Become a Creator today!Start creating today - Share your story with the world!
Start for free
00:00:00
00:00:01
074 | Five Views of Communion
388 Plays3 years ago
Why do churches practice communion so differently, and how do we understand these differences? Dive into the history of the Eucharist in this high-level overview of the denominational differences surrounding communion.
Recommended
Transcript
Introduction to Verity Podcast
00:00:00
Speaker
Welcome to Verity. I'm your host, Felicia Masonheimer, an author, speaker, and Bible teacher. This podcast will help you embrace the history and depth of the Christian faith, ask questions, seek answers, and devote yourself to becoming a disciple of Jesus Christ.
00:00:18
Speaker
You don't have to settle for watered-down Christian teaching. And if you're ready to go deeper, God is just as ready to take you there. This is Verity, where every woman is a theologian.
Summer Break and Return
00:00:30
Speaker
Hello, friends, and welcome back to Verity Podcast. It has been an entire summer that I have not recorded any new episodes.
00:00:38
Speaker
and I completely meant to come back sooner. But with all of the responsibilities of summer and travel and some deadlines for new projects, I just could not finish the notes for this particular episode in time to record it any sooner. So that just means that I had all summer to work on the communion views episode as well as the rest of the episodes that will be coming in August of 2022.
00:01:07
Speaker
So thank you for your patience. Verity podcast is alive and well. We are just getting back into the swing of things for fall. So before we jump into this topic, I wanted to first thank you all for listening. Thank you for your reviews, which help other people find the podcast. And also thank you so much for shopping with every woman a theologian, because we are so grateful for each and every order that comes in, whether it's for one of our clothing items or
00:01:37
Speaker
one of our hospitality items or one of our many books and e-books, your support of Every Woman a Theologian is a support of this podcast. So thank you for shopping with us. And if you are new to Every Woman a Theologian and Verity podcast, you can go to my website, feliciamasonheimer.com to find more about both the shop and the ministry. And the shop is what supports the ministry and supports our staff. So thank you for shopping with
Listener Demand for Communion Episode
00:02:05
Speaker
us.
00:02:05
Speaker
Okay, so what are we going to talk about this week? Well, it's an episode that is in high demand. I have had more requests for a communion episode than for almost any other topic in the last couple of months. And I don't know if this is because someone in particular was talking about it and so it was on the forefront of people's minds. Whatever the case is, it was in high demand and it's been on my list to research for quite some time.
00:02:35
Speaker
And so as I typically do, I'm going to walk through a little bit of what scripture says about communion or Eucharist, and then we're going to look at the different denominational perspectives on this topic. So let's start with scripture. That's a very good place to start, as the sound of music says. I am in Matthew 26, 26 through 28.
00:03:01
Speaker
Now as they were eating, Jesus took bread, and after blessing it, broke it, and gave it to the disciples, and said, Take, eat, this is my body. And he took a cup, and when he had given thanks, he gave it to them, saying, Drink of it, all of you. For this is my blood of the covenant, which is poured out for many for the forgiveness of
Scripture and Communion
00:03:20
Speaker
sins. I tell you, I will not drink again of this fruit of the vine until that day when I drink it new with you in my Father's kingdom.
00:03:28
Speaker
So this particular passage is at the last supper, the last Passover with the disciples. And this account is not just found in Matthew 26. It's also found in Luke 22 and in John 6. It's also in Mark, where we see the same kind of narrative given to us, telling us that Jesus is instituting this supper, this remembrance using bread and wine that represent his body and his blood.
00:03:58
Speaker
And if we go forward in church history to 1 Corinthians 10, Paul is talking about the appropriate celebration of the bread and wine with the Corinthian church. He says, in 10, 16, the cup of blessing that we bless, is it not a participation in the blood of Christ? The bread that we break, is it not a participation in the body of Christ? Because there is one bread who we are many, our one body,
00:04:27
Speaker
for we all partake of the one bread." So this institution of the Lord's Supper was a fundamental of church practice from the get-go. And if you look in the book of Acts, we see the early church practicing these gatherings where they would remember Christ's resurrection, they would worship, they would gather together, break bread together, celebrating communion or Eucharist together.
