Zencastr
00:00:00
00:00:01
Speed1x
Format▸
Share
Embed
Report

Season 1, Gen X — Episode 14 — Summer of Sam (1999) w/Jon Repetti

Death is a Photograph
Death is a Photograph

125 plays · Feb 22, 2026

Transcript

Speaker: My throat's broken, I think I'll.

Speaker: Hey, everybody. Chase here with Sam, and our guest today is John Repetti. ah John is a former colleague of mine, i guess, over at in in the Princeton English Department, and is a writer and critic.

Speaker: He's got work coming out, forthcoming in the LARB, Review 31, Hard Stop, and elsewhere, and very, very pertinent to this episode. He grew up in the North Bronx. How you doing, John? Hey, good. i um I drank about 100 beers and smoked about a million cigarettes last night. so if I'm a little hoarse, a little busted.

Speaker: we weren't even together and it seems like we had very similar experiences. I know. um Maybe we should talk about today's today's movie, which is a Summer of Sam. John, why did you bring Summer of Sam to us?

Speaker: So I brought Summer Sam because, well, you explained the concept of the podcast to me, which is 90s films and thinking about Thinking about Gen X, yeah. Yeah, thinking about Gen X and its sort of self-reflection, right? And how Gen X uses this a certain canon of media to think about itself.

Speaker: And I wanted to talk about Summer of Sam because I think it's, A, one of the sort of really underrated films of one of the great Gen directors, Spike Lee, and because it's really a film...

Speaker: From the late 90s, about the mid 70s, using the 70s to think through itself, like the film opens, the first scene is New York Post crime reporter Jimmy Breslin saying, um you know, look how far New York has come. You know, like we're doing pretty good now. It's 1999, edge of the millennium, nowhere to go but up, property values, all this stuff.

Speaker: But it wasn't always that way. And then you go back to the 70s and to this period in the city's history that is both seedy, but also nostalgic. Like there's obvious nostalgia, like in Breslin himself, when he gives this speech in Spike, in all of Lee's films for this earlier New York that was sort of divided into these ethnic enclaves. That was a kind of, you know, grittier, realer, whatever you want to call it, version of itself that the 90s sort of produces as simulacrum.

Speaker: And he's very clear about his his sort of nostalgia for the moment. I mean, he basically says things were realer then because there was more crime. Like, people are happier now in this, I don't want to say superficial, but let's say statistical way, right? Like, now David Berkowitz...

Speaker: you know, and potentially other Sons of Sam are not stalking the city, that's good. But also we've lost something, you know, in the same way that maybe, you know, someone might talk about my hometown saying, I'm mad the factories are gone, but my house is worth another $200,000, you know?

Speaker: Yeah, exactly. And the sort of um the self mythologizing that, especially the outer boroughs, I mean, some of this film takes place in Manhattan, but it's really an account of certain Italian and Hispanic neighborhoods in the outer boroughs and you a way of talking about how they relate to the city.

Speaker: Could you place the film for sort of non-American, non-East Coast listeners? I mean, I'm fairly familiar with the areas. i think a lot of people won't be. I mean, it's kind of Yonkers, is that right? Okay. So Berkowitz lived in Yonkers. oh So the film takes place mostly in a neighborhood, in two neighborhoods in the Bronx called Pelham Bay and Throgs Neck, which are in the very far North Bronx, about as far from Manhattan as anywhere in the city.

Speaker: You know, if you ever take the six train of Pelham Bay park bound six train, that's the neighborhood it's taking place in the end of the line. It's It was then and it remains a ah sort of self-contained neighborhood. Most people who live there don't actually work in the Bronx, work in the neighborhood, work at the local businesses in the neighborhood.

Speaker: It has not gone the way of the gentrified city that so many other places have, partially just because it's about an hour from downtown Manhattan by train. And because the real estate is different, it's mostly single family houses. But it's a lower middle class, working class neighborhood. And it's historically an ethnic enclave. like I grew up there. So this is the neighborhood that i grew up in. This is the neighborhood that my parents spent a lot of time in when they were young, though they lived further south.

Speaker: And in some ways, it's a place that's been left behind by a lot of what's happened to New York in the past 20, 30, 40 years. And... thirty forty years and I think that that makes it a really interesting subject for... It makes it the object of a very interesting kind of nostalgia.

Speaker: Whenever people ask me how to describe it, I say, like oh, it's the last like real mafia neighborhood left. you know you walk down like the main street in the neighborhood, and it's Giordano's funeral home, right next to Giordano's florist, right next to Giordano's monuments. you know like It's this sort of... And then down the block, there's Giordano's pet shop. like It's a neighborhood...

Speaker: you know like I had a friend growing up who like dated one of the um like gambino one of the Gambino daughters. you know like And there's next to these kind of falling down, shitty little starter homes, there's like a big mafia mansion with like a you know with like a statue of the Virgin Mary in the yard and a fucking stucco wall with water dripping down. It's really... it's And it's charming, like you're laughing. And like it's a genuinely charming place to live and be around because it's got that kind of, frankly, like this, it harkens back to a time before Italians were white.

Speaker: and What this movie is really about, this this is my thesis for the episode, is um Spike Lee telling the story of how Italians became white um in the mid-70s.

Speaker: And their own confusing, conflicted attitude about that transformation, about entering something like mainstream American society, which really did not happen until the 70s, at least not in not in New York.

Speaker: Spike Lee seems to be very explicit about depicting the main characters as sort of white ethnic oh in the proper sense, right? like um And the clash between that culture and what might be called wasp culture. i think there's the bit at the beginning where is it Ruby who becomes Richie's girlfriend, is in a sports car with a guy in like a polo with a kind of very clipped New England accent.

Speaker: um And yeah, like what perfectly encapsulates that that meeting of the two sort of cultures. Yeah. And they chase him away, right? Yeah. He shows up in like the... He calls them spics or something, right? It's a Dago Wap, I believe, is thego what yeah is the term. of i Now, you know I am 25% Sicilian, so I self-identify in that way. you know That's going to my Twitter handle when this episode comes out. yeah Well, I was going to say, i I am talking to and talking to two Is that correct? Yeah.

Speaker: ah Certainly, qualified as my name being Chase Paduzniak, but yeah, on one side. And John, i I assume, yeah, your background is both kind of ah Balkan and Italian, if I remember correctly. Yeah, Italian on my father's side and Yugoslavian on my mother's side.

Speaker: My mom was an immigrant. She came over in the 60s from the former Yugoslavia, from Croatia. And my father was a um third-generation Italian-American. think his grandfather came over in, um, the late 19th century.

Speaker: my dad, this is an important part of New York city, um, New York city history. His grandfather, my, my dad's grandfather was a, um, a billboard painter and he painted the the copper tone girl like that, did you know, like ah like the the baby with the crab is pulling at the, the bikini bottom.

Speaker: You know what I'm talking about? They don't need anything related to tanning. and the there's really I don't think that's ah that's a big business for them. They're kind of happy with the pallor they have. Here's ah maybe the question.

Speaker: Maybe we could say a little bit about what the son of Sam is or who he is and what the kind of actual historical events behind the film are. Yeah, so the film plays a little bit with the um sequence of events.

Speaker: um The murders of the actual son of Sam killings didn't all take place in one summer. They took place over several years, and um the order is mixed up in the film. So I think a good place to start is to just give the timeline of Berkowitz's life up to his rest, partially for clarity,

Speaker: of the film because I think a lot of people watching it in the 90s would have had living memory of the events. It would have happened only 15 years earlier, right? I grew up hearing people, you know, they would tell stories like, oh, I was a few streets away when this killing, had you know, a lot of like location in terms of the killings. It was very like psychically important to people. Yeah, it's it's it's landmarks, you know, like, I mean, the neighborhoods, of nobody had ever heard of this neighborhood before. I mean, is it kind of like equivalent to something like the Maul's murders, Mara Hinley, or the Red West in the UK? It's like that kind of level of um press.

Speaker: In New York City lore, it's roughly as important as the Yorkshire Ripper, I think. He's probably the most famous um serial killer... to come out of New York city proper.

Speaker: Um, I'm kind of a true crime buff, so I shouldn't, take I shouldn't like let my really you know nasty part of myself come out on this, but like I found, I find this understand extremely interesting now because of his life trajectory, which is both like, and unlike a lot of other famous serial killers.

Speaker: So he's, Maybe I could just go into like the full story. Yeah, please. so yeah So Berkowitz, he's born in 1953, so he's like a late boomer.

Speaker: right but where's the Where's the boomer Gen X cutoff? So I think usually it's given around 65. So it's like you're a really late boomer if you're born. Like my in-laws were born in the very early 60s. I would say culturally, like this is the thing about these categories. Obviously, they're they're fluid.

Speaker: I would say if you're born in the early 60s, even if like generationally, you're technically a boomer in the way we've broken these things up. You start to take on a lot of these traits. Like, you know, if you're one of these guys who's in REM or, you know one of these kind of 80s Gen X mainstay bands, the guy from Perubu just died actually, who I think is around that same age. yeah These are, to me, if not Gen X technically, they're sort of culturally a very influential.

Speaker: There's like a Gen X vanguard, essentially, as it's a thesis, right? Like if you look at the members of the Smiths or Joy Division, they're all born in the fifth well late, early 60s. They're incredibly Gen X in some ways, right?

Speaker: Whereas Berkowitz is, yeah, if he's 53, I mean, he is not like the earliest. you know It's not like he's born as soon as the GIs get home. But he's listening to Led Zeppelin, not to Michael Stipe, you know, like at the end of the day, probably. yeah I mean, he was in prison by that point anyway. but Yeah, no, that's actually extremely helpful. Yeah, no, I guess I had never...

Speaker: I don't think of 60s babies as boomers, but it does it does make a lot of sense. no So he's born 53. He's born Richard David Falco to a single mother who immediately gives him up for adoption.

Speaker: He's adopted very quickly by a middle-aged Jewish couple, and they change his name to David Berkowitz. And this is the name that he lives with. This is the name that he's that he thinks is his name. He doesn't know that he was adopted for like many, many years later. And there are theories that his psychotic break was actually caused by realizing that he was adopted. oh um I don't have any particular opinion about that. But um it is important to the Berkowitz lore.

Speaker: So he grows up in the sort of South Central Bronx and like various Jewish enclave neighborhoods, um which like along the Concourse,

Speaker: not in the Northwest Bronx, which is now the primary Jewish area in the borough, but more in the South. And when he's 14, two things happen. His adopted mother dies.

Speaker: um So he's alone with his adopted father and a series of girlfriends that he resents. And he moves with his adopted father to the under construction housing development co-op city. um Do you know what co-op city he is, Chase?

Speaker: I've heard of it, but no, I mean, I'm guessing it's ah one of these large, like mid-century developments, yeah you know, like a sty town or something. Yeah, it's it's a lot like sty town. I don't know which came first, but it is, it looks like sty town. It is a um neighborhood in the North Bronx, right on the border with Westchester, composed of like, you know, several dozen, if you know, less than a hundred, but more than 50 high rise project style apartment buildings. Yeah.

Speaker: Still exists, assume. It still exists, yeah. but It was built on marshland. It was in a landfill. So it's the there are very high cancer rates in that area.

Speaker: It is separated from the rest of the city, not just by physically, but also like transit does not really go there. There are buses that go in and out, but there's no train line. There's no Metro North line. And there would have been even less when Berkowitz was growing up. It was construction began 66 and was not finished until 73. He moved there in 67.

Speaker: They were one of the first families to live in this massive under construction, radioactive like landfill neighborhood that was completely disconnected from the rest of the city.

Speaker: It's like a comic book origin story for, you know, like yeah you fall into the radioactive swamp and you come out as David Berkowitz and you go in Falco, you come out Berkowitz. Yeah. So there's definitely, ah there's definitely a comic book factor to it. Yeah. I mean, and in the golden age of comic books.

