Zencastr
00:00:00
00:00:01
Speed1x
Format▸
Share
Embed
Report

Going Deeper with Beth: Reclaiming the Feminine in the Divine

Red Tent Midrash: A Red Tent Living Podcast

Transcript

Speaker: Hi there, and welcome to Red Tent Midrash, where a mystic, a pilgrim, and a storyteller gather to ponder the feminine themes of the Bible.

Speaker: We are women who nurture a love for our faith, even as we grapple with reclaiming scripture from traditionally male and religiously charged contexts. We three are writing books and curating experiences that connect women to themselves, to one another,

Speaker: and to the divine as they live their stories. This podcast is a safe space where we commit to keep learning together. We invite you to join us.

Speaker: Hi there! Welcome to episode six! Hello! Hello! So, this episode is yours, Beth. I'm just gonna hand it off.

Speaker: It's it feels like a great segue from yours, Katie, so much of what we talked about um with what you're thinking about and studying, i think overlaps and parallels a little bit of where I'm at.

Speaker: um i I'll just start with a little bit of context and history. so was it two years ago maybe, Tracy and i were were on the heels of of our Lost Women of Turkey pilgrimage.

Speaker: We were following the, I think the threads of Empress Theodora, who's the sixth century Empress, Byzantine Empress, who shaped so much of our faith in unknown ways. And we we were following her trail and it led us to Egypt. And right around that time too, I think in conversation, Tracy said something about um a trip you had gone on in Egypt and how the tour guide had said, Christians should become, yeah everything starts and leads back to Egypt. And so it was the birth of our planning and imagining the Lost Women of Egypt pilgrimage. And it it like it like ignited something in me.

Speaker: And i would say starting last summer in in more rigorous preparation to go there twice, but last year, i started just deep diving into of the Sinai, actually less about what was on the other side of the denial. And there was something about the stories of the Sinai and St. Catherine's monastery there at the foot of Mount Sinai that just captivated me.

Speaker: Parallel to that time of deep diving there, i was in Turkey again, just personally on sabbatical. And i went to a museum by myself one day,

Speaker: And i went in search of what I had learned they had discovered in 1967 was this tiny statuette of a mother goddess.

Speaker: And i saw her, i just stood there for so long, just staring at 8,000 years old, for fully formed. This woman sitting down, huge breasts, huge buttocks,

Speaker: and flanked by felines, which they believe were leopards because of other paintings they found where she was buried. And giving birth, there is something in between her legs.

Speaker: And as I finally tore myself away from her and walked the museum, I saw as as the the layout of the museum went through like came closer and closer to present day and went through the civilizations,

Speaker: in the central in central Turkey, I saw civilization after civilization, people group after people group. The mother goddess morphed, but was still there.

Speaker: Always a seated woman flanked by felines, wearing some sort of headdress. Her dress changed. Eventually she was in a toga as the Romans incorporated her as mater, ah mother god.

Speaker: But there she was over and over again. So I was fascinated by that. And then I'm studying Egyptian cosmology and we're seeing the mother goddess there in numerous forms.

Speaker: And Then i'm I'm in the Sinai and I'm just thinking, where did she go? where What happened? um And so I'm starting to study the the Israelite people in the Sinai as they leave Egypt. What do they bring with them? So this is kind of all where my brain has been over the last year.

Speaker: I'm reading all sorts of crazy books like Goddess and God, the Great Goddess, the Hebrew Goddess, Goddesses and the Divine Feminine, When God Was a Woman. I mean, I'm like all over the map and they are all over the map too. I'm reading you know women who actually literally worship the goddess and Jewish scholars like Tichofa Fry-Markinski, who we've mentioned already, who is clearly a Hebrew Jewish believer herself, but who is handling like there was definitely something here around the the nature of the feminine in the Hebrew Bible. And so whole spectrum.

Speaker: And I'm lost. I'm just like toying back and forth. My brain's going back and forth as I'm continuing to wrestle with this. And I can't i can't get rid of this kind of compelling draw to the Sinai.

