Transcript
Speaker: You're listening to The Wound Dresser, a podcast that uncovers the human side of healthcare. I'm your host, John Neary.
Speaker: My guest today is Vic Comfer. Vic is a filmmaker, poet, and clinical social worker who produces films addressing a wide range of social issues through the lens of healing. Along with Rodney Wittenberg, Vic recently co-produced The Eagle and the Condor Unite, a story of climate restoration, which advocates for the restoration of our climate to its pre-industrial condition.
Speaker: The film explores both humanistic and scientific perspectives, which offer her hope amid our current climate crisis. Vic Kumpfer, welcome to The Woundgresser. Thank you very much. It's good to be here.
Speaker: So you recently directed and released a documentary, The Eagle and the Condor Unite, a story of climate restoration. For our listeners at home, can you ah define that that term, climate restoration?
Speaker: Yes, climate restoration has to do with healing the planet, healing particularly the atmosphere where ah there are some trillion tons literally floating around our Earth of carbon dioxide.
Speaker: And that mix with other chemicals is what creates the forest fires, the acidification of the ocean, ah the hurricanes, the disasters and the global warming that we are seeing right now.
Speaker: Annually, we're also adding to that trillion tons as we continue to burn fossil fuels. But there are now emerging methodologies and that look promising if we really adopt them on a ah large scale that will draw down that CO2. And that's kind of like the elephant in the room because most of the conversation about climate change is about our transition and necessary transition
Speaker: to um ah solar and wind energy and other forms of sustainable energy. ah But we really need to continue to focus on that, which is very important, but also to address this other major issue, which is the storage of that trillion tons of CO2 in the atmosphere.
Speaker: Yeah, i I know that healing is kind of a theme that goes through a lot of your work and in documentaries. I'm i'm curious to hear kind of at the the onset of this project, what moved you to to create this documentary, um perhaps instead of other forms of advocacy or other forms of you know ah ah climate work?
Speaker: Well, I heard a interview maybe um five or six years ago with Peter Farkowski, who's kind of the
Speaker: how shall we say, the founder of that term and of the movement that's beginning. And that interview gave me hope for the first time. I think like many people, i was feeling so discouraged about ah the climate change and the threatening aspects of all that, the damage happening. and And it sort of woke me up because he was for the first time saying ah there there are solutions and we need to we need to really support these solutions. We need to do all of the science that's necessary. He himself is a um a graduate of MIT, a physicist, professor,
Speaker: And his concepts I found very, very intriguing. So I purchased his book. I started reading up on the subject. There's a a growing literature about it.
Speaker: And I think it was sort of a wake-up call to me that got me interested in this this whole field. So ah we we define climate restoration, but the the the kind of big metaphor that runs throughout your your documentary is this story of the eagle and the condor. Can you summarize that story and kind of um ah discuss how it's relevant to climate change?
Speaker: Yes, yes. Well, it's an indigenous story. Yeah. um it originated in the the Andes and it is said to be a legend that goes back some 500 years that says that the eagle and the condor will sometime at some future time unite.
Speaker: And the symbol, the symbolism or the representation of the metaphor, the eagle represents the indigenous way of thinking with a sense of real connection to nature.
Speaker: ah a You could even call it a spiritual kind of affinity, a sense that we are nature, that we're part of nature, that um intuitively in our connection with nature, if we listen to to nature, we can learn and respect and appreciation for the natural world. And these values and these qualities are seen through virtually all indigenous cultures.
Speaker: and And that's the representation of the condor. The eagle represents more the what we think of as Western civilization and particularly the emphasis on scientific inquiry upon analysis, upon um data.
Speaker: And both of these things are important, but there has been quite a conflict and and I would say a suppression ah by the more analytical world to repress, ah deny, struggle against, in many instances, this other view of the world.
Speaker: In modern language that we might more commonly use, um there's a lot of understanding developing about our right brain and our left brain.
Speaker: And the right brain is more like the condor. That is metaphorical, representative, intuitive, um Some would use the term spiritual, not in a religious way, but a sense of connection.
Speaker: ah And the left brain we think of as more analytical. of course, I'm being somewhat simplistic here, but I think that that is probably the origin.
