Zencastr
00:00:00
00:00:01
Speed1x
Format▸
Share
Embed
Report

The Building of the Domestic Panopticon: 25 Years Since 9/11

The Beautiful Idea
The Beautiful Idea

0 plays · Nov 18, 2026

Transcript

Speaker: Thanks for listening. to the beautiful idea a podcast from a collective of several anarchist and autonomous media producers scattered around the world we're bringing you interviews and stories from the front lines of autonomous social movements and struggles as well as original commentary and analysis follow us on mastodon and at the beautifulde dot show thanks for listening

Speaker: All right, welcome back to The Beautiful Idea. Today we're going to have a conversation about the past and also very much the present. When we initially talked about recording this episode, this was going to be an episode about what was going on with Noblogs and the fact that the Department of Justice is coming after us, right? i think...

Speaker: Like a lot of you I feel a bit like the wolves are closing in, right? hu I've been around long enough to know that feeling and I can feel that they're coming.

Speaker: It also feels like they're coming in an incredibly haphazard way. And both of those things can be true at the same time. And part part of The discussions that we were having leading up to to getting this episode together started leading into the question of how we actually got here.

Speaker: That many of the people who work on the show, our guests today, were older, right? We remember a day before September 11th. I was nine days into college when September 11th happened, right? So I was already an anarchist. I was already like doing political stuff, right? When all that went down.

Speaker: And the world before that was drastically different. Right? It wasn't great. There were still plenty of problems. Obviously, there were lots of us out in the streets and stuff. But there seemed to be a sense in which there was a series of rules that were played by.

Speaker: And that series of rules had a sort of legal bound, which prevented the state from becoming fully dictatorial. And we could sort of feel those limitations on state power playing out in the ways that their investigations would get limited or in the ways that prosecutions would, would play out, right? Like you'd get arrested for political action and the prosecution generally was like pretty light.

Speaker: And then all of a sudden, you know, now we're 25 years since September 11th. Right. And as we were talking about recording this episode, that fact became very obvious to us.

Speaker: And starting to think about how to explain how we've gotten here, how to contextualize what's going on right now, all of our discussions kept coming back to what happened on that day.

Speaker: And so today we're going to do have a bit of a discussion with myself and our guest today, who is Pooja Gehi, the co-founder of the Alyssa Rodriguez Gender Justice Center and former executive director of the National Lawyers Guild.

Speaker: And we're going to be talking about how we got here. Right. How did the law shift? Right. right How is law completely different today, even if on paper it doesn't look particularly different? How is law drastically different today than it was on September 10th of 2001? How is the state surveillance technology, the motivations between the two, right how they fuel each other, how has that changed since that period of time? right

Speaker: It's important to go back so we can understand how far we've come. that one of the, you know, I studied crisis and collapse a lot.

Speaker: no two And what one of the things that I come back to in those studies consistently is this sense that people perceive crisis in retrospect, that they don't perceive it systematically necessarily in the moment. They perceive the immediate things that are occurring.

Speaker: But the idea that those crises occur at greater frequency and with greater intensity is something that's often seen retroactively.

Speaker: And this is something that's talked about in the fall of the Soviet Union, right? There's there's a really interesting book. it It's called What Was Impossible Then Was Inevitable.

Speaker: And it's about this idea that nobody in 1987 could see that the fall of the Soviet Union was inevitable. But by 1990, it was the only thing that could happen.

Speaker: And what changed was wasn't the condition of people's lives. What changed was that perestroika happened and people started being able to talk about history.

Speaker: yeah And when they started being able to talk about history, they could see two things. One, the tragedy of their own history in the moments that they considered successful. So Stalinism, right? Which was the height of the power of the Soviet Union.

Speaker: So they saw the tragedies, the Gulag system, the massacres, the, the you know, the, Many, many executions that happened. And they could also see how far they've fallen.

Speaker: And it was when they saw both of those things that it was inevitable that something had to fundamentally change. Right? It was in retrospect. And so I want us to talk about the retrospect today.

Speaker: We've come a very long way. And I know we talk about this retrospect in relation to things like climate change all the time. Right. So when I got involved in politics, one of the things that we were going to do is we were going to stop the planet from getting destroyed.

Speaker: You know, we were like, we knew climate change was coming. We were very convinced that it was going to like start to have really catastrophic effects in the very near future. And we were also convinced that if we drastically changed the way we lived right now, we could probably stop that from happening.

Speaker: Right. Ten years later, the UN is releasing reports saying that we have 10 years in order to stop the worst effects of climate change from happening.

Speaker: And that really shocked a lot of people. Five years after that, they start releasing a reports saying we've got a year or two. Now they're releasing reports saying we're past that limit.

Speaker: and Like we're past it. It's gone. And now we are going to experience the worst effects of climate change. And the one thing that we have left is figuring out whether large parts of the planet will be habitable by 2100.

Speaker: We've come that distance in 25 years. So I want us all to just think about how long human history is. right?

Speaker: Think about all of the major intellectual shifts that have happened in human history, how long those took, right? We are watching, we watched a shift from Americana when America was at its height in the late 1990s to a world that is rapidly hurtling towards heat death in 2026.

Speaker: That's how far we've come. So we talk about this when it comes to the climate, or we talk about this when it comes to the economy, right? lot of Lots of people who listen to this show probably don't remember what the economy before 2007 or so was like, but it definitely didn't look like this.

Speaker: It was drastically different. And the financial crisis and the mass concentration of wealth that happened in the process of that really created a lot of the economics that we see today.

Speaker: It's hard to see that if you weren't an adult already in 2008, right? And so when we're studying these things, I know that there's a tendency on the internet for nothing to have context and for nothing to have history and for nothing to have intention or for people to take time.

Speaker: But these sorts of phenomena really caused me to really implore everybody to take the time Read your economics history.

Speaker: Read your environmental history. Read your history of surveillance and law. right Understand your context. right Because the thing is, is we've come a long way.

Speaker: And so we're going to talk about how long, how far we've actually come. today in this in this discussion, right? And we're going to talk about it sort of linearly, right?

Speaker: So let's go back to 2001. For those of you that weren't alive yet, or for those of you that were very young, when that day happened, it sort of is like how my parents talk about the Kennedy assassination.

Speaker: Everybody remembers where they were. When it happened, I was, I was in the student center at my university when I saw tower on fire after the first plane hit. Right.

Speaker: By the time I got back to my dorm, the second plane had hit the second tower and it was clear that this was intentional. So that was within like 45 minutes. Right. After that happened, after that happened, everything changed.

