Transcript
Speaker: Welcome back to the World of Education with Colleen Sellers. Before we dive in today, I want to give a huge thank you to everyone tuning in. We now have listeners joining us from across the United States the UK, Canada, Finland, Sweden, the Netherlands, and now Indonesia.
Speaker: all completely organically. Thank you for being here. And as always, if you are listening on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or watching on YouTube, you can find the full companion article with every single statutory citation and international benchmark laid flat on my sub stack.
Speaker: Red Schoolhouse Notebook. Today, we are stripping away the bureaucratic illusions of special education and asking a critical question. When we tie classroom dollars directly to diagnostic paperwork,
Speaker: How does that shape the decisions being made for students and teachers? When people talk about special education in the United States, Public debates almost always suffer from a fatal flaw.
Speaker: They confuse legal rights with financial mechanics. To have an honest non -fluff conversation about how we serve students with disabilities, we have to look at both sides of the ledger.
Speaker: We need to look at what the United States has built that genuinely works and compare that across the globe before we examine how our funding pipeline creates financial incentives that push students from informal supports onto formal legal plans.
Speaker: Let's start with the global baseline because credit belongs where credit is due. Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, idea the United States established one of the strongest civil rights frameworks for students with disabilities anywhere in the world.
Speaker: Under federal law, eligible students are guaranteed a free, appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment, backed by legally enforceable procedural safeguards and due process rights for parents.
Speaker: Think about what that means in practice. In the United States, roughly 67 % to 80 % of students with disabilities spend the vast majority of their school day inside general education classrooms learning alongside their non -disabled peers.
Speaker: Parents in the US have the legal standing to sit across an IEP table, review data, request independent evaluations, and hold school districts accountable in ways that families in many other countries simply do not have.
Speaker: That is a massive civil rights milestone, and it deserves to be recognized. When you look around the world, you can see just how differently nations approach inclusion and student placement.
Speaker: Look first at countries that share an inclusion -focused philosophy. Italy, for example, passed law 517 all the way back in 1977, eliminating nearly all segregated special schools and mandating that students with disabilities learn inside mainstream classrooms alongside specialized support teachers.
Speaker: Finland uses a structured three -tiered support framework inside its comprehensive schools. general support, intensified support, and special support designed to keep students integrated in regular classrooms with targeted help.
Speaker: And Canada relies on provincial individual education plans and human rights barrier removal mandates, though funding and service models vary significantly across provinces.
Speaker: Now, look at other developed nations that operate under a very different structural philosophy. systems that rely far more heavily on dual -track or segregated school placements.
Speaker: Take Germany. Even after ratifying the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, Germany maintains a deeply established dual -track school system.
Speaker: Nationally, only about 44 % of German students with disabilities attend mainstream schools, while more than half are educated in separate, specialized schools categorized by disability type.
Speaker: Japan operates under a similarly structured dual -track model, where separate special needs schools and separate special support classes remain a major pillar of how students with disabilities are educated.
Speaker: I am not sharing those international comparisons to throw stones or slap labels on any country. Every nation builds its school system around its own history and priorities.
Speaker: rather I want you to think about what that contrast reveals. On the civil rights front, Guaranteeing access to the general education classroom and giving families enforceable legal protections, the United States stands at the forefront globally.
Speaker: So, if America's civil rights foundation is strong, Where is the friction coming from? It comes from the financial machinery underneath it. Let me be crystal clear about something before we go any further.
Speaker: Students with disabilities need and deserve every bit of support, accommodation and specialized instruction required to help them thrive. Questioning how we fund special education is never about questioning whether kids need help.
Speaker: It is about asking whether our financial rules force educators and administrators to use formal special education labels as a funding mechanism. Look at the actual numbers across the United States.
Speaker: Right now, roughly 15 .2 % of all U .S. public school students, more than 8 million children, have a formal individualized education program under IDEA.
Speaker: On top of that, federal civil rights data collection figures show that another 4 % of U .S. students, roughly 2 million children, carry a formal Section 504 accommodation plan without an IEP.
Speaker: Put those two numbers together and nearly one in five U .S. public school students, 19%, is operating under a legally binding disability plan.
Speaker: and if you widen the lens to include multi -tiered systems of support, MTSS, National district benchmarks indicate that another 15 % to 20 % of students are receiving Tier 2 or Tier 3 targeted academic or behavioral interventions at any given time.
Speaker: now Follow the money across those three tiers. because this is where the system breaks down. Out of those three tiers of student support, MTSS, Section 504, and an i IDEA IEP p Only one of them comes with dedicated federal and state special education funding.
