Transcript
Speaker: Let the players help you. You don't have to shoulder the whole burden of making up world details yourself. Remember, the more collaborative you get, the more emotional investment the players are going to have in the result because they share it in its creation.
Speaker: All right, Mark has served up a steaming helping of ska today. I warned you. yeah For those of you that may not know what's going on here with our music cues, Every week we have the same lyrics, but in a brand new musical style chosen by our musical maestro, Mark Lehman. Oh, no there's no maestro, our musical maestro is Suno. That's right. It is AI -generated music. ah We have that in the show credits, so it shouldn't come as a surprise, but really fascinating what you can get this thing to do. This week on Tabletop Tune Up, I, Ben Dyer, along with the aforementioned Mark Lehman, are interviewing our
Speaker: friend and GM Dylan. Welcome, Dylan. Well, hello there. Thanks for having me. We are so pleased. Now this is going to be a little bit of a different kind of segment. Usually on this show, what we do is we take some topic and we kind of break it down a little bit and we lend some new insights or ideas to our topic. This time though, We're going to look for the insights from our guest. Dylan, first question for you. Tell us about how you got started in role -playing games. What drew you into this hobby? Yeah, so if we're talking role -play games in general, it's like a super broad topic, I guess, but specifically like tabletop role -play.
Speaker: Just purely by existing in the right place at the right time. I've been pretty fortunate to like maintain a ah Relatively large friend group like if if it exists someone in my friend group is like dabbled in it or is doing it and for whatever reason they had started um I think it was originally actually Pathfinder 2e like a campaign and they said hey, do you want to play with me? and like all of our friends, and I said, absolutely not. um as I would rather do anything else. And then enough time had passed by, and I was like, man, that was actually kind of rude to deal. Very. You know what? like How dare you? Yeah. If somebody asks me again, I will be open. I'll have an open mind to it, because I'm Despite the fact that you know I play so many hours of video games and like just just consume so much nerdy stuff, for whatever reason, I had like a disposition towards tabletop roleplay. I'm like, come on. There's no way you could do what my Baldur's Gate 3 could do. That's just ridiculous to think. but um wrong
Speaker: yeah So wrong, so unbelievably wrong. And then um I dabbled in it a bit. We we had super short campaign. The movie had like 10, 15 sessions. And I was like, wow, that was actually really, really fun. All of our characters were brutally murdered. I actually wasn't even there for like the day that everyone was brutally murdered. Oh, so it was you that ratted the party out. Basically, it was my fault. ah you know the The DM took control of my character during the tech site. I'd stepped out for like an hour or something. And everything hit the fan in that moment. And you know everyone was brutally murdered. And so I came back. I was like, oh, I'm dead? No, I ah guess that's the way she goes.
Speaker: And how long was the game you were in? So that game got broken up into two different games because the first game we all got murdered. That took like probably four to five months um just because, you know, I would say every third week we would just have to postpone or reschedule, which I think is just a common thing that happens in any tabletop group. There's there's a little bit of a method to our to our inquiry here, right? And that is that. Mark tells me that that GMing is actually kind of a newer thing for you. You haven't been doing it very super long and that actually makes you a really interesting person to talk to because you're bringing fresh insights and new ideas to this art and this craft. What what drew you to GMing? What was it that like made you want to GM?
Speaker: So it was just like, okay, I really enjoyed this like thing that we did with our D and &D campaign. The second time around when we did it, it petered out a bit. we I think we swapped to 5E. And then for like X amount of people couldn't show up and I was like, you know what? I actually like that. I want to keep doing that. And the best way to ensure that I get to keep enjoying this experience is to host it myself. Because when you host it yourself, you you have like full creative control. So when I just like threw out a feeler in my group, like, hey, who wants to join? Overwhelming responses, like 10 to 15 people being like, oh, I want to play. And me being like, OK, well, I can't read. There's no universe that I can manage a 10 to 15 person table with no experience. So um I did a little bit of research and came away with the idea of, OK, the game is designed for roughly like four to five players, like five, b particularly.