Speaker: Intuitively, I think this is kind of where that legend, perhaps how that legend developed, um, And so it's been around for a long time.
Speaker: It's common to several of the indigenous cultures um in both Latin America, so South America and Central America.
Speaker: So i was intrigued by that. um The story is a very beautiful story about how these two things can converge and need to converge and will converge. And some people believe that's beginning to happen.
Speaker: I love that metaphor so much. I i connected it to so so many other things as well. ah You know, you think in like Buddhism, there's kind of this middle path. um When I think about more healthcare, care ah there's dialectical behavioral therapy, kind of this this middle path between doing and being.
Speaker: um And even in medicine, we kind of say the art and science of medicine. So there's always kind of this dialectic that exists, I think, kind of the the yin and the yang almost, right? i think so.
Speaker: I think it's a ah common archetype throughout cultures that you see this kind of balance. And I think it's, yeah, undoubtedly right that that we're kind of... ah you know, a little one-sided right now. And um it's it's it's it's humbling to think that ah indigenous folks have been, you know, that this has been a story in their culture for a long time. ah I think it would be easy to kind of be upset how our our society has become very one-sided. um But I think it's it's a humbling story to hear about that. I don't know if you have any thoughts on that.
Speaker: Well, it is humbling um because we've had, um and the Western way of thinking, ah a great deal of arrogance about the superiority um ah bu of this Western modality and and certainly white supremacy and domination of brown and black people.
Speaker: where you will find more of this sensitivity and intuitive thinking and connection to nature. ah So we have a lot to learn ah from these other cultures and civilizations. And as you say, it's not totally foreign.
Speaker: ah You gave some very good examples nature. of how we do touch on this, but we've given a ah strong dominance to um this particular form of sort of scientific inquiry and not enough into um the metaphorical and intuitive. Now, where these two things can come together and what I find particularly exciting is ah in the
Speaker: and the growing understanding in science of biomimicry. And biomimicry is a respectful analysis of how nature does things, which is somewhat akin to this indigenous way of of thinking and doing things.
Speaker: And by really studying how nature does things, um there are ways that that we can copy that and be instructed by that.
Speaker: um ah photosynthesis, for example, is is a methodology that we know helps the climate and and draws down CO2 and produces oxygen. what What I was unaware of, not being myself, not coming from a scientific background, is that ocean synthesis ocean um photosynthesis is even more impactful in the creation of ah the oxygen that we breathe and that ah surrounds our planet.
Speaker: And so the cultivation of the ocean and a healthy means um its is one of the ways that by studying all this, studying the the ice ages and the cyclical way that the the planet has evolved heal itself over and over, over thousands, over millennia, thousands of years, ah we can we can begin to copy that. And um a number of scientists are beginning to do that.
Speaker: And that is part of the encouraging message that it it is theoretically possible that we can draw down this damaging process
Speaker: layers of CO2 that um are so destructive. So to dive more into the the the kind of eagle and the condor, first I want to focus on you know how the humanities are relevant in climate change. I really like you had one person on ah the documentary. I believe he was a faith leader who said, you know, technology won't save us. um And that, you know, we needed to also look to things like art, music, spirituality ah to help us solve these modern problems.
Speaker: um So zoning in on spirituality for a second, how can spirituality be a ah relevant lens to help us solve the climate problem? Well, how one defines that, of course, depends a lot on one's individual or cultural orientation. But there are many forms of spirituality. You mentioned Buddhism.
Speaker: buddhism i think um Mindfulness-based stress reduction is becoming increasingly um common, and that is a form of being very present in the moment, honoring and being respectful of the moment and what is occurring at that time, not only in relationships, but in sensual ways, visually, um orally.
Speaker: um that is a form of one would one could say of spirituality. um and Poetry and art are ways that we nurture that sense of understanding the world that we live in.
Speaker: um and then when we we take that respect for the moment and and ah kind of an affection for for the natural world and for people, um we open up our possibilities of learning and growing and maturing.
Speaker: And there is there are ways in which that can intersect with um science and and basically our survival.
