Zencastr
00:00:00
00:00:01
Speed1x
Format▸
Share
Embed
Report

Season 1, Gen X — Episode 2 — The Darjeeling Limited (2007) w/Matthew Ellis

Death is a Photograph
Death is a Photograph

149 plays · Nov 23, 2025

Transcript

Speaker: I'm going to tell the story about when I tried to take a bass for about six months in a band called After School Affair when I was in college. ah And we were the most ragtag assembled just for the purposes of Battle the Bands group ever. It was a drummer who was the number one ranked like teen drummer in New York.

Speaker: A guy whose nickname was Factoid who played the saxophone. a guy who I think had just learned the guitar, but only because he wanted to learn the ukulele because it was like 2012. Oh, no. Like it was a bad time. Anyway, we were set to play a you know little show at the student bar.

Speaker: And we were supposed to do... Empire State of Mind. I was, of course, the rapping part. I was the GC part. And our female lead singer was supposed to sing the main part. ah But she didn't show for the show. So we're now in pretty desperate situation here. We have a guy who is, let's just say, who will be doing the rapping.

Speaker: And then you have no one who can step to the mic. So we have our drummer, who's like a 6'5 guy who weighs like 87 pounds, try and do the female part for the song. We finished that song, we realized we don't have another one to go into, so we just started again. And that was the point at which, you know, we were booted off the stage. So we were eliminated in the first round for the Battle of the Band. So that's because we're here today with Matthew Ellis. How you doing, Matthew? Good. Thanks for having me. I'm pumped.

Speaker: Yeah, of course. So Matt teaches film at, I promised I would say, Portland State, not Seattle Pacific, which for some reason is stuck in my head. And he also has a sub stack and a podcast. You want to tell us little bit about that?

Speaker: Yeah, sure. So my sub stack is called Histories of the Present. I have newly some deals with some, if you subscribe, do some online teaching with this group called Cine Journeys. So just go to my sub stack, Histories of the Present.

Speaker: I also have a movie podcast. It's a very ridiculous name. The Pacific Northwest Insurance Corporation Movie Film Podcast. We just talk movies. It's it's fun. Me and my friend Corbin, who writes for some Rolling Stone, Portland Mercury.

Speaker: Check them all out at the online, you know, ah the big the big internet. all the All the links. That's wonderful. And you know maybe maybe we can beckon Corbin on sometime if there's any interest in ah millennials or one of the other generations we sort of want to cut through going forward. But yeah, so you brought a film to us today that I think is, ah I was attracted to because it was an unexpected pick and we're trying to look kind of obliquely at all this. So what did you bring and why do you think it was a good fit?

Speaker: Yeah, I was pumped. um I love generational analysis. So when I got your your email, i was like, oh let's go. But yeah, I'm also, you know, boomers are Occupy and Outsides source of my fixation for many reasons.

Speaker: But yeah, I was thinking the classic Gen X sort of hits. And then I thought about the Darjeeling Limited, Wes Anderson's 2007 movie, with ah Owen Wilson, Adrian Brody, Jason Schwartzman. um I love this movie. I think it might be my favorite, Wes.

Speaker: But i I don't know why. i just i i was like, they are very Gen X-y in that movie. I hadn't seen it in years. But I was like, I bet this would be interesting to talk about. I'm interested to see if you can convert me. Because I have to confess, this was my first DJ viewing. I've seen most of his other movies, but for some reason...

Speaker: I feel like the Darjeeling Limited is sometimes the forgotten one, which is part of the reason why i was so attracted to the pick. I'm pretty sure it got like it's got the like lowest ratings from critics of any Wes Anderson film. is Was this your first viewing, Chase?

Speaker: Yeah, yeah. No, i I grew up in the age of like the Royal Tenenbaums was on Comedy Central 24 hours a day. So I was sort of like brought into the ideological apparatus by way of like Gene Hackman in that movie. And and I've seen, you know, the older stuff. I've seen some of the newer stuff up through at least Grand Budapest Hotel. It sort of fell off when you started making movies about The New Yorker or whatever that was about.

Speaker: um But, you know, I think like many people my age, Wes Anderson is is one of those big names and is sort of one of these very influential, at least formal thinkers, if not also just in terms the kind of characters he writes.

Speaker: And that's at the heart of this movie. And maybe something I was curious about as a as a Gen X question, if I can be so bold and and sort of frank. There's something subdued about the average Wes Anderson character, kind of repressed,

Speaker: Is there any kind of relationship there you think to, don't know, think of as Gen X on Wii or the the coolness that comes with the lack of overexpression, something of which I'm incapable? Does there seem to be a connection to you there?

Speaker: Yeah, you know, I actually kind of have a theory about Wes Anderson sort of related to this. Maybe I'll answer it through this. um i like I struggled with Wes Anderson's 2010s output.

Speaker: um I've been convinced about readings of the Grand Budapest Hotel. But starting with Moonrise Kingdom and onward, I was just like, I don't know. Something's something's not hitting yeah the way that these used to.

Speaker: And my theory is, if you look up through Darjeeling Limited, the films are about real people, we weird people, but well Let me rephrase that. The films are about man children, really awkward, strange people set in the real world.

Speaker: And the environment around them is is normal. Even if it starts to get a little goofy like the the boat in Life Aquatic or the train here, it's generally still the real world.

Speaker: responding to these adult children who just can't get their shit together. And this is everything, right? Gene Hackman and Royal Tenenbaums, Bill Murray and Rushmore, on and on and and on. And then after Darjeeling, the whole thing switches.

Speaker: And he gets really interested in constructing artifice from like a filmic language thing. It's very, really interesting formally, but it inverts. And especially those first ones, it's like children are the adults.

Speaker: And the world they're in is artificial and fake. So it like inverts this weird kind of paradigm between the two. And personally, I like the first one more. I like it being in the real world and sort of making fun of our characters, right?

Speaker: Yeah, you're basically describing him as like Michael Mann, which is really kind of an interesting... Yeah, yeah. There's this like... it off off i don't is that the right word you know a person who does not fit in in some way but who i guess the difference is in man they're often kind of um proficient right that's what makes them stand out and in these they're deeply deeply you know not proficient to mean i my favorite line well i just my favorite line in this respect is royal tenenbaums owen wilson he's the novel author and he gets up and says you know well everyone knows custer died a little big

Speaker: What this book presupposes is. Maybe he didn't? Like, just sort of this, the most, like, Twitter meme reaction image of the guy with the big brain that's, like, been blown out by a pinprick. It's also, like, a fist take of Corbett McCarthy, right?

Speaker: Oh, yeah, yeah, of course, but... Like, very obviously. No, I'm just thinking generationally. um It's, like, India is an interesting pick, right? um I mean, i was trying to figure out where it sat as a kind of...

Speaker: lack a better term, like an India head. Like, it feels like it's initially set in the Punjab. He's a classic British person, is what he's saying. Sorry. Yeah, he's yeah sorry. i've Yeah, I've got a, like, Brit out here, unfortunately. But, like, it feels like it's initially set in the Punjab, and then the train is sort of traveling into the deserts of Rajasthan.

Speaker: And obviously... What I think is noticed about this choice is it's a kind of real visual break from the boomer idea of what India is, which is kind of like Ganges, sitas and ashrams, sadis, like Varanasi, the ghats, the temples, like the bending of the bodies, that kind of thing.

Speaker: And this is like a particularly, like visually very different India, which like Wes places is his characters in. And it seems to be drawing a much more from like Merchant Ivory's passage to India. um David leans like bridge over the river Kwai and even Lawrence of Arabia, which also isn't set in India.

Speaker: But like a lot of like the desert scenes like really seem to like the train in the fucking desert, right? Like it's so Lawrence of Arabia. So like Gen X's search for spirituality in this film seems to be sort of like reaching back beyond the 60s, beyond the Beatles and all that shit to like something earlier, which I thought was like a really interesting aesthetic choice.

Speaker: But yeah, I mean, I do wonder about India, whether like it could have been set in any sort of foreign location to the protagonists or if there's like a specific reason why it's set in India. I mean, could it be anywhere? I don't know. Yeah, I know. Anderson's also really, like, this is a film about cinephilia for Indian cinema, too, you know? Yeah, of course. um and So I think that's really important. Like, especially, it's, even though it's Schwarzman, you know, Jewish-American actor, he looks like kind of an Indian leading man from, like, 60s and 70s Bollywood movies. You know, the mustache, the hair, Yeah, I felt like kind of like a cross between that and a Beatle, oddly. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. You're right. You're right. The Beatles, too, obviously, going to India. Yeah.

Speaker: but But, you know, part of it, yeah, I think is Anderson's cinephilia, but which, right, would be very non-Boomer thing. Like, you know, i don't think a lot of Boomers are like, oh, boy, awesome. A Sadie Jiray film. I can't wait, you know. the Music Room. Cool. Yeah, yeah exactly.

Speaker: Well, maybe this is a good opportunity, something we keep forgetting to doing as non-professionals, which is actually describe the movie you know before yeah we ah actually start asking questions about it. So you both have more experience with it than me, but maybe it matters that it make sense to pass this off to you.

Speaker: mean, how would you basically summarize, if not the action, then the spirit of the film? Sure. So we start kind of in Medias Res, these three brothers, played by Owen Wilson, Adrian Brody, and Jason Schwartzman, arrive on a train, various different ways of getting there.

Speaker: um And there are various kinds of, you know, they haven't seen each other in a while. It seems to be some stuff has just happened. They're on the train. Owen Wilson's in a face mask. um They're all very clearly broken in some kind of way.

Speaker: We discover that they've come to India in some kind of spiritual quest thing. um We find out their father has just died. Owen Wilson hasn't really told them what the plan is, but the plan is basically they're going to go find their mother, who's also come to India and has been hidden off in a Christian convent somewhere. Mm-hmm.

