Zencastr
00:00:00
00:00:01
Speed1x
Format▸
Share
Embed
Report

Understanding EPR Episode 1

Understanding EPR
Understanding EPR

9 plays · Nov 7, 2026

Transcript

Speaker: Welcome to essentially understanding EPR, I was going to call this EPR, because of all the frustrations it caused. I was also going to call it EPR. Maybe there's a revelation in there that shows us. Okay.

Speaker: actually live with EPR going forwards but for now we'll call it understanding EPR. The reason behind the podcast is is quite simple. We... We're at a point now where more and more API legislations are coming online globally. Um... there is clearly a lot of angst out there and we and hopefully give you some guidance on on what that looks like. and maybe how to to work with it and maybe even work around it, we'll see. Two.

Speaker: The podcast is hosted by myself. and and matthew rogerson i'm neil shackleton i'm founder of medulla we are a packaging consultancy working in this space.

Speaker: Matthew, I'll let you introduce yourself. I'm Matthew Rogerson. I'm the founder of the Pack Scout, also a packaging consultancy with a focus on regulation and trying to bring clarity to how to implement what the rules are telling you to do. in the packaging industry Perfect. So hopefully,

Speaker: From those two introductions you've kind of fused together that we we come at EPR from slightly different angles but with a whole kind of collective understanding of exactly what should and and shouldn't happen as we go through. so As with all things, We are going to start right at the beginning to

Speaker: epi Episode one is is really the fundamentals about understanding exactly what EPR is and where we're at and then Over time, hopefully we can build out into some more detailed explanations, look at specific the hours.

Speaker: and hopefully i have a few um interesting facts and figures we can bring into the equations as we go. matthew has his own series of insights which i would ask you to follow and we'll be able to put some links up as we go through to to to that which i'm sure will be of use okay So we're going to start from I'm not going to call it the idiot's guide but I'm going to basically say we we're assuming no knowledge of EPR so Matthew let's EPR what does it stand for

Speaker: So, It stands for Extended Producer responsibility. and If your business puts packaging on the market, you carry some level of responsibility for the cost.

Speaker: and management of that packaging once it becomes waste. and as I'm sure You're very familiar, Neil, because we we have this conversation before. the complexity isn't what it stands for,

Speaker: but it it is understanding what it can mean. So behind the acronym of extended producer responsibility, it's a policy approach. So it's not a single law.

Speaker: It's delivered through national and regional legislation and different schemes and traditionally councils and taxpayers were responsible for paying to collect.

Speaker: and deal with household packaging waste. So EPR has moved that part of the cost to the businesses that produce the packaging. and put it onto the market.

Speaker: And the final thing before I pass it back to you for how you would describe. EPR. is that producer is a somewhat misleading. word. So depending on which scheme we're talking about.

Speaker: The producer could be the brand owner, the retailer, the importer, the person who is filling or even the first supplier. It's not just the factory or the location that's making the packaging. So overall, extended producer responsibility, the idea. is that it creates less waste and more importantly it helps with better packaging design and development so that that waste can be better handled once it's being used by us as consumers. I hope that makes it.

Speaker: somewhat clear, but I'm sure you've brought got ah an even more sensible way of describing EPR. I'm not sure there's a lot that I can add to that, to be honest with you. I mean, logically, I can i can understand this. so we We know that they're irrespective of where you are in the world, there are pressures on local authority infrastructure for for recycling and and capturing and collection.

Speaker: logically to push back towards the producers whoever they may be and and suggest that actually they need to become stakeholders in the problem. Next. a degree of sense. and However, there are you know kind of within within the context of this i think there are clear

Speaker: Problems and opportunities, I would say. And I think this is this is probably what we're going to start speaking a lot about as we go through you know different different episodes here. But the logic the logic stacks up at that level. In terms of you know What does it mean for businesses? The the the baseline is essentially This is more Fees.

Speaker: taxation if you like that you are going to have to pay to put your products on the market which in all honesty is supremely difficult right now. We are in a climate of uncertainty or when aren't we even you might argue but economically you know we're not in an upturn right now we're in downturn and you know we are seeing that the pressures.