Speaker: And I don't know why. Tracy says I'm a quick, fast thinker, but I am really slow to understand my own soul. So I tend to write to figure myself out.

Speaker: And sometime in the spring, I decide, well, I'm just going to write. the stories of the Sinai. And I'm a linear thinker, so I decided I'm just going to go backwards in time.

Speaker: And I'm going to touch on the stories that feel like they are capturing this idea of erasure of the feminine. So women who have somehow had their fingerprints, they on the Sinai, around Mount St. Catharines.

Speaker: And I'm i'm intrigued. like I love those stories, but I know as I'm writing them and I'm going backwards in time, there is something deeper that I cannot put words to and I can't shake.

Speaker: And there's a theme here for sure of kind of the nullification, the eradication of the feminine um voice, the feminine story here, these women who keep to keep appearing and tending to the sacred around this place, this geographical place. But what's the point? What is it actually telling me? what is Why am I still so drawn?

Speaker: And so I keep going backwards. I know at some point I'm going to be wrestling and writing around about, and we've talked about this already, where Moses is on top of the mountain and God says, i am like, I'm a womb-like God. And I know there's something there in the theme that I've already been exploring of the erasure, the nullification.

Speaker: i don't realize until I actually write the last my last substack of the series, that the actual nullification I've been so drawn to is the nullification of the feminine of God.

Speaker: And it was such a challenge to write a thousand words that that summarize these tens of thousands of words that I've read over the last year.

Speaker: And so I will attempt to just summarize in a nutshell today where I'm at and still am at, like, I still just feel like, Oh, this is what I want to be learning more about. And I'm still very much in the midst of it. And I also just want to preface for listeners. Like I feel, i feel so much respect for scholarship, scholarship,

Speaker: for PhDs for those who are who've spent their lives focused on one tiny little aspect of what I'm about to do broad strokes over.

Speaker: So there's a lot of risk I feel and even writing about this and talking about it because it feels just so insufficient to the scholarship that's out there and available for, for people to read more about. So I just want to say that because it's always, that is always with me in the back of my head, but here's where my last substack ended. And here's where I'm currently at in my mind is that the Israelites leave Egypt we're We're in the second millennium.

Speaker: And so in in that time period, in that region, ancient Near East Mesopotamian region, it is polytheistic. It is the norm. For thousands of years, like my little goddess statuette that I discovered in the museum, there has been there have been goddesses.

Speaker: There have been gods and goddesses. And it was how humanity negotiated gender roles. So if women in a society were basket weavers, there was typically a goddess who was in charge of basket weaving.

Speaker: And of course, then there were always mother goddesses because there were always mothers. And in early civilization, when it was far more egalitarian than what it has become, goddesses and therefore women had equal status in society.

Speaker: And therefore there were plenty of goddesses, plenty of gods. When we have the onset of monotheism, which is complete departure from surrounding culture and pretty revolutionary in history, that like that is the beginning of this whole new way of viewing the divine.

Speaker: we have problem. And this was this is largely influenced by Tikva Krimer-Kensky and her book, In the Wake of the Goddesses, where she really addresses the unintentional consequence of one God who now has absorbed the function that every God and goddess played in society.

Speaker: And in the attempt to be that one supreme, all-encompassing, both genders and also genderless God, there is a vacuum left for people trying to negotiate and understand themselves and also therefore who God is to them.

Speaker: Despite all of the Beautiful metaphors and attempts, I think, of God to communicate, I am like a mother.

Speaker: i am like a father. That was not the lived reality of the Israelites. Because around that same time period as the evolution of monotheism, there is also an increase in patriarchy.

Speaker: because we have had small city states turn into nation states. So now we have Israel becoming a nation. We have other civilizations becoming nations.

Speaker: That leads to warring. We have more aggressive civilizations coming from the north, waging war We have the Iron Age. So now we have weapons. And all of that leads to a more patriarchal world.

Speaker: which leads to the suppression of women and also the suppression of goddesses, the diminishment of both. And especially in the Hebrew culture, we have this, and you named it last episode, Katie, of the Old Testament is a very male-centered, male-dominated kind of picture of God.

