Zencastr
00:00:00
00:00:01
Speed1x
Format▸
Share
Embed
Report

Season 1, Gen X — Episode 4 — The Princess Bride (1987) w/ Philip Womack

Death is a Photograph
Death is a Photograph

117 plays · Dec 6, 2025

Transcript

Speaker: I'm frozen.

Speaker: Our guest today is Philip Womack. He is an author and journalist. He specializes in children's books and cultural writing. He's the author of Ghost Lord 2023, Wild Lord 2021, and most importantly, in my opinion at least, How to Teach Classics to Your Dog.

Speaker: He's a frequent contributor to The Telegraph, The Spectator, and The Guardian. He also writes regular roundups of children's literature for the Literary Review, um one of which actually I had the pleasure of proofreading.

Speaker: Back as an intern in the heady days 2017, I found myself in the Soho Lexington Street office. There was, certainly when I was there, there was a hole in the floor, and um and you had to be quite careful if you pushed backwards in your chair in case you fell into it.

Speaker: And I wish today todays talk about surprising pick, Princess Bride, which is 1987. 1987, that's right, yeah. nice youc seven that's right yeah yeah so So why did you pick Princess Bride? What do you think it seems says about Gen X?

Speaker: I partly picked it because it's um it goes against the grain of that deep-seated irony that everyone associates with Generation X. And certainly by the time I was 10 or 11 or 12 and we had films like Reality Bites,

Speaker: where the presiding mode is this kind of slightly bitter irony. And the thing about The Princess Bride is that it combines irony with this incredible sweetness and adventure and sort of open-hearted joy. um And I think that's something that Generation X certainly wants,

Speaker: And I think that what the film does is show that it's impossible to attain that kind of delight, even within um this knowing, metafictional, slightly winky framework, which he deploys so well.

Speaker: Yeah, I think that's super youre interesting in the sense... I was thinking about this film in a sort of spectrum of earnestness and irony, and a lot of Gen X things fall somewhere in between the sort of ironic earnestness.

Speaker: And the films put me in mind of two other films, which were Shrek, which is I think is the early 2000s, and then Bridge to Terabithia, which is, I think, 2007. Yeah.

Speaker: And if there's a sort of movement between irony and earnestness in the generations and the sort of the filmic output of those generations, like Shrek to me is all postmodern irony. It's completely tongue in cheek.

Speaker: There's very little earnestness in it. It's all sort of like knowing reference. But then by the time you get something like Bridge of Terabithia in 2007, which is, I think, maybe the equivalent of Princess Bride for my generation, sort millennial Gen Z cusp.

Speaker: It's incredibly earnest, very much driven by like narratives of trauma and psychology. And yeah, this film to me, it was incredibly refreshing. I've never watched it before, but it was incredibly refreshing in the sense of it's kind of David Foster Wallace combination of earnestness and irony, right?

Speaker: Yeah. Chase was one that was amazed that you'd never seen it before. yeah because it's and just such a staple of it. Like, i I hadn't seen it when I first met my wife, and she, like, basically berated me for my lack of, you know, I don't know.

Speaker: And I can see, i mean, it's so wonderful. i I can see why someone would be upset, you know, that one hadn't seen it it. It feels like a secret. if If you meet someone who hasn't seen it, you want to press it on them and and and also make them watch it a hundred times so that they can quote it alongside you. Because, you know, when you say inconceivable to somebody, you want them to know where it comes from. And, you know, it's kind of an interesting. You mentioned... the the trauma narrative behind, say A Bridge to Terabithia, Sam. And I, you know, I have friends who've worked in the world of children's publishing. And, you know, I know often today people are very, my wife is a first grade teacher. People are very interested in, you know, how can they speak to the experiences of whatever group of people or person or or potential psychological state.

Speaker: And I think this film is very interesting because it, It doesn't do that at at all, really. I mean, it if anything, has this wonderfully kind of sweeping, melodramatic, romantic narrative that it would be easy to say is old-fashioned, but contains that within this slightly more knowing framework. And I guess...

Speaker: I mean, how do you see that as fitting into the broader sweep of maybe what Gen X was raised with? I mean, I think of, I don't know how much this crossed the Atlantic Ocean, but The Goonies or something like this, or these other kind of 80s kids films.

Speaker: Well, I think it's it's interesting that you said melodrama because one of the influences on the film of um The Prince's Pride rather than the novel, because as you probably know, it began life as a novel by William Goldman, um who was a screenwriter. and He said that the novel was the thing he was most proud of, which is interesting because it is completely bonkers. But but one of the um one of the influences on the film is The Prisoner of Zendel, which is so the film and the book, which is possibly the first kind of modernist thriller. don't know if you know the story of it.

Speaker: I'm not heard of this one, no. So had a redhead man who um goes to visit a country called Ruritania, which is to all intents and purposes a sort of made-up medieval country. So he goes on a train there, and he steps off the train, and he he's literally stepping off the train into a world of horses and carts. He's sort of physically going back in time to a world of duels and adventures.

Speaker: He's mistaken for the king, who he's a distant cousin of, and he has to take his place. and And you get those themes, those same themes in The Princess Bride. And it is that sort of very knowing um attitude towards, well, this is a fantasy. we're We're not saying that this is a real story where we're stepping off the train and we're going somewhere that's that's unreal. So um you've got that all those influences behind it, which we all had growing up, and because things like The Prisoner of Zendarr and Errol Flynn and all those films were always on television all the time. And

Speaker: The jewel scene in The Princess Bride is is literally taken from the prison of Zendarr, you know, with the black mask and everything. It's almost almost exactly the same in many ways. um In terms of its relation to other Generation X films of the time,

Speaker: I think it it really stands out um from them because of those influences and because of its tongue-in-cheekness. And off the top of my head, and the only one that I remember from being that little is a film called The Last Unicorn, which had Mia Farrow as a unicorn in it. And that film was much more earnest, um much more fantasy, also based in a novel by Peter Bruegel, I think.