Speaker: for everyone, you know from the cost of living up, but also for the cost of goods and in going out to market. is is starting to take its toll. At the time when this has been introduced, you can see that the logic behind it is Is it okay? Boop.

Speaker: perhaps a difficult one to swallow for businesses right now. alongside other taxations that they already have to take on board as part of their packaging going into market.

Speaker: So let's try and frame this a slightly different way so You've kind of touched on it already, Matthew, but Why now? why Why has this been introduced now? So I think Because packaging waste costs money and as well as the actual waste of having made something that then has

Speaker: goes nowhere. except into the ground. the waste of the costs of moving that wasted good because it's going to go all the way through a supply chain and then to a consumer and then it's going to landfill or recycling center or somewhere.

Speaker: and the typically or previously the person choosing the packaging hasn't traditionally paid for what happens to it afterwards.

Speaker: So, Beforehand, it was a kind of a bit more open -ended where you know I bought my packaging and I put it into a bin or some kind of stream. and didn't really care too much about what happened.

Speaker: off But... Because waste management costs money, Because the resources are lost when recoverable material, so something that's perfectly usable or reusable, is thrown away. because Design affects the outcome. So the label or adhesives or closures or material combinations all change whether packaging can be sorted or recycled.

Speaker: because the buying decision, both from the people who are producing the packaging and us as consumers, may not reflect the end of life costs. So i'm I'm buying a product. I'm not considering when I buy that product.

Speaker: what happens to it after I've used it. And finally, there's a lot of data. architecture issues where governments don't really know what is being placed onto the market. so the The reason for those rules is to get a lot more clarity onto something that they currently don't really know a lot about.

Speaker: because if they get that clarity then they can find a way to make the people who are creating The problem? i .e. the material that can't be recycled or reused currently.

Speaker: pay for the infrastructure that would change that. And so it's a the The kind of caveat is that EPR is one tool of many.

Speaker: So governments can use lots of different things like design rules, recycled content rules, reuse targets, deposit return schemes and format bans. But EPR is one of the probably fairest ways currently.

Speaker: of addressing this gap between waste costs, money, and currently we're not doing anything to reduce that cost. Okay, okay interesting. are you touched on on kind of

Speaker: where we're at now is to say that I think again to try and frame this what you've touched on here is what the government are actually trying to solve by brains and then then let's Let's be very honest, this is not something which they just decided to do. It's been in the pipeline for a number of years there's been a number of consultations which i have my own opinions on but but in terms of in terms of those this has been being driven out by historically what's gone on. So if you think about

Speaker: The word landfill often causes people to to kind of gasp in horror at such a situation where we're dumping this. But you know for many years, the UK and other countries around the world were actually paying for that. Peace. to be taken away. um and and hidden somewhere else. um that

Speaker: Kind of. That has to stop. legislation has made that stop, you different industries have made different commitments to actually banning you know, materials into landfill, the future into the sub -industry. to mind specifically. Yeah, legislative minister. nothing. Looks kind of fun. and then you're left with essentially

Speaker: different end -of -life scenarios for every material and packaging as a whole has a number of different materials that you can you can activate and use. Through that the infrastructures for those It could be better, shall we say. It could be bigger and there is a very limited amount of resource around. And I think it's...

Speaker: It's very safe to say that The EPR legislations are built around exactly what you just described, resampling and reuse. And... if you have a material that doesn't apply in those kind of categories the likelihood is

Speaker: you it will end up costing you more. through the schemes that are in place. And the other thing that for that is that ultimately the The problem or the the problem they're trying to solve and the direction they're trying to take is they want to end as close to a circular economy as possible.

Speaker: So, wherein, in theory, because I don't think it's a... something that has necessarily the ah the the chance to become reality just given the way that things are made and atrophy and various other kind of physics. They're involved. But as close as possible to when I make something, that material stays in use for longer, whether it's being recycled or being reused or being upcycled or something, just so it's not just being made.