Speaker: And this is what a lot of indigenous cultures have been doing. ah for millennia. And um so there are ways that we can, we can begin to do that a lot more.
Speaker: Another word that keeps coming up in my head when I think about spirituality and climate change is minimalism. I think across spiritual traditions, um there is an emphasis on, you know, living simply on kind of only taking what you need, ah even or even to kind of adjacent to that is the indigenous philosophy. You know, you have to both take and give to the earth.
Speaker: yeah Curious how how you think we we might be able to to create a culture of minimalism in our very consumerist consumer society we live in. Well, I think a number of environmentalists for some years now, to to their credit, have been um trying to help us understand how to minimize... um the damage that we may be unwittingly be doing. ah let's Let's take something as basic as recycling.
Speaker: um So much of the packaging and the ah tremendous amount of waste um can be repurposed and upscaled and And we can also reduce,
Speaker: um you know we can we can check in a restaurant instead of a plastic container to take out your extra food after ah a nice meal, do they have a cardboard container?
Speaker: and And some restaurants are being sensitive about that. um and Composting, tremendous amount of um extra food that is just thrown out.
Speaker: ah can be composted. um Thinking about the kind of cars we drive and minimizing um our use ah fossil fuels in thoughtful ways.
Speaker: um All of those are ways among many that we can minimize our materialistic approach. Of course, there are many other forms.
Speaker: um Sometimes I think, well, I think if enough people do these things, it it has an impact. But I think we need to be doing more than that. And, um you know, and that's where that's where other forms of science and such can help us.
Speaker: In your your film, you also ah interviewed a lot of thought leaders who are um exploring green technology. um I believe you went to a really cool tech meetup in Baltimore where you met a lot of these folks. What are some of the promising technologies that can help restore our climate?
Speaker: Well, one of the encouraging things is to see a whole new generation of people, i would say, in their 20s and on up toward the middle range of, let's say, into the forty s that are essentially engineers and scientists and that are creating a lot of startups that are exploring the ah forms of science that i'm I've been alluding to.
Speaker: And I find the attitude of these individuals, like the ones we interviewed at the um event in in Baltimore,
Speaker: I find them to be upbeat, positive. ah They don't carry the gloom and doom ah sense of the future that so many people, I would say even the majority of ah people do in our cultures um because they they see that there are methods that that can be developed and um So in the in the film, as far as um what we feature, um there are ah there are things like kelp farming.
Speaker: um There are ah forms of ocean iron fertilization that are talked about. There are ways of making concrete that can actually absorb or hold on to CO2, the production of concrete ah causes about 8% of the pollution every year ah that goes up into the atmosphere. Steel, about 10% of planetary pollution comes from the production of of steel.
Speaker: And to um to discover these technologies and to see the the younger generations that largely, as I said before, of scientists and engineers that are getting into this field, um I find very, very interesting. One of the young men we interviewed in in Baltimore ah is using a methodology that on reduces the pollution that certain types of mining create and processing the
Speaker: um the ores and rocks and so forth that may be produced in such a way that they they actually can fertilize ah the oceans and by that proper fertilization um promote ah photosynthesis.
Speaker: that That's a process that basically um enriches the phytoplankton in certain parts of the ocean that can then, as it develops, it can draw down CO2 and produce oxygen. so So these younger people are really, you know, onto something. And um I find them very exciting to be around and to talk with.
Speaker: Yeah, setting aside the clean production of, of say, steel and concrete, which are you know amazing, amazing things, um it seems like a lot of the other technologies you looked at that have that biomimicry lens are are essentially related to ah cultivating photosynthesis. Is that correct?
Speaker: Yes, that seems to be the cheapest and the best way to, on ah on a very large gigaton scale, make a change.
Speaker: in in our atmosphere. ah So that's emerging. There are certain um things that are being talked about, which are of some questionable value in terms of the expense involved in some of those technologies. um But the Ocean iron fertilization, the development of kelp farming, ah these kinds of things create a photosynthesis and seem to be both safe and um have a good deal of promise, I think, as the science develops.
Speaker: So with that, we said the the kelp farming and the the iron fertilization. I know you also you know talked about how our earth works to use you know volcanoes and ice you know ice ages to essentially help move that photosynthesis further along.