Speaker: So he grows up there in this sort of four room apartment with his adopted middle-aged adopted father. He resents it. He is a bright kid, but he's very disinterested in school and stuff. And at 17 in 1971, he volunteers for the army um before he turns 18.

Speaker: So what does it mean to join to volunteer for the army in 1971? This is after the Tet Offensive. this is Things are not going well in Vietnam. this when they're all addicted to heroin. I mean, you know, this is like chief, you know, we're all just smoking weed and fragging the officers because we're all conscripts moment.

Speaker: Exactly. Things are, and he actually doesn't get sent to Nam. He spends most of his um time in Korea. He's actually stationed at Fort Knox for a while, which has led some weirdo conspiracy theorists to think that he was. He has the gold. The gold that's not there anymore is in David Berkowitz possession. Yeah. so Exactly. Yeah. No, it's.

Speaker: ah Steve, you know this conspiracy theory that I'd not to... Yeah, there's not it's so like a right-wing conspiracy theory that there's not as much gold in ThoughtWorks as they say there is. Yeah, they're like siphoning it off because I guess since gold is the real value thing... This is very this is very relevant, right? Because Nixon uncouples the dollar from the gold standard around a few years before.

Speaker: Exactly. yeah And this is precisely what leads to, I mean, if it was a Thomas Pynchon novel, it would be perfect, right? This is the decoupling of the dollar leads to the runaway inflation of the seventies, which leads to the decline, the quote unquote decline of New York city, um the bankruptcy of New York city in the mid seventies that happened during the killings. I mean, it's a really like, it's sort of, he has main character energy in a lot of ways. Like kind of like evil Forrest Gump.

Speaker: Yeah. And he joins for a few reasons. He has, by the time he's a teenager, been arrested for, i don't know if he was ever charged, but he was at least like booked and taken in and dealt with for petty crimes.

Speaker: Arson being the main one. He loves setting fires. And in some ways, his legacy, the actual damage he did is much more connected to the arson. he It's estimated that he set over 2,000 fires in the Bronx over the course of his life. My God.

Speaker: So the body count of those acts is inestimably higher probably than the actual shootings. But it's also important to note that he attended Columbus High School in the Bronx with my dad. And may or may not have been bullied by my dad. Want to thank your dad for his service. Exactly. Yeah, I know. Creating content left and right. But he um he was bullied for being Jewish. He was bullied for being, I assume, David fucking Berkowitz. you know like you It's not like he was normal then either.

Speaker: So he develops this kind of resentment. He takes it out on animals, on buildings, on you know, by committing these petty crimes, by kind of distancing himself from his family and so on. He joins the army, spends four years in the army. um He's, I don't believe he has any issues there necessarily. Nobody really picks up on the psycho stuff, but he comes back in 71.

Speaker: After four years, he, he, he immediately starts setting fires again. After he's arrested, later on, they find three stenographer's notebooks filled with the dates, times, locations, and you know clippings of reports about the fires that he set.

Speaker: oh And so like the Bronx's burning stuff in the mid-70s, a good portion of that was literally David Berkowitz's setting warehouses and abandoned buildings on fire.

Speaker: like He was a major contributor to the destruction of the South Bronx. um And this goes completely unremarked. yeah know I just i want to maybe we should clarify what that's about because it does kind of fit into, especially a Spike Lee movie. I mean, I'm not an expert, but Sam, maybe you know. The kind of Bronx is on fire narrative is part of this broader notion that basically as New York City became less white ethnic and as you know white flight started taking hold, that kind of like black people couldn't take care of the city, that they were sort of destroying yeah the the place itself. So it's it's just an interesting intersection.

Speaker: And this coincides with like Robert Moses, right? And the kind of like the the revamping of the city um and sort of the birth of hip hop at the same time in the Bronx, right? It's kind of like late 70s.

Speaker: Yeah, that is a famous story. So like what happens in the mid seventy s after the Moses reconstruction of the city cuts off a lot of these neighborhoods in the South Bronx from the rest of from the rest of New York, property values tank and a lot of the buildings are abandoned. So there's entire, you know, basically empty apartment blocks, empty warehouses, empty garages in the South Bronx.

Speaker: i'm I'm currently living in but in Birmingham in the UK, which is, this is all very resonant now for the city I'm currently living in, which is cut into like tiny fragments by railway, like railway developments and like just abandoned warehouses everywhere. So it's, yeah.

Speaker: Yeah. it's It's the physical separation that does it. So like yeah when all of those values have tanked, Part of it is accidental fires just because they're shitty buildings. They're mostly made of wood and stuff. Part of it is landlords and insurance fraud. And a big part of it is arsonists.

Speaker: But mostly not local arsonists burning down their own neighborhoods as as it is reported, but like outside figures like Berkowitz and like who knows how many others who are going down there and who just like it. I mean, like arson is a...

Speaker: It's an epidemic. and It's like Disneyland for them. I'm not to, you know, not just like, I mean, imagine you love setting fires. There's a neighborhood people are not living in full of combustible buildings. You know, i mean, come on.

Speaker: Yeah, exactly. So while he's doing that, and these are sort of his, that's the point of major escalation in his crimes. He gets a job as a cab driver in Co-op City, which is necessary because as I said, and there's not really public transit, which is just an interesting little historical tidbit. And he becomes a postal worker.

Speaker: One more fun fact, guess who else was a postal worker in Co-op City in the mid-70s? My dad. Yet again, he could have stopped this if he had just bullied this man a little harder. I fully believe that.

Speaker: um So I don't believe my dad knew him at this time, but um it is just a kind of amazing, I'm fascinated by this amazing like- You picked the right movie. I did. um So 75 is when the killing starts. um the The Spike Lee film starts and is takes place entirely in the summer of 77, which is actually the third year of the crime spree and the last year. But in reality, the crimes are spread out across 75, 76, 77.

Speaker: 75, we're just roll through a bunch of names and a bunch of dates um just to give a sense of the scope of what he's doing and the um geography of it. So 75, he stabs two women in co-op city with a hunting knife.

Speaker: Both of them survive. He does this like, you know, a couple blocks from his own apartment. It's reported a little bit, but it's not really, you know, this is 1975 New York City. There's 10 murders a week or 10 murders a day. Like, you know, it's not of particular importance.

Speaker: Interest. Nobody goes looking for him. Nobody ever finds him. um It's not connected to him until much, much later where he basically says, oh, yeah, also, by the way, I killed those two girls and or didn't kill. I stabbed those two girls in 75. So it's one of the one of those stories that we only know because he told us.

Speaker: So somewhere around this time, he starts having schizophrenic delusions that his neighbor's dog is talking to him and telling him to kill people um and to sort of give their blood to Satan or whatever. Like there's a various forms of this, his sort of personal mythology that emerged, but that's the basic one is that the dog is telling him to do these things, and he feels that he has to.

Speaker: This is a story that he sticks with throughout his life, after his arrest. This is a story that people have picked up on. This is story that's well reported. And i think, based on everything we know about him, we have every reason to believe that he does actually believe this.

Speaker: And it's in the movie. It's in the movie, yeah. And you know it's if it's in the movie, it has to be true. like i mean but he but but like By all accounts, like he does actually believe this. So that's the source of the delusion.

Speaker: Or not the source the delusion, that is the um the sort of central delusion that's driving everything else. July seventy six He commits the first sort of classic son of Sam murder. um He finds a couple, Donna Loria and Jody Valenti. There are a lot of great names in this story.

Speaker: And these are just the first two. um He shoots them in a lover's lane in Pelham Bay, about three minutes from the house I grew up in a location that my parents, who were had just begun dating at this time, oh my god were known to frequent. So there's that.

Speaker: um And this is in the Pelham Bay neighborhood. And this is where most of the events of the Summer Sam film take place. Loria dies instantly, but Valenti survives and gives some descriptions and so on.

Speaker: There's no connection made. Nobody's found, no suspects, et cetera. um The police kind of move on from it. In October of 76, he shoots Carl De Naro and Rosemary Keenan in Flushing, also in a car.

Speaker: Both of them survive. There's no connection made between this and the Lauria killing because they occurred in different precincts. so New York City, I don't know how it works in England, but in New York City, police precincts are separated by neighborhood. Those precincts famously do not talk to each other very much.

Speaker: And this is how a lot of... things tend to slip through the cracks in this period in the city's history. November 76, he shoots Donna DeMassi and Joanne Lamino in Laurel Park, Long Island, which is a um so unincorporated community just outside of Queens. So he drives out into the island and...

Speaker: Shoots them in a park. They both survive, but Lamino is paralyzed. They give a description. The description does not match any of the other descriptions of the killer. there iss no can Again, there is no connection made between this and the other murder and the other murders and attempted murders.

Speaker: And frankly, it confuses people further because the sketch just looks nothing like Berkowitz. It's a tall, thin blonde man and not a short, pudgy brunette with curly hair.

Speaker: 77 January, he shoots Christine Freund and John Deal in Forest Hills, Queens, which is ah um and a sort of a middle class, upper middle class neighborhood in Queens. Freund dies. At this point, the NYPD announces the connections between the various shootings. And at this point, it's when they realize that all of these people have been killed with the same gun, um which is famously a.44 caliber, a Dirty Harry gun, but also...

Speaker: you know, a gigantic blow your head off type gun. It's kind of amazing that he didn't manage to kill more people with it, considering that it's a 44 Magnum. I don't know anything about guns, but this is like a large object.

Speaker: Yeah. So at this point, there are rumors that begin to circulate that these killings are connected. It's not the widespread panic that'll become in 77, but it's the beginning of that.

Speaker: So in March of 77, he shoots Virginia Voskarichian, who's walking home also in Forest Hills, a few blocks from the last, from the Freund and Diehl killing.

Speaker: And the next day, Mayor Abraham Beam, goes on the news and announces that the same gun was used to kill Voscarich and Donald Loria. He gets the name, um the 45, the 44 killer. And the story goes global, which reported all over the world. It's probably the biggest serial killer story since Bundy.

Speaker: So you get that in April of 77, the, We get, this is the killing that starts the film and of Summer of Sam is the April 77 killing of alex Alexander Esau and Valentina Suriani, who are shot on a service road in Pelham Bay, either, I think, after going to a nightclub, like a nightclub very much like the one that is depicted in the film.

Speaker: Which is importantly back in the Bronx. Which is back in the Bronx, yeah. He goes back to the same neighborhood that he killed Donaloria. They're both shot in the head. They both die instantly. It's the only like like truly successful, quote unquote, murder that he um commits.

Speaker: And this is when he leaves the note. So he is, at this point, he knows that they know that these murders are connected. And he is reaching out to...

Speaker: the NYPD into the New York post to claim them. Um, and he leaves the famous first son of Sam letter, which is depicted in the film. Um, yeah, at this point you get mass hysteria.

Speaker: I mean, like things start rolling very quickly. The letters are printed in the post, the daily news, New York times, every, you know, they're translated into every spoken language in the world. Like everybody has their eyes glued to this. And also at this point,

Speaker: There is a connection that people draw between the victims themselves, who are all, almost all, I guess at this point, um young women with shoulder-length brown hair. And this is depicted in the film that you get this moment in New York City where...

Speaker: you know thousands and thousands of women are having their hair cut. My mom, actually, this summer um had her hair cut like up to here. she you know She went from shoulder length ear length hair, and she kept that for the rest of her life because she is... she You don't know. Maybe there was another guy. You've got to be sure.

Speaker: Did she dye it blonde too? Because that's the other thing, right, is this idea that blondness is protection. yeah Oh, yeah. I guess I hadn't thought of that stylistically, but no, she didn't. My mother did not.