Speaker: Um, but there are ways to stretch it to seven eight nine. It's a bit more difficult So I took some time to really looked up the like the pitfalls ahead of time to make sure that like, you know Oh, I just had a quick quick question. Are you talking about in person or are you talking about like online? How are you playing this? Strictly online we have done in person a few times because you know once or twice a year I get all my friends together and like we all meet up and do things together um I would prefer in person. I think that in person is like a thousand times more fun in my experience But if you have people live, you know all around the world so it's it's tough but everything that I do is online interesting so some of us started playing these things before there was an available internet set of services that could support it and so if you didn't have that
Speaker: that local group, you kind of just were out of luck. And then you had to kind of poke around and see who among your friend group might be into this and who wasn't hip to it. COVID certainly changed a lot of this. So yeah, just based on my research too, like you can literally see like the the marking of like when these tools and things became so much more available and like sort of the um the infrastructure around like online D and &D really cranking up like and becoming an industry and it's like tons of tools are available and it's really easy to get started if you're willing to like just spend some time looking into things. You say learning new things, what tool do you use for your your games? I would say Reddit's probably my most used tool. YouTube videos are pretty great. So that's your research tool. What are you using when you actually run these games online though? Oh, my tool! Uh, so Foundry VTT. I got into that because that was just the thing that my friend had used initially when introducing me to our first online game.
Speaker: And I was like, oh, how much is it? you know until I was like $60 or something. I was like, OK. Well, let me start looking into like what other tools exist. A price tag on something doesn't always necessarily mean it's the highest quality or like the best tool. In my experience, Foundry is definitely worth the money. I am a massive fan of of what that toolkit can do. um but But there are also other tools that I've you know purchased over the ah the year or two that I've been doing this. I'm going to second your agreement on the know the things you can do in Foundry. i I've used it as well. The one thing I like about that particular program, I actually enjoy working in it. like It's a fun thing to build in, and I didn't and don't think I had that with other VTTs.
Speaker: When you started GMing, what were some of the fun surprises? What were the things that you didn't maybe know to expect, but when you sat down for that first game, you got done and you went, Oh, Hey, you know what? That was something I didn't know to look for that I thought was really cool. So I actually had the inverse of that. So I guy did so much research prior. So there were very few things that surprised me. There were a lot of things that I learned very quickly um in terms of like how to control the flow of things and like you know you'd be surprised how long you can plan for one scene to be and then how quickly that it can be a 15 second adventure and they leave or it's two and a half hours and you're like, wow.
Speaker: I guess I don't have to prepare for next week because, you know, two and a half hours talking to Joe here and he was supposed to be there for a minute. I think we've all had that experience where the party spends an inordinate amount of time on the wrong side of a door. Yes. And I've actually learned to embrace that. It's one of the first things I read about the idea of like, you know, if you if you want to tell a story or whatever, like go write a book. you know If you're GMing, you're you're sort of you're acting as the vehicle for the players fun, and you've got to sort of make decisions with them in mind. And so a lot of my GMing has been shaped by, okay, sure, this might be the most logical thing to happen, but are are they going to have fun if like this is the immediate thing that happens? And then so there's a lot of like conversations with each of my groups that I host about, like what are you looking for?
Speaker: And now I'm more shifting towards, ah again, the inverse of that, where I'm like, hey, here's what I want. Here is the theme. Here are the types of ramifications that happen. Here are the types of characters I'm looking for. And if you want that, you can join. My first you know three or four groups are for the player, and now my like fifth and so on and so forth are for me. That's the balance that we're all kind of looking for. it Because let's face it, ah as a GM, you need to have fun, too. Because like if you're not having fun, how can you expect them to be having fun? I find that, too. like When I pick up and run a game, it's going to be something that i want I want to run. And if the players aren't down for that, then maybe somebody else can GM. Yeah, 100%. I think that is kind of ah it's interesting to put it that way, because even though it is a kind of a service profession, it's got to be a service you want to do.
Speaker: It is art and you know if you're miserable you know trying to make art, you're just not going to make good art. That's so true. You've been doing this for a little while now. What things do you struggle with consistently? oh that so That's a tough one actually. When you're managing you know five to eight players and I'm running five groups and you're trying to manage schedules, I guess that can be an issue. When I was running two groups, we're meeting every week and we're figuring it out, okay? This will continue every week. Now it's like, okay, you know what? We can't do it this week. That's fine. I've got five other games to run. I don't got time to you know manage six people's schedules. you know You show up and we go. I used to also... Oh, one person's not here? We're not going. And now it's like, sorry, dog, you know, you weren't here. We're moving on. bed This is this is why this is a young man's game. I gotta tell you, he said five groups. I run two groups. And I swear to God, I i feel like I'm pulling my hair out every week trying to come up with new stuff.
