Zencastr
00:00:00
00:00:01
Speed1x
Format▸
Share
Embed
Report

Season 1, Gen X — Episode 3 — Glory (1989) w/Spencer Leonard

Death is a Photograph
Death is a Photograph

177 plays · Nov 30, 2025

Transcript

Speaker: I feel broken.

Speaker: Today we have with us Spencer Leonard. He is an Adjunct Assistant Professor of Sociology at Jones Madison University. The author of Marx and Engels on Bonapartism and ah Marx and Engels on Imperialism, both 2023. He is a founding member of the Platypus Affiliated Society and a former editor of Civilization Magazine.

Speaker: Most importantly, he taught me Indian political history back in the dark days of 2017. We're here today to talk about the film Glory, which was, I think, published on the screen in 1989, but might have been produced in 1988.

Speaker: I think it hit theaters in December 89. So maybe we should ask Spencer ah what made you decide to bring it to us for our little podcast here. Well, it's really the background that that Sam was raising in terms of being an organizer of the Platypus Affiliated Society, which is a leftist self-education organization that I helped to co-found 2006-07 in Chicago.

Speaker: We're based on campus and we often, you know, we run reading groups and hold coffee breaks. But one thing that we do is screen films. And it's a perennial favorite.

Speaker: and it's And it's a very divisive film in a good way, I think, you know, for leftist education. What people object to, know, kind of questions that they raise are wonderful for basically raising questions of,

Speaker: leftist history, most obviously, but not exclusively in the United States. Could you give us a little bit of background on Prosper Society? I'm aware that it sort of opened with a slogan, which was, the left is dead, long live the left.

Speaker: Am I right? Yeah, I would say that we basically believe that, you know, all bets are off, that the legacy of mass political parties for socialism is entirely negative in the sense that it it only operates in history as absence.

Speaker: that history is sort of marked by this this wound, if you will. You might say it's what's happening historically. you know, what's happening historically is the absence, is the ongoing failure of the left.

Speaker: And, you know, that that's the sort of the underlying dynamic, you know, the headlines. And we basically see that as at least, you know, in part, of course, that's an organizational problem. That's a problem for for the working class, for society as a whole, but it's also acutely a problem at the level of subjectivity.

Speaker: It's a problem for intellectuals. I joke that, you know, at least when I was a student, the professors were good enough to inform me that the point of every class was that Marxism was wrong.

Speaker: Now they don't tell you that anymore. And so students are even sort of more unaware of what's going on And of course, they weren't wrong in saying that. But it's an organization that attempts to grapple with that at the level of you know students, at the level of elite students who want to be intellectuals.

Speaker: It understands itself as being, as it were, in a division of labor ah with other dynamics in society you know that have other tasks in terms of what it might mean to reconstitute.

Speaker: you know If not Marxism, maybe Marxism has gone beyond recall. but at least something that rises to the level of the task of freedom that that socialism led by parties that espouse Marxism once attempted.

Speaker: um ah You mentioned the term subjectivity. Yeah. It seems to be a sort of profoundly resonant term in glory. There's a sort of sense in which glory is a kind of left to Galian film.

Speaker: Oh, yeah. Which is sort of constantly thinking about mutual recognition and inter intersubjectivity among the sort of white officer class and the so newly recruited African-American men.

Speaker: And the sort of the recognition and the subjectivity that's developed by partaking in war as an individual in a bigger sort of yeah social unit. um And in that sense, it feels like a very...

Speaker: hey A film of its time in the sense that couldn't be made today, in the sense it's very... A film made about the same subject now, a bit I feel, would be incredibly individualistic and about sort of individual self-actualization in a sort of morally repugnant society, whereas this film feels like it's focusing on the unfolding of history itself, to use a sort of pretentious alien term.

Speaker: It's curious that it obviously comes out right at the end of the Cold War. And I'm just wondering what you think the resonances are there are in terms of the kind of so-called end of history, the kind of, you know, the development of...

Speaker: the self within society and that sort of intracranial self-recognition that's happening in the film. I think it's remarkable that this film was ever made. And you know i certainly wouldn't see it as like expressive of any sort of dominant spirit of the 1980s, at least as regards the black question in the United States.

Speaker: you know which is in some ways a peculiarly American or new world dimension of of history. I mean, ultimately not, but in a limited way. You could see other films from this time, I think, as much more, i don't know, characteristic, like Mississippi Burning or Do the Right Thing and Malcolm X. And I think we talked about this a little bit just in the very limited preliminary email exchanges that we had.

Speaker: You know, i think that there are a lot of layers of history that are passing through this. So ah one of the moving forces behind the making of this film is maning Lincoln Kirsten, who is quite an old man.

Speaker: i think he dies soon after the making of this film. I think he was maybe born in the 19-0s, 19-0s. like in arts Oh, wow. And he wrote a book ah called Lay This Laurel in 1973.

Speaker: nineteen seventy three There was another book that's an inspiration, clearly, for the film One Gallant Rush that was written you know at the time of the passage of the Voting Rights Act in 1965.

Speaker: You could even see echoes of a kind of, you know, the the idea that communism is Americanism of the 20th century, a kind of 1930s left patriotism that you get in the popular front.

Speaker: I think it's a more sophisticated film than that, but one could see that. Certainly, I think the filmmakers knew, you know, and what I would say is that it you it is a kind of a lucky strike in that, you know, the people who made this film are, these are well-known Hollywood people.

Speaker: They are, you know not just the actors, but the screenwriter. I mean, I think the the guy who wrote the script, you know the script that he wrote before this was for Rambo two That's particularly bizarre given the shift from Rambo 1 to Rambo 2 and sort of, you know, the ideological content. Yeah.

Speaker: Right. yeah ed Ed Zwick, the director, is you know, very much a mainstream filmmaker and had come out of television. Nevertheless, I think they were really self-conscious about, you know making a radical film.

Speaker: And, you know, the they're reaching back to the liberalism of, the nineteenth century what you i think you alluded to you their the liberal abolitionism, a kind of spirit coming out of the abolitionism, ultimately, of the American Revolution, particularly in the northern states.

Speaker: Obviously, abolitionism itself is a kind of product of the crisis of the American Revolution and the crisis of of Enlightenment liberalism itself.