Speaker: But that is like a common thing that a lot of people did. And it's actually- see it in the movie. She dies, I'm blanking on the name of the character, but kind of dies her hair blonde, presumably as a way of protecting herself, which I think, and we'll get into this later, but fits into this idea maybe that you can kind of like whiten yourself for protection in certain way by sort of going blonde. Yeah.

Speaker: Yeah, and of course, like it's another um gesture towards, on some level, the collective unconscious is recognizing that These murders are being committed mostly on white ethnics of one kind or another. Either there's a few Hispanic victims, but for the most part, it's Italians and Germans.

Speaker: So like white ethnic groups. In May 77, he writes the famous hello from the gutters of NYC letter to Jimmy Breslin and calls himself the son of Sam. He's one of the few, you know, him and Jack the Ripper are probably the only two serial killers ever name themselves. Yeah.

Speaker: He's, and he's clearly enjoying the um notoriety. Like he is treating this very much like a game. In July of 77, he shoots Salvatore Lupo and juy Judy Placido in Bayside, Queens, which is an area um in Northern Queens towards Long Island. So sort of, um again, a very marginal neighborhood of New York City, very difficult to reach any way by anyway besides by car.

Speaker: He in July 13th, you get the great blackout and the subsequent looting and riots during which about two billion in property damage are committed. Hundreds of people are injured. um Buildings are burned down all over the city, et cetera, et cetera. It's just this moment where it really does feel to a lot of people who were there, like as my. um my New York family have said, like, it really felt like the fucking world was falling apart. Like, you know, nobody knew it It felt like this was the last days of New York city. Um, we should come back to that. Cause you, you could say that that's essentially the theme of the, of the film. And if we want to think about it generationally, yeah there's a way in which I think it's interesting to think about Gen X as a generation that,

Speaker: comes up both in the moment when it seems like America is going to die, you know, whether because of the stagflation we might very soon get to experience again, or then in the sort of roaring 80s where you have this amoral or even immoral recovery from that brink of supposed destruction um that obviously is not the the isn't in the ambit of the movie, but we know lies right on the other side of of the events. Yeah.

Speaker: Yeah, and and there's absolutely that quality of the film, too, where like it's constantly saying, like but things are going to change. like this is a sort of like it recognize The film recognizes itself as this transitional moment, I think, really.

Speaker: and I think Spike gets some really interesting effects out of that um because we know... Sorry, were going to say something, Sam? I'm sorry. Yeah, I just think in terms of the late 70s, right, it's this real transition between a kind of the end sort of ebbs of the New Deal order of America and the sort of beginning of neoliberalism. Yeah.

Speaker: yeah It's sort of like an interregnament in that way between these two eras. And I suppose for Gen X, who are like looking back on this era from the ninety s it's kind of like what the oldest of them would have been about 12 or 13. Yeah.

Speaker: Yeah, it's an interesting film in the sense that the adults at the time would have understood that something political was changing. But for someone who's 12, 13 at the time, it's much more, sort of to use lack a better term, vibes-based.

Speaker: Yeah. And the film is quite vibes-based in that way. It doesn't really give you the specifics of what what the interregnum is and whats what's being lost and what's what's changing. It's also a film about um frame of reference and how limited various frames of reference are and what happens when you live within those limits.

Speaker: I think that should be the first thing we talk about once we get through this. We're almost done. Sorry. No, no, it's good. I do think it's important for people to understand. because it you know and i will give you i we We will finish, but I do think it's important because Berkowitz, unlike ah a Bundy or Dahmer or one of these maybe more famous American serial killers in a way, these are kind of national figures who become famous either for the terrifying nature of their crimes, because of their mobility, ah or because of, in Ted Bundy's case, his perceived kind of attractiveness and um his allure, basically. But Berkowitz is this peculiarly

Speaker: New York killer. I mean, it isn't to say that the story doesn't become more famous, but the the nature the the terror caused is highly localized in a way that I think leads him to maybe be forgotten by people who are not you know still living in a certain kind of shadow of the case. so it's it's Most people may not actually know what the crimes in the background are.

Speaker: Yeah, no, and it's you know it's important to remember, too, that like there these are, i mean, it's hard to imagine that they're not sexually motivated on some level, but they're not the kind of like very grotesque kind of torture crimes at the other that say... More like a Zodiac. I mean, if you want to give a comparison, yeah. Yeah, it is yeah no, exactly. like It seems that he is doing this sort of for the love of the game, so to speak.

Speaker: So seventy seven July 77, he shoots Stacey Moskowitz and Robert Violante in Bath Beach, which is a neighborhood in deep South Brooklyn I have never heard of before. like I've never heard of it.

Speaker: Yeah, it is it's sort I think it's either south or north of Brighton. i It's about as far south Brooklyn as Pelham Bay as north is the North Bronx. um So again, it's a kind of ah an enclave neighborhood. um He probably went there to avoid the dragnet that's been established in the Bronx in Queens. Oh yeah, that makes sense.

Speaker: And in 77, he's caught in Yonkers in his apartment based on a parking ticket that was written for him um at the scene of the Moskowitz-Violani shooting. Like they somehow, I don't know the details exactly, but he gets a parking ticket because he visits the scene after he does the shooting and they find him.

Speaker: They go to his house. He basically cops everything immediately. They find the arson notebooks and he is taken to, it happens not exactly in the way that the film portrays it. It's not like this kind of rock concert vibe where like you have just these massive, massive crowds of people waiting for him, you like in Times Square, like to catch a glimpse, but it is a kind of a huge media sensation. The,

Speaker: photographs of him are not taken until several days later when reporter manages to sneak a camera in and to the cell and takes a very blurry picture of him kind of like laying on his side in bed like but there's a this obsession with his image of like we want to see the killer we want to see him and he is to this day i think one of the more striking one of the more striking mugshots in true crime history. Partially, of course, because of like the kind of the white ethnic quality of it. He really is a distinct-looking figure in a very particular way. He looks like a fucking mailman. He looks like a

Speaker: you know he looks like a New Yorker of that. Exactly. And he talks like one. And you watch like the the footage from this stuff. There's this one amazing... um It's not in the ah the Spike Lee film, but it's this amazing like real interview that they did with people on the street in Pelham Bay like in the 70s. When they catch this guy, what do you think they should do with him? And just somebody goes like I think he should be tortured!

Speaker: Tortured! It's these... And this is what's so... and this is what's so I think this, to me anyway, is what kind of brings me, makes me interested in this story, is the that that the connection to a kind of almost simulacrum-y type of New York. because even Because in the film, and the film gets this very right, that the 90s are being nostalgic for this moment in the 70s.

Speaker: The characters in the film in the 70s are being nostalgic for another even earlier moment in the 50s for a kind of normative... They want to fit in more securely to sort of normative American society. And they have these what I would call almost screen memories or false memories of what it was like to be you know living in like these neighborhoods in the nineteen forty s and fifty s um it it Maybe we can relate this to... So first of all, thank you for that because i i you know frankly, it's good to hear the names. that They sound like people that like you know could be living in my town right now for the most part. um But I think maybe we can relate that to what Sam was talking about, maybe bring some of these threads together as we dig into the film itself.

Speaker: And that's that they're nostalgic both for a moment of lack of recognition in a way, this kind of pre pre-white Italian-ness, and at the same time for a moment when you know New York was not about to declare bankruptcy, a moment when you know there was a lot of building happening because of you know all the GIs are coming home, there's all this money flowing in, there's um you know Robert Moses hasn't remade the city in his image just yet.

Speaker: It's still the New York of um you know of ethnic whites living in Manhattan, for example, which is not really a thing that exists in in the same way anymore.

Speaker: it's It's a movie that shows this nostalgia both, I think, for an economic model that is gone and for a certain kind of like psychogeographical model that is related to but is not coterminous with that economic model.

Speaker: it's just telling that I think the first episode of the Sopranos comes out the same year, right? In 1999. Yeah. the The first episode of the Sopranos, 1999, Tony Soprano. You have, it I just feel like a, what is the exact quote? Do you know it?

Speaker: I was born after the good times. Oh yeah. Uh, Oh, it's like the it's literally the equivalent of that like Twitter meme that goes around where it's like, born too late to experience you know the the the Super Nintendo, born too early to experience, you know I don't know, Roblox, born just in time to play. Born too late to to deploy to the Middle East, born too early to deploy to the Middle East, born at exactly the right time to deploy to the Middle East.

Speaker: ah but No, but I'm just, The Sopranos coming out the same year is interesting because that's very much a film about Italian-Americans sort of striving for ah sort of suburban whiteness, and you know, obsession with the daughter going to an Ivy League or Georgetown and this big suburban house in suburban New Jersey.

Speaker: And then at the same time, you've got this film that's very much about like urban Italian life coming out at the exact same time. Even in The Sopranos, there's a a deep nostalgia for the 70s and for Tony Soprano's father and the neighbourhoods of, I suppose it would have been, yeah, 60s, 70s, right? Tony Soprano's youth. um And I want yeah wonder what that so this says about Italian-American Gen X. Yeah, I think there's It's this weird give and take

Speaker: Right. So one of the things that's particularly, I think, amusing about the film, and I think is what Spike Lee gets absolutely right about these sorts of neighborhoods, is the fact that you get um Joey T, the drug dealer, and his like little cohort. You got Joey T, you got the the heroin addict guy who sells lobsters that he's found. You've got the Goon Squad, you know, the Goon Squad characters that they, you know...

Speaker: How do I say this? Like, they're like, no, somebody was killed in this neighborhood. Ha, must've, must've been somebody from this neighborhood. Who do you, who do we know? And then they go to the peace place and they're discussing this. Like, who do, and it's like, I know you. And it's like, no, not us, dummy. Like, who else do we know? it's like, oh, i know Bobby. It could be Bobby. Like, and it's that kind of thing. it's played for laughs, then it's sustained, right? like Then they actually do bo start to believe their own bullshit, probably because they're just fucking popping lewds and doing coke all the time. say like They will believe their own kind of paranoia, but it's also about the frame of reference, right? like this It's hard for them to imagine anybody living anywhere else.

Speaker: but like This is your whole world, and in these neighborhoods, it is your whole world because there's no reason to go to to go to Manhattan unless you're you know, trying to kick the shit out of, you know, Adrian Brody outside CBG. So two things that need to be said about this. One is of course that for those who have not seen the movie, you need to see it. Cause I, I hadn't until this and it was phenomenal. i say One is of course that to clarify, Adrian Brody is this character from the neighborhood who's basically become a punk. He's speaking in this faux British accent, which the second I heard that I was like, I don't know if we've made a terrible mistake making Sam watch this or not. was like, Deeply, deeply insulted. i so the american Every fake British accent is like a weird sort of amalgamation of Cockney and like RP posh. is there you are You're spot on in terms of ah what I know I do when I try to do my fake Bob Hoskins. I mean, it feeds into this narrative about the ethnic whiteness and the sort of the wasp horizon, right? Like that even in his in his own way, Richie is sort of reaching for that.

Speaker: So, yeah, yeah. So, right, right. To the point. the the The story I want to say real quick is just when they go and they're trying to find the Adrian Brody character who's going to CBGB's and he's like, they're suspecting that he might be the son of Sam because, of course, he's from the neighborhood, but he's also this weird kind of boundary transgressor, both culturally and physically because he's going to Manhattan to go to CBGB's.

Speaker: And there's a great moment where they run into this punk on the street, these kind of mob-looking Italian-American guys. And, you know, i i think, you know, it probably calls him a WAP or something. I can't, calls him a Guido. That's what it is. yeah And he says, I'll give you another chance.

Speaker: Who's your favorite baseball team? And the guy says, the Red Sox. And then they just start beating the shit out of him. I just, I love that scene because it's, it's like, it's literally, you know, the the sports identity is more important than the ethnic slur, which is just, ah you know, probably true, honestly, to the It's it's incredibly like resonant to me. i mean if Other films at the time set in the same kind of class position like Trainspotting.

