Transcript
Speaker: Welcome to SCORE Podcast.
Speaker: In this podcast we discuss the responsibility of sports for and within society.
Speaker: What impact should sport have on our world?
Speaker: Can sport do more?
Speaker: Who's responsible?
Speaker: To address these questions, we focus on possible solutions and desired scenarios.
Speaker: We break our discussion down in four parts.
Speaker: First, we describe the current situation.
Speaker: Second, we draw the ideal future scenario.
Speaker: Third, we walk backwards, defining the key milestones.
Speaker: Then, we call for actions needed today.
Speaker: And we are your hosts today, Donata Taddea and… And Alexandra or Sasha Volkova.
Speaker: Today we got together to discuss the future of International Federation's engagement with grassroots.
Speaker: And we invited Mike Naivelersnik to do this exercise with us.
Speaker: Welcome Mike to SCORE Podcast.
Speaker: Hello, hello from Munich.
Speaker: Mike is an international senior sports management consultant.
Speaker: Mike switched over to the sports sector in 2011 after 10 years in corporate management consultancy.
Speaker: Ever since, Mike has been mainly working in strategic planning and commercial business development in various international sports federations.
Speaker: Mike paved the way for 3-3 basketball to become an Olympic sport and reorganized volleyball's event assets for media and partnerships.
Speaker: Currently, Mike is working on Handball Masterplan 2028 and is a member of Sports Climbing TV and Marketing Commission.
Speaker: Mike told us that throughout all these years working in sports, he has been amazed how well sports governing bodies are exploiting their commercial rights for the elite sports in comparison to how little is invested into global grassroots projects.
Speaker: I'm quoting Mike here, but instead, I suggest we start right away talking to him.
Speaker: So let's move to the first part of our discussion and define what is happening now and today.
Speaker: Mike, let's actually start by establishing a common ground.
Speaker: What are grassroots programs and why should they be important for international sports federations?
Speaker: Well, it's complex and as multidimensional like many other things in sport.
Speaker: My personal description of grassroots is literally everything that is not elite.
Speaker: And now, as we know from the Olympic history and from the history of many other sports, even the discussion about what is an elite competition or what is elite sports is rather complex.
Speaker: So I would break it down to grassroots sport for me is everything where people are doing sports and not getting paid for it.
Speaker: And can you explain how it's different from amateur or the concept of amateur sports then?
Speaker: What's the difference between grassroots and amateur?
Speaker: Well, there is, as you probably know, back from the 70s or 80s, there was this big discussion like which, for instance, in tennis, but even in boxing, that certain players or certain athletes had amateur status.
Speaker: And then on the other hand, were not allowed to participate in certain professional events, which I personally never understood.
Speaker: why this distinction was actually made anyways.
Speaker: But from our perspective as of today, and I would think that's probably the definition that most modern sports marketers and sports management people have in mind, elite sports, elite competition is really where professional compensation for the players is involved.
Speaker: where everything else, so, meaning grassroots, is really people practicing and participating in sport events, but not getting paid for it.
Speaker: But this is, again, my personal definition and it's probably something that you would not find, or maybe you would find it on Wikipedia, I didn't check, actually.
Speaker: Mike, and why then this ecosystem of grassroots should be important for the International Sports Federation?
Speaker: Well, the interesting thing is that over the last, I would say, 20, 30 years, so let's say as of the 70s, 80s maybe, were really not only the American leagues as probably one of the first ones, but then also event organizers, of course, like FIFA, like UEFA, like the IOC, really commercially drove their assets to a whole different level.
Speaker: I would say this really started in the 70s, maybe in the 80s.
Speaker: And what happened is, in my opinion and from today's view, is that many of the sport marketers and of the sports governing bodies, of course, realized that you can make a lot of money with the creation of your elite competition through media rights, marketing rights, licensing, you name it.
Speaker: And this worked well.
Speaker: I mean, if you look at the income those organizations are making over the last decades, that's really impressing.
Speaker: And I feel that at the same time, because there was so much money to be made, in a way, most international sports federations, at least, in a way, forgot about the development of the grassroots.
Speaker: because they did not see an immediate return on invest financially on one side and on the other side.
Speaker: And this is now a highly political point.
Speaker: And we might go into more details later on.
Speaker: But the second reason is that from an international Federation's perspective, the grassroots sports, meaning that development aspect per definition was not part of their responsibility, but was actually
Speaker: the responsibility either of a national federation of the respective sport, if not even more local, meaning some kind of regional federation.
Speaker: So they didn't really feel responsible for a global development of their sport.
Speaker: Again, not in every case, but I would say in the majority of the cases.
Speaker: And this also really just changed maybe a little bit over the last five or 10 years, I would say.
Speaker: I just want to come back to what you said before.
Speaker: Can you explain by what you mean by international sports federations are quite reluctant to invest in grassroots?
Speaker: So why is it important for them?
Speaker: Why they should invest and why they are not investing?
Speaker: If you could give us more detail.
Speaker: Well, if you benchmark it, literally what is happening in the private sector, I mean, if you see or if you just read what the big management consulting companies, for instance, the McKinsey's, the Boston Consulting Groups and so on, what they did over the last 20, 30, 40 years is there was always a trend of centralizing and decentralizing businesses.
Speaker: This happened in many industries.
Speaker: There were certain periods of time where it was very
Speaker: en vogue to centralize businesses.
Speaker: Then after a couple of periods, there were other times where then decentralization was very much en vogue.
Speaker: Today, the common, let's say, management sense is that it depends.
Speaker: There is no one fits all solution for different businesses, for different industries.
Speaker: For instance, in the private sector, if we take the automotive industry, where I used to work before,
Speaker: It is in a way common sense now that of course you have a headquarter and of course you have centralized business operations, for instance, accounting, for instance, central product development on one side, but then on the other side, the whole sales process in the automotive industry, so where you buy your car, for instance, is a very much decentralized business.
Speaker: So this is just a benchmark from the automotive industry.
Speaker: Now, if you copy paste this into the sports world,
Speaker: In my opinion, the same thing should actually be happening.
Speaker: So as international sports governing body should actually reflect and think, okay, what's the status?
Speaker: What are my capacities?
Speaker: What of my entire work that I need to do in order to grow my sport can I do centrally and should I do centrally?
Speaker: And what can or should I outsource to my national federations or so on?
Speaker: So this is the choice that they could actually make.