Speaker: it you started seeing this mass rise of almost sort of frantic patriotism, right? Every single one of us that was a dissident was immediately suspect, right? Like immediately suspect by the people around them. the government was telling everyone to call the FBI if they saw anything suspicious, right?

Speaker: We really did see this kind of intense, intense, horizontal social repression happened, right? But at the same time, there was this sense in which it was all sort of an attempt to put something together in the moment, right? That they were trying to sort of build a self-defense mechanism as they were using it, right then actively.

Speaker: And it didn't really have the systematic force. And in the months that followed, they then passed the Patriot Act. Right. Which is what systematized all of that. So maybe walk us through the Patriot Act. Like, what does the Patriot Act lay out? What does it let them What bureaucratic changes did it force? Right. Like major bureaucratic shifts. Like what what happened when they passed the Patriot Act?

Speaker: Yeah, and thanks for having me, Tom. Always love chatting with you. And this one this is also particularly interesting because i I told somebody recently, we are at the 25th year, right? And I told somebody recently that 9-11 changed to the trajectory of my legal career. and so And whoever I was talking to was a journalist and they said...

Speaker: Mine too, exactly. and that And I've heard that from a lot of people my age. And so I'll just say that, um well, I went to law school. I'm going to go into the Patriot Act in a minute, but I went to law school. I got a bunch of money to study international human rights and then I guess I'm a little older than Tom, but my first semester of law school, September 11, right? 9-11 happened. I was in DC and I quickly shifted from like, oh, I don't want to work with these white dudes who rewrite constitutions and war torn by the US countries and have studied and practiced criminal immigration since then and now specifically for trans people.

Speaker: And so I was right was working on a paper early on about like, I will just start by saying it was the Immigration Nationality cis Service was INS. Before DHS, before the Patriot before all of that ever happened, INS was a pretty dysfunctional agency, highly critiqued. I published a paper about inefficiency.

Speaker: September 11th, they did away with the INS. It was largely blamed for September 11th and issued the Patriot Act, which went on to create the Department of Homeland Security.

Speaker: And i looked you know I looked up the statute just to sort of remember what it actually says, what the actual title of the statute is. And it is and i think this is important because it's so broad and also sort of names everything that the Patriot Act does allow the government to do and continues to for the most part. So it's called Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Abstract Terrorists, 2001.

Speaker: two thousand one And so the Patriot Act is quite long. It allows for domestic and international surveillance and and and in the many forms, including wiretapping, phone tapping, door knocks. there's no It goes on to say there's no impunity for any kind of illegal activity that happens within it the act of trying to protect national security. There's many, many, many, many other pieces of it.

Speaker: And i will say the Patriot Act set the stage for what we're seeing as like so and the intersection of criminalization and immigration, which has continued and strengthened since 9-11. And so at the time, the immigration system was a separate system from the criminal justice, criminal injustice system, say. They quickly merged it to create, what I'm not, oh, I do. It's like, it's NCIC, which I do not know remember what it, stands for, but it's combining two very flawed, already flawed systems into one system. So now law officers can go, like cops can go into the system and see exactly what a person's immigration status is and both arrest them based on that. Well, this has been debated and is coming back in style, was defeated, whatever. That's a whole other thing. But but being able to see both criminal convictions and immigration status in the same database is one, deeply flawed often. Often there's mass amounts of errors in those descriptions. And then two, gives the police and the feds, and we didn't have ICE in the same way, an enormous amount of power to to arrest, deport, et cetera, people without any grounds of evidence, very little grounds of evidence. And so I think the pink, The thing, it's very long. I encourage people to go through the actual Patriot Act because I think it is very applicable to everything that happened since then and how we literally got here today.

Speaker: And then I wanted, I can't remember exactly where we our next big hit was, but I kind of wanted to just name that in the precursor to this is in 1996. I want to say, i can't remember who passed it. i want to say George h w passed the IRA. It's the i r IRA. It's like I-I-R-I-R-A. No one remembers what it stands for. But it is it is basically like increased punishment, deportation actually for two crimes,

Speaker: that are any crimes of, what do they say, moral disconduct, misconduct. So it's basically what I say is like crimes poor people do you to to survive. Like in New York, it's like jumping a turnstile, like petty shoplifting, sex work comes fun into that. So any kind of two of those convictions and you're out of here or one felony conviction and you're deportable also. So I think it's been like a slow build to combining those systems and then 9-11 gave them the exact rules moment they were kind of waiting for to increase the criminalization of both, you know, the war on terror, like all of the classic tropes that we've heard before, four, like the war on terror, including immigrants in the way that it does now, but like the war on drugs, the war on welfare, the war on poverty, like all of those things combined into one big war on terror.

Speaker: and so I think it's just important to name that. And a lot of people in immigration world, there continues to be a campaign that is Fix 96, which means get rid of this IRA ira bill, which is seems almost impossible to new to do now, given the infrastructure and the ways in which it's moved forward so rapidly, to have immigration and law enforcement overlapping and, in in fact, able one and the other able to implement each other's whatever they're supposed to do, criminalization, Yeah.

Speaker: Yeah, I mean, you're getting into this question of data exchange. yeah yeah And, you know, one of the really sort of fascinating parts about that era of 2001.

Speaker: So for those of you that that don't remember, a lot of us weren't on the Internet. Most of us weren't. One of the great things about going to college is you got the Internet. For free. And it was a streaming 10 megs a second T1 connection. Like wild, right? $3,500 computer, which I worked for a year and a half to save up money for, had one one thousandth of the power of my cell phone now.

Speaker: And if you had a phone, it was like a brick phone. Yeah. And you could only send text messages and call and there weren't apps, right? Like none of that existed. There there was none of that.

Speaker: Servers, like the things that are in data centers, were less powerful than your laptop. Mm-hmm. Right. So what was happening at this time that I think on the technical level was really fascinating is going back, you know, we can talk about the roots of the Internet with Project Phoenix with the CIA in Vietnam.

Speaker: Right. And they were using motion sensors. And like wired motion sensors that they would drop from helicopters into the jungle along the Ho Chi Minh Trail and phone lines to transfer back motion information to an office in Saigon.

Speaker: right And it was the first time that like network devices like that had really like used a network stack to send data back in that kind of a way. right And then they port this forward and they start using it to network missile silos together. And then they start using it for the military to exchange information. Then they start using it for universities to exchange information. And then it gets used to build the FBI crime database. Right.