Speaker: various inabilities to be emotionally mature result in lots of hi jinks and they cause troubles on on this train that they're on which is very much set up it's anderson having fun beginning to do his sort of stagey setup stuff which is similar he really begins with the boat and the life aquatic before this um And the train becomes this interesting place. They sort of navigate through.

Speaker: They get kicked off the train. And then a series of events unfurls where they're like, okay, now they're in nature. And now they start to face reality, right? um I'm sure we'll talk about it later. But a really interesting, hilar for at first hilarious, and then darkly really like troubling scene where...

Speaker: ah this little boy dies and they go to the funeral and they find their mom and their mom's like, I don't ever want to talk to you again. See you later. And they're kind of like, all right, you know, you know, I skipped over stuff, but that that's kind of the gist, right? It's a go to India sort of spiritual awakening, also coming of age story.

Speaker: Yes. And i I'll just say that the main thing that seems to be hanging in the immediate background is the death of their father, right? So the mother is the essentially the goal of the pilgrimage, because it is explicitly this, I'm going to go to these different shrines, which they do. They get the, I don't know what the red dot is called, but this thing, they're praying in front of these various temples. They don't seem to be really having epiphanies. um And then this culminates in the death of this child, but also the funerary rite that they attend for the child as well. So there's something interesting

Speaker: death-haunted and absent and religious, but in this manufactured, like, I need to go somewhere where I can find spirituality. Yeah, and anderson Anderson really interestingly uses that moment of the child's sort of death and funeral to that's when suddenly we start to actually visually represent the father's funeral and and all this stuff. yeah Well, that the two funeral scenes are spliced together, right? Like, halfway through the Indian funerary rites, you get a splice into sort of the New York funeral. Well, the brothers attempting to get to the New York funeral. So sort of having this detour to this like automatic mechanics shop to get the father's car.

Speaker: And then you splice back to the funeral again. Which is interesting because the American funeral maintained some of that comedy. It's sort of this semi-slapstick mechanic answers. And it's like, oh, who are you, boss? And they're like, oh, we're here for this car. And the guy's like, oh, I don't know. Mr. Whatever's his thing ain't going ready for another week. And then he's like, they're basically like, he's dead. like, well, what do you mean he's dead? And they sort have to come in and there's this whole process and blah, blah, blah. But that stands in immense contrast. That's the spirit of most of the rest of the movie. This kind of classic Anderson.

Speaker: you're You're sort of always a little bit removed from the characters, kind of make not making fun of them. But there's you know a Cohen-esque sort of distance going on here. As compared with the funeral happening in India, which is kind of deadly serious, there's ah white, you know, sort of everywhere as as part of the ceremony, there's these washing rites that are taking place, they're mostly kind of just...

Speaker: there, you know, it doesn't have the slapstick quality in the same way. it's It's an interesting tonal change in that moment that carries us to that moment of rejection from the mother that happens not too much later.

Speaker: Yeah. Yeah. And, you know, I would imagine that I think part of the reason maybe this film isn't as highly regarded is it it was read maybe in some places as like, oh, this is just the classic sort of go to India and find, you know, sort of a white person's spiritual awakening or something like this. But but I don't know. I think that's kind of a misread. Like, they're bumbling fools, you know? yeah this is not, they they, in fact, are trying to do that. and Maybe it kind of works, but everybody's like, you're, this is stupid. Like, what are you doing here, you know?

Speaker: No, I think you're you're spot on. Like at no point, I've never seen this movie before. you know, I'm going say this is, you know, I'm the impartial commentator who's bringing my ah totally unmotivated judgment to bear. I did not end this movie thinking, like what a wonderful Buildings Romanesque tale about the edification of the noble white man who makes his way through the deserts of eastern Punjab or whatever. like you know It's a Rajasthan. Sam, you know your geography better than I do. By the end, they're very much in Rajasthan. But I think that goes back to like E.M. Foster's A Passions to India. right like The characters in that film, for instance, are searching for some kind of spiritual awakening or...

Speaker: encounter with the other and they sort of just are made full of ah effectively like the the main female character is he sexually assaulted in a cave and can never really figure out who the assailant is. um One of the main male characters is completely corrupted by the imperialism of the country and another one sort of like never really, this ah this elder lady never really encounters the spirituality she's looking for and all three Western characters are just sort of like humiliated by the country and and yeah I don't know if Anderson's drawing on that, but it's that's a kind of older European and India tradition to the Bhuma one, or a counter tradition to the Bhuma tradition of sort of Ashram enlightenment.

Speaker: And I think that's really interesting that the the mother, who I suppose must be silent generation or maybe early Bhuma, is very much like bought in to the spirituality of India in a way, and in a very colonial context, right, this convent. um Yeah, yeah. One of you brought up black narcissists, yeah.

Speaker: Yeah, which is, was going to is an echo of Powell and Pressburg as black narcissists from 1947, which is, i think it's an Anglican convent of nuns, which is very unusual, but rather than a Catholic one. And that is all about sort of emotional repression and the desire to be elsewhere and the sort of failure of, you know, yeah journeying to find something. And I think the mother, the mother's kind of like selfishness,

Speaker: It's quite boomer. What's the hymn they're singing? like It's like, i love you, Jesus, over and over again or something. i do i recognized it from school. oh Catholics are not singing whatever that is. i have not once in my life. it I thought it was made up for the movie to make fun of Christian hymns.

Speaker: and Now I'm trying to remember what it is. Well, the point I was making was just that, like, you do get this tonal clash between the mother's rigidity and seriousness. And then what is played at the convent is this, like, to me, very Andersonian bizarre. Like, the kids are chanting this thing that, in my again, to my mind, was basically, like,

Speaker: the South Park episode where Cartman realizes you can just take any song about sex and put Jesus in for the lover character. And like that is, you know, you'll sell a million Christian albums. It was that kind of song to me. And I was like, oh yeah, this place is obviously like a spiritual desert, you know?

Speaker: Like an Anglican primary school hymn. That's so funny. but That probably all means something, you know, but yeah, exactly. for the mothers The mother's deeply selfish, right? Like, she's very self-serious, but she's incredibly selfish. um Not to get into, like, personal generational analysis, but on re-watching this film for, know I don't know, want to say, like, the fifth time, the three brothers reminded me of my own three Gen X uncles, who are... I have three Gen X dad and two uncles, the three brothers who are, you think, born in 65, 66, and 1970. You've a fairly absent, very religious mother,

Speaker: um She happened to be a Presbyterian minister rather than a nun in the Himalayas, but same shit. you know My father, who was the oldest, would always kind of go, oh, I know i had to raise my brothers. My parents were negligent. um The congregation was their real family. and i mean it was just it should It was strikingly odd because um the oldest brother, who's played by Owen Wilson, Francis, yeah drops in passing into, I think, the first scene in the train.

Speaker: um This kind of question, which is left unanswered, which is, um did I raise us? ah to which neither of the younger brothers ever sort of respond. um And then later in the film, Francis sort of has this kind of imperative, um bordering ah sort of tick where he'll sort of go, Jack, you'll have X, Peter, you'll have Y. Yeah, I'll have this. because but And then obviously the the the sort of younger brothers dispute this authority, but ultimately he knows what's best and he always has the right a idea. And then later on in the film, when they're in the, in the conden, the mother does the exact same thing with the breakfast.

Speaker: And he sort of realized that Francis has picked this tick up from his mother. And it's obviously like taken on the role of the mother in terms of the the two younger brothers. I do wonder where that kind of gen X sensibility of being a latchkey generation of having these negligent parents of having to mother their own siblings comes from, because it it comes out in the film massively. Right.

Speaker: Yeah, that's super interesting. You know, insofar as we're talking about stereotypes, obviously, like, you know, with millennials, it's the helicopter parents. My parents are boomers and both of them grew up on farms in Montana with like 10 Catholic siblings, but like the parents were always there.

Speaker: Um, At the very least in the media, boomers represented in America anyway, right? that there not There aren't really absent parents, right? But when then you get to like 80s films, that's when the absent parents sort of come in, right? So that there definitely does feel like this kind of wave that this film is kind of like plopping their characters into.

Speaker: Well, and I think it it's interesting to think of, if we think of Gen X, which let's be clear, you know Anderson is, as you know he's born in the mid-60s, I believe, which you know his films, for me, often associate with millennials, but the man himself is is of that generation and certainly comes out of a context in in Austin, I think, where you get a lot of these other big Gen X people like Owen Wilson, Richard Linklater, so on and so forth.

Speaker: But To the question Sam is asking, one thing that struck me about the film is the way in which their neuroses basically represent three different reactions to that kind of absence, right?

Speaker: So if if Gen X conceives of itself, and again, yes, we're talking in terms of stereotypes, but there is this idea... in popular discourse, that Generation X is the generation that is forgotten, that is left out. In the words of Fight Club, it's the middle child of history um that, you know, sort of is responsible for itself and is now proud of that, you know, the sort of we drank out of the hose thing. Mm-hmm.

Speaker: But that means you're missing the neuroses caused by the trauma of being you know independent at too young an age. So maybe we can get somewhere here by thinking about what are the different kinds of neuroses that develop in the brothers? And ah maybe we can say something about how they're kind of characterized and what it is that's going on in their lives outside the train that informs us about you know sort of the who they are essentially.

Speaker: Yeah, I think it's important too that they're rich, you know? Yeah. um As you noted, obviously the mother's wealthy enough to go live in a convent in india and not have it be a thing.

Speaker: But Owen Wilson doesn't tell his brothers that he's orchestrated this whole thing and he has an assistant that's sort of running on the train, keeping track of everything out of sight. In the way they act in India, on the one hand, some might call it colonial insofar as it it has this kind of relationship to this land that's very othered that they're privileged enough to travel through or something like that.

Speaker: But I think as one of you brought up earlier, right, it is like, on the one hand, they're very much like, oh, I've got this like $3,000 thing and and oh, can I... But then they get off the train it's like, oh, cool, interesting snake. let Let me buy that snake, you know?