Speaker: But what I'm trying to say
Speaker: is that in my opinion, many international sports governing bodies were focusing on the elite part only, as I said before, purely because of commercial reasons.
Speaker: And second, because they always thought no development is done by the national federations.
Speaker: Now you asked me, Sasha, why do I think that this should potentially change?
Speaker: Or why should they have a motivation to change?
Speaker: Again, if you think about the benchmark that I gave you, of course, if you centrally at least steer and define
Speaker: your development programs and your grassroots programs, if you do this centrally, well, then of course you have a way higher chance to have a, let's say, common and aligned development process along the entire world.
Speaker: If you leave this to every country or to every continent, well, then they can literally do whatever they want.
Speaker: And this is unfortunately what happened in many, many sports over the last years.
Speaker: I want to come back to what you said previously, that they have to grow the sports.
Speaker: So apologies, I'm repeating the same question like third time.
Speaker: Why is it important?
Speaker: What's happening now that the grassroots should be involved?
Speaker: Do we see the decline in participation rates, which affect eventually the fund base, like the fund base going down and then less people participate, so less elite athletes consequently?
Speaker: Or what's the problem?
Speaker: I want to come back to this essence of why question.
Speaker: Well, if you look at what's happening recently or over the last 10 to 15 years in the sports participation in general, we have declining number of active sportsmanship anyways across all levels of society, across all sports.
Speaker: Being at soccer, being at football, being at tennis, all of them are facing declined participation.
Speaker: They're all facing declined participation of youth.
Speaker: They're all facing fewer membership in sports clubs.
Speaker: So
Speaker: literally all those sports governing bodies have actually the same problem.
Speaker: So this is in a nutshell, Sasha, this is actually the answer to your question that because of different, let's say, trends in society, being it people become more lazy, being it because people are much more attached to TV and social media, there are many, many reasons that we can discuss for hours.
Speaker: But the fact is that the numbers of people practicing sports grasp
Speaker: Sports is declining globally.
Speaker: So literally, this is the one and most important reason for all international sports governing body that they need to invest in grassroots sports.
Speaker: If they want to make sure that their sport survives both on a grassroots level, but then ultimately also on the elite level, because of course, without grassroots, without development, you will not have elite sport as well.
Speaker: I think this is quite a strong statement.
Speaker: Grassroots are essential for the survival of sports, elite sports and international federations.
Speaker: And this brings me to a how question.
Speaker: And I'm connecting to what you said before about this idea of centralization.
Speaker: Is there nowadays an international sports federation that is implementing this model that is successful in investing in grassroots?
Speaker: Not very many.
Speaker: Again, if we do a little benchmarking and see how, let's say, sports funding or development work is being done these days, I would say you can technically separate or cluster all international sports governing bodies in five, let's say, development statuses.
Speaker: So you have the really, really small federations.
Speaker: I don't know.
Speaker: Just making examples now, archery or bowling or trail running or you name it.
Speaker: Those federations, especially also the ones that are not part of the Olympic program, they are so small and they have such limited budget that they are not really doing centralized global development efforts anyways, simply because they don't have the money for it.
Speaker: The second level, a little bit more developed, are probably the ones that at least they have a certain amount of budget and they are able to financially support their national federations or their continental federations.
Speaker: Again, this is better than nothing.
Speaker: Unfortunately, this is what probably most federations are doing until today.
Speaker: And Sascha Donate, as you both know, because you also worked in sports,
Speaker: we know how, I would say, little success those purely sending money development efforts actually had.
Speaker: Because in many, many cases, then the receiving countries did not use the money the way it was actually earmarked for and then normally you don't have any development success.
Speaker: Yeah, there is also a problem of accountability and reporting about the money expense.
Speaker: Exactly, exactly.
Speaker: Then the third level, I would say again of the little bit advanced ones, those are the ones that are maybe on top of sending money, developing really active development programs for the grassroots, mainly everything around, of course, coaching and refereeing, which is understandable because again, coaching and refereeing is probably the most important element of in sport on grassroots level anyways.
Speaker: So if you want to make sure that your sport is developing correctly in one country or the other, you need to make sure that you have the coaches and the referees.
Speaker: So this is the third level.
Speaker: Then the fourth level, I would say are the ones
Speaker: that already have understood that they need to centrally develop a development plan.
Speaker: So meaning they are on top of maybe sending money on top of maybe providing coaches and referee support.
Speaker: They are centrally spreading the word and centrally doing development work.
Speaker: And there you have, of course, the prominent examples, for instance, of UEFA or of FIFA, they have,
Speaker: They are professional freelancers, they are professional development staff.
Speaker: They are actually traveling literally from one country to the other and really teaching and educating people on site.
Speaker: But obviously this is only to be done with a certain amount of money that you have in your business.
Speaker: in your budget and then the fifth hold on mike just a little clarifying question when you say like when they they have coaching and refereeing programs so do i understand the grassroots coaching and amateur coaching and referees programs or at the end it doesn't really matter at the end you need to start with educating referees and coaches if they then at the end educate and and and work with grassroots in their country or with elite
Speaker: At the end doesn't matter at the beginning, but ultimately, of course, you have a certain development curve, both with coaches and with referees.
Speaker: So when you start to educate them, you would, of course, prepare them first to work with grassroots themselves because the rules and regulations are not as strict.
Speaker: But then in the long run, of course, you can or you should develop a
Speaker: those people then also to be able to, for instance, work with international competitions.
Speaker: So it's also like a gradual growth that you have both with coaches and with also the referees.
Speaker: So you need to do both, but you start with grassroots.
Speaker: Understood.
Speaker: Thanks.
Speaker: So I was saying, so the fifth level, maybe if you want to use this model of development of the grassroots are the federations that are really building, I would say, a holistic academy.
Speaker: Now, if again you take the example of UEFA, they even call it Academy.
Speaker: As I said, of course, you cannot compare the budgets of UEFA with a sport that is not even Olympic.
Speaker: But I would say those national governing or international governing bodies that are able to really build a holistic academy that would really include all elements of a professional development program, that's then probably the fifth, in my opinion, and really, let's say, highest level of development that you can offer to your stakeholders as an international sports governing body.
Speaker: Mike, you made me think about these layers and different capacities of International Federation's focus and structure.
Speaker: I'm thinking, how are they measuring their success?
Speaker: Are there any general indicators common across all these five layers of categories or are there any specific innovative indicators that have been developed?
