Become a Creator today!Start creating today - Share your story with the world!
Start for free
00:00:00
00:00:01
Under the Banyan Tree – What can China learn from Japan in the '90s?
48 Plays2 years ago
It's an ongoing debate in markets and economics: is China going the way of Japan in the 1990s? Fred Neumann and Herald van der Linde discuss the various points for and against, plus the lessons China can learn from its fellow leading Asian economy. Disclaimer: https://www.research.hsbc.com/R/51/wJTWhRk Stay connected and access free to view reports and videos from HSBC Global Research follow us on LinkedIn https://www.linkedin.com/feed/hashtag/hsbcresearch/ or click here: https://www.gbm.hsbc.com/insights/global-research.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Recommended
Transcript
Introduction to HSBC Global Viewpoint
00:00:02
Speaker
Welcome to HSBC Global Viewpoint, the podcast series that brings together business leaders and industry experts to explore the latest global insights, trends, and opportunities.
00:00:13
Speaker
Make sure you're subscribed to stay up to date with new episodes.
00:00:16
Speaker
Thanks for listening.
00:00:17
Speaker
And now onto today's show.
00:00:24
Speaker
This is a podcast from HSBC Global Research, available on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
00:00:30
Speaker
Search for HSBC Global Viewpoint or join us via the HSBC Global Banking and Markets page on LinkedIn.
00:00:36
Speaker
However you're listening, analyst notifications, disclosures and disclaimers must be viewed on the link attached to your media player.
Is China following Japan's 1990s economic path?
00:00:52
Speaker
Welcome to another episode of Under the Banyan Tree, where we put Asian markets and economics in context.
00:00:57
Speaker
I'm Fred Newman, Chief Asia Economist.
00:01:00
Speaker
And I'm Harold van der Linde, Head of Asian Equity Strategy.
00:01:03
Speaker
On today's show, we tackle one of the great economic debates facing the region.
00:01:07
Speaker
Is China heading the way of Japan in the 1990s?
00:01:11
Speaker
We'll be comparing the macro and micro environments for both economies, including how issues like income levels, demographics and government policy are all stirring the debate.
00:01:20
Speaker
Absolutely.
00:01:21
Speaker
All that and more coming up right here on The Banyan Tree.
00:01:41
Speaker
Let's kick off with some historical context.
00:01:44
Speaker
Throughout the 1980s, Japan was booming.
00:01:46
Speaker
Nikkei index valuations were really high.
00:01:48
Speaker
Japanese equities had done very well.
00:01:51
Speaker
But in the 1990s, the bubble burst and years of rapid growth gave way to a sharp decline that took well over a decade to bottom out.
00:01:58
Speaker
Fred, let's start a conversation at the macro level.
00:02:00
Speaker
What parallels do you see between Japan back then and China right now?
00:02:05
Speaker
There are parallels there, and obviously pundits recently have taken this up as a theme that perhaps the mainland Chinese economy is going the way that Japan has because of these parallels that they are seeing.
Real estate bubbles and debt: Japan vs. China
00:02:17
Speaker
Now, some of these parallels are that Japan, for example, in the 1980s had an enormous real estate bubble with prices for not just residential real estate, but for commercial real estate also soaring up.
00:02:31
Speaker
And of course, that bubble deflated in the 1990s, and for three decades, the Japanese economy barely grew in aggregate.
00:02:39
Speaker
And obviously, there's a parallel that some people argue that perhaps China is looking at a similar risk because its real estate market is now looking very strong.
00:02:48
Speaker
soggy indeed.
00:02:49
Speaker
And so is that going to lead to another maybe lost decade in China?
00:02:54
Speaker
But it's not the only parallel.
00:02:56
Speaker
It's also the debt that is associated with it.
00:02:59
Speaker
So in the 1980s, you saw in Japan a giant amount of debt burden
00:03:05
Speaker
among households, for example.
00:03:07
Speaker
Similarly, in China, we've seen a big rise in debt as well coming through.
00:03:12
Speaker
And of course, there's now talk that perhaps China could go into a debt deflation period or what some analysts deem a balance sheet recession.
