Transcript
Martin Davis: Welcome to Virginia 365, a podcast highlighting the people, topics and ideas that are driving Virginia. today stephen farnsworth professor emeritus of political scientists Pardon me. Professor Emeritus of Political Science at the University of Mary Washington. He joins us in the studio. Stephen, welcome, and I don't suppose you'd be too upset to say that you're a Professor Emeritus. so political scientists writ large.
Steve Farnsworth: That's right. it's It's a fine line of work.
Martin Davis: So thanks for being here today, and let's let's jump right into the topic of this on everyone's lips, right? you know the elections and the one word that explains what has you here today in my mind is wow
Martin Davis: The midterms were absolutely wild. Repudiation just seems like too small a word to describe how voters felt about Donald Trump and Republican leadership. But of course, this isn't the first time the country has experienced.
Martin Davis: this kind of dramatic shift. I'm wondering if you could kick us off with a bit of a brief history about the last time we saw both houses of Congress flip.
Steve Farnsworth: Well, the reality is that Americans are very instrumental voters. They look at the current conditions and often don't like what they see and want to change to the other party. and so Pretty much every president has a significant amount of time when they're in office that the other party controls at least one chamber. president Trump had Republicans for two years.
Steve Farnsworth: And going back to the Biden presidency, he had Democrats for two years. And then going back to Trump won. Again, two years before Democrats took over the House. The Obama presidency, only two years of a Democratic. House and Senate during his eight years. And so over and over again, you see that presidents have to deal with a divided government environment.
Steve Farnsworth: That's not unusual at all. It's in fact more common than unified government. That of course leads to a lot of gridlock. But maybe that's what the voters have in mind. They want each party to check the other.
Martin Davis: When was the last time we had both houses? flip like this.
Steve Farnsworth: What happens in other cases generally is the year six midterm is when both chambers change. In terms of the, for example, the the first Trump presidency, he was able to keep a Republican majority Senate during his first term across the entire four years.
Martin Davis: Okay.
Steve Farnsworth: Similarly with Obama, it was year six of the Obama presidency before both chambers flipped. So if you think of the Trump presidency as being in year six right now, this is part of the norm for two -term presidents.
Steve Farnsworth: You can see examples of both chambers flipping in year two of a first term. That happened during the Obama presidency. I mean during the Bill Clinton presidency in the 1990s.
Martin Davis: Okay, great. so let's talk about the results in virginia just a little bit i'm wondering what stood out to you both in terms of how the wave blue wave washed over the state.
Martin Davis: but also maybe in ways that Virginians We're sending signals that maybe others haven't picked up on to this point about what's happening here in the state.
Steve Farnsworth: Yeah, I think Virginia sent a very clear signal a year ago. when Abigail Spanberger was elected governor by double digits.
Steve Farnsworth: <unk> And then, of course, you saw a net loss of 13. Republican seats in the House of Delegates. The Democratic majority now in the House of Delegates in Virginia is the biggest that it's been since the 1980s. So if you're looking at politics as of November 2025, it was pretty clear that President Trump was a
Steve Farnsworth: huge drag on Republicans. That was clear a year ago in Virginia. But what you saw in the last year was continuing deference to the president on the part of Republicans. And the president himself. getting involved in uh various nomination struggles around the country that created another environment for for President Trump's favorite loyal candidates to lose in the general election in November. With respect to Virginia, of course, The congress the Republicans in Congress have had very little by way of challenging the president.
Steve Farnsworth: and basically the environment was an all Trump all the time election. It didn't really matter. how moderate or how conservative a Republican you might try to present yourself as being. now What mattered was you had an R after your name, and people who were mad about President Trump just simply didn't vote for a Republican in great numbers last cycle.
Steve Farnsworth: The depth of the Republican problem in Virginia is seen, I think, most clearly with respect to Virginia 5. That's the congressional district that stretches from From Charlottesville to the North Carolina border. That's the evangelical Christian conservative heartland of Virginia and even there uh republicans uh struggled struggled
Steve Farnsworth: the Republican candidate, the incumbent. Congressman McGuire was reelected, but not by much. And that, I think, speaks to the challenges that Republicans are facing, even in areas that used to be pretty safely Republican.
Martin Davis: in regards to mcguire you know perriello ran a really close race a lot of people thought that he would in fact come out ahead on this thing and uh you know he fell just a little short Okay.