Speaker: they They are not doing the very paternalist boomer thing, but they are in this weird zone of, like, they're all trying to find different ways to self-actualize amongst themselves, right? Owen Wilson, very much right, is that the missing the missing father figure he's going to re-inhabit. um I'd be curious to hear what you two would say about Adrian Brody and Jason Schwartzman's neuroses. I feel like Francis, but Owen Wilson's character is more trying to inhabit the mother. Yeah, a parent figure of some sort, right? but i think well and I feel like it's it's Peter, it's Adrian Brody, so the middle child, who is sort of taking on the literally the affects, not so much in terms of Mian, but like the actual physical affects of the father, right? Like the belt, not really about the belt, the belt's from the brother, but um the sunglasses, the razor, and there's a lighter as well, some scissors,

Speaker: And of course the car, most importantly, right? like that There's this kind of strategisation, like the father's objects during his period of grief, which I think is actually quite un-Gen X, in a sense of like Gen X as being a generation of ad busters and like the WTO protests and anti-consumerism.

Speaker: This is a film that feels very ambivalent about objects and about consumption and about... i mean, it's like half the film is about shopping, but like... The first thing they do when they get off the train before they go to Temple is like go on a friendly shopping spree.

Speaker: There's a scene at the end where Francis, the older brother, is allotting them periods of five minutes to do different things at the airport before catching their plane. And like the first thing he lots is like five minutes of shopping time, which I suppose you could see as this kind of like wry dig at consumerism. I don't think it's particularly moralizing, right?

Speaker: Like Anderson doesn't seem particularly interested in moralizing about consumerism. Yeah, it's kind of like all they know how to do or something, maybe. Even the objects, like the relationship the objects. Francis' £3,000 belt and £3,000 pair of loafers, right? He's upset when they get stolen, the loafers. But he ultimately gets over it really quickly. It's not something that's dwelt on.

Speaker: And the belt you know is given as a gift to Peter for the newborn baby. And yeah, I don't know. I think that's just a very interesting, ambivalent relationship to objects in the film. You know, if I may, just yesterday, my wife and were thinking about to various amusement parks in our part of the United States. I thought you were going to say you bought £3,000 pair of loafers. Yes, and they were stolen, and I'm actually not over it, which is why I need to talk about right now.

Speaker: No, but the the the point of this is that when you do this, if you're looking at sort of local enough amusement parks, there are no big accounts that cover them. So we discovered this person was really fascinating. She's definitely definitely very Gen Z.

Speaker: And all her videos are is walking around these amusement parks. And she has a very thick New Jersey accent just by total accident. And is just like, oh my God, that's so beautiful. like you know it'll it Literally, she was at Hershey Park or something. And it was just a bar, like the hotel bar at Hershey Park. And she like sticks her hand over the like great gate to like you know show everyone inside. And she's like, my God, so spacious, so lovely.

Speaker: She's pure. Yeah. like And it's the same five adjectives, you beautiful, cool, delicious if it's food. And that feels very like post-Gen X to me. like There's a way in which something that Gen X is interested in is the critique of that like immediate experience of objects as a means of fulfillment, right? And so in this movie, the ambivalence you're detecting, at least to me, is a reflection of that. like Well, you're in another place and shopping is like what it means to be American in a certain fundamental way. So of course, you have to be doing that. And and to be honest with you, i mean, it's also just the case that religious pilgrimage sites, whether Western or Eastern, are sites of of exchange. They have been for a very, very long time. So you're going to have to do that at a certain level.

Speaker: At the same time, if the experience is reducible to the acquisition of these items as talismans of this place you've been to, you've like failed so far as the 1990s through like maybe about 2010 are concerned or maybe a little later.

Speaker: So I think they're trying to thread this needle. And that's why it's okay for the Adrian Brody character to be obsessed with the dad's things. Because those are non-consumable. They're they're loved for their relic-like aura.

Speaker: not for their exchange value. But the problem within the family unit is that he's not... They're seen as being a common possession, especially by the Owen Wilson character. And so Francis, Owen Wilson, keeps being like, you know, those are all of ours or something. I'm doing a really... Doing Owen Wilson really dirty in this call, but...

Speaker: I went to log them, I went to put them in the trust. Yeah, exactly. exactly like Which is exactly what happened with my dad and his two brothers when my grandfather died. Oh, interesting. that to two to a t it's It's uncanny.

Speaker: That's actually a very interesting point, because that says something that sounds very antigenics, right? Which is like a desire for mediation. a desire for like by establishing this formal structure and executor and like managing things in that way, we will avoid the problem of immediacy that where, you know, someone just goes in and grabs all the stuff and then sort of, uh, like I was just watching, ah Pedro Almodovar's Volver, I think, where part of the plot actually hinges on being able to take a bunch of stuff from the deceased's house before the villagers show up and sort of get to pick the bones clean. And this is like, we need to avoid that at all costs. Like, we need as much mediation as is necessary to produce a stable structure.

Speaker: And that's interesting, because i don't think that tends to be how people would think about Gen X, but it does seem very true. Francis is... constantly seeking to mediate right through the itineraries as well um for the sort of allocation of food and beds i suppose it is maybe telling that he's the oldest brother right and the closest yeah to being a boomer yeah i think actually the characters in real life sorry that the actors are actually also maybe five or six years apart in age interesting Which would interestingly map intergenerational you know divisions. if If in that case, Owen Wilson is the Xer that's sort of closest to Boomer experience, he's going to have some of the kind of Boomer structures, right?

Speaker: Brody's just pure. He's the closest to that kind of You know, it's obviously depoliticized. Anderson doesn't really think about politics until later. ah But that kind of, you know, well, I need this this sunglasses because this is what my dad had. And Schwarzman is the closest to the millennial, right? The like, he's just finding chicks all the time. True. Schwarzenegger was born in 1980, right? So yeah, right on the cusp. Yeah. It's great on the hinge. Um, bringing it back to the sort of the, the tripart sort of valley or sort of representation of the brothers, right? Like, and you were asking like how each one of them is coping with the trauma or the grief of the father being killed by a taxi. Um,

Speaker: I think it's very interesting how each one manifests. So like Francis is, I think, a workaholic and there there are these little tags on um his personal assistants clothing, which say Francis Whitman Industries, which is very sort of self-indulgent and almost, don't know, boomer-esque and it's kind of like self-actualization. And yeah hes he's constantly sort of seeking intimacy.

Speaker: I'd like to imagine hypothetically through hiring like numerous dozens of personal assistants, which he then fires. Yeah. Peter, the middle child, is kind of um it' sort of ambivalent about his wife. He also happens to be British alongside the mother, which is kind of Freudian, maybe.

Speaker: And then Jack is this kind of sex addict in an on-again, off-again relationship um with a woman who torments him. I think also possibly the first contemporary mention in passing of Gaslighting in popular film.

Speaker: Very present and early mention of gaslighting um in terms of contemporary discourse. So yeah, you've got you've got these like three different coping strategies, a kind of like workaholic self-actualization, kind of structural ambivalence of the middle child, and then a kind of immediacy, a kind of hedonistic immediacy from the the youngest child.

Speaker: And the the kind of addenda to that are Owen Wilson has almost just died in what may have been a suicide attempt. It's not really clear exactly. Which is interesting because he himself, actually, i think, I don't know if it was around this time, but Owen Wilson did try to commit suicide and it was a big thing. Yeah.

Speaker: isn' that true in Royal Tenenbaums too, or am I mixing him up with different character? Oh, I think it was Luke Wilson. Okay. That's a little a little better. But so you've got this going on, which is but interesting. Maybe we can return to that. um And then the other two are respectively having a child and getting divorced, right?

Speaker: The seventy s late 70s, early 80s, which is the period where Gen X is kind of coming into something like adolescent maturity, is the era of the divorce film. This is when you get Kramer vs. Kramer, very famously, of the Roses, the Danny DeVito movie, I think is late 80s.

Speaker: um you know That's the decade when America kind of has to confront the reality of the family as something that can be broken. And I think Gen X is interesting because it's the first generation for whom that's kind of a granted or at least something that can be accepted as... I mean, I think the boomers accept it as normal, but I guess what I mean is they grow up in the shadow of it being normal.

Speaker: So I'm interested, personally at least, in the way that the characters are reenacting the destruction or attempt to continue those family structures. Like Owen Wilson...

Speaker: seems to be almost like, you know, don't know, the mom in Daria or something. Like, the work character who, like, doesn't even really need a family. I mean, maybe they have one, but they don't really need one. You have one who has kind of gone the Charlie Sheen and Two and a Half Men route or something. and then you have one who's, like, trying to stage something that resembles the traditional family unit. And these seem to me, like...

Speaker: Three kinds of response, a generation raised in an absence of authority who takes on a certain kind of self-authority and authorization. Three responses they could have, but that are all sort of insufficient in different ways to the challenge.

Speaker: Yeah, and it and it's really interesting, speaking of mediation, as far as this being an American film, you know, Sam, I think you're noting a lot of the, what I would imagine is Anderson's nod to the sort of history of the UK and India, but the way that it shows up in media, right? As far as I know, that's really his sort of connection there, but like,

Speaker: You know, the American family unit of the 1950s, the idyllic sort of television version. You'll see these occasionally pop up in like 50s films, you know, sort of Douglas Sirkey kind of melodramas. But it's always viewed as this thing that we don't really quite talk about. It's it's kind of on the margins. There's this sort of ideal that we always must gravitate towards.

Speaker: And in a way, it is kind of like... as America enters the sort of late 20th century globalization through stuff like, oh, you know, Wes Anderson saw Bollywood films, and this is like a global consciousness is sort of starting to emerge. That's where you go work out all the sort of domestic family unit stuff is like in this larger media sphere, which itself brings out all the neuroses or something like that, right? Yeah.