Speaker: But is ah is that not, are like the ice ages and volcanoes, the the way ah they operate, is that less feasible for us to mimic those activities with technologies? Yeah.
Speaker: Well, I think you're onto something that's very related here, and that is that um the ice cores that are being drawn from ah ancient ice ah ah tell us a historic story of how the Earth has cooled and gone through these periods of a freeze,
Speaker: at least major parts of the planet, and then how um oxygen um has been reproduced on a large enough scale to restore ah the problem that that has occurred.
Speaker: ah so So I think that um ocean iron fertilization became important more of an understood concept when there was study of the Mount Pinatubo volcano of 1991.
Speaker: And for the next 12 months after that volcano occurred near the Philippines, ah the planet had net zero emissions.
Speaker: ah for the first time in many, many years. it It seemed rather miraculous, and scientists became very fascinated about how that could have happened.
Speaker: And what appears to have happened is that the iron from the dust that was blown into the atmosphere when it was carried to certain parts of the ocean, not just any part, but it appears to be parts where there are certain currents, like down-dwelling eddies, for example, that when it lands in certain areas,
Speaker: there is a safe bloom of phytoplankton. And the um it sort of enriches and fertilizes the ocean, which has been very damaged and acidified over the years.
Speaker: And in those particular safe areas, ah it can produce a lot of oxygen. And there are a couple of other such volcanoes that have demonstrated this same phenomenon over recent centuries.
Speaker: And so this is this is the area that we focused on primarily in the film and that Peter Farkowski and other scientists are currently developing pilot projects.
Speaker: to to do this safely on a small scale to study its impact and to see how this particular process can be developed. So this is an example of what we call biomimicry because it's looking at how nature has healed itself. and And then extrapolating from that,
Speaker: the kind of science that is respectful of nature. This is where you have, so to speak, metaphorically, a ah union of the eagle and the condor, if you will. That is to say, ah a real respect and appreciation of nature and then copy nature through this process that's called biomimicry.
Speaker: You mentioned that the ah younger generation, ah they're starting to develop a lot of resilience and even hope about, you know, our climate. um Can you reflect on, can can you say the same about some older generations?
Speaker: Well, let me say, just to put this in um maybe better context, it's not to say that the younger generation in any global sense is feeling more hopeful. In fact, ah the um American Psychological Association is documenting quite clearly that ah that climate anxiety is rampant and that the majority of younger people um
Speaker: are very anxious about the future. They've heard only about the possibility of the human race destroying itself and and much of what's in the planet on the planet. So it's not like the younger generations have this optimistic What I'm referring to is a very narrow segment of scientists and engineers that are exploring these new solutions.
Speaker: And that's that's the hope that I was referring to. So yeah I get the sense that, you know, for for this small segment, as you said, action can kind of be the antidote to despair and and giving them a sense of purpose in this whole problem.
Speaker: I think you're putting your finger right on it. Yeah. And action um is meaningful. And even for the many teenagers and young adults that um have the anxiety that I was referring to,
Speaker: um which which is also characterized by some depressive and hopeless feelings, giving them action, even you know basic actions, um whether it's a something as basic as cleaning up an area along a river getting rid of debris, planting and getting into agricultural projects. um There's a a large movement here in Philadelphia where I live of of urban agriculture.
Speaker: There are many, many lots now. A program called Neighborhood Gardens Trust nurtures um neighborhood engagement in ah creating vegetable gardens or perennial gardens or what have you, that um I think those kind of hands-on action things are,
Speaker: reconnect us with the earth and the soil and our relatedness to nature. And those kinds of things are healing and, and helpful to counter weigh, counterbalance um these feelings of, of hopelessness.
Speaker: I feel like another, another, segment or aspect of our society that can cause some of that hopelessness is just sort of the, um you know, the distrust in government, the the belief that government can't really get things done, whether it be in Washington or local governments or.
Speaker: So ah do you have a sense that. You know, regardless of what may be going on at washington in Washington, D.C. or at the United Nations or or what have you, that these efforts can keep moving forward regardless of, of you know, whoever's in office?