Speaker: used and then disposed of, which is where we are currently. day. So, yeah the the more that they're able to provide some kind of guardrails to help move. So if if you are Using a product today, which might be fit for purpose, but is not possible to recycle, reuse or or kind of retain in some way, then the government's thoughts are

Speaker: you should probably try and find a better way of doing it, which is why EPR comes in to kind of nudge you towards hopefully making better. design decisions but that's i think the kind of

Speaker: in a perfect world. what they're trying to do but as we both know very much there's ah there's a huge gap between where where this sits in there in their minds when they're creating this around the table somewhere and what happens when it comes out into the the industry. And I think I think another thing just just to clarify the point on is Um,

Speaker: As you described it can be a manufacturer, it can be a brand, it can be a retailer. i mean It can be a... an agent, or or a training company so there are many different ways that you might be liable for EPR. Um, from from different perspectives.

Speaker: However, the added complexity is that EPR is based on the market that you land in, not not where you actually produce from. to The added complexity now is even if you are a producer that supplies globally, you are looking at a number of different APR mechanisms, all with slightly different nuances.

Speaker: that you may have to navigate. And obviously in previous times, you've probably looked at this from, okay, we're manufacturing from from this country here, therefore we will be liable to pay all these fees. within the country of origin and this is not the case for EPR.

Speaker: Hmm. And it's, yeah, it adds to that that complexity. you find regularly that Even if you're compliant in one of those frameworks, the next law country or the next place along that you're trying to sell into might have a slight difference. And when you... combine.

Speaker: that small gap that might emerge between how those different frameworks are. managed It means that there's a sort of slight whack -a -mole situation going on where you find yourself in a slightly weird position where I am compliant in country A, but I'm non -compliant in country B. And then I'm trying to make

Speaker: my manufacturing plants cater to both of those two, which might be completely divergent endpoints. So it is very interesting where The intention is great, but the way that they administer and set up these frameworks leaves enough of a gap that it can be very complex, particularly, as you said, you know if you are a global or a multinational selling. product selling company, then

Speaker: It can be immensely complex to try and figure out. How do I make it? over here and sell it over there. without being tagged or having fines or some kind of...

Speaker: complexity coming into it. Yeah, I agree. I think the thing is that, that and we've we've had this conversation before, but You know? I've been in the packaging industry now for 30 plus years and the number of times we've worked with clients on one thing which was to reduce the complexity. of componentry you know across

Speaker: but you know Not just countries, but globally. Let's get those components down to something which is far more manageable and a little bit less out of shape. And if we if we were only using EPR is the only lever. What we're now saying to businesses is,

Speaker: that's now gone out the window so to cater to every potential market that's coming on board you may have to have adaptive design in order to mitigate the amount of EPR.

Speaker: that you would pay. Now luckily, PR is not the only lever here. There are other factors that you need to consider. buh at a at a point where we are now and I believe You know, i'm i'm I'm speaking for everybody so it's but excuse me, but I believe we're in a kind of a status which is panic right now.

Speaker: because the moment When I speak to pet people and clients, the moment that they feel they are on top of EPR, then they suddenly have a realisation that another EPR has sprung up. And then your whack -a -mole analogy is is the perfect one for this. It's kind of, OK, UK's up, we understand UK.

Speaker: We're on board with that. and then all of a sudden australia new south wales comes up and that's completely different And so it's it's a bit of a minefield. to to to kind of get your head around this but EPR should be defined a field. It's not defined as a tax. It's basically a system of which They outplace techs.

Speaker: Do you agree with that statement? I do, and that helps to... Keep it. clear. I think that's the The main objective of our conversations and anything to do with EPR is reach for simplification first because it has the ability to be immensely complex. But instead, if you focus on

Speaker: what is it doing at its simplest and at its simplest it is a system that turns out or highlights which materials, within your portfolio are going to cost you the most amount of money to process and send through your supply chain and it then gives you the opportunity to rather than use that as a tax or financial burden to use it as a guide to say okay

Speaker: I am spending an awful lot of money on this very small part of my business. Does that need to be the case? or can I make some changes to your earlier point about that idea of harmonization or simplification. being best so like you know if a large company has a good handle on what they make and where they make it and what the components are and they try to keep them as simple as possible.