Speaker: From my mind, kind of Gen X is... Western white Gen X's sites of sort of um exoticism or Orientalism are like Thailand, Vietnam, Korea, Japan, retabet China. It's very much like tied in with like the the internet and like cyberpunk and manga.

Speaker: And like India's old hat by like this point, right? You think about films like The Beach, I don't know, like, you know, those are the kind of places these people are going. India is kind of like their their parents' generation. um So I think it's ah it's an interesting stylistic choice in that way.

Speaker: Well, and they are going to see the mother. like I guess that's sort of the interesting point is they're kind of being left in it because that's where she is, right? And they know that or they hope that their destination is going to end with her. Which maybe it's something like, right, ah she goes to India to self-actualize. Maybe at least we're reading it generationally insofar as she still has to go to a Christian convent. um But they have this idea that it will—at least Owen Wilson has this idea that it will work out, Right.

Speaker: But they go and they're like buying weird shit because the markets have already been set up for tourists and they they get the snake and the guy on the train is like, dude, we like this isn't some 19th century colonial thing. Like, don't bring that snake on. We have rules on here. what are you talking about? You know?

Speaker: It's as if they're just reenacting this thing. It's if they were told that they were supposed to do it, but they show up and in India, even though it's shot in these beautiful 35 millimeter, you know, very tangible kind of aesthetics. It's like, India is not this just weird other place. It's like, there's there's people here and they're looking at them like, what are you doing? Yeah.

Speaker: No, that's an... It's especially... i remember ah you know good old mainstay Roger Ebert, you know the sort of cinephile's birth canal, so to speak. He, in his review, i was reading after I watched it, talks about how the the stewardess on the train doesn't have an accent or has an American accent, I guess is what I mean. That basically you're expecting this exoticizing, you know, yeah one of the brothers is going to have this affair basically with this this woman who is responsible for them on the train basically.

Speaker: And they do, they have this affair, but it's like, it doesn't become this like swept off your feet by this foreign woman and everything has changed. It's like, you know, that he's poking his head out the door, trying to leave. And she's like what are you doing? and He's like, you know, I'm getting ready to go with you. And she's like, go by yourself. Like, you know, we are not supposed to be seen together coming out of the bathroom. Like, you know, this, everything sort of returns back to normal.

Speaker: And even again, in her voice, we get the sense that like, he may as well be in, you know, Des Moines. Yeah, exactly. Being in India has nothing to do. He still has to smoke. You can't even smoke in the train. Yeah. That kind of like deep,

Speaker: I don't know. Whenever I go to like continental Europe and you can, you can smoke in restaurants and that they're kind of the the exoticism of the other or the particularity of something different. And yet, whenever you travel, and I think Gen X maybe was the first generation to really experience this, of, like, you still experience something of the other when you travel, but increasingly you also experience this kind of universal regulatory sort of state of being that kind of crosses across all boundaries. um And, like, yeah, with the Rita character, the sort female Indian train conductor, like, you can imagine her, like,

Speaker: having just graduated from graduate school at Berkeley or something and it's just like a part-time job she's doing. Yeah, exactly. um You know, the exotic and the the world of the Diageo Unlimited is much, much smaller than it would have been probably for these characters' parents or grandparents. Like, it's...

Speaker: Yeah, which, you know, again, i i've been I've been convinced recently by readings of Grand Budapest that, you know, this is a this is a parable about fascism. But, you know, Anderson is never really explicitly political. I think he is more now. but But again, you know, the way this generational stuff works out, conscious or not, it is like, well, this is the world of global capitalism. It's come to India now, right? And it's like, they are, just as much as they're buying little trinkets, they're going to purchase experience in India, right?

Speaker: And it's not even like, I'm going to go have a colonial experience in India. It's like, I'm going to go have a consumer experience in India and buy self-actualization or something like that. you know but Here's a question. so like The last scene where they're running for the train, which echoes the first scene where Bill Murray, which is this kind of weird side character, doesn't really get involved, is also running for the train. The three brothers are running for the train and they drop all their father's immaculate premium leather suitcases with embossed initials on.

Speaker: And I wonder if we should read that as a rejection of consumerism or as, is it a kind of more subtle kind of like liberation from the baggage of the part, which is isn't even that subtle. I mean, that's pretty unsubtle. What is the meaning behind them like dumping all their father's kids on the railway station and sort of, you know, jumping on the train and going, let's have a cigarette and a drink?

Speaker: What's interesting there, though, is they go have a cigarette and a drink. It's not like they're like, all right, now we're going to go to the ashram. The rejection of the baggage is accompanied by taking the grill pill, to use a term from 10 years ago on Twitter.

Speaker: They become like homo consumer ickus In the nicest way possible, right? I don't mean that they become the girl I was describing from the YouTube videos who just calls everything beautiful. But they do say happiness basically inheres in ah you know the song from Hey Arnold. Mr. Wynn sings all the simple things or whatever it is. like That's kind of where they land.

Speaker: Which is, to me, that is a very Gen X reaction. It's sort of like, everything's sort of shit. We're not going to become stockbrokers like our boomer parents did. But also, like globalization hasn't like done what it does a year after this film is released or at the end of 2007, really, which I do want to come back to.

Speaker: So what do you do? You know, there's kind of no politics. I mean, there's a very vague idea of a left that kind of explodes in 1999 at the WTO protests. But like prior that, it's Rage Against the Machine, which like, I love Rage Against the Machine, but like you listen to those songs and tell me that they're going to build like a vanguard party out of those songs. you That's not going to happen. And so what's left of you but learning to appreciate the little things, taking like the post-Christian pill or something, you know, like sort of just saying, like, I don't know, the products are pretty good. As long as you don't dive too deep into them and don't get too attached, it's pretty much fine. Like that that's how I read the ending. Yeah, just don't be weird about it, you know? Yeah, exactly. I wish you bring up the fact that they're constantly taking like prescription pills and painkillers throughout the entire film.

Speaker: Yeah. And it's like really glossed over. and There's like one point where the Sikh train can conductor sort of goes, do you have a you have prescription for this? And that's quite an interesting 180 on the colonial thing where they're kind of like, oh, we're in India. We don't need prescriptions for high-quality painkillers. No, you do. There's a regulatory state. like This is globalization.

Speaker: um But I mean, yeah, they're constantly sort of self-medicating, which you know you think about the Sacklers and the sort of um the epidemic of opioids in America. It's, again, incredibly prescient.

Speaker: But you know it's also the flip side of the kind of grill pill thing. right like There's a way in which i don't know like popping a lewd and frying up a hot dog is sort of like why you know those things are are kind of perfect complements in a way.

Speaker: I think it is interesting that the movie, I think, tends to make us think about that as a way of repressing the pain of the of their family situation. But by the end, it seems like they've almost found a way to do that alongside the medication, because I don't think they're just going to stop taking the pills or something necessarily. But they're supplementing it now with like the spiritual practice of like mowing your lawn and having friends over. you know like That's really what it feels like. They're reinventing the third space or something. What's that incredibly popular book for Gen X of the 90s? The Zen of Motorcycle Maintenance. Yeah.

Speaker: That is perfect. like I hadn't even thought of that, but like yeah, they that they may as well like buy that at the airport bookstore on the way out or something. like That would be spot on. I have a pet theory, which is that like millennials... you know I'm technically a millennial. ah Sam, I think you're a little bit closer to Gen Z, but maybe also technically a millennial in the generational breakdown. I'm right on the cusp, baby. Yeah.

Speaker: I'm not, but like spiritually, I do feel sort of split between the two, you know kind of in a in a hinge way. But in any case, I remember as a younger person, you know all of the millennial discourse, and there was a feeling among millennials that was sort of like, when will we stop being spoken about? And then one day it stopped, and I think there was a bit of a generational identity crisis, but that's for a different podcast.

Speaker: So I think as much as we feel like that went on forever, it really started in 2008. Like that is when the millennial becomes a figure in large part because of course the millennial generation is like,

Speaker: now in a position where they're either just getting out of college or have been out of college for a few years. Obviously, that's a group that's going to be strongly affected by this this massive break in in in the economy.

Speaker: So here's my question, or maybe my my thought. It's interesting to think of this movie as the tail end of the Gen X movie period. as sort of like the goodbye to the Gen X filmmaker cinematic moment that goes all the way back to maybe like, I mean, we've reviewed things that are quite old on this show, but ah one of them, you know, the early ones would be like Slacker, which I think is 1990. You could go back further than that. um And this is like, all right, well, Gen X is making peace with all of its problems, most of which seem to stem from a lack of parental authority of one kind or another.

Speaker: It's telling that the characters are kind of on the cusp of middle age, right? like Especially the um the Francis character is probably just about in middle age, and then the Peter character is you know sort of maybe late mid to late 30s at this point. um Yeah, but I guess i I'm thinking like even just at the level of... It's almost like a ah historical accident. that you know The movie manages to come out in 2007, presumably before. I didn't check the release date, but since the collapse is so late in 2007, odds are that it was released prior.

Speaker: And it works so well as this... like we're We're going to say goodbye the slacker characters. You're not going to get a whole lot of those anymore because that does not make any sense from ah a sort of an ideological perspective to be talking about.

Speaker: We're certainly not going to be doing the slacker characters who like seem to be financially stable somehow. Yeah, that's over. We cannot do that anymore. it does not make sense. you know Think of a character like the dude in The Big Lebowski who like somehow is living in LA despite like clearly never doing anything.

Speaker: That's got to go. This whole kind of like... spiritual thing even, i find it very interesting, and these are my own biases coming out, obviously, but to think about this movie in light of like new atheism, which is going to happen basically right after this movie comes out, which is this very like millennial, I would say, driven, though Gen X is involved too, kind of deeply anti-religious, often very Islamophobic sort of movement that is nowhere present here. Like these guys still do think you can do some sort of milquetoast spiritual quest. Um,

Speaker: in like ah To me, almost like a Kurt Cobain kind of way. like i don't know if Kurt Cobain talked about spirituality, but Kurt Cobain isn't isn't singing songs about like God not being real or how you should put a colander on your head.