Speaker: But also, you know i think this movie gets to the heart of the 19th century revolutionary spirit. And in that sense, you know, issues that you're suggesting, like, you the legacy of the high enlightenment, such as Hegel.

Speaker: When you look at the figures around the Civil War, whether, you know, Frederick Douglass and Wendell Phillips, you know, the great abolitionists, or Abraham Lincoln, who had been a part of something called Young America, ah or Karl Marx, whose writings I've edited on the Civil War. They're all self-consciously grappling with with the legacy of of German idealist philosophy and and the Enlightenment, the legacy of the French Revolution.

Speaker: So, yeah, I think obviously the the film itself is about it's about a historical event. But it's also about history itself, like history per se, as the struggle for freedom.

Speaker: First, we should say also for anyone who hasn't, has somehow managed to avoid glory in the last, you know, almost 40 years. Which is me prize is a day. Well, you you have a pass as a as a non-American, I suppose. But it's a film about the first black regiment to serve in the Union Army in the Civil War, whose sacrifice at the Battle of Fort Wagner In the act of sacrifice, we have essentially her mission for a broader serving of Northern, well, it basically also escaped slaves, any Black person living in the North or in the border states, well, not the border states because they prefer slavery, whatever, in the North to serve in the Union Army, which leads to hundreds of thousands, if I'm not mistaken, of further registration. So essentially, it it's a moment of sacrifice, which is a moment of recognition. That's right.

Speaker: ah that sort of releases a force unavailable to the South. I think saying this movie is silent about, obviously, because there's no point to bring it up, is that there is um an Irish officer serving the Confederate forces who late in the war basically says, we have to arm the slaves or this is not going to work. I mean, we we don't have the manpower to keep doing this.

Speaker: And of course, the Confederate higher-ups basically say, no chance. Because that is, they're fighting the war for that purpose. If you arm the slaves, you've lost. That's right. So it's this moment where the North, in a way, overcomes a version of its own racism. Obviously, racism is not abolished as a problem for the United States, but But it's a, if we want to speak Hegelian terms here, the racism meter, viewing it quantitatively, breaks off and there's a qualitative shift in the view of what it is that a black person in America is capable of doing. And that's at the subjective level of bravery and courage. And it's also at the practical level of bearing arms in service of the nation, which is, I mean, from a liberal perspective, essentially citizenship. I mean, it's not, of course, there's also going to be that's right actual citizenship. Importantly, pre-liberal, right?

Speaker: It's pre-liberal. The idea of like the recognition of citizenship or subjecthood, political subjecthood, goes back to like Plato, and you can trace it through medieval ideas of like being up to join a militia or man-at-arms.

Speaker: Well, you you don't want to involve the medievalist in this conversation. I will say this. that The neoclassical liberals pick up on themes about what it means to be a free citizen. That's true. But um I think the medieval question is more complicated. so But yeah, you're you're're basically right that that tradition is is there. But it's it's really much more bourgeois, right? It's really about, you know, you see it in a painting like Night Watchman in the Rijksmuseum, the armed burghers,

Speaker: of the free cities of Europe, patrolling, creating militias for the defense of their own freedom. right So it's not it's not just a gentleman's right to bear arms, ah but it's the obligation to defend you the republic or at least the polity.

Speaker: Right. The city of state. it's there yeah It's there in Britain. it's you know It's there in the history of Birmingham. It's there in the history of London. right This is a very deep a bourgeois question. And the fifty fourth is very aware of this. you know So they there are meetings when they announce that the Secretary of War, Edwin Stanton, has approved in the wake of the Emancipation Proclamation ah The raising of a black regiment in Massachusetts at the request of the governor.

Speaker: They have meetings in churches where they raise Crispus Attucks, right? One of the first martyrs of the American Revolution who was killed in the Boston Massacre, who was an African-American, probably an African-American and Native American.

Speaker: a man of mixed heritage and in that sense of pure American, you know, a product of the new world. Yeah. So this is quite explicit in the way that they understand what's happening. And obviously the goal is not to be defeated, but the goal is to show yeah that black soldiers can accept military discipline up to and including a complete risk of life.

Speaker: And that's the significance of being the lead regiment in the assault on on Fort Ragnar is that you know that that they show their courage under fire.

Speaker: Right. And and it's that that that generates this explosion of recruitment. The news of this goes around the world. It's reported in the British press. It's reported all over the world.

Speaker: And the numbers of of black recruits grows, even despite, of course, the slaughter that takes place at Fort Wagner. And so this is, i think that's a very good point. It just makes me think of of two things that maybe I can toss out there and see what we think.

Speaker: The first is that the film as a as a film, right, as an art object... does a lot of work to demonstrate the different sorts of problem that might be encountered in achieving military discipline in a population. Now, of course, that the people in the movie are black, but these are universal problems, right? You have the kind of intellectual who is, you know, in in maybe a conscript army, is forced to the front because he's a, you know, you could imagine this existing in modern Ukraine or something like that. Mm-hmm. You have the Denzel Washington character who is recalcitrant. If I were a young younger person than I, I might say black-billed. He is unhappy with the state of race relations to the extent that he's achieved something like proto-Afro-pessimism or is ready to kind of get with Marcus Garvey or something like that.

Speaker: Then you also have... um Morgan Freeman's character. Yeah, there's Morgan Freeman, of course, who's an older character. He becomes an NCO in this moving scene in a boat. Hawkins, his name is Hawkins. Side note here, but wonderfully sentimental film. This really has nothing to do with the point at hand, but it despite it's its melodramatic, the music swells in the moments you expect it to, I still think it works. It makes you, in a way, ah proud to be an American, as silly as that sounds, maybe. But the second point, I just want to bring it full circle real quick.

Speaker: is you mentioned at least William James and not the James brothers. My understanding is historically one of their siblings was there and died at, at, at, at Fort Wagner, I think.

Speaker: I think he lives. I think he's, I think he's wounded. i think he's wounded one brother. you This is Henry James and William James. They have two brothers. One is with the 54th and the other is with the other ah black regiment from Massachusetts, the 55th, I believe.

Speaker: I mean, that's a direct connection here we're talking about, a direct connection between these essentially Boston Brahmin families and this not just commitment to abolitionism, but a commitment to a kind of racial equality um in in a way that you know you're not going to get from a unionist, an Andrew Johnson or something like that.