Speaker: Then, EPR becomes a really good way or process that they can. fact and sense check that say, okay, well, We're spending X on our materials. Where are the areas of our business where maybe we're spending a bit too much or we're we're buying a material that is maybe more expensive or doesn't necessarily need to be the material that we're using in that case.

Speaker: it doesn't tell them that they need to change. It doesn't make any demands. of any company that is in that process.

Speaker: But it's almost like a packaging materials audit to give you an idea of where there are some areas that you might be able to improve or optimize or make more efficient. But I definitely agree that it's... It's definitely not a tax because, yeah, that's not the the purpose of it. It's not being designed to sort of say, you know, we're just going to extract money from you without any kind of... Heartless.

Speaker: but There's a lot more what lot more to it than that. But I definitely like the idea that it's it has within it the ability to also understand that the rules aren't just It applies to everybody who makes packaging. It depends on the country's definition of a producer. And so behind the rules, there's the different roles of the people who are involved. And so the question isn't who made the packaging.

Speaker: It's who the law says is the producer in the market where it's sold. And then back to our point that we're just talking about now. That will then determine who that producer is and what material they're using and what the cost of those materials are. and then they can make a decision on whether they want to optimize or make that more efficient. Most people probably will because there will be something in every company where they are using a material that they're probably using because they've always done it.

Speaker: rather than because it has any actual current purpose. and This is one way of being able to highlight or flag that and say, do we need to continue using this material, that component, that cap, that closure, that label?

Speaker: Or is there a better way of doing this? and better way can read as both better for reducing waste but more importantly for most companies that are engaging with EPR it will be how do I save some money in this as well? So I think that's ah that's a big one. I think that that's that's a really really good point and and obviously When we talk about EPR, it's very easy to be very negative about its emergence and what it's doing and the pain that it's causing.

Speaker: but there is an opportunity with this and then that's exactly what you pointed out it's kind of irrespective of whether you are a new startup business, a small business, a big business.

Speaker: what you find is that over time, they the philosophy is always you know if if it ain't broke We don't need to fix it. but over time things evolve you know we see this all the time you know even to the point that you know soon. Organisations never question but they're paying for material. They they never question whether the specification could be better or could it be right. and the one thing that epr is doing is is by being Howdy.

Speaker: By being this kind of enforcement leader, the of the the real kind of opportunity is to get behind the data and really start to think about people. on your music.

Speaker: not just to mitigate the EPR, but maybe you'll actually find some efficiencies you know in other areas, which is what you've just discussed. The... so you know kind of I don't want to be pessimistic all the time about EPR. think there's opportunities there but it means getting in the right headspace and this is where For me, this is where businesses are not right now and we're hopefully you know, maybe maybe be listening to us, maybe not, but I mean, it's kind of hopefully we can start to go on that journey.

Speaker: and start to be able to gain from it because you know, yes. Can we mitigate the the the costs? Yes, we can. Can we actually do things which which add more value into a business alongside mitigating? Absolutely. So that there's lots of scope here.

Speaker: once you get on the right kind of mental frame to be able to deal with it. Newt. Interesting segue for me to this is kind of because We're talking about how to get on on the right frame one of the key questions We've talked about EPR being about packaging, it's a tax on packaging, it's a tax on packaging of the products you put in the market. We can frame this in a number of different ways. place.

Speaker: But EPR, in terms of being able to understand what it means for your business. It's not just a packaging problem. it doesn't sit directly with your packaging team to solve all this all on their own.

Speaker: And where... I think people are at the moment right, you know, and right now is in a series of conversations. trying to define Whose responsibility is it?

Speaker: Now, I have my own opinions on this. I'm sure you do too, Matthew. But in terms of what it means for me is Packaging teams control packaging. okay They are in charge.

Speaker: of specifications. Okay, and... they The reason for being is to guarantee the specifications that they have in the system. exactly what's been developed and tried.