Speaker: Now, when that gets built, what they did was they, that's the FBI crime database back at in that day, in the 80s or 90s, what that meant is that if you were a police department with the internet, and most of them didn't have it, but if you were one with the internet, you could go query this system, and then a query would go to a physical person.

Speaker: That physical person would go find the actual paper documents, digitize them, and then you would get a response in email. And it would take days. so Right? This is what that meant. Okay? so one of the things they talk about around, like in the 9-11 report, for example, is they talk about how it was a failure of data exchange and data collection that allowed this to happen. And so their solution was, we'll just do mass data collection. Mm-hmm.

Speaker: We'll collect all the metadata of all the emails. We'll collect internet traffic. We'll collect phone call data. We'll collect all of this stuff as much as we possibly can. And then that will give us visibility into what's going on.

Speaker: Right? But the problem was that they collected all this information and then the computers were way too slow to process And so there was this sort of period of time here in 2001 where the ideas were in place.

Speaker: Right. There were ideas kicking around the and NSA already about things like data correlation engines. Right. That now they use AI for. Right. Like these ideas are old. Yeah. And so they're kicking these ideas around all the way back in 2001.

Speaker: But the tech just wasn't there. Right. And the coordination wasn't there. But I think that we really start to see that shift like five, six years later. Right. So I know in my life, what that looked like was by 2006 or seven, it used to be that you would just like go to an action and then crash the state border and you're good.

Speaker: Right. Like you, you would just bolt right after the thing was done and you're, you're fine. But starting about 2006 or seven, that stopped being true. And all of a sudden I started getting pulled over at a bunch of different States around where I live.

Speaker: So like, say where I live in all the states around it, I started getting pulled over very consistently. And every time I would get pulled over, it'd be a big problem. Dogs would come out, backup would show up, guns would get pulled, I'd end up in the back of the car, someone call me a terrorist, right? It was all very confusing, right? It was all very confusing for a period of time, especially when you're dealing with small town cops who like, caught their first terrorist, they were so excited.

Speaker: but what changed? Like, what happened during that period of time bureaucratically? That allowed for all of that to happen. Like it wasn't just the internet. Right. So what sort of structures did they start creating around this period that really kind of, I mean, ICE was created. ICE was created. Right. DHS really started to consolidate. But like what really, what really started happening during this period of time?

Speaker: Yeah, I mean, I think it my response is that the large databases, right? There's all of this information on all of these people into one giant database that I really believe is incorrect. And know i don't know as much about the FBI. I guess maybe I do. But I will also say DHS is created, i believe, in 2003, which then and holds USCIS, which is the U.S. Custom Immigration System, ice As we know, the Customs and Border Enforcement, CBP is the criminal, does CBP, Border, Criminal Border Defense, TSA, which I think is interesting, FEMA, including, i believe there's a total of 25 agencies now under the Department of Homeland Security, and massive, massive budget increase to all of these agencies that were largely underfunded in the past. And so I think, i mean, i I'm curious to think we to hear what you think, Tom, but I think that the combination of Patriot Act, you could do there's basically no penalty for any kind of surveillance for versus prior to the patriarch Patriot Act, there was like a Fifth Amendment, there was due process rights, like a wiretap, You had to get a warrant. You know, I had all of these things had to be in place and you no longer had to do any of those things. And then would you say that it was around the time of Facebook, the social media, et cetera?

Speaker: yeah i I think a couple of things yeah started kind of happening around here around this time. So the first was more people got online. Right. Right. So they were doing online data collection, but it wasn't necessarily the most useful thing. Right. So like when I was doing the organizing back then, I did that in person with people. Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker: do that on the internet. We met in coffee shops. So like monitoring our digital communications wasn't going to teach you anything. you know If we got really sketched out about the feds being around and seeing us in person together, we would just start leaving dead drops around. Like that's how we did this. It wasn't Like we didn't, we were all sketched out about the internet. yeah Like that, that's the reality all of us were super sketched out about the internet already. And so when Facebook started happening, right, because MySpace didn't really have the same,

Speaker: data collection capabilities that Facebook has. MySpace was really basic comparatively and like LiveJournal was very basic comparatively. It didn't collect your data. It only had the data you gave it.

Speaker: What Facebook did that changed is Facebook started adding what we refer to as super cookies So when you go to Facebook and you log in, it sticks a tracking cookie in your browser and it tracks your browser activity, right? It looks where you go to buy things. It checks, you know, what videos you're watching. And then it starts to craft your content for that user, right? Google also started doing this. So like early Google didn't do this. Mm-hmm. After Gmail was created and now you had a Google account, they started doing user tracking.

Speaker: So user tracking tech started increasing. And that also meant that there was data available to the state that they didn't have before. Right. Because there was data at all that didn't exist before.

Speaker: They were creating it for the first time. So there was that. The second thing that happened was they started fusion centers around this time. So I know in my city, the Fusion Center is a physical location, and it is the regional Fusion Center for this entire region of the country. And it is and it is a floor of a police district station, kitted out with, like, every computer monitor you could imagine, and an entire team of people that sit there and just watch the surveillance cameras and monitor all of the flock hits and, you know...

Speaker: do records or requests calls from police and like all this stuff. They just serve as a constant 24 hour a day interagency coordination center. Like that didn't exist before. Right.

Speaker: And so when you start to take the fact that data is now ending up in one place, And that our rights have eroded so much that they cannot collect it in a lot more places. And that we've started giving it away for free. Yeah, I was going to we're sharing everything about us on the internet and organizing. And that I feel like that's the beginning of organizing starting to happen online, which is very different than you and I came up, which was like...

Speaker: Spot the infiltrator. We're always in a meeting together. We do deep, deep vetting. You have actual relationships. Spotting the infiltrator was really easy because they were the new person. They were wearing clean clean Converse was the thing. Too clean. yeahp to clear yeah yeah but yeah i mean it's i think it's all i mean i think it's ah from thinking about it from a disability perspective or like a globe like organizing globally perspective i think it's really Yeah.

Speaker: you know both Tom and I are a stay off the internet, don't share your information person. I have been i was an ED for a long time, so I actually cannot get on off the internet, which makes me bananas. But I think, yeah, i mean, I think that's around the time where, and obviously, we'll flash forward later, but it's increased exponentially. But back then, there was there was a database, so they knew a lot more money more about where we were, who our friends were, where we were going, you know where we lived, et cetera.