Speaker: And i I can't help but also think about... the role that a certain kind of New England Americanism plays here, this kind of peculiarly Calvinist, eventually Unitarian, highly bourgeois in in in the way that you were saying earlier, ambivalent connection to both the American project as a project of enlightenment, as an essentially capitalist project, but also to a kind of radicalized Calvinist Christianity um that becomes you know so radical it kind of departs from Calvin. And the movie mostly absents that. The spirituality is mostly left to the black characters in that wonderful scene at the camp, but it hangs over the movie like a a cloud, the sort of Emersonian transcendentalist ideological nexus. so i think it's I think it's adequately conveyed. i mean, as I understand it, the original script, and I believe that they actually shot these scenes.

Speaker: ah But if you look at the, there are journalistic accounts of the filming of Glory, where they talk about the shooting of scenes at Brook Farm.

Speaker: ah which was the utopian socialist community in which Robert Gould Shaw was partially raised. His parents were connected to this. ah This produced... um Is that an overnight community or is that something else?

Speaker: Fourier. It's Fourierist. It's a utopian socialist. Yeah. And so this is Horace Greeley, who becomes the editor of the New York Tribune. Later Republican candidate for president. Yep. Right. ah But... ah Right wing. He breaks at the moment of the Emancipation Proclamation. He basically cracks up. ah But his man his managing editor, Charles Dana, was also at Brook Farm.

Speaker: And he's the one who hired Karl Marx to write for the New York Tribune. Oh, okay. And both he and Marx are fired by Greeley around the time of the Battle of Antietam when this film begins.

Speaker: So at the moment when the the war begins to turn revolutionary. And you know it just is conveyed in the character of Thomas. yeah He talks about reading Emerson.

Speaker: The childhood friendship of Robert and Thomas is suggested in the opening scenes, of course. It's a leitmotif throughout the film. yeah So you have this kind of... Sam and i yeah we met at the University of Virginia. And the University of Virginia is a temple to the...

Speaker: Virginia Enlightenment. And the Virginia Enlightenment is extremely fascinating, and and i will defend... you know Jefferson and Madison as great American revolutionaries. But obviously there's a profound red thread that runs all the way back to the pilgrims in the North, the radical Protestants who take the turn to enlightenment in the 18th century and provide the revolutionary spark in Boston, which of course is an epicenter of the American Revolution.

Speaker: on into early ah socialist utopian communities, communities that basically were the American counterpart of the socialism you that was much more proletarian in in Europe, especially in Britain, with the Chartists, the young Hegelians, and the utopian socialists. But it it does, you it it is a real, you know, crucial background that something like, you know, the 1619 Project, and in 2020, we had a attacks on, know, we destroyed the monuments of Frederick Douglass, for God's sake,

Speaker: Abraham Lincoln. Well, I was going to mention, wasn't there a vandalism attempt against the Robert Goldshaw Memorial in boston on Boston Common as well? there was a kind of a defacement of the Shaw Memorial.

Speaker: And it really gets to this, you know what really is the the founding of America, right? is it Is it the old story that, you know, was taught, albeit in a kind of desiccated way to me, yeah which is about freedom and revolution that you could trace through the Shaw family in a certain way?

Speaker: Or is it a kind of Afro-pessimist history, right? And this is exact this is why this film... yeah I would say that if you, you know to go back to Sam's original question, this film is a critique of the black power turn and of black nationalism in the late 80s.

Speaker: yeah if You know, if you wanted to really locate, like, what is the force of this film? It's a critique of the way that that black nationalism is being mainstreamed by the Democratic Party into, you know, electing black mayors, um you know, community policing,

Speaker: multiculturalism, the kind of Democratic Party race hustle that you see in the people who were coming to be the you know dominant figures of black America in the late 80s, like Reverend Al Sharpton and Louis Farrakhan.

Speaker: And it's hearkening back to the revolutionary integrationist tradition. Yeah, I mean, it seems to be a profoundly different film to another sort of Gen X staple on race relations, which is ah A Time to Kill in 1996, which is a John Grisham adaptation with, don't if you've seen it with Matthew McConaughey and ah Kevin Spacey around a murder in I Think It's Mississippi.

Speaker: but it's incredibly like legalistic, individualistic, pessimistic about reconciliation or integration. And then there's, what, like an eight-year time span between these two films? And one seems almost to be proto-Marxist, universalist at least in a sense, and reflective of a politics at the time that I can't quite place.

Speaker: And then you get to A Time to Kill in the late 90s, and it's very much a Clintonian view of race relations. And I'm wondering how Gen X... and maybe sort of younger boomers understood those topics at the time?

Speaker: Yeah, this is where I would i would emphasize, you know yes, deeper historical strains, but, you know, most powerfully, the early New Left.

Speaker: yeah This is a film that inhabits the spirit of the civil rights movement in its, I think, most, know, in its grandest aspirations.

Speaker: And those aspirations, you know I would put those in terms of you know the new left was a project of creating a new socialist left ah in the failed project, but it that was understood as a renewal of the American Revolution.

Speaker: And I think that that element, which you can see you know in a figure like Bayard Rustin ah you know He's now just turned into like a gay black hero in the ah Barack Obama produced film on Rustin that recently came out. But you know he was ah much more radical than that, right the organizer of the March on Washington.

Speaker: The overcoming of the McCarthyism, Through the civil rights movement, the rediscovery of radical traditions in the United States through the civil rights movement, which was, after all, a political crisis because it was a attack on...

Speaker: you know arguably the strongest political pillar of the entire global capitalist order, namely the Democratic Party, with its Dixiecrat constituency.

Speaker: right So it was a crisis of the political order on a global scale and inspired the whole, I would say that the civil rights movement was bigger than the Khrushchev's speech at the 20th Congress of the Soviet Union you know condemning Stalin.

Speaker: and his cult of personality in inspiring the global new left. So, you know, to me, this film grows out of that. And that's where I would point to figures like, you know the author of of One Gallant Rush or, you know, a historian that I'm quite fond of, James McPherson, who started as a young man, participated in the sit-ins,

Speaker: published his first books of history in 1965. And then in 1989, when Glory comes out, wins the Pulitzer Prize for Battle Cry of Freedom, which is one of the greatest books of American history ever written.