Speaker: yeah I'd have to check that. And I think The Princess Bride is set apart from that really deep-seated, kind of almost Dungeons and Dragons fantasy, you know, where you have the wizard, um the elf, the dragon, and you kind of know what to expect. But with The Princess Bride, it's playing with conventions. It uses conventions, but at the same time, it plays with them. And I think that's um that's what's partly so appealing about it.

Speaker: I think that that's wonderfully put. And you know we you know we we'll give a little bit behind the curtain look here. you know There's some questions circulated before the ah beginning of the actual interview. And one of the things that I asked about, because i was very interested in it, is the way in which it does feel like a lot of later Gen X media was very interested in figuring out how to square precisely that circle.

Speaker: um I think David Vosdois may have been mentioned earlier in terms of you know new sentimentality. I guess I'm interested in maybe where you think some of the sincerity went. I don't mean that it disappeared. I think it just ends up in a very interesting position. I'll give an example. I mentioned Rocco's Modern Life. Are you familiar with this? Did this go across to the UK?

Speaker: It did. Well, it's about it it's about it a little Australian wallaby named Rocco who lives in a town called O-Town. And it's very knowing. It's very like he he lives next door to a guy named Ed Bighead, who's a toad, who works at a corporation called Conglamo. There's an episode where they just want to see this movie and they keep running into problems. You know, trailers are too long. The person next to them has stinky breath, whatever. And one of the trailers is, after a million trailers, it's the final one right before the the movie's supposed to start.

Speaker: and it's Dracula, as you've never seen him. And you know Van Helsing is walking up to the castle, and they open up the casket, and there's a skeleton with a stake through the heart. And then the narration comes in and goes, already dead. And then they just say, okay, let's go get lunch or whatever. So, you know, this was, I was raised on, ah created often by Gen X cartoonists, Gen X children's writers of some kind, that very much was interested in entertaining both the adult and the young person, usually through this kind of knowing, winking sort of style. And that's obviously continued. But I think of Gen X as a very, in some ways, a very earnest and passionate generation. um And I guess maybe where do you see that in The Princess Bride? What aspects of it highlight um its earnestness or honesty?

Speaker: Well, it's a deeply emotionally honest film. And I think that um is really at its core. You've got these wonderful relationships, almost a triptych of relationships that form the basis of it. You have the framing device, which is this really lovely and as a father now, I really appreciate it did a lot more than than when I was a child, um the relationship between the grandson and the grandfather. And and that's the sort of This real, honest, deep-seated is this inter intergenerational understanding, the idea that, yes, even though you've got a boy with his computer games and his... i was As I was watching it for this, re-watching it again for the hundredth time for this... um i I noticed how full of consumer objects that boy's room is. It's almost like this is the end of consumerism. It's full of toys and and like he's got some Cheetos on his like computer games. It's it's like clearly meant to be seen. It's like a poster Michael Jordan. Yeah, exactly. That's a question I wanted to ask because this is an abiding theme that I think has come out in all the movies that Augusta's picked is this... um

Speaker: Concerned with TV and consumerism as sort of the ultimate evil. you know I think right at the start of the film, um the grandfather says, you know, when I was your age, television was called books. Yes. And it has this obsession with the sort of corrupting power of TV. that You can go from the The Simpsons to later on in the 90s, early 2000s, Darius was sick, sad world.

Speaker: yeah Thomas Pynchon, who's not a Gen X, but his Gen X novel, Vineland, is obsessed with the sort of deathly qualities of TV. Always like David Foster Wallace and, you know, Yeah. The sort of dopamine hits that TV gives you. And I think even about, you know, on the sort of same level as The Princess Bride and The NeverEnding Story, yes which I had seen as a child, which I think the young protagonist in that runs away from some bullies into a bookshop. Yeah, that's right. And he sort of says, I really like books. And the bookshop owner kind of goes, what, you mean magazines? Yeah. You don't read books. Your generation doesn't read books.

Speaker: I said, yeah, that concern over sort of all that juxtaposition of like TV or computer games versus books. I think, well, it's an abiding concern. um i mean, as you say, it's it's an an enormous irony because, of course, you know, we're watching a film and we're not reading a book. And I would like to think in hopeful terms, although whether it's borne out with hard data or not it' is another question, but I would like to think that all those kinds of media can coexist alongside each other without necessarily causing ah much detriment to people who only consume wine. form. So you can have cinema, you can have television alongside books. And the people who read books are always going to be the three or four people in a class of 100. Let's be honest, you know, it's never really much more than that.

Speaker: I think also, particularly in the 80s, there was a ah real thing about video nasties, which, um um do you did do do you have that in America? it was ah It was a real scare. We had a similar thing. night We didn't call it that, but yeah, more or less the same thing.

Speaker: Yeah, this finds its way into brass eye, right, and stuff like that. Exactly, yeah. So that there is this... And again, it is interesting, isn't it? Because there is this idea that media can be toxic and it can have a detrimental effect, particularly on children. um But in The Princess Bride, we see the palliative and, and in fact, restorative effects of literature on a child, even though it's done through a sort of visual um format. So it's, you know, if...