Speaker: The Beautiful Idea is a proud member of the Channel Zero Anarchist Podcast Network. Here's a taste of another project on CZN.

Speaker: The State Between Us is a damn near weekly show on the wacky weirdos and long loony lore base of our ruling class, their state keeping us apart, and efforts around the world to bring us back together. Want to know about the nasty Nazis behind the conservative movement?

Speaker: Patreon.com slash thestatebetweenus. The centuries of resistance against our common foes? Just how terrible fascist fanfic can get? That's all on patreon.com slash thestatebetweenus. A member of the Channel Zero Network.

Speaker: Yeah, and it it got to the point, so, about 2008, when the RNC-8 case happened, right? So, to give you all... So, let's go back a little bit.

Speaker: In Minneapolis, in St. Paul, the Republican National Convention was going to happen in 2008, and this was at the height... of sort of coordinated anarchist direct action street demonstrations where we were capable of shutting entire cities down and like tactically taking on police departments effectively. And so in the two years leading up to the convention, because they announced the convention site really early in the two years leading up, they stuck four infiltrators into organizing circles locally.

Speaker: They ran a two year long infiltration campaign and They even arrested eight people for conspiracy to riot and furtherance of terrorism. They even wrapped up a crew of kids from Texas in some sort of conspiracy plot.

Speaker: Right. And out of that, kids from Texas went to jail. And the people who got charged with conspiracy ended up pleading guilty to disorderly conduct. But in the lead up to that, there they had put together a list. I mean, this showed up in Discovery. They put together a list of 300 of us whose job that they gave to local police was to stop us from getting to the Twin Cities.

Speaker: Right. That was not a thing that would have been possible two years before that. yeah Right. That that's how big that's a drastic of a shift we're talking about here. So like now all of a sudden the fact that I'm doing stuff in Washington, D.C.

Speaker: becomes relevant to police in Minnesota. And we now think of that as like, well, yeah, of course, that's what happens. Right. That isn't what happened before that. So to to give you all another example of of a period just before that, during the Green Scare, yeah you know, we talk about the Green Scare often through the lens of court cases. But for those of us that weren't on the court case side, what that really meant for us on the ground was the FBI was doing what I would refer to as generalized local sweeps. Mm-hmm.

Speaker: So like I live in an area really close to where some of those actions went down. And so in every city near where I live, you would just wake up one morning and you'd start getting calls from people the next city over like, oh, the feds are around. And then all day they'd just be knocking on doors, pulling people over in their cars, dragging people in for questioning. And they do that for like two, three days and then they'd move on to the next city.

Speaker: And so the response that a lot of people had was they just moved. Right. Or just move to a different city. Right. And for a lot of us, this didn't work for me. I did move. um I actually moved to a completely different state.

Speaker: It didn't work for me for reasons. for But for a lot of people, it actually did work. Like that actually was a thing, you know, like you you could just do that and like vanish for like six months and then just pop right back up. That used to be how people would would sort of let the heat die down.

Speaker: is you would just move somewhere else and lay low for six months. That changed all of a sudden, right? And that changed during this period with joint terrorism task forces. Right. And and mass amounts of... the construction of the databases. Of infiltration during the Green Scare. And the infiltration got more sophisticated, i will say, by around that time.

Speaker: yeah Yeah, and so what was happening with legal strategy, right? So I think from the outside, what it feels like... is before September 11th, there was this sense in which the state, though we were dissidents, the state considered us citizens. Right, right. and therefore we had certain rights.

Speaker: And that those weren't to be violated. It didn't matter how much they didn't like us. Right. And like you can even see things like prosecutions of weather underground people. Right. Exactly. Going certain ways because like the cops violated their Fourth Amendment rights. And you're just like, wow, that definitely wouldn't play out that way today. And you're right. You're right. You're absolutely right.

Speaker: So what changed? i mean, like, there is this moment where, like, that that seemed to be the rules of the game. And now we look at the way that the state approaches us, which is open warfare. Open warfare. Right? Just, like, open, overt weaponization of the law, open, overt weaponization of the Department of Justice, right?

Speaker: Overt weaponization of the FBI, right? I mean, we would they literally give press conferences about it. So what what changed, right? Like that that's a pretty drastic shift.

Speaker: right, in the way that a state approaches its citizens. Yeah, yeah. And I think we were just talking about this, Tom and I, before this. And, you know, i think one, i think there's a lot of things that have shifted. And one is the very, very, very intentional stacking the courts, right? It's stacking. i mean, it goes back. There's people on the courts who were appointed by Reagan. They're still kicking it. You know, they're still creating bad law. But I mean, we see the Supreme Court now and it's not a coincidence that it's been like, that it's whatever it is, it's majority read, hard read, and we're losing like basic constitutional arguments that have been on the books and in the case law forever and they're correct and they're somehow overturning it without creating a constitutional amendment. And, you know, I think in that time, it was, i think there was a lot of, i would think there was like the war on terror had escalated, the war on drugs. It's like never going away.

Speaker: and the the amount of money that it went to into criminalization and also surveillance, counter joint terrorist tax force was ridiculous. And I think that there was ways in which the court both, like the laws were changing really quickly, but also the courts were just saying, ruling against people, it doesn't matter if your Fifth Amendment was violated because, like whatever reason, and it would hold. And I think that is a really big shift from what it used. Like I would read these cases in law school from

Speaker: you know even the ninety s and be like, oh, okay, if you plead the fifth, like they got to let you go. but but they, as we know, absolutely don't. right So i think those were i think there's a lot of legal shifts, but I think it's hard to point to one thing specifically. I think they all intersect with each other. And the thing that I think about the most is the stacking of the courts. Because I'm like, I am so glad I'm not practicing in immigration court right now because you can win on a lower level, you cannot win on a paddle level. We can certainly not win anything on the Supreme Court level. And I think that a lot of it, I mean, like Tom said, is the weaponization of law. like These were your rights. And and even when I do Know Your Rights trainings, going back 20 years, even say when I started practicing, we're like, these are your rights, it doesn't really matter. Like you don't actually have rights. You should know them what they are. You should try to state them. And also there are many ways for them to get around to them, including like like anything. It's so easy, so easy to criminalize yourself by saying nothing even or saying like, I plead the fifth. So I think i think those those are just increases and shifts in the law that really have been really intentional over a very long amount of time, including the tech side, which i know Tom knows more about, but also people just put themselves up there. So yeah, I don't know. I mean, I will say one the one that sticks out for me is the the first action I ever legal observed was the free trade area of the Americas, which goes back further, right? It's 2008.