Speaker: Well, Donata, I think this is pretty much a new ground.
Speaker: I mean, if you think about what I just explained, that in many cases you don't even have reached, let's say, a holistic level of global development anyways, well, this automatically explains you in a way that, of course, none of them or very little of them have defined any kind of measurement or KPI.
Speaker: In my opinion, but again, I'm coming from the corporate world,
Speaker: always literally working with KPIs, with dashboards and so on.
Speaker: I personally believe that of course you can, maybe not easily, but you can definitely measure the return on investment and even the success of your development efforts.
Speaker: This can be KPIs like growing numbers of children playing your sport.
Speaker: This can be number of clubs in a certain territory.
Speaker: This can be number of sponsors, sponsorship income.
Speaker: So there's actually a whole variety of
Speaker: of numbers that you can collect that could give you an indication if your money that you spent on your development efforts was actually successful.
Speaker: But I agree, Donate, this is probably a pretty new field still, and I'm not aware of many
Speaker: international sports governing bodies that are actually doing so i actually had a pretty interesting discussion about this topic a couple weeks ago where i was also saying well you know what technically if you really mean it very serious in your development efforts you could even make the money that you give to your national federations dependent on their own development efforts and this is also something that's
Speaker: that's hardly ever ever happening i mean as you know i have worked with basketball with volleyball with many others to my knowledge until today this is not happening so they are still giving money as i said in addition maybe also some other kind of support but they are hardly ever really asking for hard
Speaker: feedback or hard kpis that would justify what they actually spent the money with and also there are no consequences so if you give 500 000 to some country and you hear nothing back you maybe don't get any kpi maybe no project well they will still keep those 500 000 and they will probably receive the same amount next year because there's no
Speaker: follow up and no consequence and this is by the way let me just continue here and this is also coming back to what sasha asked before what is the advantage or why should international sports governing body invest in grassroots and why should they do it centrally well again because if you don't have one central hub really taking care of it well then the money goes everywhere and you will never see it again
Speaker: You actually summarized the first part well for us doing our job here, Mike.
Speaker: Thanks.
Speaker: And I think we understood, we got the idea of what's going on today, right, Donata?
Speaker: Yes, I think so.
Speaker: I think it is time to jump to the second part of our conversation, our desired future.
Speaker: Mike, what future have you taken us to?
Speaker: Where are we?
Speaker: Well, we are in the year and again, I haven't aligned this proposal with the IOC, but we are now in the year 2054.
Speaker: And by then we got rid of all national Olympic committees and of all international sports governing bodies because we realized that we actually don't need them anymore.
Speaker: Now, of course, this is a little bit accelerated, but what I'm coming down to is.
Speaker: And again, we don't need to define a certain period.
Speaker: I mean, what I'm going to walk you through now in my mind, this is of course something that's not happening in 10 years, maybe not in 20 years.
Speaker: So maybe the year 2050 is not that far away.
Speaker: So let's come back to what I said before with the benchmarking from the automotive industry.
Speaker: In the ideal scenario, all the international sports governing bodies underwent the same professional, let's say, procedure of strategic planning and really making sure where are their strengths and where are the weaknesses when it comes to the development of their sport.
Speaker: And then maybe you will have some sports that say, oh, you know what?
Speaker: In a way, we do feel actually powerful enough and knowledgeable enough to do the entire grassroots development centrally
Speaker: from whatever, Lausanne, Geneva, you name it.
Speaker: By the way, you see first examples of federations going a little bit in that direction.
Speaker: If you think about FIBA, International Basketball Federation, as you probably know, they still have their continental confederations, they call it.
Speaker: But from a legal perspective, they are more or less under one umbrella with FIBA.
Speaker: Also with the same, by the way, you probably know with the same look and feel,
Speaker: of their events.
Speaker: So this is already very much centralized, at least on a commercial level.
Speaker: But then, okay, you will also have other sports governing bodies that say, oh, you know what?
Speaker: We are so weak in our headquarter.
Speaker: We don't feel, for whatever reason, we don't feel like developing grassroots centrally.
Speaker: We will maybe continue writing certain books and maybe certain educational material, but we will continue to leave
Speaker: the development of the grassroots sports to our continental confederations or to our national federations.
Speaker: And then maybe, and I'm not making this up, maybe you will have other sports that will actually say, well, you know what?
Speaker: It would actually be super efficient if we really get rid of all those boundaries and borders of national federations and continentals.
Speaker: Let's just be the governing bodies for our athletes directly.
Speaker: And then we come also to a, let's say, quote that I always like to mention is, by then sports would really move from being a B2B business to a B2C business.
Speaker: So what do I mean when I say this?
Speaker: B2B business is what's happening today.
Speaker: An international federation is serving the national federation.
Speaker: The national federation then is serving the regional federation.
Speaker: The regional federation is then serving the local club and so on.
Speaker: So you have this cascade of businesses serving businesses.
Speaker: Whereas B2C business, again, as you know it from many other businesses, is an international sports governing body, would be directly be in touch and in contact with the athlete.
Speaker: And there I can give you some examples as well.
Speaker: You know the 313 basketball project probably.
Speaker: launched back in 2012.
Speaker: This was a first attempt to say, okay, the entire three-in-three competition landscape, so meaning all events, all organizers, all results, all players are on one central platform.
Speaker: So we don't need a national basketball federation anymore.
Speaker: We don't need a national club anymore.
Speaker: If they want to be part of this project, organize three-in-three events, perfect.
Speaker: But the end FIBA has now, I don't know the
Speaker: the numbers up to date, but in the three on three planet, which is this central platform, I think FIBA has access
Speaker: 120 000 basketball players so this is pure b2c business in sports climbing where i'm in the in the in the sports commission now as well in the tv and marketing commission this is also an idea that we are that we are playing back and forth because we say should we not have the opportunity or give climbers sports climbers the opportunity to become direct member of the ifsc
Speaker: with all the benefits that you then could then give them.
Speaker: So what I'm trying to say in the year 2050, in my ideal future, at least all those boards governing bodies made this exercise to contemplate about it and not just leave their governance and leave their way of management and leave their way of grassroots development just the way it is because it has been done like this forever.
Speaker: Sorry, just to clarify about this third model, actually, like a step back.
Speaker: So you drew for us three potential models, not necessarily calling them ideal.
Speaker: One is when it's totally centralized.