Speaker: it's It's saying that it's about story, I think, rather than the media through which it comes. You know, yeah that that accords, I think, very interestingly with the earnestness or sentimentality thing we were just talking about. What I mean is, if it is a movie, and I think you're right, about the enchanting power of narrative, of the enchanting power of fiction, regardless of the medium through which it's you know portrayed,

Speaker: That becomes a way of generating exempla, basically. And this is ah a long tradition of edification or education, that you sort of tell a story that allows a person to kind of mimetically identify with, you know, whoever the protagonist is. One of the things that's kind of interesting to me about the movie in that respect is that the Fred Savage character, the the boy, and maybe we should take a second here to say this is a story about a little boy being read to by his grandfather, and the story of the movie is essentially the the novel. Maybe that's clear to people, but just to clarify, the main character is actually a a girl, and this is something that Buttercup is

Speaker: that even in my youth, you know, 15 years ago, you'd still hear boys complaining about this. I don't want to have to identify with a female lead character. i don't want to have to, you know, make that imaginative jump.

Speaker: So the movie seems to really believe in the power of narrative to the extent that it can cross all sorts of boundaries that, you know, maybe society or your, you know, someone might think is, or that they're unrealistic or difficult to cross.

Speaker: I think that's a really interesting point and it's really pertinent, I think, as well, because neither Buttercup nor Wesley. Wesley is Buttercup's lover. Is it worth recapping the story just for just for those listening? yeah um So essentially speaking, there is ah an incredibly gorgeous ah girl called Buttercup, which is a ridiculous name for a princess, but we'll come to that. Buttercup is more usually given to cows um as a name, so whether that's... I'm not sure that he intended to make that um that sort of reference. But Buttercup has a farm boy working on her farm. He's also ridiculously gorgeous. And that's something I noticed actually for the first time watching it now um is that Buttercup and Wesley...

Speaker: basically look like each other. Um, they're very, very similar. They're almost like doubles. Um, so there is something going on there, I think. And, um, Wesley, uh, is passionately in love with Buttercup. Buttercup is passionate, realizes she's passionately in love with Wesley.

Speaker: Uh, but Wesley doesn't have any money. So he's got to go and make his fortune. He goes off and then he dies. That's the beginning of the story. I'm not saying any more.

Speaker: But what's interesting is that Buttercup isn't, she she throughout the whole thing, she displays incredible courage. So at one point, she pushes someone that's chasing her down a hill um in order to kill him. um She goes off riding on her own. She jumps into the sea um when she's being kidnapped. um She threatens to kill herself, which um I think is sort of almost like a Roman maiden. It's the kind of thing that that a virtuous Roman maiden would do in order to sort of, you know, I don't want to be dishonored, so I'm going to murder myself. which is effectively what she does.

Speaker: So it's just she's got all these qualities. um She's not a sort of weeping, wailing princess. And then, of course, you've got Wesley. And I suppose I can talk about it, can't i without spoiling it too much.

Speaker: I'm sure that anyone listening will have seen it hundreds of times as well. but But Wesley is an interesting character too. And there's a moment, again, these things pop out at you where one of the characters says, never trust someone in a mask or something something along those lines. And of course, Wesley is wearing a mask and and that's quite interesting. And he actually uses deception all the way through. and And he doesn't, although he can be active and virile and all those sorts of things, he's also quite camp and quite but quite effeminate. And at the at the end he actually doesn't expend any force at all in order to win. he he he essentially uses use lies to defeat the Count. The action hero is a secondary character who is probably most people's favourite character, who's Inigo Montoya, wants to take revenge on on on the count. um He's the one who's a more classical sort of um action figure. So in in a way, Wesley and Buttercup are these sort of types of each other. They're almost versions of each other. And that, that I think, is partly why, you know, a boy or a girl can identify with, empathise with both.

Speaker: Does that reflect something of the times? I mean, you're coming off the back of the androgyny of the sort of uh david bowie era and you've got new romanticism in the air at the time yeah um i mean it deeply reminded me of the prior music video um the safety dance i with hat which has got these two kind of very pretty you know medieval girl and a boy almost like the girl is slightly masculinized the boy is slightly effeminized and um almost a kind of pre-raphaelite um aesthetic as well in

Speaker: That's it, actually. that's I hadn't thought of that, but there is a kind of pre-Raphaelite sense to it, isn't there, of um of these kind of maidens and knights with kind of perfect features um doing courtly things. But then, of course, it's it's undercut by the kind of rompiness of it. I'd i' love to go back to the the court bit, sorry, the dueling bit on the cliffs, because I i think how Chase brought this up in his questions as a kind of homoerotic slash platonic slash Greek sort of recognition between the two main male characters that I found like fascinating and something that I hadn't seen on screen really um before.

Speaker: Again, it does come from the it comes from the prisoner of Zendor as well, where um there's a realisation between Rudolf Rassendil and his enemy, Rupert of Hensau, that they are essentially the same person and that all that all that would have to happen is for one of them to make a different decision and they would do the same thing.

Speaker: and And it is that... awareness of equals meeting, even though they were on the wrong side, which of course, um as Sam knows, I'm a classicist, um comes from the Iliad where you have a Trojan and a Greek meeting or an Achaean in the Iliad um on the battlefield, realizing that they're connected um through their prowess and also through their ancestors who knew each other. And so they so they change their armor and they agree not to fight with each other. So it's that same sort of thing. And again, we were talking about sincerity and it's that deep seated honor that between these two masters of their arts, which allows them to kind of come together like that. Again, it's interesting that you mentioned homoeroticism because again, we were talking at ah the beginning about the sort of triptych of relationships between that the kind of support, the films, you've got the father and the,

Speaker: grandson, you've got Wesleyan Butter Club, and then you have the giant and Inigo Montoya, and their friendship is so touching. um And there's a moment when Inigo goes back to drinking, and um you know he's discovered by the giant, he sort of slaps around the face and dunks his head. Hot water, cold water, hot water, cold water. Yeah.

Speaker: Inigo opens his eyes and sees this terrifying giant and he smiles and says, it's you, which is almost like a parody of a sort of romantic, you know, meetup after a long so separation. So that there is that sort of edge there as well. um Another sort of, I think, more homoerotic coupling is between the prince, Humperdinck.

