In this episode, we explore an incredibly rare event in Tolkien’s legendarium: a formal Elven trial. We examine King Thingol’s judgment of Túrin after the death of Saeros, uncovering how law, evidence, and mercy operate in Doriath. We also look at:
How Mablung’s testimony and Nellas’s surprise appearance shifted the king’s verdict.
The evolution of Thingol’s character since his harsh treatment of Beren.
Túrin’s growing list of titles and his first official toll.
Why The Rings of Power repeating “the very” over 30 times highlights poor writing.
1:03:54
53:31
56:17
52:31
50:23
32:50