Speaker: albeit in a kind of a domesticated academic mode, but on the U.S. Civil War. You know, so that it's it's that, I would say, kind of quarter century digestion of the missed opportunities of the civil rights movement that you see in a film like this.

Speaker: Well, there's a kind of specter haunting. Now I find myself making a reference that meaning to. there's There's something stalking the conversation here, which is, of course, the kind of lost cause historiography that has both a huge cinematic footprint. I mean, ah you know maybe what one could say even even up through Ken Burns, which I think is after this in the 90s. But you know obviously, D.W. Griffith, i mean, this is all there. When I watch a movie like Glory,

Speaker: I read it almost more in terms of a break with that tradition as much as with the Afro-pessimist one we're talking about, though, of course, it it is also that, that, you know, a lot of Hollywood is making movies to be played in theaters all around the United States. And for a long time, there was a ah fear about essentially making the Confederacy too much the bad guys. It had to be a fraternal war.

Speaker: It had to be a war in which, unfortunately, the same group of people killed each other over these opaque questions that we don't really even understand fully now. It had something to do with a way of life and... you know, the cloth-making bourgeois elites of the North and the aristocratic quasi-feudal cavaliers of the South. And, you know, that's what this is really about. And we're just going to patch it over. And yeah, it turns out that there was this reconstruction thing we had to shut down, but let's not talk about that.

Speaker: Glory I have to imagine if I were around, you know, 88, 89 watching this, the refreshing thing just would have been that I didn't have to receive the Confederate perspective at all. That they are showcased merely as a mob, basically. I mean, they become more or less how it is that black people or abolitionists are depicted in Birth of a Nation.

Speaker: kind of just they're there to serve the purpose of a particular scene. The subjectivity is lost in this kind of, in i mean, literal smoke and and various kinds of occlusion. Whereas in this movie, we're centering not just the black experience of the soldiers, but the obviously also the white officers' experience as people who actually need to seek liberation, who go get the time of day and who get quite literally time on film to be shown as developing. And so I, I i mean, I don't know what, how do you feel about, about that? i mean, maybe that's not so much a question.

Speaker: i mean, look people, i mean, our culture is entirely stagnant. So, People at the time this film came out said everything that anybody would say about it now.

Speaker: oh You can see all the expected responses. one response you One response that comes out from The Economist, which I think is just priceless, is you know they say exactly this. I'll quote it if you'll allow me. Please.

Speaker: it. In some ways, glory is no less a distortion of the Civil War than gone with the wind. That is astonishing. Yeah. Where Scarlett O'Hara and Rhett Butler glamorize the whites of the Confederacy, glory dehumanizes them.

Speaker: The men in gray emerge as cruel bigots. Never for a moment does the film concede that they were fighting for an ideal. in its early stages after all the war was not about slavery, you know blah, blah, blah.

Speaker: ah Which, by the way, in saying this, you know one thing you have to you say for the economists is that they are being true to their traditions because this is exactly what they said during the war.

Speaker: And this is also true to the economists' tradition of not really being as objective and cutthroat as the Financial Times. like having this veneer of idealism over its pre-trade Whiggism, then, yeah.

Speaker: Right. yeah marx would have called a he Marx would have called it Palmerstonian, which is his way of talking about ah Bonapartism within the parliamentary politics of Great Britain at the time.

Speaker: wanted to ask a quick question about the the politics of recognition in the movie versus, again, American Civil War is not something I grew up with as a sort of historical mythology, but at least the sort of idea of the 19th century British army is that the enlisted soldier really doesn't have a kind of historical subjectivity until the first world war. When you get the so tomb of the unknown soldier and suddenly the sort the British Tommy becomes a vehicle of history, an actor in history. Before that, someone Duke of Wellington will describe the enlisted man as, you know, no no better than scum um on the heel of his boot. like They're really the the lowest of the low and that they there is no representation of the nation or the will of the nation or the identity of society in those enlisted troops.

Speaker: And yet, obviously, glory personifies the enlisted men as a kind of semi-paternalistic subjects of these enlightened officers who are sort of growing into actuality and sort of self-consciousness. um I wonder if that's sort of wishful thinking or whether that was a real element of the Unionist army at the time.

Speaker: You can see it both ways. you On the one hand, the U.S. s Civil War is just... you know the latest war in the post 1848 environment in this kind of counter-revolutionary environment and European military advisors, of course, came and studied the U.S. Civil War as no different than any European war. on the other hand, I would say that, you know, the American Civil War was the revolution that, you know, a revolutionary conflict that gives rise directly

Speaker: to the first international in Europe. It gives rise directly to the struggle for the second reform bill. It gives rise directly to the opening of a political response to the regime of Louis Bonaparte in France.

Speaker: For instance, there are mass demonstrations when Lincoln is assassinated in Paris that the Bonapartist regime can't put down. The students of France and together with working people fight their way to the American embassy ah through the gendarmes of Paris to present their sympathy to ah the American ambassador there.

Speaker: And of course it was recognized to be that in the United States. And in that sense, you know, the the dignity of the working man ah in uniform Indeed, the freed slave, the escaped slave was recognized. So just to allude to the movie directly, the penultimate scene is is Robert Gould Shaw being buried with his black privates, which is with his men.

Speaker: And that's historically accurate. And that was viewed, of course, as ah denigration, a disgrace, because the officers would have been buried you know with markers and the men would have been buried without their identities necessarily being marked. though At a lot of Civil War battlefields, there was an attempt to do this, and you can see the the dignity of the common soldier in that effort.

Speaker: you know So if you go to Antietam, for instance, you a battlefield not far from where I live, you'll see the in the German section of the battlefield, you'll see revolutionary songs from 1848 in German on monuments of the battlefield and names on every one of the markers.

Speaker: So with Shaw, there was you eventually, this the film is a little misleading and it says that Fort Wagner never fell. That's not really true. It was abandoned.

Speaker: And at that point during the war, and at that point, the Union officers wrote to Robert Gould Shaw's father and offered to disinter Shaw.

