The Kayfabe Problem | Why Gabe Kidd’s Story Arc Feels Off

Welcome to the Squared Circle Podcast! i am your host Marie Shadows!

A deep dive into Gabe Kidd’s chaotic character shift, AEW’s inconsistent storytelling, and why fans are struggling to suspend disbelief.

In this passionate episode of the Squared Circle Podcast, Marie Shadows tackles the inconsistencies in Gabe Kidd's recent storytelling arc—especially his alliance with Jon Moxley after proclaiming loyalty to NJPW and Bullet Club War Dogs. Marie breaks down kayfabe logic, character psychology, and the missed beats in AEW's storytelling framework. This episode explores not just the creative struggles behind the scenes, but also the creative mindset required to maintain strong wrestling narratives.

🧠 Topics Covered:

• Gabe Kidd’s character integrity

• Why AEW storytelling feels inconsistent

• Bullet Club War Dogs fallout

• Kayfabe vs Reality

• Wrestling’s creative direction

https://youtube.com/squaredcirclepodcast

https://marieshadows.substack.com