Speaker: Humperdinck, I had to say that.

Speaker: Humperdinck, Prince Humperdinck and the Count. There's a moment when they're about to go in to torture Wesley and and they're talking to each other like a married couple. It's like health is all you've got. One one must protect oneself. I have my wedding, i have to kill my wife, i have all these things to do. yeah I think that's really interesting in the sense of the sort of Gen X generation of children who are watching the film like recognize that kind of therapeutic self-actualization, yeah dave hippie style self-help language from their parents. Yeah, probably.

Speaker: don't know. But also the Cold War, right? I meant to say that the Gilda-Florin dichotomy really does echo the USSR and the USSA. like Kids watching this, they're going to kind of, like especially if they're like 10 to 14 at the time, the Cold War is going to be something they know about. And there is this kind of like Cold War element to the film, like especially around Vincenzi, the Sicilian sort of comedic con man or whatever. you um And there are all these lines that are very geopolitical, the bit where he's like,

Speaker: You fell victim to one of the classic blunders. The most famous is never get involved in a land war in Asia. yeah It's justs almost like a false flag operation. like ah the The prince is constantly trying to like kill the princess to start a war with the neighbouring country. And I do wonder whether those sort of echoes of the Cold War would have been present. I think certainly, yeah absolutely, yes, definitely. And and don't forget that Goldman...

Speaker: wrote um All the President's Men as well, and which was about Watergate and and the and the bringing you know bringing down of Nixon and you know the Bay of Pigs and forced flag operations and all that sort of thing. It's all there.

Speaker: I think I wouldn't necessarily go so far as to say that Gilda and Florin were USSR in America because they're, mean, Gilda, we don't even really get a sense of at all. And it it's also quite interesting, I think, that when they they seem to cross over into Gilda, but nothing really happens.

Speaker: um they never We never meet any Gilderians and they they seem to know where to go and they know where the fire swamp is and all that sort of thing. yeah but But yes, where where I would... The fire swamp is Afghanistan, clearly. I would say that the paranoia and the politicking um and the the sense of of using power in the wrong way are very much all there.

Speaker: Yeah, it it is one thing that we kind of touched on earlier that seems to me maybe worth exploring a little further is the way in which the Dread Pirate Robert slash, you know, question mark, I won't reveal who, you know, he secretly is, if that's not already very clear, um that we said that he wins sort of via brains. And the movie is very explicit about the brains, brawn, steel. I may have the words slightly wrong, but that there is this explicit sort of trinity of of almost in a almost in a Dungeons and Dragons sort of way where you sort of specialize, right? um And what makes the Dread Pirate Roberts character ah so successful is that he bests

Speaker: each of these three bandits, two of whom he absorbs into his own kind of coterie, one of whom played by Wallace Shawn, son of longtime New Yorker editor, and from My Dinner with Andre, a great movie. um You know, he he unfortunately dies thinking he's so smart. And I just have to say, how i can relate so strongly, maybe I'm just an idiot, but to that feeling of like, well, no, of course you would do this, but then again, what if you did this? I just, I think that's so wonderful. But anyway, that,

Speaker: that There is this almost division of labor in the party in a way that is reminiscent of a kind of RPG where Inigo Montoya is this expert fencer. Andre the Giant is, you know, he's he's a giant. It's sort of in the name.

Speaker: And then, you know, the Dreadpire Roberts character is the brains to the point that later on when this machine, it literally just called the machine, sucks 50 years off of his life and basically makes him not quite a paralytic, but close,

Speaker: he can still succeed because he still has his brain, right? Like he, the way that he overcomes the count is through deception is by pretending for a brief moment by stabilizing himself, I think on the bed that he is still able to fight this kind of cowardly, you know, classic sort of Lord Fauntleroy kind of cowardly little, little man character. And i I think you're right that that allows us to cross a certain kind of gender divide. But if I may bring it back to my, you know, I think quite lovely questions. I was very interested in the way that I think Gen X, in the way that it evolves later on, so you know maybe I'm moving beyond the late 80s here, does kind of bring a certain ah nerdy intellectualism into the mainstream at at a certain level, I think.

Speaker: And I wonder about the degree to which, and this is a genuine question because I don't know my like boomer kids media quite well enough, No, there is something in the the tone of Wesley that's quite like Reddit.

Speaker: um like lady you know a few him which is the so like In the context of is incredibly charming and r but yeah yes somehow i think maybe if it was transparent just twenty seventy five would be sort of intolerable Well, it's a pastiche, isn't it? And and it's even consciously parodying Errol Flynn and and all those sort of upper-class heroes and even even Shakespeare in in a sense as well. um So, yeah, it would depend on the tone and and um and what you did with it. But if you think about something like Ella Enchanted or or some other kind of slightly more sophisticated films where they play with fantasy elements in those ways, you know, it can be very successful.

Speaker: Yeah, I wouldn't say that Wesley was nerdy. i would say he was brainy. and The nerd is... God, now I've forgotten. Vizzini. Vizzini, of course. i think Okay, that's fair. One thing I thought was fascinating was this element of ethnic humour in The Princess Bride, which you just don't see in...

Speaker: sort contemporaneous or the sort of films of aimed at children now. The kind of element of fair that yeah his reference to being a Sicilian and the kind of Sicilian-Italian-American humour, but also a very strong strain of like sort of groucho Marx and Woody Allen-esque sort of like Jewish New York style, like yeah dry humour in it as well.

Speaker: Well, Inigo Montoya is Spanish and is very obviously this kind of um romantic warrior type. you know He's sort of like if Don Quixote were decent at what he did or even beyond beyond decent, in fact. yeah Yeah, I like Cross. And there's there's the sort of connotations of Zorro as well, I suppose.