Speaker: Another one...
Speaker: with the same umbrella structure when there is international federation, then confederate confederation level, regional confederations, then national federations, et cetera.
Speaker: And the third model, which is governing body for athletes, B to C model.
Speaker: So this is kind of ideal model we are talking about.
Speaker: So when you say that, just a little question before you continue.
Speaker: When you say that athletes are members, like it is happening in IFSC, you mean all the athletes?
Speaker: Not only athletes performing in elite competition in the world level, you mean all the athletes even performing on a local, regional, city level?
Speaker: In the ideal world, yes.
Speaker: Okay, thanks.
Speaker: Because other question, why shouldn't it?
Speaker: And just to clarify, Sascha, those examples I gave you before, none of those models is the ideal model.
Speaker: model because again think about the benchmark that i gave you in automotive or the money that boston consulting mckinsey is doing the money they are making is by every 10 15 years contemplating what is for my asset for my industry or in that in our case for my sport what is the elite and the perfect governance model so i'm not saying that one is better than the other but what i'm saying is that right now they're all doing the same thing
Speaker: they all have an international federation then they have a national one a regional one blah blah blah what i'm saying is that it's worthwhile looking and contemplating if this is really the best way to go and because for instance maybe for one sport or for some sports and this is part of the solution in my personal opinion part of the solution is indeed a mixed model so you will have certain again
Speaker: Let's again take the comparison of automotive from before.
Speaker: Also in sports, I believe there are certain aspects of the operations that should be central.
Speaker: For instance, of course, the organization of the world championships, for instance.
Speaker: This is something that will always be and should always be centralized and should always be made or developed from the headquarters.
Speaker: Or Olympic qualifiers as well, yeah?
Speaker: For instance.
Speaker: Then there are other parts of the operations where I think, okay,
Speaker: And let's stick with the development program.
Speaker: I do believe that a development effort and development program should be steered, managed and governed centrally.
Speaker: But I do believe that the implementation should happen locally.
Speaker: So I'm not a super big fan of those, let's say,
Speaker: Jan Bogaert, PhD.
Speaker: : Your professionals or consultants travel from one country to the other and explain them how to do things.
Speaker: I do believe that the local development works best with the local resources that you have.
Speaker: Of course, you fly in external and capacities once in a while, but it should still be happened locally.
Speaker: So in a nutshell, Sasha, what I tried to say is in 2050, I'm not sure what is the ideal model.
Speaker: I'm just saying I do believe that having more B2C is helping in any case.
Speaker: And we might come back to that why I'm thinking this later on.
Speaker: But I'm not saying that central or decentral is the one is better than the other.
Speaker: I'm just saying it depends on the sport.
Speaker: That's the one thing I'm saying.
Speaker: And the other is I don't think that this procedure is being done by many of the international organizations.
Speaker: sports governing bodies because they just replicate as i said before how the structure of sports and the structure of development has always been since coubertin and since the games in athens we have this model of again ioc national olympic committees ifs nfs and so on
Speaker: Yes, definitely, Mikey.
Speaker: There is a lot of repetition, right?
Speaker: There is perhaps lack of creativity.
Speaker: So in 2050, you envision a future where there is more experimentation playing with these models, governance models.
Speaker: And my question is, do you also see new stakeholders joining this new governance system?
Speaker: Do you see any new actor arising and taking a key role in defining this future?
Speaker: Personally, Donata, I would hope so.
Speaker: We come back again, what we just discussed, because also the inclusion of the private sector in the operations of a sports governing body is happening quite rarely.
Speaker: So if you could, I mean, you could question, for instance, why an international federation is actually organizing events themselves.
Speaker: So if you question it really critically, you could really argue that
Speaker: Is a sports governing body per se really the perfect event agency?
Speaker: In my opinion, they are not.
Speaker: And maybe they also shouldn't be.
Speaker: But this comes back to, in a way, chicken and egg discussion.
Speaker: Okay, so what is then the core responsibility of a sports governing body?
Speaker: And this on the other way is coming back to our vision of 2015.
Speaker: That's where I said from a sports perspective, I'm not really sure if we really need the sports governing bodies in the way they are today.
Speaker: We might need them for certain organizational reasons.
Speaker: So for, again...
Speaker: being sure that we have the qualifiers for the Olympics and so on.
Speaker: But other than this, at the end, ultimately, you might really challenge that question to which extent you still need those international federations and what their core purpose at the end then should actually be.
Speaker: so to come back to to your question donada i would yeah i would by 2050 i would hope for way more corporate and private sector involvement again we see first trends there if you take of course the example now of cvc investing in volleyball world or if or if you look at other private equities investing in major soccer clubs so you already see
Speaker: private sector money flowing into sports and of course mainly affecting again the elite part of sports by 2050 i also hope that we will find this engagement and investment of external money also into the grassroots part because and maybe this is also for our discussion still yet to come i also do believe that there's a lot of money to be made in the grassroots sport and not just in the elite sport
Speaker: I just want to trip further a little bit here.
Speaker: So talking about this other stakeholders involvement, I just had an idea.
Speaker: What do you think if the model was like to adopt one grassroots engagement of development agency like WADA is for anti-doping matters in the Olympic world?
Speaker: So the same could be like completely different centralized body.
Speaker: So, which is independent from international federations, but they're subject to comply with this World Development Agency kind of thing.
Speaker: This is, for instance, one very good example, or you can have other examples.
Speaker: What I also never understood is why many national federations don't see the benefit of cooperating with their neighbors.
Speaker: especially if you look at territories like Europe, where the territories are so small anyways.
Speaker: I never understood why then countries like, and again, I'm just making examples, again, Austria, Switzerland, Slovenia, so on, why they are not in different sports, but also across sports, working way, way more together in every terms of the sport, in organizing their own leagues,
Speaker: So we come back to a whole different discussion.
Speaker: Why does a little country like Austria or Switzerland really think that it's of any global value to have their own national league in football, for instance.
Speaker: My personal opinion, there is no real value, just the fact that they are stubborn and think that they need a national league because they are their own nation.
Speaker: But we know that there are tendencies of combining certain smaller national leagues from a sporting perspective.
Speaker: But what I'm saying is also that in the development area, I never understood why smaller countries or neighboring countries are not making common efforts, why they are not combining their coaching programs.
Speaker: why they are not organizing maybe certain kids camps together.
