Transcript
Speaker: Welcome to the Policy Layer, where we talk about the real decisions shaping crypto, tech, and the future of trust. I am Silvia Sanchez, your host from the Avalanche Policy Coalition. We aim to bridge the gap between the builders of Web3 and the people that are shaping the rules. On our podcast, you'll hear from policymakers, developers, academics, and others working at the edge of tech and regulation.
Speaker: We ask the questions that everyone's actually wondering and we keep it easy to follow. This is the Policy Layer.
Speaker: So hello, hello. Welcome back to the Policy Layer, everybody. So the Mika consultation has closed and just as we've done a little recap on policy on the US, we definitely have to talk about what's happening on the EU side of things. So We'd also like to know what happens to all that feedback. We also um were active with a blockchain for Europe and seeing what else was happening. And before we start talking about changes to Europe's crypto rules, I want to understand how those decisions get made and how much can be addressed without necessarily rewriting the legislation.
Speaker: And today we're catching up with Tomas Vastazzi, Policy Director at Blockchain for Europe, one of our dear trade associations that Avalabs is proud to be a member of. And we'll talk about what the consultation could lead to, the other European policy discussions worth watching, and where companies and users still need clearer answers on stablecoins, tokenization, DeFi, all that good stuff.
Speaker: and Just as a reminder, this conversation, like any of our conversations, are just for educational purposes. This is not legal or financial advice. You know how they say, D-Y-O-R, do your own research. But with that, let's get started. Tomas, welcome.
Speaker: Hello. Thanks, Silvia. It's great to be here. Really happy to to be back, actually, for another episode. So always, always good to to be joining this conversation. Thanks so much. Amazing. um So we'll try to do a nice little overview because a lot has happened since the last time you were here discussing Mika. Things have changed quite a lot in this past year and a half or so. So the consultation has closed and I'd like you to walk us through what happens next. now How does the commission use the responses and what would need to happen before we we saw a legislation proposal? Yeah, happy to do that. I think it's important before we get into the details to clarify a bit this point, right? Everybody is already now talking about MECA 2. But, you know, first of all, amikaoo a MECA 2, a new MECA framework is not really given, it's not granted that we get a proposal anytime soon.
Speaker: We just had this consultation, right? The Commission now is collecting, has collected the views from the industry, from other supervisors, from the central banks. And now we also filed our own response at the end of September. And all of this is now going to be analyzed by the European Commission. What we were told just last week in our latest meeting with the European Commission is that we might expect something before the end of the year in terms of an assessment, a summary, basically, of how... you know, of what the respondents actually focused on in their in their feedback to the Mika consultation. um And so then this would then feed into the work that the European Commission will do in 2027. There is in theory a report that is due in June 2027 by the Commission exactly trying to, which is meant to review how Mika is working in practice and what are the challenges and so on and only then if the commission thinks that it's needed we will see legislative proposal so there is still some time to go and there is also some ongoing discussions around actual simplification and regulatory poses in Europe and so we might even be um
Speaker: spend a whole 2027 without actually getting any new legislative proposal. um But even if we do get a new Mika proposal in 2027, the other important thing to clarify is that Mika is actually just one piece of a much bigger puzzle.
Speaker: um So, of course, it's the main most important when it comes to the provision of crypto asset services. But right now, we're also negotiating a whole package on market integration and supervision, which already is amending me kind of introducing a new structure for the supervision of the largest crypto asset service providers and on stable coins as well. um There is also discussions on the digital euro, which is in the final negotiations.
Speaker: There are also the new anti-money laundering rules. and And even digital files like the general data protection regulation is being reopened. And this has actually a very important ah impact for public permissionless blockchains, for example. So, you know, when we talk about now the future of crypto in Europe, We're really talking about four or five different files more moving at the same time. Mika remains the masterpiece, but it's really not the whole picture on which to focus on.
Speaker: And that's a lot definitely to keep watching on. And with those different pieces in mind, I think it's also important to tie it back to your consultation response, which says that we should basically enforce the rules before adding more and before making things even more convoluted than they already are. um And from a practical approach, what problems would that solve and where do we still need to to change the rules or do a bit more of adjusting?
