Transcript
Speaker: Hello everyone! I am Masiara Kirasarope. And this is modern subjects. a podcast dedicated to understanding nationalism and national identities, both in the past and in the present.
Speaker: Sometimes you can feel when a book you're reading is gonna be important for a field. Sometimes it's because the radical thesis that points towards a new interpretation of old facts or due to a resuffling of previous assumptions.
Speaker: On other occasions you simply are amazed by the sheer amount of detail and erudition in display. the multitude of dots of theories of concepts that the author has managed to connect to each other.
Speaker: And sometimes, as with the latest book written by today's guest, emeritus professor of modern European literature, and the University of Amsterdam, Joep Leusen. You can feel both. at the same time.
Speaker: Charismatic Nations, published by... Cambridge University Press. It only provides an overview of Romantic nationalism. but also engages with the topic of explaining its cultural and ideological roots and how these intersect at particular moments throughout Europe.
Speaker: It is a single volume that condenses Professor Lerson's vast learning. and makes it available for anyone in a very readable very educational and frankly speaking entertaining manner with Lots of anecdotes and stories about writers, about poets, painters, architects and many others.
Speaker: that rewrite more familiar accounts. from a European and transnational perspective. And the book is is also well timed, I think. Romanticism. a term which often stands for 19th century nationalism as a whole.
Speaker: is in many ways the main antagonist in nationalism studies narratives.
Speaker: its talk of national spirits and races is the augur against which generations of scholars armed with the bare truths of academic criticism, have ceaselessly battled debunking and refuting beliefs about the supposed antiquity or exceptionality of peoples and nations.
Speaker: And in doing so, what their works have demonstrated is that large parts of these traditions were not grounded on fact. but were rather invented. willed into existence, if you like.
Speaker: by the efforts of zealous patriots statesmen and artists seeking to elevate their people over their rivals.
Speaker: These were at the time, and remain, momentous victories in our path to understanding national phenomena. as a result of human imagination, rather than as biological or natural facts.
Speaker: But the problem... Was that... following these results. scholars were only too eager to throw the baby out with the bathwater. and assumed that the emotional ties that these inventions produced must have been invented as well forgeries that would dispel effortlessly.
Speaker: once the stories and myths that animated them were displaced to the metaphorical dustbin of history. This of course has not been the case. popular historical imagination all across the world.
Speaker: seems to continue to be haunted by images of national heroes momentous battles of world -shattering importance invasions and racial replacement and myths of ancestry whose roots date back to the Romantic period.
Speaker: Herein lies one of the main attractives of Professor Lerson's book. in its rehabilitation of romantic nationalism. not as a tool by which to understand our past and present,
Speaker: but rather as a cultural and political project that provides answers. that many men and women culture and then cultured. in cities and in the countryside.
Speaker: found useful. to understand their own world.
Speaker: Before leaving you with the interview, a quick note on the episode. Professor Lersen is one of the creators of the Collaborative Encyclopedia of Romantic Nationalism in Europe, which is available long online and has thousands of pictures, maps, biographies, lists of documents and...
Speaker: many more things. And... It is much fun to navigate for anyone if only a little interested in the period. and I encourage all of you to check it out. Also, the latest book by Professor Lesson and the one we will be discussing today, Charismatic Nations, is also available for free on the Cambridge University webpage.
Speaker: We had some technical problems during the recording of this episode and this is why you might notice some cuts and repeated questions. I have tried to edit these out and I hope that they will not prevent you from enjoying the episode.
Speaker: I'm still Quite new in all this business of podcasting, so... Any help and feedback is always well received. And now, without further ado... my conversation with Professor Joep Leusen.
Speaker: so Welcome to the podcast, Professor Larson. Thank you for being here. Thank you. So... um I invited you because I just read your... ah most recent book, Charismatic Nations, and I thought it was it's It's not often that you find... kind of so such a broad and also like i think that the words to the force are just so so much so many times in in scholarship.
Speaker: but i think in your case it's actually true this is an actual tour the force in which you brute force in a way through lots of case studies lots of Uh... fields of of inquiry that are usually separated. and And I think that...
Speaker: Once I read your book, I understand much better some aspects of of 19th century history that perhaps in my mind were kind of separated before. So. the first question would be like What is that drew you into this?
Speaker: a topic of Romanticism. Because I know that you've worked on this for for quite a long time. So what is it that... Drew you too. romantic ah the romantic period.
Speaker: and specifically to romantic nationalism. Well, to begin with, thank you very much for your kind words. um the and And I should perhaps also state that um I stand on the shoulder of very, very many colleagues.