Speaker: So why do they all need to facilitate and create their resources by themselves and not share them?
Speaker: Like again, take the corporate world as a benchmark like you would have in a corporate world in many, many aspects.
Speaker: A company like Apple or a company like Tesla, they don't sink in national borders.
Speaker: They think as a national company, they maybe have still their local regional sales agents, but that's about it.
Speaker: Everything else is managed centrally and they make sure that they can add value and exchange knowledge across any kind of national borders.
Speaker: They don't exist for companies like that.
Speaker: Saying on this reasoning, I'm thinking now about the examples of the European Union.
Speaker: They have euro regions and they invest a lot of regional cooperation.
Speaker: So I'm thinking that the sports sector has a lot to learn also from these other experiences, institutional experiences.
Speaker: And I'm also thinking...
Speaker: Could these new regional entities be the one thinking centrally the development programs?
Speaker: Because I'm not so sure that the international layer, the international level is the rightful owner of the development programs, leaving up to the national actors to implement.
Speaker: What if is the other way around?
Speaker: What do you think?
Speaker: If it's the national...
Speaker: the one more entitled to define the development program because they leave their experience on site and the international layer stakeholder should be the one supporting the implementation.
Speaker: Yeah, Donata, this is what I meant before with what I mean with a really very distinct and very clear definition of what the capabilities are and that they really probably differ from one sport to the other.
Speaker: To answer your question, in a way, yes and no.
Speaker: So for instance, of course, when you think about development, of course, the central guidance on the rules and regulation of a sport, they always need to come from the very, very top.
Speaker: So you cannot have your national federations now all of a sudden create development programs.
Speaker: And at the end, after a couple of years, you actually see that they used for the same sport, all of a sudden they use different laws of the game.
Speaker: So there are certain
Speaker: Key elements, and this is what I mean with those are the key elements that will always be the main purpose of a sports governing bodies and rules and regulations is definitely one of them.
Speaker: So this will always, even by 2015, be, this needs to be centrally steered and needs to be centrally managed.
Speaker: But then I agree, Donata, that then the implementation or the development of certain grassroots initiatives.
Speaker: So
Speaker: whatever programs for kids after school or certain programs for disabilities or certain programs for obese people you name it those different maybe now national initiatives that's exactly what you also said they don't necessarily need to be national those can be maybe private sector companies private entities that create their own
Speaker: let's say, development plans and maybe even finance them themselves.
Speaker: There are examples that those kind of things are actually working, even financially independently from an international sports governing body.
Speaker: And then, yeah, maybe this is the solution.
Speaker: I always, in that regard, Donata, Sascha, I'm always a big fan of the word endorsement.
Speaker: So I always believe that a national or international sports governing body should, at the end,
Speaker: work together with as many parties as possible.
Speaker: And they should be coming from the private sector, they should be coming from the governmental sector, they should be coming from the educational sector.
Speaker: And I know that for many old school presidents, secretary generals, this endorsement, this inclusion is a mindset that they just have never appreciated.
Speaker: And this is slowly, slowly changing and shifting.
Speaker: There are examples of different sports
Speaker: where I do believe that the management is already quite open to corporations in different ways.
Speaker: Let's face it, it has always been a typical white man problem that those certain presidents, certain senior staff just always wanted to protect their sport against any kind of influence from the outside.
Speaker: And this is why they for many decades never allowed corporations, again, with private sector or with other cooperation partners.
Speaker: Before we move to the next part, I just want to clarify one thing from what you said.
Speaker: You are talking about shifting from B2B to B2C mindset.
Speaker: Yes.
Speaker: But then now you're saying that on the international level, there should be key elements should be worked on, like rules and regulations, guidelines and other things that are going down to the local level and that's where it should be implemented.
Speaker: So isn't it a bit controversial to B2C mindset when the International Federation should work directly with a client?
Speaker: Oh, I'm misunderstanding something here.
Speaker: No, that's exactly what I said, but this is also exactly what I meant.
Speaker: There are certain key elements that always, no matter B2B, B2C businesses, that always need to be
Speaker: at the core and at the center and rules and regulations are one of them because as I said before otherwise you end up with different rules for the same game.
Speaker: but many, many other things.
Speaker: And I would say, if you think about the entire, let's say, value chain or let's say operational chain that a sport is facing, I would say 90% can be decentralized and also made, let's say, to a B2C business at the end, but 10%, core 10%, and as I said, things like anti-doping, things like rules, regulation, those 10% will always stay
Speaker: within the headquarters and will always be centrally and again if we let's make up our mind again with the benchmarking what i said before this is exactly what's happening in the private sector as well you have those certain elements as i said the development of a new apple product or of a new tesla model this will always be done central you will not leave your sales agent in switzerland and leave him all of a sudden with the task to to create a new tesla that's not going to happen this will always remain
Speaker: at the center of the corporation, whereas then other elements are then definitely up to a B2C business.
Speaker: All right, I think it's a bit more clear for me, but let me summarize before we move to the next part.
Speaker: So you are talking about the mixed model that could be different and should be different for every sport, where certain processes are clearly centralized and clearly defined on the international level.
Speaker: Lots of other operations should be left on the national level, but to thinking about accountability and quite a strict control.
Speaker: Certain types of operations should shift to B2C mindset when international federations are working directly with athletes, even if we talk about basic and just participation level sport.
Speaker: And as I understand, what is needed is just to act.
Speaker: So this question needs to be raised and the action should start.
Speaker: And with this, talking about actions and thinking about actions, I suggest we move to the next part of our conversation.
Speaker: Or do you have anything to add, Donate, actually?
Speaker: Let's walk back.
Speaker: Let's start to walk backwards.
Speaker: Deal.
Speaker: So, Mike, what are important milestones in this pathway?
Speaker: And I remind you that we are walking back from the future to the present.
Speaker: It's not an easy exercise, but let's try.
Speaker: Well, ultimately, I mean, at the end, we talk about the typical change management process.
Speaker: And as we know, change always hurts and change always costs resources and change is always painful.
Speaker: So again, those are ideas that we just discussed that not going to happen from one presidential election to the other.
Speaker: So if we, as we said before, if we keep the year 2050 or 2040 in mind,
Speaker: The way or the operational work to actually make up your mind and move in that direction is not that much of a hard work.
Speaker: Ultimately, this would be the outcome of a typical strategic planning process that you do with your sports governing body.