Speaker: In the second one, and there's a bit where they are the Irish Catholic protagonists stumble upon a Protestant Rangers club and you have to sort of pretend to be virulently anti-Catholic for about half an hour.

Speaker: There's real joke about Glasgow's and Rangers fans where like yeah ah you know you're you're cornered by a Rangers fan in Drum Chapel in Glasgow and then it goes, are you Catholic are you Protestant? And you kind of go, oh, I'm an atheist. And he goes, are you an atheist Catholic or a Protestant? So it's that kind of like incredible like fantasy of small difference sort of.

Speaker: But yeah, I feel like everyone who's ever told me that joke has been Gen X. ah no So this was the point I was going to get to is you're talking about the way that these like psychic realities kind of end up. Why would you imagine anyone being from outside the neighborhood if, you know, if you don't have to basically, you Yeah, but also the idea of subcultures, right? This is a very subculturally different film. Oh, I want to go there. But I just... Yeah, this brief thing about the psychobiography. I think it's interesting because there is, I think, a meaningful sense in which Gen X... And this is not part of the movie because movie comes out early enough that this isn't something people would been thinking about necessarily. But they are kind of the last generation to really get pre-internet world and a world in which your horizons really... could be limited by the place you're growing up simply because, mean, what, you're going to read a zine that gets put out at the nearest state university? There are real media-based limits on how far you can think. Even right at the end of the film, that's very much the point that's made there, where the sort of

Speaker: the sort of the I don't know what you want to call them like the gang members the sort of junior mafioso guys go to beat the shit out of Richie and it's only when the stepdad comes up with Luger that they're informed that the some of Sam killers have been caught because there's no 24 hour news there's no they haven't read a newspaper they haven't seen a TV in the last five hours That's a very good point.

Speaker: It's like people make the joke about less than zero. you know If they had fucking cell phones, this thing would be over in 15 minutes. like all this We could have avoided all this. like It's definitely that. And i you do wonder. I mean, I do actually think that Spike is playing with that because it's 99. We're getting there. We're getting we're getting to the... We're a few years off the dot-com crash. I mean, it's it's closer to that than...

Speaker: Well, I guess what I mean what i mean is like I even technically I'm like a – okay, I'm just going to admit it here on the podcast for the first time. i am a millennial. I'm not very happy. not very upset about it. But no, I mean, but I'm a late enough born millennial that, you know, i I remember a world without the internet, of course. But, you know, by the time I'm a teenager and by the time i'm in college, certainly smartphones are ubiquitous. And so I have a memory of this world. You know, computers were always there, even in my very boomer-fied household. But if you're born in 1965,

Speaker: unless you go into a very particular industry, are not going to have to look at a computer until you're probably in your mid-20s to thirty s you know, really. And that means it's, i don't want to say easier, but you can see why it is.

Speaker: i'll give you an example. I was out Knights of Columbus last night. I think I mentioned earlier in the ah in the show, maybe it was before. And I'm there with people from my hometown and the names that they're able to just sort of like rattle off,

Speaker: Guys who, you know, played Little League baseball in the mid-1980s, who, you know, then someone will say, oh, yeah, I heard he's living in Kenilworth now. And, you know, he's married to this lady who's the but you know sister of this guy. And, like, that sense of neighborhood or town that exists in part because that is the horizon of the world, which is the flip side, right, of the kind of punk desire to escape the hermetic unsealed dome of the small town, the small neighborhood. And that's where the Ritchie character maybe comes in that we were mentioned earlier.

Speaker: Yeah, and the um and the the aggressive rejection of outsiders, you know, and I mean like, like and of insiders who become outsiders, e etc.

Speaker: i mean, that's a shadow, right? Like the... the cop the The cop that's sort of berated by the Mafia Don for not asking permission to become a cop right at the start of the film. You'd have made a brilliant Mafia member and why have you become a cop? And it's kind of that, yeah, sort of like suspicion of this guy who's got one foot in two worlds. Well, foot in one world, one foot in the other. um And then what diffuses that what diffuses that encounter? More baseball arguments. Yeah. Yeah. And racially charged baseball.

Speaker: Who's better, like Reggie Jackson or Mickey Mantle? Can we talk about this? Because I know, John, you're ah a man who who knows a good deal about baseball. There is this theme that runs through the movie. There's a joke at one point that Reggie Jackson could be the son of Sam. And the joke is, right, like, you know, when they're they're pointing fingers at all the people from the neighborhood and sort of like, well, may as well be Reggie Jackson. You know, you don't know. You've never seen him. You've never seen him.

Speaker: Spike Lee takes this and and turns it into a kind of a leitmotif throughout the movie where you know you get, I think the news report of his being caught is basically played over Reggie Jackson hitting, I think it's three home runs in the World Series, right? It's one game. So there is this interesting fusion of the New York identity that's produced through baseball,

Speaker: And something about the mindset or the geography that's being produced in the characters in the movie. And I mean, do you have any thoughts about that? I just, I couldn't quite work out exactly what was going on.

Speaker: It's important to know that the New York Yankees were absolute fucking dog shit throughout the 70s or throughout the 60s. Like they were the great days of like...

Speaker: Frankly, like the pre-integration Yankees, um like in the in the imaginary of the average Yankees fan, the good old days were pre-integration, was the years of the 20s, 30s, and early 40s when you had Babe Ruth, when you had like the white teams.

Speaker: And this kid doesn't it get brought up? I think Mickey Mantle comes up at one point, if I remember correctly. Maybe I'm... yeah mar one of One of these sort of classic Yankees, ethnic white baseball players is is brought up.

Speaker: Yeah, no, it's and they have a debate. you know The black cop and the um the mafiosos say, like you know who's who is the best Yankee? And it's like, you know the black cop says Reggie Jackson, who is at the time basically the greatest baseball player on the planet, the biggest star in New York since Babe Ruth.

Speaker: He also plays a very flashy, very kind of like, almost like contemporary style of baseball. Like he he steals aggressively. he like does these hilarious interviews. He fucks with interviewers. He's not the picture of like kind of put your head down and swing.

Speaker: baseball player. Like he's, an and, and this is accentuated by the fact that he is in a very well publicized dispute with his manager at the time, who is a noted racist.

Speaker: And they have like, they just, they just call each, you know, they call each other the N word and they go like, you know, back and forth, like on like sports radio. But it's largely this fact like that you have all of these racist Yankees fans who are like have to cheer for Reggie Jackson for this guy that they all fucking hate. And it's important to note that the, I think that John Leguizamo, who is the main character of the film, we haven't even mentioned him yet.

Speaker: In several scenes, John Leguizamo, he's the only one who's wearing a Reggie Jackson jersey. Oh, I didn't notice this. Okay. spike Which is, um yeah, 44, which is Spike Lee's way of saying he's a friend of the people, I think. Like, that there's a certain kind of, like, um you know, it's a, Reggie functions as almost as a litmus test for the various characters. Like, can they look past, you know, like, like are they so obsessed with race that they can't, you know, et cetera.

Speaker: that's So maybe it's it's worth saying here, well first of all, that Yankees jerseys to this day do not have names on them, right? So there is this general kind of culture among Yankees fans of um professionalism, but with this meaning of sort of like whiteness, I guess you could say. Yeah, absolutely. you know, creating, ah there's the famous Simons episode where Mr. Burns is basically George Steinbrenner and is like, you know, what did I say? Shave no sideburns.

Speaker: That's the Yankees, right? And so a person like Reggie Jackson, who's showy, who's black, who is very good, is challenging this dynamic. But maybe... Talk about John Leguizamo real quick, because he's our he's our main character, more or less.

Speaker: He has this wife who he is constantly cheating on. He is convinced that God has saved him from the son of Sam, and that this is a sign that he should be repenting, and that he should stop cheating on his wife so much.

Speaker: He is also, very importantly, because I think if we want to talk about Gen x a hairdresser. And his wife will use this against him, but I think we forget that in the seventy s and maybe even today you could see a version of this, there's really nothing like sexier than being a straight male hairdresser. like If you've seen Hal Ashby's Shampoo, it's basically just a movie about like the the the man who has the most sex is like a guy who cuts women's hair who wears a shawl unbuttoned like to his belly button.

Speaker: You know what I mean? like That's the hottest a man can be. So he's like... this fusion of the feminine and the masculine in the form of this hyper-masculine, you know, this Bronx guy. But notably shorter than his wife. And like, again, like, this is a theme that's run out, run through the podcast, like Gen X male protagonists being kind of metrosexual or...

Speaker: Yeah, that's an interesting point. I guess that's kind of where I was going to go is he is an interesting representative of like a, don't want to say a non-standard masculinity, but there's an extent. one of the things we've talked about on this podcast a few times now, John, is how different media, whether produced by Gen X or about Gen X or or whatever, are often obsessed with or trying to find ways to deal with quote-unquote traditional masculinity, you know the fifty s kind of husband Yeah.

Speaker: And in this movie, we do get various versions of that. John Leguizamo is this tiny man who tries to do like swinging with his wife. We can go there. You've got Richie, Adrian Brody, who's being a punk. And is you know he has a mohawk at one point. He's got the he's gotten these spikes. And he also is a gay stripper and porn actor, which we have also not spoken about up to this point. And then you've got, what's his name? Bob the Fairy, I think, who is this...

Speaker: local gay man who is kind of within the community, kind of outside of. I think it's interesting to your point, John, where this Bob character is protected insofar as Bob is like ah is is from the area right is like you know But at same time, he's bullied relentlessly.

Speaker: you know yeah you he is he is protect He's protected, and he is you know he's a customer, as as we're told by Joey T a few times. like Leave him alone! He's a paying customer! like And there's a...

Speaker: but But he's not just that. He also, like key like, he goes to the diner with these guys and hangs out. Like, you know, he he's invited to to go beat the shit out of Richie later. You know, like, he is this he occupies this kind of inside-outside quality. like as And I think that the key... would you say I think that the...

Speaker: The key term that kind of ties all these figures together is the term is deviant, which is a word that like Wizzamo uses all the time. He says it um early on to Richie when he's trying to say like, I want to stop cheating on my wife, but like, I can't like, you know, like I can't get off. I need to like have all the, you I like the 69 in and the, thought but and then like, he goes, it's, it's really.

Speaker: you don't You don't have anal sex with your wife. That's not for your wife. like That's an amazing. Yeah. Yeah, no, but he's... I mean, that is... that's that's I find that fascinating, that the kind of like that that we've not got like a fully se secularized kind of subculture or youth culture at this point. and like it there's the The strain of Catholicism is still like really prominent.

Speaker: yeah just kind of Again, it's that kind of interregnum, where it's like, the characters are still nominally Catholic, they sort of still believe in sin, but you know they also want to like have anal sex and do cocaine and swing.

Speaker: They're constantly sort of dancing between these two is two poles, um which is fascinating. Leguizamo says it at one point, like when he's talking to Richie about how he I'm trying to stop cheating on my wife, but I can't help it.

Speaker: Like once you're deviated, you can't go back. um Or he says one, some variation on that a few times, like, and he calls himself a deviant. He calls other people deviants. And I think that that,

Speaker: Formulation is probably the the key one for the film because like it it ties together Richie, Leguizamo, Ruby, and not just them, but also Bob the Fairy and um even like the the the Heroin Addict.

Speaker: It ties together all these figures. as Whereas it doesn't apply to somebody like Joey T, who like is within a recognizable structure. you know he He has a job. He's like, I got to stand at the end of this alleyway and sell and sell you quaaludes. He has respectable job.

Speaker: And I think it becomes a question of legibility because what is... on the minds of a lot of characters is, do I understand why he's doing that or not? Or why this person is acting the way that they are? That is, in the case of the heroin addict, they of course understand it. in even in And even in the case of Bob the fairy, they understand, you know, like,

Speaker: what is motivating. They have a narrative to themselves that can explain this person. They don't understand Richie. He's like, I understand you, you live in the neighborhood, then you left and you come back like this. What is it? Like, you know, like they don't get it.