00:03:22
Speaker
That is that the value of collateral, that is real estate is declining, but you're left with a lot of debt.
00:03:27
Speaker
And because of that mismatch, it's a disinflationary
Policy responses: Japan then and China now
00:03:31
Speaker
problem.
00:03:31
Speaker
And then there's another paradigm
00:03:33
Speaker
Parallel here is worth mentioning, and that is the actually very weak policy response, at least initially in the 1990s.
00:03:41
Speaker
So Japan didn't go forth in terms of stimulus, at least initially.
00:03:48
Speaker
Yes, they eased monetary policy, but actually on the fiscal side, 1990s, they were a bit more cautious because they thought this is only two or three years and then we'll go back to our growth rate.
00:03:58
Speaker
That's what you get after these kind of bubble periods, right?
00:04:00
Speaker
That you think, oh yeah, we have a small correction, but
00:04:03
Speaker
This is a structural trend.
00:04:04
Speaker
It will go on.
00:04:05
Speaker
And therefore, the policy response can be a bit.
00:04:07
Speaker
And we see arguably some of that in mainland China now, at least according to some observers, that maybe the policy is not large enough.
00:04:14
Speaker
But Harold, there are other parallels certainly as well.
00:04:18
Speaker
Demographics might be one of those.
00:04:20
Speaker
Yeah, there are actually very interesting parallels.
00:04:23
Speaker
First of all, both countries are aging.
00:04:25
Speaker
Japan, of course, is more aged society now than China, but if you go back 20 years ago, it was actually fairly similar to where China is at the moment.
00:04:33
Speaker
But there are other parallels as well.
00:04:35
Speaker
For example, you can deal with aging, with getting immigration in certain countries.
00:04:40
Speaker
The US is very good in that, but both Japan and China don't really have a history of large immigration.
00:04:48
Speaker
And another parallel on the demographic front is probably the role of women in society.
00:04:54
Speaker
In China actually a lot of women work.
00:04:56
Speaker
Female labor participation rates are really high, below amongst the highest on the planet.
00:05:03
Speaker
In Japan that was not the case actually in the 90s, but more recently it's gone up.
00:05:07
Speaker
It's one of the ways that they've tried to deal with declines in labor that more women have started to work.
00:05:13
Speaker
On the demographic side, yeah, you could say, hey, there's some interesting parallels as well.
00:05:19
Speaker
Having now discussed that some of these things look really similar, there are, of course, some clear differences as well from an economics point of view.
Economic differences: Japan's past and China's present
00:05:29
Speaker
Yeah, there are about three broad differences that are very important, actually.
00:05:34
Speaker
The first one is that Japan was at a much higher level of economic development than where mainland China is today.
00:05:41
Speaker
The income levels were much higher.
00:05:42
Speaker
The income levels, yeah, and usually in economics it's measured relative to the U.S., as well the U.S. is taken as the most advanced economy in the world.
00:05:51
Speaker
And what that means is that actually mainland China has more scope to grow itself out of the problem because there's still a lot of catch-up potential.
00:05:59
Speaker
So that makes the problem potentially easier to deal with, and that's a big, big difference.
00:06:05
Speaker
The second one is that actually when you look at where the debt resided in Japan, it was largely the private sector.
00:06:12
Speaker
That is, households had levered up, corporations famously had levered up,
00:06:18
Speaker
In mainland China, it's mostly the state sector, government entities, local governments, state-owned enterprises that leveraged up.
00:06:26
Speaker
And in some sense, that may be easier to deal with because, of course, the government is not as balance sheet constrained as the private sector is.
00:06:36
Speaker
And I guess also China is a closed capital system.
00:06:39
Speaker
Japan is open, right?
00:06:40
Speaker
So money can flow in and out as it wants to.
00:06:42
Speaker
And in China, that's not the case.
00:06:44
Speaker
The money stays in there.
00:06:45
Speaker
There's enough money there, and if the government has much more control over where the money is allocated to, that obviously helps you to kind of get out of this issue.
00:06:55
Speaker
So just to make this very practical, for example, you have a real estate company that falls over, then you can say, okay, sorry, you go down, but those assets are now going to go to an insurance company who gets these assets for cheap and can actually do something with it.