Speaker: Like the IOC is doing, like UEFA is doing, like FIFA is doing.
Speaker: Normally, you do your long-term strategies and they include then the development and the grassroots part.
Speaker: Normally, you do those strategic plans for a five to 10-year period.
Speaker: And the process to get to those kinds of plans can be as quick as, let's say, a three, four intense week workshop.
Speaker: Or like in the case of European handball, for instance, one of my mandates I just had over the last
Speaker: period with was actually a process of 18 months.
Speaker: But this is still the first step that you would need to do.
Speaker: You would need to get the engagement of the senior staff of the president, of the secretary general, of the board of the sports organization to be really up for a strategic planning process and including of this strategic planning process a clear
Speaker: review of the governance model that we have right now um and then if the if the oh by the way let me not forget in this in this process it's always super important to get the external input
Speaker: So of course we will never come up with a new governance model and a new way of development.
Speaker: If only the president, the secretary general and the board of administration sits together, you need to have the external input, of course.
Speaker: And with external input, I mean critical external input.
Speaker: So meaning you need someone from the media, from the media partners, from your sponsorship partners, from your players, from some grassroots representatives,
Speaker: So the bigger the party, the better, I always say.
Speaker: It's again, a lot more work to get all those opinions together.
Speaker: But at the end, the outcome will be way, way better.
Speaker: So this, I would say, is the first milestone to get this agreement at the end.
Speaker: signed by everyone, like a written documentation.
Speaker: We, by the year of 2050, want to make sure that we have found our new governance model that best serves our grassroots players.
Speaker: We want to have this and this targets and goals, and those can be KPIs.
Speaker: And we also want to move our sport from a more, or from a, let's say, old-fashioned B2B to a B2C business, wherever possible.
Speaker: this will be the first step.
Speaker: And I think this can be, this alignment can be done within two years maximum.
Speaker: Mike, to summarize, external input, engagement of senior staff, so a fundamental shift in the mindset.
Speaker: What else to achieve this agreement?
Speaker: What else do we need?
Speaker: What resources do we need?
Speaker: Well, as I tried to say, it's...
Speaker: If, I mean, if we compare or if we look at the sports industry, how is it working these days?
Speaker: It is still very hard to find ways to get external input really be heard by management staff.
Speaker: And again, this is actually applicable for all the major international sports governing bodies.
Speaker: In my experience over the last 10 years, Donata, the best way to open up minds is
Speaker: is by having private sector businesses in the room.
Speaker: So again, if we take some prominent examples, FIBA signed a very prominent deal with Infront and DAZN already back in 2012, I believe.
Speaker: And great things happened afterwards because with Infront and DAZN, you had two very capable, strong commercial partners who just know how businesses are run in the private sector.
Speaker: Again, we talked about this before.
Speaker: If you take a recent example of the FIFIB, where you now have with CVC, a strong American venture capital company in it, of course, with also their own expertise in how to run commercial businesses.
Speaker: European Handball, another client of mine, they also signed a deal with...
Speaker: in front of DAZN, I think in 2016.
Speaker: So having those external views, ideally from commercial partners is always the best step to open eyes and ears for new sorts.
Speaker: So for everyone listening out there who is maybe working for some international sports governing bodies and is wondering
Speaker: how change in his or her organization can start and he or she does not have the feeling that it's happening internally.
Speaker: And it, by the way, never happens internally.
Speaker: Getting partners from the commercial external private sector is probably the best route to go.
Speaker: I'm thinking now about civil society organizations, how they fit into this equation.
Speaker: Because often grassroots overlaps with social programs, social impact programs.
Speaker: So were these NGOs, the experts, let's say, on specific matters, come in this picture?
Speaker: I think they will actually come in more and more in the future.
Speaker: Because if you see what happened just in the last four or five years,
Speaker: Everything around, of course, the, let's say ecological topic of sustainability, but also the CSR topic of corporate social responsibility is these days almost mandatory.
Speaker: Part in every strategy that you read from any kind of company or sports governing body that is working in sports.
Speaker: And if we take the prominent example from before, if we look at those companies, as I said, CVC, Infrontazone, just to take those three examples.
Speaker: Those are companies that are, of course, coming from a strong commercial background only, but even they by now have their own units dealing with CSR topics, dealing with sustainability topics and so on.
Speaker: And since all those companies, and again, this can replicate to many, many more, since these topics are not their core expertise, they will engage themselves more and more NGOs.
Speaker: and more and more other partners that are experts on development programs.
Speaker: And then kind of the circle closes to what I said before.
Speaker: At the end, the word endorsement, so meaning the cooperation of many, many stakeholders, is the key to success.
Speaker: So you will not create your successful grassroots program only with your commercial partner.
Speaker: Of course not.
Speaker: But it's definitely helping if you have your commercial partner and your development NGO partner, if you have them
Speaker: together on one table, just as an example.
Speaker: Mike, I want to challenge one of your ideas here and to ask a question here.
Speaker: So you say strategic plan.
Speaker: So to develop a strategic plan, which is not short terms, but a real strategy, like 30 years from now.
Speaker: Recently, we've seen by many sports covenant buddies, they are presenting even 10 years ago, World Archery and Olympic Agenda 2020.
Speaker: We've seen many examples of such strategies that have been presented, that have been worked on, that included in the working and development process.
Speaker: They've included lots of outside, I wouldn't use the word outsiders, but external.
Speaker: stakeholders and where are they going now?
Speaker: So is creating a strategic plan and publishing it, is it efficient tool?
Speaker: What should be, what could be the other milestone from just creating and signing under the strategic plan?
Speaker: This is one question and another question, they are related a little bit, you say involving private partners and you gave example of a five EB, FIBA and other things.
Speaker: When this partner signed up, do they, did they claim any plans to engage grassroots?
Speaker: Did they show any KPIs about involvement, about their development programs or something?
Speaker: to your first question sasha um excellent comment and um excellent um yeah um putting into words the current situation i would say 99.9 percent of all strategic plan in sports are only documents um and no implementation so
Speaker: I know my friends from McKinsey will now not like me if I say that, but they have this typical McKinsey approach.
Speaker: They have excellent presentations and they have a great command in publishing it.
Speaker: But then the implementation, normally they leave to someone else.
Speaker: Now in sports, it's even worse because in sports, the implementation is normally done by no one.
Speaker: So you're perfectly right that as of today, and I'm aware of many, many strategic plans in sports because I also worked on many of them.
