Zencastr
00:00:00
00:00:01
Speed1x
Format▸
Share
Embed
Report

Welcome to Cicely Alaska: A Northern Exposure Podcast Episode 61

Transcript

Speaker: Welcome to Sicily, Alaska, a Northern Exposure podcast. I'm Anne Flynn Terrell. I'm a cabaret performer and MC. I'm Caleb Cohart. I'm a documentary and commercial filmmaker.

Speaker: I'm Amy Gerlich. I own and run a improv and sketch comedy theater in Denver, Colorado. This is a podcast where we talk about Northern Exposure and how it's affected our lives. And we have some amazing special guests.

Speaker: Season four, episode 25, Old Tree. Old tree. Final episode. It's classic. It's a classic. Classic, classic old tree.

Speaker: All right. Log line. An old tree near Sicily seems to be on its last legs and the locals enlist Joel to make a diagnosis. Wow. Old Vicky, the tree, Akalakatuvik, is ill.

Speaker: And what is our subplot to a gigantic community tree being ill? Shelly can't stop singing. This was so stupid.

Speaker: I thought you would have loved that plot point, Caleb. Me? I have so many issues. i have so many issues. i all my all my notes are the issues with the singing plot. Okay.

Speaker: Yep. Really, like, I thought the Akalakatuvik, Old Vicky plot, I enjoyed because I viewed this as kind of the death of Old Northern Exposure as we knew it. See, I wrote this felt like they brought in the old writers or they skimmed through spec scripts.

Speaker: And they ticked all the Northern exposure boxes. It started with the golf game of Joel, how much Sicily sucks for golf, class classic Joel picking a fight with Maggie, losing his mind about being stuck in Sicily and hating it, wanting to be in New York.

Speaker: Wouldn't be a season finale without it. Yep. Basically, they rolled the dice and they found out what Joel was going to be angry about that this episode, what was going to be weird between Shelley and Holling, ah what Chris was going to talk about, and how the episode ends and what song.

Speaker: I remember all the songs. I thought all the songs were really catchy. The songs were the best part of this episode. Yeah. yeah I was so unhappy with who they chose to give a musical episode to.

Speaker: that I couldn't stop thinking about how beautiful this episode would it have been if it was hauling. My very final note is how I think this entire thing was a ruse to finally get John Column to sing at the end.

Speaker: Look, I started watching out of a joke. I started watching Cop Rock lately because I saw it on some WatchMojo countdown. on like the but it was like It's considered one of the most expensive television shows ever produced. huge Yeah.

Speaker: So in like the early, late eighty s early 90s, there was a show called Cop Rock. Yeah, there was. And it only made it 11 episodes before it got canceled. Look, it's on YouTube. It's so good. All 11 episodes. it is so It wants to be serious, but it's like they hired all very stereotypical musical theater actors to do it.

Speaker: Trying to be like hardcore NYPD blue cops while dancing and rapping to... Just very stock beats. um Randy Newman does the intro theme song. Yeah, he It's so bad. That sounds familiar. now that you're saying that, so that part sounds familiar.

Speaker: i have been hate watching it and getting so much joy out of it because it is the shittiest television show. This is horrible. Shelly, all right. Singing on TV.

Speaker: I did musical theater. I do musical improv. Musical television is painful. It never works. It has never worked. Clearly the actors don't want to be doing it Television actors can never sing. They can't hold a tune.

Speaker: Just like Shelley, she's always just slightly off pitch. Sometimes she's really great. Sometimes she's off pitch. And I think it has to do with the idea that they fall back on this dumb idea of ratatative, which is this musical form where you actually just kind of like sing your dialogue.

Speaker: um So you're just like singing natural talk. So it's unmotivated. it was It was sing talking the whole time. all over the place. his name? My Fair Lady, the... the gentleman, the professor in My Fair Lady did a ton, Rex Reed, did a ton of sing talking throughout that.

Speaker: Yeah, that that's called like rachitative. Rachitative. If you ever like, the the entire idea behind music in musical or musical improv is that you've built to an emotional height where words no longer service.

Speaker: You have to sing it. You have to express emotion. where television does it wrong. And I'm talking every goddamn musical episode, Buffy the Vampire Slayer's musical episode, all of them, they all rely on, well, now let's just sing the plot points.