Speaker: These guys are like the epitome of like spiritual but not religious, right? yeah Yeah, exactly. ah Spiritual for what, though, is not very clear. think that's an interesting conversation. is that the kind of There's a real dialogue between the sacred and the profane in this film, or should say maybe more the sacred and the mundane.

Speaker: i quite like that Anderson never comes down one way or the other. yeah These two things are just sort of held in radical ambiguity. um And that is gen X, right? Like, well, I don't know. I mean, I love this theory because it describes my experience perfectly. I mean, ah obviously without the Islamophobia thing. But I'm i'm a like right middle millennial, vividly remember nine eleven But 2008 is the thing that's just like, well, I guess my life is going to be like this now. yeah but i But I agree, especially because you know my little theory about Anderson in the flip that happens after Darjeeling is, I think, a formal and narrative shift. But I also think it's exactly what you said. I think it's a generational shift in his audience, right?

Speaker: you know I remember when people around my age started to get into Wes Anderson and it was Royal Tenenbaums, It was a little bit um ah life aquatic.

Speaker: We didn't understand any of it. It was just like kind of goofy and funny and like, oh, look at how cute everything is and kind of this music, right? And those movies are speaking, I think, more to these sort of like adult Gen X audiences because they're man children. They're like, well, we're we're in our early, we're like in our mid thirties now, but we're still kids. I don't know.

Speaker: But then as audience shifts to primarily millennials after this movie, And really part of it, maybe is's just that I don't think it is, but it to me feels a little unvantalizing to be like, well, okay, your world's this little play world of you know artificial construction. you know And it is like, okay, after 2008, Wes Anderson's universe cannot exist with foreclosed homes in you know empty suburbs in DoorDash, right? DoorDash does not exist in the world of Wes Anderson.

Speaker: So we have to go into this artifice because that world is over, right? um So yeah, the cusp before 2008, I think, really is something. that's That's so interesting that almost in a way,

Speaker: Wes Anderson's sort of filmic connection to the real world is sort of reliant on the end of history. Like, it's reliant on this unipolar moment of, you know relative abundance, and that when the world suddenly becomes chaotic... I mean, it's not like... Like you said, ah it's not that he refuses to deal with the sort of reopening of politics and reopening of history after 2008. Yeah, those earlier films are much more epochal in the sense that they really represent particular period.

Speaker: Yeah. And they're kind of... um There's a synchronicity with that period or a sort of comfort with that period in way that there isn't with the later films. I definitely agree. um And it takes place in the real world because that stuff still happens in the real world.

Speaker: But when it starts to happen in our real world, it's like, oh no, I have to i have to go back into the cinema world. And it it is interesting. I hadn't really thought about this. And maybe this is a good opportunity to talk about Wes Anderson like as Gen X filmmaker more more broadly.

Speaker: He does Fantastic Mr. Fox, right? Not too long. Oh, that's right. I think that's the next one. Yeah. I mean, that is the classic. like We're literally doing a children's book by a children's author, and we're setting it in a claymation sort of um you know a literal storybook world. And then Moonrise Kingdom is a film about children, and there are all sorts of ways in which it it does develop in this.

Speaker: infantilizing direction, which is interesting to consider in terms of what that might mean for a certain kind of Gen X person and like where they go after 2008. Oh, yeah.

Speaker: What are they thinking about? Why is that escape from reality? Because one of the things we've revisited several times so far is Gen X as the Trump voting demographic. I mean, just just in terms of the percentages, they go the most for Trump, which is bizarre. I think most people don't realize that. They think it's boomers. It's not boomers or the arch libs. I say boomers boomers are ah the Ukraine liberals. for Yeah, exactly. Yeah, well, and they're but they're also like the Supreme Court. like they're the They're the institutions. They are the norms. I mean, that's part of why things feel so, I think, frayed right now. like The generation that was the last to really try and

Speaker: hold on to whatever the kind of Cold War American project is is going, and nobody else really has any idea what to do with that. And a lot of them want stability because of of their the value of their homes, right? um In the nest egg, whereas, yeah, I think Gen X is like, well, I got a little, but shit, I got a lot of time left and things aren't looking good. Let's, you know, let's shake this stuff up, you know? I really have to find out for this podcast whether Gen X is the same in the UK in terms of like... That'd be so interesting. Like Reform UK or Brexit, that kind of thing. I don't know. I mean, and it is interesting that Gen X's children, who are predominantly Gen Z, are also the ones sort of turning to the populist right, especially the men.

Speaker: And it's the millennials who are the children of the boomers who are the kind of like fluffy left liberals. And yeah, there's an interesting kind of mirroring there, right? Well, there is something that... A movie I don't think we're slated to talk about, but that is like very contentious for Gen X, partly because all Gen X people hate it, that we've spoken to about it, Sam, but like it is taken in popular consciousness as a Gen X movie which is Reality Bites.

Speaker: And if you go back and watch that film... It's very frustrating to watch because the implicit claim of the entire thing, like the ideological core, the point de capitaine, whatever it is, the quilting point, is that like it is better to be a crazy, abusive guy who likes art than like a stable guy who ah you know is is nice to you. And believe me, someone who watched it for the first time last year my wife and I were just like jaws on the floor. Like, what is this movie smoking? This is insane. And even if that isn't how GeneX sees themselves, I think about that a lot as at least how they were portrayed to themselves in media. And so for Anderson to be making this break, this kind of running away into...

Speaker: the realm of formalism, you know, they're running away into that world. It is an interesting parallel there. that Like, it's better to be the romantic kind of poet character who abstracts and gets away from than to be too dirty with the ways of the world. And after 2008, it sounds like that might be a way for Anderson to do that, at least one of the ways to do that.

Speaker: He at least turns to begin to try to allegorize things, but it should not be forgotten that this also Iron Man comes out, I think, in 2008. And this is the moment in which at least American popular culture turns back into sort of franchise, you know, 1980s reboots of reboots of reboots of reboots and... YA picks up after this. and Anderson, obviously, i'm not i'm I'm saying he's doing a a sort of opposite version of this because it becomes self-critical, but but it is the turn to to artifice. you know yeah is

Speaker: What the fuck is going on? I just realized that Zencaster has a soundboard and I really wish I had an organ for when you said Iron Man. If we were not live doing this and I could import a sound file into this, guy yeah, just like Iron Man 2008, you know, sort of, ah you know, Count Dracula style music. Because I saw the first Iron Man movie when it came out. I was ah a teenager, was a child.

Speaker: I was like, that was fine. You know, I don't know anything about politics. That seems fine. 10 years later, I'm living in New York City. I spent a lot of the intervening time in college and then graduate school. And I'm living with four other people in New York City. A lot of roommates, classic situation.

Speaker: And all of a sudden, everyone around me is talking about Endgame or Infinity, one of these movies. And i literally said was like, what the fuck are you people talking about? like They made an Iron Man movie 10 years ago. And I was forced to confront this fact that there had been like a secret generational capture happening while I wasn't paying attention and everyone but me. Chase, you got the last helicopter out, so I got apparently lin I mean, it's because I was in college. You had to, like, drive to the movie... We weren't drive to the movie theater to see the newest Iron Man movie. That just didn't make any sense to me, you know? So, like, I saw Fury Road because that seemed cool. but Yeah, I think that's, like, really interesting about, like, who goes to college and who doesn't from the millennial generation.

Speaker: Like... And if if you go to college and you're not that mobile and you can't get to a cinema, what do you do? You pirate films on your computer. you're pirating films on your computer, you're much more likely to end up watching weird shit. I mean, in one sense, you know, to be a vulgar Jamesonian about it, it is like, if we're starting to get into sort of media pastiche, Darjeeling is totally the sort of version 1.0 postmodernism of like, well, there's some Satyajit Ray films in here. There's some, you Schwartzman kind of looks like a Beatle, kind of looks like a Bollywood actor. there's some sense of history still, right? Oh, India, that's there's some history there.

Speaker: But then, you know, 15 years later, it's like, oh, Spider-Man, you guys. Harry Potter, you know? Well, and the political issue, right? What's what's interesting is a decade after this movie is made in sort of what some might uncharitably call high woke. I mean, I might just call when I was in graduate school in an English department. You know, you you are necessarily thinking about popular media as as a political vehicle. i mean, I will never forget seeing Black Panther with a friend of mine who's in my program from the inner city, like very much like in a way the the target audience of the movie, or at least the represented audience of the movie, representation of the movie. He came out of the movie and told me that he thought that Tupac would have hated it and killed whoever was responsible for it. That would that was what he said. Okay. Yeah. Which is, I think, probably true. That's neither here nor there. The point is that like you're at a point of you're you're sort of i mean pandering with uncharitable way of putting it. Whereas 2007, and granted, Anderson is never going to become that kind of filmmaker. I don't mean to draw that kind of comparison. But in 2007, Anderson does not even remotely feel the need to make this relevant in any obvious way. like This reading we're giving, it if you've never seen this movie and you turn this off and go watch it,

Speaker: Maybe what we're saying will make sense, but it's not going to be the surface of the text. You're not going to watch this movie and be like, oh yeah, that's what this is about. like we're We're abstracting several layers to fit this into the mold that this podcast is interested in, this kind of critical lens. But you could easily just watch this as like an offbeat comedic you know dramedy, basically.

Speaker: And that's fine. You pick up a really good point, Chase, which is Darcy Unlimited is kind of at the end of the era of what you might call the post-political world. so There's a guy, a political theorist called Anton Jaeger, who wrote a great article for The Point magazine called Everything is Hyper-Political. He sort of divides the late 20th century, early 21st century into the post-political moment. So this is all after the end of history, really. So the post-political moment, which is kind of Gen X's moment, it's kind of like...