Martin Davis: Does this, given how red and how evangelical that district is, is there any indication that There is some evangelical movement. At this point against.
Martin Davis: uh Trump and what he's represented the last. 12 years.
Steve Farnsworth: Well.
Martin Davis: because they have been a core of his base.
Steve Farnsworth: Yeah, well, we don't have the kind of exit polls we do in some years in Virginia this year. So we're having to. kind of speculate, read between the lines of these results. And so I don't know that it's so much an erosion of evangelical voters. I mean, surely there are some voters who are very upset about the economy and voted accordingly, even if they have supported Trump previously.
Steve Farnsworth: You could hear plenty of people making the argument that. President Trump hasn't delivered what he promised, and a lot of Trump supporters were pretty demoralized. But I think what we saw more clearly in in our elections in Virginia was that we saw a lot of people turning out who were angry, people who might not normally vote in a midterm election, particularly when you think about younger voters and non -white voters. These are two groups that often
Steve Farnsworth: don't show up in comparable numbers. to turn out in presidential years. They're showing app in greater numbers this let midterm in, I think, large part because of the anger that they have.
Steve Farnsworth: i happened to you know think about you know issues with students a lot because of you know being a college professor. And there was this great concern, great anxiety about data centers and AI and whether there are going to be jobs for them.
Steve Farnsworth: And that kind of dynamic, I think, is is part of the reason why people vote, because angry people are much more likely to vote. And then, of course, with respect to African -American voters. there was a significant concern with respect to changes in the Voting Rights Act and issues that that also would be of great interest to them. You had, on of course, one of the constitutional amendments dealing with issues of convicted felons and being having their voting rights restored. That's an important thing in a lot of communities where people have raised questions about equity in policing and fairness in court in the court system. And so those kinds of things.
Steve Farnsworth: coupled with you know the Trump presidency's Very, very. intense focus on issues of concern to white voters could get those people turning out. And so I'm not sure that it's so much. It's a large number of Virginians saying.
Steve Farnsworth: I wanted Trump before and I don't want him now. I think it's a lot of people saying. I have a reason to turn out now. I'm really mad and I'm going to show up.
Martin Davis: So, like you said, we don't have the early voting numbers and we can't really tell because we don't register by party here in Virginia. how big the Republican turnout was, but. Assuming that Republicans...
Martin Davis: their votes were suppressed in the sense that a lot of them stayed home this time. This would mark the second election in a row in Virginia that which that Republicans just didn't bother to turn out.
Martin Davis: I wonder what you think Republicans in Virginia are going to have to do. to to respond.
Steve Farnsworth: Well, I could see two possible scenarios here. The first one is you just simply wait out President Trump. I think that that President Trump...
Steve Farnsworth: really lost his ability to connect with voters this election cycle. It is really striking. President Trump used to be very good at speaking to voter anxiety and voter fears and really convincing people that he understood their trouble and that he was going to do something about it. What we saw this election cycle was Trump belittling the concerns of voters. The economy is much better than you think it is, he said over and over again. And then he pivots to conversations that have no no connection to voter anxiety. and worries. Talking about the triumphal arch he wants to build near Arlington Cemetery.
Steve Farnsworth: thinking about the the reflecting pool. uh outside the lincoln memorial and of course tearing down a third of the white house all of these things of course occur without congressional financial authorization but that's another story for another day but the reality is that he's tone deaf.
Steve Farnsworth: in a way that we haven't seen before. And that's what's really striking. So that's one solution. You just simply say Trump's going to be out in two years. Maybe the Republican brand is tarnished now, but can be rehabilitated in the 2028 election with another candidate.
Steve Farnsworth: That's one option. The other option is that the Republican Party has to think much more seriously about who it's putting forward and how it presents itself in Virginia in particular.
Steve Farnsworth: If you look at the dynamics. The Republican Party's challenges in Virginia started long before President Trump. The Republicans have not won a U .S. Senate race in Virginia since 2002 when John Warner won his last term. That's a long drought.
Steve Farnsworth: for for Republicans with that. being shut out of senate and shut Senate elections. A year ago, of course, you saw the the election of of Abigail Spanberger about double digits, big gains for the Democrats in the House of Delegates. And so there is, I think, a real challenge.
Steve Farnsworth: for the party to appreciate the way that Virginia is changing. In the 1990s, when you think about... Jim Gilmore being elected and George Allen. they were governors who could campaign as evangelical christians cultural warriors if you will those days in Virginia are long gone. The suburbs are much bluer than they were.
