimensions of student well -being.
Speaker: positive emotions, engagement, Relationships Meaning, and accomplishment. Higher test anxiety predicted poorer well -being one year later across all five dimensions.
Speaker: That is significant. We're not simply talking about students feeling nervous before an examination. We're examining the relationship between test anxiety and their broader experience of life and school.
Speaker: Now look at Switzerland. Its education system is decentralized, with cantons exercising substantial responsibility. National monitoring of educational competencies can provide system -level information without requiring every educational decision to revolve around a centralized high -stakes accountability score.
Speaker: And Northern Ireland offers another example. Although it ranked lowest in my original comparative framework, it has introduced representative sample assessments for system level literacy and numeracy monitoring.
Speaker: Its first results, published in September 2026, involved more than 12 ,000 pupils across 358 schools. Those results were designed to inform educational policy and system improvement, not to produce public performance rankings for individual pupils or schools.
Speaker: So here's the question. If our goal is to understand how an education system is performing Does every child need another high -stakes score to give us that information? And what about the financial cost?
Speaker: One commercial estimate valued the global K -12 testing and assessment market at approximately $13 .85 billion dollars in 2024, with North America accounting for the largest regional share.
Speaker: Testing has become a major commercial industry. encompassing examinations, software platforms, scoring services, reporting systems and data products.
Speaker: we should be asking whether that spending is producing information valuable enough to justify the instructional, financial, and human costs. Because that's the trap.
Speaker: We sacrifice instructional time to collect data. We create assessment conditions that can influence students' performance and well -being. We treat different definitions of proficiency as interchangeable.
Speaker: use college readiness examinations for broader accountability purposes, and sometimes extend individual scores far beyond what those scores can reasonably establish.
Speaker: Meanwhile, The students behind those numbers are whole human beings. They have abilities, experiences, ambitions, fears, and futures that cannot be reduced to an assessment dashboard.
Speaker: We may not be able to fix every problem facing American public education at once. but we can start examining which assessments provide meaningful information.
Speaker: which ones duplicate what we already know, and whether the consequences attached to those scores are justified. We can protect instructional time while still demanding accountability.
Speaker: And we can recognize that student mental health is not something to discuss separately from academic success. It is part of the educational environment in which learning occurs.
Speaker: So I want to leave you with two questions. How much education are we sacrificing to keep measuring education? And what are we doing to our children's well -being in pursuit of data that may not even tell us what we think it does?
Speaker: For the data fanatics like me, the research behind today's episode, including our assessment comparisons and source material, is available with the companion article at Red Schoolhouse Notebook.
Speaker: This is the World of Education. And this has been the US Assessment Trap.