Speaker: Well, I do think things will be moving forward. I think the current administration has attacked the attacked ah the environmental ah methodologies and ah the healthy directions that we were going in or the the much more favorable
Speaker: programs. I think that it can slow things down, but... but um The market has also become pretty established, and it's not just in the U.S. I would say in Europe and certainly China, ironically, is leading ah all the countries in the world in the development of solar and wind energy.
Speaker: But even here, um it hasn't been destroyed. And ah paradoxically, even as the, let's say, for example, electric vehicles, that um that industry has been dampened as a result of the attacks of the current administration.
Speaker: the ah The war has ah in Iran has driven up the price of gasoline and there seems to be a rebound occurring, at least I'm reading about that and the New York Times just ah very recently, a rebound of EVs.
Speaker: um In Texas, of all states, Texas is now the the leading producer of um of wind energy,
Speaker: of all the other states in the country. And while it there's still this emphasis on fossil fuels and um a lot of that unfortunately happening,
Speaker: um the inexpensive nature of of solar and wind energy, um they have a foothold now. And solar energy system solar energy is tripling in its productivity around the planet every year, regardless. So I think the the market is driving um things or are helping us hold on some of these positive um energy transition kinds of things that existed before the current administration.
Speaker: I want to now ah think more about kind of just the bigger picture in our outlook. ah We did say earlier, you know, there is this prevailing sense of anxiety and despair about climate change. So, um you know, other other than some of the things you've already mentioned, how do we create a sense of hope amidst all this ah climate anxiety?
Speaker: Well, I think to get through some of the distress that exists in the and the climate, but I think on a much more severe and prominent scale right now, what's happening in our country, um that community and relationships um are really key and are what sustained us during difficult times.
Speaker: And um I would say that in sort of a global and a global way and, um I know that that's true for me personally, cultivating circles of friendship.
Speaker: um There are an increasing number of intentional community supportive efforts, on sometimes in a political realm, but sometimes just in ah and a more personal realm. Affinity groups, for example, that develop among groups of friends that help sustain each other.
Speaker: and and and help us deal with those issues. My hope is that films like the one I produced will we'll be able to get more messaging out. It's not, I mean, it's is not known very well what we're talking about today and what the message of the film is about. But I think getting that into the mainstream and into the the broader media is,
Speaker: one way that offers hope when people can see that there are answers to these things and that we need to give our attention to them, they create a much better sense of the future.
Speaker: And lastly, kind of bringing us ah you know full circle back to the some of the spirituality discussions we had, I really like the dichotomy ah you painted in the film of hubris versus wisdom, right? On one hand, we have ah had this this hubris that is widespread of of of conquering the earth, of kind of ah if a river is going one way and we want it to go the other way, we'll sort of bend it.
Speaker: ah Whereas, you know, on the other hand, you have this wisdom, which is more ingrained in the indigenous culture. um How do we shift values from hubris to wisdom and and kind of you know, to to to truly bring forth the the story of the eagle and the condor.
Speaker: Well, you know, I think in an earlier communication, you asked me a very fascinating question, which I think relates to what we're talking about. And that is, um
Speaker: is there an element in climate restoration that is related to restorative justice? And it really got me thinking about that. And um there are a couple of books I've read recently. One is is called is a River Alive?
Speaker: And it's it's a wonderful book um that explores how indigenous cultures work a group in Canada, another in Northern Ecuador and Colombia, how they have actually gained a legal status for certain natural elements.
Speaker: You know, you think about how corporations now have legal standing as if they're persons. These indigenous cultures have in fact brought to the courts of Ecuador the the question of legal status of a cloud forest us there that we think of as as really, they think of as very sacred ground and it's been very threatened by the mining industries.
Speaker: And they were able to get legal status for that for that forest. Similarly, in Canada, ah the Magpie River, of an enormous river up in the northeast of Canada, was under threat ah from hydroelectric plants that were going to basically change the whole flow of the river and and its geography and so forth.
Speaker: And they were also successful in the courts of getting legal status for the river. This is described to end in that book about of the legal standing of of nature.