Speaker: Three, i think. Yeah. there' other three Yeah. In Miami. And it was, it was families. It impacted that that FTA impacted everybody, you know, impacted workers and impacted immigrants. It impacted like factory workers impacted students. Like all in the streets, all of the unions, all, all of the anarchists, us. And,

Speaker: same Same with Minneapolis. like there were There was massive amounts of infiltration happening for years prior to that. And we were really on it I mean, we had been organizing part before leading up to the FTA for like a year and a half, probably, including older people, including professionals, including you know all of these people who did not identify as an anarchist.

Speaker: And it was full-on war against us. like they Somebody threw something at the police in their riot gear, and I i was legal observing with my partner who got thrown. There's like old people with their glasses shattered on their face and getting getting thrown in the cop car. My legal observing partner, this is the first time I did this. It never, ever used to be like this at all because they were like, Which is also a whole other like lawyers are exclusivity bullshit but that I don't believe in. But no, my co-person got tackled to the ground and thrown in the back of a cop court. I ran for three hours and still ended up going to jail for four days. like Every single person on the streets got arrested. and People got arrested arrested after the fact from looking back at organizing meetings and things like that. People went in before the action. like That was the one where I was like, I mean, I will say my case was dismissed and I did get a settlement. And and I think that is maybe...

Speaker: It's not a thing that would happen today, but but it was such egregious, for the illegal all use force of action that, I don't know, that's that I've seen nothing like that before. I couldn't even go back to Miami, like literal war zone for a long time.

Speaker: Yeah, yeah, there are definitely parts of cities I came to because of stuff like that. yeah Yeah, I think the thing that strikes me about Miami, or my version of Miami, it was April 2003 in Oh, yeah. It was the month after the Iraq War. Oh, I did that one too, yeah. Yeah. Let loose on us rubber bullets right in front of the World Bank. I'll never forget that. But like, because after September 11th, like radical activity died down for a couple of years. And then during the anti-war movement picked back up. And so I think when that happened to me and I heard rubber bullets whizzing past my head, it was like, oh shit, this is a war now. Yeah. Like, this is not a protest. We are not, like, having a good time anymore. Like, they're trying to hurt us. Like, this is actually an actual conflict.

Speaker: And that changed everything for me when that happened. And what that reinforces for me, right? So there's been a lot of really interesting writing about this. And I think kind of pushing our timeline forward a bit.

Speaker: What we started seeing, I think, around this you know, 2008, 2009, and then into the through era, was we started seeing what you know, anti-imperialists call the imperial boomerang happening, right?

Speaker: The methods that they were developing in Iraq. So after they invaded Iraq, the insurgency didn't start immediately. It actually started after Paul Bremer, the guy who was sort of the, you know, governor general of Iraq or whatever, disbanded the military.

Speaker: And when he disbanded the military, he threw like thousands of people out of jobs and those people had weapons. And so an insurgency started really, really, really quickly.

Speaker: And so the U.S. military immediately started pouring money into tech development. Cell phone system monitoring, internet monitoring, network mapping software, all of this stuff. They started pouring money into this. And like, if you go back and you look at the tech of the Iraq war,

Speaker: in 2004 or five, you can see all of the precursors of the stuff we see today. So they would, they had a system, which I actually used this in Baltimore during the Freddie Gray riots in 2014, but there was a system where they would fly Cessna over a city for like 24 hours, right? So it would land and refuel and go up and it would just fly circles. And it had a high res camera and it was taking area images of the entire city.

Speaker: And what they were doing was they would do this in Fallujah, for example. They'd fly around, and then if a roadside bomb went off, like an IED went off, they would then go back to the footage, and they would look at the spot where the IED went off, and then go back in time, find the car that dropped the guy off that put the the IED there, then follow the car back to the garage that it had come from, and then go raid the house next to the garage.

Speaker: And they were moving back in time by doing mass data collection. Right. This was like 2005 or six. Okay. They also started doing mass cell phone data collection in Iraq around that. So they started tracking who was calling who.

Speaker: And this wasn't tech that they were using in the U S necessarily yet. They also innovated the idea of tracking people's locations by their cell phones in iraq So that was a thing that they really started innovating there.

Speaker: But most importantly, what they started doing was they started doing mass data correlation in Iraq. So they started taking all of these data systems, bringing them together. And then, and this is before AI, mind you, right? So this is before like what we now call AI. It back then was referred to as machine learning, right?

Speaker: okay And it was incredibly rudimentary. I mean, the the roots of AI that we have now go back to experiments that were done in the 1970s. So they were using like machine learning and data processing scripts to get all this information and figure out like who was calling who at what times and stuff like this. And really starting to like use information backwards, like use it retroactively to build storylines.

Speaker: right? By the time we get into like 2010, 11, 12, and into 2014, we now have companies like recorded future who are doing this for the government, right? So they're now monitoring Facebook. They're monitoring Twitter. They're monitoring Instagram and all this stuff. And they're writing reports and they've got contracts like every police department and the federal government and the feds are doing this themselves, right?

Speaker: So we start seeing this period where all of a sudden they can gather way more information. right And they can correlate way more information.

Speaker: And I think the thing that we started seeing around that time was we really started seeing this phenomena of people getting arrested like five or six months after the fact right for stuff that would have happened in riots where their image was like caught on a surveillance camera.

Speaker: Right? Like that kind of stuff started happening around this time. They also, I think, started prosecuting people a lot more heavily around this time. So I think that's what really sets the stage for where we are now, right? We sort of, that tech has gotten better.

Speaker: The data collection has gotten significantly better. The amount of data we give away has also increased dramatically. All of that is happening at once. They now have flock cameras that can put data into these backends. They have tools like Palantir that can query the backends, right? Like Palantir is a data backend and agent system for querying backends to do data correlation, right? They're using you know all manner of...

Speaker: Retina scanning, DNA testing data, all this stuff. And it's all getting pumped into the same systems, right? Clearview AI. So when in Minneapolis there was footage of ICE agents like scanning someone's face with their phone and then pulling them out of a car. Yeah. yeah What was happening there is they were using the Clearview AI app, which is a private company app on their private phone, scanning someone's face. Yeah.

Speaker: Having that generate a possible recognition, having that go back into Palantir, gathering a bunch of data, bringing it back to the agent, generating a report and giving it to them in the street. And then the agents were going, oh yep, this person's this person, just dragging them out of the car. Yeah.