Speaker: uh i digested a lot of data in this book but these data were all brought together by the 450 collaborators in the encyclopedia of romantic nationalism that i edited And because of my editorships, I familiarized with them. myself with a lot of cases from the Basque country to Estonia which normally are not but brought together into the same scope.
Speaker: and I could start connecting the dots. So that's basically all I do is I connect dots. And if you want to see all the dots and the real brute force, I recommend everybody to go to the Encyclopedia of Romantic Nationalism in Europe or ERNI for short. It is a free resource online. So having said that.
Speaker: um what What was it that drew me to it? By training I work in comparative literature. And I was always interested in how literature negotiated identities.
Speaker: what happened if, you know, cross -border ah processes took place in literary traffic, an author moving into another country or a book being read by foreign readerships.
Speaker: And um very early on, it struck me that in the Romantic period something really, really changes. It is a real tipping point in a number of respects.
Speaker: um So I was interested in literary romanticism, first of all. um and then began to look at the political implications. In particular, I was interested in the... um link between Creative literature.
Speaker: poetry, novels, drama. and literary knowledge production, because something starts happening in text editions, reading medieval texts. editing medieval epics.
Speaker: And I realized that most of the medieval epics that we read as the beginning point of a literary tradition. were actually forgotten. in 1750.
Speaker: and they were all rediscovered in 1850. So that the Romantic period is also the period in which Europe rediscovers Beowulf and the Nibelungenlied. and the chanson de roland and kalevala And all these things which we think are old, but they in fact are. romantic or at least they were brought into circulation at the same time as wordsworth and byron and heine uh so uh
Speaker: This intrigued me. And that was really the starting point for Charismatic Nations. How romantic is the rediscovery of the national past? Okay, thank you. By the way, I will make sure to link in the description Encyclopedia of Romantic Nations.
Speaker: Magnificent resource. that i uh command everyone to to check out it's it's great so i will link it in the in this description Going back to to this topic, I think it's... ah It's very interesting, something I wanted to discuss perhaps further down the line. but now that you brought brought it up.
Speaker: I think that sometimes... for scholars and especially for historians romanticism has been accused of forgery and invention of having been faking. and nations where there were none and of course like many of the classical works of national ah Modernism.
Speaker: are directly stand directly against the claims made by romantic authors about their own nations. and Correct me if I'm wrong, but i am I right in thinking that your book well doesn't refute does this invention taking place, in a sense?
Speaker: asks instead why these forges were so successful. where Why was that drool? people to claim them as their own. Yeah. Yeah, thanks for bringing that up. ah This is where I also felt that I had something.
Speaker: to teach, if you like, and social historians, political historians and historical sociologists, who are the core cohort of people who study nationalism. um they have if you like a professional ethos which is skeptical.
Speaker: which tries to debunk. which tries to be source critical. And they have no time at all for anything that has to do with the imagination or and which in a way is part of.
Speaker: Hmm. I would call the Weberian term no disenchantment so you know weibo says that modernity in modernity we no longer believe in fairy tales And that certainly happens for to modern historians. They no longer believe in fairy tales and they are very severe. about fairy tales.
Speaker: um But romanticism is about... re -enchantment. It's the resistance. against disenchantment and so is nationalism to some extent. Now, the notion of the invention of tradition.
Speaker: is but It was coined in 1983. It is really, really Stone Age. I mean, that's, you know, almost 45 years ago. And it's about time we moved on to the next stage. And a number of people have done that. They've played with Notion. le the the tradition of inventions and other ways of playing with the notion of the invention of traditions.
Speaker: um Yes, romanticism imagines, it invents, it embellishes, and sometimes it contrives and falsifies. um But this.
Speaker: is in itself a social praxis. And you cannot pretend that it didn't happen. and write it out of history. And you cannot pretend that it didn't appeal.
Speaker: to public opinion at the time, to readerships. So to say that it was materially unsound is no reason to write it out of your analysis. And this is... One of the big things I have with people like John Broily and other, if you like, sociological soci sociological modernists.
Speaker: I am a modernist. You know, I'm no Anthony Smith. And on the whole, I believe that nationalism is a byproduct of modernity. It's a modern invention. But the materials on which capitalism on which nationalism draws...
Speaker: are pre -modern. And they're very ancient and very often they're pre -scientific and non -academic and nationalism believes in fairy tales. It's a form of superstition. Yes, but that is an extremely important historical fact.
Speaker: So this is where I want to talk about the agency. of beliefs. The agency. of the literary imagination to actually mobilize people politically.
Speaker: And this I feel is steering in middle course. between the people who believe in fairy tales or who are national essentialists um on the one hand, and the very skeptical.
Speaker: Modernists on the other hand. and this is it here in this overlap between these two traditions that your notion of charisma well max weber's notion of charisma mediated by you Take two. Yes. stamp it is so if you could um explain a little bit what you mean by by charisma.