Speaker: Yeah, so this is actually being our main, let's say, position throughout our consultation response, throughout our engagement with European Commission as Blockchain for Euro, with our members, is that Mika in the end has only applied in full since the end of 2024, right? And the transition period only ended this July. So in general, before we write new rules, we actually would like to see the current ones being properly applied, right? So we first want to see where the actual issues and challenges are, and then we try to address them. And so enforcement of these rules, first of all, solves the biggest problem that I also, that I was referring to, the fact that there is ah still a bit of uneven playing field.
Speaker: right Even though we now have this one single rulebook for Europe, it still ah carries a lot of different interpretations across the 27 EU member states and their respective regulatory and supervisory authorities. And so when this implementation and enforcement of the Mika rules is still not um creating this level playing field, then there is a problem, right? We need to make sure that the rules are applied properly, that only licensed firms are ah servicing European customers. And when unlicensed firms are trying to do that, um you know, the MECA protections, the rules, the requirements should potentially, should actually prevent it. um And also what we also reiterated in our consultation response quite often is that the tools are already there. The supervisors already have the available tools to implement all of these all of these requirements and rules. The blockchain analytics, the travel rule data, these are actually showing where the U customer's order are actually going and so we can actually trace where activity is happening in europe and whether this is happening only from regularly regulated entities because otherwise the whole the whole job that we did the whole effort of introducing the mica regulation loses its value right when this is undercut by non-regulated entities providing providing services and then at the same time it's not like we're saying we don't need to change anything right we're asking for targeted fixes with a clear timetable.
Speaker: We don't want to just reopen everything, but we ah we understand that there is maybe need to address some areas of MECA in the short term, but we we actually hope that it's a longer term consideration of how the EU regulatory framework for crypto assets, for digital assets is evolving and if it's evolving in the right direction.
Speaker: Indeed, and I think that with those different things happening, I also want to tie it back to what companies are experiencing today, just elaborating a bit more on on your point. And I'd like to tie it back to token classification, for example, which has continued to be an issue, not just, I think, with with Mika, but with a lot of these regulatory regimes throughout the world. but In the case of Mika and what we've seen with a the feedback and these changes, is the line between Mika and existing financial regulation clear enough? Where are companies getting different answers across EU countries?
Speaker: Yeah, so this is also a very interesting question that the commission itself has asked in, it's probably the the very first one in the consultation, right? So if you have responded to the consultation, you know what we're referring to. But basically, we believe the principle is right. What we did with Mika, um the principle that was adopted is still the correct one, as in the rules should follow what the asset actually does, not the technology behind it.
Speaker: Right? A tokenized bond is still a bond um and so on. But at the same time, the edges, the the cases at the borders of this delineation delineation are actually getting blurry sometimes. And that's where then we get different answers at national level. So, for example, you know, a toke tokens can change over time, right? So if you think about a utility token that later on adds governance or profit sharing rights, well, this is potentially not a utility token anymore, right? It changes somehow the the nature that can be of the token itself. There is also questions on fractionalized real world assets. um where, you know, these potentially could then be classified as as securities and so will fall under the financial services, the traditional financial services instruments legislation.
Speaker: And so that's also, you know, what what the European Commission was asking in the consultation was whether this delineation between the two categories is still very clear, if there needs to be more guidance, some more clarity on some you know borderline cases but then the underlying question and of this is what to me it's really interesting right so far we have developed these two frameworks we have developed a framework which deals with deals and regulates financial instruments and this is MIFID and it's been the same for for many years now um But also being a directive, it means that we have 27 different applications of MIFID, of the principles adopted at European level. And so this is where the differences in the way that different member states regulate financial instruments or define financial instruments in the first place, it's different.
Speaker: And then the other leg is the Mika crypto assets leg, right? So we introduce the Mika regulation for all of these new tokens that we classify as crypto assets.
Speaker: And then we say again that if a crypto asset is actually a financial instrument, it's regulated under MIFID, and otherwise it's regulated under Mika. And this is the framework that we have now. But the question there underlying the consultation questions is really like, should we still have these...