Speaker: the strong willingness to actually implement so meaning to not just put down the goals but to really make a proper project management following up so where you clearly define who is working on what kind of matter with which timeline which priority which budget which outcome and so on and so on so on this is literally work for two three people full-time staff
Speaker: And literally no one of the, let's say bigger, again, except maybe the IOC, FIFA and UEFA, no one of the other sports governing bodies is actually working on the implementation of their strategy the way they actually should.
Speaker: So to answer your question, the difference between just signing and then other results is simply the execution.
Speaker: And that is really, really missing.
Speaker: To your second question, um,
Speaker: And again, I think I have a quite good view into this industry.
Speaker: So companies, as we said before, but let's make the picture wider.
Speaker: It's not just the zone and in front and so on.
Speaker: It's, of course, the IMGs and Sports 5 and you name them.
Speaker: Even they have now understood that you can easily monetize
Speaker: um grassroots sports that you can easily monetize even sustainability efforts that you can easily monetize ccsr efforts now of course again they are doing this with a different view on things because at the end ultimately those are still private sector businesses but all of them and then ultimately also the sports governing bodies understood that with the investment
Speaker: In grassroots, in sustainability, in CSR, there's also money to be made.
Speaker: So it's not just that they do it for the sake of it, because those are trendy topics and you need to do it.
Speaker: But all of them understood that you can actually monetize it very, very well.
Speaker: And this is, again, nothing that is just very special for the sports industry.
Speaker: Literally all the bigger companies out there understood by now that there's also money to be made with sustainable business.
Speaker: And there is definitely money to be made in B2C rather than B2B businesses.
Speaker: I like this monetization, very difficult word, conversation.
Speaker: There is a clear benefit to invest on grassroots.
Speaker: This is what you're saying, right?
Speaker: There is definitely.
Speaker: There is definitely.
Speaker: How can then we shift, and I say we as sports professionals, how can we shift this mindset from this solidarity approach that is still embedded with ideas of charity, of giving because it's good to give back to society, into a more structured approach that benefits not only the international federations, but all key stakeholders through society.
Speaker: capacity development programs, empowerment to implement their own projects and so on and so forth.
Speaker: I think Donata, in order also to keep our conversation really on the point, I think if the audience kind of can take away two arguments in that regard, I think that's already helpful.
Speaker: The first one is to really, and we said that before, to really see investment in grassroots into the future of the sport because without grassroots development,
Speaker: you will ultimately also not have any elite sport because you need coaches to educate young children.
Speaker: You need referees, even in young age, to tell young people how certain games are actually played.
Speaker: So if you don't invest into that, well, then ultimately you will have no one left to play in the Champions League or in the NFL because you need those players and they need to be educated in some way
Speaker: And okay, there are ways or different ways to do it.
Speaker: Maybe the American system of having, let's say, all the sports development happening in schools, that's maybe one way to do it.
Speaker: But even there, you see the United States are heavily investing already in high school sport because they know if they don't invest in high school sport, they will not have proper college sport.
Speaker: And if they're not having proper college sport, they will not have an NFL or an NBA.
Speaker: It's that easy.
Speaker: So that's the one argument.
Speaker: And the second takeaway is because by exploiting grassroots, there is also money to be made, as I said.
Speaker: And this is a very, very easy argument because if you look at the pure numbers of grassroots
Speaker: players that you have in all those sports and at the end if you just say through whatever initiative you get just one dollar one Swiss franc from all those players well then in most sports you talk about two if not even three digit millions that you get and there are already prominent examples where where this B2C approach meaning directly taking money or selling items
Speaker: to your grassroots players is actually working.
Speaker: I still want to come back to the same question and I'm a bit annoying today, no, with this coming back to the same question, milestones.
Speaker: So strategic plan and make sure it's implemented.
Speaker: What else could you name as a success factor to enable the change?
Speaker: Well, if we continue the example that
Speaker: that we started before so let's say after two or three years we really have a strategic plan that would then include or implore or yeah include a proper development plan as well then I would say whatever is written down in this development plan of course needs to be yeah needs to be executed on a smaller scale first so I would not roll out globally
Speaker: especially not if we really talk about a significant change, then I would go step by step and maybe make changes just with some very prominent countries initially.
Speaker: And this is also a time period that I would allow to do for two or three years.
Speaker: So to make it very concrete, remember what we said before about those five development phases, literally, that you maybe have for an international sport.
Speaker: So let's say one international sports governing body now says, oh, you know what?
Speaker: Okay, let's move from just sending money to our members.
Speaker: Let's move to centrally decide what we're going to actually teach to our member countries.
Speaker: And let's also send certified coaches to travel from one country to the other and actually execute those development efforts.
Speaker: So let's say this is the goal that is written down in this development plan.
Speaker: Of course, I would then not start to implement this in all whatever 180 or 220 countries at the same time, because you need to see
Speaker: and try and error if this is really working for your respective sport.
Speaker: So maybe just take five, six, seven countries.
Speaker: Maybe it's even good to start with some big countries in your sport, or maybe some smaller ones so that you really have kind of the feedback on, let's say, a very professional organizational level on a very primitive organizational level.
Speaker: And this is something where I also believe you should take your time.
Speaker: So this, let's say, testing phase,
Speaker: I believe should go at least over a season, if not even two.
Speaker: And then because you will not see any of the results quicker than this.
Speaker: You will not see increased numbers again of referees or of children.
Speaker: You will not see this within a year.
Speaker: So this testing period definitely needs to go over two years.
Speaker: If you have more time, the better.
Speaker: So, and then if we continue our example and we have a proper
Speaker: analysis that would then say, yes, okay, this new development, grassroots development initiative is working for our sport, then a global rollout can actually happen.
Speaker: And this, again, if you think about it, to roll this out then to 180 countries, and let's say you're not a federation with huge amounts of money where you can send several dozens of experts in parallel, this is a process that will also take years.
Speaker: we are probably not that far away if we say the final status will be reached by 2050.
Speaker: Okay, just to quickly summarize.
Speaker: So if we go backwards from 2050, 2054, so we have a phase, final phase before total rollout of testing it on small federations, big federations.
Speaker: So step before that of developing the guidelines and implementation strategies,
Speaker: And the step before is developing a strategic plan that is embraced by everyone and that involves a lot of external collaborators to make it innovative and really the one that would enable the change.