00:04:58
Speaker
As time went on in church history, there came to be different perspectives on what exactly happens when Christians partake of this sacrament.
Liturgical vs Non-Liturgical Views on Communion
00:05:12
Speaker
What do I mean by sacrament? So we've talked about this in previous episodes, but a sacrament is a visible sign of invisible grace.
00:05:20
Speaker
And more liturgical churches are going to emphasize this sacrament a little bit more than maybe less liturgical churches would. Liturgical churches are those like the Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican, etc. And less liturgical churches would be more of the Baptist, Pentecostal, sometimes Methodist, non-denominational types.
00:05:44
Speaker
And so we're going to look at these different views of how communion works, but it's important to note that early in church history, there was a general consensus regarding communion that was more liturgical in nature.
00:06:00
Speaker
communion was seen as a very sacred act, a sacred act that we as believers would participate in together and remember Christ's sacrifice and even participate in grace that's received through this visible sign of invisible grace.
00:06:19
Speaker
Now obviously not all of us will agree on exactly how communion functions or how we should understand it, but it is helpful and important to know what other people think about these issues so we can have healthy conversations about them.
Catholic Beliefs: Transubstantiation
00:06:35
Speaker
So we're going to start with the Roman Catholic view of the Eucharist.
00:06:41
Speaker
The word Eucharist comes from the Greek word for Thanksgiving. And if we look at Luke 22 or Matthew 26, what we see there is Jesus giving thanks, then breaking the bread and passing the cup. And so this word Eucharist is taken from that instance. And then when we participate in Eucharist or communion, we also are giving thanks for Christ's sacrifice on our behalf.
00:07:08
Speaker
So in the Roman Catholic view, the sacrifice of Christ is given to the believer who's participating in a sacramental form. So the sacrifice of Christ is truly present when you participate in the Eucharist. After the bread and wine have been consecrated, Catholics believe that the bread and the wine actually transform into the body and blood of Christ. And this process is called transubstantiation.
00:07:38
Speaker
Trans means change and substantiation means substance. So the very essence of the bread and wine has changed to become Christ's body and blood is the belief in the Catholic Church. This is from the Council of Trent which outlined many of the primary doctrines of the Catholic Church in the medieval era.
00:07:59
Speaker
By the consecration of the bread and wine there takes place a change of the whole substance of the bread into the substance of the body of Christ our Lord, and of the whole substance of the wine into the substance of His blood. This change the holy Catholic Church has fittingly and properly called transubstantiation.
00:08:19
Speaker
Now I want to look at the Orthodox views.
Orthodox Mystery of Eucharist
00:08:22
Speaker
This would be the Greek Orthodox Church and then also the Russian Orthodox Church, which is a branch of the overall Orthodox liturgical church. So for the Orthodox, the Eucharist is the center of the church's life. This is very similar to in Roman Catholicism.
00:08:41
Speaker
Everything in the Church leads to the Eucharist and all things flow from it. I took that from the Orthodox Church of America and their statement about the Eucharist. The Eucharist then, or Holy Communion as it's called, is the completion of all the Church's sacraments. So it's kind of like this pinnacle of doctrinal belief in practice.
00:09:06
Speaker
One thing that's unique about the Orthodox Church versus the Roman Catholic Church is that they view communion as a mystery. They call it Holy Communion, whereas Roman Catholics are more commonly calling their practice Eucharist, but they focus on the mystery of this sacrament in the Orthodox Church.
00:09:26
Speaker
The entire ceremony itself is called the divine liturgy, and similar to Catholicism, the bread and wine are mystically turned into the body and blood of Christ once it's been consecrated and you are consuming it.
00:09:40
Speaker
It's common and encouraged for Orthodox members to fast before they take communion, and they're also encouraged to take communion at least four times a year, usually during their highest holidays, but of course taking it more often is encouraged as well. And prayer, praying certain prayers is a part of the liturgy before and after you take Holy Communion.
00:10:03
Speaker
What I hope you take away from these two practices, these two diverse practices of the Eucharist, is they both have a very sacred view of this practice. It's so much more than a symbol to them. It's so much more than just a reminder of Jesus.