Speaker: And his father wrote back and said, absolutely not, that he should be he should remain in a common grave with his men, you know, because he is leading a essentially a ah ah democratic revolt and a revolutionary army.

Speaker: And so he thought that his aunt his son's honor was best served by his remaining in a mass grave. in the beach by Fort Wagner.

Speaker: It's very interesting um for you to, ah yeah just it just kind of hit me, that you can see this movie in a certain sense as the ah successful reenactment of John Brown's Raid on Harpers Ferry from, you know, at this point few years earlier. What I mean by that is,

Speaker: Brown is giving weapons to black and mixed race people and saying, we're we're going to do this together. Brown, of course, previously had been Jayhawk. He had you know and been involved in the Bleeding Kansas militias and fought in in that conflict.

Speaker: Sometimes to this day, sort of lost cause people will hold that against him, but so be it. In this film, you get that receiving ah an official kind of recognition. So Sam, you've asked a few questions here about recognition and how it functions in the movie.

Speaker: This is essentially a restaging, even down to the failure of the assault of the John Brown raid. But another step is sort of achieved in the historical process. So if Brown makes possible kind of the unveiling of the of the injustice of the South and what it is, right? John Brown's body becomes a very popular a song I know if you're familiar with that one, Sam. You should check it out. If not, it's ah it's another another real banger.

Speaker: It's more commonly you recognized as the Battle Hymn of the Republic. It's the same song. Yeah, the music. yeah But the the original lyrics are more revolutionary. The the lyrics that the soldiers is sang...

Speaker: as as marching lyrics. and There's a pretty good Pete Seeger version that is probably worth checking out. But to just finish the point is that, yeah, then here we have another assault, in this case on a fort rather than armory, but where the failure of the thing is precisely what generates the possibility for the next stage in the revolutionary process. And... um The film doesn't recognize that by, say, showing the soldiers singing John Brown's body or something like that. But it does seem to me to be explicit, even down to the ways in which the Goldshaw character kind of, i wouldn't go so far as to say renounces his whiteness, but he says, okay, if you're going to reject your pay, then I'm going to reject my pay. you know Sort of accepts himself as as one of the group and and attempts to kind of ameliorate the tensions that are caused by racial identity in United States, much like Brown.

Speaker: Right. I mean, i i entirely concur. I mean, there's ah there's a revolutionary core to the American civil war And that comes out of radical abolitionism up to and including the attempt to foment armed slave rebellion ah in the South, which of course was John Brown's aim.

Speaker: He led a raid on a federal arsenal in Virginia. It's now in West Virginia, but at the time it was in Virginia at a place called Harper's Ferry. And he took a band of his children and some radical abolitionists freed slaves and they went and seized this armory. And they were the idea was is that they were going to broadcast to the slaves in the immediate area that they were prepared to gather them, arm them, and lead an armed revolt against slavery in Virginia. And it failed, and Robert E. Lee led the the recapture of the armory, and eventually he was tried and hung.

Speaker: The song that Chase is referring to is, the chorus of it is That was a song sung by Union soldiers marching.

Speaker: song sung by union soldiers marching Was there a self-understanding of the Civil War? I mean, there's a there's always this kind of dynamic played out among some historians of the kind of Anglo-Saxon egalitarianism of the North versus the sort of aristocratic Norman slave society of the South. And there's all these kind of echoes of the English Civil War.

Speaker: And it it does feel the sort of contemporary American understanding of the Civil War is fairly analogous to the English understanding of the English. civil while british War of the Free Kingdoms, more correctly, um in the sense that it's there's a revolution sort of embedded in a war and that the war sort of is the headline topic and the revolution is sort of secondary to that in popular understanding at least. um And I wonder, is glory reflective of a broader generational attempt to sort of recoup or resurrect that that revolutionary core in the Civil War?

Speaker: I would say, you know, again, the the full significance of the American Civil War has to be grasped internationally. What's happening is, on the one hand, there's the American problem, the American situation, which is that slavery was an issue that was not addressed in the American Revolution at a national level.

Speaker: In the wake of the American Revolution, there was a a significant and crucial a wave of abolition that created the free north. So slavery is abolished in the northern states in the 1790s, 1800s, creating the free states. and And the slave trade, the abolition of the slave trade, which is certainly memorialized in Britain,

Speaker: That was participated in by the United States, as it was written in the Constitution that the United States would bar participation in the slave trade within two decades, and that happened.

Speaker: ah So as in Britain, it's in the 1800s, 1800s, at which point the northern southern states become breeders of slaves for the Deep Souths.

Speaker: because that that's how the demand for slaves is maintained as the deep South ah grows under the cultivation of cotton. And so at one level, it's a it's a reckoning of an old failure.

Speaker: But the deeper question is, and here I'm just going to be, permit me, I'm going to speak as a Marxist. The deeper question is the Industrial Revolution and the way that the Southern states are being integrated into the Industrial Revolution And the Industrial Revolution is occasioning a full-scale crisis of the Enlightenment bourgeois revolution, freed labor, and therefore the a threat of a regression from the threshold reached by the English Civil War, the American Revolution, the French Revolution, that unfolding world historic process. and

Speaker: the Union is fighting the whole world. Britain is on the side of the Confederacy. France is on the side of the Confederacy. The French have overthrown the Mexican Republic and installed a Habsburg prince as the emperor of Mexico.

Speaker: And this, of course, Maximilian. The British are the the british send 10,000 troops to Canada to menace the Union under Palmerston. It's an overarching project of recolonizing re-subordinating to European power the Western Hemisphere and reintroducing slavery.

Speaker: in it and in the union is very aware of this. You know, William Seward, the secretary of state, invites the European diplomats in and very famously in a fairly dark room lights ah a match and starts to smoke his cigar and he explains that if the Europeans intervene in the civil war, the United States is going to encircle the whole world in flames.

Speaker: Right. That it's going to become a world war. And it's understood that the allies of the union would be the working classes of Europe. And as I said before, the you know what stops the English from attempting to break the union blockade and intervene in the U.S.

Speaker: is mass demonstrations amongst the working people in the mill districts and eventually mass demonstrations in London. And those mass demonstrations in London and the mill districts lay the foundation for the formation of the first Socialist International in 1864, the first act of which is to write a letter to President Lincoln congratulating the people of the United States on his reelection.