Speaker: Danada, do you have to add something?
Speaker: And the previous step work on the change of mindset, which I believe this is the first thing that we can work on.
Speaker: Let's not answer for Mike, because I think it brings us to the last part of our conversation, which is a call for action.
Speaker: So Mike, tell us what should be done already today and by whom to enable this change?
Speaker: Now, I could make a very quick and dirty answer and say you should send every president and every secretary general who has never worked outside of sports, you should send all of them to do an internship in the private sector.
Speaker: That would already help a lot.
Speaker: But no, funny things aside, what Donata actually just said before is also a very important thing.
Speaker: So let me just quickly also connect those two points.
Speaker: This change of mindset is, of course, something that's not
Speaker: only happening initially again if we think about a change management process that might go over 20 years if not longer um hell we all don't know um how the world entirely will actually be developing or changing in 20 years anyways so this constant review of the current status of a sports governing body needs to be done constantly this is also why and is also coming back to what sasha said this is why
Speaker: doing those strategic plans but also implementing them and also
Speaker: review and correct them every other day is so important because no long-term strategy if you even if you do it for three or five years and maybe that's already the max you can do these days anyways if you want to look further into the future it's really getting tricky so you need to be sure um donata did this change of mindset and this raising awareness of new topics this needs to be a constant process you just need to be sure in your organization
Speaker: that you have someone in the organization that is actually challenging you enough and at least on a yearly basis to really make sure that you actually, that you're actually doing this.
Speaker: Sorry, just to clarify a little bit.
Speaker: So who should start acting already today?
Speaker: Who is that key point to, key Enabler?
Speaker: So in the private sector, those would be the shareholders.
Speaker: Very,
Speaker: Easy answer and probably very clever answer because in that way you already have a very wide public and a wide publicity of shareholders that will judge the success of the management board of a stock traded company.
Speaker: And now you will probably realize that again, since I take this benchmark, how, and this is what I said before, how the sports governance needs to rethink if the way they operate
Speaker: is the perfect thing.
Speaker: So should they're not also, and again, I'm, I'm, I'm accelerating now, but since we talk about moving sports into a B2C business, shouldn't then be the C meaning the clients, the consumers, the grassroots, should those not be the directed shareholders of the sports governing bodies.
Speaker: Now the presidents, the reason once they will hate this idea, of course, because they want to be elected by their 180 national Federation members.
Speaker: But just imagine that the sports governing body is 100% reliant on the election and on the results and on the wishes of the grassroots or of everyone that is doing that sport, how massively this would actually change the democracy in a sport.
Speaker: And now we talk about really about 2050.
Speaker: And let's say on 2050, and I suggest we wrap up, we start wrapping up.
Speaker: Mikey gave us a lot of insights and an interesting and desired future in 2050 with less bureaucratization, less structure.
Speaker: More centralization balance with decentralized program.
Speaker: Mike has suggested that sports sector, International Federation can explore B2C initiatives, can explore what endorsement is, can be more creative and experiment more with their stakeholders outside of their ecosystem, like private sector,
Speaker: civil society organizations, athletes, directing, engaging with athletes.
Speaker: There are some things that I really liked from this conversation.
Speaker: The idea that this centralization also entails more democratization, give more space directly to local actors, athletes, private sector, but also associations, civil society organizations.
Speaker: essential a change of mindset of the leadership, but also of the sports professionals that have to embrace a new narrative in understanding the true potential and opportunity based in grassroots programs.
Speaker: And there is also a lot of work to be done in understanding the peculiarities of the sport.
Speaker: Each sport, Mike said, has its own capabilities, its own features, and there may not be one size fits all solution.
Speaker: But sports, international federations have to be more aware of their strength and opportunities that lay ahead.
Speaker: Sasha, am I missing anything?
Speaker: No, I don't think you miss anything, but I know that our guest is Mike today, but I start thinking because I like this topic very much and I'm moved by this cause as well of increasing the participation in sports and working with grassroots more.
Speaker: And I'm actually thinking that we could have missed something.
Speaker: I just had an idea.
Speaker: what is needed as well as the first step it's also to raise awareness and to understand where we are to work with numbers and do some statistics about the participation rates about what's going on in the world we we we don't have this numbers maybe we have numbers of amount of obese people of amount of
Speaker: infrastructure existed.
Speaker: But I think collecting this data could be an interesting step to start with to understand where we are in comparison where we were and actually where it leads us to with some projections.
Speaker: But you summarized it well, Donata.
Speaker: Do you have anything to add to this, Mike?
Speaker: Sasha, just a very prominent example because you just mentioned this.
Speaker: If you ask the majority of international sports governing bodies how many people are playing their sports,
Speaker: The majority will not have the answer.
Speaker: And this is, I think, is the perfect prominent example why the status is the way we describe them today.
Speaker: Why the international sports governing bodies know exactly how much money they can make with world championships and so on, but why the majority of them don't know how many people are actually playing handball, volleyball, football, baseball, you name it.
Speaker: The reason being because they never had this strategic centralized approach to take care about grassroots.
Speaker: They always left it to the national federations.
Speaker: And then with good luck, you can summarize the numbers they have and come up with something.
Speaker: So the example you gave was like working on those numbers.
Speaker: Yes, that's a great effort, but unfortunately, at least the federations will not be of great help.
Speaker: I have the feeling that Mike is not ready to wrap up yet.
Speaker: So Mike, I think we're going to invite you again to dig down on this last point you mentioned, because we think it's very relevant.
Speaker: Sasha, over to you.
Speaker: Thank you very much, Mike, for being here with us today.
Speaker: It was an amazing conversation.
Speaker: Thank you.
Speaker: Thank you very much, Donata.
Speaker: Thank you very much, Sascha.
Speaker: Great talking to you.
Speaker: And always keep in mind, let's make sport more democratic and let's endorse it more and let's make it B2C.
Speaker: All the best from Munich.
Speaker: Bye-bye.
Speaker: Thanks again.
Speaker: And this brings us to the end of our show.
Speaker: Thank you for listening.
Speaker: This show is produced by SCORE, a sport think tank based in Lausanne.
Speaker: Check out our website, scoresport.com and our LinkedIn page to find more information about this episode and what we do.
Speaker: All our episodes are available on all main podcast platforms.
Speaker: Please rate, comment and share.
Speaker: This will help us a great deal.
Speaker: Stay connected and remember, nobody can score alone.