Speaker: Yes, and um indeed. um i've I've been trying to... operationalize if you like a non -rational attitude towards collective identity.
Speaker: in terms that are uh you know analytic and non -ideological non -metaphysical. And I felt that. um Max Weber's Charisma.
Speaker: ah was a very very good midway point to open a space for that discussion. um and the book begins with a concept historical discussion of Max Weber's charisma.
Speaker: which I lead back to Edmund Burke. who begins to speak in his critique of the French Revolution. of the need to regard the institutions of the state with reverence.
Speaker: and with awe. Now those are religious affects. We acknowledge that the state is older and larger than us. and deserves our piety or our reverence.
Speaker: So para -religious. discourse has always been there to describe the feelings that the state and inspires in us. This will later on also and inform the sociology of Durkheim.
Speaker: um I trace this idea of the reverence for the state and the idea of the state as an almost trans -historical. Uh... presence in human affairs.
Speaker: um through the great man make history. um theory of Hegel. So Hegel's notion of the heroic leaders, the the history -changing leaders like Napoleon or Muhammad. um and then which is taken up by carlisle um And from there, you can see something about the idea of superhuman heroic leadership in national history makers.
Speaker: Go on into Max Weber. If you look at the actual discourse of charisma, you see that the charisma. that Weber described has something to do with hero worship. mm -hmm now so usually we speak of charisma when we talk about charismatic leaders And of course, charismatic leadership is a very, very heavily debated ah notion nowadays.
Speaker: partly because Weber was you know, Not very... explicit when he wrote about it. He he wrote this ah but towards the end of his life. um And we're now asking ourselves, would Hitler have been a charismatic leader? Would Mussolini have been? All these people who showed up just after Weber's death, would they have been charismatic leaders?
Speaker: um and nowadays of course we begin to mistrust charismatic leaders because populism relies very heavily on them and this is also what the note that my book ends on it begins with charisma and it ends with narcissism. You think that you're a hero, you think you're superhuman, but there's something unhealthy about that.
Speaker: In my book What I try to do is not have a... sociological or a political discussion of charismatic or authoritarian leaders. but to point out that if we look at
Speaker: Public opinion. What really inspires a... Joyful devotion. which is how we can describe charisma is often the nation itself People get tears in their eyes when they sing the national anthem.
Speaker: when they think of their country. it's not And the the charismatic leader is only a proxy. for that. So what I'm tracing from Burke. Two.
Speaker: if you like, the First World War is how the nation became a charismatic entity. something which almost religiously inspires inspires joy, fidelity.
Speaker: and you know obedience in the people who believe in it. um and Romanticism. is um is is is an absolutely necessary ingredient in that trajectory.
Speaker: oh Thank you. I think it's it's very interesting, this idea of Charismatic Nation, of course, that's the name of the of the book as well. But I think the idea of the nation as being the repository of this ah reverence that previously perhaps would have fallen to the monarch or to the church or or other entities how that transforms into the nation and I think it's it's very interesting about the the period that you study.
Speaker: That. As you mentioned, this is a moment of re -enchantment, it is a moment of looking for essences, for metaphysical... and principles that underlie reality in some various way of looking for the origins of of races and nations and and all this kind of of thing. But at the same time, it's also the highday of the heyday of ah rationalism, of scientific approaches to well, to to many studies such as philology or history even.
Speaker: and also like an expansion of the state on a scale that hadn't happened. earlier so I think it's these two currents at least from the outside seem to be contradictory. so it's It's kind of paradox that the re -enchantment occurs at the same time as the rationalization. So how do you think that the nature of romanticism helps them? help us understand this this or balance these two two approaches.
Speaker: Yes, thank you very much. This is very acute and and' ah I maybe should have brought that out more clearly in in my book. There is a deep paradox here.
Speaker: um As a literary historian and a historian of ideas. I could... begin by pointing out that the history of ideas and the history of mental attitudes is fugatic.
Speaker: It is cumulative. it is the the The new does not about abolish the old. So when... people start thinking romantically around 1800, they don't stop being rationalist. It's just another voice added to the fugue. And when in the 1830s, 1840s, they become positivistic, they don't stop being romantic. All these things are mingled. in the cultural streams um it uh i
Speaker: I don't want to go too deeply into the details of this, but um It is obvious that there are always mixed feelings at work. now um We can see this in the notion of nationalism. It is layered. it is if if you like in the fugue there is a certain polyphony going on in that we have...
Speaker: in the reverence that we feel for the state, there is a classical and even classicist tradition network Cicero. when he talked about ah the the offices of the Roman citizen, talked about the piety that we should feel. for our the patria, which was the Roman Republic.