Speaker: Like, and that is, and I think that that is the key formulation for it. Like they just, they can't psychically, you know, metabolize him as, you know, even though it's not that extreme, like nothing he did. I mean like, okay, like later on the, like some of the, like the gay stripper stuff is pretty intense. Like, you know, like when he, Those guys, yeah. There's an amazing scene where he like stabs the sex doll.

Speaker: Oh, yeah. How about it? Like it's a great classic Spike Lee scene. Anybody hasn't seen the movie? um It's a they play Baba O'Reilly, the um the Who song.

Speaker: And you get this montage of what all these characters are doing, like in the month between um two of the Son of Sam murders. And, you know, you get Leguizamo cheating on his wife. You get, like, people doing drugs. You get people, you know, all you get cuts to the the mafiosos and the cops and everybody and cuts to Berkowitz.

Speaker: And then you get the crescendo of it is um Richie, A.G. and Brody dancing at a gay strip club on stage doing this routine with a big sex doll that he dismembers. yeah um He like cuts it into little pieces and a bunch of feathers fly out and he throws the feathers around. You get this slow motion, very, very Spike Lee stylized shot.

Speaker: Clearly, it's a moment of like self-hatred on Brody's part. yeah like His aggression towards himself, like but it's also a kind of exuberance that kind of I don't... I guess I was wondering what you how you guys read that moment. There was something of the kind of Weimar, Christopher Isherwood style cabaret to it, right? um Which again, like if you see Weimar as this kind of interregnum period or like connotations of decline and sort of um deviance again, right, transfer to 70s New York. and It really gave me the sort of cabaret, sort of, yeah, that vibe off it. Like, and the questions around sort of the idea of like degenerate art propagated by, you know, the far right versus like sexual freedom and the the sort of negotiations between those two poles.

Speaker: Yeah, I mean, I think that even with like the top hat that Michael Imperioli is wearing, right, like, so you this Sopranos crossover. Christopher! Oh, yeah. Did you ah did you know Imperioli wrote the film? Imperioli wrote the film with Spike Lee.

Speaker: No, it's amazing. it it's i i I have to say, I read that moment very much in terms of like a... I feel like fear is at the heart of the movie. I mean, of course, genius. It's called Summer of Sam. Of course, fear is at the heart of the movie. They're all afraid they're going to get killed. But I mean fear even for the characters who are knowingly transgressing. So you take a character like Richie.

Speaker: He is notably less sexual than Ruby, his sort of now girlfriend. like They're deeply in love, but when they first meet, she wants to, I think, basically give him oral sex.

Speaker: And he's like, no no, no, no, no. And she doesn't understand, right? like She's yeah she is confused as to why this man would to have anything to do with her if not for that, because she's notorious, I guess, as this relatively, quote-unquote, loose woman in the neighborhood. Yeah.

Speaker: And even later, it seems to be her who kind of drags him into the world of porn, right? And he's like not that interested. So I i see that moment as this... odd.

Speaker: It's self-hatred. It is exuberance of a certain kind, but i I think it's maybe fear about where the lines end up drawn. like He wants to rebel. he wants to be a punk, but he's still an Italian-American from the Bronx. like you know what i like That doesn't go away just because he cuts his hair. And you see a very similar thing with John Leguizamo's character where they get coked up. They you know end up going to Plato's retreat, with which John, apparently both you and I exuberantly declared to our wives like that was a real sex club that was a real thing wheelpoints yeah a very famous uh you know sort of swinging 70s new york place and they go there and it's this you know for him awful experience it it really leads to the destruction of their marriage which is an important part of the latter part of the film and he realizes

Speaker: that he is afraid of those sexual instincts. And I mean, his reasoning is very stupid, right? Like he brought her there, it's entirely his fault. Like, you know, the level of blame, you know, he has no leg to stand on. But at a psychological level, he is afraid of the forces he has unleashed and that he can't get them back in the box, basically, for the rest of the film. And that leads to his psychic degradation. So I think part of what's interesting to me about the nature of fear in the movie is that it takes seriously...

Speaker: The lack of preparedness for a kind of transgression. And I read Gen X in those terms very often. It's come up on this podcast before where like there's this worship of punk in terms of transgression itself. is Not even as a political phenomenon, but just as a thing that crosses boundaries, that pushes people, that you know makes you think in new ways. yeah But that you know then Gen X says, well, I didn't mean that.

Speaker: And you i obviously we're painting with a large brush here, but I just mean that the downstream of that is then something that the original transgressors are ready for. i mean, Morrissey is like the shining example of this kind of guy, but there there are you know lots of of more minor examples, I think.

Speaker: Yeah, no, it's like when Richie and Ruby perform at CBGB's, they sing the text of the Son of Sam letter. Oh, I didn't catch that. Oh, that's amazing. Hello from the gutters of New York today! They're singing the Son of Sam letter, which in the timeline of the film would have come out about a month before the performance. And so my wife and I are on the couch just like, too soon, guys. This is like... That's too, like, I mean, it's a pretty cool letter, but too soon, you know, but this is like, but there's definitely this aspect of deviation and exuberance and deviation the same time.

Speaker: Like, how do I put this? That's a very clear moment, and there are many moments throughout where Spike Lee encourages us to sort of identify, or has depicts characters identifying with Berkowitz, and and um showing, not saying, oh, aren't we all just David Berkowitz on the inside? like That's not... it' not like He's not that guy, but he's saying like, you know, like they're clearly seeing parts of themselves in this in the same way that say like, you know, how many people afterwards see themselves in a Tyler Durden or in a um De Niro and taxi driver, like, you know, famously certain people saw themselves as De Niro and taxi driver. So it's that that play of identification then that we are then encouraged to also inhabit

Speaker: Yeah, I was just sort of interested in in that subculture question again and the kind of deviance question among, is sort of in line with Gen X. I mean, Really, like Joey T and his the sort of goons, they've really like discussed there's like a visceral disgust when they go to CBGBs, and there's this visceral non-understanding Richie's punk aesthetics. And yet, at the same time, like the way they dress, what you know like the kind of like disco light, I suppose, is an incredibly flamboyant, incredibly feminine, um would probably be seen by their fathers as pretty gay. And yeah they've lived through the hippie movement of 10 years prior.

Speaker: and Yeah, that kind of like alienation from punk. I do. It kind of rang false to me that they would have really reacted in quite that way. Oh, I can i can say something on this. I mean, there's this very famous moment, at least in the United States. I think it's 80 or 81, a little bit later than this. And it's called The Day That Disco Died. It's another baseball moment, actually, funnily enough. Yeah, they blow up the vinyl desk. I think it's 79. Yeah.

Speaker: Yeah, okay, so it's... in yeah yeah so it's just great deie what do yeah It's barely after this, right? And, you know, ah if I may throw out a little thing here, I'm a very big fan of Arthur Russell, who's this, like, New York ah composer, I guess, to the 70s, kind of classically trained, but...

Speaker: cuts his teeth in disco. That's kind of what he's best known for during his lifetime dies of AIDS in 1990 or 1991. Anyway, he's a great example of this kind of person who used disco to cross these ethnic boundaries that he got a lot of a lot of shit, frankly, for doing.

Speaker: So... There's, I think, more... The resistance is greater than we might suspect. And for some reason, specifically between punk rock and disco as this... lake I think disco coded is both too popular, right? like like Kind of the way I might think of Taylor Swift. you know No disrespect. I'm sure the many Swifties will be listening, but not my cup of tea. But then also, it has these associations with...

Speaker: Disco is non-white to a certain extent. That's certainly where Arthur Russell came in for trouble. ah It's it's yeah basically, Coach is gay because of the flamboyance, the disco ball, the the men dancing right in this very like flowy sort of way. And punk is it's masculine, it's destructive, it's rage-filled, and it's maybe most importantly, rock.

Speaker: It's rooted in what has already taken taken root as this kind of like, this is what mut this is this is what white music is, for lack of a better way of putting it. Yeah, in that sense, the punk scene is weirdly conservative, I think. In a way, the disco is not. rling up It's the disco scene that leads to a huge orgy.

Speaker: Yes. It's not yeah not the punks who are having the massive orgy. I think it's interesting because it's it's you're 100% right, but it's also that the popularity of disco makes it the mainstream as much as it is also you know all the all these other things we're talking about. It is the thing that these guys… I just constantly put me mind of Whit Stillman's The Last Days of Disco, which I think came out two or three years prior, i think it's 96, The Last Days of Disco.

Speaker: Gen X, looking back on the disco era and the end of the disco era, so the start of neoliberalism um and the decline of, or questionable decline in New York City. i mean, that film is really about, you know, sort of Ivy League elites finding disco and finding identity in that subculture. And the kind of, their venom against the punk movement as being this kind of reactionary working class blue collar thing.

Speaker: And i want I want to have resonant that actually is to real life. i mean... Well, I want to maybe let's say something about about this question of of sort of New York in the 70s, because we've danced around it. And I think it it does kind of fit in here very, very explicitly, which is New York, some point in the mid-70s, I don't know if it's 77 a little bit earlier, is on the edge of bankruptcy. I mean, it comes very close to basically saying, we don't have the money.

Speaker: And to put things in perspective, I mean, I think Detroit is the biggest city to ever declare bankruptcy. I think that was a couple decades ago at this point. And the one behind that is like, I don't remember if it's Gary. And it's one of these like rust belt cities. So like New York would really just adding to my sense of living in 1970s New York now. Because so long story short, I'm a British city. I'm living in this declared bankruptcy. that yeah Oh, really? Yeah. Oh, gosh. Well, I guess the the point is something we haven't talked about a lot in the movie is that there's this overall sense

Speaker: Not just that things are getting worse, but that the reign of terror of the son of Sam killer is somehow related to the broader world of New York City in 1977. And this really comes out in the blackout riot scene, which John touched on earlier.

Speaker: And I guess I was curious, maybe if you had something to say about this, it's a very odd scene because it's highly racialized. There's a lot of comments about Harlem being you know sort of the um the main location for this rioting. I don't know if that's historically true or not, but certainly that's what's said in the movie.

Speaker: The scene showing it, you have Spike Lee as this reporter who's going around and sort of like, just showing, um you know, basically if a conservative in 2020 like wanted to validate their ideology about like BLM or whatever, they would like post that be like, this is this is the real thing. You know, this is this what's going on. Like it's a very, um it's it's a moment of of taking because it seems like people don't have, but it also is this sense of like a lack of control that like whatever is going on in the city is no longer capable of being bounded by whatever the government is or whoever's in charge.

Speaker: Yeah, no, I think that that sums it up pretty well. And that is really how the, i think the moments of the riots are remembered in among like that generation of New Yorkers, at least in the outer boroughs, many of whom didn't actually experience the riots. Like the riots, well, there's a place not in the, it like not in Pelham Bay and Throgs Neck, but in, you know, in Harlem, in the black neighborhoods, et cetera. And the experience that people had of it was mostly through you know, through the television. Right.

Speaker: And it's this sort of pseudo event for many people. There's the scene... I will say this. I was wondering whether not to tell this story, but I think it is useful. During the riot scene, what struck out the most to me is not even the um the sort of playful, almost Godardian stuff that Spike is doing with like news real newsreel footage, fake newsreel footage, and self-insert stuff. You have somebody say, like like you know he's interviewing this woman, and she's like... like ah you don't like black people, do you? And like, it's this really kind of amazing, you know, like in some ways it almost loses some of its effect because it's almost, he's getting too cute with it.