Speaker: I'm fortunate enough that I'm so new to this, like, game that right now it's we're endless. We've got a never -ending flow of ideas. I'm always writing something down. And an idea might be something as simple as, like, you know, goblin being walked like a dog. That becomes a character that, like, everyone loves and I end. I try and set all of my games in the same universe, too. um Around the same areas etc. Obviously people have spread out from those like centralized locations But it's very fun to be able to like have one group build up a character and I've got a fleshed out NPC that they are they're never gonna meet again that you can like Put somewhere else and it makes sense and you've had tons of experience fleshing them out so a lot of my ideas yeah are influenced by the group and just what what they turn the characters into and Well, one of the things I think is neat about that is that you're actually economizing on all of your production. So you build an NPC or you build a location or whatever, and one group might encounter a slice of that one week and then a different group on some other occasion, maybe not even soon after that.
Speaker: 100%. There are characters that, you know, I made the first day that I was playing, and I had them written out, and we were gonna... Steve the Butcher was gonna be a huge part of the first session, and we never went to the butcher shop. And then six, seven months later, they're like, is there a butcher shop in town? And I'm like, you you bet there is. There's a guy named Steve, and he's he's been ready to go. And you know what, another thing too, you mentioned that, you know, the the players, they pick which NPCs are the are the ones that are gonna stick around. They pick them. Yeah, I've had tons of one -off characters, and I'm like, okay, how do I introduce this concept? How do how do I logically give you guys a different... ah Okay, this guy shows up, and he tells you this, and he's about to leave, and they're like, wait, little guy, we wanna talk to you. And now he's just been in the group for eight months, and I'm like, i this was just a guy that was meant to tell you, go left. I wanna go back for just a moment.
Speaker: One of the things that we are really keen on in this show is that we are here to encourage people who are maybe a little concerned, trepidatious about taking on that GM task. What is your advice for the person who is brand new, they've got some concerns, you know, they got all the books, they've done their homework, but they're kind of going, I'm a little freaking out about that first session. Go watch The Wizard of Oz, because that is the perfect analogy. The wizard, the grant, he's such a scary character. And then you finally look behind the curtain, and he's just a dude. But the players can't, they have no idea how much you've prepped. They don't know what you know. And as long as you're just confident in your delivery of ideas and concepts, they can come away with that being like, wow, you were so prepared and knew it was like, no, I woke up an hour late, had no time to prep. And I wrote Goblin in a trench coat on a piece of paper. And that was what how we went with today.
Speaker: Yeah, you don't you don't lack confidence for for anything, so. Be confident and do your best, and don't be afraid to mess up. I promise you, your players are there to have fun. They're not there to be like, um actually, you said it was a two and a half hour trek, and it's only been two hours. It's like, okay, well, sorry, dog, i my bad. Yeah, confidence is a huge theme, I think, in being a good GM. And I like your point that like players aren't sitting around you know looking to score points on you. I think a lot of people also have that concern. Hey, I'm a newer GM. I'm sitting down at a table with
Speaker: people that are more experienced maybe know the system better, they've had more experience with this. As somebody who is newer, obviously that confidence goes a long way and I think it probably makes it easier to work with those people that are more experienced. But how do you kind of manage or engage with players that are deeper into this? uh... so the for the first thing is just being comfortable being wrong and being like pots you know that there are tons of moments where i say something if those are actually this is how it's real to go be willing to be flexible you might have a goal that you're going for or or a way you want to rule something but if people are like no here are the rules and here's how i think you have to accept that and you move on it being rigid is like
Speaker: the worst thing you can do if you're trying to have like the game go smoothly, if you're willing to just completely 180 on a dime because someone is like, actually, here's are the rules and you know it's okay, you didn't know that. No one's going to get mad at you for not knowing something. There there's there are a lot of moments where i am you know someone is actually, you um there's a verbal component to this. I'm like, oh, never mind. yeah that's You've got to be willing to learn. And that's a big part of jamming. That's part of being a player too. But bent Dylan, there's something you do that I think is really unique. You utilize something with Discord. Can you tell us a little bit how you use Discord?