Speaker: division in the future or should we move to a future where we have one single regulatory environment for digital assets as a whole as we imagine in that more and more financial assets and non-financial assets are going to be brought on chain does it really make sense one day in the future one day to keep talking about financial instruments being separated from crypto assets and digital assets well that's an interesting question and almost one on which we are all deliberating thinking through what that would mean ah but we at least appreciate that the European Commission is thinking about it to try and understand what the future should look like in Europe once we have adopted the regulatory frameworks that we need we have ah you know also made it possible for tokenization to take place and so then we are getting into a more advanced future and innovative financial market. Yeah, and it's a very complex thing, now because it also raises a whole set of sub-questions in the sense like, oh, could the same token get different answers in two different European countries? Or also, like when you think about it from the developer perspective, what would that eventually do to to a company and trying to serve both? So I think that this obviously is something that should be dissected even more. And also going back to the... to earlier point of like okay financial instruments are excluded from Mika's scope at the moment other exclusions also exist and I'm sure we can continue um dissecting this even more or even going back to the point of a bond issued on a blockchain like once we agree that it's a bond
Speaker: what could still get complicated about owning it or selling it on chain. um But instead of spending too much time there, which I think that point alone could be another episode of itself, let's go to stablecoins, which is another point that I think it's important to mention because stablecoins also bring another cross-border question that the the token can move globally while the obligations sit with particular issuers.
Speaker: um So going back to to your response, it supports stablecoins issued both inside and outside the European Union. So with this in mind, what does that make possible and how would we protect European holders if lots of people want to redeem at once? Yes, so this is also one of the hottest topics on in Brussels and beyond Brussels. This is about multi issuance, global stable coins that are issued in different jurisdictions, but became because they are fungible tokens, then there is a question of how do these tokens flow within the global markets, the holders, the rights that they have, the redemption, and so on. So the first point that I think it's important to make is um global stable coins are, first of all, important. They're essential and we don't want a Europe that closes itself, that closes its market from allowing the circulation of global stable coins.
Speaker: Also, this was never the intention, right? The European Commission prepared its approach to global stable coins based on the FSB recommendations on global stable coins, which were to integrate global stable coins into the jurisdictions economy um and markets. And so that's what the European Commission did, right?
Speaker: the MECA was pretty clear that multi issuance is allowed under the rules. The problem though is that in the last few years, and last year or so, this was questioned, especially by the European Central Bank and by other voices in the European policy making world. And they basically prevented the European Commission from bringing regulatory clarity to this. Now, this is ah became a hot topic again. It's a question in the in the consultation, but also being addressed in the mispackage that I mentioned earlier. So it's going in parallel. We don't really know where it's going to be addressed properly. But the point...
Speaker: ah The point is that, you know, again, we don't want global stable coins to be banned from the European Union. But at the same time, we agree that um holders need to be protected and that's the essential redemption right of a stable coin, which is, you know, the most important element of it, right? I hold a stable coin because I know that whenever I want, I can give back one euro stable coin and get back one euro, right? That's the most important aspect of it. and so of course we want to make sure that this is protected there are some safeguards in mica but which already exist and what we are working on with our issuers our members that are issuing global stable coins is to clarify how they plan to adopt and implement those safeguards and potentially add additional safeguards so that you know multi-issuants remain allowed and permitted But then we are also addressing the potential concerns of those that um that are scared about a potential bank run on a stablecoin issuer, which will then potentially create a situation where holders of stablecoins in the US then come and withdraw ah they you know the assets behind the stablecoins in Europe. So this is obviously something that we are also potentially concerned about. But at the same time, we still believe that you know the most important principle is that the European holder must be able to redeem against the EU issuer under EU law and without relying on a foreign supervisor in a crisis. right So we agree with the idea that a global stablecoin operator should have ah EU entity and this EU entity remains the one responsible to ensure the redeemability of the stablecoin. But then again, you know, there is some questions around the reserves and how this should be rebalanced regularly, potentially between the EU and non-EU issuers, maybe up to a daily basis so that the EU side can always cover for its own redemptions.
Speaker: um At the same time, we're also considering the idea of binding backstop arrangements for sudden imbalances. And so there are ah many many of these safeguards that can be introduced. There is stress tests, liquidity buffers, reporting on new holdings, cooperation between supervisors. These are all elements that we have also supported in our consultation response. But at the same time,
Speaker: What we agree is that if the risks are real, they are calling for smart safeguards and not for a ban. That's our main principle on this. Definitely. and i And I think that if we were to like synthesize it, it actually brought down a lot of words with R's. Now we have reserve requirements, rebalancing and responsibilities, which in this case, I think i the most salient point of all is also responsibility. As we shift from stable coins, I think, into DeFi as a whole. And I want to discuss that as my next point. um Because that question of responsibility is is huge because with DeFi, we can have a developer, an interface and people making governance decisions. But I also would like us to understand which roles should carry responsibility for the financial activity.