Speaker: It's spiking guilty of sometimes. um But what struck me is like the moment when you get, you know, Basically, mob rule. And by that, I mean like mafia rule, right? You get this like all the men of the various families get together and they hand out baseball bats to each other and like, we're going to defend our neighborhood. you know It's like, who is coming to your neighborhood? Once again, it's the question of like, well, why wouldn't they come to our neighborhood? Are we not good enough to steal from? like There's really this like, but it's, it's, and and then it becomes, and then it's sort of defused and it becomes this like block party and this yeah ah genuine, like kind of togetherness and like kind of release.

Speaker: And Spike is playing with this dialectic between like the nasty, like lynch mob, like, and it is coded as a lynch mob that is being formed and that then, When they have no object, when there's nobody to lynch, they decide like, okay, like whatever, we'll go, we're going to put a pool in the street and have a, like a block party and, you know, grill some dogs, you know, it's, it's, it's a very, and we, I think in the moment of watching it, you kind of fall for Cause it's like, this is charming. This is old New York. This is like, isn't this nice? But then you realize like, you know, it's made possible by the exclusion, et cetera. The reason I'm bringing this up and to want to talk about is because this

Speaker: continues to exist very much in these white enclave neighborhoods. um So like during the 2020 riots, um and I was living with my grandmother in Pelham Bay, taking care of her during COVID.

Speaker: And there were reports. I remember watching this all unfold like on my computer, you know, you log onto Facebook, And there were reports of while the more intense protests were happening in downtown Manhattan, somebody said on ah in a Facebook post in a local community group, you know, there's ah a group of like black teenagers riding bikes around town and like stabbing white people. And like, we got to protect ourselves. You know, like we got to, and then I was like, that's fucking hard. God, this guy's, I hope that there, I hope this is a pure lie because if not, there's just some fucking 14 year old kid who's going to get killed like for no reason. you know And so I'm watching this unfold and then, you know, an hour later it's like, all right, like everybody, everybody like get together and they like meet actually in front of the night to Columbus. Um,

Speaker: It's as good of a landmark as any, but you know all these guys, and I see like you know phone recording videos of like a bunch of these guys standing outside in Aids of Columbus with baseball bats. I'm strapped, some of them, saying, like all right, like come get us. Pelham Bay Strong. like All this sort of... and like Thankfully, no nothing that I know of ever happened. like there wasn't They didn't actually get together and kick the shit out of anybody. like nothing It was sort of this just this...

Speaker: It was this moment of what was clearly racial reaction of a bunch of people who I think many of them were old enough to have remembered the blackouts. If you are not, you have grown up with the stories. It's an important part of the kind of like white New York unconscious, I think, is the stories of the blackout.

Speaker: And so there's a sense of it where like all of these things are still happening. you know, not much has changed in these neighborhoods. I mean, I was going to say, even in the nineties, right? Like this is in one way, it's a film about many things, but it's it's a film about moral panic isn and moral panics. And the nineties is obviously, you know, you've got the central park five, which is 89, but like going into the nineties, which is great moral panic that feeds into the Clinton movement. And Joan Didion obviously wrote about, you obviously have, um,

Speaker: Marilyn Manson, the video Nasty is more a panic in the UK. There's something like the satanic ritual abuse. Satanic panic, yeah. And the film feels to be feeding off of those sort of contemporary panics, right?

Speaker: Yeah, and this, I think, particular panic, I think it gives... The Son of Sam stuff, the Son of Samurai, um and the satanic panic stuff, I think, really bring to the fore the racial and the sexual aspects of, you know, that are sort of underlie so often other versions of it. um It really makes it explicit. it's I mean, there's even a sort of recovered ah memory. is Is that the term sort of during the satanic panic? There was this kind of recovered memory process, wasn't there, that led to all these people being accused of things?

Speaker: And there's almost a sort of recovered memory scene where um the main character is sort of a bunch of quaalus and coked up and then someone draws a sort of mohawk on the um the the police drawing. He suddenly has this kind of like Freudian, it's from the side of the way, he says, shit, it's Richie.

Speaker: Oh shit it is. That is, but and again, it's it's, that's so Spike too, because it's this, it's like this objectively hilarious moment that is like, that he doesn't allow to just be a joke. Like he then says like, okay, well what?

Speaker: Okay. Like you put a moho on him. It's what fucking, it's tequila. Yeah, it's really, yeah, no, it's, um and of course, like we're talking, there's the other panic that I think is present into the, very much the film, which is the AIDS panic and the AIDS crisis, right? 81 is when the first confirmed cases happen. um This is in New York.

Speaker: One looks at this, and I think Spike wants us to see this, is like, um how many of these people are going to die? Yeah. I think this is part of where the like the film's obsession with anal sex comes from. um There's a disco and swinging in the the various associations there, the gay club, which is again part of a kind of a ah missing New York, a lost New York. Yeah, go on. Yeah, I think the sexual revolution is very much like a Gen X.

Speaker: yeah staple, like my parents are Gen X and they do so tell me about how they were incredibly scared of like sexual encounters or sort of like you know being licentious because of the AIDS crisis.

Speaker: there's this kind of like closing of this window that their parents had. um And then they sort of like missed by like, you know, just a jot. And i think, yeah, that that's very sort of, that thread runs through the film, doesn't it? The kind of, the preemption of AIDS and the kind of like fear of sexuality that's coming back into the, into consciousness after the 60s.

Speaker: What's interesting to me is that in i to frame this in the late 70s, even before AIDS, I think you're already beginning to get this kind of exhaustion of the, um I don't i'm very obsessed with this idea of kind of transgression against a norm that disappears exhausting itself. So I mean, like this this idea that by the late 70s,

Speaker: You know, Plato's retreat has probably been around for, you know, a solid decade and a half or something and is somewhere you can just end up at the end of a night at the disco club. You know, it's like it's you just get invited there by the guy with the camera. It's not maybe not de rigueur, but it just sort of like, well, it happens. And obviously he's not prepared for it because he's not a Manhattanite. But, you know, among the enlightened, it's just another thing that's happening.

Speaker: And so, yes, you have kind of AIDS on the one hand, but it feels like just out of view over here is like, i mean, the killer is not even being sexual. I mean, in the way that you expect from it, you know, this is not like a Michael Mann movie where the, you know, I don't know, he's like putting panties on the wall or something. it's Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker: David Berkowitz is basically just shown in this film, and I did want to ask about this just because i the inclusion of it was a little confusing to me, as kind of just like a freak in a room who's assembling blocks. ah You know, there's not, really, if anything, he's maybe shown to be a little bit like childlike and kind of just like an annoying neighbor, you know, because he yells at his neighbor for his dog's barking.

Speaker: Well, there is that explicit kind of satanic symbol drawn on the wall with like ah a male gender and a female gender sign divided by a sort of backwards cross. this is Oh, I may have missed this. So suppose mirrors that the there couple's in the car.

Speaker: Oh, yeah. that is a um That symbol is a real son of Sam symbol. He signed the second letter with that symbol. um And he was found, um his apartment was actually covered in these sorts of images and like scraps of poetry. and like like It's a pretty accurate description of the apartment itself.

Speaker: um But yeah, know i thought that I thought the weakest parts of the film were the Berkowitz scenes. I did not get it. I did i do love the scene where the dog talks. when yeah that' that Yeah, that was good. Yeah. It's really good. like i think i think it all should have been that instead of the block. But, oh God, but you know, i I think the way to read it is partially by the placement of those scenes. Like when do they occur? And I think what they often, the function that they often serve within the film is to like, he's sort of, he's like screaming, bashing his head against the walls. They occur after moments of um where emotional release by other characters is not allowed to happen.

Speaker: Right. where like things go unsaid. I think the first time he appears is when like it becomes clear to John Leguizamo's wife that John... Yeah, it's like they're they're in the car after he's cheated on her with her cousin, and she smells his fingers, and you get the and that comes out like later It's like, I smelled the pussy juice on your fingers. like you know like You were fucking my cousin. like It's a really... um like But after it's after that moment when a character has a thought and cannot express it that you get the cutaway to Berkowitz. And then he is sort of I think that is how Spike is using it. And it's one of these moments of like, you know, there's a... I think a lot of Spike Lee's films do this where if he has a kind of an overarching ethical vision, it's something like, um there but for the grace of God go I.

Speaker: It's not the worst ethical vision to have, i mean to be honest. No, it's absolutely not. And i think it's a very um I think it's a very New York vision, too. I think that there's something i cosmopolitan about it. yeah you know like It's a picture of Berkowitz as a sick man. He is castrated. like He is not...

Speaker: He's not the monster. he is a sort of like, you know, this flailing bundle of limbs and flesh. He is so ill that he can barely wipe his own ass, it seems like. Yeah.

Speaker: And and that That gesture, it defangs him, and it's in part of it is like, Spike said, aren't we all the real monsters? There's like the stupid guy reading of that, right? like aren't we Weren't we all the son of Sam all along, or wasn't the son of Sam the friends we made along the way? like's there's There's a stupid guy reading of it, but then there's also like a slightly more nuanced re version it.

Speaker: Wherein, i think we're supposed to see him as a sick individual, as not just the sort of perennial outsider, but a kind of like a social failure, for example, you know, nobody's checking up on this fucking guy, like, you know, like what...

Speaker: No, no, it just, it it sounds to me like you're describing him as the unconscious of New York City. Like, you know, whenever any of these characters are unable, you know, when the sort of oppression becomes strong enough and this thing is, you know, forced into, you know, back into the ocean of the real or whatever, that, you know, then we cut to Berkowitz and we see, I guess, uh...

Speaker: you know for lack a better term, this kind of pure libidinal energy, not in the sexual sense, in the you know sort of more broad Freudian sense, that just pops off. And that's when he shows up, right? And in that sense, the killings he's doing are you know it's not that, oh, we're all David Berkowitz. It's that David Berkowitz becomes this way of framing or understanding this broader set of social pressures that are also personal psychological pressures that are occurring in 1977 New York, which links together a lot. I mean we're talking about the blackouts. We're talking about racial tensions. We're talking about the city going bankrupt. We're talking about these kind of subcultural battles that are you know tearing apart these previously community-based groups of people, these neighborhood-based groups of people. And Berkowitz just becomes maybe a way of um

Speaker: you know he's the outsider He's the insider outsider. you know He's from New York, but he's living in Yonkers. He comes back in New York to do the killings. He shows up in the moments when people you know run up against the wall of their own consciousness, and their ability to express themselves.

Speaker: That's what I take you to be saying. I don't know if that's too much. There's very little psychoanalysis or real treatment of intentionality behind Berkowitz. Lee just sort of presents him as this figure who is... It's just, is there, there's so sort of explanation of like, there's no sort of like narrative of trauma or, you know, social alienation. It's just kind of like, did this is sort of alien forces present. um which I kind of appreciate it. Like it's, it's, it feels structural in a way rather than an individual, the violence that he is, he's unleashing.

Speaker: um It's him as like a Travis Bickle character, basically. No, that's what the streets, you know, like, sorry, go ahead, John. I do think Lee is deploying him. I think Lee is definitely thinking about Taxi Driver when he's making this movie. like there are like He is borrowing from the Martin Scorsese playbook.

Speaker: There are scenes that are shot a lot like a Scorsese film, like you know the diner scenes, like the kind of the way that he uses the city. Bob O'Reilly montage. Exactly, right? That is a classic. That is so... And that's very 70s, 80s Scorsese too. like That's a certain era of Scorsese.

Speaker: Yeah, I think, I don't want to say I wish he had made a different film, and I don't want to make any criticisms and make it sound like, oh, I wish this film was completely different. i I do think that the the showing Sam as often and as sort of, in the way that he does, sort of weakened the film for me, took me out of it, kind of. They functioned as, in the same way that he functioned as a release of the unconscious energies of the characters structurally within the film, he also functions to kind of like...