Speaker: And in the anti -absolutist Enlightenment critique, of absolute monarchy. A lot of people were inspired by Cicero. And instead of...
Speaker: Prioritizing the obedience to the king they prioritized the love of the fatherland. So fatherland and the king were two opposed notions um and amor patria.
Speaker: which we would now say is straightforward. Nationalism was in fact part and parcel of the enlightened and patriotic tradition. and this patriotic tradition was if you like cannibalized or overlaid by romantic nationalism.
Speaker: and it's important to see that the two still go on. If you look at the vestiges. of enlightenment patriotism. and and and and rationalism and rationalization of the state.
Speaker: you can see that a lot of People who are part of the typology of nationalism still do the type of things that 18th century patriots did. I give you one example. In Bulgaria there was a man in the 1830s who stands at the beginning of the rediscovery of the Bulgarian language. He is the godfather of Bulgarian nationalism. His name is Peter Barron.
Speaker: and the thing he did he had studied medicine in heidelberg he had had a an academic education um The thing he did was he publish he he wrote a school book to teach kids how to read and write in Bulgarian. And that is very much a sort of thing which in Western Europe you'd see in the 1760s, 1770s, you know, education for all and and making people literate and all that sort of stuff. um So.
Speaker: There you see what Kozelik would call die Gleichzeitigkeit des Ungleichzeitigen. At any moment you can see two different paradigms, an old one and an an emerging one, coexisting in in the same. social sphere.
Speaker: Now the state is modernising. And it ah the romantic nationalists... all profit. from this Modernizing new. post French Revolution state.
Speaker: For one thing, universities... National but libraries and archives are placed under the control of the state. Before they would be under the control of a dynastic monarch or of a a monastery or something like that. And now they become public institutions. And the people who work in these public institutions are civil servants.
Speaker: you get a whole new Cohort. of Professional. intellectuals who are civil servants and they are all of them romantic nationalists. Michelet in France, Thierry in France, Jacob Grimm in Germany, they are all making use of the modernization of the state and they use it for their idealistic romantic celebration of national identity.
Speaker: at We cannot go into the details and because, of course, this this book... like As I've mentioned, Travels from... one side of the continent of Europe to the another and in and this expanse of a paragraph so But I would like to... to point out a comparison that came to my mind all the time while I was reading because I As I mentioned, I also read your National Thought in Europe, think which is also a fantastic book.
Speaker: and There you talk about Tacitus and the rediscovery of Tacitism in the 16th century and you put it in relation with the Dutch Revolution and well constitutional well disputes in the early modern period.
Speaker: And in this book, you talk. at length about another case. about another also that To my mind. kind of fills fill thats fills up the same niche.
Speaker: which is Ossian. Of course, this is a vastly different ah author if you want to call it that that It's a literary epic writer kind of. ah a bard of the lost.
Speaker: ah ancestors. But. To me, the idea was the same. like It was a way to give Northern Europeans... northern europeans uh way too be proud of their heritage in a sense.
Speaker: invented or not, or contested or not. so Do you think that this case is is is far -fetched? My comparison is far -fetched? Or do you think there's something similar in there? And if not, or what's the similarity between these two cases?
Speaker: That's a very creative question. You're you're connecting two dots that I... who am a professional dot connector had not connected. Ossian and Tacitus. But I think you are spot on right.
Speaker: um let A few words about this. um
Speaker: Tacitus was lost, at least the the portion the portion about the the annals that were about the Roman conquest of Northern Europe and about the the Germanic peoples.
Speaker: This was lost. ah practically until the 15th century. And the rediscovery of Tacitus, um who were who had a critique. of Roman belligerence and Rome's drift towards autocracy and the empire.
Speaker: um this the and The. Sympathy that Tacitus showed for the barbarians in the north who who resisted. the imperial might of Rome.
Speaker: was a deep inspiration for those barbarians in the north who were you know resisting specifically papal supremacy in the 15th century. So Tacitus was a huge inspiration particularly for Protestant thinkers.
Speaker: um who said, okay, the Germans resisted the Romans in the first century, and we, Luther and the reformers, are still resisting the Pope nowadays. So Tacitus becomes a master narrative.
Speaker: I want to add one thing which will be very relevant for Ossian. um Tacitus? describes what I call an ethnotype. An ethnotype is a profile of a national temperament, a national character, a Volksgeist, by which a certain ethnic tradition. stands apart.
Speaker: from all the rest of humanity. Disclaimer. I do not believe in national characters. I want to describe how everybody else believed in national characters. That's why I talk about ethnotypes, a bit like stereotypes.
Speaker: The Ethnotypes of the North Europeans were something that were that that we see in Tacitus, were really internalized by North European Protestant intellectuals.