Speaker: Well, exactly. And that's Scaramouche is the other one that it that it picks up on in that sort of fantasy fighting genre. But yeah, the other thing it does with all that is it mixes genres because it's it's not it's got it's a romance, but it's a revenge tragedy. It's got pirates. It has adventure. It has war. it has deception. it's ah It's a pick and mix. It's a grab bag. it's um I was thinking um the other day um as I was watching it was that it's a little bit analogous to Peter Pan where you have a children's fantasy world where you've got everything like a theme like a theme park.

Speaker: there's the um There are the mermaids, and there are the pirates, there are the Indians. that This is this is the fan the Edwardian child's imaginative landscape. And it's a similar thing with with The Princess Bride. You've got all these sort of elements to it, which kind of, it's almost like taking all the best bits from all the all the things that we love and making them into something new. That's a very, you know, if we can take things a little classical, there is maybe ah a certain sort of odyssey element. you know Obviously, this is i'm I'm not claiming we have an an Odysseus per se here, but there is a sense in which by setting us along this kind of travel narrative, at least until the end for the most part, you allow yourself to experience a relative variety of phenomena that would be maybe harder to do if you just set it within the castle or you know something similar.

Speaker: Yeah, quite exotic, isn't it? It descends from romances, for as in the Greek romance, the generic form of the novel where you have a shipwreck, a lost child, um a lost princess, which then feeds into Shakespeare. and And, you know, all of those generic elements come into it. Absolutely. There's also sort of an element of the picaresque as well, I suppose, and something like Henry Fielding.

Speaker: Also, Tristram Shandy, this kind of so slightly shaggy dog, non-linear. Absolutely. If I may be permitted a bit of medieval indulgence, um not not in the papal sense, but in the in the indulging myself sense.

Speaker: i I think there's something interesting going on here in parallel with medieval trends in romance. And, you know, a listener, you can you can turn it off right now if you want. Unfortunately, I have no choice but to proceed. ah but Basically...

Speaker: When I think of sort of the arts and crafts movement, when I think of this kind of late 19th century embrace of a certain kind of medieval aesthetic, especially in in the UK, though not exclusively, there is a certain earnestness about what that represents because it represents something pre-industrial, it represents something worth returning to that's happier, that is, you know, sort of um ideal, and that that ideal needs to be approached with a certain earnestness.

Speaker: And what's interesting to me here is obviously that's not the case. And in some ways, that parallels the way that the romance, that that's more how medieval romance plays to itself. It's it's very cheeky. If you've ever read in an actual medieval romance, they are deeply earnest in the sense that they're about love a lot of the time. They're about relationships. They're about basically the destructive power of love, which to some extent this is. They're not as strongly as a medieval one would be.

Speaker: But they also are usually interested in being pretty funny about it. So, I mean, to give you an example, I don't know if either of you are with Quentin de Troyes, Lancelot or the Knight of the Cart.

Speaker: But in it, it opens where Lancelot fails basically in his duty to protect... he He has to get in this cart, and carts are used as a way of, you know, you're a prisoner or something like this. and It's very shameful, right? So at the earnest level, it's very sad. This knight has been debased. It's, you know, he's he's failing in his in his role.

Speaker: But what happens, he's dragged around by a dwarf and is sort of made fun of. And this is supposed to be somewhat funny, right? Like the dwarf is the stock medieval kind of character of the of the of the the Joker, you know, maybe a little bit malevolent, but, you know, ultimately supposed to be very funny.

Speaker: And he has to cross this bridge that's just a big sword and it gets narrower as it goes across. And it's very adventurous, but it's also like how ridiculous is that? It's a gigantic sword. you know That's something you might see in this movie, right? um So I have to kind of doff my cap at The Princess Bride for, I think, capturing something of the spirit of the material it is playing with.

Speaker: It it is sort of pseudo-medieval, or really maybe just medieval, in its approach to its own subject matter. So I think that's that one was really just for me. i think there is something i think deeply Chaucerian as well about Princess Bride. Oh, he would have loved it.

Speaker: Yeah, I think about The Wife of Bath or... What's the one that's sort of mocking the troubadour sort French romance tradition? I can't remember exactly which one that is. Certainly The Merchant's Tale has a fablio or is a fablio, but yeah, it does have that sense of of earthiness to it, I think. and And that comes through partly through the terrible sets and the fact that you do feel like you're almost watching a a play and these are real people, they're muddy, they're dirty, um you know. It's funny in that sense, actually, isn't it? were we're We're sort of encouraged to think about the artificiality of it nearly all the way through, i think, um you know, with the the sky and um the cliffs of insanity where it's these enormous cliffs and it's very, very clear that some dummies are being carried up. Even the ships they sail on are like conically small. Yeah, exactly. i mean, is that to some extent...

Speaker: sort children of the times in the 1980s would have recognised sort of pantomime elements that. Yes, don't know. I don't absolutely. No, no, actually you're right. I think you're right because i i recall seeing it and filing it alongside the same category as Robin Hood, Men in Tights.

Speaker: partly because it has that same sort of Monty Python, you know, that sort of um slightly down at heel, um you know, BBC drama, we're going to use two coconuts to make a sound of horses. like The set might sort of keel over at any minute.

Speaker: Exactly. and and And all of that, I think, is is deeply charming and and and certainly a lot more charming and likeable now than something made purely through CGI or with green screen effects or something. you know um i think I think part of its its long long long longevity is the fact that it feels real.

Speaker: um it's not um There's no distance, really. I have a confession to make. ah The fire swamp part, which is one of the places they end up as they're escaping from ah the the cow to sort of set them up.