Speaker: take the tension out. It's it's ah it's a release valve. It's almost like we're cutting to commercial. they put a ter Just this terrifying commercial that's like David Berkowitz alone in his apartment. Instead of murder, it's like Colgate. I quite like that in the sense that it's not really a crime thriller. We know that the murderer is from the start. We have his face from the start. like yeah it's the the the kind of The violence he unleashes is quite sort of like structural. It's like the Manson murders in 68, 69, whatever it was. They're sort of epochal in a way.

Speaker: They're sort of... um auxiliary to the actual matter of the fact of the film. like And I don't know, that's a version of the kind of crime thriller, whatever genre, true crime genre, I think was, I kind of deeply appreciated that I think that maybe that's a good way of thinking about it in terms of the 90s. Because, you know, i'm i'm no expert here, but I grew up in a very true crime-centered household, especially with my grandmother. i remember watching like one of these like late 90s, early 2000s police procedural shows. ah I learned what the word rape meant because it was used in the show to be like, Grandma, what does rape mean? You know, i'm like five years old. you know this is This was just on television. i remember I also learned what sodomy meant because a man had been sodomized with a banana, and I had asked my grandmother what that meant as well. So like,

Speaker: you know We're watching The Bone Collector. We're watching these these movies that are usually police procedurals about sickos in the you know capital S sense of guys who are doing these for these ah bizarre psychological reasons that are uncovered. A movie like Seven, which I think is still a pretty good movie, is like maybe in a way the apotheosis of this kind of thing. and I think that's i think very early two thousand s if i remember correctly. Spike Lee's making this at a moment when you're really getting the kickoff of this, maybe you could call it like first wave true crime interest. And it's interesting that he chooses to make a movie that even in the title is very clearly about the force created by someone like Son of Sam and not by about the person, not even about the person covering it. Right? So...

Speaker: Right. And I think that this actually was a the movie. It was not a flop. It actually did make money, but it was it was a disappointing film. And I think part of that is like, you know, Spike Lee's making a movie about white people. Like part of it was that. But also part of it was the fact that it was not a crime film and that people expected it to be a crime film.

Speaker: And it was not. it was a It was what Spike Lee does, which is like a kind of a moral, a satirical moral tale, um which is his preferred mode of operating. And I think that's part of why it's been forgotten um in his um filmography, really, and why it's not usually referenced you know within this framework.

Speaker: Yeah, I mean, it seemed like half-Buildings Roman, half kind of parable in its effect. It's also, it ah you know, it's funny, when you recommended this, i you know as ah any any great intellectual does, I type the name in and see what the you know Rotten Tomatoes score for all it's worth is. It was like bizarrely low. I remember seeing it, and it's like under 50 maybe. And then, you know, that's already kind of shocking because Spike Lee is one of these directors who, you kind of just know you're in for a good ride. I mean, whether or not the film is a failure, it's sort of, he's the kind of guy where you're always at least going to be interested

Speaker: And then I watched it and I, you know, I was kind of just blown away. And I, I can only attribute that to what you're talking about, John, because as a film taken on its own merits, it's this phenomenal portrait of both for me when it's made and the moment that it's talking about. Cause I mean, you could make a bizarre version of this.

Speaker: That's like about the sex in the city version of Manhattan from today's perspective where you're like, you know, Now everybody is is wearing, i don't know, Ralph Lauren shirts all the time, and it's pissing me off, and there's all these brunch spaces, you know, taking over this part of lower Manhattan and in the late 90s, you know, you could you could make $32,000 a year as a secretary and still live in Manhattan. Like, it's legible to me almost in those terms.

Speaker: It's just a very different kind of thing it's reading. But it the the impulse is totally legible. This is important, I think, because like I want to talk a little bit about the economy of the film, too. like I mean, in the sense of, like what do these fucking people do all day?

Speaker: like yeah yeah Yeah. I mean, like we got one guy with a job. like As far as I can tell, the only two characters with jobs in this entire movie are John Leguizamo and his wife. His wife is a waitress at her dad's restaurant, and John Leguizamo cuts hair. And nobody else has a job.

Speaker: No, Jerry T is a drug dealer. Yeah, exactly. This is what I was going to say is like everybody Everybody has some kind of scam going. you know Whether you're selling lobsters that you found for like $2. I love that.

Speaker: Yeah, or like you're Richie's mom who um you know is runs a poker game at her house, or you're her husband who's like a wedding singer or a lounge singer. i like Because that's a great moment too because we're supposed to think you know he's in the the frilly shirt and everything. We're supposed to think that he's like the ah like the goon watching over the game, but he's actually like, the fuck you wearing that shirt for? It's like, well, i' so I'm singing at the... you know It's this kind of like...

Speaker: There are all these informal economies. It's important also that the restaurant is failing. you know that like did you like they go to all the They eat all this food. The food all looks terrible, but there is so much of it.

Speaker: They're always eating. They're always at a restaurant. That's called being Italian-American. You're just describing being Italian-American. I'm just like, i can't i wish yeah No, like there's like the scene where like the cops sit down at the, at the mafioso table and he's like, yeah, take some chicken piccata. He gives them like you like a veal cutlet. He's like explaining, right? yeah No, exactly. Right. Like, and it's this, um but there's a sense that like,

Speaker: The only people that are making money are the ones who are scamming. um Even scams do not make very much money. But but at the same time, it's cash-based. It's internal. It all stays inside of this neighborhood. did look up the... Because you get inflation hits in 73, right? You get the OPEC oil crisis after the Yom Kippur War. I mean, that's a real trauma for America. And America's sort of psyche has been the dominant world donant wild superpower.

Speaker: yeah You have these Arab nations just sort of turning around and cutting off the oil supply. And suddenly, you you know, in this very car-reliant society, you're you're paying five times more for gas. But inflation actually gets way worse around 77. And I was just looking at the stats for this. So, yeah, 9% by inflation rate of 9% by 78, 13.3% 79. is huge. Like, why wouldn't operate informal economy?

Speaker: see um this is this is huge like why wouldn't you operate in an informal economy yeah Yeah, like why wouldn't you run a poker game out of your kitchen, right? like And like you know keep it all in cash, keep the money in the mattress. There's definitely a... um Yeah, no, that's really... Yeah.

Speaker: But I mean, when I say stagflation, I guess yeah the other point is is not just that, oh, yeah, you want to be protective of your money, but it's also that the economy is shrinking as inflation is going up, right? like That's what stagflation means. So the job opportunities are just by definition diminished. Yeah. And what happens when the official, when the, the, the quote unquote real job market shrinks, you get these informal economies that arise. Right. And that is all over the movie. I mean, again, the only other guy with the job is in the sex trade in Manhattan.

Speaker: Right. yeah exactly. Yeah. And you have these like, um, God, you have these small businesses, you know, like, um, like, John Leguizamo's character, whose name I forget. What's his name in the film?

Speaker: Vinny. Vinny. Of course it's Vinny. Right. You know, like, you know, he' is he has a chair at a local hairdresser, and he's fucking his boss, and, like, you know, he's basically a gigolo, right? Like, I think that's you're supposed to get from this. And there's, like... Yeah, like, an overname, yeah. Yeah, like, and it's like, you have the nerve to to give Richie shit? Like... You know, he makes an honest living. There's a kind of, um...

Speaker: When I said like, what do these people do all day? I kind of meant, I meant that as a joke, but also seriously in that like they live at home. Right. I mean, like Richie still lives with his parents and he's like, you can get me out of my bedroom. putting me in the garage. I don't want to live in the garage, ma. that you um I can't afford my own apartment. Like, and so there's this kind of extended adolescence into the, into your twenties, which is part, which is frankly, what was the birth of punk really, which is what the birth of what caused these subcultures all to emerge is the fact that all these people have too much fucking time on their hands, you know?

Speaker: What I found super interesting about this is that Ruby, Richie's girlfriend, earth just drops disco in a moment and picks up punk. The kind of interchangeability, at least, presented in the film. i think which What did she say? She says, yeah, can I have some money? I want to ditch this whole disco look.

Speaker: um It's very like flat and like right. just like yeah I don't know. They're somehow fungible. yeah These boundaries. that i mean One can be ah a disco girl one night and a punk the next.

Speaker: so This is a kind of a question that just occurred to me for the first time. i mean is Gen X, or at least this, let's say, very young boomer period, and also because Gen X is a little young at this moment, but like you know this is what they're growing up in the shadow of.

Speaker: Is this kind of very young boomer moment, the first real moment of this huge number of subcultures. Because like with with Silent Generation, and to a certain extent, then Boomers, we're familiar with right beats, we're familiar with ah you know mods, I guess. And then, of course, in in America later, you're going to get hippies right in the in the later sixty s But it feels like the 70s into the eighty s is when you really start to get this, and the Reagan ears complicate this to a certain extent, but this ability for this like variety of scenes to somehow really explode, in some cases along ethnic lines, like the ska scene that's going to happen in the UK.

Speaker: But you're also going to get, in the US, yeah, punk. You're going to get this, immediately afterwards, this post-punk world that is basically like 30 different scenes, you know all kind of competing with each other and saying that they're the real... you know um the real inheritors of that tradition. Disco is going to break down and turn into this like mixture of pop. And then this hair metal scene, which is the subject of the second Penelope's furious decline of all Western civilization movie.

Speaker: And then also you're going to end up with, yeah, as time goes on, the broader metal scene that gets associated with the satanic panic and all of this stuff, right? Is Jen actually the first generation that gets the opportunity to, yeah, I don't know, pick and choose in that way.

Speaker: in in it in such a With so many choices, I guess is what I'm asking. I mean, the division between, say, mods and rockers in Quadrophenia, which is what, early 60s, it seems to be like set in stone, and it's like kind of bounded around. Those subcultures are less fluid. I mean, they're very much like set around like class. like Mods are kind of, I think, for our back lack of a better term, upper-working, lower-middle-class people, and the rockers are kind of like the underclass. And there's a kind of material basis to these subcultures, whereas...

Speaker: Yeah, I mean, my impression seems to feel that Gen X subcultures are a little bit more consumerist, bit more consumer a bit more fluid. Or it's a transfer from... I guess you could say it's a transfer from a kind of like ethnic local based like um form of subculture, you know, even yeah this even goes down to the level of like, say, like, you know, football, super fans baseball fans, you know what i mean Like that kind of, that kind of thing, which which is a thing that you're born into. You're born into your family's fandom or you're born into a kind of like,

Speaker: you know, you know, if you're born into this neighborhood, which has its own distinct energy and vibe and subculture that you kind of to, it to this sort of fungibility economy of like fads, the faddishness of it.

Speaker: Jets and sharks. Like, I mean, just this idea that you can have these basically ethnic gangs. Also, you've given me a horrifying nightmare vision, which is, you said you're born into the fandom, which is true. But given what fandom means now, I'm imagining this like horrifying situation where this kid is being raised. It's like, no, you love Inuyasha. You know, no, you love, ah you know, I don't i don't know enough anime titles, but just like, these are the Funko Pops you're going to get when I die. You know, like this kind of

Speaker: and know Yeah, exactly. It's like, no, this is a Disney Plus household. You bring that MGM shit in here, you're out of there. Just horrifying. you know i mean One thing I was thinking about was this 70s nostalgia, Gen X's 70s nostalgia in the late 90s. I'm thinking, right, Baz Luhrmann's Romeo Plus Juliet has very similar aesthetics to this film. It's very much like vests, i open shirts and flightla vests and gold chains and flares. um And that, like you know,

Speaker: The City is Burning in that film as well. Boogie Nights as well, the Portables Anderson film from... When was Boogie Nights? I think it's 1997. 1997, yeah, which is obviously deeply nostalgic for the 70s.

Speaker: That is a great counterpoint film to this, actually, in a way, because it's also it's also about real events, it's about real murders. Boogie Nights, yeah. And it's L.A., not New York, so you get a kind of an interesting...