Speaker: And in that letter written by Karl Marx, the secretary of the First International, ah he says the American Revolution gave the signal for the French Revolution in the 18th century and in the 19th the U.S. Civil War is the signal for socialist revolution.

Speaker: right And I would argue, like I said, the first time the red flag was raised over European capital, the Paris Commune, ah in 1871 should be seen as a part of the unfolding of the world revolution of which the US Civil War was a crucial galvanizing element.

Speaker: And this brings me to a question which is, there is this kind of understanding you're putting forward of a kind of historical continuity through these various imperfect revolutions yeah that have managed to self-actualize to an extent and then you know lead there are sort of gaps in that dialectic that lead on to further revolutions.

Speaker: yeah A large element the millennial left turn from that understanding of continuity and sort of dispute these revolutions. It's not just imperfect, but it's sort of unforgivable or sort of im things they want to like separate themselves away from, especially in America. And I wonder...

Speaker: where that historical turn happens from the understanding glory has, a sort new left understanding of historical continuity or revolutionary potential in imperfect revolutions to a kind of disavowal that you see maybe in the 2000s. Well, you see it the 90s as well, but it really reaches a peak in probably the 2010s.

Speaker: Again, glory is not representative of a dominant strain within the nineteen eighty s I wouldn't call the 1980s like counter-revolutionary or a backlash or something like that, but I would call them a moment of exhaustion on the left, that the left had reached its limits ah in the 1970s, that it found no way forward. and in that sense, that the goals of the new left were cashed out by

Speaker: Margaret Thatcher and Ronald Reagan. Ronald Reagan is the way in which um yeah the smashing of the unions, ah for instance, or the weakening of the strength of American organized labor is how tens of millions of women and black people enter into the division of labor on a vastly expanded scale.

Speaker: in the 1980s. The 1980s are a huge expansion of the of the American economy. And it's where I would say there is a post-racial dimension to it.

Speaker: I grew up in the 80s. I'm a member of Generation X. And you know it's the era of Michael Jordan, of Michael Jackson, of Prince,

Speaker: Vanessa Williams becomes, albeit problematically, ah Miss America. Everybody's listening to Public Enemy, right, in 1989. I remember my brother coming back from Oberlin College, my older brother, in 1989, coming back and reciting the lyrics of the new Public Enemy album to me.

Speaker: you know But it was Farrakhan is a prophet. you know It was black nationalism. That was the dominant strain. right in there's There's great writing by, for instance, Adolf Reed, a black political scientist.

Speaker: Black particularity reconsider a great essay from 1979 in which he talks about how dashiki-wearing black nationalism, as well as a kind of Maoist, black-left, white-left division that what this is resulting in is you know, mayoral campaigns for black politicians.

Speaker: In other words, it's an integration into the Democratic Party. The deeper point is that something like glory, you know, I i call it like a lucky strike. It's also... you know Someone like Walter Benjamin will talk about the way that history flashes up.

Speaker: What is it that allows for a certain consciousness? right It's not mainstream. like the The history of the world is not the history of you know Marx and Lenin and revolution. It's not. right It's the history of of capitalism. It's the history of FDR and Hitler and and Nixon and so forth and so on.

Speaker: That is the mainstream, of course, historical consciousness of of the world. But this film is a recognition that that's never integrated, that there's never one zeitgeist in coherent consciousness in capitalism.

Speaker: Spencer, right there's a very, i think, a very interesting answer. And I have to just maybe add a little color as someone coming here from New Jersey, sitting in New Jersey. or I mean, we have a gubernatorial race coming up. um I guess the primary will be ah sometime this summer, and then the race will be in the fall, and of course, a Democrat will almost certainly win.

Speaker: And who is one of the main contenders ah but Raz Baraka, the son of Amiri Baraka, Black arts movement poet and and playwright from Newark, New Jersey. No way. who is it and yeah, yeah who's a major he was a former mayor of Newark. I mean, there there are direct connections between the sorts of cultural movements that you're talking about, and I mean... Politics as they exist in the state right now. I mean, I i don't know if this is clear, but i'm sort of I'm a reluctant local political figure. Just I'm on the council for my town.

Speaker: And I see this all the time. I mean, this is a reality of living in a place that's dominated by the Democratic Party, politically speaking. What I think is interesting about a movie like Glory in light of all of these things is not just that it's a flash in the pan in in the way that you're describing, which is true.

Speaker: but also that it is a movie that does bear a tradition that I think does exist within Gen X, but that is put to different sorts of means depending on who's speaking. So I'll give you an example of what I mean. ah my My wife is a teacher, um and she used to teach in a preschool. Now she's a first grade teacher. And in the preschool, she was the assistant to a woman who is a An evangelical, you know believed the end of the world was coming, all of these things.

Speaker: Definitely very conservative as far as the American political spectrum is concerned. She celebrates MLK Day with those kids religiously. I mean, she is probably in her 60s. There is absolutely no contradiction to her.

Speaker: in her mind, between being a kind of relatively far-right evangelical who is, you know, with St. Paul on eschatology, and also being like, no, these are, even if in kind of sanitized form, important facts that need to be discussed. You know, this is, in a way, a difference with the moment we have now, where A lot of the time, say it might be a Gen X person tending towards Trump who puts out the the kind of colorblind idea or the ideal of, well, I was raised not to see these things as the defense against a certain more particularist or pessimistic, at least liberal wing of of American politics, if not further left than that. So it's it's a strange movie because i I completely agree with you that it gets someone like me very excited about the possibilities of

Speaker: of of what the left can be and and the way that it can you you can build solidarity across these difficult, particular historical questions that exist in the United States. But the way that that tradition is born by Americans since then, and including Gen X, who is the first generation to be raised on this movie, basically— where it it it doesn't break in the way that we would imagine it it might break, or the way that it would have broken in the 80s necessarily. I mean, obviously you would have had black particularists who probably would have taken issue with it, but I think even a a mainstream, you know Rainbow Coalition, Jesse Jackson probably would have had nice things to say about Corey. I don't know, but i would I would guess to some extent that's true. So it's it it occupies a very strange space in post-late 80s, early 90s American racial consciousness, because it it doesn't really...