Speaker: I had it mixed up with what I think is a set piece from The Labyrinth. and I might be wrong, which is the swamp of farts, uh, where it just smells really, really bad. And as they were getting closer and closer, I was like, this doesn't seem like a movie that's going to do a, a fart swap. Like it it, it is cheeky, but I don't know if it's quite that over the top. And, uh,

Speaker: The satire is like bounded, isn't it? Yeah, that's kind of, yeah, I guess what I'm getting. You should go this far. You should go this far and no further. Well, and I think there's something, it it is still serious enough that it's not going to have like, ah like if you've seen the labyrinth, the sort of Jamaican, think they're like dinosaurs or something or throwing their heads around. Like it's not going to go there.

Speaker: You know what I mean? it It's going to stay in the sort of general realm of what you might... In that way, it reminds me, if if you know... I think it's Thomas Berger's Arthur Rex, which is this comedic retelling of the Arthur legend from the 70s. And it's a totally comedic... I mean, like it's all one gigantic joke.

Speaker: But it takes its material seriously enough to kind of try to keep you bounded in in the world of of the medieval setting, so to speak. And this is similar. Well, it's interesting that you mentioned The Fire Swamp because what I think The Princess Bride also does so brilliantly and effectively, and i don't think that contemporary films could do this, even if they tried, is is is toe that line between...

Speaker: humour and absolute terror and the rodents of unusual size, the RAUSs, despite the fact that it looks like a bloke in a rat suit, which is what it is.

Speaker: You know, when when i'veve i've watched ah I've watched that film with a nine-year-old, so I was about 20 and i I brought it with me and and this is the days of VHSs and It might have been a DVD, I can't remember, but anyway, we put it on.

Speaker: And this little boy who was about eight or nine, which was sort of just about the time i think that I first saw it, was so transfixed by that scene. And he actually stood up when ah Wesley is about to kill the um the rodent. And then he was like, going, wow! you imitating Wesley as he did it. And he was so involved in it. So gripped. And it it remains this completely terrifying moment because you really think that they're going to, they're going to be destroyed. And, and then it sort of shifts tone again. It's, it's very, very good at tone shifts.

Speaker: mean, it's somehow, it's somehow coherent. I suppose that's an interesting. Have you shown it to your own children? Yeah, we watched it. So, um well, ah so the eldest is nine and then the little ones are a bit too little. But so I've i've been trying to get them to watch it um for quite some time. And we we normally get about a third of the way in. um And then I was watching it the other night and um my eldest came down and sort of was peering through the door.

Speaker: And then, i you know, you can come in and watch it if you want. And when we got to it got to the first one bit and he was straight behind the curtain. and and wouldn't come out until until he knew that they you know even even as Even as I was telling him that um you know it's all right, they're past, they're at US's now, you know all that sort of thing. it was It was very, very sweet. It's just like the grandfather and the Fred Savage. It's like Peter Falk and Fred Savage. I mean, there are multiple points where the film pauses and starts with him being very detached, you know sort of saying like, oh, get through the kissing parts, I don't care, you know let's get to the action.

Speaker: And then by the time we get to the action, he's so scared that, you know, he like wants reassurance from the grandfather yeah that it's all going to be okay. And of course, the wonderful ending where he forces the grandfather to read the final kiss to him because now he he needs to know. yes um you in that sense, the frame narrative plays out this relationship between the the earnest and the ironic through itself, which is kind of an interesting yeah dynamic.

Speaker: yeah That's very interesting because you sort of start out there's a sort of dyad of the the grandfather and this and the grandchild, the grandchild being this kind of cynical gen X kid and the grandfather being an incredibly earnest, I suppose greatest generation. i was trying to figure out when he would have been born, I suppose around 1922. Yeah.

Speaker: yeah And the the grandfather becomes this kind of wry, cynical, ironic interlopa and the the boy becomes Ernest again, which is quite yeah it's quite charming, I think. Yeah, it's very charming. you've got um you know We must mention um probably the best cameos in it, which is Miracle Max and his wife, who who are these incredible, cynical people who can perform miracleicals miracles.

Speaker: and and And they're just wonderful. i I laughed and laughed and laughed when I watched it again. you know It's just so funny. They remind me Larry David, effectively. ah Yeah, I mean, whether that it is that sort of Jewish, elder elderly Jewish humour, which is, you know, ah have fun storming the castle. It's just so good.

Speaker: ah But yeah, i know that because there is that cynicism in the elderly generation as well, even embedded within the film. And yet they give them the tools to go and and um and succeed. So it's um it's interesting that.

Speaker: The movie does predate, you know, because we're we're we're circulating in this season ah among all of the sort of different decades in which Gen X could be located. You know, could be anything from the 70s to today, whatever. And this movie is interesting because it's coming along, you know, relatively early in in the process for this generation. You know, some of them would have been basically achieving adulthood, but for the most part, you're talking about children still.

Speaker: And we haven't yet gotten to the so-called end of history. you know The USSR hasn't fallen, in at least in... I mean, I recently watched some Mike Lee films. He didn't make it look like the UK was doing great in the 80s, but you know ah maybe there's still some hope somewhere, certainly in the US, outside of very, very left-wing elements.

Speaker: you know people were sort of excited about you know the potential of the United States. So there is a degree maybe to which the younger generation is in the position to have the more optimistic streak at this moment in in the in the zeitgeist.

Speaker: No, I think so. And I think that's what it captures so marvelously as well. And I think it's, it is essentially saying that, you know, there is a sort of cycle between those two generations that there is, it's about growth and it's about change. And you have that sort of sweetness and innocence growing into cynicism, but then the the old, a the the elderly can pass down what they know to the innocent. And it and it is a sort of,

Speaker: um a circle like that. um I think like Sam, I'm on the cusp of generations and I think I just come into, I'm afraid, millennial just about. We'll ending the interview right now. If you could please get off the call, Phil. Last generation.