Speaker: You know, political issues have been solved. We're just going to like go to raves and take drugs um and like fuck each other. And then you have the anti-political moment, which is the 2010s, right? It's the post-2008 crash. It's the millennials. It's popular the rise of populism, left populism, right populism, anti-systemic politics.

Speaker: And then you kind of have like what we're in now, which is like high peak politics, which is that everything is kind of like incredibly political, but there's absolutely no staying power. So you have all these kind of like internet mediated political movement movements and moments, but that, you know, vanish within a year.

Speaker: And like Darjeeling limited really feels like it's like at the end of that kind of post-political moment where like there are no real questions about colonialism or race or identity in this film. Like there are kind of like subtle mocking moments about it. Like, but there's no real explicit, like reckoning with any of these things. Um, in a way that I don't like, I'm fine, fine, refreshing.

Speaker: I do too, and I think it's because you can do a ah useful symptomatic reading of it. you know It's like they're actually, okay, if it's symptomatic, it still at least points to something. right the The symptomatic reading of Wonder Woman is, you know oh, this is ideology speaking itself, and it's obvious. you know i I can't help but note in the in this conversation or think in this conversation that to kind of pick up what you were saying before, Matt, about the Anderson turn, right? So the movies after this, we talked about Moonrise Kingdom, we talked about Fantastic Mr. Fox, but then 20, I think it's 13 or early 14, is Grand Budapest Hotel.

Speaker: And what did you say earlier? You said, well, you know, he's returning to, or you not returning to, that you've been convinced to some degree of the political reading of that i didn't like it at the time because i was I was viewing it this way. I was like, this is just another fun, he's just playing with toys again, you know? And But this is the thing. After that, you get the movie I disparagingly did not name earlier, which is The French Dispatch, which is, you know, made in the moment of, like, high journalism. You know, the moment of, like, democracy dies in darkness. We must protect the, you know, Gia Tarantino at all costs, or whatever her name is. Gia Tarantino. Half the film is basically, like, a prestige of the, sort of, May 1968 moment, right? Yeah.

Speaker: Like, it's a, But it's it's funny because it's it should be expected to be a Gen X satire, the Bima mythology of the Suissant who dies of like May 68. And yet it's not. it's like this loving treatment of that of that moment, um which really fucked me up, to be honest. I think so bullshit came from 1968, really.

Speaker: And that kind of like turned to a kind of ideal idealistic left over material left. And I don't know i feel like Anderson could have done something interesting with that, but it just kind of valorizes 1968 rather than doing anything more interesting. Yeah. But he no longer shies away. i guess the point I'm making is that like yeah those movies in this period of the of Wonder Woman and and all these things, he obviously feels, or at least at some level implicitly desires, to to represent these explicitly political problems. That even if he maintains all these formal tricks that seem you know deeply anti-political, they take on like a Brechtian quality once you introduce obviously political content. So he makes a transition there. And i think that kind of lends credence to your theory there, Matt, because basically you've got the end of these movies, these kind of children's playhouse movies, and then a movement into something that feels it has to speak politically. And that does mirror Gen X because...

Speaker: Gen X, Blue Sky, you know Blue Maga, for that's like a 95% Gen X social media platform where it's like, I'm putting on my pussy hat, I'm getting in the streets, I'm i'm putting on the Kente cloth. like That, to me, is a very Gen X-coded political move, and it it is one-to-one with the period of filmmaking we're talking about for later Anderson.

Speaker: Absolutely. i mean, one other way to do it in this regard, you know bringing up French french Dispatch, the little fun house sets before it goes totally virtual with the animation stuff, the boat in Life Aquatic, the train in Darjeeling Limited, there's kind of more of the boat. There's kind of a reference to the Ziga Vertov era Godard films, like specifically, I think it's Tuva Bien,

Speaker: It's about the strikes right before May 1968. And he builds this big, like almost like dollhouse set of a factory. And he stages his actors and the camera moves like room by room by room. And it's like, this is how he shoots the boat in the Life Aquatic.

Speaker: So it's a Godard reference there, utterly dehistoricized, depoliticized, right? But then he returns in French Dispatch. It's as if he can't quite figure it out, but he's like,

Speaker: Okay, maybe Timothee Chalamet is is someone one of the actors in the Godard films that's like kind of this hot teenager. I don't know, I don't know. Does that make sense, guys? you know It's incredibly reminiscent of Bon Depart, or Peut-il-Sifflet, right? exactly yeah Those characters have a criminal legend.

Speaker: Godard's revolutionaries are also criminals. um And Timothee Chalamet is kind of like bourgeois, wet wipe. Yeah. I guess, and there's this is kind of this is quote i'm from the female journalist who's kind of covering the youth revolt in what's presumably the Sorbonne.

Speaker: um And she kind of goes, you know, the kids have had enough. The kids are up in arms. The kids are going to change the world, which is, you know, incredibly Gen X. You know, the kids are going to save us. Gen Z is going to save us. You know, meanwhile, Gen Z is getting like really into Andrew Tate.

Speaker: Yeah, exactly. Tradwiping or whatever else. So, yeah, this kind of reluctance to let go of the end of history or the reluctance to, i don't know. Yeah. I mean, speak Gen Xers and like any kind of disagreement with their,

Speaker: ideological carapace is kind of seen in bafflement because it's kind of like, well, we're, we're the finalization of kind of ideological development. And yeah, this is, this is what it is. And like, you can either kind of get on board or fuck off.

Speaker: Um, and I think that kind of weird harking back to 68 sort of projecting into the sort of Trump resistance at the same time is, yeah, it's fascinating. Matt, did you tweet, is this you, if I'm remembering correctly, who tweeted like yesterday or something about, I'm sorry, posted on X, the Everything app, about um how you were perplexed by or disliked when older Marxists seem to imply that that ideology didn't exist anymore? Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Yeah, I mean, that does seem to be a version of, I mean, obviously, we're not, blue the people on Blue Sky are,

Speaker: If they're Marxists, they're Marxists of a deeply heterodox variety. But yeah yeah there is something to this idea that that a certain sort of Gen X stereotype is all about ideology being at an end. Yeah. And that you know there's a reason that I think Slavoj Zizek becomes so popular when he does in the twenty ten s because he's like, actually, everything is, yeah it's the opposite of what you think. It's all ideology yeah all the way down. And you know I think millennials probably reacted to that so strongly.

Speaker: Yeah, yeah, i completely agree. And yeah, right, whether they're cringe libs or whether they're some of the smartest, you know, people who consider themselves Marxist intellectuals, like— Historical experience, and this is why I like generational theory, it's not about inherent qualities. It's about the historical experience that you all share by dint of being alive at a certain moment in the development of capitalist society, right? And I'm sorry, like you both, cringelibs and leftists, you have the same little thing in the back of your head, you know, that tells you like, oh, well, well, it's different now. you' you don't understand the eighty s and 90s. Like,

Speaker: it it's it's this way now. there's There's a kind of like clinging to teleology, right? Yeah. There's this is innate teleology to Gen X. um It's just like John Gray, the the British philosopher, a kind of secularized Christian teleology to another Gen X thought, I think. I think that spans across ah To give them a credit, like I feel like maybe it's like only a certain brand of conservatives that really ah have any suspicion about that teleology.

Speaker: That's funny you know to to take that to its... Because that, in a way, you both just summarized the sort of motive force of the podcast, ah you know that generations can be evaluated materially, essentially, even if you're necessarily talking in heuristic categories, not in you know ontological realities.

Speaker: But to think of Gen X, okay, as the bears of the secular Christian tradition, and to think of the end of history as the eschaton, then the sort of purpose of the show, the purpose of this conversation is to think about like the post-Paulian moment for the for for liberal society. Because if you take christian you know early Christianity to be saying it's it's going to come to the end.

Speaker: soon, right? If that's something that's baked into the religion, at a certain point, you need to start saying, well, like, okay that didn't happen. So now how do we maintain this faith, this set of institutions, but in light of what otherwise might be evaluated as a failure? And frankly, I got to give Christianity an A-plus in that respect, really saw that through, still going.

Speaker: What remains to be seen is whether or not liberal society is able to affect the same change. And I think that when we talk about the end of history, least when I do, I take Fukuyama to be saying, to be kind of still fundamentally correct, which is that even our autocrats are liberals.

Speaker: That like they still feel the need to, you know, Bukele in um El Salvador is a great example of this. He says he's a great partisan of democracy. he likes to talk about how he has 80-90% support. He uses this kind of populist rhetoric about gangs as his primary means to gain political power, right? All these things. Which is... which is deeply-reached in the social contracts and got, like, lock-in theory, right? like Exactly.

Speaker: Like, we're we're still liberals. At the end of the day, we have not gotten beyond that, and we're just trying to figure out how to write the post-Paulian writings about liberalism, and we have not figured that out. Yeah, since the the collapse of the USSR, there is no feasible universe. I think Fukuyama's specific point is, like,

Speaker: okay, there's stuff like there's Islamism and there's, you know, nationalistic particularities, but on the universal global stage, like, post-USSSR, there is no alternative to, like, liberal democratic capitalism yet.

Speaker: It's interesting to think about that. and One of our other guests we had on, Spencer Leonard, who with we did Glory, the 1988, I want to say, Civil War movie. don't know you're familiar with it. And a lot of his thinking about that movie has to do with it being about the kind of victory of a certain kind of universalism over a certain kind of particularism. And that it being made in the late 80s is this weird moment where You have Republican control. you know Obviously, neoliberalism is really kicking into full swing.

Speaker: But these myths about the ability of a project like America to subsume differences and produce a universal ah kind of Kojivian state ah are are are still there. And breaking out the Kojivs.