Speaker: right smashing their window and dragging out of the car. right That's where we're at now. which is so so and like i I was just thinking about just having grown up in the ninety s right? and like When there were drones, you know we were like, oh my God, a drone. It's surveillance. Now I'm like, there's drones like everywhere all of the time and they also can read my retina. you know It's just like so such a rapid escalation of surveillance in such, a I think, a short amount of time because it's our life you know our lifetime.

Speaker: but but yeah, thinking about that and then thinking about the ways in which all of these things are flawed, right? It's like, We know about false DNA matches. People have been locked up for 30 years and then they find out that it's actually not their DNA. you know they Their DNA matches and then they they find out they're incorrect. and i mean Same with that with this, the images of it you know migrant folks, immigrant folks, and then they're like, oh, actually...

Speaker: never mindd And it's kind of the same as like a lineup from back in the day of like a bunch of black fit men you know who have fit the same description and someone picks it out, except it's not. And I think also people believe in it.

Speaker: don think people believe in that too. and I think people believe in the accuracy so much because of the tech side. Yeah. Well, and and I think this is the part that you can speak to best, but I think what it's led to... So there there was this... You were talking about stacking the courts, right?

Speaker: And that's a strategy that takes kind of a long time. And so we've watched it play out for a while. And what I've seen from that is that... though the law was in place to functionally declare war on dissidents, though the technology increasingly became possible, right? Right. um The legal field for a long time held an increasingly shrinking line, right?

Speaker: That they would issue rulings sometimes that, you know, seem to push back against that dynamic. right And now but you still have judges doing that, but now you have an overt unquestioning weaponization of the federal government. Right.

Speaker: Right. So in, in a way in which there is no more confusion about what they're doing, there is no more hedging about targeting certain groups of people. Like they have just crossed over the sort of like Schmittian line and have moved like full on into understanding the state as a relationship of force. Um,

Speaker: And that's led to, I think, you know, what we're all seeing, which is really freaking a lot of us out. So what is going on? I mean, like, what is happening in the DOJ? What is happening in the FBI?

Speaker: What is their strategy right now? Like, it seems, Noblog seems like, i don't want to call it a random target. Yeah. But it seems... if you know what's going on, a bit random.

Speaker: Right. Yeah. So, like, what what's happening here? Like, how are you reading this? Yeah. And what think they're trying to Honestly, I don't think... they know where they're trying to go. i think it's like, big I mean, I think a lot about the targets, right? It was the ED of the National Lawyers Guild. They're on the do DOJ investigation list. SPLS, the Southern Poverty Law Center, which, you know, granted, is pretty mainstream. Like, people know about it, but not but it's not like...

Speaker: the biggest and and non-profit like representing trans people, representing poor people. I don't know. Like I don't honestly know. Like I know that it's not random and i also it also seems incredibly random of who the targets are, which makes me really be, I mean, one in and of itself, they don't even know what Antifa means, right? And so it's like a grasping of this language that And there's like, you know, Tom, there's a video of me on YouTube that I'm the CEO of the Antifa. And so I think there's like that piece and it's really a scare tactic. And also I'm like, what does it mean? Or like no blogs, right? And like, what does it mean to say there's there's an open investigation and how is it moving forward? Because the NLG, SPLC, I mean, s SPLC I think is is happening. I think it's a bad one. The NLG, like they've been quote on that list for a very long time.

Speaker: I don't know what's going to happen. It also makes me think like all of their offices, all of their information, and their confidential legal stuff could be raided at any moment. you know and so Which happened in Cointelpro. It's a thing. and also i also think like using the language that we use for o ourselves, like I'm an anarchist, I really legitimately do not think they know what anarchist means. I think that you know they say things like Mandami is an anarchist. and like That is not true. And the whole like DSA sweep,

Speaker: sweep which ah surprising but also the way the way in which that's all weaponized it's like the things that are that are the rhetoric is just so feel like it's so out there but it's also so fear-mongering and so I don't actually know what do you think about how they're happening how the and these investigations are happening and what is next and what it's what is really gonna happen I don't know And I could tell you another, just like look thinking back, sorry, I'll just answer this more. But looking back at Cointelpro, and we could do a whole episode on that some other day, but which was the Red Scare days, like they were really going for administrative errors today. tax fraud, things like that, right? for things For organizations that they considered to be too radical or the NLG for representing like the Black Panthers or the Young Lords or something like that. And they are. And the fact is like a lot of nonprofits do not have the infrastructure set up because they don't have the money to be very, very careful and

Speaker: their administrative files. It's not like they're trying to be fraudful. It's not that they are committing fraud. It's just though there's very technical ways that they they were going after folks, which is kind of what I've been anticipating in this moment, but it's but we're not seeing it in the same way.

Speaker: Yeah, that's that's what I anticipated too. I know like myself, I... do some side work outside of work. And so have a little LLC and like, make sure that I file all my taxes for that now. yeah I don't want to be, i don't want to get caponed essentially. Right. Like that's, that would be a really dumb way to get out. And that is what I thought was going to happen. I think part of why we're not seeing that, and you, you would know more about this cause you talk to lawyers a lot, but yeah,

Speaker: It feels like the Department of Justice and the FBI are shells of their former selves. Yeah. but Like the, what was It was the Colorado Attorney General hired an entire civil rights division of attorneys that used to be federal prosecutors in Minnesota because they all quit earlier this year, like every single one of them. And so they just got snapped up by the Colorado Attorney General office, like every single person. What does that do?

Speaker: To the DOJ. Like, yeah you would understand this better than anybody, but, like, what... When you have a systematic loss of institutional knowledge like that, when you have...

Speaker: this evacuation of the hierarchy. And so you have this mass scramble for jobs. Yeah. Right. Within the people that are still left. Yeah. Like what kind of dynamics does that bring forward? Because it what it seems to me to do is it seems to call forward federal prosecutors who are trying to make careers for themselves. So yeah these really absurd cases, right. It's like anything they can hook into yeah and kind of haphazard prosecution. Like that's what it looks like from out here. And that,

Speaker: My theory, my thinking is that that's probably why they might not have done some of the more technical things is that they're actually just not capable. Yeah, I kind of think that's true as well. And we see people, I mean, the GOJ is one, people are fired.

Speaker: Two, people are just leaving. Like all of the good civil rights lawyers I've known, and there's many in the civil rights division have gone to the nonprofit sector. either from getting fired or from from leaving. Most people leave. It's same with judges. Immigration judges have resigned masse. And so I think there's like there's a lack of historical knowledge. I don't even think they know about that history of Cointelpro, to be honest, because that's not what they're skilled up on. They've never learned it, right? Or they've never been trained. and like i like the people that are they're giving away like a million dollars to join ICE you know without any...