00:07:09
Speaker
And that's the kind of stuff that they can do in China without...
00:07:12
Speaker
money leaking out of the system that, for example, other countries would struggle more with.
00:07:18
Speaker
That's right, and that actually leads to another big difference, which is the effects.
00:07:22
Speaker
So in the 1980s, you saw the Japanese yen soar in value, becoming arguably massively overvalued, which is not something you can say about the Chinese currency today.
00:07:33
Speaker
And so that already reduces some of the distortions.
00:07:36
Speaker
But Harold, there are also differences when it comes to the equity market.
00:07:41
Speaker
Japan's equity market obviously was famously...
00:07:44
Speaker
the bull market of the 1980s.
00:07:45
Speaker
It's not something we can really attach a label to in mainland China at the moment.
00:07:51
Speaker
No, no, absolutely not.
00:07:52
Speaker
So you're absolutely right.
00:07:53
Speaker
In US dollar terms, and that's partially because the currency was strong, but also in the market had run up a lot, the valuations of that market were really high.
00:08:02
Speaker
Japanese equities had done very well.
00:08:05
Speaker
In China, that's of course very different now.
00:08:07
Speaker
The valuations are low.
00:08:08
Speaker
Chinese equities over the last decade have not done very well.
00:08:11
Speaker
Pretty much flatlined actually.
00:08:14
Speaker
So we never really had that kind of frothy, bubbly atmosphere that you had in Tokyo and Osaka in the late 80s.
00:08:22
Speaker
So that's a key difference, absolutely.
00:08:25
Speaker
So a lot of parallels and differences, but maybe it's a good place to take a quick
Lessons from Japan's 1990s experience
00:08:29
Speaker
break.
00:08:29
Speaker
And when we come back, we should talk about the lessons that at least economists and investors have drawn from the Japanese experience and whether they're applicable to mainland China.
00:08:48
Speaker
So Fred, we've highlighted some key parallels between Japan in the late 80s and China at the moment.
00:08:55
Speaker
But we've also discovered that there are some really big differences in the way these economies work, such as, for example, the structure of their debt and these sort of things, right?
00:09:05
Speaker
The role of FX.
00:09:07
Speaker
So from here on, we try to draw a couple of conclusions, a couple of lessons really out of that.
00:09:11
Speaker
As an economist, what would you say are the key lessons we can learn from Japan for China now?
00:09:17
Speaker
So just looking at the Japanese experience, particularly of Japan in 1990s, that is after the bubble burst, one lesson is not to be too shy on stimulus.
00:09:27
Speaker
Because there was a sense that the Japanese initially were quite hesitant.
00:09:31
Speaker
QE, which Japan obviously adopted in the modern era, only came in really much, much later, a decade later.
00:09:37
Speaker
So they were quite out of the gate, a bit cautious on stimulating.
00:09:41
Speaker
And that perhaps in hindsight is seen
00:09:44
Speaker
as a disadvantage because it then meant that really that deflationary mindset could become more ingrained before the stimulus came and was much harder to get out of this.
00:09:53
Speaker
So don't be shy on stimulus as one.
00:09:55
Speaker
The other one is really you have to combine stimulus with structural reforms.
00:10:00
Speaker
Even Japan had actually enormous distortions
00:10:03
Speaker
in the 1990s and was very important to clean it up.
00:10:07
Speaker
For example, the banks were not incentivized to get rid of bad assets, for example.
00:10:13
Speaker
They kept them on their books and that obviously then meant that gradually the problem was festering in the financial system without being addressed.
00:10:21
Speaker
And so really taking much more forceful steps, writing off the debt, getting a clean slate.
00:10:26
Speaker
I got the impression a little bit that China's more willing to do that now than probably Japan did in the early 90s, right?
00:10:33
Speaker
They're talking about structural reform.
00:10:35
Speaker
That's right.
00:10:36
Speaker
There's talk about structural reforms, but it's not necessarily clear that we're moving at the pace that you might need.
00:10:43
Speaker
The other thing, of course, for China is also that on the stimulus side, there is a bit of caution, right, at the moment, at least relative to expectations.