Speaker: Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act is a civil rights statute. not a grant program. Congress provides zero dedicated federal funding for Section 504 plans and virtually no states attach extra per pupil funding weights to 504 students.
Speaker: Every accommodation Every health plan, every testing modification, and every hour of administrative coordination for that 4 % of the student body has to be paid for out of a school district's already stretched general education budget.
Speaker: The exact same thing is true for MTSS. While federal rules technically allow districts to redirect up to 15 % of their IDEA dollars toward early intervening services,
Speaker: Almost no district can afford to do that. especially when Congress originally promised in 1975 to fund 40 % of the excess cost of IDEA, yet consistently funds closer to 11 % or 13%.
Speaker: That leaves states and local districts scrambling to cover billions of dollars in unfunded mandates. So, what happens inside a real school building when MTSS brings in zero extra dollars, Section 504 brings in zero extra dollars, and an IDEA IEP is the only key that unlocks dedicated federal grants and state -weighted special education payouts?
Speaker: You get a structural financial push to move students from a 504 plan or from Tier 3 MTSS onto a formal IEP. And I am not speaking theoretically here.
Speaker: As a special education teacher and former manager, I have seen this happen with my own eyes and heard it with my own ears. When a school's general budget is squeezed and teachers are drowning without enough support staff, the pressure builds to evaluate a student for an IEP.
Speaker: Not necessarily because the student's instructional needs changed overnight, but because an IEP is the only way the district can capture state -weighted funding or count that student on annual child count snapshot dates like December 1st.
Speaker: Even worse. Once a student is on an academic IEP and makes enough progress to exit back into general education, that same financial math creates subtle... and sometimes not so subtle, administrative pressure to keep that student on the IEP roles just a little longer.
Speaker: right past that December 1st funding cutoff. When you look across the globe again, you can see that this financial distortion isn't unique to American culture.
Speaker: It happens anywhere money is gated behind a formal legal plan. Look at England. England split student support into two levels. Classroom -level SEN support, which covers about 14 .8 % of students and must be paid out of a school's existing general budget.
Speaker: and Formal Education Health and Care Plans. known as EHCPs, which cover about 6 % of students and unlock extra top -up money from local authorities.
Speaker: Because English schools cannot afford intensive help out of their capped general budgets, schools and parents have pushed so hard for formal EHCPs that EHCP numbers have more than doubled over the past decade, plunging local councils into multi -billion pound deficits.
Speaker: Now contrast that with Finland and Switzerland. In Finland, Roughly 26 % of students receive learning support. but nearly two -thirds of those students sit in Tier 2 intensified support, which requires zero medical diagnosis and zero formal legal plan.
Speaker: Why doesn't Finland push those kids into formal Tier 3 special education plans? Because Finnish municipalities pre -fund permanent special needs teachers inside every school building out of general block transfers.
Speaker: The specialists are already paid for and standing in the hallway regardless of whether a child has a formal label. Switzerland operates the same way through cantonal block budgets.
Speaker: Integrative support teaching is funded inside regular schools without requiring a formal special needs classification. which is a major reason Switzerland's formal special education rate sits at just 4 .8%.
Speaker: Think about what that tells us. In the United States, we built world -leading civil rights protections under IDEA. And then we wired the funding mechanics so that schools only get paid when they formalize a disability label.
Speaker: Meanwhile, educators are buried under mountains of compliance paperwork trying to justify those labels, while unfunded 504 and MTSS tiers starve for staffing.
Speaker: And here is what makes the American picture even more complicated. We don't have one single funding formula in the United States. We have 50 different state experiments running at the exact same time.
Speaker: plus a federal military school system. D -O -D -E -A or D -O -W -E -A that plays by a completely different set of financial rules altogether.
Speaker: In our next episode we are going to follow the money across the United States. We are going to open the ledger and break down how many states use tiered disability weights where those bounty incentives are sharpest, how many states use flat per IEP weights,
Speaker: How many states have tried census -based block formulas like California and Massachusetts? And what actually happened to their IEP rates? and how military -based schools operate without local property tax wars or per diagnosis payouts.
Speaker: Is our current funding patchwork truly serving the students in the desks and the teachers in the classrooms? We will lay the numbers flat next time. Thank you for listening to The World of Education with Colleen Sellers.
Speaker: Don't forget to check out the full companion article, the international comparison breakdown, and all of the institutional data citations on Substack at Red Schoolhouse Notebook.
Speaker: Subscribe, share the episode with a fellow educator or parent, and I will talk to you next time.



