Transcript
Speaker: Welcome to Sicily, Alaska, a Northern Exposure podcast.
Speaker: I'm Anne Flynn Terrell. I'm a cabaret performer and MC. I'm Caleb Cohart. I'm a documentary and commercial filmmaker. I'm Amy Gerlich. I own and run a improv and sketch comedy theater in Denver, Colorado.
Speaker: This is a podcast where we talk about Northern Exposure and how it's affected our lives. And we have some amazing special guests. Season 5, Episode 10, First Snow.
Speaker: This episode came out on my birthday 1993 when i turned years old Your birthday's coming up. Fun fact. And we just had our first snow here in Denver, which is wild. It was after Thanksgiving. Wild. One of my friends said, it was this really beautiful saying. She was like, nature has finally unburdened herself.
Speaker: I was like, oh I love that. It was a good snow too. Yeah, it was. ah Joel goes and gets locks from one of his patients, um Nedra, and she tells him she's dying next week sometime. She's waiting until her daughter and her family gets there from Boston.
Speaker: Ed comes in and tells Holling about someone who is going to die soon. He keeps track as the mayor so he can dig enough graves before the ground freezes. Also, when did Holling become mayor again? When did he become mayor again?
Speaker: I had the same question because he lost to what's her face. Yeah, lost to what's her face. Maybe she just died in an episode we didn't get to see. But also it's like it was such a long time and. It's only been two or 30 years, one or the other. Yeah, um true.
Speaker: Joel, of course, thinks his preemptive grave digging is morbid instead of practical. Maurice gives Shelley... think it's a great idea I think they should always leave a couple extra holes in ground.
Speaker: Yeah, absolutely. it's It's one of those moments of ah people looking at him like, you're an idiot, Joel. This is Alaska. These are the things we need to do.
Speaker: Joel, of course, ah sorry, Maurice gives Shelly a super expensive rattle that the baby shouldn't actually touch until it's over. So disconnected from reality right here, Maurice. Yep. Maurice tells Shelly he still remembers when she told him she loved him.
Speaker: She says, um yo, that never happened. Even before that, he says, I remember when you belonged to me. Maurice is yeah straight up skis in this episode. It's gross. It is a really awful...
Speaker: i don't like it i don't like what they did with maurice in this episode i mean they always have to bring this back for some reason yeah they've got to always bring this back it's like he cannot let this go or the writers can't it's just something they need to always constantly be bringing back yeah we're done it's over it's been more than three years since she left him him and hauling have completely reconciled she's now married and pregnant like nine months pregnant at this point it's just move on bro yeah it was like other storylines that we could talk about like maurice can get bent out of shape about so many other things we could go back to the space program we could talk about his bad business deals like we could talk about so much else but we have to go back to shelley i again you do somethings ski the space program though like he just can't move on exactly yeah this is a man that can't move on he was with samansky longer than shelly for christ's sake yeah and they actually had a real connection and were appropriately aged oh my god so anyways nedra is still giving things away to people and joel is angry about it he is pissed um maurice is back on his bullshit about shelly it's two-week relationship why why ah why is this happening again we don't know shelly wakes up and thinks her nose is bigger we got the pinocchio syndrome happening joel goes back to nedra's house and her family from boston is there he tells them she's not dying everyone should stop encouraging her thinking this
Speaker: I actually applaud her in this. i At first in this episode, I thought Joel is just young and selfish with this regard. My opinion about his perspective changes later in the episode.
Speaker: But her just knowing, like, I've lived my time. I'm good. My grandmother did something extremely similar. And in retrospect, it's just, it was beautiful. It was was like, yeah, this is my time. I know. I'm will i'm ready.
Speaker: Yeah, and if you recognize it and you get to go out on your terms, great. this i I was pulling for her this whole thing. Well, yeah, she knew what she was about.
Speaker: Like she was close to her death. Like she had lived her life. She knew that it was about to be done and she wasn't in pain. Like she just, yeah, she had some stiff bones, but that was it. I, I love, I always loved the representation of death in this show. It was just another great show about death. Yep.
Speaker: I love the i don't know if you would even can call it the C-plot of everyone eating in excess and bulking up in the episode. Yeah, that was great. All the food. They're like all hibernating. ah All the food looked amazing. looked so good. That slice of cake. That white cake, it looked so good. It made me, when ah I went grocery shopping like a couple days later, i bought a similar looking piece of cake because I was just like, it looked so good. did give me one in pasta.