00:10:23
Speaker
I was talking to a friend once and we were talking about this issue and we both are in non-denominational churches and she mentioned that one time she was in a non-denominational church and she watched someone go up to take communion while talking on the phone with someone.
00:10:39
Speaker
And she pointed out to me that there is something lost when we no longer see communion as a sacred act. And the advantage I think of the more liturgical churches is that they do still treat this with great sanctity.
00:10:57
Speaker
after a three-year hiatus, Verity Conference is back. And it's coming to Petoskey, Michigan, November 4th and 5th. I am so thrilled to bring back Verity Conference after our short break of a few years for COVID. And this time, we are much bigger with two amazing speakers joining me to talk about apologetics and evangelism. How do we share our faith
00:11:22
Speaker
in today's culture in a way that is both gracious and truthful. You'll hear from me, Jeremy Jenkins of All Things All People, and Priscilla Dominguez, who is going to share with us how to love other people while also speaking the truth.
00:11:37
Speaker
Jeremy specializes in world religions and cults, and he will be talking about evangelism in that context. I am so excited for this event. I hope you can join us. You can grab the remaining early bird tickets on my website, FeliciaMasonHeimer.com, if you click the conference tab.
Lutheran Consubstantiation
00:11:56
Speaker
So the third church I want to look at is the Lutheran church. So in the Lutheran tradition, Christ's body and blood are present in, with, and under the bread and wine. And their view is called consubstantiation.
00:12:11
Speaker
So the presence of Christ co-exists with the bread and the wine. So it's not transforming into the actual body and blood like the Catholics believe, but the presence of Christ co-exists with the bread and wine. One Catholic belief is that the Eucharist or communion makes present Christ's sacrifice on the cross. So when you participate in communion, you're participating in his sacrifice.
00:12:40
Speaker
but that's not the Lutheran belief. They believe that Christ sacrifices once for all time, but Christ himself is present in the elements when we take communion. Their term for the bread and wine is the sacramental union, the sacramental union. And this is from Living Lutheran, a website for the Lutheran Church. We commune with the saints who have gone before us
00:13:08
Speaker
and with other Christians around the globe who gather at our Lord's table. The uncontainable presence, grace, love, forgiveness, and mercy of Christ come to us in simple bread and wine." What I loved about this quote is the note that when we participate in holy communion, we are not only communing with God and Christ, we're communing with all of our family of God around the world.
00:13:36
Speaker
I've never thought about it that way, how when we participate in communion on the same day that others are participating in it, we're actually joining hands with them in a spiritual way by participating in Christ together, and that is really powerful.
00:13:52
Speaker
The fourth tradition I want to look at is the Reformed tradition.
Reformed Spiritual Presence
00:13:55
Speaker
So in this tradition, Christ is not present physically in the Eucharist, but He is spiritually present, and we receive Him through the Holy Spirit. So this view largely came from John Calvin. If Lutheranism came through Martin Luther, the Reformed view is influenced heavily by John Calvin, and his view is called receptionism.
00:14:17
Speaker
we're receiving Christ through the Holy Spirit as we participate in the Eucharist. This is also called the spiritual presence or real presence view. And this is directly from Calvin's Institutes of the Christian Religion. The rule which the pious, the Christians, are always to observe is, whenever they see the symbols instituted by the Lord, to think and feel surely persuaded that the truth of the thing signified is also present.
00:14:46
Speaker
For why does the Lord put the symbol of His body into your hands, but just to assure you that you truly partake of Him? If this is true, let us feel as much assured that the visible sign is given us in seal of an invisible gift as that His body itself is given to us.
00:15:04
Speaker
So he's basically saying that we should have assurance that this visible sign of an invisible gift or grace is a reminder that he truly gave his body for us. He truly gave his sacrifice for us. He's present with us. And this is a quote from Christianity Today in an article on communion. The Holy Spirit uses the bread and the wine as vehicles to catalyze a connection between Christians and the risen Christ.
00:15:33
Speaker
So, in the Reformed view, this participation in communion is connecting us more to the risen Christ by the power of the Holy Spirit. It's not like the Holy Spirit leaves us and comes back during communion, but that during a holy communion, we are connecting closely with our God and remembering who He is and what He did and participating in His grace.