Speaker: And it doesn't work because it's that's not what it's for. If you can just talk the plot points, just talk the plot points and then sing when you get to those emotional heights. But man, this is so bad. And you can just tell like the actors don't even want to be there.

Speaker: There is one at time when Shelly is singing to Maggie. about something and she's like filling up all the bar condiments while she's doing it. Yeah, the snake song.

Speaker: They cut to a shot of Maggie and she like rolls her eyes big and you're thinking like, oh, she gets it because of the snake song. No, look at Maggie's face.

Speaker: that actor was seriously on stage going, I can't believe I signed up for this shit. Yes. All right. this let me be Let me be devil's advocate because you guys are both- for it. Go for it. You guys are both singers and you do singing improv. ah This is coming from a person who- does not sing well, but thinks they can sing, and also enjoys watching other people sing and perform singing things and enjoys watching episodes that has random singing and enjoys watching improvised singing.

Speaker: um But, you know, God forbid you put me on stage to do karaoke. I enjoy stuff like this because, a i cannot do it, and I cannot do it well.

Speaker: But, like, I love it because I think it's it's unexpected, it's different, and it's fun. So you guys are critiquing it on a level of that I i can't because i don't I don't do those things. Like, I'm just – so I'm saying – from a point of view of somebody who is not super in it that it was fun and I liked it.

Speaker: um So it's like, but I get it. Like I'm also very critical about, and I will give notes on the backend of stuff like the improv portion of certain elements of things.

Speaker: And in Austin, what are you doing with that dog?

Speaker: Get back. but My friend just arrived. Trish just arrived and the dogs go crazy. So I had to hand Jim off to Austin. It looked like a really sad moment. It was literal handoff. Yeah. It was fun. Oh my God. That was great.

Speaker: But yeah that's the thing. It's like you guys are very critical because it is something that you guys are very good at knowing how to note and look at it at a critical eye. i am not that person. So it's like I just thought it was fun and it was interesting and silly and cute.

Speaker: yeah It was fine. It was whimsical. It was whatever. But knowing but you also, Amy, know that John Collum is a very good singer. And when he sang with her at the end, how did that feel?

Speaker: Knowing that we got that Shelly for a whole episode and then John. But that's the thing. I agree with with Caleb. It was a way to... He probably is like, no, I didn't sign up to sing.

Speaker: I signed up to act. And also knowing... the little The little stuff that we know about John Colum, he is a hard no on stuff.

Speaker: So they probably were like, they probably did create this episode to try to get him to sing. And he was probably like, no. He probably just straight up said no to them.

Speaker: And they probably made Shelly be the person who sang. And then they probably got him to just sing that last part with her. I guarantee it. yeah Yeah, maybe. That was good. Whatever. Maybe they had to pay his equity. Absolutely. like And he was like, no not doing it.

Speaker: So can we pretend for the rest of our recording that that subplot is done? We've talked about that plot. I've had my soapbox. I don't need to be it anymore. I feel the same way because I liked the tree. liked old Vicky.

Speaker: Yeah. She had her little snakeskin dress and her little snakeskin earrings for her snake song. Okay. i will say i loved that scene because I knew the song. So I knew I could fast forward through the whole thing.

Speaker: Yeah. you know what I got really excited. it seems this didn't This episode in general didn't feel like a very ceremonial season finale. It seemed like they were forcing a lot of stuff into this one. Yeah.

Speaker: Yeah. I do love this tree plot, though, ah where the tree's sick. Holly wants to cut it down. Practical issue here. The opening scene is Joel playing golf in Maurice's back 40 where this tree is growing, where old Vicky's growing.

Speaker: This is an enormous field. e yeah Enormous. And we find out at the town meeting where the... Apparently the mayor we elected a few episodes ago doesn't exist anymore because Maurice calls the town meeting.

Speaker: He wants to cut the tree down so that he can build a shed for his tractors. He could have built 4,800 sheds for his tractors in this field. Why does he want to build it in the middle where Vicky is?

Speaker: That one I didn't like. But yeah, they decide that the only way to diagnose if the tree's sick or not is to have Joel come out and do a diagnosis. And I loved that. That was so great where Joel's trying to diagnose this scene.