Speaker: Well, I was taught by Straussians, but fortunately I'm too too versed in these debates. But yeah, that like that even by the time of this movie, I mean, listen, I'm not trying to compare Glory and the Dirge League Limited. They're very different movies made about very different things. But in the world of the Dirge League Limited, we are very much in the world of the family. We're in the world of the personal unit. We're in the world of um travel in ah in a global society, but that is ultimately about personal or at least small unit spiritual quests. And if I can say one thing about contemporary American politics,

Speaker: It is that, especially on the conservative side, they're not exclusively. It is increasingly anti-solidaristic. It is increasingly interested in relatively small units of organization, whether that's the family. Frankly, not even the community most of the time. It really is just the family or the individual.

Speaker: Because, you know, even conservatives now aren't like... for the most part, that interested in, like, I don't know, protecting everyone who's been... Like, you know, we did Summer of Sam, another movie where a character's called Bob the Fairy and is still protected by all of these straight characters because he's from the neighborhood. Like, even those relatively...

Speaker: what in Catholicism we would call subsidiarity, the kind of layers and levels, these concentric circles of affiliation. It's been sort of reduced to just that fundamental layer right around you. A little shout out to not friend of the pod, but admired podcaster and and journalist Yasha Levine, who did an interesting podcast on the Red Scare Girls in this dimension, where it was sort of like, yeah, they're basically just like Russian suburban moms. And if you read them that way, it actually all makes a lot of sense because Russian suburban moms really just care about family. I haven't picked up on this, but I'll i'll have to...

Speaker: I mean, it's kind of like everyone now, sort of leftists and conservatives are. I mean, there's this is interesting binary that the sociologist David Goodhart came up with everywhere, some somewheres and everywheres. And like the the characters in the film, like Summer of Sam, ah they're somewheres. ah They're particularly rooted to like covenantal ideas of like society. They're rooted a particular place, a particular neighborhood.

Speaker: Like you say, like that's encompassing enough even a deeply conservative neighborhood to like take in certain kind of outsiders like this this one queer character. Whereas everyone now is kind of an everywhere sort person in the sense that, yeah, the units that really matter are family and individuals and they're kind of like fungible.

Speaker: I think the characters in Dijillion Limited are kind of everywhere people in this sense, right? that They are kind of children of globalism in that sense. I think even going back to the end of history, right? Like these three brothers, that um it's the end of history and the last man, right? It's the Nietzschean last man as well.

Speaker: And Fikiyama always talks about FIMOS, right? Like this this search for an Aristotelian spirit or like bravery or courage translated in multiple different ways. But the sort of the perfection of liberal democracy could be ended by boredom, effectively.

Speaker: Yeah, I feel like Gen X is struggling with that kind of proclaimed end of history, which they in one Like simultaneously they embrace, like these characters in Dodging Limps are embracing their end of history, but they're also really fucking bored.

Speaker: Yeah. You see that throughout the film, right? Like they're searching for an Aristotelian Thymus. They're trying to revive some kind of quest, some kind of struggle, but they're desperate for struggle. Yeah, that's what, you know, Fukuyama was so important to me, and it still runs a thread through all of my work.

Speaker: And I used to always really bristle at the boredom thing, because like, you know, as a materialist, you're like, well, this is absolutely silly, right? It's the contradictions of, you know, social reproduction and blah, blah, that...

Speaker: generate contradictions and all this. But um if he had just used a different word, you know Sam, I think you were getting around it. Like, yes, boredom is one affect, but it is this like inability, not to go full Mark Fisher, but it's like an inability to like conceive of what we do with it or like an exhaustion with like,

Speaker: being unable to see a next step or something, right? it's It's not just boredom because when he says boredom in there, around it, Fukuyama is also talking about, you know, the great struggles of the 20th century, you know, or something like that.

Speaker: um And Chase, to your point that, you know, conservatives like have reduced back to, well, if it's ever a back, But they you know the smaller unit, whether it's a family, um i mean, some leftists do this too, right? Like, oh my God, you're really going to try to like go talk to normie liberals that the Democrats are going to just do X, Y, and Z? You need to go have your little reading group. you know Nobody can imagine anything outside that size. And like is that boredom or is that like the horizon of what I can see is like this little unit?

Speaker: No, I think it's ah it's a very good point. I tend to think of it, I guess, as a mixture of the two rooted in the kind of psychoanalytic problems produced by material change. So something like social media, obviously a very easy example. But if you look at something like Gen X, right?

Speaker: they deal with this problem of ennui and where where do they think it comes from? They think it comes from too much stuff, basically. They have access to too much stuff and it's too cheap. And this produces a certain kind of reaction. And you can figure that in terms of boredom. You can figure that in terms of a lack of meaning or request.

Speaker: You can figure that in terms of, yeah, a problem of social reproduction where it's like, Eventually, my supply of the treats is limited, and then I'm mad because I can't have all the treats anymore. Which, you know, moving back, the Trump admin guy tweeting that like the American dream is not just about treats is the craziest thing I've ever seen a human being. like We're in the treat empire.

Speaker: didn't see this. That's perfect. Oh, yeah. No, it was like if you put that into a movie, everyone would be like, come on. You can't do that. Yeah, yeah. I mean, that's incredibly, is this guy a Gen Xer?

Speaker: Now there is the question, because I don't even remember who said it. I'm sure we could. assassin it he's like, I think he's a young boomer. Because, i mean, that's just like it's it's so resonant of that anti-conceitement. Like a right-wing anti-conceitement. I mean people are saying, yeah like, Trump managed to do what the anti-WTO protests never did. Right.

Speaker: A right-wing populist anti-consumerism. Yeah, to to the point, sorry. I mean, that is amazing, and I don't i had to bring it there because i just... Genuinely, one of the most heart-stopping things I've ever experienced in my entire life reading that. But now we can take social media as an example. like It produces all of these, to me, very obviously, material problems have to do with attention spans, that have to do with you know frankly, just like your ability to engage with the people around you and therefore build various kinds of relationships, whatever word we want to use to describe them. It seems obvious to me that there's a reason that you know Marx talks about being a poet in the morning and a fisherman. maybe Maybe like the fifth time I brought this up on this podcast in as many episodes.

Speaker: There is obviously a dimension of the, at least Marxist project, that has to do with a sense of actualization, whether you want to talk about it as fulfillment, eudaimonistic thinking, or whether you want to think of it as Lacanium project of Gisson's generation, whatever.

Speaker: it is an obvious problem, and it seems to be the defining problem of at least Gen X, if not if not every generation. I don't know if I'm willing to stake myself on that, but at least for Gen X, that inability to figure out how to capture whatever that remainder is,

Speaker: seems to motivate a lot of the responses we're talking about. I mean, hit them is there anything more, quote unquote, the real than death? And this movie is all about like figuring out if there's any way to meaningfully symbolize that problem. like yeah That's why you have the funerary, right? That's why you have the holding on to all the different objects. That's why the mom is in a convent. like There are all these different attempts to to make sense of that.

Speaker: problem of the the real, which is basically that which has not been symbolized and in a certain sense can't be symbolized, the remainder. Is it also like these characters are constantly dealing with like Marx mentions in the Grundrisse, which is this kind of like, over time, this reduction of necessary labor time, right? Let's see, necessary labor is that which goes into social reproduction.

Speaker: We get to a point in the, not for everyone, but we get to a point in the 90s and 2000s where for a certain class of person, necessary labor is like at possibly its smallest historically. And these characters are kind of in that position. And they're all sort of trying to like deal with it in different ways. So you've got the wife, is it Alice? I think the wife of Peter is Alice, the one who's pregnant.

Speaker: She makes these sort of like little clay jar pots. There's a scene where she's pregnant on a hospital bed and she's surrounded by these clay jar pots. and yeah I think the youngest brother, is ah Jack, is like writing these kind of like terrible autofictional novels, to which all the other characters go, you know like i really like how you were X in said piece of fiction. He goes, all the characters are fictional.

Speaker: Obviously, the oldest brother is like rejects the premise entirely. His whole thing is that there is no reduction of necessary labor time. In fact, all time is is necessary labor time. Which, yeah, weirdly, and this is definitely mapping like cycles of accumulation and declining profit rates and and everything, right? um Even if Anderson's not properly conscious of this.

Speaker: But it's there, right? The kind of generational shift where the oldest brother, I think, has less of a sense of leisure time. Whereas the younger T-brothers are, to quote Chase's favorite Marx bit, they're kind of fishermen in the morning, the evenings.

Speaker: That's so... It's funny. I just had a vision, a dark vision from a mystical realm of a version of this movie where ah generative AI is doing all of the jobs, but it's still the same movie. Yeah. They, you know, this sort of Marc Andreessen dream has taken place. They actually have somehow in this totally fantastic way, like, eliminated visible labor and reduced necessary labor time to, like...

Speaker: being a bunch of engineers somewhere who are like throwing buckets of water on you know things that are like cooking the ocean around them. And like it's what's funny is it's still basically the same movie.

Speaker: The amount labor that you're actually seeing that has to do with economic and social reproduction is economic production like basically nil in the world of the movie. And that does seem kind of interesting to me. There is something...

Speaker: almost like totalizingly slacker about that, where it's, instead of it being the early Gen X idea where you push the slacker into the real world and the slacker sort of shows up all of these, you know, the, the big Lebowski in that movie, for example, who's like, you know, what does he say? The,

Speaker: ah the bums lost Lebowski won you know that whole thing like instead of it being that it's just the world of the slackers have won like the labor is invisible it's either being done by post-colonial subjects who could just as easily in their world be replaced by generative AI or whatever and you just carry on you do the spiritual quest you know And the pilgrimage, instead of going to India, is to attempt to try to get to Brooklyn 2011. And there are all these Gen Zers, you know, like, man, those were the good old days. And we're like, they weren't, man. like like This is the thing. It's the constant expansion of necessary labor time back to a like a and nineteen fifty s level or something.