Speaker: fit with any of the way these traditions have played out, which is part of what makes it so amazing to me. The first thing I would say is I just agree with a lot of that.

Speaker: I think it's a huge mistake. It's definitely a huge mistake of you know for people outside of America, but of course they get it from America ah to believe that you know the Democratic Party is like to the left of the Republicans. you know i don't I don't believe that.

Speaker: I think the Democratic Party's the enemy of the left in a fundamental way. And they're the old you they're the old ethnic constituency slash race hustle party.

Speaker: I appreciate what Marx would call the bourgeois socialism of of Lincoln or in even Teddy Roosevelt, even Nixon, even Trump.

Speaker: of, you know, basically, you know, the problem is jobs, we got to get people to work, right, we're going to solve the social question through capitalism. That's the the dominant voice of the Republican Party 150 years.

Speaker: ah And you know it first came a cropper on reconstruction. Anyone who tells you, i think, you know that it's like Northern capitalists, right? It's just Northern capitalists like asserting their interests in the Civil War and there's nothing idealistic about it.

Speaker: Well, the Northern capitalists didn't do very well when it came to industrializing the South or even industrializing Southern art agriculture. That took a very long time. And of course, that was ultimately what solved the race problem, ah is the industrialization of Southern agriculture, you know to the extent that it was resolved. I mean, I would say that these things are super opaque.

Speaker: Again, I'll ah refer to to my friend and older comrade, Adolf Reed, who said, you know the only thing that doesn't change about race in America is the way that we talk about it.

Speaker: I think to a significant extent, we're not entirely clear what society's even like anymore because of the absence of of a left that really has to engage it, really has to attempt to change it, has to work within it. you know The left is just an idea in some intellectuals' heads at this point.

Speaker: yeah So I would say, like, if I were to point it to any event that is contemporaneous with glory, I would look at the Yusuf Hawkins case in New York City in 1989, where a young black man and his friends go into an Italian American neighborhood and one of them gets shot because a bunch of Italian American young men think that they're there to ah date, you know white girls or something. And you know It's a horrific racial case in the late 80s in New York City.

Speaker: And it becomes a cause. It becomes the crucial question in the New York City mayor's race.

Speaker: And it defeats Ed Koch. And Ed Koch is a kind of... Proto-Trump in a lot of ways, I would say. He's a very funny character. he's a Yeah, he's a New York City Democrat, but very conservative, very law and order, like Trump.

Speaker: Also makes a claim that he's colorblind. right That he makes decisions based on you know the fiscal necessities and the practical necessities of rebuilding the city and you know serving everyone and doesn't want to engage in a kind of clientelist ethno-politics in New York City.

Speaker: you know And of course, the response to him is, No, actually, he is engaged in ethnic politics, just anti-black ethnic politics, just as people claim that Trump is a racist. And he says, no, I'm not playing your ethnic constituency politics game. I'm appealing to everyone.

Speaker: Right. I want to make America great for everyone. And I think that, um you know, my sympathy is always, you know, to the extent that I, you know, obviously I'm a leftist and I abstain, but i always have a certain sympathy to the party of Lincoln in the face of this old Confederate Jim Crow racket constituency politics of the Democrats, which i fucking despise, you know, and I think that, you know the communists liquidating into the Democrats through the popular front, through supporting the New Deal,

Speaker: ah was catastrophic for the American left, just as coarse as I think that Stalinism was catastrophic for the left worldwide. So, you know the American left is, ah of course, ah a super complicated animal. And we do have these two dominant parties. I would say they're two wings of the party of capital.

Speaker: And we don't have any alternative to that and haven't had for many generations. And so, you know, one can understand, you know, the pessimism of the working class and people, you know, turning to their you know families and communities and churches. And that can take on a kind of neighborhood racial solidarity for sure.

Speaker: But it's whipped up and enforced by the Democrats. Right. you think there's a missed opportunity sort of at the end of radical reconstruction to turn the Republican Party, as was in that period, into something, i mean and this is going to sound completely counterintuitive to some people, but to yeah to move it towards something like the Labour Party, i mean, this is the thing that's always shocked me about America, is the lack of a coherent, independent, you know sort of self-identified social democratic movement outside of liberalism.

Speaker: This is because I didn't teach you Marxism. Britain is the only first world country that's never had a socialist party. the The U.S. Civil War and Reconstruction is direct inspiration for the writing of Das Kapital by Karl Marx. It's invoked in the introduction, and it's also invoked in the chapter on the working day.

Speaker: where Marx talks about how Union soldiers and radical Republicans are raising the demand for the eight-hour day in Chicago and St. Louis as a direct result of the war.

Speaker: It's great. Back to the film. it's it's I mean, obviously, it's interesting. that The story is the 54th and the sort of how it centralizes on Robert Gould's rule. i mean, obviously he's historically prominent, but the particular era like that, that he's not just a white officer, he's at the particularity of him being a Northeastern, you know, transcendentalist. I think it's not made clear whether he's Congregationalist or a Unitarian, but it doesn't really matter on that sort of radical enlightenment.

Speaker: He's a Unitarian. Unitarian, yeah. i Was it David Brooks who called the Wasp the sort of like self-abolishing class? i Wait, I need to interrupt here, Sam, because this I didn't know this until I read about him on Wikipedia because I i did not know much about Goldshaw. tried to dig up stuff there and and some other brief places before I watched.

Speaker: I didn't realize this, but I guess he became involved in some way with Catholicism vis-a-vis an uncle who wanted to be a Jesuit and then died. I didn't see that, yeah. which I don't know what's on, because that's um bizarre for America. i mean, this does happen with certain figures, you know, often because it's it's quite countercultural to be Catholic in 19th century America. In other words, i I think that you can see that in a way as an outgrowth of the Unitarian thing, insofar as it represents a radical break with the the extant, you know, politics, religious and other otherwise as of of his society. But I mean, I also would would want to underline the point that

Speaker: There's a moment where another white officer who's commanding a black unit basically tells him to let his men or orders his men to pillage this small settlement where they only find women, basically. That guy, that guy is not, did not historically do that. But where is he from?