Speaker: Yeah, oh it just looked so good. um And then Shelly just gaslighting Maurice throughout this episode was just so funny. And she's tortured by yeah. oh um and joel he takes it hard he is like yeah he takes it hard hard yeah i don't and it's hard to even understand why he does this i know he was hanging on to this idea that she once said that she loved me but this is like shakespearean in proportion this is blown so out of reality
Speaker: that you almost lose a lot of respect for him as a character in this episode. But you know what? It's a great... I feel like it's such a good example of gaslighting because you watch him...
Speaker: like unravel in a way where you're like he buys into it he's he knows he knows it happened then he's fully convinced because he he is so in love with her that he's like she can't be lying to me she can't be lying to me i must be the one that's wrong you know it is such a good example um and he is such a good actor You're just like, damn, that it it is it's just so well done. um
Speaker: Joel's just racking his brain over Nedra and her theory on her winding down and dying. She just knows. ah He will not accept that it's not backed by science.
Speaker: Of course, because he needs everything to be backed by science. Shelly goes to see Maurice and gives him a pie and he's a mess. She's a wreck, but still gaslighting him again. Great scene. She and you can tell that she's even rattled to the core by his acting in this scene.
Speaker: I guess I'll mention Maggie's weird decorating attempt. Like the whole, they keep bringing it into the episode, but for some reason I'm just, I don't care. And there's the whole chair thing. Yeah.
Speaker: It's interesting. Yeah. The chair, the chair plays in the last scene. Um, They did in her decorating her house, like everybody else is fattening up and she's redecorating her house. They did throw out a cool little Twin Peaks reference because Ed came in and saw the one red wall and he was like, oh, very David Lynch. No, he didn't say very David Lynch. Didn't he say very, I thought he said very.
Speaker: Twin Peaks. I thought. No, thought he said there endless highway. Oh, what did he say, i thought he said the movie. No, he didn't say endless highway. Okay. Um, But then so he was delivering the chair. And so this is how the chair plays.
Speaker: Ed sits in the chair. Maggie really likes this chair. By the way, it was peak mid-90s. It was godly. Oh, yeah. God awful ugly, but Ed sits in it, looks like a comfortable chair and something's off.
Speaker: He doesn't fit. He's ah square peg in a round hole. Right. And then a little bit later, Chris comes in and sits in the chair.
Speaker: Doesn't fit. Something's not right. He's ah right. He's a triangle peg in a round hole. Doesn't fit. We're going to get to where this fits, but I just want to tease the audience here because the chair plays off in the last scene.
Speaker: Ed uses his first movie reference instead of a parable to Shelly to help
Speaker: ah her with Maurice's problem. His shaman work is starting to blossom. ah Joel comes to see Nedra, but she passed away an hour before he got there.
Speaker: Yeah. His first patient he lost that he really How is that possible? How that possible? Well, he even says to himself, this is the first patient really knew. Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker: this is where my opinion of him changed in this one, where at first I thought, oh, he's just being selfish. He's being the Joel we've all come to know and not love. And then throughout this, he starts to really think like there is something wrong with her. He even says to, so I forget who he's in the office with. I think it was Marilyn. He's like, I'm not a good enough doctor to cure her.
Speaker: It's starting to really hit him. And then you start to see in this, like he is torn up and he even admits in this scene that I've treated this woman for three years. I've known her. I've gotten to know her intimately.
Speaker: i know her family. She's a part of my life. And now she's gone and I couldn't save her. i love Ruthann. She's the one that met Joel and Ruthann, like she always does, can put it in perfect perspective. She's like, good God, Joel, you're just a doctor. It was her time.
Speaker: was man, well done. Way to like take him off the God pedestal and put him back in humanity. Cause even Ruthann's like, you did everything you could buddy, but you know, we're all just human.
Speaker: Now get in here and sign the death certificate, do the job you can do. I thought it was a great scene and I really liked how this humanized Joel. We're starting to see this though, right? Like,
Speaker: we're starting to see like little slivers of humanity sliding into Joel, which are gonna pay off here in another season. half a
Speaker: We got another timeline check. Joel says it's been three years. So we're halfway through season five and it's only been three years. I feel like they've been paused in year three for about three seasons now. Yeah. a Yeah. That feels about right.