Speaker: So with DeFi, where would would you draw the line between providing infrastructure and running a financial service? And this is a point that I think we've also discussed a lot a back in the U.S. with the SEC and this whole thing of infrastructure versus intermediary companies.
Speaker: We're like a parrot now. Like instead of an owl, we should be a parrot because we say this all the freaking die. But um who should be responsible when different people can change the code, when they can set fees or control the assets? like
Speaker: Yeah, these is like these are key questions and indeed it's explaining the it's cleaning them to regulators is really not easy, right? Let's start from saying this, that I don't blame necessarily regulators that are, um you know, they're doing what they know, right? They apply the laws in the way that ah they ah they have applied laws forever. And so they are going to be looking for the responsible person that will be responsible for anything that goes wrong.
Speaker: Now, in a decentralized, disintermediated environment, that is not always so straightforward. And so what we have um held in our position, in our engagement and in our consultation response is that for us the line is control and custody and not code.
Speaker: right So if there is an identifiable party which is providing a so a regulated service and this party can move, freeze or seize your assets without your consent, well, that's an intermediary. So there is an intermediary and in this case this should be, because it's providing a regulated service, it should be regulated like an intermediary. A software that never really takes custody of anyone's assets in the end is infrastructure and it shouldn't be regulated as an intermediary. So, in general, the obligations for us should sit with whoever holds actual control, whether that's the protocol, the interface, or a service that is built on top. If there is control, there needs to be some responsibilities. Now, if we look at your three examples, for example, you know, so changing the code.
Speaker: Well, you know almost every system can be upgraded, even Bitcoin, by community consensus. but then what matters is whether one party can change it on its own with no time locks nor or no checks in a way that actually reaches into users funds so that is not possible in a in a decentralized community consensus basis there is no single party that can change that and access users funds in a way right um On setting fees or voting on param parameters that's just governance in the end and at most it's a warning sign that the network the protocol should be somehow understood better ah But as as long as it doesn't turn into actual and real control there needs that doesn't you know doesn't carry any need for regulator for regulatory intervention. and
Speaker: When then it's about controlling controlling assets, that's a lot more simpler, I think. When there is custody on behalf of a client, in the end there is control, there is there is responsibility that the intermediary in that case should somehow bear. um But then at the same time, you know, if we can also think about, you know, those platforms and that in the end, you know, there is an issue of defining everything as decentralization, even when there is clear control. Right. So I think that, ah first of all, you know, substance over form. So the labeling doesn't really change the outcome, of course. and so we want to first in any case make sure that these principles are respected now i'll just add something quick that is quite recent quite relevant maybe for your audience you might not have seen that but in the consultation response by esma so the securities and markets authority basically the european sec or what's going to become the european secs at the end of this whole process um they are proposing an idea of making those you know know cusps licensed meca entities to become gatekeepers for defy so that whoever wants to access defy needs to go through a regulated entity and because the regulated entity basically takes over some of the responsibilities of you accessing defy decentralized services and so we are not but a great big fans of this idea and we will definitely prefer a disclosure and conduct approach and we believe that users should still be free to access decentralized self-custodial services without necessarily having to go through a regulated entity.
Speaker: If they want to, that's an option that should be allowed, should be existing. And when CASPs, when regulated entities are providing this access to to DeFi, there should be disclosure, conduct obligations and so on, but it shouldn't be a mandatory gatekeeping role.
Speaker: yeah And that's huge. And I think it's also worth looking into that because it's obviously a different approach, um like proposing that regulated gateway for providers connecting customers to DeFi, like your point about ESMA earlier.