Speaker: And I do recall a sense of ah reading the news, you know, when when I so started becoming aware of the news um of the Berlin Wall falling, the Iron Curtain coming down, of a new sense that things were going to be better across the world.

Speaker: did certainly seem to be borne out by what we were watching in films like The Princess Bride, where there is an absolute optimism there. um in In the core story, there's an optimism. I mean, obviously it's undercut by irony and cynicism, but it's not undercut so much that it falls apart. You know, I would say that its its emotional core is is is optimistic.

Speaker: from From what I understand, by the time we get to sort of the mid-90s in the UK... that sort of optimism and sort of earnestness about the potentiality of like us. And we have Britpop and the Hacienda, Manchester, and like literally London is booming. Yeah. Um, think all of those things start happening a few years after Princess Bride. Yeah. 9-11, of course, you've got you've got to remember and the Iraq war and and all these things where it seems that, you know, things were falling apart again. And, and, um,

Speaker: Well, it it's interesting because one of the films that we have already spoken about, and I assume will be released prior to this, if not, sorry, audience, ah is Fight Club, which is 99. little but you know not not too much and certainly more distant from this than from nine eleven And that is a movie that is, you know, feels a certain kind of spiritual rot. Now, granted, it wasn't aimed at 10-year-olds, but it was aimed to some degree at 18, 19-year-olds, nineteen year olds you know not not that much older, really.

Speaker: And I guess it's it's interesting how quickly that shifted. It's the same audience. Yeah. I mean, you could grow up on Princess Bride and then be like, Tyler Durden is the greatest character, yeah you know. Yeah, like someone who's like 12 when they watched The Princess Bride in 1987 is an adult by the time they watched Fight Club in 1999. And is probably the target audience.

Speaker: Yeah. Well, I think my experience of people enjoying Fight Club was that they were completely drawn into the aesthetics of it. And, um you know, they all wanted to be Brad Pitt, essentially. speaking they were men you know But how different are how different or Wesley and and Brad Pitt, Tyler Durden, right? I mean i don't know. I don't know if I'd buy that. I mean, they are, but and they aren't. They're both incredibly metrosexual.

Speaker: yeah Wesley with his little ponytail. Absolutely. He obviously moisturises. Yeah, like, as we were discussing in previous episode, like, Tyler Durden is is both the kind of epitome of masculinity, but also incredibly feminine. Yeah. um yeah And, yeah, actually you think there's more of a mirroring between Wesley and Durden in some ways. I'm going to i'm going to claim claim them as blood brothers.

Speaker: I think it's fair. i guess that was sort of part of the point I wanted to get at is I think the thing that remains in some ways, I think they both display the same kind of mixture of earnestness and irony in the sense that both of them are, instead of love, in Tyler Durden's case, it's you know this but this form of masculine self-empowerment, but there is an earnestness about the possibility of that empowerment and the destruction of a system.

Speaker: But they also are both knowing and smart and sort of always one step ahead. And you know this is, I think, what earlier maybe Sam referred to as the more Reddit aspects of this kind of cultural moment that lasts.

Speaker: yeah But they are different in what they're earnest about and what they believe in, and also in their, I guess, hopefulness. if that's a term that we want to invoke, about change in the way that it's carried out, right? In the story of The Princess Bride, we're still, and it is for children, so of course, you know, these narratives are always going to be a little different.

Speaker: But in The Princess Bride, there is still this, they still get away on the four horses. There are just enough horses in the stables to make sure that everyone gets away. And how is it handled? Andre the Giant says,

Speaker: I had to get four horses because in case we find the princess. And then, you know, oh, hi, princess. You know, this thing, right? Oh, hello, lady. yeah I have to ask quickly. I mean, Andre the Giant becomes a Gen X icon with the Obey stickers and posters. I don't mean, these Shepard Fairy...

Speaker: a very iconic prints that sort of like start going around in the 90s and the 2000s, or in the end makes the Obama change poster. I just wonder if the Andrew the Giant's kind of cult status, is is that from this film?

Speaker: Oh, it must be. It must be, yeah. Well, here, I need to be very American here and say that he enjoyed extreme popularity through his professional wrestling career, at least here. So the the late 80s and early 90s. I'm obviously now...

Speaker: I have to say that Princess Bride is the direct cause of the Obama win in 2008. This is is it beautiful.

Speaker: The dread pirate Robert telling you to believe in hope and change. Hope and change. I mean, yeah, exactly. As you wish. It's a sort of consumer manifesto, surely. It's kind of a post-scansity.

Speaker: it's It's abundance. This is what Ezra Klein and Derek Thompson are. I guess that that's that's a question i meant to ask is that the kind of class element of um Princess Bride, like them Princess Buttercup before she's a princess is a commoner, but she's a kind of One that is to take it that she's a kind of get the daughter of a yeoman farmer or something, who owns his own land.

Speaker: yeah And then Wesley is this landless peasant labourer, who's her, lack of a better word, bitch. um And and you know it's sort of ordered around by her, and yet self-actualises through the film into this all-knowing, omnipotent, good at fighting, clever, rich.

Speaker: I wonder what that says about the American Dream and Gen X. Well, actually, it's im just before we get into that um that point, which I think is really valid, that is is also the Cant of Monte Cristo, which is it it's almost exactly the same plot. It's um Mercedes, the the daughter daughter of a local, can't remember who her father is, but she's not particularly well off, but she's slightly more higher class than Edmund Dantes, who is then symbolically murdered in the waters um and then comes back to life and becomes all-knowing, supernatural father. figure like Wesley. But yes, I think that is a really good point um about um Generation X and self-actualising through doing stuff. I mean, it's the Protestant work ethic, isn't it, as well? and um and it But it's also it's it's also the sense that

Speaker: that you can do it and it's all there. And, you know, if only you sort of, um you know, go out and get it, you know, the the Dread Pirate Roberts being a sort of franchise, effectively speaking. Yeah, like in the real world, Wesley is a sort of McDonald's franchising. Exactly.