Speaker: That is very cultural, the Israelites are becoming more patriarchal. And so that filled the void of this genderless God.

Speaker: whether or not And it's hard to know, like the Bible was written in Hebrew, which is a gendered language. What if it had been written in a language that had a neuter option?

Speaker: What if it had been written in a non-patriarchal world? What would we have? What would be we be reading about? But instead it was written in a gendered language in a patriarchal world. And what Tikva writes about is it left this, like I said, this unintentional vacuum that was then filled and masculinized.

Speaker: And so i just have been sitting with this call, this pull for me to the geographical space of Mount Sinai and what happened there. Like why am i so drawn to to this place?

Speaker: And I have have found myself in this kind of ground zero moment of that is where, where the birth of monotheism happens and the eradication of humanity's ability to negotiate gender.

Speaker: And it was this the ground zero of the nullification of the femininity of God. And it's no wonder that if the femininity of God is obscured, then the femininity, our femininity of women,

Speaker: would be obscured because we are created in the image of God, right male and female. But if the female of God is obscured, then our femininity is obscured as well. And it's what we have inherited. That is the lived experience that we have today.

Speaker: And so that's what I'm sitting with is despite God saying, i am a womb like God, despite in Exodus 6, when he says to mo Moses, says, who is sending me?

Speaker: so back to the back to Egypt and God says, I am, i appeared to your forefathers as El Shaddai, but I am appearing to you now as I am. God is saying, oh yeah, yeah, back then i i showed up as the breasted one.

Speaker: They might have known me as a mother goddess. It's not how I'm showing up to you now. Despite that, despite Rahum, I'm a womb like God, despite all of what you talked about, Katie, last week, that is not what the Israelites knew and it's not the world in which they lived. And so lost.

Speaker: we lost I don't know where to go with that, but it has been this kind of, I've just been allowing myself to sit in that as I realized that I think that's what has been pulling me.

Speaker: I've long had this theme of erasure and invisibility of of women. And I think this origin ground zero story is where I'm landing as maybe as kind of the source of that for me.

Speaker: So what do you think? So I guess I have a couple of thoughts, Beth. I mean, i you're so careful around your scholarship.

Speaker: And i heard you even in your like disclaimer, you know, around around your scholarship. And you are a very thorough scholar. Like you're very careful.

Speaker: But the intersection of like your your scholarship is is intersecting with your own soul's journey.

Speaker: And the only expert on that is you. So i I think I'm wondering, like how how is that for you? That like this you're you're so you're headed into this territory that is is only partially quantifiable.

Speaker: I told you recently, i i make meaning first with my head. um And so i i think that has been part of this is my head leads my heart and It's almost like I i do need something. i don't know if it's quantifiable, but something concrete to locate myself inside of.

Speaker: And I think that's what this journey of right of going backward in time was a part of, is trying to figure out my heart and locate itself in something historical. It's not lost on me that that the the thread that I can actually pull all the way through is Theodora.

Speaker: Yeah, so i I think it's so interesting that I'm just going to say it again. It's this intersection of what is concrete and you can go back and like touch it and touch it and touch it. And, and and you know, you start with like these fingerprints. You can find their fingerprints, right? Because there's not like this hardcore evidence always.

Speaker: And yet their fingerprints lead lead you these places, right? and And the fingerprints are all here for what you're naming. But I think what you don't have words for yet is is not concrete.

Speaker: And it's going to be really risky to name. As I listened, I felt like as you were setting the stage, you were talking about this pull, felt to me like an ache. Like there's there's a a longing, but it's it has maybe pain, maybe fear, maybe like questioning, maybe like there's ah there's a wound, there's a wound here.

Speaker: And because you can go on quests for different reasons. And so like, I just, I was conscious right away that I was like, okay, there's there's ache in this quest. And then it it felt to me like as you were narrating, like there was this realization, like we can't grieve what we don't know we've lost. And so like, what have we lost? Because as you were narrating, I was like, I've never heard anybody talk about the goddess God pairing that way, the negotiating of roles and like a ah loss of ability to negotiate roles with people.