Baptist Symbolic Remembrance
00:15:58
Speaker
The last view I want to look at is the Baptist view. But this view is not only Baptist. It's also in other traditions, such as some Methodist churches, even some Reformed Baptist churches. It may be in Pentecostal, Charismatic churches, possibly Church of Christ. And this is the view that refers to Eucharist as the Lord's Supper or Holy Communion. And it is a remembrance of Christ's suffering and death.
00:16:27
Speaker
I think that a lot of my listeners will relate to this particular view. Many of you who grew up in the United States in non-liturgical church environments, this is going to be the communion you are familiar with. It's a remembrance of Christ's suffering.
00:16:43
Speaker
and it's mainly symbolic. So this particular view arose from the work of Ulrich Zwingli and it's called Memorialism. Zwingli lived at the same time as Calvin and Luther and he was actually heavily persecuted by both of them over this issue. In fact, he divided from the other reformers of the church because of the communion view.
00:17:05
Speaker
because he believed it was simply a memorial, a symbol, and not an actual either participation in grace, or he did not believe that Christ's body and blood were a part of the communion ceremony. So some Anglican and Methodist churches may take this view, but many of them are closer to the Lutheran view.
00:17:27
Speaker
And this is from James Akarti on this topic of symbolic communion. The bread and the wine serve as flashcards for Jesus. See bread, remember Jesus. See wine, remember Jesus. Here the Lord's Supper serves as an opportunity for remembrance and thinking deeply about Christ and his work, but not necessarily an occasion for a unique encounter with his presence.
00:17:53
Speaker
And this viewpoint is sometimes reflected in our churches because if we don't expect to have a unique encounter with Jesus through communion, we're probably not going to notice if one was available. So our outlook on communion, our understanding of it, is going to change our participation in it.
00:18:10
Speaker
And in churches like this, you may sometimes do communion every week. You might do it every fifth Sunday. You might do it once a quarter. It just depends on how your church has decided to celebrate the Lord's Supper. But in the end, the point of the memorialist view is that Jesus is not physically present in the bread and wine.
00:18:30
Speaker
There is no extra work of grace. There's no particular powerful revelation of God through this act. It is a memorial to what Christ did on the cross. And that itself can be very, very powerful. At the same time, it can lack a lot of the sanctity and sacred expectation that some of the other traditions have.
00:18:55
Speaker
A few last points I wanted to make.
Non-Observance and Passover Connection
00:18:57
Speaker
First, the Salvation Army and the Quakers don't observe communion at all. This was interesting to me when I was doing the research for this episode. These two do not celebrate communion, or the Salvation Army in particular doesn't believe it's necessary to the Christian faith. And then in Messianic Jewish communities, so Jews who follow Jesus,
00:19:19
Speaker
or Gentile non-Jewish Christians who have decided to convert to a Messianic Christianity often don't celebrate communion because they believe that the passages in Matthew 26 and in Luke and Mark and John refer instead to the Passover. They believe that Jesus was commanding his followers to do this in remembrance of me, do the Passover in remembrance of him,
00:19:46
Speaker
until he returns. And because of that fundamental difference of practice, they celebrate Passover and sometimes or often will not take communion.
00:19:59
Speaker
I hope this episode was helpful to you, and I hope it gave you a bit of a high-level view of the history behind these different views, some of the pros and cons or weaknesses and strengths of each, and that most of all, it will help you understand a little bit more of where your friends are coming from when they adhere to a different denominational perspective on communion. But mostly, I really hope that when you do take communion in your church and you participate in the Lord's Table,
00:20:26
Speaker
that you have a little bit deeper understanding of what it stands for and how powerful it really is. Even if you don't subscribe to some of the theology behind these different views, there's still a universal expectation that Jesus Christ is present with us when we take Holy Communion. And we're communing not just with Him, but with our fellow believers around the world.
Connect with Felicia Masonheimer
00:20:51
Speaker
Thank you for joining us for today's episode of Verity. You can connect with fellow listeners by following me on Instagram at Felicia Masonheimer or on our Facebook page by the same name. Also visit FeliciaMasonheimer.com for links to each episode and the show notes.