Steve Farnsworth: in those days. and the share of the vote. cast by rural Virginia significantly declines as the population of Virginia increases. There are many, many more suburb suburban voters than there are rural voters in Virginia.
Steve Farnsworth: And so the Republican Party has to think. about how to reach those voters. And that I don't know is going to be an effective strategy.
Steve Farnsworth: uh to reach them through evangelical christian messaging uh through the you know the issues of of trans politics and things like that i think that what you need to do if you're a republican is connect in a more centrist political messaging particularly with issues with respect to taxes and the economy those are often areas where republicans can do well but republicans need to show that they're connected to those concerns that they speak to the anxieties and talk a hell of a lot less about.
Steve Farnsworth: the ballroom at the White House.
Martin Davis: You raised the issue of data centers, and there's there's an interesting dynamic going on with those that I've picked up on this election cycle. Obviously, there's been a lot of public backlash against them. There is, you know, you see localities touring with moratoria or slowdowns or... you know in loudon they're they're talking about putting the brakes on things for a year a lot of turmoil about that. but when
Martin Davis: When... really good pollsters have gone in and talked to voters this midterm about whether or not data centers are driving their votes, the answer seems to be no.
Martin Davis: I'm curious, coming out of the midterms now, where do you see that debate going in Virginia?
Steve Farnsworth: Well, I think that when we turn to data centers and AI, Some people are more concerned about it than others. I think that particularly for young voters thinking about how the workplace is changing.
Steve Farnsworth: and it's going to change rapidly. There's a lot of anxiety. For older voters, I think the issue is the question of of electric bills above all. I think that People are very concerned that data centers won't end up paying their fair share. I mean, remember, Virginia's state government, Democratic or Republican rule, has always been traditionally pretty friendly to business. And sometimes that means that the consumers, the individual citizens, end up paying a bit more than their share for some of the economic development projects that have gone on across Virginia's recent history.
Steve Farnsworth: for for the data centers going forward, I think that the the The road is uncertain. Democrats do not agree on how to handle data centers. There are very different views depending on where you are within Virginia. Some places where there's very little economic activity, or these are places that are much more welcoming.
Steve Farnsworth: than places like, say, in Northern Virginia, where there isn't a lot of available land. If you do cite these places, you often cite them relatively close to to residential districts that that create you know noise and environmental concerns. that that the public will talk about if they are near located nearby one of these sites so i do think that the the the future of this question is is uncertain, but there does seem to be a very significant
Steve Farnsworth: Issue. of how the public feels about this that wasn't present two years ago.
Martin Davis: Yeah, it'll be interesting to watch, to see. how that plays out in the year ahead, which kind of leads you to the next thing I wanted to ask you. You know, it's... It's way too early, but it's Virginia. We can't help ourselves. We're going to go to the polls every 12 months, right? How do you see?
Martin Davis: thing shaping up in 27 when the General Assembly is up for grabs. To what extent? you know what lessons do we take from the midterms that potentially could affect that. What other issues like data centers do you think might play into that? that vote next year.
Steve Farnsworth: Well...
Steve Farnsworth: When we go to the polls a year from this week, we get a chance to vote on 100 members of the House of Delegates and 40 senators of Virginia. The Democrats have a big majority right now. Trump will still be president and as far as we can. predict, that means that this will be another campaign in which Democrats make the name Trump the first name of everybody running for office.
Steve Farnsworth: on the Republican side. That's going to be a challenge, I think. The Republicans, some of them looking at the... The results this week...
Steve Farnsworth: might wonder about whether it's worth it to run another campaign. They might decide it's time to retire. but I'm particularly thinking about you know individual senators in places where Democrats have had significant gains. If you think about Republicans in the 1st and 2nd Congressional District, for example. You know, some of them might say that's not.
Steve Farnsworth: uh maybe a fortuitous uh environment which to seek re -election maybe the some of the senate republican senators that are in the seventh district this is the fredericksburg prince william district maybe some of them will say it's time uh to spend more time with their with my family as the saying goes so i think that there will be challenges for republicans this cycle in terms of recruitment I think there will also be challenges in this cycle in terms of donations.
Steve Farnsworth: The. environment isn't really favorable in the short term. But remember, Virginia is not a place that has a permanent majority or a permanent minority. If we'd had this conversation in the 1990s, Democrats would have been very cynical. very negative about their prospects.