Speaker: the advent of monotheism, like just the way that you framed that, I was very connected to what that would have cost a culture. And then and then you talked about this vacuum that just got filled.

Speaker: There was like a taking in it, like that at patriarchal seizing. And so it's like, I i feel like most of the time, I was getting getting a sense of the landscape of loss. And i I want you to even like press deeper and go deeper. and And almost like that was like an aha moment for me as I was realizing like, oh, there there are things to grieve here. And then it felt like the turn at the end was like, now that we've named it, what are we grieving?

Speaker: And i i don't know I don't know if that's in similar space to where you were, mom, but I i felt like there were like multiple stages of work and care. like we're We're on a different kind of journey. This isn't just to know.

Speaker: You love to know, but this isn't just to know. As you said all that, Katie, I was thinking, there's like the again, there's the concrete sense of what was culturally lost and What was lost with this shift? What could they no longer negotiate? But what i know, Beth, and whether you write about this or not, i don't know.

Speaker: i Although I kind of do know because I know you This is going to mirror, this is mirroring something inside of you. This is mirroring something ah of your own story, like your own journey. Like I don't, it's going to be there.

Speaker: It's going to be there. You didn't drive that day. What compels you to go to the museum that day and sit in front of, is it Kai Belli? Is that what her name is? That's what she became. They refer to her as just the seated woman. The seated woman. That seated woman is about more than history to you.

Speaker: So I love the way that Katie said that. like And I think maybe that would be part of what I would be wondering about and inviting you to is like, as you're doing this excavating, as you're finding the concrete words over here, you know, and it makes me even think about your master's and what you what you chose to do in your master's, which was what?

Speaker: Participatory photography, letting communities tell their story. but And you're still doing it. it's still It's still you looking through the camera lens to like tell the story of a community.

Speaker: But while you're doing it, to be asking, like how does this intersect? What do I know of this? What do I know in my core of this? because Because then on the other side, that that then invites your readers and your audience to to do the same. Mm-hmm.

Speaker: And I think that's part of what's so beautiful about how you write, even like the way you wrote Lost Women of Turkey. is like you're youre you're narrating your own journey through history, like all but you're but you're saying, and this is what I'm realizing about me, and this is what I'm realizing about me. And it's just, it's so beautiful. It's this, I don't, I really don't know anybody else that that I know of or that I've read that that has done that the way that you do.

Speaker: And so it's this really sweet, it's like, and and I think it's done this for me. It's like, oh, I can be a historian and a scholar And be wondering why this matters.

Speaker: Like, how does how does this touch my life? And the fact that you're taking it all the way back. And now what we're about is the loss of a part of who God is.

Speaker: So now i want to ask you something else. Like, what do you what have you been thinking about about Hathor and that golden calf? And that that feels like a breaking point.

Speaker: Like that's the last moment, right, of this of it being present. And I i wonder, if youve have you been thinking about that? Yes.

Speaker: I think to Katie's point last week, bringing up Shekinah and the the desire and the ache for something more tangible of the femininity or of the mother,

Speaker: in in people did not go away. And it's where Shekinah, the feminine presence of God comes from in Jewish mysticism. It's where perhaps the emphasis on Virgin Mary comes into play.

Speaker: And even for the Hebrews, it was potentially Asherah that was still worshiped in some form all the way up until the exile.

Speaker: and so

Speaker: again, I wonder, and this is just more in my brain still, like if the ache and the the genderless God in a patriarchal world robbed them, robbed them of that ache and of that mother. It left them nothing, right? it robbed them it It robbed them of the good mother, right? He's a good father, but do we have a good mother? And as you name that, right? It's like,

Speaker: Hathor at the base of Sinai, potentially Asherah moving forward. And then, and, and, you know, we, we stood there where Mary is like named the Theotokos and we and we wept like, which is wild. You know, i grew up like, that's all so bad. Like all this veneration of Mary is so terrible, but, but there was something of like that,

Speaker: connection I think that we felt at at that point in time as we're starting to realize and we've just walked through erasure, erasure, erasure. They're gone. They're gone. The women are gone. They're gone. They're gone. They're gone. And this is the last like, okay, but she's the Theotokos.