Speaker: in case the business. Confidence. that their that their packaging is exactly what they need. So they're part of an iterative process to develop, maybe linking in with R &D to produce new things, maybe linking in with operations to kind of ensure that... for days.

Speaker: running 24 -7. So that's where packaging sits in the whole delivery of this. but it's not packaging responsibility to control and mitigate. cost or tax.

Speaker: And especially with EPR, there is there is so many different stakeholders um in an organization. So for me, we've got CFO that should be involved in this. Essentially what you have is EPR is an additional cost. which will come and buy your profit margin so you need to be aware of what that looks like You have.

Speaker: procurement teams who buy materials, they need to be much more understanding of the materials that that they buy and the implications. You have R and &D and MPD.

Speaker: who need to be aware of this so that when they're developing, new product, new market, maybe both. that these COS. that that are going to come from EPR are included into their cost of goods.

Speaker: otherwise you're going to market with with with hidden costs that you can't see. We've got operations and supply chain that need to be aware of this and in my mind be part of the stakeholder group. because they need to they need to understand that and Quite often, especially in big businesses, we get you know oh we we made that change we just did that little adjustment there It doesn't matter to you. You don't see it. It's just going on.

Speaker: but it has a big implication. so All of a sudden, we're seeing the It's not just about packaging, it's become an entire business. problem.

Speaker: to work around and try and solve. Have I missed anybody out? Thank you very much for listening. That's it. i know I think that's... That's really really captured it really well. And there's there's a couple of things in there that I've been very front of mind lately. The first is that packaging is responsible.

Speaker: in pretty much any case that you have a consumer packaged or consumer product good coming to a market packaging is the one that delivers that brand promise that retail promise and yet They are not in control of their own destiny because there are those other departments that are making the decisions that impact packaging.

Speaker: And so the first part is to understand that If you are in a company that is producing a packaged goods and selling it into the market, i .e. all the organisations are going to be affected by EPR, you need to understand that just because you're not a packaging expert, you are still affecting packaging outcomes. And the second part of that is that because those self -same different business units that are affecting packaging's ability to deliver that brand promise.

Speaker: but might not be aware of it. Within that, it's the same thing for EPR, because as you said, you know it's not the the packaging person, the packaging technologists. role is to make sure that the preservation or the promotion or the the packaging parts of their their product hits the market in the best possible quality so the consumer experience is the best it can possibly be.

Speaker: When you have something like EPR, which is talking to you about material costs, the ceo the chief sustainability officer if they have one the chief sales officer is going to be impacted, the marketing officer is going to be impacted because as well as the finance department or division bearing the cost of what results as that that that their their costs of what materials they're putting off the market.

Speaker: You've then got the rest of the executive team are having to react to this because this is going to be a number that in theory should be able to go down. they should be able to talk about it, promote it to their own stakeholders. so The investors, that entire community is going to be impacted by EPR feeds. The sustainability or engineering or operations or health and safety teams are also going to be impacted.

Speaker: because if you change the material to reduce your costs of EPR, you're going to need to at some point probably change machinery or process or some kind of system. And those systems are really rigid.

Speaker: So they don't tend to enjoy being changed. um and They're not ones that you can kind of agilely pivot from one to the other. So, when you have the decision to change a material, for example, which might be because EPR is flagged. plastic is too expensive to continue to use in your operations, the Whiplash response, the knee -jerk response might be from somebody in the executive team, well, we'll just switch into X.

Speaker: switching to paper. For example, The problem with that is that it's not a pivot. It's something that you're going to need to invest a lot in machinery and processes. formats. and pilots and trials. and There's a whole raft of money that's going to need to get thrown at that.

Speaker: in order to realize the cost saving of making that change eventually. So I think you're totally right that It needs to be something which is really company, supply chain and industry wide. And another reason why we will try to, why will you and I will both try to keep it as simple as possible when we're talking about it.

Speaker: is because the moment you try to engage with an entire company, because ultimately probably somebody in every single division. makes decisions every single day that could impact EPR because ultimately everybody in that company makes a decision that will ultimately impact packaging and packaging is what is generating the EPR. costs.