Speaker: against the civilization. and the decadence and the imperial power of Rome, Tacitus placed moral integrity,
Speaker: collective decision -making communitarianism. and more a sense of personal responsibility. And this is becomes a core tenet of how Protestants see themselves.
Speaker: So it really gave a discourse and a format for Germans and also for the Dutch and to some extent for the English. to articulate what they felt was their specific identity.
Speaker: Okay, that was the importance of Tacitus. Ossian does something like it. Of course, Ossian was a forgery. And his if you like his real influence over European thought only lasted for a few decades in the end of the 18th century.
Speaker: but what he does is he invokes a poetic formula. which is crucial. for romanticism. it is not too much to say that ossian is one of the architects of european romanticism and that is that um
Speaker: literature and true literature is made not by slavishly following rules and forms and and doing things in the approved, accepted form, but by being personally inspired. and very often being personally inspired by the ghostly voices of the dead generation.
Speaker: Ossian channels the past. Ossian It has a sixth sense by which he is in tune with the collective feelings of the nation. He is almost a shamanistic.
Speaker: Visitor. to the metaphysical identity and history of the nation and he puts that into poetry. That is what every national poet wanted to do.
Speaker: And a lot of the things that are in Ossian, even though Ossian was debunked, inform the eye the but the poetics and the politics of Inspiration.
Speaker: and this is what makes a poet A hero. Indeed. you know, Hegel -Carlyle sense, the poet can intuit. and sense things of a world historical importance that normal people can't. He has superhuman powers.
Speaker: now OCEAN Also. articulated an ethnotype. i want to urge namely that in Northern Europe People are not motivated.
Speaker: um by the
Speaker: straightforward commonsensical vitality of Homer The power? the vigor of room but that they instead they are inspired into contemplation by the melancholy skies, the cold climate.
Speaker: that they are more philosophical, that they are more profound and they are less superficial. And maybe they're not quite as practical. they tend to lose their battles but they are spiritually superior And that too becomes a very, very important. enabling archetype for all the nationalisms in the celtic regions um So Scotland, Ireland, Brittany, and even, dare I say it, in Galicia.
Speaker: Emanuel Morgia. ah says that he is a Celt. and that it partakes of of this particular ethnotype. so I think you are right. Here are two authors that somehow...
Speaker: intervened at a very peculiar moment. Tacitus in the Reformation, Ossian, At the eve. of the french revolution the industrial revolution and the romantic revolution and they got if you like, the spirit of the age, and they really appealed to huge audiences. So yes, I like your comparison very much, and I think it is totally justified.
Speaker: thank you Thank you for your answer. Now that you mention these cases, these Celtic nations, Scotland, Ireland... And now that we're talking poetics and literature, I think the influence of Walter Scott, for example, it's... it's hard to miss. and I think that...
Speaker: One of them... Interesting points that you raise in your book. one of many of course. is that Historical novels on the Walter Scott style influenced the newly born scientific scholarship on history.
Speaker: So. um yeah you mentioned michelet and of course this kind of search of of essences of metaphysics under history. Right now it's not how we do history. these days, but it was how... academic history was written at a certain point in in the past.
Speaker: So. Can you tell us more about this influence? of of what we call historical novels into what's scientific ah history.
Speaker: and And if I... if i ah might i also as a follow -up question, what do you think academics. gained and lost in this exchange and in this influence. with this influence Okay. Again, thank you very much for that question. um I could say a lot about what Walter Scott and about the historical novel in literature.
Speaker: There might be an occasion later on to come back to that. because walter scott i mean very very interesting and very important author but let's look specifically at walter scott and our approach to history and Walter Scott and the historians.
Speaker: um What Walter Scott did. was that that there had always been romances. uh about the past but they usually were a bit like conan the barbarian or something you know a lot of action and Walter Scott turns this into almost like a psychological novel like Jane Austen.
Speaker: You could say that ah you know Walter Scott is like Jane Austen set in the Middle Ages. I'm exaggerating slightly, but only slightly. ah What he does is he allows readers to really empathize with the heroes and to experience There.
Speaker: Experience of the past. So if we read Waverley, we ourselves move back as Waverley's companions to the Scottish rebellion of 1745. When we read Ivanhoe, we move back.
Speaker: to the middle ages when we see how an Anglo -Saxon knight has to deal with the Norman uh occupation and how he falls in love with the jewish woman and that is something which you know,
Speaker: engages us emotionally, directly with what? the past must have been felt like. This is in instead in fact doing what Ranke was going to tell historians they should do, namely to describe the past wie es eigentlich gewesen.
Speaker: a very debated term but to um i i interpreted to say the past in its own terms, as it was experienced at the time. So the reader time travels back and emotionally, imaginatively becomes part of the past. And the great skill of the author is to magically.