Speaker: Like we have our woman. Well, and all of the parallel we saw in, again, her depicted, even her is seated now with Christ in her arms, but still in that same kind of pose yes as all of those mother goddesses throughout time.

Speaker: So it just feels innate to who we are, how we've been designed and created. We long. and And maybe that's i mean that's felt more poignantly probably among women because the image in which we we were created has been obscured.

Speaker: Well, if we take it, if we tag back to what Katie was talking about last week, if that's what we were meant to understand about who God is, we all, men and women, have been robbed of like an essential part of the divinity.

Speaker: It's been, it hasn't just been lost for women, right? It's been lost for men and women both, which feels important to acknowledge and to remember because in the loss of that, the expansion of masculine energy and the power and the overcoming and the warring and the like, all all of that is just, it's out of balance.

Speaker: There's nothing to balance it. And that has been very costly for men. And then it's been costly for women, you know, in a different way. And and for women, it has come with the with the narratives, the biblical narratives being tied to humiliation for us because we are whores and we are responsible for the fall of the world and not to be trusted. Mm-hmm.

Speaker: right so oh it's It's not just out of balance for us. There's a naming of us. a marring of our barring our image. Yes.

Speaker: There's a particularity, I believe, there's a particularity to the engagement in Genesis 3 and the words around the curse about what will be true between evil and the woman.

Speaker: that they're It's different. You're at enmity. There's something there different.

Speaker: and the experience of women from that point forward. And I think that's what we've seen. Like if our battle is not against flesh and blood, it's not against other men, it's not against the patriarchy. If our battle is ah is against evil, then it it begins there in in particularity for the female.

Speaker: So back to what you're fighting for, Beth. I think I'm both fighting for my own reversal, reversed erasure, or feelings of my own invisibility, but I'm also fighting for my faith. i became so bored by the version of God and Christianity that I feel like I've been handed.

Speaker: And it feels so anemic. And yet my gut knows it's not true. I think ultimately I'm trying to reclaim, not reclaim, I don't think I ever, I'm trying to refashion my own faith around a God that feels more true.

Speaker: And to read, like what you said, Katie, last week, to read differently. And that feels like reclaiming, reclaiming scripture, reclaiming the God of the Bible.

Speaker: that is That is truly different than I feel like what I've been given. i found myself wondering if it's like reforming, reclaiming, or if you still don't have the word yet for what you're doing, you know?

Speaker: i don't think you ever had I don't think you were ever invited to believe in the many-breasted one. but Right. you You were never invited to believe in that God.

Speaker: and and i i I know for myself, when when i when I consider the the many-breasted one and the womb-like God, and like this is who God is, and then the Bible is this epic story,

Speaker: If we start there, how does that change then how I read some of those stories that feel so disturbing?

Speaker: That's you know an episode for another day or maybe many other episodes, but but it but it matters. you know What if it's fresh faith, it's not reformed faith?

Speaker: That idea feels catching for me because like, Something that was happening as you were speaking, like I i was realizing like, because you saw the seated one, she she was a window for you. Like you have this ability, you see windows into the divine. It's like, whoa, that like, that shot through with something true.

Speaker: And as i as I think about in the polytheistic cultures you were explaining it, it was like, those were mirrors. People were creating gods for mirrors for who they are. There's a basket weaving God because I weave baskets. There's a mother in God because I'm a mother. And like this formation of like, I know who I am because I have a mirror, like I can negotiate this.