Speaker: any experience. And I think that is a different piece because that's just like a recipe for full on war, which we're seeing every day. But I think that, yeah, I think the technical piece, they don't know how to do that or they don't have the admin tools to figure out how to do that, which is interesting, which makes me think when they open investigation,

Speaker: on an organization say no blogs. like How are they doing that? like How are they going about doing that and what does that mean? And I i don't know. i mean, it is depleted. They're shells of themselves. But also, they're being the people who are being ah hired, appointed, are like wingnuts. They're extremists, like Christian nationals, who I don't know. It's like,

Speaker: Yeah, and then, I mean, I think it also goes to the legal system being broken. Like, I think there basically is no legal system anymore, and so it kind of allows for a rogue Department of Justice, you know? And I think that's really scary, because we don't quite know what's next, and then we're also like, and are they just not efficient, and they don't know how to do anything?

Speaker: i don't know. Well, they think that this is where the stacking of the courts becomes super important, right? So you're seeing... I think you're seeing prosecutors willing to file more ridiculous cases because they're hoping to land on a judge that's going to hear the case.

Speaker: o And so we're seeing things like the cop city indictments and things like that, because, you know, I mean, if you if you think back about the cop city theory of the case, it was completely absurd.

Speaker: and right But there was a person in a position to file that case that probably wouldn't have been in that position 20 years ago. Right. Just to to give a like corollary, you know, institutional knowledge becomes this really important thing. And I think we we lose sight of that because we have the Internet now. We can just look stuff up. But there are lots of things that we do as humans that aren't written down.

Speaker: The two examples of this that I always go back to. The first is German workers in the 1960s used to have this strategy called the work-to-rule strike, where what they would do is they would still work in their factory, but they would do it exactly to the specifications of the manual.

Speaker: they wouldn't do anything to go faster or make their job easier or it better. like They would just do it exactly by the book. And what everybody found is that production would like grind down 70% when that would happen because so much of the the productivity was happening because of these like small little adaptations that workers were making yeah to their workstations and stuff. right But another version of this is Twitter.

Speaker: So after Musk took over Twitter, he like fired everybody and they lost 10,000 years, literally aggregate 10,000 years of institutional knowledge about how a relatively complex deployment system works.

Speaker: Right now Twitter breaks all the time that there, there was a situation, think it was four or five months ago where ever since the beginning, Twitter had this accessibility feature for people with astigmatism and you could click a button and it would like render the page in a certain way that would make it easier for you to see if you had an astigmatism.

Speaker: And then one day this year, it just went on. Yeah. Yeah. And no one knew why. So the director of engineering for Twitter was, you know, doing an interview and someone asked him about it and he goes, oh, well, it was really hard to maintain feature.

Speaker: The reality is, is that was a entirely passive feature that was like 40 lines of code, right? It wasn't a hard to maintain feature. What actually happened to what he didn't want to admit and what came out later is that Grok, their AI had decided that, you know, accessibility features were like woke.

Speaker: and made it go away and then didn't know how to put it back later because it didn't know how the code worked anymore. yeah Right? Like that's what happens. So when something like that happens at the DOJ, you start to see these really intense effects. Right? So I think the question that everyone's asking yeah right now is, you know, we've got two and a half years of this administration left. Right.

Speaker: Right. Probably due to the political unpopularity of what they're doing, the next administration, whoever it is, is going to have to do things pretty drastically differently. Right. Right.

Speaker: What can they do in two and a half years, given the slowness of the pace they've been working at? Right. The kind of so like what it feels like to me is like they're establishing a bunch of legal tools like they're saying,

Speaker: this is a terrorist organization and we don't know how they're going to use that tool later, but now they have a tool and they might use it later. Right. And then we see it sort of pop up in the Prairie land case. They kind of use this terrorism argument that it pops up in the Minneapolis case. And, you know, like they kind of have these tools that they've been building and they have this little toolbox now, but it seems like they've been taking so long to build the tools that they're running out of time. So like, what, what are they capable of doing? Right.

Speaker: in this period of time with what, with the tools that they've built. So they've already figured out that they could internationally declare as terrorists because they can't do it domestically. Right. And that, that might disrupt what we're doing and things, but like what, what else can you anticipate them trying to,

Speaker: trying to do at this point. I mean, I know it's hard to guess. I would kind of push back and say like they are ah yeah they're dysfunctional and inefficient and all of those things, so it's moving slowly.

Speaker: But at the same time, like these masks, whatever his he's calling, Operation Mask, Deport, to whatever he's calling it, is happening really quickly. They're bombing the ships in the Caribbean on the daily. People are dying and people aren't even thinking about it or talking about it. Similarly with immigration, people are talking about it. It's live streamed. It's disgusting. believe that's a piece that's moving people away from the Republican Party in general and Trump specifically, but I also think it like the judges aren't stopping it necessarily or they stop it on a lower level and it gets overturned. And so it's like people are getting shipped to countries not for that they're not from or here and like on the daily and plain rules. And so it's like, what can they do on the books versus like what can they do? you know And I think what can they... i mean, i

Speaker: I like have also been anticipating like the camps. you know like are like i work specifically with trans people, and are they going to round up all the trans people and put them in a camp? like I don't know. I don't think they have like the tools or infrastructure to be able to do that at at a rapid pace, especially within two and a half years. But also, like they're throwing they're shooting andre like they're shooting white women in the head for... protesting you know the arrest of a migrant or whatever. And so it's kind of like, I think it's kind of both. like If you think about it, and I know I'm the lawyer, so I'm supposed to answer it from the like legal perspective, and I think legally it it's limited. and then ah functionally, i think it's endless. And so I don't actually know. And then another piece of this, which is not exactly related, right? But like we are in a war with Iran and forever, it seems, I don't know, and war multiple wars around the country. And so I think like,

Speaker: is you know It takes like that with's shock doctrine, Naomi Klein's book. it's like If there was a bombing, if there was an attack like on the US, how would that pivot the not the like national mindset and politics and the national landscape? And how quickly could they invoke some furthering of anti-terror laws ah domestically or whatever they it is they want to do? you know And I know that's like...