Speaker: and therefore everybody's got a part to play. And to your earlier points that definitely brings out that challenge of who's responsible because people tend to move away from or move with fear.

Speaker: where they don't want to be blamed for something going wrong. So it's easy just to say it's not my role, it's not my responsibility, it's not my job. And so, hopefully what EPR does is it gives a clean, set of data. When you understand what it is that you make in your organization and what that costs, then hopefully

Speaker: It makes it easy to understand that it doesn't really matter who is in charge, just that somebody is in charge. And I would say... personally that CFO would probably be the best person to kind of take a ah sort of top of the pyramid approach to it.

Speaker: because ultimately it is something that is going to end up with money being exchanged. and so because it is eventually going to be a cost then the person who is responsible for paying the money in the organization is probably going to be the best person to hold and run and manage that budget. And then they've got enough seniority in the business to essentially make everybody else do what they need them to do because even though a CFO isn't necessarily

Speaker: higher than the CEO. if a cfo doesn't want to do something it's not going to get done whereas if a ceo wants to do it doesn't necessarily mean that it's it's automatically going to happen so I think even though Mind if everybody? is is responsible in the packaging companies for all plays a small part at least in EPR I think.

Speaker: To your earlier point, if if you can get the CFO to manage it, that would probably be the the strongest way for her. any sized organisation to most efficiently.

Speaker: keep it simple and keep it managed by it by one one relevant person. I don't disagree with you there i'm sure anybody that's a CEO that's listening in mind. We know you're up there.

Speaker: the The thing that... the the consensus of feeling that I'm getting at the moment is that everybody is working a little bit in isolation in EPR. ah So there's there's not a lot of companies that have been vocal out there saying these are our frustrations, these are our challenges. keeping it internal.

Speaker: And I'm not. 100 % sure why that is because you know kind of Everybody's going through the same kind of issues with with EPR right now so you would think that being able to pull it for the share would actually help people. solve problems together. However, I do do know that the biggest problem right now is being able to define who has ownership within organisations.

Speaker: and Let's be honest, nobody wants to take ownership of this. this is This is more work, more resource required, something that nobody has. on their original kind of CV.

Speaker: But... I completely agree that the the being at a CFO level and being able to drive this program of work through a business.

Speaker: is the best way to deliver an opportunity. So... I'm going to close out on this this first this first piece but What I would say is don't be afraid Don't be afraid and if you really don't understand what's going on with EPR then you know you only have to look at LinkedIn every day. See, there's plenty of people you can talk to. Or talk to me or Matthew. Happy to have a conversation with you at any point.

Speaker: And actually within this podcast, we'll put up some some links. uh in future so that if you have any particular questions we can we can feel them and they can be become part of what we what we go forward in just to just to kind of close out with one story and one one client of mine i was not named that's not fair I asked him, essentially if they but in how they got their head around ETR.

Speaker: And... You know, did they know where they were going? Have they got a strategy in place? And very bullishly, I was told, you know, you don't need to get involved in this meal because it's OK, we've got everything sorted. We know exactly what we're doing, we've got everything sorted.

Speaker: I was... quite amazed by this because you know nobody really has got anything sorted with this i would not expect them to you know it based on the fact that more and more of these are emerging Um...

Speaker: but But my client said, look, I'll show you. and he got out this fantastically beautiful slide deck and he went through the slide deck with me and and it was beautifully created, lots of imagery and everything.

Speaker: and he sat there after he presented it to me and said there you see we've got it all sorted we don't need any assistance and I said to Sybil This is really good and it's a really fantastic. deck but the deck is on ERP not on NPR.

Speaker: And... or somebody at such a high level in a big business. This is is kind of one of the things, there's lots of acronyms out there, but EPR is one that's probably going to cost you money.

Speaker: So, We'll leave that there for today from Matthew and myself, thank you for listening and tuning in. We will be back with episode two, which is going to be about looking around packaging rules globally.

Speaker: and whether we could truly get to a holy it poly grail of one single set of rules. So thank you for listening and we will see you next time.

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Recommended