Speaker: what it What I hear happened in monotheism is that got ah a hell of a lot more violent. the pattern didn't change. It was just imaging it was still a mirror. Nobody was looking through a window. Nobody, like God was trying to, we could argue God's creating windows and, and everybody's using mirrors. And so like a new faith, a like who, cause there were multiple kinds of violence happening. There was erasure happening. There was warping happening. There's othering happening, but it's like,

Speaker: it's different than what you do when you like, you're like, I'm looking through to see the heart of it. i don't know. And that probably feels kind of like, met but it's like, I think the, the, what the image is for matters. Is it so I can know God or is it so I can know me? Is it so I'm okay in the world? Cause like a lot of how,

Speaker: to even to this day, like part of why God feels so anemic is it's like the image exists to validate and to justify violence and patriarchy and things that don't, like it's it's the image is for us.

Speaker: So interesting the way you phrased that, Katie. Yeah. yeah like the And I liked the play of mirrors and windows. If God was always creating windows and But all the people wanted was the mirror or the people are only seeing mirrors.

Speaker: And it made me think like, I'm okay because God is in my image. I mean, I think there was like, I i don't know who I am if I can't see me in God. like Right. Right.

Speaker: and And so there is there's a very violent erasure that women are feeling, but there's a simultaneous violence that's happening with like, the point wasn't to keep doing that. The point wasn't to have like these shadows that,

Speaker: to be seeing through mirrors dimly, who it it was to blow the whole door open. And like, there's a different way to relate. And the divine is not like you. It's many breasts, not two.

Speaker: So is it feminine? Yeah, but it's not human. It's feminine, but not human. And we don't know we don't know what to do with that. like Well, and that you you you are like God, but you are not God.

Speaker: And so you are in his likeness. You'll have part of this. You have some of this. You are like God. God is not like you. Right. God is not like you. And that's not that is not bad.

Speaker: No, but it goes to the point of why Jesus then was so important because Jesus was like us. Well, and all of the descriptions are met it like, I am like this. I am like this. I am like this. I am like this in our in an attempt to relate to us. And so then like I'll come and I'll be like you. Right.

Speaker: incarnate in the flesh. Because God knew it would take that. It's very, it's very fascinating. Keep going, Beth. I just think there's such richness, like things that arrested me. Like I i think the genealogy, the heritage of the goddesses, like what passed down, i thought that was really important. Like that needs to be pressed on and named.

Speaker: I thought understanding like, the direction of the imaging and what it's for is potentially really important because it might be the second piece of the story. You know, you know, some of the wounds and some of the aches and some you've, you've named one loss, but there's another threaded loss.

Speaker: And so like to name both, I think is the secret to new faith, not reformed faith. It's acknowledging that the, It's acknowledging that the core is corrupt, that we've we've all been- We don't want it back.

Speaker: We don't, right, right. It was never good to begin with. It's why it's why culturally so many have walked away from church because they've recognized the core is corrupt. And they're afraid that means the like the whole thing. Because started.

Speaker: Right. And it's like, maybe we started in the wrong place. That's why it feels so big. Right. Yeah. i I say yes. Yes to everything that Katie said. and i and I think in the same way that we told her, like, you've done enough with your connection, you know, potentially with Egypt. I want to tell you, like, Beth, your gut will tell you when you've done enough. Your head won't.

Speaker: Your head's going to tell you you have to keep going and you need you need more concrete and you need one more citation, right? And so i i guess...

Speaker: I think your gut is good. Thank you both for processing that with me. It was so fun. Like, thank you for giving us a peek into all of what you're sitting in.

Speaker: And why. It's beautiful. This is fun. this is This is more fun than walking around in Exodus. I told you it would be.

Speaker: i mean, it was, but I think, I think that was good too. It's been the food for the thought, but yeah, I i was excited about the second half too.

Speaker: All right, next week. see you, mom. Bye. Bye.

Speaker: This is Red Tent Midrash, where a mystic, a pilgrim, and a storyteller ponder feminine themes in the Bible and the Christian faith. We share this space to learn together and to grow, pointing to wiser and more studied scholars who have served as our guides.

Speaker: We do not claim to offer a definitive interpretation of scripture. But we do seek to consider it from multiple perspectives and encourage you to do the same.

Speaker: If you loved this episode or have a question to share, connect with us at Red Tint Living on Instagram.

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Recommended