Speaker: Wait for the phrase. Bring the past back to life. Now... The... Romantic generation of historians realized that Walter Scott was doing something for his readers. that the historical craft had failed to do.
Speaker: They came out of a tradition of philosophical history writing. when history was philosophy teaching by example. it was a form of seeing how societies worked etc etc why battles were won lost or won and they were not really getting through to the audience what also happened and this is a fortuitous circumstance, is all these archives are opened up.
Speaker: So all the archives that were closed off uh behind lock and key for a long time, suddenly become public knowledge. And we should not forget that Michelet and Thierry worked in the archives. Thierry went blind because he he worked he read so many manuscripts.
Speaker: So they're not just airy -fairy amateurs saying, oh, let's imagine what it was like to be a Gaul in 5th century France. They really, really were good historians and they really went back to their sources.
Speaker: but in there writing style they were evocative they were dramatic they were even melodramatic but they really tried to let Grab the reader and say, this is what the French Revolution must have felt like. This is... you know what the Fronde must have felt like. so um It was this dramatic writing style.
Speaker: which was later disavowed. by ah historians as they really professionalized. So the name Rankin here marks the... the tipping point around 1830 we get the new universities and the new universities get history departments And the main task of the history department is to train young men to become history teachers in schools. So ah you know it becomes a a sort of a professional factory.
Speaker: And they still work with the archives. And Branko works at... quite ah source criticism and has seminars where he trains his students to work with you know document original documents. It's a new skill.
Speaker: So they take that over. from the the earlier generation. but they become factualists they want to become serious scholars, they want to become reliable, and all the melodramatic rhetorical flights of fancy and the generalizations of the previous generation, they rigorously reject.
Speaker: um I think this rigorous rejection of the imagination and of rhetoric is still something which dominates the historical profession. Yeah.
Speaker: I'll give you one tiny little... It's all right there. Go ahead. yeah hell I'll give you one example. Two books came out in the same year. Um, One was ah Fritz Fischer, Griffnachter Weltmacht, which is the notorious Fischer thesis about what started the First World War. And the other one was Barbara Tuchman's The Guns of August, which is about the month of August 1914.
Speaker: Nobody compared those books. They both had a similar argument. And in the public ah ah public imagination, the guns of August had a huge influence. It had an influence in on John F. Kennedy during the Cuban Missile Crisis. But Barbara Tuchman was a popular historian. She wrote paperbacks for, it you know, so.
Speaker: And she had never done the rite de passage of going to an archive. but she had But, you know, there is this sort of professional ethos. um And it sort of blinkers.
Speaker: ah historians from, if you like, the um And then. audience -friendly way of triggering their imagination. And what happened as a result of that, I think is the following.
Speaker: History became a very highly respected academic profession. but it lost the ear of the general public. Everybody read Michelet. Everybody read Macaulay. You know, these were better. Their books were reprinted until the very...
Speaker: present you know they and Whereas all these statistical analyses... of the grain prices in northern France in the 15th century, the Annales sort of, ah you know, was written by historians for historians, but totally ignored by the general public.
Speaker: I leave certain Exceptions like Braudel on the Mediterranean. It's not all that black and white, but still. I was going to say that. it' These authors were really popular. they were bestsellers in some cases and I can think of Uh, Um... john green in for example in in in britain and also michelin in france and i think it's It's so curious that...
Speaker: history as a profession moved away from what was actually so popular and as as you've said they had the year of of the of society in a sense and of course of the state as well And they chose to...
Speaker: to pursue this. idea of scientificity in a way, rather than popularity. And I think that perhaps there's... a cultural distinction distinction there between highbrow and lowbrow and something something along those lines that I don't get but
Speaker: it's It's so curious that they they chose to do that. And in a way, we're still in that kind of mindset. There's still this kind of tension between popularizing efforts by some historians and also kind of rigorous research as if they were incompatible in a sense.
Speaker: That's right. And we also have a certain conceptual split nowadays between history and memory. um And what you see is that the romantic historians.
Speaker: um who were disavowed in a sort of Oedipal father -son conflict by the historians from the mid -19th century onwards. um Still...
Speaker: have enormous influence on collective memory. If we look at the view of history that is ambient, among non -historians that we get from if you like street names or from statues in public spaces or from, you know, movies that are based on historical novels and movies like Braveheart. You see that the the public imagination and collective memory.
Speaker: is still informed by the romantic historians and the professional historians are unable of improving on that They rejected it wholesale and they got no traction. I think it's a great pity because at the moment there's a lot of fake history.