Speaker: but I think that's really true. And is it's about spotting an opportunity and using it and then, um you know, making a fortune out of it. And yes, off you go to make your fortune and then you get your bride, you know. So yeah, absolutely. the meritocratic wins out over the aristocratic. I mean, we can bring Chaucer back in here. This is the tale of Griselda. This the clerk's tale or or Clark's tale, if I want to put on my British pronunciation, ah where this commoner is picked up by this noble man and essentially made to, you know, endure to become an aristocrat. Except here, the McDonald's franchise owner

Speaker: wins. You know, kind of comes in and says, yes yeah, you you don't need to be patient and endure like this medieval woman. You can be saved by by by Calvinism or whatever, you know?

Speaker: Yeah, this maybe brings us to Trump. i think yeah I think that's absolutely there. I mean, it's practical they they're practically sans-culottes. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, they're revolutionaries, except that they want they they want the market forces as well.

Speaker: This is the bourgeois revolution. They're kind of perfect libertarian subjects. Right? Like, ah buccaneering, kind of... Yes, exactly. and and And promoting their own identity and making the world in their own mim image and all that sort of thing. well And they're they're sort of a freely contracted company.

Speaker: You know, right? Like, they they come together for presumably their own interest, although I guess the giant character does have a friendship. Of course, Vecini and Ego, the Giant and and an Ego, who offer their services. yeah it's a They're presumably on zero-hours contracts, though.

Speaker: Yeah, I think Inego says, I'm sort of doing this to pay my bills. Yeah, he does. He does exactly say that. Yeah, because he says there's no money you're not in. And that's a Gen X thing. That is absolutely a Gen X thing. It's the dream of of the writer or the artist who goes to New York and can't do anything and ends up being a waiter to and pay the bills.

Speaker: Yeah, he is yeah he because he says there's no money in revenge, so he has to be a sellsword, basically. And it's it's funny because it it maybe even more than the waiter thing, it's like the person who wants to be a novelist who's like, well, I guess I just have to you know be a copy editor or write for this web website, or you know you know do product reviews for consumer reports or something. like I have these skills, but I have to use them in this kind of market way because the market isn't ready for... you know I feel like that's only intensified, though. And it's probably still yeah know fairly relevant to a Gen Z audience. did I do a podcast, so... ah

Speaker: this is maybe, you know, as usual, I will i will take us ah slightly off the itinerary, but I promise it's it's a question I hope is interesting. Are either of you familiar with Mark Twain's A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court?

Speaker: Yes. Yes. yeah Just because it it does sound very similar to the the sort of Zendar book you were describing as the the, you know, sort of proto version of The Princess Bride or related, because it's the story of this good 19th century Protestant sort of industrious man who is transported to King Arthur's court and sort of just ruins everything or makes everything better by just applying science.

Speaker: You know, sir and it's it's very much this anti, you know, Walter Scott, anti-romantic, like, Well, i mean, the Middle Ages kind of sucked. Like, if you could just, you know, do, if you could just do 19th century capitalism, you would just immediately overcome all of the problems, you know, intrinsic to the, to the, to the Grail cycle. And, ah you know, ah that doesn't sound like it's quite, you know, Mark Twain is like about as sort of bitter and cynical as you can get. But, you know, it does sound like the Zendar sort of approaching that then Princess Bride is, is trying to stay more towards that middle. Yeah. I just had to bring it I love that novel. Yeah.

Speaker: No, i I think that's really, really interesting. um And it actually, as you were saying it, ah it reminded me that the Narnia books do exactly the opposites. And they say, we don't we don't want your progress and and your um you know your capitalism and and and all that sort of thing. We want to be in and ah in the medieval world where you can go hawking and and all that sort of thing. And Lord of the Rings.

Speaker: Yeah, and Lord of the Rings is the same exactly, looking looking backwards to an idealized medieval... Is this an Oxford-Cambridge issue maybe? You've got your kind of Cambridge scientists who are like, we need to import Mark Twain to ah you know industrialize the countryside or whatever, and then you've got your Oxford sort of romantics. We actually did that when at Cambridge, but and i don't tell anyone. but when i was When I was at Oxford, I made sure to check out ah Beowulf, the Monsters, and the Critics from the Mansfield ah College Library and read it you know cover to cover. so should we Should we wrap up there? Or is there anything else we want to... but the Oxford Cambridge war for Gen X's heart between, ah different sort of versions of British children's novels. is thing I think we could sell that to, uh, don't know.

Speaker: Someone one will pick it up. Philip, is there, there anything you'd like to plug? Anything I'd like to plug? oh gosh. Um, uh, yes. I mean, all of my books, go and buy them, read them. The most the most recent two ah Wild Lord and Ghost Lord ah for 12 plus, they're available in America and in England. ah they I suppose they're, are they anti-capitalist?

Speaker: if They're about a teenagers finding their own powers and and ah growing up um and dark magic and Dr. John Dee Elizabethan rituals and all sorts of things. So worth worth looking at John Dee is showing up in your in your novels?

Speaker: Well, the um in in the second book, there's ah an Obsidian Mirror, which is um based on John Dee's Obsidian Mirror, which he obviously used to communicate with angels.

Speaker: ah well there He did, no. I mean, this is I don't see why we have a question of that. um We should reveal that Chase is a practicing Catholic. i Well, not only that, but I mean, i study religious mystics of the late medieval period. So I love a good occultist. You know, what can I say?

Speaker: i can't thank you enough, Phil. This is so fun. Thank you so much. Yeah, it's really nice to chat. Thank you so much for having me.

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Recommended