Speaker: But I mean, also, what's really interesting about the film, so 2007 is kind of the period where globalization is happening, but you also, third world labor costs are probably at their lowest around the, like now, you know, Indian labor costs are like, you know, half to 65% of American labor costs, but,

Speaker: In 2007, I'm like, haven't got the stats on this, but, you know, my instincts say, oh, like, 20, 25%. So you can kind of, like, imagine these characters kind of, like, more hard-pressed than America, and actually, like, part the reason it's going to India is that you kind of, like, have this simulacrum of the leisure class of less necessary labor time ah because things are so much cheaper. And I do imagine, like, ah like an equivalent American sort of going to India now, it would be so luxurious because actually, like, the labor costs, the inputs are so much higher than what they were in 2007.

Speaker: hu Yeah, that's interesting. This is still very much a unipolar moment. Okay, we've had 9-11 and we're about to have 2008, but it's still kind of a unipolar American hegemon moment where like, as an American, you can go to these places and like live in luxury.

Speaker: Well, yeah, think about, mean, people forget this, but like Russia was all on board with the Iraq stuff. I mean, like, you know, there was a period where they were trying really hard to, you know, more or less be a part of the the club. And I mean, in this time, especially when it seems like America is just kind of being in charge forever, why not try to do that? China has joined the WTO and I think is frankly trying to like lay low.

Speaker: Because they're benefiting from that. Why would they you know cause any trouble when they're benefiting from that? So I think you're right. like It is a moment of... um And it's pre-Modi India too, right? Maybe interesting to think about. This is still the... I was i was thinking about that. He was Prime Minister in India in 2007. That I don't know. but I think it's still Indian National Congress. was going to say, it's still got to be a National Congress...

Speaker: For Anderson, I think it very much is this still kind of a dehistoricized place, though. you know like it looks like the 60s. But that is what the National Congress is. I mean, until Modi takes over, there's a sense in which India is this dehistoricized place ruled by like the Gandhi clique and the you know sort of other yeah ah the people around them. Is it is that the case, Sam?

Speaker: Yeah, so it's Manmohan Singh, who's a National Congress guy, went to Nuffield College, Oxford, you know, just yeah very much part of that upper class PMC world.

Speaker: Yeah, I mean, india really India's middle class really starts growing in the 90s, and it Modi really comes to represent this lower middle class of India. Yeah. through the BJP and like Hindu identity, middle-class Indian identity. And yeah, like it's ah interesting in a film, there's like no real distinction between the religious elements.

Speaker: Yeah. None of that is really reflected in the film. Um, I wonder even if, if, you know, Anderson made this film 10 years later in 2017, possibly he would have reflected that. i mean, Modi's in power. He's a kind of resistance lib.

Speaker: Modi is kind synonymous with Trump in the American mind. And maybe there would have been some commentary. That's kind of to to Matt's point, though, or to kind of fuse the two ideas together, that India is a kind of dehistorical phenomenon in the Western mind from independence until Modi takes over, more or less. That you do basically have one party rule.

Speaker: There's a brief period in the 70s where Indira Gandhi basically does martial law. But, I mean, absent that, it's this relatively successful, almost unitary party democracy. Obviously not actually unitary, but, you know, functionally at the level of government. And so, yeah, I think he would have had to have dealt with something like that because India could no longer serve as this non-historical place because now there is history in India. Yeah, yeah, in that mind, yeah, yeah.

Speaker: You know, there's the famous Hegel line that Africa has no history. It basically means like, Africa's existing under this dark shroud. I assume it's basically always been this pre-feudal or feudal society at best.

Speaker: So anything that happens there is both unavailable to us as a written history, but also like not subject to change in the way that European history is subject to change, or maybe even Asian history is subject to change.

Speaker: And there's a way in which the India of the 20th century for a filmmaker like Anderson is... Like Africa, it has no history, but, and here's the contradiction that enters into this, it's full of history. I'll never forget watching an episode of The Bachelor. don't know if you guys have seen The Bachelor.

Speaker: They go to Thailand. It cuts to Thailand. they're walking around. One of them just goes, oh my God, this place has so much history. And I was like, as compared to what? Like, everything is the same amount of history. What are you talking about? like But of course, what she meant is that there's this obvious remainder of the past. Exactly. Uneven development, basically, if we want to put it in that way. And like that's the contradiction that that Anderson is inhabiting here. is like India is both like history as such. It is like so oppressed by the weight of history, of temples, of of ritual practices, of a certain kind of authenticity that comes with those things. and

Speaker: It is a totally dehistoricized place because India as a political unit is has been the same for as long as he can remember and for as long as anyone important can remember. and I have to point in this out. It's something we'd we'd actually missed, but the film doesn't just come out right before the Great Recession, but it also comes out a year before the Mumbai bombings, which were a sort of Islamic terror attack on Mumbai by a radical Pakistan sect, right? And like the fact that India is sort of like a year after this film is made is drawn into the world of the war on terror, the world of like alienation and paranoia around Islamic terrorism and like joins...

Speaker: on this kind of like trajectory, I think it's really interesting that in Darjeeling Limited, all kind of conflict, religious conflict, all kind of geopolitical strife is sort of absent. And i I guess one could say like, well, it's film, it doesn't happen. you But yeah, I think there's something interesting about the fact that the kind of, for those years, you sort of read the news.

Speaker: off deck A year after seeing Darjeeling Limited, deck because they're reading about like atrocities in Mumbai, right? It really does feel like a cap to the end of history and in this kind of way. yeah Matt, you have i you plugged at the beginning, but maybe do you want to just ah make people aware of what you're up to here at the end?

Speaker: Yeah, my sub stack is called Histories of the Present. um Check out my podcast, ah the Pacific Northwest Insurance Corporation Movie Film Podcast. I know it's a very SEO-friendly name.

Speaker: We're doing a series on digital cinema. um It's going through summer, I think. So ah check us out. Yeah, we'd love to maybe have you guys on soon. we would We would love to. And thank you very much again, Matt Ellis. Thank you so much, Matthew.

Speaker: so ah How much do you know about Darmic Law? ah very very Very little. so yeah this This movie was entirely incomprehensible to you then. It didn't help that you and the guests had both seen this movie like 15 times between you and this was my first viewing. so i i do have i have an incredible fondness. I think this is probably this might be my like fifth or sixth rewatch.

Speaker: I kind of had a i had a long anti-Wes Anderson period in my life where I sort of you know was like, I'm too good for these films. They're like a midwits idea of like, oh, how's it going to be?

Speaker: But, you know, this i think like re-watching, re-watching Darjeeling Unlimited, I think especially his early films do still really stand up. I find his later stuff a bit cutesy, but the early stuff is is is' good.

Speaker: And this particular film, like, as a ah bit of an India head. that Is that an acceptable term? I don't know. I think it is. As long as you're not like making fun of Sikhs or something, I think it's fine. If you're describing yourself, it's okay. yeah For clarification for listeners, I do a lot of journalism on them ah South Asian geopolitics and sometimes get in trouble. But...

Speaker: Well, N was in Spencer Leonard, other guest of the show's class on post-1945. I think it is South Asian politics. so Yeah, it broke me. It really did break me. um I kept watching the film through the lens of V.S. Nightfall's Wounded Civilization.

Speaker: um I mean, it's just, it is incredibly interesting, just on globalization, that the the Indian characters who have the most speaking time, the train conductors, have American accents, not British accents. Because obviously a prior generation of kind of Indian middle class to elites would have very much had a British accent. hunt And yet by this time they have American accents.

Speaker: I mean, I think it, on the Modi thing, I think Modi is the first Indian prime minister not to have been educated in England in some form and not to be fluent English. so That's kind of fascinating. I mean, it makes a certain amount of sense, obviously, just based on who he appeals to and sort of what he represents, but it's not something I've ever actually thought about. There is a way then in which the movie, if Modi represents a certain kind of like India for the Indians, where Indian means what Turk means in Turkey, as the old joke goes, which is that anyone can be Turkish as long as they're a Turkish-speaking Muslim.

Speaker: Like, you know, it's sort of that version of the Indian, right? where Right. He is weird in the sense that he is obviously attempting to make it monocultural along religious lines.

Speaker: But, and maybe I need to check up on this, but I'm fairly sure there's not any element of what you might call Hindi nationalism. Like, obviously, India is a massively multilingual country. um And that's actually not really reflected in the film. But, yeah, the kind of monocultural move in India, I think, is ah is mostly a along religious lines rather than linguistic.

Speaker: No, no, sure. and I guess the the point I was going to make is just that insofar as the India of the movie is the dehistoricized India that's like almost not for Indians, you know, like in the world of the movie, it almost exists for them. And insofar as you have this kind of relatively secular kind of Cold War leftover kind of governance at this point that is in a certain sense, exists to like be a a Western country that happens to not be in the West, you know at least at the level of the political class and how it wants to sell the country. Whereas now, Modi very much wants India to have its own identity that you know happens to have this religious dimension as its kind of glue, but that is also just a way of like reclaiming the country for its quote-unquote own people. Yeah.

Speaker: Maybe the way to close is the comment that Matt made as soon as we got off the call that he wished he'd been able to tell on the podcast, which maybe summarizes the connection between Darjeeling Limited and our own moment, which is that when the train stops, and you know all credit to Matt on this because he's the one who brought it up.

Speaker: When the train stops, brothers get out and they say, you know, what's what's going on? You know, why? what I don't understand. And one of them goes, says the train's lost. How can a train be lost? It's on rails. Apparently we took a wrong turn at some point last night. That's crazy. How far off course are we? Nobody knows. We haven't located us yet. And the idea is that's a little bit what it feels like now. Maybe that's a description of the end of history.

Speaker: It's not 100% clear where that train is going, where it's intending to go, or even to a certain extent where it is. So maybe that by way of closing, we will see it. We'll see you all next time.

Speaker: Death is a photograph, culture at the end of history. Bye-bye.

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Recommended