Speaker: People are like, oh, that's not good really going to happen here. like They have all the military bases in the Gulf. It's such an easier target. And also, like the escalation of violence in this country and the way in which people are losing their mind, like regardless of... going down the conspiracy theory trail, like being a right-wing libertarian, you know, any of those things. I think people, just the escalated violence and fear is so increased right now that should there be, should you know, I'm in New York City right now. Like I always think about it on the train. Like should there be chemical warfare on the subway? I don't know. And then what would a response to that be? Because there are the emergency power things, right? That can override Congress. I mean, we're doing this war without Congress. So think both and, right? like It's slow, it's a shit show, and also it's rogue. So i don't really know what the answer is. and i i mean I also think a lot about like like special registration right after 9-11. There's NCRs where... Muslim men within a certain age group from some very large amount of majority Muslim countries had to register with the federal government. Like a number of times, not just once, but periodically. And I think about like all this stuff, the attack on voting booths, the closing down polls and like poor, this is a whole other thing.

Speaker: other thing, but I do think it's all related. And so it's like, what like like there's they're not legal things and they're going through anyways. you know And so I think just like, is the midterm election going to be a ridiculous like mass arrest of people, of immigrants, of us, of radicals, of terrorists? you know I don't know, but Yeah, I guess I don't know. i feel like kind of like opposite. like They're capable of a lot in two and a half years that are they're not legal, but nobody cares. Yeah.

Speaker: Well... On that positive note. On that positive note, yeah, we always close the show on positive notes. Well... yeah Yeah, I just... i want to I want to just encourage everyone to...

Speaker: take these things seriously, right? Like we have been building in the United States for like 30 years as anarchists and have really gotten to the point where we present a threat to their ability to continue their projects, right?

Speaker: That has consequences. And i think, you know, it's sort of like I used to say back in the day, We should note but not complain about police brutality when we experience it because we're fighting them.

Speaker: That's what we should expect, right? This is what we should expect if we are an effective movement. There's a reason that, you know, the PSL doesn't see this kind of oppression, right? because they're entirely ineffective.

Speaker: But when we're effective, this is what we see, right? And so I want everyone to be cautious, but I also want everyone to be focused on what's actually happening around them.

Speaker: Right. Don't fall into paranoia, which is really easy to do situations like this. yeah Don't fall into conspiracism, which is really easy to do in situations like this.

Speaker: Focus on what's in front of you. Read, study, right. Make your decisions with all the knowledge that you can. Right. I was recently talking to a young person who was telling me that you know, a lot of the young activists, they just, they think the telegram is backdoored by the Russian government and signals backdoored by the U S government. And I went and I went, well, but signals open source project and we know the founders. And like, I also know we know the founder of signal. on its Yeah. who's right

Speaker: Yeah. And that's, and that's the thing. Yeah. And then people call me boomer. Those are all pieces of information that you could easily look up online. Hell, I've written an article about it. If you want to go back into the old, it's going down archives. I wrote an article about this myself, about why we can trust open source projects, specifically things like signal and where, and other people have written about like where the latent security holes still are. Like there's been plenty of research on these things. So go out and read the research. Yeah.

Speaker: Because it's been done and it's yeah been done well. Right? So this is a time to not rely on emotion, to not rely on what some dude on the internet said, but to actually sit there and understand what your risks are and what threats exist around you and what you and your crew people need to do to lock yourselves down so you can stay quiet but also be effective. Right?

Speaker: Because this is going to be a relatively fraught time. And we have to learn how to do this again. right For those of us that have been around for a while and have been through this more than once, this is the time for you to teach the younger people how to survive this. right There are a number of us that have had to go in and out of living semi-clandestinely over the years and have learned a lot.

Speaker: Yeah, and I think i i personally like you know collect elder like radical feminists, mostly mostly queer and trans people, because I love learning, and I learn so much. I mean, I have a number of friends who survived, who fought the civil rights era, were in and out of jail all the time, did Mississippi Freedom Summer, did all of those things, and did SNCC, and you know all that, and I'm like, listen just listen to your elders, like even, organ I organize a lot with people who are like 10 years younger than me doing solidarity work and I've said things like, you know, saying you can't actually, um yeah they can't actually intercept signal, like it's about your disappearing messages, you know, like you don't need to to use a fake name, you know, you can if that makes you feel good, but it's actually not going to do anything because it doesn't stay on the server. But then people don't listen to me, you know, because they really do.

Speaker: I think me I'm a boomer and i think it's I think everything that Tom says and also like stay off the internet as much as you can. you know like i know that it's a way to keep in touch with people and I know that we want to put ourselves up there and I know that I'm like already on the radar of the dark deep web because it never goes away and I still and i have to do social media for my organization and stuff and I hate it. like I know that everything we put up there is being surveilled and sometimes I do it as a fuck you. like whatever, which I don't recommend. Don't do that. But i just think that like as far as far as, especially with organizing, like keep the organizing off the internet to as much extent as possible.

Speaker: i think what I'll, what I'll close with and leave everyone with is, you moments of repression, you want to feel certainty and you want to feel safety. And the tendency is to get ideologically rigid and very certain in your ideas. Yeah.

Speaker: The irony is is that that's fatal when you're dealing with refreshing. You have to stay flexible. You have to learn from your environment. You have to learn from the people that have been around. right like We have the skills. We know how to do this.

Speaker: Don't just wing it. okay so like This is a time to build relationships. This is a time to go back to the old ways. right This is a time for us to start to really build the human networks that have sustained this movement for over 100 years. Yeah.

Speaker: Right. That's what I'll leave you all with. Thank you for being. I mean, i like, this is really bad, right? This federal repression is very bad. And also, like think globally, you know, like, folks have survived and resisted for a number of number of years, like the U.S. is a young country and you know empires fall and I do believe that it's going to fall. But I think like global like learning about global uprisings and revolutions is also ah a pastime of mine and Tom's. But I think it's a really powerful tool. you know And I know globally it it looks real fascist right now too, but historically there's been really amazing like overturnings of governments until...

Speaker: the OS coos them again. but But that's all. I mean, I think just like learning, rough forever learning and it's ah it's all a new, like Tom helps me with the tech stuff because that is not my area of expertise and like just thinking about the ways that all these things interact and have like built upon each other over a number of years. And yeah, we got this.

Speaker: Cool. Thank you for being here. Thanks for having me. And thank you all for listening. This has been The Beautiful Idea. we will talk to you all soon.

Speaker: Thanks for listening to today's episode of The Beautiful Idea. News and analysis from the front lines of anarchist and autonomous struggles everywhere. Catch you next time.

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Recommended