Speaker: And... professional historians. should be able to help us. to contradict the lies that are you know broadcast on the history channel for instance or in in in in social media um And the American Historical Review tried at some point to review historical movies to see is Gone with the Wind really a good you know representation of the American Civil War.
Speaker: But it's somewhat like being a musicologist in a disco. You know, somehow there's a big... but gap between the two and I think you need to bring it back together. Yeah, but would you say that's something that is possible? Would you say that Or does history have to... surrender in a sense.
Speaker: some of but Because, for example, historians are usually Kind of. uh makes into a parody. saying, well, everything is very complex and nothing has a quite clear explanation and all of that. Of course, no one likes this kind of explanations.
Speaker: And those are not the kind of... explanations that Arouse that. Charismatic. uh spirit that you actually makes so central to engagement with the past.
Speaker: So. Yeah. Is it possible to square this circle in a sense? Is it possible to to overcome this this tension? What do you say? well What's your opinion on this? yeah well So, yeah, I was asking if that's this.
Speaker: unsolvable tension between Well. scientific history and popular imagination and if it's possible for historians while being rigorous to tap into the mental kind of collective memory of of of society and and the masses in a way. so to reproduce this kind of success that romantic historians had in their prime.
Speaker: Yeah. It's um It's a difficult one. It's not easy. To begin with, at the moment, society is moving away from um Reliably tested knowledge.
Speaker: ah it It goes for journalism. So professional journalists are being overtaken by influencers on social media. and um Uh... history channel and all the f about you know the the great pyramid was built by beings from the planet zog and all all the fake history that you get and certainly fake archaeology is appealing to society and they are impatient.
Speaker: with historians who stroke their chin and saying, yes, well, this is actually, you know. um There is a reason why we we started to have... a discovery channel on on on television and People like discoveries.
Speaker: Now, the romantic historians had it good because they were living in an age of discoveries. They were discovering things in the archives. They came up with new things. and that you know, appeal of fresh insights and new things is was a great trump card.
Speaker: So historians nowadays tend to refine knowledge and also correct errors. There's a lot of debunking going on. and And it was very big in the 1980s. you know with the invention of tradition and and that sort of thing and i think You know, historians got used to the fact that they got high grades if they debunked something.
Speaker: um because that met showed that they were a good historian. I also feel that or to give you another sense political historians Try to work Only. on state archives to see what the rational decisions of governments were.
Speaker: And they discountenance anything that comes from public opinion. You see this in the Christopher Clarke approach. the If you compare Christopher Clarke and Margaret MacMillan about the run up to the First World War.
Speaker: You see that Christopher Clarke seems to imply that All the governments were Henry Kissinger's and they only went by a sort of rationalistic way of what is in the national interest and what is not. And not a single irrational collective feeling entered into 1914.
Speaker: I find that that is stultifying. I think it's, you know, history that needs to be. that is a bit one -dimensional. because not everybody was a Henry Kissinger, certainly not in 1913.
Speaker: um and it's also projecting the professional ethos. of the modern historian on the choices and behaviors of actors in the past. So it's a form of projection. much as much as the romantic historians were projecting so to the rationalistic positivistic historians nowadays are projecting.
Speaker: I think historians should embrace the idea that you can come up with discoveries. That is really what the public likes. And we have that. very strongly in a certain number of professional This sub -disciplines, we have it in archaeology.
Speaker: archaeologists discover things. We have it in art history. You know with certain things about artists and paintings are being discovered by x -ray scanning or by whatnot. And we have it in literary history.
Speaker: There was a very, you know, my great colleague Frits van Oostrom in the history of medieval Dutch literature. said that the famous line from the 11th century was probably spoken by a woman.
Speaker: In a sort of Cantar de Amigo type of love tradition. um and Nobody had thought of that. They always thought that the... lyrical subject was a man and oh this could be a woman's poem and he made headlines he was on the front page of the national newspapers that is still possible he discovered something he brought something fresh But...
Speaker: Archaeologists? Literary historians, art historians are not considered... proper historians by the social and political historians. So I think historians should try and get away.
Speaker: from the government archives. I think that is a really important thing. uh they should embrace knowledge that comes from printed sources from publicly available sources not from archival sources and there is still a lot of fresh and and they should try and find something new um and and not be scared of the thrill that hey this there could be something here right and to have a yeah to have a productive knowledge rather than a debunking knowledge.
Speaker: So... Now that you mention archaeologists and... I was reminded of this case in in the Basque Country, which is of course the case that I know best. there's there was this artifact uncovered.
Speaker: four years ago. It was... a little hand, a little amulet. And. Of course it had some kind of script. and apparently it was related to current it was scar that which is the Basque tongue.