00:10:52
Speaker
We haven't seen as big a stimulus boost so far, at least.
00:10:56
Speaker
And so there's a debate, a genuine debate, should mainland China do more in terms of support or is this just the right amount?
00:11:04
Speaker
And obviously that's an open question, but I think that's where some of the lessons come in.
Investment strategies and China's unique path
00:11:09
Speaker
Well, they've got this new economic team that has been installed, what was it, February this year.
00:11:14
Speaker
I guess we'll hear over the next one or two months or so from that team what really their plans are going to be in terms of stimulus in the long-term direction of the Chinese government.
00:11:22
Speaker
And structural reforms.
00:11:23
Speaker
Right there still, we have the third-party plan come up later this year in mainland China that might give us more of an idea about stimulus.
00:11:31
Speaker
But Harold, what's the lessons for investors then?
00:11:35
Speaker
If you lived through the Japanese experience in the 80s and 90s and you're now looking at mainland China, what are some of the lessons you might draw in terms of your investment approach?
00:11:45
Speaker
I think one of the first lessons is that the unwinding of a market with high valuations is
00:11:52
Speaker
can take an awful long time.
00:11:55
Speaker
I mean, it took from 1989 to 2011 when the Japanese market bottomed.
00:12:00
Speaker
So these processes in the market can take a very long time.
00:12:05
Speaker
And as I said, one of the differences is that China never had that particular bubble.
00:12:09
Speaker
So maybe that's not as big as a hangover.
00:12:12
Speaker
But the other key lesson here is that if you would have put money into the Japanese market in 1990, of course, you would have lost money by the time it was 2011.
00:12:19
Speaker
It wouldn't have gone anywhere.
00:12:22
Speaker
However, you could have made still very good money by being very selective in that market, by looking at sectors that are emerging.
00:12:29
Speaker
For example, the automation names in the 1990s came up and they've gone up 10 times, these stocks.
00:12:35
Speaker
So instead of looking at the market just to say, I want to be in, say, Chinese equities, I think you need to take that away and say, no, I'm going to go much deeper.
00:12:43
Speaker
And there are 230 companies in China that have a market cap over $10 billion.
00:12:48
Speaker
They're really big.
00:12:49
Speaker
So you can do that in China and say, okay, I'm cautious on that overall market, the direction I'm not quite sure of, but I am really positive on certain consumer names or really positive on certain renewable names or these sort of things.
00:13:02
Speaker
That's what you need to do, be much more active and go much deeper in this market and more so probably than in other markets across the Asian region.
00:13:10
Speaker
And of course, investors didn't ignore Japan entirely.
00:13:13
Speaker
It may have shrunk in terms of its relative presence in global portfolios, but Japan still, right through the last three decades, was an important part of a key global equity portfolio.
00:13:24
Speaker
And so similar with China.
00:13:25
Speaker
And the size of China means that that will not go away either.
00:13:27
Speaker
I mean, if you are a market that accounts for, say, 2% of the Asian index, you might get marginalized.
00:13:32
Speaker
People just don't look at it.
00:13:34
Speaker
You can't do that with China.
00:13:35
Speaker
The market is so big that people will need to take a look at that.
00:13:40
Speaker
So it sounds to me, Harold, that really those parallels, there are some parallels there, but we have them taken with a pinch of salt because history doesn't exactly repeat itself.
00:13:50
Speaker
And these are two different economies ultimately.
00:13:54
Speaker
And it really much depends also on the policy response and really how that will evolve.
00:14:00
Speaker
Lumping mainland China into the Japanese Basque and saying that that's exactly China's destiny is probably overstated.
00:14:09
Speaker
No, and understanding both the parallels and the differences allow you then to also understand the nuances of how the market is going to perform and which sectors and which companies you should be looking at.
00:14:29
Speaker
So, Harold, you went to India recently, and I remember you told the story about, you know, the first Asian equity market was under a banyan tree at some point.
00:14:40
Speaker
And so I was wondering, how many people have you seen trading stocks in India under banyan trees?
00:14:45
Speaker
I have not seen many people trading stocks, but two things like this.
00:14:48
Speaker
First of all, while in Mumbai...