Speaker: And both of these, and and there's some other examples in on the planet, um have a restorative quality. they not only protect those natural resources, but they also require remediation and restoration.
Speaker: So it is sort of a parallel process if you think about restorative justice and you think of these the river and the cloud forests.
Speaker: as having intrinsic value, almost as if they were persons, these indigenous efforts have been successful and ah this is becoming more and more known in the environmental world. So this particular book is a bestseller, Is a River Alive? And I would encourage a you know your listeners to to listen to that or to actually read it.
Speaker: So it sounds like re reclassifying ah some entities that we might not have necessarily thought of as living, kind of reclassifying them as living is perhaps a step in that direction of of bringing about that wisdom?
Speaker: Well, I think this is part of the message of the indigenous cultures. um they're They're telling us that we need to respect these natural entities, whether they're rivers or rainforests or what have you.
Speaker: as as if they were persons. Now, we don't think that way in our Western world. It sounds kind of absurd on the surface, but they are using that argument from their own indigenous culture.
Speaker: You could say the cultures of the condor, and they're bringing this into the courts, which would be the the territory of the eagle. and And they are having some success in getting these people ah natural places ah designated with a kind of legal personhood, if you will.
Speaker: i mean, not literally, but essentially it's the same thing, that they have rights and privileges to be protected, to be restored. ah so that that I would say is a modern example of the eagle and the condor coming together. The other thing we've been talking about in this conversation is the degree to which scientists have that sort of this new group of scientists have a real appreciation and respect for
Speaker: for nature and learning from nature and being being students, letting letting nature show us how to do this through this phenomenon of biomimicry and then copying the methodologies of nature. So so these are examples of a science and spirit coming together, if you will, or legal entity, legal structures coming together.
Speaker: in a way that I think does give us a little bit of a glimpse of what it means when the eagle and the condor unite. With that, it's time for a lightning round, a series of rapid fire questions that tell us more about you. Okay.
Speaker: You've made, ah as I understand, four documentaries now. what's What's a powerful documentary that inspired you to pursue that art form? Well, uh, I think Al Gore's ah film was very, very provocative for me and instructive.
Speaker: And I'm very grateful um ah for that. And that that's what comes to mind, first of all. What's the topic of your next documentary? That I'm not at all sure about. um i yeah I call this sort of my second retirement. ah I hope to continue to stay with this particular film and its promotion and discussions like this and screenings.
Speaker: And I see a future for that. um i don't I don't have a topic in mind at the moment. I'm just going to have to let that ferment a little bit and so and see where we go with it.
Speaker: What's your favorite outdoor activity?
Speaker: It's definitely gardening. That's very easy. I've been working for 21 years as a volunteer in the development and maintenance of a perennial garden, which is kind like a park up in North Philadelphia. It's under the aegis or supervision sponsorship of a drug recovery program.
Speaker: And I work a little bit with the residents of that program to and teaching them some things about gardening, but mostly it's is for my own pleasure and and sense of connection to to the earth. My father oh raised um us to have an interest in his gardens. He he did gardening in the city and in small towns where we lived long before urban gardening was a concept. So that's that's easily my answer to your question.
Speaker: I imagine gardening's therapeutic, but do you have another ah wellness practice that helps you decompress? ah i write poetry.
Speaker: And um just this weekend, i spent a whole weekend at a program up in the Poconos that it's called Poetry Medicine. And it it's a way in which ah poetic process can help us kind of deal with our our own anxieties, our own hopes and dreams, of what we love about life, as well as what we're struggling with.
Speaker: So poetry does that for me. ah Art does. um And it's probably what what has drawn me into filmmaking.
Speaker: And lastly, what's a climate initiative or technology you're most excited about? Well, I think it's the one that I've been referring to several times in the conversation, and that is the development of ocean iron fertilization and and carefully constructed small-scale experiments that are being designed and to see how those develop.
Speaker: um Because I think that that's that's the most promising technology that that we have for turning things around. Vic Comfer, thanks so much for joining The Wound Dresser.
Speaker: It's been a real pleasure talking with you. Thank you, John.
Speaker: Thanks for listening to The Wound Dresser. Until next time, I'm your host, John Neary. Be well.