Speaker: And. it made all the... the newspaper pages and all that. It was quoted in the in the Guardian in in the UK. So it was this big piece of news. but immediately was overtaken by, once again, this kind of very romantic inspired view of language as the carrier of the values and the essences of our people. so in a way yeah the thrill of discovery made something. available though it's not.
Speaker: But. it was immediately introduced into this centuries -old narrative of how the Basques were always here. they were They're unchanged and all this kind of ideologically shaped discourse. So, yeah, it's it's it's as you said, it's...
Speaker: how How would you how would you ah process this kind of transformation? from what should be a scholarship to well memory or collective memory and how this processes that that fast.
Speaker: Well, yeah, that's that's a good point. um And of course. There's a lot of exceptionalism in the Basque Country. and I could see how... archaeological finds like that would feed into this exceptionalism.
Speaker: Historians do have an academic responsibility. they should not prostitute their status as such um to Facile. notions of, you know, uh indiana jones style uh you know this is So...
Speaker: That's a dilemma. It's a quandary. And I think... Walter Scott was already facing it. When Walter Scott wrote his novels, he was trying to take his... readers back to the middle ages and he realized it's two things On the one hand, the excitement of... No, no.
Speaker: It's partly to see. This is us. They were doing things in the Middle Ages that we can still relate to nowadays. um So they were ah had table manners or ways of saying goodbye with a a cup of wine, which we...
Speaker: still have nowadays in our popular culture. So the continuities, the identity. if you like, were stressed for Scott to give people access to the middle ages. At the same time, he showed that the Middle Ages were a foreign country, that they did things differently, that women could be burnt at the stake.
Speaker: on the accus accusation of sorcery. of witchcraft, and that a knight would have to do mortal combat in a duel to save the woman. And that is how the judicial system worked in the 12th century. Very different from the bourgeois system in 820 when he wrote that book.
Speaker: So he was working on, if you like, a... ambivalence saying that in the past we see things that we recognize that we can empathize with but there's also things which are exciting because they're totally alien So in the Iliad, we see notions of heroism and loyalty, which are so which are perennial. But we see that Achilles and Agamemnon are fighting over sex slaves of women who were captured. and they want to have
Speaker: we can't relate to that at all and that duality is what makes it interesting and i think historians have only used the one bit but they should try and and get that exciting ambivalence of the past Okay, so I will make just...
Speaker: last Last question. How do you think? all of this matters in what ways do you think romantic nationalism is still with us it's something that you um talk about in your book but i think that if you have to choose a couple of points that you think are the most important what what would they be
Speaker: Um. I think romantic nationalism... at the moment has a huge... in lasting influence it on the a collective imagination of large publics.
Speaker: um It has trickled down into ever more popular media like Braveheart, like movies, like television series, and it is ambient. And at the moment, there are very, very few anti -nationalistic forces at work. There's very little. cosmopolitanism or multilateralism at work.
Speaker: in the world today. So all we have in international relations is transactional relations between different silos. of different national identities.
Speaker: So the legacy of romantic nationalism is the absolute uh hegemony of nationalism in the you know global ideological landscape.
Speaker: um And ah the notion of charisma. is still with us um all populist leaders populism strangely enough wants charismatic leaders you'd expect populism to be grassroots but they all want to have somebody who is a proxy between the collectivity of the people and the abstract of what these people feel is their interest and they all want to believe in somebody who takes care of them. mcauudy olive you know so um
Speaker: And I think... um These are, at the moment, the great dangers of society in the world. A lot of people make connections with the 1930s and the rise of Nazism. I don't do that, but I see...
Speaker: parallels with 1913 and how the world sleepwalked into the First World War. you know the narcissism of Putin or Trump or Berlusconi. is the narcissism of Wilhelm II of Germany. So if you look at dangers, I'm sounding a warning bell here. It sounds nice. It sounds like...
Speaker: you know a theme park of nice novels of braveheart movies but there is something toxic in there. And I think... we begin to see um the beginnings of a rejection of charisma.
Speaker: um as a political force you should You know, we realize why it appeals to us, but you know you also have a brain. You should not just respond with your heart and your gut feelings, but you should also have a bit of critical rationalism and revive, if you like, an enlightenment tradition. That would be my takeaway.
Speaker: Okay. Well, on that jolly note, we will finish this interview. Thank you very much. e This has been a wonderful talk. It's always a pleasure hearing you. and Everyone, please.
Speaker: Read Charismatic Nations. it's As far as I know, it's open access available. So it's available in open access. i think It's in open access. yeah If you go to the Cambridge University Press website.
Speaker: And you look for charismatic nations and you see the the page on the the Cambridge website. You can download the PDF for free. Now. So you've heard it.
Speaker: please do it thank you very much eve for your presence here and see you thanks very much for having me See you again.