Speaker: This has evolved like so much more the more I do it. um I would say it's actually a lot less now because what has happened is those people have now just started their own campaigns with me. So the the first campaign, you know throw out the net, a lot of people want to join. It's like, okay, you know again, there's just there's a a limit on the amount of people that I can interact with at a time and give like a fair amount of screen time to, because you know you don't want to have a scenario where like two people just haven't said anything for two sessions. So I came up with the idea of like, okay, what would happen if I brought on guests and like, you're this character, you're only there for 15 minutes, you're gonna do this? Obviously sometimes, you know, you're there for two hours because it's goblin and a trench coat, it's a great idea. So it just, it started with people would just sit in the channel and we'd have like, you know, 10 to 15 people just like listening. I used to be a lot more strict about like who even had permission to talk.
Speaker: um That also naturally segued into a pretty nice way to introduce special guests because oh there's a goblin in a trench coat and they go to approach it. Suddenly someone that's been in the channel for an hour speaks up and they're like I had no idea it was gonna be this person and it's a fun little experience. I do that less and less now just because I've really gotten good at structuring things and having the time in my schedule to just host more games. It started originally as a way to um include people without having them to have to commit to, you know, hey, we're going to be playing once a week for three -ish hours. And not everyone can commit to that. But a lot of people can commit to, you know, just tuning in for 15 minutes or being like, hey, can I be a character? Like, absolutely. Who do you want to be? There's a lot of, you know, people messaging me saying, here's a concept for a character.
Speaker: Could I be this little guy for 15 minutes? It's like, absolutely. I can find a way to have, you know, Doug, the traveling merchant show up and he like, oh, you want to sell these? Sure. You've got this whole thing. Absolutely. Have have fun with it. You know, one thing I love love about this idea, too, is if you're an audience member, if you're watching, how much does that make you want to actually play so much? Yeah. Yeah, I do remember back when I was in college, I had a roommate who was just, I won't play D &D. I won't play these games. He's too nerdy. And he just had this attitude about this. But every Saturday, my friends would get together, we'd be playing, and he could hear us. And this went on for a few months. And all of a sudden, he came out of the room and he slammed down a notepad and goes, I'm making a character. I'm in this game.
Speaker: Yeah, no, that happens so frequently. Again, the the the Discord audience thing really just evolved into, how many games can I reasonably run without making me want to pull my hair out? And every time I add a new one, I think it's going to be too much. But I actually, it's fine. The more that I add, the easier it gets. Because people love to tell you things and give you ideas. And it is not hard to listen to someone talk for 15 minutes and they give you all these great ideas and then just implementing them somewhere else. You know, just community is like the most important thing or or like collaboration and being willing to like take in people's ideas. Something you're talking about, which I think is really cool and really interesting and I want to draw attention to because it's it might not jump out at people is you're very confident when you're at the table.
Speaker: And I can tell by the the quality of your responses here to our different questions that you've you've got plenty to say. But I'm also hearing that you spend a lot of time listening. And I think that's a really great point. And so you're using your good judgment to balance those things and make sure that you're getting as much from the players as you're giving. Yeah. I mean, it was also just like the the fundamental idea behind my D and &D sessions has really just become like, I am a vehicle for the players. And it's super important to know what they want, what they're interested in. And being able to feel out, like, okay, I had an idea for today's session, but I can see you guys really like the idea of this other random thing I had zero preparation to make, so we're going there instead. That's where some of the real fun stuff is, though, is those little random detours that you didn't expect. And I wonder if part of that fun is, you know, you had mentioned earlier about how the game has to be fun for you.