Speaker: No, I mean, it's a way, the sort of Gen X audience with the main consumers of these films in 1997, 1999, they're going to be, it would have been their oldest, about 12 or 13, or the youngest, what, two or three years old during the 70s period.

Speaker: Yeah. um And yeah, it's it's interesting that there's this is return to that period when they sort of reach, what, 1999 would have been, what, in their 30s, I guess. Yeah.

Speaker: well And there's an explosion in that moment that um i just I'm kind of obsessed with. In the very early two thousand s and this could be, you know, this is sort of Gen X filmmakers maybe starting to come into their own. You get some boomer people doing this, but with the idea that you're appealing to a younger-ish Gen X audience.

Speaker: You get these movies like Dick, if you know this one, which is this bizarre reimagining of the Watergate scandal where like I think it's like Kirsten Dunst or something. like it's you know it's It's about the 70s. That 70s show is from that period. there's a There's a massive uptick of interest in Hunter S. Thompson as well in the ninety s yes Yeah, yeah, yeah. This recovery. And my favorite is there's a a much forgotten show that I i always show it if I teach anything about TV called MTV's That 70s House or The 70s House. And it's this amazing show from like 2004 or 2005, something like this, where it's reality TV and it's conscious of itself as reality TV. It's completely on YouTube for those who are interested.

Speaker: And it's just you go in and you have to pretend it's the 70s. You can't use technology. The clothes have to be 70s style. All the challenges are sort of based in this idea of what it would have been like to be in the 70s. And people are thrown out constantly because they'll use slang that's 90s. You know, instead of saying groovy or something, they'll say, ah you know, rad. I don't know. And like that gets you thrown out. So there is this...

Speaker: I mean, even Britpop, right, as well in the UK. Britpop is deeply nostalgic for like the late sixty s early 70s. Oasis like taking on the kind of mod sub subculture of that era.

Speaker: This is a small note, but um famously Berkowitz, when he was first identified, the first person to sort of say what he looked like, they said that he looked like a mod.

Speaker: They said he he looked modish, which I don't know, if which again, we you older was there more than one killer? We don't need to go into all of that. When is it exactly that you get kind of like young white professionals moving back into the city and especially like outside of Manhattan into the boroughs, like into Queens, into Brooklyn?

Speaker: When that start happening? Oh, so the highest crime, highest murder year in New York City history is 1990. Almost positive about that. So like the murder rate continues to climb through the 80s with the crack epidemic.

Speaker: and after 1990 it starts to decline, the serious gentrification processes really ramp up after 9-11. yeah so after 9-11, Lower Manhattan is rebuilt, refurbished, bought and sold for very cheap.

Speaker: And it becomes what it is today. i mean, like clearly, property values in Tribeca but we have never been like it's never been easy to live Tribeca exactly. but like But it's really after 9-11 and through the early aughts that like Manhattan itself started to transform.

Speaker: um that spilled out over into Brooklyn, you know say, 03, 04, roughly. that sound right, Chase? Yeah, I was just going to say that I think I'm interested in doing, when we get to the millennials, which may or may not be next season, and I'm not telling the people because you know i don't I don't want to give too much away. But you know I think you're basically right about the timeline. I would just say that what's weird is that it kind of has become exponential, that it gets like worse and worse. So in other words, I remember growing up,

Speaker: there was this sense that Williamsburg especially was you know becoming gentrified and white. And by the early 2010s, you have vice articles about like, here's what the Rugrats would look like if they were Brooklyn hipsters now, you know this kind of crap.

Speaker: But then by the time i've I'm moving to New York in the mid twenty ten s at this point, you're already starting to hear about Ridgewood. You're starting to hear that Queens is becoming, you know, adjacent. at this Yeah, Storia. At the same time, my wife is living in Bed-Stuy and it is, you know, she's living there because it's cheap, right? Like it's not even being gentrified that much at that point, except there's one Swedish couple who lives on the block in a brownstone that they've totally refurbished, painted white, and it has like an early version of a ring doorbell on it. So you feel like you're being watched, you know, where you go past. But Everyone else on the block is basically like, you know, biggie era Bed-Stuy person. And now I'm sure I haven't been Bed-Stuy in several years, but I imagine that the Swedish people have won out.

Speaker: So it's, yeah, it's it's weird because it's like in the total geography of New York, gentrification actually hasn't gone that far. Like New York is so big. That like yeah lots of parts of the Bronx, lots of parts of Queens, even lots of parts of Brooklyn, especially places that are not super mass transit accessible or just in the Bronx because the Bronx is so far no matter what. Yeah. Are still, you know, working class, often non-white neighborhoods. It's just that this corridor basically from like the early two thousand s until today

Speaker: is hipsterized. What's weird is that now that hipsterization has taken on a professional quality. Sarah, yeah, I don't know if that's the right word, but like it's good a professional quality where now you move to New York. league Gabby and I commented on this whenever we go to New York. because she She moved there for modeling at 16. She was there as a kid. It was a very different world. it was you know it was not you know It's like that's where, i don't know, Mac DeMarco or something is playing. like It's you know it's its is its own weird little subculture that it's trying to develop.

Speaker: Now, I mean... And now, you put on my, i don't know, jaded older man voice. But you know now you go into Manhattan or certain parts of Brooklyn. I went to a show at Warsaw recently, which is a huge cultural club in Greenpoint. Greenpoint's one of these like ethnic white neighborhoods, now totally gentrified. I hadn't been to Greenpoint in years.

Speaker: ah Saw Horse Girl, shout out Horse Girl, great band. And I did not recognize it. Everything is like luxury apartments now. You could see these like single family or two family dwellings of the kind John was talking about that are in the Bronx and in a lot of outer borough neighborhoods that are kind of interspersed between these like tower developments. And you know everyone around me looks sort of like they want to be like They're really into Vampire Weekend, but without the like maybe more ah hipster cultural cachet that Vampire Weekend would have held at the time.

Speaker: And it's funny because this is a... If we're thinking about this as like a wave of gentrification, and maybe this could be like the the wrap-up because it ties back to the beginning, is just that... um This wave of gentrification is about reshaping neighborhoods that exist into the image of like a Williamsburg. Whereas the the late 60s, early 70s had their own version of this, and it was Co-op City, it was Stuy Town, it was the, um we're going to build a neighborhood from the ground up, we're going to invent these developments. you know And this happened all over the country, this It was a kind of like Le Corbusier style. Exactly, yeah. Like this kind of brutalist... And it's that moment of gentrification that I think, like in a sense, like produces Berkowitz. right like He grows up in this... I can't um emphasize enough to you how weird it would it would have been to move to Co-op City in 1967. There would have been... like Basically what he would have moved into is like there's four big project-looking towers in the middle of a swamp and there's a deli.

Speaker: It's like Dubai in 1979. Exactly. it's bias he It's crazy that he did that. And it makes a lot of this make sense, but that is, and it's an earlier version. It's like a, like the modernist equivalent to sort of like it is, yeah, it's Corbusier to like, say the current moment of, um, reshaping neighborhoods, taking old neighborhoods and making them into something else.

Speaker: I think my question is sort like Jet X's attitude to the city that's displayed in this film, right? Like, ah Something I find very dissonant about Gen X is the kind of, and not all of Gen X, but like and a large proportion of them is this kind of fear of the city that remains that you see across American media, right? And like the obsession with San Francisco or bits of New York still, this kind of like, that the city is the center of like the destruction civilization orves of derogation.

Speaker: um And of course, that really contrasts with what you were just talking about, the kind of like the corridors of gentrification where it's like the most like beautiful like you Swedish furniture coffee shops. And um and that that that that bit of the city really doesn't sit in Gen X's imagination to the same way that it does maybe with millennials and Gen Z.

Speaker: You've given me a kind of an epiphany here, Sam, which is, yeah, it's interesting that the the thing that John was describing a moment ago and that I sort of took off in this wild direction of me getting mad is really a millennial phenomenon, right? Like it it is this thing where the millennial seems to believe it's okay to go back to the city because, you know, the millennial generation starts in 1980 or so. By the time they're coming of age, you know, I mean, New York, these places are not...

Speaker: If they're scary, they're scary because it's like, you know I don't know, Robert Altman's the player or something. They're scary because Hollywood's evil or because you know New York is full of finance capital. But they're not scary as like places where you're going to get murdered by a wild serial killer. And I do think that Gen X, because of when they grew up during this moment and then later on in the 80s, you said...

Speaker: you know murders in 1990 come to their you know their apex, remain kind of afraid of the city. And you know this is why maybe you get Gen X guys now with their big pickup trucks or like think if they go into Manhattan, they're going to get beheaded by Hamas or something. It still exists.

Speaker: It does. it's like But i maybe, okay, we should go, but I did want to leave us a moment here at the end ah just because I know, John, you and I are both big fans of the Netflix documentary that came out by the guy who did Cropsey a few years ago on ah Was Maury Terry? Am I remembering the name correctly? Maury Terry, yeah. yeah Do you just want to say a little bit about him as this interesting New York character of the period who maybe is just a nice little cherry on top to what's been going on here?

Speaker: yeah Yeah, so Maury Terry was a reporter, reporter, in New York during the, during the son of Sam killings. And he is a, he wrote a book.

Speaker: I forget what the title of the book is. You're in the title of the book, the ultimate, the ultimate evil, right. Where he raises, he takes seriously the idea that Sam was not working alone, that, but that there were multiple sons of Sam. um He bases on a lot of things like the, the main point, the most convincing point that he makes is that there are,

Speaker: Not only multiple police sketches look nothing like Berkowitz, but they look a hell of a lot like his neighbor, who was the son of the guy who owned the dog that was telling him to kill people.

Speaker: There were these two guys named um John and Dan Wheat or something like that. And they... What Maury Terry believes is that they those two kids and Berkowitz worked together to do the murders. um Only Berkowitz was ever caught.

Speaker: the other the two The other two died They ended exactly. One of them died in a car crash. I forget how the other one died. Um, but Terry goes increasingly insane and, and he is kind of like picked up by Geraldo, who's a great sort of, you know, 80s TV character, Geraldo Rivera and by, um, the Dateline lady, what's her name? Um, he gets these interviews on like schlock late night television and stuff talking about this and he convinces himself more and more that like, it's not just

Speaker: Like it wasn't just David Berkowitz and these two guys. It's actually like a massive Satanist nationwide global Satanist conspiracy all working together. It's all connected to Manson. It's connected to MK ultra. It's connected to all like he becomes a sort of full-fledged, um,

Speaker: conspiracy theorists of the worst kind. Um, and he basically destroys his life doing this, putting out various um rewrites and new books and revisions of his already excessive son of Sam book, the ultimate evil.

Speaker: Um, he's not a very good writer. He's not a very smart guy. um but there is a, um, a Netflix documentary called the sons of Sam, which begins as a documentary about the son of Sam.

Speaker: Um, the The first episodes are about New York in the 70s. It's about all this stuff and the killings. And it becomes, over the course of that, about Maury Terry and his just sort of like descent into like conspiracist madness. And, you know, that as another defining Gen X feature, which is the conspiracy theory, um like as a kind of, um which is interesting because so many Berkowitz and others,

Speaker: believe there's a conspiracy against them. yeah Right. There's this kind of like, it's, it is the preferred psychosis of Gen X in a way that, um, I think is, does not translate so well to millennials. i think we have different, um, you know, different problems.

Speaker: Uh, John, do you have anything you'd like to plug? Oh, no, not plugging. I don't plug it plug. Well, I can say that John is a good Twitter follower. He he does manage to, ah ah you know, I think they call it because the Twitter main character, but that's not dismissive and bad. you You do a good job of generating the discourse, so I think people should follow if only for that reason. Very entertaining. follow yeah Going to work in the post-mines, baby. All right. It was a pleasure. see you guys later.

Speaker: See guys.

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Recommended