Steve Farnsworth: uh at that time so you just simply get tired of losing and you read brand. in a way that more uh more appropriately connects with the Virginia of the moment.
Martin Davis: Yeah. You and I have talked about this. before offline at length, but I am curious. it's It's interesting to me that...
Martin Davis: when you look at polling on favorability ratings for the two major political parties. They're both underwater. Which one is more underwater tends to...
Martin Davis: fluctuate a little bit but They've been underwater for a while. I think right now Democrats are underwater. I think the last poll I saw from the New York Times by about 19 points and the Republicans were like 21. Those numbers may be off, but I remember Democrats had a little bit better rating than been Republicans, but not much.
Martin Davis: you know, the party is. have real There's a real brand issue with parties. And I thought a lot about this in the sense of. is this really a bad thing because one of the things that i kind of wonder about is Maybe this is putting a greater emphasis emphasis on, maybe if people are thinking less about party and thinking more about candidates and issues.
Martin Davis: which is what appeared to happen this year, that might be that might be a positive thing in our body politics. Any any thought about that?
Steve Farnsworth: Yeah, i I do think that. That neither party has a monopoly on wisdom and I think it makes sense to look at individual issues and make judgments about where.
Steve Farnsworth: uh these individual lawmakers or candidates would take the country if they were elected or take Virginia. if they were elected. I think that... the The reality is that a lot of people uh look to the two parties and don't see something that matches up.
Steve Farnsworth: with where they are. and speaks to the confidence of of where they want the Commonwealth or the country. to to go in particular you see that the evangelical Christian message, for example, doesn't work all that well with suburban voters.
Martin Davis: Mhm.
Steve Farnsworth: a low tax message might work better if you're on the Republican side. And then if you're on the Democratic side. you know know You want to be... cognizant of the fact that people feel very pressed economically and so they may not be interested in a lot of new programs and paying for those new programs because Of course, in Virginia, unlike at the federal level, Virginia has to balance its budget. And so anything that you want to do, you have to pay for it.
Steve Farnsworth: And unlike the federal government, you just say i want to give you this tax cut but i'm not going to cut the spending to match it and the deficit will get bigger but it's not my problem the federal government has that indulgence.
Steve Farnsworth: that the state government does not and so it is a challenge i think to work through many of these issues and I would be very happy if voters... had a better understanding of how uh budgets work how medicare works uh how we pay for transportation and schools. These are things that are at the core of what government does. But I think a lot of voters just are kind of looking at the D or the R and say, I know which team I'm on. I know how I'm going to vote.
Martin Davis: Okay. So let's switch gears a little bit, Stephen. yeah you've had a You had a wonderful career at at at the University of Mary Washington. uh and One of the things that made that career so great. Beyond the fact that you're so well known here in Virginia, but also across the nation, the fact that you yourself started off as as as a reporter endeared me to you. You understand. So the reality we have to contend with.
Martin Davis: but also Being at UNW is giving you a chance through Fulbright scholarships to travel the world, talking about politics, teaching about politics. I'm just kind of curious if you can talk a little bit.
Martin Davis: about how politics in the U .S. differ from Poland and India, two places I know you've been recently, and and how are they similar, but both in terms... maybe not search so much in terms of structure, maybe in terms of how the people interact with politics and think about it.
Steve Farnsworth: Yeah, I think that one of the... One of the great parts of of my job as a professor is the chance to interact with people are around the world.
Steve Farnsworth: and then take those lessons back. to my students at Murray Washington. I worked for many years during the summers with media.
Steve Farnsworth: development projects, talking with reporters in Ukraine and Azerbaijan and Armenia. and then learning about how the media operates in these countries from the people who are struggling.
Steve Farnsworth: in those places to be journalists. And those stories come back and they talk about how different it is to be a journalist in America versus Ukraine or something like that. And so there is a great richness that can come from that, that I've always found really valuable. It helps me as a scholar thinking about about American politics because outsiders often have perspectives that insiders do not.
Steve Farnsworth: And that, you know, helps with some of the the the things that I. you know, would talk about in class or I would write in my my books and my articles. where One of the things that I really noticed, I was in India this fall, earlier this fall, and They have, in many ways, the same anxieties in India. the young
Steve Farnsworth: students that students in the United States have. They're very concerned about AI, what it's going to mean for their careers. They're also very frustrated. They want to see more change in their society than they're seeing.