Speaker: I just have fun any time my players are having fun, especially because I get to have my own separate game that's like, hey, here's what I want. So it's very easy for me to just have fun with what everyone wants to do and just making sure that like everyone is getting along. It's very hard to manage that many personalities. Any research you do on DMing online, you'll find like horror stories of like groups that just tear themselves apart. I've never had that issue. but like I've also gone out of my way to, okay, what might be a contention? Okay, these people seem to be bickering whenever this type of moral conundrum comes up and like how they want to resolve it. So instead, we'll we'll just find a different kind of thing to resolve that doesn't involve like the three of you arguing the philosophy of letting the goblins go. Because if you' a say if you're actually getting too invested in the fate of these goblins and whether or not they deserve a 15th chance or not,
Speaker: We'll go somewhere else because we don't need to be arguing during our like having fun time. That's great. Well, these are great answers. And ah now it's time for us to move on to our tune -up segment. But we're going to do it a little bit differently because this is our GM interview episode with Dylan. And instead of us tuning up somebody else's stuff, we're going to ask Dylan to tune us up. So Dylan, here is our tune -up question for you. We have a small discord that's the one we use to play our games, and it's got about 16 players or so in it. And we play maybe three to four different games at any given time. And so we're thinking about how we might be able to bring in occasional guests, cameos and so forth to our games, specifically into the games they're not already playing in, obviously.
Speaker: What kind of ground rules do you use for that? What do you tell the players? And this is maybe just as important as when that happens, how do you know if that's going well or poorly? OK, so so it depends on what your goal is, right? If your long term goal is you want to introduce this person and then integrate them into that group long term. So going from four players to five players, that is significantly different than. going from four players, having five for a session, going back to four. um if If you're going for like just the one -off, like you're here to play a character and dabble in the idea of roleplay. There are several ways you can do it. You can sit down with them ahead of time and say, hey, the game isn't necessarily about you. You're part of the production now. Your goal is to facilitate fun for them. Here are your goals.
Speaker: Give them a list of things they ought to be doing. But if you're trying to long -term integrate them or just introduce them to D and &D as a concept, I would say the session prior, talk to your group and say, hey, how do you guys feel about you know adding a new player if it's just for a session? And then layout how you want to introduce them. You don't have to do that. You could certainly just spring it on them. Spontaneity is always fun. But just as long as everyone is sort of aiming for the same goal or or is aware of of what they ought to be doing, But as for specifically how to integrate them, I guess, I've always just been like, you come across Steve on the road, he's a nice guy and you know he he needs help changing the tire on his car. And usually things evolve from there. It might be a bit slow at first. As for knowing whether or not somebody is going well or going poorly, I would hope you would know ahead of time how well your friends will mesh.
Speaker: Obviously, immediate hostility would be a great indicator of things going poorly. It's like, Oh, it's Paul. I hate that guy. Exactly. And I've had situations very similar to that where I've introduced someone and maybe three or four hours of the group are just like, how do we like just mash a through this dialogue to get this NPC to go away? um And you know, you you just roll with the punches and you just try and resolve it as fast as possible. And like, thanks for coming on, you know, Paul, goodbye and try to integrate them somewhere else. Cause again, not everyone's going to get along and it doesn't have to be like a big fight. You can just, you know, amicably separate them, give them their moment and then move on. Hey, Dan, you know what? This has been a real pleasure to talk to you about this, this stuff. And I'd love to get you back in to hear about your crazy game and see what's going on with your, with your troops.
Speaker: Everybody, that's it for this week. This is another episode of Tabletop Tune Up. This is one of our first GM interviews, and Dylan, we'd just like to thank you for dropping by. If you have ideas that you would like to get tuned up, Go ahead and email us at tabletoptuneup at gmail dot .com. They could be NBCs. They could be encounters. They could be bits of world building or questions about how to manage your table. Everything that the GM does is fair game. So we'd love to hear from you. Also, if you get a minute and you like what you're hearing and you'd like to help us understand if we're doing a good job for you, drop rating, maybe some comments. Let us know what you'd like more of wherever you find this podcast. So that's it for this week. And until next time.
Speaker: Keep those days rolling. Toon up Level up your fun toon up Your quest is now begun Toon up We'll show you how it's done Toon up, toon up Toon up, toon up Toon up, toon up
Speaker: Tune up, tune up, tune up.
Speaker: Tune up, level up your fine tune up. Your quest is now begun! Tuna! We'll show you how it's done! Tuna! Tuna! Tuna! Tuna! Tuna! Tuna! Tuna!
Speaker: Tuna!