Speaker: And I just want to like, I know we're also going towards the end of of the arc, but I like think we have to mention also staking because staking gives us another way to test that. Because somebody can do it themselves or have a company do it for them in the sense that a customer sees an offer to earn rewards on their tokens and it could involve either staking or lending, but with very different consequences for for their assets. um And so what difference should the rules reflect? and obviously at a more practical approach, what should users be more mindful of before saying yes and jumping in on that? Yeah, so that's ah also very important area also being analyzed, of course, at eu level, as you point out, you know, staking and lending could look identical to someone on their on their screen, right? From considering what they are receiving, but the risks are very different, right? so you know,
Speaker: With staking, your tokens are basically helping securing a decentralized network, a blockchain network, and their words come from the protocol itself, right? So the risks that you're facing are in the end about lockups, validator penalties and technical risks.
Speaker: When with lending actually, you literally, you know, give your hand, you know, you hand your tokens to someone else who uses them and your your return depends on them paying you back. right That's counterparty risk, and the kind of counterparty risk that blew up in 2022. And so the rules should obviously look at the same two questions as with DeFi. right Who's actually holding your assets and who owes you?
Speaker: Right? So on lending, I don't think that we um that we believe crypto needs its own special licensing regime. um And so there are some principles that can be taken from existing legislation and so on. But at the same time, we also agree that you know clear disclosure is the right idea. And this is also something that Esma has been pointing out. um But then, you know, when looking from a user perspective, I guess these are more or less also the same question that someone should ask themselves, right, before jumping into something that we don't really understand.
Speaker: So who's actually holding my token and can they land them lend them on, right, or what they're doing then? Where does the reward come from? and how long am I actually going to be locked in and what up what happens if the provider goes bust, right? So there are some questions that me and myself as a users, I would ask myself before jumping into a product and from a regulatory point of view, I think these are also similar to the questions we have on DeFi. So before regulating anything, we really need to understand what it means and where lie where lies the control and so where should also the responsibility lie.
Speaker: Great, no and we're almost out time, but before I let you go, i just want to bring us back to what progress could look like, whichever route policymakers choose to take, and I'm sure we'll continue to see that unravel. But if we were to catch up a year from now, what would you hope that this review has changed, and what should other countries learn from Europe's current experience?
Speaker: So first of all again, we don't know whether in one year from now we will be talking about Mika 2 yet, but you know if we are then it will be a new proposal that just came out. So it would also be the beginning of a much longer process to agree on this proposal. So this is also important for you know listeners. um Even if we get Mika 2 proposal in 2027, we're not gonna get Mika 2 rules in practice in place before 2030. So we still have a few years to actually play it with the MECA 1 rules. At the same time, you know what we are hoping to see for a MECA 2 revision is that, first of all, enforcement of the rules become really and harmonized and create this level playing field for firms within the union, so without differences between the different member states, but also for firms
Speaker: that are actively somehow providing services to the union. We also would like to see a stablecoin framework that is ready to scale up, right, for a clear path for global stablecoins, workable rules on rewards, which is also a very important topic, but also the reserve requirements that will make it more economically, and ah ah you know,
Speaker: sustainable for stablecoin projects to launch in Europe. And then, you know, when it comes to DeFi, DeFi that is approach on control and custody and not on codes. And so all of these we're hoping that actually bring Europe to increase the competitiveness of its capital markets, of its industry, and we can close the gap with the other with the other jurisdictions where we're probably lagging behind when it comes to you know tech the tech industry and and so on right so again I think we can close with this Mika one in the end was good for what it had to achieve this one single license the passporting but at the same time if we evaluate and assess it and when looking at the numbers of companies that are actually getting licenses in Europe, the number of startups that are pushed out of the European Union, well we're not completely happy, right? We still can do better, we can be more successful and if we are then it will really bring for clear economic benefits for the European Union and its citizens.
Speaker: Indeed. And wow, I think that with that, I think we can close it off. I'm sure licensing is another type of issue later on. But as I said, trying to synthesize it into 30 minutes or so. But I'm really glad that we we started with the process, that you walked us through that, because there are several ways to address the different issues that we've did but that we've been discussing. And each approach comes with its own decisions, with a...
Speaker: Also like affecting what companies can offer and what people can expect when they use those services. So and to our listeners, thank you for spending time with us. Thanks again to Tomaso. I'm Sylvia. and I'll see you all next time.
Speaker: We hope you enjoyed this episode of the Policy Layer. If you want to learn more, check out avalanchepolicy.com for free educational resources. And also follow us on social media at avalanchepolicy to stay updated.