Steve Farnsworth: there have been some some big protests particularly in the capital and in New Delhi about the students wanting a better
Steve Farnsworth: more open future, a more integrated India. India, as you know, has all kinds of challenges trying to bring a very diverse place together into one country.
Steve Farnsworth: That's something that you really see in a lot of places. The one thing that really struck me was when you think about my... programs in teaching in India and in Poland. the last two that I've done, those... places
Steve Farnsworth: are are are filled with students who are totally totally into learning about the United States. They are very fascinated by what's going on in the United States, sometimes quite baffled by the choices that Americans make, and and they are are really very motivated in trying to understand it.
Steve Farnsworth: It is a... I think a really... challenging thing. uh to recognize how much the world knows about us and how little we know about some of these places and so it is a yeah you know a great opportunity. And that's one of the things that that I think can be can be really, really useful. you know We in political science use this term soft power, this idea that there is a cultural connection that can be built.
Steve Farnsworth: that can be very very useful in terms of trying to understand different societies and and how they're motivated and so it's something that i was glad to be a part of And hopefully there'll be other opportunities down the road.
Martin Davis: Awesome. Of course, it would not be a Virginia Free Press product, Stephen, if I didn't end up by asking you what you're reading. so What are you working through right now?
Steve Farnsworth: Well, I just finished Nerd Reich. which was a really interesting study about how AI is trying to, and the tech industry in the in Silicon Valley is trying to have a greater footprint in terms of the way American politics works. That's a really interesting book. But the book I'm reading right now and.
Steve Farnsworth: Uh, is going to be It's a reread, actually. It's the Odyssey. I watched the film, the the Nolan film, The Odyssey, a few weeks ago.
Steve Farnsworth: and His read on Odysseus was different than I remember from the book when I read it a while back. And so I'm diving back into the Odyssey and making another go of it to see if maybe I missed something when I read it before or the interpretation.
Steve Farnsworth: uh in the film which was an excellent film by the way Okay. is is one that is more consistent with the book than I remember. So so i'll I'll have to get back to you on that.
Steve Farnsworth: That may seem strange for a political scientist to read, but I did start my...
Martin Davis: Okay.
Steve Farnsworth: college career as a lit major. and so I've always been very interested in classic work.
Martin Davis: Well, you know, great works never go out of style or out of date. It's our popular culture reminds us, as with this particular film. I do have to kind of pick at you a bit and ask, having studied classics as an undergrad, or are are you reading The Odyssey in Greek or in English?
Steve Farnsworth: Oh, no, no, it's in English. I am i am linguistically challenged. this The single most humbling experience of my life was trying to learn Polish. I had a tutor every week.
Steve Farnsworth: online. native speaker polish and then i spent 45 minutes minimum every day. on Duolingo. And after all of that, I could.
Steve Farnsworth: Buy a train ticket. and get directions. And that was about it. you know It was just such a challenging language. And they have all these rules because about a significant part of Polish actually is Russian.
Steve Farnsworth: subject to Russian rules. Now, they don't have Cyrillic. They use the the script that we know in English. But, you know, like there would be a word that would, by the nature of its ending in Polish, would be masculine or feminine, like like in the Romance languages in French or Spanish.
Steve Farnsworth: And if it were a Russian word, that might not be the subject of the same gender identifying words rules and so So like the word Miss Chisinau. which is man in Polish. it the ending is an a which in polish would mean that this is a a female verb okay or female noun And.
Steve Farnsworth: And they say, no, no, no, but it's not a female noun. in in in in Polish because it's a Russian word that we've imported into Polish. How in the world am I going to know which words are Russian imports into Polish? so and so And so this was the kind of challenge that I faced every day struggling to do.
Steve Farnsworth: uh whatever i could in in polish and so i was a very very discouraged so no i i did not I did not face the Odyssey in the original Greek.
Martin Davis: That reminds me of the nightmares I had learning. greek and becoming aware that there were at least 14 or 15 different uses of participles in Greek. which Yeah, good luck, right?
Martin Davis: It's a nightmare. Well, look, that's all the time that we have for today. Stephen, thank you so much for being here.
Steve Farnsworth: Glad to be here.
Martin Davis: Do you know a guest we should be talking to? shoot me an email at mdavis at VirginiaFreePress .com. dot com Until next time. Be well.