Speaker: They have come from Kansas in the in the in the movie, and he may have been there historically, I don't know. But the man himself, the name they use, is a guy who is from New Jersey. And New Jersey, my my home state, and proudly so, is a sort of a copperhead state. It's a democratically oriented state in the North. I mean, yeah, it's not 100% that, but it's a state that is not a part of this more radical New England tradition in the same way.

Speaker: obviously nothing is one way or the other 100%. But there is a certain sectional within the North split on these questions. It's why a lot of your post-Civil War presidents come from Ohio. They call the Ohio Dynasty. And this is because a lot of these radical Midwesterners serve in in the Civil War. They wave the bloody shirt, as it's called, which is basically to say, you guys killed a bunch of us. You don't get a say in matters in in the same way that we do. So it's I guess what I'm trying to say is,

Speaker: even in the movie, his New Englandness is highlighted, if only tacitly, by comparison with this New Jersey slash Kansas guy. So it is it is certainly important. The thing I found interesting about the presentation of Gould Shaw was this kind of, that he sort represented this self-abolishing class, which I think like people describe the wasps in America as being a self-abolishing class that, you know, sort of like create the American state and um in some ways, I mean, not entirely, and then hand it over or to sort of disappear from the historical stage. And it that feels like that that tendency is sort of present in this film.

Speaker: I'll just say on the Copperhead thing, I was thinking of George McClellan, who had come up and I think serve as governor of New Jersey. So yeah, we have a bit of a stain on our state in the immediate post-war years there. I mean, McClellan is not a great guy to bring into your you know government. like Like Wilson, we have a record with these things. What can I say?

Speaker: Right. I mean, I would say that um you know there's ah it's a conjuncture. There's a lot of strains within the politics of the country. you know i come from a very peculiar region of the South that was Republican, East Tennessee, which was basically placed under military occupation by troops from Nashville.

Speaker: A lot of the schools and monuments in my area are to Republican politicians who were hung by the Confederacy. So there's a very distinct sort of sub-regional memory My congressional district has voted Republican in every election since Abraham Lincoln was on the ballot. That's that's a long time. It's incredible. All right. and and In this way, Sam, it's very much like the English Civil War.

Speaker: Just as you can determine like which way some family is going to be politically in eighteen hundred based on which way they were in the English Civil War. Similarly, um yeah American politics still has this character. but after um yeah But there is a kind of preserved and formaldehyde aspect to that. um And what changes is, of course, America emerges as a second industrial revolution world power movement.

Speaker: in the post-Civil War era and ultimately embarks on a career of imperialism beginning with Spanish-American War, some of which could be viewed as having its roots in, you know, undefeated strains of the Civil War and ah dimensions of the subjugation of the Native Americans and the colonization of the West.

Speaker: All of those things are, you Of course, just ah riven by contradiction. And this gets to, I think, the difficulty of the movie. I mean, the movie is saturated with militarism and the symbolism of the flag.

Speaker: you know, the symbolism of the flag at the end, Denzel Washington, you know, saying, ain't fighting this war for you, sir.

Speaker: But still don't want to carry a flag. And then at the end, of course, takes up the flag from the dead hands of of Shaw, only to be killed himself.

Speaker: right But in that image, right the flag doesn't fall to the ground, which is part of the history of the regiment. right There's a kind of a myth ah or a story that's told that results. in the granting of the first medal of honor to an african-american soldier And it's his action in preserving the battle standard, the flag of the 54th Massachusetts at Fort Wagner, which supposedly never touched the ground.

Speaker: Right. Which was, which was brought back by a man who was severely wounded. Of course, a black soldier named Carney, who, who is sort of partially expressed in the Morgan Freeman character, partially expressed in the Denzel Washington character. He was a freed slave, who or rather an escaped slave, who had escaped the South via the Underground Railroad.

Speaker: And in that sense represented the most kind of demotic elements of of radical abolitionism. You know, the radical abolitionism of of, of the illiterate of Harriet Tubman and of the freed slaves.

Speaker: And glory is, it's on the one hand about an event, but it's also about freedom per se. And it's why the movie is not about like white people and black people.

Speaker: It's about the ensemble. It's about intellectuals or educated people, in this case, people with military education, bringing that to people who need it and those people who need it then taking up the cause, perhaps even more powerfully than those who imparted the cause or at least the necessary skills of the cause.

Speaker: right That all of these people... have sacrificed themselves their individuality to the project of emancipation. And that project of emancipation ultimately isn't like bourgeois or socialist in the U.S. Civil War.

Speaker: right It is simply the fate of the revolution. right And that's that's where I would say you that socialism gets it goes astray.

Speaker: because it thinks it's somehow not the same emancipation as the deep revolutionary project. You can learn, in other words, the the the movie Glory and the history of the Civil War can teach you as much about the question of freedom in the age of capital as can a study of the Bolshevik Revolution.

Speaker: I don't think we could ask for it because i I have to go to the dentist and then fight with some Democrats about a municipal budget. ah But i don't I don't know that we could ask for a better a better way to summarize the what what it is that Glory means and why it was a good to have on the podcast. Spence, I can't thank you enough. And also, I mean, is there anything you'd like to promote or anything coming out? or or Even if it's just your your course on South Asian history? No, I mean, I...

Speaker: I semi-regularly appear. I appear about once a month on a podcast on Sublation Media that is just an ah creatively called the Spencer Leonard Hour. I'd encourage people to listen to that.

Speaker: Thank you guys for having me. Thank you. It's been fun. it's been lot of fun. I should say, I really enjoyed getting talk to Spencer about this because Glory is, I think, the only movie this season that is this kind of sentimental blockbuster, basically. I mean, we have kids' films, we have other kinds of blockbuster, but Spencer's kind of able to find find it ah kind of an ideological kernel in there that becomes extremely interesting, at least it is to me.

Speaker: and I think as a sharp way through this podcast, I suddenly realized that my brain had turned to merch the last five years. That's what you said. i i don't agree. I feel like you had very like trenchant kind of journalist style questions. Yeah, but this is the con. This is the great con of journalism is that like that your reticence is ah confused for intelligence.

Speaker: I will say this. If you join our Patreon, Patreon slash death photo pod at the highest tier, I will send you a video of an episode of your choice where I'm wearing my full Oxford sub-fusk and black tie. perfect That might be the best place to leave it all. Anyway, see you guys next time.

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Recommended