Speaker: Yeah. so we we have a shot of marie's destroying the gazebo and to destroy or does he actually start it because like he's got the bulldozer he does he knocks her over air' into it he does he goes down he goes through it when she's screaming and she comes up screaming saying she she said it she she said she loved him she runs up she tells him the truth But she um she's not that girl anymore. That's what she says. Yeah, she's like so in love with Hauling.
Speaker: And what I found even more ridiculous about Maurice, he doesn't care. he's like, oh, cool. no I don't care if you're in love with me now. I just cared that you were then.
Speaker: I'm glad I'm not losing my mind over the fact that you one time said you loved me when I possessed you. Facts. I mean, that's a thing. Yeah. Yeah. Joel visits Maggie and he likes Maggie's chair.
Speaker: Let's talk about it. Ground peg, round hole. This is the payoff. And this is why this was the big plot point because we are finally after either six seasons, five seasons or three years, we're finally getting to the point of, well, they won't they. And we're getting, we're inching closer and closer to the, they will. Yeah.
Speaker: But it's unprompted. He's really comfortable. So it's like, so it's like is that is that why? is that the whole point of this subplot is to show us that Joel is the one?
Speaker: i think so. I just viewed it as she was getting more boring. I didn't because she and Joel were together, were meant to be. i just viewed it as like he was starting to rub off on her in an uncomfortable way.
Speaker: Well, and you know, he has taken a journey over the last few episodes. I would say this season, like you are starting to see some cracks of humanity. And I don't know if it was the writers finally doing this, Rob Morrow chilling out in general, the contract disputes they were going through at this point and him wanting to try to get something else out of this.
Speaker: The Thin Red Line, I believe, which was supposed to be his huge breakout Hollywood movie, utterly flopped. So maybe he was humbled at this point in his career. I don't know what happened, but there was a clear shift in him. We still get, listeners, don't worry. You still get plenty of annoying Rob Morrow in northern exppe Northern Exposure Season 5. But there's something happening.
Speaker: And yeah, something's shifting with them. I don't know if they were like forcing the whole Ross Rachel. Well, they won't they issue here, but i I saw this as a nice, clever play on... Because why else would she have Ed sit in the chair?
Speaker: Doesn't fit. It's the... You know, it's the um Goldilocks thing. That's what I thought. quite right for me. Not quite right for me. and This one's just right. That's what I thought it was. But I was like, but I don't get why it's a Goldilocks thing. Because we have the... He's the forage.
Speaker: But that's the thing. It's like, okay, if it's the rule of threes, we have the Pinocchio story. We have the Goldilocks thing. But I was like, but what's the Goldilocks thing?
Speaker: Like, why? What is it? What's the payoff here? And then I was like, so what's the third one? And then I couldn't find the third one. But I figured it was like had something to do with Nedra.
Speaker: Right? Like, was it like a Sleeping Beauty thing? Or was it like a, like, what was the fairy tale there? you know? It had to have been something.
Speaker: This episode in its A plot, again, feels like a great Northern exposure episode. And then its B plot feels like another forcing of something relationship. trend Actually, both a and B plot I like. This is the C plot that I don't care for.
Speaker: Yeah. Yeah, it feels left out of left field. Joel... it gives joel a respite and a closure after his plot with Nedra.
Speaker: But it could just be that, yeah, it's a weird forcing together. Yeah, I don't know. i Or it could just be. Yeah. He's the only one that finds it comfortable. Or they were just trying to force a Goldilocks theme because they had the exactly Pinocchio thing, which is not really a fairy tale either. Anyway, so the snow is falling and everybody's coming out and enjoying it. And everyone's saying, Bonnie Bear. um Maggie touches Joel's face delicately.
Speaker: and weirdly so i looked this up because i had not heard the expression boni ver before um and i was like why are they saying the musician's name over and over and over again i looked it up um justin vernon is boni ver he saw this episode and named his musical project boni ver after this episode really he loved that phrase that phrase literally means good winter in french and he loved that expression so much that that's why he chose to name his musical project bear oh i didn't know that so it's just like eve six and that x-files episode
Speaker: Okay. There's an X-Files episode called Eve Six, and that's where the band took their name from. Nice. Cool. Nice. That's all I got.
Speaker: Same. And you got some musical trivia on top. So for your next trivia night, you guys are set. Set.