Speaker: Well, and this is the other roll of the dice. Like, what will Joel not like doing that is still kind of part of his job this episode? No, he is not an arborist, but he is the town doctor, so he has to diagnose whatever needs diagnosing.

Speaker: yeah actually does a hell of a job. He dives in. yeah does good. oh he dives in more than when his human patients are ill. and needs a bit to done He has to like he that fear that he could be wrong and the whole town will blame him for its fate. You know, for a ton, though, he has to.

Speaker: Yeah.

Speaker: I feel like the tree should have been kind of was 75 percent of the plot, but my ire. for the rest of the episode kind of overtook it. I will say another thing since I'm on the soapbox, least favorite Chris Hare of the whole series so far. Yeah, he's got like this weird short slicked back thing sporting a pencil thin goatee at the same time. It was like, yeah you know what this was? This was pure 90s rock pop sleaze lead singer. like I expected him to start singing Closing Time.

Speaker: You know, it was like, it was right there with... He could have been a Nickelback singer at this point. Could have. ah But I liked as we were venturing into what was making old Vicky sick, like people taking different types of ownership over maybe it was me. Like I love Ed thinking that it was broken love that was what was killing Vicky. That he had loved and lost too hard and that's what was causing the illness and just everybody's different relationship. because he carved their initials in.

Speaker: And then it didn't last. Ruthann, our stalwart

Speaker: purveyor of wisdom comes in and he's like you know Ed at one point was it his her granddaughters were climbing the tree or some young kids were climbing the tree and they got up 30 feet up in the tree and Ruthann yelled at him to get down and Ruthann solves or soothes Ed by saying you know I realized afterwards that maybe I hurt the tree because trees love kids to climb them.

Speaker: there minute They're meant to be there. So she's like making Ed feel better about it. And she has she throws down some of the best advice that, God damn it, where did I write it?

Speaker: um

Speaker: Trees are better at forgiving us because they're bigger than us. Yeah. I did remember that. I liked that line.

Speaker: but it passed me by for some reason. Yeah. Yeah. Vicky probably forgave Ed and Ruthann because trees are bigger than us. That's great advice. I also like how heavy handed they've been lately about just really dumping Walt into every episode. Like in this one, they just have- And the farmer.

Speaker: Well, yeah. my dad My doppelganger's back. He's been at town meetings. he's He's really interacting with Maurice a lot. But- Walt is literally in Shelly and Holling's house helping to build the crib. I'm like, they are they are just... because they I did like that.

Speaker: They know that they're going to be using him a lot more now, so it's like they're really going to showcase that he's been there the whole time. I liked him. I enjoy his character. I love Walt. Walt's one of my favorites.

Speaker: Yeah, he's great. That's all I have to say. Okay. Really? No, I agree. i thought that the crib making episode was fun and like, well, it's like, oh, that's enjoyable. And Hollings like, hell no, it's not.

Speaker: Yeah. Well, let's be honest. If, if any of our partners just saying incessantly at first, it'd be like, oh, that's endearing. And by the end, all you, you would turn to your friends and go like, I am going to kill Austin. If he doesn't stop singing.

Speaker: Austin tells me, cause I do get into these moods where I sing too much. He's like, you need to get back on stage. need to You need to do this. Yeah, well, Zach does. He goes through phases where he just will have randomly do a word for word. um ah ah you think I think you should leave episodes where he will just go and I will just look at him and be like, that's that's good.

Speaker: That's enough. Yeah. You're done now. um Because, you know, I like it too, but I don't need to hear the whole sketch. Like, it'll just be random too, where he'll just start and it sounds like he's having a conversation with me and he'll just continue and I'm like, no.

Speaker: ah

Speaker: And then at the end of the episode, I feel like we are symbolically cutting down northern exposure as we knew it. I love that you're trying to cut you're trying to cut to the end of the episode.

Speaker: We've got more things to talk about, Anne. What do we want to talk about? What do we want to talk about? Maggie, we're so shallow. I feel like this episode was so shallow. Let's talk about Maggie being a healer from the last episode. And now she is supposedly causing Joel to have an injury every time she comes near Yeah, because she's being nice to him and he can't handle that. He can't deal with the niceness.