00:14:51
Speaker
I stayed in a hotel not too far away from the kind of circle where that banyan tree stood.
00:14:56
Speaker
So I went there to look around, oh there is a banyan tree, but I'm not quite sure if that is the banyan tree that we refer to where people trade it.
00:15:03
Speaker
But it is very close to the stock exchange, literally the Dalal Street comes onto that particular circle in southern Mumbai.
00:15:10
Speaker
So I went to see that.
00:15:12
Speaker
And then much later when I was traveling with my wife through Tamil Nadu, I once, we were in an area just north of Pondicherry, there was a fantastic, beautiful banyan tree on a meticulously kept field.
00:15:24
Speaker
And it stood on its own.
00:15:26
Speaker
And I thought, I gotta make a picture of this banyan tree.
00:15:28
Speaker
So I went there and it was a bit of a dirt road.
00:15:31
Speaker
So I went over the dirt road and there was a gate.
00:15:33
Speaker
I went over the gate, maybe I shouldn't have been doing so.
00:15:36
Speaker
So I went there and I put my tripod down and I made a picture
00:15:40
Speaker
And then I saw my wife basically waving at me to come back.
00:15:45
Speaker
And I saw why, because two security guards were running up to me and says I wasn't allowed to be there.
00:15:49
Speaker
But I got the picture of that particular banyan tree.
00:15:52
Speaker
It was a beautiful, very nice one.
00:15:54
Speaker
But yeah, banyan trees are here everywhere in Hong Kong as well.
00:15:56
Speaker
They're everywhere in Hong Kong, actually.
00:15:58
Speaker
So Hong Kong obviously has a lot of hills, very steep hills.
00:16:01
Speaker
And in the 19th century, they built a lot of retaining walls to prevent landslides.
00:16:07
Speaker
And over the years, St.
00:16:09
Speaker
Banyan trees have grown on these walls.
00:16:12
Speaker
And it looks beautiful here in the mid-level district.
00:16:15
Speaker
But they look like sometimes these trees, like they're going to take the whole wall down, right?
00:16:19
Speaker
Yeah, but actually it turns out the banyan trees help to reinforce the wall.
00:16:23
Speaker
So they're not cut down because they destroy the wall.
00:16:27
Speaker
They're just actually left there.
00:16:28
Speaker
And Hong Kong has about 1,200 of these banyan trees on about 500 of these retaining walls that help to secure these walls.
00:16:36
Speaker
And some of these trees are actually well over 100 years old.
00:16:40
Speaker
So it's integral.
00:16:43
Speaker
to, I think, the landscape of Hong Kong and the cityscape, if you will.
00:16:47
Speaker
And some of them, of course, look fantastic and just add a certain character.
00:16:51
Speaker
Oh, absolutely.
00:16:52
Speaker
But we're not trading stocks in Hong Kong under banyan trees as well.
00:16:55
Speaker
No, but the lesson we've learned is that it's safe to be sitting under a banyan tree.
00:16:58
Speaker
That's right.
00:16:59
Speaker
No apples falling on your head under a banyan tree.
00:17:02
Speaker
Well, we're going to have to bring things to an end there, folks.
00:17:05
Speaker
It's been great having you with us.
00:17:07
Speaker
And no doubt the Japan-China debate will keep on raging and give us plenty to talk about going forward.
00:17:12
Speaker
Indeed.
00:17:13
Speaker
Meanwhile, remember to check out our sister podcast, The Macro Brief and The ESG Brief.
00:17:18
Speaker
wherever you get your podcast.
00:17:20
Speaker
And finally, HSBC clients can sign up to our Global Emerging Markets Conference, which is taking place online from the 18th through 29th of September.
00:17:28
Speaker
Get in touch with your HSBC sales representative if you'd like to get your name down for that.
00:17:34
Speaker
Thanks again, everybody.
00:17:35
Speaker
Talk to you soon.
00:17:54
Speaker
Thank you for joining us at HSBC Global Viewpoint.
00:17:58
Speaker
We hope you enjoyed the discussion.
00:18:00
Speaker
Make sure you're subscribed to stay up to date with new episodes.