Speaker: But she has she has the exact same realization in this episode that I did like a couple of episodes ago where she tells Joel, I've realized it's me. You are who you are.

Speaker: The problem I have with you is me. I'm just going to let you be who you are. It throws him off. But I've come to this realization with Joel now too, which ah is good timing considering he's almost off the show.

Speaker: That you just got to let him be who he's going to be and deal with it. Yeah. I do like the funeral for old Vicky at the brick. I think that's sweet that they put a chunk of her on the bar and everybody's saying little things.

Speaker: I mean, I like the town hall meeting for her. I love the idea of living in a town where we have a meeting about a tree. i say that now, but if that ever really happened to me, I think I might actually hate that. these are the power These are the powerful scenes of this show though. when And that's where the some of the magic has not been lost yet, where we bring all the cast together to have these very poignant, important moments that on the outside, it's like, it's for a tree or, you know, in previous episodes, a town hall for whatever.

Speaker: But we have these amazing moments where the town comes together and this is a big impactful thing for the town. When in reality, it's a tree out on Maurice's property and it is dying. It's a sick dying tree.

Speaker: But yeah, that's where some of the fun and the magic of this show still exists. Yeah. i I was really, it drove me crazy to see the remaining limbs of old Vicky like strewed out all over the field. Like,

Speaker: Coming from a place where I, you know, i like i I grew up in the White Mountains, like like seeing when people don't clean up their tree branches, because that is like a huge thing where I grew up because we lived around the woods and and trees.

Speaker: Like when they don't do that, that drives me bananas. ah Yeah, that's that drives me crazy. Oh, yeah. It's just the social contract. Mm hmm. marie's they're all out there before they have the funeral they're all out there to cut down the tree the whole town shows up to stop marie's and he's got the lumberjacks he's going to go to town with it and um joel's diagnosis arrives with ed via ed because joel's had a horrible fall because maggie was talking to him um can you guys hear simon yeah right let me let him in real quick and i'll finish my poetic thing

Speaker: Okay, so Ed shows up with the diagnosis that Joel's come up with, and Vicky's got a terminal condition. She's only got a few months left, so they go ahead and cut the tree down. In this moment, I just feel that Maurice is truly heartless.

Speaker: ah You know, when we were talking about, a in prior episodes, about how maybe he's realizing there are shades of gray, That's not in this moment. That doesn't exist.

Speaker: It's just all ambition for him and it's what he wants over what everybody else wants. Afterwards, he starts to have a lot of regrets about this. He misses the sight of her in the skyline.

Speaker: And so he goes and he plants another tree at the base of old Vicky. And I think this speaks to the idea that our ambitions can blind us.

Speaker: We don't realize the impact of what we want until we've received it.

Speaker: That's all I got. That's all got. I was going to say, if my neighborhood has taught me anything, when people try and chop down a tree, it's never dead. It's never dead.

Speaker: My neighborhood is full of trees that have been cut and cut and cut again, and they always sprout back. again and again and again it's that root system baby mm-hmm yep this is this was a this was a surface level tree removal situation but i also think that it was like an early example of a record what do they call it needle drop uh to every season turn turn was our final song in this episode and i think that northern exposure is still really does a great job with the music

Speaker: Yeah. This far on. Not a lot of shows then i remember doing a lot of music like this. Now it's totally commonplace. Like they're needle dropping all the time, but it wasn't as common back then.

Speaker: Yeah. My only other thought was ah first time we see the baby's room, like where the hell did this room pop up from? From the same place Ed got the other half of his apartment. Yes.

Speaker: yeah The magic trolls built it. So weird. So weird. All right. Well, that was the season finale. yeah Yay.

Speaker: Womp womp. And Anne's last ah recap until so her partial recap in season six. Good job, Anne. Thank you. Thank you. i am so sick of this.

Speaker: um Well, the episodes are only going to get worse from here on out. So we're all excited. I feel like there's a little less onus moving forward because can go off of vibes.

Speaker: I really had to beat for beat, know these, so we could keep things moving. And even then i missed some beats because I was so angry about other beats. Um, But yes, I've got to run to Colorado Springs. So I will talk to you all later. Yes.

Speaker: Thank you, Amy. Thanks everybody for moving this. All right. No problem.

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Recommended